Ferrite Microstrip Design Guide
Ferrite Microstrip Design Guide
Abstract—A coupled-mode approach is applied to a microstrip Their normal mode approach confirmed the CM operation con-
circulator with a distributed section of axially magnetized ferrite ditions of the FCL. However, the matching problem was also
coupled lines (FCLs). The equivalent model of the FCL junction neglected. Therefore, the satisfactory design procedure of FCL
is found, which includes gyromagnetic interaction between prop-
agated and evanescent isotropic modes. On the basis of the cou- junctions in principle has not been achieved. Recently, Xie and
pling process, the ferrite modes in the FCL are defined. From the Davis [6] have examined the reflection and power transfer of the
decomposition of these modes, the waves in each line of the struc- even and odd isotropic modes at the interface between the cou-
ture are determined. The mode matching is applied at the junction pled isotropic and ferrite lines. They solved the problem using
ports, which allows one to obtain the scattering matrix of the mi- the mode-matching approach where the dominant modes of the
crostrip FCL. Validity of the approach is verified by checking the
scattering parameters of the FCL section and comparing the nu- cascaded dielectric and ferrite lines were applied in the field ex-
merical results with available measurements. The proposed model pansion. However, their solution has omitted the excitation of
gives the properties with regards to the impedance matching and the interface by the ferrite modes so that the scattering problem
ferrite section dimensions, which can help the design of the FCL at the considered interface has been only partially analyzed.
nonreciprocal devices. As an example, the -parameters of an FCL Hence, their theoretical prediction is applicable to the case when
circulator are presented.
the second interface of the FCL section is perfectly matched. We
Index Terms—Circulators, ferrite-coupled-lines junction, scat- can conclude, therefore, that the scattering problem of the mag-
tering matrix. netized FCL section has not yet been solved sufficiently.
In this paper, the mode-matching approach is also applied to
I. INTRODUCTION define, for the first time, the scattering matrix of the FCL sec-
tion. The problem is solved by matching the fields of isotropic
(a) (b)
Fig. 1. Coupled lines loaded with a slab of an axially magnetized ferrite.
(a) Ferrite guide. (b) Corresponding dielectric basis guide.
(a) (b)
together and integrated over the cross section of the investigated
structure.
Due to the orthogonality of the base eigenfunctions, the inte-
gral equations are reduced to a matrix eigenvalue problem, and
solutions correspond to the modal fields and propagation con-
stants of the ferrite guide. The resulting system of linear equa- (c) (d)
tions has the ordinary form [9] written as
Fig. 3. Schematic distribution of the transverse electric and magnetic fields of
isotropic modes in the cross section of the FCL. (a) Even dominant mode 1.
(b) Odd dominant odd 2. (c) Higher order even mode 3. (d) Higher order odd
mode 4. Symmetry plane: magnetic wall for even modes and electric wall for
odd modes.
(1)
to (3), we expect that the coupling of dominant modes as well as
where of the higher ones can appear only in the ferrite region situated
near the slot between the strips. Moreover, the additional cou-
(2)
pling of the dominant even (odd) mode and higher odd (even)
mode can occur in the ferrite regions beneath the strips. If we
(3) include the above assumptions into CM equations and assume
the wave propagation along the ferrite guide as , then (1)
and denote the wavenumber and intrinsic impedance in can be reduced to the following matrix forms:
vacuum, and and are the propagation constant, wave
impedance, and the wave admittance of the th isotropic mode,
respectively. are diagonal elements and is the off-di-
agonal element in the relative permeability tensor of the ferrite.
The coefficient defines the perturbation of the th isotropic
mode, while the coefficient determines the gyromagnetic
coupling between the th and th isotropic modes. The cou- (4a)
pling occurs in the ferrite region where the transverse
and vectors are perpendicular to each other. Moreover, the
following condition for the coupling coefficients is satisfied, i.e., and
. The unknown voltage and current coeffi-
cients are functions of only, with dependence , where
is propagation constant. (4b)
(a) (b)
(11)
Fig. 5. Schematic representation of an FCL junction magnetized: (a) axially
and (b) transversely.
and
(13) (18)
(20)
(16)
(22a)
(22b) Fig. 6. Cross section of the ferrite section of the microstrip FCL junction
presented in Fig. 4. Structure parameters in the text follow from [7].
(22c)
V. NUMERICAL RESULTS
One way for (22a)–(22c) to be satisfied is when ,
which results from equal power coupling between the lines of Having defined the scattering model of the microstrip FCL
the junction. Equations (22a) and (22b) are now employed to structure, we now investigate the behavior of the microstrip fer-
give . Equation (22c) is then satisfied when the rite four-port junction that was designed and measured by Davis
phase difference . Hence, et al. in [7]. For the design of the junction, they applied new
we obtain independent of normal-mode conditions, which they recently developed in [6]
FCL parameters. If we choose the reference planes of the four for the model of the FCL. These conditions allowed one to find
ports so that and , not only the optimal length of the ferrite section, but to also es-
then from (22c), it can be shown that . Hence, timate the matching properties of the FCL junction. For realiza-
the nonreciprocal phase shift occurs in FCL when . tion of the junction, they have applied the section of ferrite cou-
There is the optimal nonreciprocal effect when or pled microstrips whose cross section is given in Fig. 6. It is made
180 and or , respectively. It implies a gyrator on a saturated ferrite substrate with saturation mag-
effect between the FCL ports 1 and 4, as well as 2 and 3. Obvi- netization kA/m, dielectric permittivity ,
ously, it makes it possible to use the FCL sections in the design and thickness mm. The widths of the microstrips are
of nonreciprocal devices. Consider now the other way that al- mm and they are separated by the slot mm.
lows one to satisfy the equations resulting from unitary condi- The microstrip ports of the junction are designed on the di-
tions of (21). We introduce the matching conditions and assume electric substrate with and have the same dimen-
that the ports 1, 3 and 2, 4 connected by the lines are now iso- sions as the ferrite microstrip lines. The measured responses of
lated. The elements and are then equal to zero the FCL junction of 48-mm length are presented in [7, Figs. 4
and the unitarity of (21) yields the following equations: and 5]. These results indicate that the considered FCL oper-
ates optimally near the 6.6-GHz frequency where most of the
signal energy is transmitted to one of the output ports for even
(or odd)-mode excitation. It only confirms the power exchange
ability of the two-coupled lines resulting from Faraday’s rota-
tion effect of the ferrite section. Note that a similar, but recip-
(23) rocal effect can appear at the sections of the coupled lines con-
taining, for example, anisotropic medium, where the change of
Here, we have two solutions of (23), i.e., the polarization state of the wave is possible. Therefore, the non-
or and or . It indicates the operation of reciprocal behavior of the FCL can be identified only in the case
the structure as a four-port circulator. However, the assumption when the phase shift additionally occurs for the reverse direc-
that the ports connected here by the lines are uncoupled cannot tion of magnetization on the FCL. In such a case, the rotation
be accepted because the signal transmission between these ports direction is reversed and the signal energy should be transmitted
will be observed. Hence, the circulation effect should not be ex- to the second output port of the FCL. However, this effect has
pected in the considered FCL configuration shown in Fig. 5(a). not been measured in [7] where the properties of the structure
Now we consider another model of the FCL [see Fig. 5(b)] in are presented only for one direction of the magnetization. The
which the ports 1, 2 and 3, 4 are coupled by the lines, whereas normal-mode approach [6] was developed [7] to model the be-
ports 1, 3 and 2, 4 are disconnected. It means that the mentioned havior of the measured FCL junction. The results are presented
isolation condition can be satisfied and the circulation effect can in [7], showing good agreement between the experimental and
be met in this configuration. Thus, this configuration relates theoretical values of the operation frequency (6.6 GHz) esti-
to the experimental FCL structure investigated in [10], where mated for minimum reflection. It indicates, in principle, that
the circulation effect was confirmed and qualitatively explained. theory [6] can be applied to the design and optimization of the
However, the different field phenomena determine the operation microstrip FCL section. However, values of the scattering char-
principle of the considered FCL structures. The Faraday phe- acteristics theoretically predicted in [7] did not agree well with
nomenon is possible in the axially magnetized FCL, while the the measured ones. For comparison, their measured values of in-
field displacement effect occurs in the transversely magnetized sertion loss and isolation at 6.6 GHz are approximately 1.5 dB
structure. Therefore, the other CM model is needed to explain and better then 30 dB, whereas the calculated ones are 0.4 and
the operation principle of the transversely magnetized FCL. In- 11 dB, respectively. Such disagreement could be expected since
deed, the CM model of the FCL presented here can be used theory [6] concerned the FCL, whose second interface was per-
only to design the axially magnetized FCL junction shown in fectly matched. In our opinion, even small reflection from the
Fig. 5(a). second FCL interface can provide such differences. Therefore,
1492 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON MICROWAVE THEORY AND TECHNIQUES, VOL. 50, NO. 6, JUNE 2002
Fig. 7. Dispersion characteristics of the dominant ferrite and isotropic modes Fig. 9. Computed scattering parameters of (Davis et al.) microstrip FCL
of the microstrip FCL shown in Fig. 6 (spectral-domain approach). Propagation
coefficients of isotropic modes: ; and ferrite modes: k ; k .
junction (see Figs. 4 and 6) at the frequency f =
6:6 GHz for different length
of the ferrite section (signal enters port 1).
Fig. 8. Computed coupling coefficients C ; C = C ;C for the Fig. 10. Frequency-dependent scattering characteristics of the (Davis et al.)
microstrip FCL shown in Fig. 6. microstrip FCL junction (see Figs. 4 and 6). The length of the ferrite section is
equal to 48 mm. The junction is excited from port 1 of the FCL.
(a) Fig. 13. Scattering characteristics of the microstrip T junction used in the
structure of the FCL circulator shown in Fig. 12.
(b)
Fig. 11. Computed insertion loss and isolation of the (Davis et al.) microstrip Fig. 14. Performance of the distributed FCL circulator presented in Fig. 12.
FCL junction (see Figs. 4 and 6) for: (a) odd- and (b) even-mode input at the
ports 1 and 2. Comparison with experimental results from [7] (dashed lines:
experiment [7], solid line: CM theory). of frequency. The best operation is seen in the 6–7-GHz band,
where the even-mode output from its ports 1 and 2 is evident.
The overall scattering matrix of the circulator is calculated by
combining directly the appropriate scattering matrices of the
cascaded T-junction and four-port FCL. -parameter character-
istics are shown in Fig. 14, where the three-port circulator be-
havior is clearly presented. In particular, the computed charac-
teristics demonstrate asymmetrical operation of the device. For
FCL circulators, this effect was previously predicted in [4]. It
can be seen that maximum isolations and , together with
Fig. 12. Schematic representation of the circuit of a three-port distributed return losses and are better than 25 dB at the operation
microstrip FCL circulator simulated as a cascade of the investigated FCL and
microstrip T junction. Ports impedance Z 50 . Details given in the text. frequency of GHz. However, values of these parame-
ters decrease to 15 and 12 dB at the 6.6- and 5.7-GHz frequen-
cies, respectively. At these frequencies, the isolation and
excitations of the junction by the even and odd mode give an
return loss of 19 dB are obtained. One should note that the
output at the opposite ports of those presented in Fig. 11. This
isolations and return losses of the circulator varying between
result clearly shows the FCL nonreciprocal behavior required
10–20 dB at the 5.7–7.3-GHz frequency band with maximum
for the three-port circulator. The three-port circulator consists
1.5-dB insertion losses over this range. These initial results were
of an FCL junction in cascade with a hybrid , as shown in
obtained for a nonoptimized structure. Although the result is not
Fig. 12. Thus, the T-junction ensures even-mode excitation of
very encouraging to promote the microstrip FCL circulator, it
the FCL, which is in need of circulator operation.
proves, however, the validity of the conception of this device
We simulated a T-structure realized on the same dielectric
design and shows that further work is needed to allow one to
substrate as the input sections of the FCL junction. Its cou-
design the optimal structure.
pled dielectric microstrip lines feeding FCL have the same di-
mensions as ferrite lines, and they are 5 mm in length. The
quarter-wave transformer (see Fig. 12) is used to match the VI. CONCLUSION
characteristic impedance 29.4 of a T-junction input line and The CM method has been successfully applied to solve the
impedance of port 3. In Fig. 13, the scattering char- eigenvalues problem of axially magnetized ferrite-coupled mi-
acteristics of the hybrid T-junction are shown as the function crostrip lines. On the basis of gyromagnetic coupling between
1494 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON MICROWAVE THEORY AND TECHNIQUES, VOL. 50, NO. 6, JUNE 2002
the dominant propagating and higher order evanescent isotropic [9] J. Mazur, P. Kutysz, and A. Cwikla, “Coupled-mode analysis of fer-
modes, the eigenmode solution of the FCL was found to bear rite microstrip lines,” IEEE Microwave Guided Wave Lett., vol. 9, pp.
300–302, Aug. 1999.
through their decomposition of the eigenfields at each line of [10] I. Awai and T. Itoh, “Coupled-mode theory analysis of distributed
the guide. The results of the analysis were used to derive a scat- nonreciprocal structures,” IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory Tech., vol.
tering matrix for the four-port FCL junction. This problem was MTT-29, pp. 1077–1086, Oct. 1981.
solved by matching the fields of isotropic and ferrite waves at
each port of the investigated junction. Considering the sym-
metry property of the structure with respect to the magnetization
Jerzy Mazur was born in Brno, Czech Republic, on
direction, the general nonreciprocal performance of the axially March 23, 1946. He received the M.Sc.E.E. degree
and transversely magnetized FCL junction has been discussed. and the Ph.D. and habilitation degrees in electrical
Verification of the modeling was demonstrated by comparing communication engineering from the Technical Uni-
versity of Gdańsk (TUG), Gdańsk, Poland, in 1969,
numerical results with an experiment presented in [7]. The good 1976, and 1983, respectively.
agreement with experimental results indicates that the presented He is currently a Full Professor at TUG. Since
model can be used in microstrip FCL junction design. It makes 1992, he has been also a consultant to the Telecom-
munication Research Institute, TUG. His research
it possible to investigate the novel nonreciprocal devices com- interests are concerned with electromagnetic field
prising the section of the FCL. As an example, the three-port cir- theory and integrated circuits for microwave and
culator constructed as the cascade of the microstrip T-junction millimeter-wave applications.
and FCL section has been described with promising scattering
performance.