Sheet No.

: 2 of 6
TECHNICAL BID EVALUATION FOR
PROJECT NO.: P11P3351

TREL Doc. No. :

CHILLER UNIT [R-1704]
9-13-317

Date:30-05-2019 Rev. No.: 0A

REVISION LOG

REV NO REV DATE REVISED PAGE/S REVISION DESCRIPTION

0A 30-05-2019 - ISSUED FOR INFORMATION

0 1/0/1900 4 to 6 0
 Sheet No. : 3 of 6
TECHNICAL BID EVALUATION FOR
PROJECT NO.: P11P3351

TREL Doc. No. :

CHILLER UNIT [R-1704]
9-13-317

Date:30-05-2019 Rev. No.: 0A

TABLE OF CONTENTS

NO DESCRIPTION PAGE

1 TECHNICAL BID EVALUATION FOR CHILLER UNIT [R-1704] 4-6

 Sheet No. : 4 of 6
PROJECT NO.: P11P3351
TECHNICAL BID EVALUATION FOR
TREL Doc. No. :
9-13-317
CHILLER UNIT [R-1704]
Date:30-05-2019 Rev. No.: 0A

Design requirement/ CARRIER

S/N Evaluation Criteria
Specification
Offered Specification Accpt. ? Remarks

1 Vendor ENTECH Yes

2 Quotation Reference ST62050315-R3 Yes

3 Chiller unit Make / Country of Origin USA / China / Japan/ Thailand Thailand Yes

4 Model Vendor To propose 30GTF030 Yes

5 Item No. R-1704 R-1704 Yes

6 Required Quantities 1 set (3 parallel x 1 in series) 1 set (3 parallel x 1 in series) Yes

7 Rerquired Compressor Unit 3 x 50% 3 x 50% Yes

8 Type Air Cooled Air Cooled Water Chiller Yes

9 Location Outdoor Outdoor Yes

Chiller unit is considered safe
Safe Area for External Bund zone
10 Hazardous Area as per TTT Classcification wall Safe Area for External Bund wall Yes TREL understands this is because
Zone 1 for Internal bund wall chiller unit skid content only
water however electrical team
11 Process Data
106.98kw/Unit
Design total system heat duty capacity(155) +
12 kW 186 (AT 100% OF Yes
margin 20%(31) KW
2Unit=213.96kw)
Tons of 30.41RT/Unit
13 Total Cooling Capaicty 52.9 Yes
Refrigeration(RT) (2 Unit=60.82 RT)

14 Design Heat duty per Unit, KW/ Unit kW/Unit 93 106.98 kw Yes

Chiller unit to maintain tank T-1704 product Required,follow TREL Process Confirm, follow TREL Process Data
15 Yes
temperature 10 Deg.C Data sheet and Calculation sheet and Calculation
16 Efficiency (Without Pump) : EER BTU / WH EER (VTA) 5.22 Yes

17 Design pressure bar g 9.2 9.2 Yes

18 Design temperature °C 93 93 Yes

19 Ambient temperature °C 35 35 Yes

20 Refrigerant Non CFC R407C (Non CFC) Yes

Confirm, follow TREL Process

21 PO Mass flow rate @ Tank Kg/Hr Inlet=84,050 / Outlet=84,050 Inlet=84,050 / Outlet=84,050 Yes
Data sheet and Calculation

22 Water Mass flow rate @ Heat Exchanger Kg/Hr Inlet=55,000 / Outlet=55,000 Inlet=55,000 / Outlet=55,000 Yes

Confirm, follow TREL Process

23 PO Specific gravity at 10 DegC @ Tank °C Inlet=0.84 / Outlet=0.84 Inlet=0.84 / Outlet=0.84 Yes
Data sheet and Calculation
Confirm, follow TREL Process
24 PO Viscosity at 10 DegC @ Tank cP Inlet=0.41 / Outlet=0.41 Inlet=0.41 / Outlet=0.41 Yes
Data sheet and Calculation
Confirm, follow TREL Process
25 PO Specific Heat @ Tank kCal/Kg-C Inlet=0.456 / Outlet=0.456 Inlet=0.456 / Outlet=0.456 Yes
Data sheet and Calculation
Confirm, follow TREL Process
26 PO Thermal Conductivity @ Tank W/m-C Inlet=0.156 / Outlet=0.156 Inlet=0.156 / Outlet=0.156 Yes
Data sheet and Calculation
Confirm, follow TREL Process
27 PO Temperature @ Tank °C Inlet=13.5 / Outlet=9.4 Inlet=13.5 / Outlet=9.4 Yes
Data sheet and Calculation
But Vendor confirm at Inlet Note
28 Water Temperature @ Heat Exchanger °C Inlet=7.2 / Outlet=10.08 Inlet=7.2 / Outlet=10.08 Yes
: For outlet depend on Load.
Confirm, follow TREL Process
29 Pressure Drop Total / Allowed (PO) bar g 0.77 0.77 Yes
Data sheet and Calculation
Confirm, follow TREL Process
30 Pressure Drop Total / Allowed (Chiller water) bar g 0.15 0.15 Yes
Data sheet and Calculation
31 Connection
PROPYLENE OXIDE NOZZLE SIZE / FLANGE
32 6'' / 150# RF/FF, ASME/ANSI 6" 150# RF,ANSI Flange Yes
RATING INLET:
PROPYLENE OXIDE NOZZLE SIZE / FLANGE
33 6'' / 150# RF/FF, ASME/ANSI 6" 150# RF,ANSI Flange Yes
RATING OUTLET:
34 Shell and Tube Heat Exchanger

35 Type Shell and Tube Confirmed Yes

36 Make / Scope TREL BY TREL Yes

37 Required Quantities Set 1 Set 1 Set Yes

38 Origin Thailan Thailand Yes

39 Hazardous Area Zone1 Zone1 Yes

40 Compressor
MYCOM / Carrier / Burkhardt
41 Compressor Make Carlyle (Carrier make) Yes
compression
TTT to confirm.
42 Compressor Origin VTA China Yes However,TREL proposed the
origin as same as Bidding stage

43 Model VTA 06E6299611 Yes

 Sheet No. : 4 of 6
PROJECT NO.: P11P3351
TECHNICAL BID EVALUATION FOR
TREL Doc. No. :
9-13-317
CHILLER UNIT [R-1704]
Date:30-05-2019 Rev. No.: 0A

Design requirement/ CARRIER

S/N Evaluation Criteria
Specification
Offered Specification Accpt. ? Remarks
RECIPROCATING SEMI-
44 Compressor Type VTA Yes
HERMATIC
45 Hazardous Area Safe Area Safe Area Yes

46 Evaporator
Vendor please provide more
47 Required Quantities Set 3 3 Yes
specification
48 Evaporator heat exchanged kW/hr VTA 128kw/hr Yes

49 Fouling factor (hr-sq-ft-F)/BTU VTA 0.00075 Yes

50 Evaporator pressure drop Bar VTA 0.5 Bar ( 7.3 PSI) Yes

51 Hazardous Area Safe Area Safe Area Yes

52 Condenser

53 Required Quantities Set VTA 2 Sets/Unit Yes Total of Condensor = 6 Sets

Max. duty 75.46Kw/set (

54 Condenser Capacity kW VTA 150.92 kW/Unit Yes Chiller1 unit= 2set of Condenser)
75.46 x 2 = 150.92 Kw/Unit

55 No. of Fans per condenser unit Nos. VTA 2 Nos/ Unit Yes
Condenser Fan Air Flow at Ambient
56 CFM VTA Approx 23,200 CFM Yes
Temperature
57 Condenser: Outdoor Air Temp °C VTA 35 Deg C Yes

58 Hazardous Area Safe Area Safe Area Yes

59 Water Pump

60 Water Supply Pump Required Quantities Sets 2(R1+S1) 2(R1+S1) Yes

61 Pump casing with Insulation Required Confirmed Yes

62 Model VTA N50/250B Yes Please provide specification

63 Make VTA Calpeda Yes

64 Origin China / India not accept Italy Yes

65 Type Centrifugal Centrifugal Yes

66 Capacity m3/Hr 55 24-69 Yes

67 Head mH20 Approx. 40 m 43-69 Yes

68 Motor Type VTA Induction Yes

69 Motor KW KW VTA 15 kw/unit Yes

70 Water Circulation Pump Required Quantities Sets VTA 3( R2 +S1) Yes

71 Pump casing with Insulation Required Confirmed Yes

72 Model VTA N40/125 AA Yes Please provide specification

73 Make VTA Calpeda Yes

74 Origin China / India not accept Italy Yes

75 Type Centrifugal Centrifugal Yes

76 Capacity m3/Hr VTA 15-42 Yes

77 Head mH20 VTA 11-22 Yes

78 Motor Type VTA Induction Yes

79 Motor KW KW VTA 2.2 kw/unit Yes

80 Water Pump Hazardous Area Safe Area Safe Area Yes

81 Mixing Tank Design / Condition Included Yes

82 Mixing Tank with Insulation Required Confirmed Yes

83 Required Quantities VTA 1 Yes

84 Tank Material VTA Stainless Steel Yes

But Vendor, please make sure
85 Capacity m3 4 m3 (VTA) 4(2X2) Yes
tank capacity enough.
86 Hazardous Area Safe Area Confirmed Yes
Total Unit Power(Electrical Load by Total loade shall be 139.8+19.4
87 kW VTA 159.2 Yes
included S/N 89,90 and 91) = 159.2 kW
Chiller/unit current 118 amp,
88 Compressor KW kW VTA 133.8 Yes Then 118 amp= 69.9kw (69.9 x
2 = 139.80 kW)
At 100% = 1.5 x 4 fan = 6 kW
89 Condenser Fan Motor KW kW VTA 6 Yes because 1 fan =1.5 kW (1 Unit =
2 Fans ).
 Sheet No. : 4 of 6
PROJECT NO.: P11P3351
TECHNICAL BID EVALUATION FOR
TREL Doc. No. :
9-13-317
CHILLER UNIT [R-1704]
Date:30-05-2019 Rev. No.: 0A

Design requirement/ CARRIER

S/N Evaluation Criteria
Specification
Offered Specification Accpt. ? Remarks
At runnig 100% = 15 +( 2.2x2)
90 Motor of Water Pump KW kW VTA 19.4 Yes
=19.4 kW,
91 Spring Isolator (Anti vibration damper) VTA Confirmed Yes

92 Chiller Plant Management System(CPMS) Not Applicable N/A Yes

93 Painting Referece to SPEC NO. 9-16-206 Confirmed Yes

94 Noise level dBA < 85 Confirmed Yes

95 Tests

96 HYDRO TEST Required Confirmed Yes

97 PNEUMATIC TEST Required if any Confirmed Yes

PERFORMANCE TEST OF COMPLETE SYSTEM AT
98 Required Confirmed Yes
SITE
99 DISMANTLE & INSPECTION AFTER TEST Not applicable at site Confirmed Yes

100 VISUAL INSPECTION Required Confirmed Yes

101 DIMENSIONAL INSPECTION Required Confirmed Yes

102 NDT Required Confirmed Yes

103 VIBRATION MESUREMENT For Rotating equipment only Confirmed Yes

104 NOISE LEVEL TEST AT SITE Required Confirmed Yes

105 Documents/ Drawings

106 Technical Specification for All Equipments Required Confirmed Yes

107 General Arrangement Dwg. Required Confirmed Yes

108 Dimension Outline Dwg Required Confirmed Yes

109 Overall Layout Drawings Required Confirmed Yes

Sectional Drawings Including Parts Lists for
110 Required Confirmed Yes
Main and Auxiliary Equipments
111 Foundation Arrangement Drawings Required Confirmed Yes

112 Installation Dwg. Required Confirmed Yes

113 Process Flow Diagrams Required Confirmed Yes

114 Utility Flow Diagrams Required Confirmed Yes

Vendor provide Chiller Water
115 Piping & Instrument Diagrams Required Confirmed Yes
Schemetic Diraram
116 Schematic Wiring Diagrams Required Confirmed Yes

117 Logic Diagrams Required Confirmed Yes

To consider as Alam , Temp ,
118 Interface Diagrams Required Confirmed Yes Pressure ,Flow. If any change
to be discussed.
119 Details / Terminal Boxes Required Confirmed Yes

120 Calculations sheet Required if any Confirmed Yes

121 Loading/weight Data Required Confirmed Yes

122 Equipment Characteristic Performance Curve Required Confirmed Yes

Spare Part List for Construction &
123 Required Confirmed Yes
Commissioning
Spare Part List for Two(2) Years
124 Required Confirmed Yes
Operation(Optional)
Installation / Operation and Maintenance
125 Required Confirmed Yes
Manual
126 Factory Test / Inspection Report Required Confirmed Yes
Such as Pipe, Valve, Etc shall be
127 Mill Test Certificate Vendor To propose Confirmed Yes
provided as well.
128 Noise Certificate/Report Required Confirmed Yes

129 Equipment List Required Confirmed Yes

130 Lubricating List Vendor To propose Confirmed Yes

No. of criteria that do not meet design
0
requirement/specification.