Trade Diary January 2023 - Week 4 & 5 & 6
Trade Diary January 2023 - Week 4 & 5 & 6
• Trade Diary
• Alcohol
• Trade Diary
•
Testing – Mind the Charting Package
I looked at the DAX 15min chart on the E-signal database. I use the E-signal database for this research because I
wanted to quickly scroll through many months of trading. The advantage you have with E-signal on the DAX cash
chart is that you only have data for the “normal trading session”, i.e., the trading session from 9am Germany time
to 17:30 Germany time.
Had I used my broker charts, which shows the DAX in one long continuous stream, I would have had to scroll
through a whole lot more data, and I wanted to avoid that.
I asked myself a VERY simple question:
How often does the 15min chart in the DAX in the morning send me an early “sell signal”? Specifically, how often
does the start of the 2nd 15min bar of the DAX (the one that starts at 09:15am Germany time) break through the
lows of the 1st 15min bar, AND close below the low of the 1st 15min bar?
My question was geared towards finding out what would happen if I simply sold short the DAX index, if the 2 nd
15min chart closed below the low of the 1st 15min chart.
Before I move on, I want to emphasize what I did NOT look for:
1. I ignored the data set if a subsequent 15min bar closed below the low of the 1st 15min bar. In other words,
if the 3rd or the 4th or any subsequent 15min bar closed below the low of the 1st 15min bar, I ignored the
data. I was only interested in in the 1st and the 2nd 15min bar, and what happened thereafter.
2. I ignored the data if the 2nd 15min went below but didn’t close below the low of the 1st 15min.
Here is the problem I was faced with. Below is the dataset for the 1st 15min chart from my brokers charting
package. This is important because it is his data we are trading from. E-signal may get different data!
Below is the actual screenshot of the documentation for the timeframe data you see above.
Look at the “open”! They are miles apart – because E-signal use a different set of parameters to register the open.
The broker data is the data we trade on. Now look at the “high”! What the f###.
That does turn testing your ideas in E-Signal a little unreliable. It seems the brokers and E-Signal disagree what
the “open” (the first opening price) should be, as well as the high. The low and the close are identical, or close to.
Let me take you through another example. This example is reverse engineered from a day where the setup turned
into a profitable trade. I will show you the dataset from the broker and from E-Signal.
It would seem that apart from the opening price, and if the “high” or “low” of the timeframe coincides with the
“open”, the dataset from the E-Signal DAX CASH CHART follows the brokers prices very accurately.
What makes the E-Signal charts so compelling to work from is that they only show the data from the open of the
stock market in Frankfurt to the close. It makes is easy to see how this particular strategy performed. The broker
charts, as you know, shows the data from the 24-hour cycle, and you have to squint your eyes to see exactly
where the market actually “opened” in Frankfurt.
I tested this “behaviour” back to May 2022. That constitutes 9 months of trading, with about 22 trading days in
each month, roughly speaking. I went through approximately 200 trading days.
Conclusions
I think you have to be careful to use the word “conclusions” when you are testing. I tested the hypothesis over
200 trading days, because I research manually. It takes time. Please bear in mind that 200 trading days may be a
good indicator for the current environment, but like any good trader, you adapt to the changing environment.
There were 54 occurrences where the 2nd bar closed below the low of the 1st bar. I am quick to add that there
were many occurrences where the 2nd bar went below but didn’t close below the low of the 1st bar, as well as
many occurrences where the 2nd bar went above and closed above the high of the 1st bar. I wasn’t testing for
that. I was just testing for the 2nd bar closing below the low of the 1st bar.
Out of the 54 occurrences, there were 5 days, where you didn’t have as much as a single point in profit. You
basically shorted the bloody low of the morning. Curiously, those days turned into spectacular trend move days,
either trending higher all day, or trending up with no retracement, and then fell with no retracement. There are
marked in RED on the charts below, all of which are 15min charts (in case that was not clear from the above).
Judge for yourself – the red circle marks your entry. Of course, there are days where you have a wait before a
profit. Of course there are days where you will have to consider a stop and reverse strategy. I will continue to
teach you this methodology, introducing stop loss parameters and stop and reverse parameters.
For now – view the charts and see what you think of these 54 occurrences – which is 25% of all trading days over
the last 200 trading days.
I would like to zoom in on some noteworthy examples.
23rd January 2023
On this Monday morning the stock indices were called significantly higher at the open. Dax had closed its regular
trading session (Frankfurt stock exchange close) at 15,033. Just before the open today it was trading up at 15,100.
The Regular Trading Hour chart (the one that ignores the 24-hour market) is shown below. There was a gap from
Thursday. Gaps do not always get filled on the day. Only 48% of gaps get filled on the day. The red circle shows
where I ended up shorting the DAX.
Here is a different perspective of the open. You see the entire swing, with the high from the previous week in
sight, with the gap clearly market, where the market opened, when it opened at 9am local time, and the 50% line
for visual guidance. So why did I short such a bullish market?
The answer is pitiful. Acknowledging that I am trading against the primary trend – which I have no issue with AT
ALL because when the trend is up/down, the counter moves are fierce, when the weak hands are caught
“following the trend – but can’t stand the heat of adversity” – I am looking around at the market.
The hourly chart is showing this pattern – chart below is an 1h chart. Basis this pattern I decided to sell short the
DAX. Trade entry ticket is shown. I am selling into resistance from the green box.
I close much too early. Later I sell short the DAX again on a School Run entry.
I close the DAX on a gap fill.
A short while later I short the DAX index again, betting on a retest of the lows. All my DAX trades for the morning
are shown below. I made 50 DAX points in total. I didn’t trade further in Telegram that day. Instead, I tested
GoToMeeting for latency. I had been told that GoToMeeting operates “with no latency”. I ran a test and 1000
people participated. It was a disappointment. Latency is present in GoToMeeting as well.
I ran two surveys about what people want from the Telegram channel.
Personally, I am thinking more and more that the way forward to me is this solution:
1/ dedicated server – using OBS software for streaming audio. I have tested it this week. The latency was down
to a second on audio. There were some audio issues, but I imagine they can be ironed out. It would mean that
people listening in will go to a website and press “play” and the audio will play.
I am not stopping educating. I said, "if you want to "SEE" me trade, as in "see my charts", then it will be at the
expense of the timeliness of the messages, and you will not be able to use my abilities to make money yourself.
But I am still posting my charts on WHY I took the trades. Ask yourself this, knowing that my charts are 100%
naked - with nothing on them - ask yourself "what would I possibly gain from seeing the same charts that Tom is
seeing?"
The answer is hopefully that you stand to gain nothing from looking at my charts. I don't draw on them. I just look
at them, and I place my trades. And when I then post my explanations on the charts during the day, as well as
sum up the trades, at the end of the week, you haven't lost anything. You are getting timely messages and the
education comes after.
If you are a tennis fan, and Roger Federer miraculously decided to teach you, would you keep interrupting him,
while he was actually playing a game against a worthy opponent? Would you stop him and ask? That is what I
need to stop. I literally get people asking me seriously uninformed questions, WHILST I am short the FTSE in £900
a point. That is what I need to stop from happening. So I am not letting the "losers call the shots". This has
everything to do with "let the professional work" and "read the messages you have been sent, because they
answer all your questions."
I have posted an Excel spreadsheet with ALL my resources. I have posted 160 pages of material in the last three
weeks. If you really want to learn to trade, then the lessons are there for you. I tell people to study Al Brooks. I
suggest how you can get Al Brooks for free, if you wish. It is all there. I am offering people a realistic shot at
becoming profitable and confident day traders. But I am drowning in stupidity, fuelled by an enormous amount
of people who think that it is better to ask than to research.
Did you know that I was up 3 hours before the open of the EU session today. In those 3 hours, I spent 2.5 hours
researching the FTSE, based on how the pattern of the last 2 days, going back 4 years. I was ready. I made £9,000.
And of course, I am gutted I closed it so early, making just £9,000 rather than £32,000. And I will study that. I will
extract the lesson. How many people do you think today spent 2.5 hours before the market opened to study? I
will say ZERO. That is why I am what I am. And all I need people to respect is to let me trade when I trade. And
respect that I truly dislike people asking me questions that I have already given them the answer to in the
"welcome messages".
So, you are wrong. No one has lost. Everyone has won, if I am given the time to focus on my trading. It means
people have to STOP and THINK for a second, before sending me messages. I have someone telling me that there
is news out this morning. Do you really think that a pro of my calibre does not know there is news out today? But
I can't stop people from messaging, so I have to make sure it is not an important message, and it takes my
attention away from the market. Even my friends send me stupid messages. "The FTSE is tanking", one person
said today. Well, duh, do you think I am sat watching porno? I know it is tanking. You don't need to tell me.
I am genuinely the person who can teach people to trade, if they truly want it. I am one of the very few in the
world who is actually trading live, but I am not interested in charging 100 dollars a month, so I can make an extra
10,000 dollars, when I make that in a day. I would rather just give it away, which I am. But this business attracts
the lottery seekers, who think that they can deposit 1000 euros and make it big. You can't. It doesn't happen, just
like zero latency is a pipe dream too.
That is all I ask. Work hard. Work your ASS off, and you will make it. And that is what I want people to do. WORK
YOUR ASS OFF. Use me for good questions. But do your own research first.
So now we are at a point where I am not answering questions anymore, because people have proven to me that
they are lazy. But I will continue to educate, and I will continue to trade. I just will not entertain questions
anymore, unless they are truly worth.
Let me show you the questions that are lined up right now:
1/ Tom, you think I can make a living from starting with 1000 euros?
2/ Tom, you should use Discord. It has low latency
3/ Tom, what do you mean by 100%
4/ Tom, why is your stop loss so big in the FTSE
5/ Tom, can I have all your other techniques?
6/ Tom, is CFDs tax free?
7/ Tom, Why is DAX falling today?
That is what I need to educate people to stop asking me. But for the record, here are my answers.
1/ I think it is totally unrealistic to think that you can start with 1000 euros and make a living from it
2/ No, Discord is not any lower latency than any other service, and it is a free service. Why would they give away
low latency as a free service. The answer is they don't.
3/ In my welcome messages, I explain what my percentages are. I get upset when people want to be part of my
universe and they then don't even bother reading the welcome messages. If I was going to be trained by David
Goggins, and he sent me some welcome messages, I would bloody well swallow every word he wrote to me.
4/ Because that is where the natural resistance is.
5/ No. You have to do your own work. I think it is disrespectful to ask. Accept what I give you, but don't ask for
more. You get more than you pay for. And you pay for nothing, and when I ask for donations, I get a measly
£2000, which amounts up to about £1 per person per month who are watching my active streaming. How
shameful is that? That is why I just fund it myself, because I want to pay Lennie.
6/ No CFDs are not tax free, but it is tax deductible in certain countries. Spread betting is tax free, but only if you
live in the UK. For many European countries they are making it increasingly difficult to trade CFDs because of the
tax laws.
7/ DAX is falling because the buyers are reluctant to bid up the stocks towards new highs. The US is
underperforming Europe and we often see the DAX being hesitant until the US trades come in. Having said that,
DAX is in a bull market, and in bull markets you buy the dips.
So, there you have it... my thoughts about everything and anything....
24th January 2023 – Dow trade
Here is my Dow trade on a 15min chart. This is not a great view, so next I will post the same chart, using a 1min
chart.
School Run Data
Here you see that the DAX closed at 15,307.98. The FTSE closed at 7,882.45. These prices are known as the
stock exchange cash prices.
Why is it important for me to know these prices?
1. It allows me to see quickly if the market the following day is trading higher or lower than the close of the
cash market the day before. This is important to me because it allows me to establish if the market is “gap
up” or “gap down”. Why is that important? Because 48% of all gaps get filled on the day.
2. If a market has been “gap up” or “gap down”, and the gap is filled during the morning, it often means that
whatever bullish or bearish overtures that was present at the open has now evaporated. In other words, if
the DAX has gapped up significantly, it would mean there has been a very bullish atmosphere around the
open. If that atmosphere has now dissipated, I am perhaps more inclined to look for bearish setups.
3. The “gap up” or “gap down” situation is impossible to see on most CFD broker charts, because their
charting service shows the market continuously 24 hours day. That is because CFD brokers derive their
“cash prices” – the ones we trade on – from the futures market. In the old days the DAX futures and the
DAX cash market opened and closed at the same time. Then the DAX futures began opening an hour
before the cash market. Now the DAX futures (as does the FTSE future) open at 9am Singapore time,
which is 2am European time. These two futures contracts are then open all the way until 10pm European
time. The brokers chart this price action, but for us who wants to know specifically what happens in just
the hours where the ACTUAL stock market is open, we have to do a little footwork on the charts before
the open, to mark the prices that are relevant to the closes the day before.
So why is this important? Allow me to show you an example from the 25th of January 2023, on a trade I did in the
FTSE index. If I did not explain this trade, and had I not done it in real-time with the Telegram time stamp, I
would sure be accused of making this up.
On this chart you see my long entry, and you see my exit. If you weren’t there to witness it, I do not blame you
for disbelieving me.
WHY did I buy where I bought? The answer is simple. The FTSE had gapped up that morning, and the moment it
hit the 7757 area, I bought. Why? Because this was the price that the FTSE closed at the night before when the
stock exchange closed. You can’t see that on the chart. You had to know about it in advance. That is why I go to
CNBC first this in the morning to figure out where the real stock market closed the previous day. The close was
just a double top. That was all.
Here is the same chart, but posted at the time:
After trading that morning I got into a dialogue with some of you about various charting tools. There is a guy on
YouTube who is selling courses, arguing that normal Candlecharts are for retail traders only, and only fools
trade like retail traders.
Theis individual calls candle charts “useless retail trading charts”. He argues that “real traders” use a different
kind of charts.
These videos pop up on my YouTube feed constantly. This individual claim to have worked for Barclays Capital as
a trader for years. He claims that they (Barclays Capital) never used conventional charts. He argues that
conventional charts are the tool of the amateurish retail trader. He argues that you might as well throw your
money away, if you use charts like this. If you really want to beat the market, you need to have a different set of
charts – and he goes on to show a chart set, which looks like Steidlmayer’s Market Profile charts.
I disagree with this argument. I want to be REALLY careful now. I do not want to be known in the world as a
person that attacks the person. I disagree with the argument. The fact that this gentleman is selling courses is
inconsequential to my argument. If people want to pay for education, then be my guess.
However, I want to be allowed to attack the argument (and not the person). I do not believe that we as traders
need a special way to present the market information. I feel my argument warrants attention because I have
made a significant amount of points in say the DAX index, with nothing more than a 5min candle chart like the
one below.
Two responses by members of the group stood out in the replies. I would like to show them. I should add that
not a SINGLE comment came to the defence of the argument made by the gentleman depicted on the previous
page. If there had been, I would have showed them.
26th Jan 2023
To my mind the opening minutes in America offers great opportunities for quick trades, trades that very quickly
give you a significant profit, or dumps all over you. Reviewing the trades in the days and weeks after is both
illuminating and hard work – especially if it was a losing trade. The mind does not want to seek out painful
experiences. Reviewing a trade deliberately – knowing it was a losing trade, and one where you didn’t trade well,
is not the brains ideal scenario for good fun carefree times.
If I wrote, “I made 60 points today in Nasdaq, which netted me £12,000”, then it makes about as much headlines
as “Djokovic won the match”. Reading what I just wrote makes me think that you think that I think I am a Djokovic
of trading, someone who always wins. I do not. He is a tennis champion. I am wanna-be. I tell myself that, so that
my mind does not become complacent. However, if the story is that Djokovic came from being 2 sets behind, to
win the match, it makes you pay more attention. And so, on this day, I start off by losing 50 Nasdaq and 70 Dow.
When I look over the trades, I see what I was trying to do, and I see how big a mistake I was making.
I short a double top upon the open, it is in hindsight the weakest double top in the history of double tops. I am
close to being stopped out on the first 5min rally. I am actually given an opportunity to get out of the trade for
minus 5, but I stay in. Then Nasdaq rally again, and now it goes 12,015.65, and my stop is 12,015. THEN it falls
hard.
What I regret about this trade is the weak reason for the short. I regret not getting out at minus 5 after the first
5min candle retraces all the way back. However, I wonder if I was too hard on myself? Would I have been so hard
on myself if I had not been stopped out, and the market disappeared into the abyss shortly after?
Reviewing trades gives you an opportunity to come face to face with your bad habits. I shorted the NASDAQ
again, and I added. I got out at my original entry price, and I was now back in plus for the afternoon. Then I
shorted it again. The problem with sharing this view you is that you only see the COMPLETED 5min chart. You do
not get feel and see what I saw, as the 5min chart was unfolding. I will rectify that next.
The chart below is the 1min chart. You will see there are two points – point 1 and point 2. The 1st entry is double
top failure entry. The index trades below the low of the candle that just made a new high (and stopped me out
by 0.65 of a point). That triggers my brain to say SHORT. Then I have 3 minutes of waiting. Now notice how price
action at point 2 – indicated by the blue line. Do you see how the market attempts to get above the two last bars,
and now trade below the low of them. Again, that to me is the ADD TO SHORT signal. Had I not been short there,
I would like to think I would have shorted it. I end the day in plus. My track record as always is in Excel and also
time stamped entries and exits throughout every trading day.
When you are down £12,000 after a few trades, you need to know yourself well, in order to not fall prey to the
normal human impulses. You need to know in your heart that you are NOT going to get reckless.
2: I expect to be uncomfortable.
The commands are the difference between winning and losing, between consistency and success, between the
large group that fail and the 5% that don't. Here's how the 95% losing group behave when they trade, compared
and contrasted against the mindset and the actions of the 5%.
Remember, I've watched thousands of traders execute millions of trades, and I noticed when most traders enter
into a position, they assume they are right. In a business where 95% of people fail, your recoding process begins
by flipping the switch. Flip the switch!
It starts with this: Assume you are wrong. You should assume you are wrong – until proven right. Through years
of observation, here's how the typical member of the 95% group trades.
PATHWAY ONE
The market continues moving in the same direction in what would have been in their favour, and they begin to
feel anxiety because they're no longer in the market.
With their pain increasing, they regret closing the trade, and they contemplate going back in. They are no longer
trading the market. They are trading with their emotions.
PATHWAY TWO
The market reverses, and they feel elation having got out in time. They saved their open profits by closing the
trade, telling themselves how good they are at timing the market.
They acknowledge their pain command centre. It was right, but they are now ruled by their pain threshold. Now
it's only a question of time before their emotionally driven pain threshold centre sends them a false signal, causing
them to lose. Welcome to the 95% group — a rollercoaster ride of disappointment, losing money, and pain.
COMMAND 3: I ADD WHEN YOU SUBTRACT AND SUBTRACT WHEN YOU ADD
First, here's how the 95% react when they're losing. And, remember, I'm not repeating factoids from a book, what
I'm showing you comes from years of empirical observations from my time working in the brokerage business.
Stay strong.
Tom Hougaard