RENEWABLE ENERGY IN ARCHITECTURE AND URBANISM ARC243

Solar Energy Tools and Softwares

Assignment (01)
Group (06)

Presented by:
Donia Ashraf Khalafallah
Donia Hatem
Mariam Ahmed Ezzat
Mariam Hussein
Merna Moataz Gamal
Momen Adel
Sama Mohamed
Sara Salah

Presented to:
Dr. Zeina ElZein
Table of Contents:
1.Introduction
2. Solar Energy Tools
2.1. Measurement
2.1.1. Pyranometer
2.1.1.1. Working Process
2.2. Installation
2.2.1. Crimping Tool
2.2.2. Solar Panel Hanger
2.2.3. Screwdriver
2.2.4. Cable Connector Tool
2.2.5. Tape Measure
2.2.6. Digital Multimeter
2.3. Maintenance
2.3.1. Monitoring Tool
2.3.1.1. Thermal Camera
2.3.2. Cleaning Tool
2.3.2.1. Soft-Bristled Brush
3. Solar Energy Softwares
3.1. Rhinoceros 3D/ Ladybug
3.3.1. Uses and functionalities
3.3.2. Strengths and Limitations
3.3.3. Integration with other solar tools
3.3.4. Data Input and Accuracy
3.3.5. Target Audience
3.3.6. Versions (if available)
3.2. Open studio
3.3. Energyplus
3.4. Aurora Solar
3.5. Helioscope
3.6. PVsyst
4. Design considerations
4.1. Features & Functions
4.2. Ease of Use & Support
4.3. Cost and Values
4.4. Customization & Scalability
4.5. Innovation & Update
4.6. Compatibility & Compliance
5. Green Academy Design Project
5.1. Design Considerations for the Green Academy Project
5.2. Choice Justification
6. Conclusion
7. References

2
 1. Introduction:

The integration of solar energy solutions in architectural design has become increasingly important in
recent years, driven by the global emphasis on sustainability and the need to reduce our reliance on
non-renewable energy sources. Buildings account for a significant portion of the world's energy
consumption, with residential and commercial sectors consuming approximately 40% of the total energy
used globally (International Energy Agency, 2022). Incorporating solar energy strategies in the design
phase can significantly reduce a building's energy demand and carbon footprint, contributing to the global
efforts to mitigate climate change.

Fig. (1): Global Share of Buildings and Construction Energy Consumption (IEA 2022)

One of the major challenges in achieving energy-efficient and sustainable buildings is the lack of
comprehensive design tools that can accurately assess and optimize solar energy utilization (Kalogirou,
2014). This design problem has led to the development of various solar energy design tools and software
solutions, which aid architects, engineers, and consultants in evaluating and incorporating solar energy
strategies from the early stages of the design process.

Solar energy design tools and software are specialized applications that facilitate the analysis, simulation,
and optimization of solar energy systems in building design. These tools provide a range of
functionalities, including solar radiation analysis, energy performance simulations, financial feasibility
assessments, and integration with other building design software (Crawley et al., 2008). By leveraging
these tools, designers can make informed decisions about the placement, orientation, and specifications of
solar energy systems, ensuring optimal performance and energy savings.

This report aims to provide a comprehensive overview of various solar energy tools and software, their
features, strengths, limitations, and applications in architectural design. It explores software solutions
such as Rhinoceros 3D with LadyBug, PVsyst, EnergyPlus, OpenStudio, Aurora Solar, Helioscope, and
others, evaluating their suitability for different design considerations and project requirements.
Additionally, the report presents a case study of a Green Academy design project, demonstrating the
selection process and justification for the recommended software suite.

3
2. Solar Energy Tools
Solar energy tools have a wide range of applications across various aspects of solar energy systems. Some
of the key applications of solar energy tools are:
2.1. Measurement
2.1.1. Pyranometer
A pyranometer is a scientific instrument used to measure the total amount of solar radiation, both direct
and diffuse, received by a surface. It captures the entire solar spectrum and provides a reading of the total
solar energy reaching the surface. Pyranometers are utilized for various applications but most commonly
it is used for designing and operating solar energy systems (Hukseflux USA, 2022).

Figure (2). Pyranometer Figure (3 ). The global irradiance includes direct sunlight and diffuse sunlight

2.1.1.1. Working Process

The working process of a pyranometer involves the following steps:
1. Solar Radiation Collection: The dome or window of the pyranometer allows solar radiation to pass
through and reach the thermopile sensor.
2. Absorption of Solar Radiation: When solar radiation reaches the thermopile sensor, it is absorbed,
and the temperature of the sensor increases.
3. Heat Generation: As solar radiation is absorbed by the thermopile sensor, heat is generated. This heat
causes a temperature gradient across the thermocouples.
4. Voltage Generation: The temperature gradient across the thermocouples produces a small voltage at
each junction of the thermopile. These voltages are additive, resulting in a measurable output voltage.
5. Electrical Output: The generated voltage is amplified and converted into an electrical signal
proportional to the solar radiation intensity (Shahzad, 2023).

Fig (4) Solar radiation measurement method using pyranometer

4
 2.2.1. Pyrheliometers
A pyrheliometer is an instrument used to measure direct solar irradiance or the intensity of solar radiation
from the sun's direct beam. It provides highly accurate measurements of the solar radiation received at a
particular location without any interference from diffuse or scattered radiation (Hukseflux USA, n.d.).

Fig(5) Pyrheliometers Fig(6) Pyrheliometers measure direct solar radiation

2.2.1.1. Working Process

When the sun's direct radiation enters the pyrheliometer, the concentrator focuses it onto the thermopile
sensor. The radiation heats one side of the thermocouple junctions, creating a temperature difference
across the junctions. This temperature difference generates a voltage output from the thermopile.
The output voltage of the thermopile is proportional to the intensity of the solar radiation. The
pyrheliometer is typically calibrated against a reference standard to establish the relationship between the
output voltage and the irradiance.
Measurement with a pyrheliometer is often performed by manually pointing it directly at the sun and
recording the output voltage. The measurements can be taken at regular intervals throughout the day to
track variations in solar irradiance (Hukseflux USA, n.d.).

Fig(7) Solar radiation measurement method using pyrheliometer

5
 2.2. Installation
When it comes to installing solar energy systems, several tools are essential to ensure a smooth and
efficient installation process. Some of the key tools that are commonly used are:
2.2.1. Crimping tool
A crimping tool is a handy device that allows you to create secure connections between wires and
connectors. It works by deforming the connector onto the wire, ensuring a strong bond. A crimping tool
consists of two hinged handles with jaws or dies at the end. To use it, you insert the wire and the
connector into the appropriate die, then squeeze the handles together. This applies pressure on the
connector, causing it to deform and grip the wire tightly. The result is a reliable and durable connection
(Thompson, 2021).

Fig (8) Crimping tool

2.2.2. Solar Panel Hanger

The solar panel hanger is a specialized tool designed to facilitate the mounting, leveling, and staging of
solar panels in traditional roof mount situations. It is engineered to act as an extra pair of hands during
panel installation, allowing multiple installers to focus on separate tasks, thereby speeding up the
installation process and ensuring precise panel alignment. The hanger also provides a safe way to stage
multiple panels on the roof at once, reducing the risk of installer injury (Ejiey, n.d.).

Fig(9) Solar Panel Hanger

6
 2.2.3. Screwdrivers
Screwdrivers are an essential tool that will be required during the installation process. And that is because
the entire solar panel will be held in place on the roof by screws. So the first things you will need to
tighten are the big screws locking the mounts onto the roof safely. The screwdrivers can come in handy
during the wiring part (Ejiey, n.d.).

Fig(10) Screwdriver

2.2.4. Cable Connector Tools

Electrician must-have tools such as high-quality pliers will ensure that there is no risk of electrocution
when you are installing electrical lines. Pliers are available in sets that are purposefully built for solar
system installation (Thompson, 2021).

Fig(11) Cable Connector Tool

2.2.5. Tape Measure
One of the biggest challenges every first-time solar installer faces is ensuring that the solar panels are
leveled on the roof. So you need a tape measure to help you determine the number of panels that your roof
can comfortably accommodate. The tape measure can also help you determine the exact place where you

7
will install the mounts which you will mark using your chalk. And once you have installed the mounts,
you can use a string line to ensure that the rails are leveled (Ejiey, n.d.).

Fig(11) Tape Measure

2.2.6. Digital Multimeter

A Digital Multimeter serves as the perfect instrument for detecting voltage quickly and also comes in
handy during installations and troubleshooting for combiner box and inverter. Digital multimeter can help
confirm the quality of power being emitted by each cell. A digital multimeter combines the testing
capabilities of an ohmmeter, ammeter, and voltmeter (Thompson, 2021).

Fig(13) Digital Multimeter

2.3. Maintenance
Maintenance is essential for ensuring the optimal performance and longevity of solar energy systems.
There are two types:

2.3.1. Monitoring Tools

2.3.1.1. Thermal Camera

The thermal camera used in solar energy applications, particularly for inspecting photovoltaic (PV)
modules, operates by detecting infrared radiation emitted by objects and converting it into electronic
signals, which are then processed into images. This technology aids in identifying defects and anomalies

8
in solar power plants, such as anomalies in PV modules or diode circuits, which cannot be easily detected
through visual or power output monitoring methods. The thermal camera provides a precise and efficient
way to inspect solar power plants, ensuring that anomalies can be located and repaired, thus contributing
to smooth power generation from solar energy systems (Linked In, n.d.).

Fig(14) Thermal Camera

2.3.2. Cleaning Tools

2.3.2.1. Soft-bristled brush
Soft-bristled brushes are commonly used as maintenance tools for cleaning solar panels in solar energy
systems. These brushes are specifically designed to gently remove dirt, dust, and debris from the surface
of solar panels without causing damage to the panels' protective coatings or glass (Solar Panel
Maintenance, 2023)

Fig(15) Soft-bristled brushes

3. Solar Energy Softwares
3.1. Open studio
OpenStudio is an open-source software development kit (SDK) for building energy modeling (BEM).
OpenStudio is a developer’s platform aimed at dramatically reducing the effort required to build and
maintain applications that use BEM and is aimed at growing and supporting the ecosystem of end-user
BEM tools and services.

9
 3.1.1. Uses and functionalities

● Building Energy Modeling: Creating detailed 3D models of buildings, including geometry,

construction materials, HVAC systems, lighting, and occupancy schedules.
● Energy Simulation: Using advanced simulation algorithms to predict the energy usage of
buildings under different scenarios.
● Energy Efficiency Analysis: Providing tools for assessing the energy efficiency of buildings and
identifying opportunities for improvement.
● Visualization and Reporting: The software offers visualization tools to display simulation
results in graphical formats, such as charts, graphs, and heat maps
● Compliance with Standards: Supporting compliance with various energy codes and standards,
such as ASHRAE 90.1, LEED certification requirements, and local building regulations.
● Integration with Other Tools: Open Studio can be integrated with other building performance
simulation tools, such as EnergyPlus and Radiance, to enhance its capabilities.

3.1.2. Strengths and Limitations

Strengths:

● Free and Open-Source: Open Studio is entirely free to use and modify, making it an
attractive option for those who want to avoid the high costs.
● Continuous Development: New features and improvements are often added regularly.
● Extensive Customization: Allow users to customize the software to suit their specific
needs.
● Learning Opportunities: Since Open Studio is free, it provides an excellent opportunity
for beginners to learn 3D modeling and animation.
● Collaboration and Community: It makes a collaborative environment, where users can
share their knowledge, and resources with one another. This community support can be
invaluable for users seeking help or guidance.

Limitations:

● Limited User Interface: which could make it challenging for beginners to navigate and
learn.
● Lack of Technical Support: The technical support might not be as readily available as
with commercial software.
● Limited Plugin Support: Plugins are essential for extending the functionality of the
software, and a limited selection may restrict users’ creative possibilities.
● Slower Performance: This can result in slower rendering times and potentially slower
overall performance.
● Lack of Industry Standard Features: Some advanced features found in commercial
software might be missing in Open Studio. This could be a concern for professionals who
require specific tools or functionalities for their work.

3.1.3. Integration with other solar tools

3.1.3.1.DesignBuilder

DesignBuilder is another popular building performance simulation software that offers a user-friendly
interface for creating detailed building models and conducting energy simulations. OpenStudio can be
integrated with DesignBuilder through the OpenStudio plug-in, which allows users to export building

10
models from DesignBuilder to OpenStudio for further analysis. This integration streamlines the workflow
for users who prefer to use DesignBuilder for building modeling and then utilize OpenStudio for in-depth
energy analysis.

Fig(16):Importing and exporting options to design builder software (designbuilder.co.uk, n.d.)

3.1.3.2.SketchUp

SketchUp is a 3D modeling software widely used in the architecture, engineering, and construction
industries for creating detailed building designs. OpenStudio provides a SketchUp plug-in that enables
users to import SketchUp models into OpenStudio for energy analysis. This integration allows architects
and designers to seamlessly transition from building design in SketchUp to energy modeling in
OpenStudio, facilitating a more integrated and efficient design process.

Fig(17): Openstudio plugin[Accessed 7 Mar. 2024] Fig(18):openstudio plugin in sketchup

3.1.3.2.BIM softwares

Building Information Modeling (BIM) software such as Autodesk Revit and Bentley AECOsim Building
Designer are commonly used for creating detailed building models with rich data attributes. OpenStudio

11
supports integration with BIM software through the development of interoperability tools that enable
users to import BIM models into OpenStudio for energy analysis. This integration enhances the accuracy
and efficiency of energy modeling by leveraging the detailed information available in BIM models.

Fig(19):Inegrating revit with openstudio[Accessed 7 Mar. 2024]

3.4.4. Data Input and Accuracy

● Building geometry: Floor plans, walls, roofs, windows, and doors. This information helps in
determining the building’s thermal properties and daylighting potential
● Weather Data: Incorporating local weather data into the simulation helps in assessing the impact
of climate conditions on the building’s energy performance.
● HVAC Systems: Inputting details about the heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC)
systems used in the building is crucial for evaluating energy consumption and thermal comfort.
● Occupancy Schedules: Helps in simulating internal heat gains from occupants and their activities
within the building.
● Lighting Systems: Providing information about lighting fixtures, controls, and schedules allows
for analyzing lighting energy usage and daylight availability.
● Construction Materials: Specifying the construction materials used in the building such as
insulation levels, glazing types, and shading devices is essential for accurate energy simulations.

3.4.5. Target Audience

● Architects: Use to assess the energy performance of their building designs, optimize energy
efficiency, and comply with sustainability standards.
● Engineers: Use in detailed building performance analysis, HVAC system optimization, and
thermal comfort evaluations.
● Designers: Utilize to incorporate sustainable design principles, daylighting strategies, and passive
design techniques into their projects.
● Sustainability Consultants: Use to provide data-driven insights into the environmental impact of
buildings and recommend sustainable design solutions.
● Energy Analysts: Use to model different energy scenarios, analyze energy consumption patterns,
and identify opportunities for energy savings.
● Building Energy Modelers: Use to create detailed virtual representations of buildings, simulate
various building systems, and evaluate overall energy performance.

12
 3.4.6. Versions
It has been continuously updated with new versions to enhance its capabilities and features. Below are
some of the major versions of Open Studio:
● Open Studio 1.0: This was one of the initial versions of Open Studio, which laid the foundation
for the software’s capabilities in building energy simulation and analysis.
● Open Studio 2.0: It brought significant improvements and added features to the software. This
version focused on enhancing the user interface, expanding the library of building components.
● Open Studio 3.0:Integration with EnergyPlus simulation engine, improved modeling tools, and
enhanced visualization options. This version aimed to make energy modeling more accessible.
● Open Studio 3.1: Introduced additional features such as improved HVAC system modeling,
enhanced reporting capabilities, and better compatibility with other simulation tools.

3.2. Energyplus
EnergyPlus is a whole building energy simulation program that engineers, architects, and researchers use
to model both energy consumption—for heating, cooling, ventilation, lighting and plug and process
loads—and water use in buildings. EnergyPlus (2019)

3.2.1. Uses and functionalities

Some of the notable features and capabilities of EnergyPlus include:
● Integrated, simultaneous solution of thermal zone conditions and HVAC system response that
does not assume that the HVAC system can meet zone loads and can simulate unconditioned and
under-conditioned spaces.
● Heat balance-based solution of radiant and convective effects that produce surface temperatures
thermal comfort and condensation calculations.
● Sub-hourly, user-definable time steps for interaction between thermal zones and the environment;
with automatically varied time steps for interactions between thermal zones and HVAC systems.
These allow EnergyPlus to model systems with fast dynamics while also trading off simulation
speed for precision.
● Combined heat and mass transfer model that accounts for air movement between zones.
● Advanced fenestration models including controllable window blinds, electrochromic glazings,
and layer-by-layer heat balances that calculate solar energy absorbed by window panes.
● Illuminance and glare calculations for reporting visual comfort and driving lighting controls.
● Component-based HVAC that supports both standard and novel system configurations.
● A large number of built-in HVAC and lighting control strategies and an extensible runtime
scripting system for user-defined control.
● Functional Mockup Interface import and export for co-simulation with other engines.
● Standard summary and detailed output reports as well as user definable reports with selectable
time-resolution from annual to sub-hourly, all with energy source multipliers. EnergyPlus (2019)

fig(20) The uses of the engine

workflow and input

13
3.2.2. Strengths and Limitations
Strengths:
Free and open-source: Accessible to anyone without licensing costs.
Highly detailed and versatile: Can model complex building systems and scenarios.
Widely used and supported: Extensive documentation, user community, and integration with
other building design tools.
Limitations:
Steep learning curve: Requires significant technical knowledge and experience to use effectively.
Time-consuming: Setting up and running simulations can be time-intensive, especially for
complex projects.
Not user-friendly: Not ideal for beginners or those seeking a quick and easy assessment of solar
energy potential.

3.2.3. Integration with other solar tools

fig(21) EnergyPlus directly supports a number o fig(22) Python Opens Up New Applications for
public and private-sector tools and services. EnergyPlus Building Energy Simulation

3.2.4. Data Input and Accuracy

Building geometry: Dimensions, shapes, and materials of the building envelope (walls, roof,
windows, etc.)
HVAC system: Type, size, and operating characteristics of the heating, ventilation, and air
conditioning systems.
Occupancy: Number of occupants, their schedules, and internal heat gains (e.g., from
appliances).
Weather data: Hourly data on temperature, humidity, solar radiation, and wind speed for the
building location. Iesl.lk. (2020)

Fig (23) Overall EnergyPlus Structure fig(24) Input and output data simulation

14
 3.2.5. Target Audience
Their intended audience is a design engineer or architect that wishes to size appropriate HVAC
equipment, develop retrofit studies for life cycling cost analyses, optimize energy performance,
etc. EnergyPlus (2019)

3.2.6. Versions

3.3. PVsyst:
PVsyst is a software tool used for designing, simulating, and optimizing photovoltaic (PV) systems. It
helps professionals in the solar energy industry with tasks such as system design, performance simulation,
financial analysis, grid connection studies, component sizing, and performance monitoring. Its main
purpose is to assist in maximizing the performance and profitability of PV systems through accurate
modeling and analysis.

3.3.1. Data Input and Accuracy:

PVsyst requires various inputs to accurately simulate and analyze photovoltaic (PV) systems. The key
data inputs include:

1. Site Information: PVsyst requires geographic data such as the location's latitude, longitude, and
elevation. It also considers local weather data such as solar radiation, temperature, and wind speed.

2. System Configuration: Users need to input details about the PV system components, including the PV
modules, inverters, batteries (if applicable), and electrical configurations. This includes parameters like
module specifications, tilt angle, azimuth, and wiring details.

3. Shading Analysis: PVsyst allows users to perform shading analysis by inputting information about
nearby objects, such as buildings, trees, or other obstructions that may cast shade on the PV system.

4. Electrical Parameters: The software requires electrical parameters such as system losses, cable
specifications, and inverter efficiency to accurately model the electrical behavior of the PV system.

5. Financial Parameters: For financial analysis, PVsyst requires inputs such as system cost, electricity
tariffs, incentives, and financing details to evaluate the financial viability and return on investment of the
PV project.

15
3.3.2. Uses and functionalities:

1. System Design: PVsyst allows users to design PV systems by specifying system configurations,
including the number and type of PV modules, inverters, and batteries. It considers factors like shading,
tilt, orientation, and electrical losses to optimize the system design.

2. Performance Simulation: The software simulates the performance of PV systems under various
conditions, such as different weather patterns, shading effects, and system configurations. It provides
accurate predictions of energy production, system performance, and key performance indicators like the
capacity factor and performance ratio.

3. Financial Analysis: PVsyst enables financial analysis by considering parameters such as system cost,
electricity tariffs, incentives, and financing options. It helps users assess the financial feasibility of PV
projects, calculate payback periods, estimate the return on investment (ROI), and perform sensitivity
analysis.

4. Grid Connection Studies: PVsyst assists in conducting studies related to grid connection, evaluating
the impact of PV system integration on the electrical grid. It analyzes parameters like voltage stability,
power quality, grid code compliance, and grid export limitations to ensure seamless integration of PV
systems with the grid.

5. Component Sizing and Optimization: The software helps users optimize component sizing based on
specific project requirements. It determines the optimal number of PV modules, inverters, and batteries to
maximize energy production while considering factors like cost, space constraints, and system limitations.

6. Performance Monitoring: PVsyst supports the monitoring and analysis of real-time energy production
data from PV systems. It allows users to compare the actual system performance with the predicted
performance, identify issues, and optimize system operation to maximize energy yield.

3.3.3 Cost:
The price for a subscription to PVsyst 7 PROFESSIONAL is 600.- CHF / year.
This also means that the purchase of an additional license or the renewal of an existing one will bear the
same cost.
The cost for student licenses is 25.- CHF for one year.
Universities, training and research centers are able to request special quotes.

3,3.4 Target user:

The target audience of PVsyst software includes professionals and stakeholders involved in the design,
analysis, and optimization of photovoltaic (PV) systems. The software caters to a wide range of users,
including:

16
1. Solar Energy Consultants: PVsyst is particularly useful for solar energy consultants who provide design
and analysis services for PV projects. It helps them accurately assess and optimize system performance,
conduct financial analysis, and make informed recommendations to clients.

2. PV System Installers: PVsyst can benefit PV system installers by providing them with the tools to
design and optimize PV systems based on specific project requirements. It helps them determine the
optimal system configuration, predict energy production, and assess the financial viability of projects.

3. PV System Integrators: PVsyst supports PV system integrators in evaluating the impact of integrating
PV systems with the electrical grid. It helps them analyze grid connection requirements, assess grid
stability and compliance, and optimize system operation for seamless integration.

4. Project Developers: PVsyst aids project developers in evaluating the feasibility and profitability of PV
projects. It enables them to conduct financial analysis, estimate the return on investment, and assess the
economic viability of projects.

5. Researchers and Academics: PVsyst is also commonly used by researchers and academics in the field
of solar energy. It helps them simulate and analyze PV system performance under various conditions,
conduct research studies, and validate theoretical models.

3.5.5. Versions:
1. PVsyst 7: This is the latest major version of PVsyst. It introduces significant updates and
enhancements, including improved modeling capabilities, advanced shading analysis, enhanced financial
analysis features, and updated databases for PV modules and inverters.

2. PVsyst 6: PVsyst 6 was a significant release that introduced several important features, such as the
integration of the Component Library, enhanced modeling options for bifacial modules, and improved
performance simulation algorithms.

3. PVsyst 5: PVsyst 5 introduced a range of features and improvements, including an extended

meteorological database, enhanced simulation accuracy, advanced shading analysis tools, and improved
financial analysis capabilities.

4. PVsyst 4: PVsyst 4 was a major release that introduced significant updates to the software, including
improved modeling of bifacial modules, enhanced system sizing and optimization tools, and enhanced
financial analysis features.

3.5.6. The strengths and limitation:

The strengths:
1. Accurate Performance Simulation: PVsyst is known for its accurate simulation capabilities, providing
reliable predictions of PV system performance under various conditions. It takes into account factors like

17
weather data, shading effects, and system configurations to generate accurate energy production
estimates.

2. Comprehensive Feature Set: PVsyst offers a wide range of features and functionalities, including
system design tools, financial analysis capabilities, grid integration studies, component sizing, and
performance monitoring. This makes it a versatile tool for professionals in the solar energy industry.

3. Extensive Component Database: PVsyst has an extensive database of PV modules, inverters, and other
system components, allowing users to select and model various manufacturers' products. This enables
accurate system modeling and optimization.

4. Continual Updates and Improvements: PVsyst regularly releases updates and improvements,
incorporating the latest industry standards, technologies, and research findings. This ensures that users
have access to the most up-to-date tools and methodologies.

The limitation:
1. Learning Curve: PVsyst has a complex interface and requires a certain level of expertise to use
effectively. Users may need to invest time in learning the software and understanding its various features
and parameters.

2. Data Accuracy Dependency: The accuracy of PVsyst's predictions is highly dependent on the quality
and accuracy of the input data provided by the user. Errors or inaccuracies in data inputs can impact the
reliability of the simulation results.

3. Proprietary Software: PVsyst is a commercial software that requires a paid license to use. This may
pose a limitation for users with budget constraints or those seeking open-source alternatives.

4. Simplified Electrical Modeling: PVsyst uses simplified electrical models, which may not capture all the
intricacies and complexities of specific system configurations. Users should be aware of these
simplifications and consider their potential impact on the accuracy of the results.

3.7. Aurora Solar

Aurora Solar is a cloud-based software platform designed for solar professionals to streamline the design,
analysis, and sales process of solar installations. It allows users to remotely assess sites, design solar
systems, estimate energy production, generate financial reports, and create professional proposals. It uses
advanced algorithms and 3D modeling to optimize system designs for maximum energy output and
streamlines the permitting process. Aurora Solar aims to improve efficiency, accuracy, and profitability
for residential, commercial, and utility-scale solar projects. (Aurorasolar.com, 2013).

One of Aurora’s key features is its high-resolution remote shading analysis, shown in Figure 1. To
generate a shading report, solar practitioners use a satellite image in Aurora’s interface to define the

18
structure of the building for which they are designing a photovoltaic (PV) system. Aurora then applies a
proprietary algorithm alongside user input to construct a 3D model from the 2D building structure, and
simulates the sun’s path over the resulting 3D model, as shown in Figure 2. The result is a heat map that
visualizes the irradiance value and provides solar access values (SAVs) for any point on the building’s
surface. (Evaluation of the Aurora Application Shade Measurement Accuracy Fast Facts, n.d.).

fig (25) A sample house with a heat map of irradiance and solar access values

fig(26) Simulating the sun’s path over a 3D model

3.7.1. Uses and functionalities

● Site Assessment and Design: It allows users to accurately model the solar potential of a site using
high-resolution aerial imagery and 3D design tools. This helps solar professionals assess shading,
roof obstructions, and other site-specific factors that may impact system performance.
● Performance Modeling: The software uses advanced algorithms to predict the energy output of a
solar system based on factors such as location, orientation, tilt, and shading. This allows users to
optimize system design for maximum energy production.
● Financial Analysis: Aurora Solar provides detailed financial analysis tools, including cost
estimates, savings projections, and return on investment calculations. Users can easily compare
different system configurations and financing options to determine the most cost-effective
solution for their customers.

19
 ● Proposal Generation: The software generates professional-looking proposals and reports that can
be customized with branding and personalized messages. This helps solar professionals
communicate the value proposition of their solutions to customers and stakeholders.
● Permitting and Compliance: Aurora Solar streamlines the permitting process by generating
accurate permit drawings and documentation that comply with local regulations and building
codes. This helps expedite the approval process and reduce administrative overhead.
● Project Management: The software includes project management tools to help users track the
progress of their solar installations, manage workflows, and collaborate with team members and
subcontractors. (Aurora Solar, n.d.)

3.7.2. Strengths and Limitations

Strengths:
Ease of use: Aurora Solar is known for its user-friendly interface and intuitive design, making it
accessible to users with varying levels of technical expertise. This is supported by positive user reviews
and testimonials highlighting its user-friendliness. (Capterra, n.d.)
Comprehensive features: The software offers a wide range of features, catering to various aspects of the
solar design, sales, and installation process. These features include:
● System design and modeling
● Proposal generation and customer presentations
● Shading analysis and performance estimation
● Financial modeling and payback analysis
● Project management and collaboration tools
● Integration with other solar tools.(Aurora Solar, n.d.)
Cloud-based platform: Aurora Solar is accessible from any device with an internet connection, allowing
for remote collaboration and project management. This is beneficial for teams working from different
locations and facilitates efficient communication.
Integration with other tools: The software integrates with various third-party platforms used in the solar
industry, such as LIDAR and satellite imagery for site assessment. This streamlines workflows and allows
data exchange between different tools. (Aurora API, n.d.).
Limitations:
Limited free plan: While a free version exists, it comes with restricted features compared to the paid
plans, which might be limiting for individual users or small businesses.
Cost: The paid plans can be expensive for individual users or small businesses, especially compared to
some free or open-source alternatives. While pricing information is readily available on their website,
consider exploring other solar design software options and comparing costs to find the best fit for your
needs.
Limited customization options: While the software offers various features, the level of customization
for specific needs might be limited compared to more specialized software. This limitation is often
mentioned in user reviews and comparisons with other solar design software.
Accuracy of data: The accuracy of the software's outputs relies heavily on the quality of the input data,
such as roof measurements and shading analysis. It is crucial to ensure data accuracy for reliable results,
and some users might face challenges with this aspect.(Aurora Solar, n.d.)

20
 3.7.3. Integration with other solar tools

Aurora Solar software and Scoop Solar offer a combined solution for solar businesses, integrating design
and proposal functionalities with project management and workflow automation. This integration
benefits various aspects of the solar project lifecycle, enhancing efficiency and collaboration.

fig(27) Aurora Solar and Scoop Solar integration

fig(28) Aurora Solar and Scoop Solar integration

3.7.4. Data Input and Accuracy

Address or Geographic Coordinates: The site where the solar installation will be located, geographic
coordinates (latitude and longitude) to specify the exact location.

Site Conditions: the software provides realistic predictions of solar energy production based on the
specific characteristics of the location.

21
Roof Orientation and Tilt: Determine the azimuth and tilt of the roof or mounting surface where the
solar panels will be installed,

System Design: influenced by the design parameters of the solar energy system, including the type and
efficiency of solar panels, inverters, etc… (Aurora Solar, n.d.)

​
​ 3.7.5. Target Audience:

Solar Installers and Contractors: who design, install, and manage solar energy systems for residential,
commercial, and utility-scale applications..

Solar Consultants and Engineers: perform technical analyses, and optimize system designs for maximum
energy production and efficiency.

Solar Sales Professionals: use software's proposal generation and financial analysis tools to create
compelling presentations and showcase the value proposition of solar energy systems

Solar Project Developers: rely on the software's project management capabilities to track project
milestones, collaborate with team members

Solar System Designers and Engineers: utilize the software's design and simulation tools to create
customized solar energy systems

Solar Financing and Investment Professionals: leverage the software's financial analysis features to
evaluate the economic viability of solar projects. (Aurora Solar, n.d.)

3.7.6. Versions (if available):

Aurora Solar doesn't offer different versions of its software in the traditional sense. They operate with a
single, unified platform that provides access to various features and functionality based on the
subscription plan chosen.

● Free Plan: Offers limited access to basic design tools and proposal generation capabilities.
● Basic Plan: Geared towards residential system design and sales, providing features like 3D
visualizations, financial analysis, and sales proposal tools.
● Premium Plan: Expands upon the Basic plan by offering features like advanced system
modeling, performance optimization tools, and collaboration features for larger projects.
● Enterprise Plan: Tailored for large organizations, this plan includes additional features such as
custom branding, bulk data import/export, and dedicated customer support. (Aurora Solar, n.d.)

3.5

HelioScope is a software program specifically designed for solar energy . It is primarily used by
residential and commercial-scale solar installers to design and optimize sapplicationsolar panel arrays.

3.5.1.Data Input and Accuracy

22
Site location:This includes latitude, longitude, and elevation, crucial for solar position calculations and
shading analysis.
System details:This encompasses information like module type, inverter specifications, system losses
(due to wiring, etc.), and desired tilt angle of the panels.
Shading analysis: Users can input shading objects like buildings, trees, or nearby structures, which are
then incorporated into the software's simulations.
Utilize satellite imagery: HelioScope allows users to import satellite images to visualize the site and
confirm the location and potential shading from surrounding objects.

3.5.2.Uses and Functionalities

1. Design and Layout:

Intuitive interface: HelioScope boasts a user-friendly interface that simplifies the process of designing and
arranging solar panels on a virtual roof or ground space.

3D modeling: The software allows users to create 3D models of the project site, enabling them to
visualize the placement of panels and potential shading objects.

Integration with Google Maps: You can directly import the project location from Google Maps,
eliminating the need for manual entry of coordinates.

fig(29)Demonstrates the use of 3D and modeling in the program

2. Shading Analysis:

Identify shading sources: Users can incorporate surrounding objects like buildings, trees, and other
structures into the model to assess their impact on sunlight exposure throughout the day and year.

Visualize shading patterns:HelioScope generates visual representations of shading patterns, allowing you
to identify areas with limited sunlight and optimize panel placement accordingly.

3. System Performance Simulation:

Weather data integration: The software incorporates historical and predicted weather data for the project
location to simulate the expected energy production of the solar system.

23
Component selection: HelioScope allows you to choose from a library of various solar panels, inverters,
and other components, enabling you to compare performance and optimize system design.

Performance reports:The software generates comprehensive reports that detail the estimated energy
production, system efficiency, and potential financial returns.

fig(30)Shadow simulation and analysis demonstrates the program interface

4. Additional Functionalities:

Automatic proposal generation: Based on the design and simulation results, HelioScope can automatically
generate professional proposals for clients, saving time and effort.

Collaboration tools: The software facilitates collaboration between team members by allowing them to
share and discuss project details within the platform.

Overall, HelioScope offers a comprehensive set of functionalities that streamline the design and
optimization process for solar energy systems, making it a valuable tool for professionals in the solar
industry.

fig(31)A model showing performance reports from the program

3.5.3.Target users
1. Solar Installers:Professionals responsible for installing solar PV systems on residential or commercial
properties.

24
2. Solar Designers: Individuals involved in the design and layout of solar arrays, taking into account
factors like roof orientation, shading, and optimal panel placement.

3. Engineers: Solar energy engineers who work on the technical aspects of solar projects, ensuring that the
system is designed to meet performance and efficiency requirements.

4. Energy Consultants:Professionals providing consultation services related to solar energy, helping

clients assess the feasibility and design of solar installations.

5. Project Managers: Individuals overseeing the planning and execution of solar projects, ensuring that
designs meet regulatory requirements and project goals.

3.5.4. Integration with other solar tools

1. Energy Toolbase:
Integration:Users can export project data from HelioScope, including system design and performance
estimates, directly into Energy Toolbase. This allows for seamless integration of system design with
financial analysis, enabling users to assess the financial viability of the solar project considering factors
like utility rates and avoided cost calculations.

fig(32)Demonstrates the nergy Toolbase interface for calculating the cost of solar panels

2. Nearmap:
Users can import high-quality aerial imagery and 3D data from Nearmap directly into HelioScope. This
enhances the accuracy of the 3D modeling process by providing a more precise representation of the
project site and surrounding environment.

fig(33)The program interface sets the accuracy and clarity of satellite images

25
4. Design Considerations:
Solar system design software can help you optimize your system performance, calculate your energy
savings, and create detailed reports and proposals. But how can you choose the best solar system design
software for your project? Here are some factors to consider.

4.1. Features and functions

When selecting solar system design software, it's important to consider the features and functions that suit
your needs. Depending on your project scope and goals, you may require different tools and capabilities
such as 3D modeling and shading analysis, roof layout and orientation, PV module and inverter selection,
battery and backup system integration, electrical wiring and safety compliance, energy production and
consumption simulation, financial analysis and incentives, environmental impact and carbon footprint, as
well as report generation and presentation. It's essential to ensure the software you choose can handle all
the aspects of your project and provide accurate results.

4.2. Ease of use and support

The second factor to consider is the ease of use and support of the software. You want a software that is
user-friendly, intuitive, and compatible with your devices and platforms. You also want a software that has
a clear and comprehensive documentation, tutorials, and customer service. You should be able to access
the software anytime and anywhere, and get help when you need it. You should also check the reviews
and ratings of the software from other users and experts, and see if they have any feedback or suggestions.

4.3. Cost and value

The third factor to consider is the cost and value of the software. You need to compare the prices and
plans of different software options, and see which one fits your budget and expectations. You should also
consider the value of the software, which is the return on investment you can get from using it. You
should evaluate how the software can help you save time, money, and resources, and improve your system
quality and performance. You should also look for any discounts, trials, or guarantees that the software
offers, and see if they are worth it.

4.4. Customization and scalability

The fourth factor to consider is the customization and scalability of the software. You need a software that
can adapt to your specific project requirements and preferences, and allow you to modify and adjust the
parameters and settings as you wish. You also need a software that can scale up or down with your project
size and complexity, and handle multiple projects at once. You should look for a software that has a
flexible and modular design, and can integrate with other software and tools that you use.

26
4.5. Innovation and updates

The fifth factor to consider is the innovation and updates of the software. You want a software that is up to
date with the latest trends and technologies in the solar industry, and can incorporate new features and
functions as they emerge. You also want a software that is constantly improving and enhancing its
performance, usability, and security, and can fix any bugs or issues promptly. You should look for a
software that has a strong and active development team, and a loyal and engaged user community.

4.6. Compatibility and compliance

The sixth factor to consider is the compatibility and compliance of the software. You need a software that
can work with the equipment and components that you use or plan to use for your solar system, and can
communicate with them effectively. You also need a software that can comply with the standards and
regulations that apply to your project location and type, and can generate the necessary documents and
certificates. You should look for a software that has a wide and diverse database of products and
providers, and a thorough and updated knowledge of the rules and policies.

5. Green Academy Design Project:

As architectural designers working on a Green Academy project, We would recommend using a

combination of Rhinoceros 3D, along with the environmental analysis plugins LadyBug and
Honeybee.

5.1. Design Considerations for the Green Academy Project:

● Utilize sustainable local materials in construction to minimize environmental impact.

● Implement passive design strategies to reduce energy consumption across all zones.
● Establish a comprehensive waste management system emphasizing recycling and composting.
● Incorporate renewable energy sources such as biomass, solar panels and wind turbines to power
the Green Academy.
● Integrate green spaces and productive landscaping throughout the campus to promote
biodiversity and environmental awareness.
● Maximize natural light and ventilation in all areas to reduce reliance on artificial lighting and
HVAC systems.
● Design flexible spaces to accommodate future changes or expansions.

27
fig(34) Green Academy Project Description and Site Boundaries: Nile River from the west, Main Road
from the East, Residential Villa from the north, Petrol Station from the south, and The site contains dense
trees in the north western and the eastern directions (Source: The author)
5.2. Choice Justification:
● Features and functions: Rhinoceros 3D is a powerful 3D modeling software that allows to
create detailed architectural designs and visualizations. When combined with LadyBug and
Honeybee, it offers a comprehensive set of tools for environmental analysis, including solar
radiation analysis, daylighting simulations, and energy performance evaluations. These tools are
essential for designing a sustainable and energy-efficient building like the Green Academy.

● Ease of use and support: Rhinoceros 3D is widely used in the architectural industry and has a
intuitive user interface. LadyBug and Honeybee are well-integrated plugins that seamlessly
integrate with Rhino, making it easy to transition between design and analysis tasks.
Additionally, these tools have extensive documentation, tutorials, and an active user community,
ensuring that we can access support and resources when needed.

● Cost and value: While Rhinoceros 3D is a paid software, it offers educational licenses at
discounted rates, making it more accessible for a project like the Green Academy. The value of
this software suite lies in its ability to combine architectural design with environmental analysis,
allowing to optimize the building's performance and sustainability from the early design
stages.

28
 ● Customization and scalability: Rhinoceros 3D is highly customizable, allowing to create
complex geometries and adapt the software to specific project requirements. LadyBug and
Honeybee also offer a wide range of customization options, enabling to tailor the
environmental analysis to the Green Academy's unique needs.

● Innovation and updates: Rhinoceros 3D, LadyBug, and Honeybee are frequently updated with
new features and improvements, ensuring that we have access to the latest tools and
technologies for sustainable design.

● Compatibility and compliance: Rhinoceros 3D is compatible with various file formats and can
integrate with other software tools commonly used in the architectural industry. LadyBug and
Honeybee are designed to work seamlessly with Rhino, ensuring a smooth workflow and data
exchange.

Reasons why the other software options may not be as suitable as Rhinoceros 3D with LadyBug and
Honeybee for an architectural designer working on the Green Academy project:

● PVsyst: While PVsyst is an excellent choice for solar system design and simulation, it lacks the
architectural modeling and building performance analysis capabilities that an architectural
designer would require. PVsyst is primarily focused on the technical aspects of solar system
design, rather than the overall building design and integration of sustainable strategies.

● EnergyPlus: EnergyPlus is a powerful building energy simulation software, but it is primarily

focused on analyzing the energy performance of existing buildings or detailed building
models. As architectural designers , we would need a software that integrates seamlessly with
the design process from the early stages, allowing to optimize the building's form, orientation,
and envelope for energy efficiency.

● OpenStudio: OpenStudio is a user-friendly interface for EnergyPlus, which provides a more

intuitive workflow for energy modeling. However, like EnergyPlus, it lacks the architectural
design and visualization capabilities that Rhinoceros 3D offers. Additionally, OpenStudio may
not provide the same level of integration with environmental analysis tools like LadyBug
and Honeybee.

29
 ● Helioscope: Helioscope is a software specifically designed for solar system design and
analysis. While it may offer some building modeling features, its primary focus is on optimizing
solar panel placement and energy production. As architectural designers, we would likely require
a more comprehensive software suite that integrates building design, environmental
analysis, and solar system optimization.

● Aura Solar: Aura Solar is another solar system design software, but it may not offer the same
level of architectural design and environmental analysis capabilities as Rhinoceros 3D with
LadyBug. Additionally, it may have limited compatibility with other architectural software
and workflows.

By choosing Rhinoceros 3D with LadyBug and Honeybee, you gain access to a powerful architectural
design tool that seamlessly integrates with environmental analysis plugins. This allows you to explore
different design options, optimize the building's performance, and visualize the impact of sustainable
strategies from the earliest stages of the design process.

6. Conclusion:

The integration of solar energy strategies in architectural design has become critical for sustainable and
energy-efficient buildings. Various solar energy design tools and software facilitate accurate analysis,
simulation, and optimization of solar energy systems, enabling informed decisions from the early design
stages. This report provided an overview of prominent solutions like Rhinoceros 3D with LadyBug
PVsyst, EnergyPlus, OpenStudio, Aurora Solar, and Helioscope, highlighting their features, strengths,
limitations, and applications. It also presented a case study of a Green Academy design project, justifying
the recommended software suite. As the demand for energy-efficient and sustainable buildings grows, the
importance of solar energy design tools and software will increase, empowering professionals to
incorporate innovative solar energy strategies and deliver sustainable, high-performance building
solutions.

6. References:

● EnergyPlus (2019). EnergyPlus | EnergyPlus. [online] Energyplus.net. Available at:

https://energyplus.net/.
● Department of Energy (2018). Department of Energy. [online] Energy.gov. Available at:
https://www.energy.gov/.
● Advances in Engineering. (n.d.). Comparison of EnergyPlus and IES to model a complex university
building using three scenarios. [online] Available at:
https://advanceseng.com/comparison-energyplus-and-ies-model-complex-university-building/
[Accessed 7 Mar. 2024].
● designbuilder.co.uk. (n.d.). DesignBuilder Software Ltd - What’s New in v7. [online] Available at:
https://designbuilder.co.uk/software/what-s-new-in-v7.

30
● Energy.gov. (n.d.). OpenStudio. [online] Available at:
https://www.energy.gov/eere/buildings/articles/openstudio [Accessed 7 Mar. 2024].
unmethours.com. (n.d.). Unmet Hours. [online] Available at:
https://unmethours.com/question/28251/revit-gbxml-to-openstudio/ [Accessed 7 Mar. 2024].
● Aurorasolar.com. (2013). Aurora Solar. [online] Available at: https://www.aurorasolar.com/.
● Evaluation of the Aurora Application Shade Measurement Accuracy Fast Facts. (n.d.). Available
at: https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy16osti/65558.pdf.
● Aurora Solar. (n.d.). Aurora Solar: The World’s #1 Solar Design Software. [online] Available at:
https://www.aurorasolar.com [Accessed 7 Mar. 2024].
● Capterra. (n.d.). Best Solar Software 2024. [online] Available at:
https://www.capterra.com/solar-software/ [Accessed 7 Mar. 2024].
● Hukseflux USA (n.d.). What is a pyrheliometer? [Online]. Available at:
https://www.hukseflux.com/applications/solar-energy-pv-system-performance-monitoring/what-is
-a-pyrheliometer [Accessed 7 Mar. 2024]
● Shahzad, H. (2023). Intro to Solar Radiation Measuring Instruments. [Online] Available
at:https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/intro-solar-radiation-measuring-instrumentsequipment
-working-mukhtar [Accessed 7 Mar. 2024]
● Hukseflux USA (2022). What is Pyranometer? [Online] Available at:
https://huksefluxusa.com/learn/what-is-a-pyranometer/ [Accessed 7 Mar. 2024]
● Thompson, C. (2021). 10 Essential Tools for DIY Solar Installation [Online] Available at:
https://unboundsolar.com/blog/10-essential-tools-for-diy-solar-installation [Accessed 7 Mar.
2024]
● Ejiey (n.d.). Solar Panel Installation Tools | Must-Have Tools | Function Of Tools. [Online]
Available at: https://www.poweredbydaylight.com/blog/solar-panel-installation-tools/ [Accessed
7 Mar. 2024]
● getpylon.com. (n.d.). HelioScope Alternative. [online] Available at:
https://getpylon.com/uk/vs/helioscope/ [Accessed 7 Mar. 2024].
● HelioScope Blog. (2016). HelioScope Goes 3D. [online] Available at:
https://blog.helioscope.com/helioscope-goes-3d/ [Accessed 7 Mar. 2024].
● www.energytoolbase.com. (n.d.). Energy Toolbase | Solar & Storage Deployed Simply. [online]
Available at: https://www.energytoolbase.com/ [Accessed 6 May 2022].
● HelioScope Blog. (2017). Financials Via Energy Toolbase. [online] Available at:
https://blog.helioscope.com/financials-via-energy-toolbase/ [Accessed 7 Mar. 2024].
● Crawley, D. B., Hand, J. W., Kummert, M., & Griffith, B. T. (2008). Contrasting the capabilities
of building energy performance simulation programs. Building and Environment, 43(4), 661-673.
● International Energy Agency. (2022). Global Energy Review 2022.
https://www.iea.org/reports/global-energy-review-2022
● Kalogirou, S. A. (2014). Solar energy engineering: processes and systems. Academic Press.

31