Bland
Bland
, 2015.
Bloomsbury Guidebooks for Language Teachers. Bloomsbury Guidebooks for Language Teachers. Bloomsbury Collections.
Web. 19 Mar. 2024. <http://dx.doi.org/10.5040/9781474257145>.
Copyright © Janice Bland. All rights reserved. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without prior permission in
writing from the publishers.
10
Oral Storytelling in the
Primary English Classroom
Janice Bland
Introduction
This chapter is about oral storytelling in the language classroom. As we shall
see, sharing stories is central to humankind. Stories, or narratives, help us learn
from experience and to Currie ‘it does not seem at all exaggerated to view
humans as narrative animals, as homo fabulans – the tellers and interpreters
of narrative’ (2011: 6). Stories allow us to use our imagination to possibly
engender new options and hopefully act with foresight, ‘to explore our own
mind and the minds of others, as a sort of dress rehearsal for the future’ (Cron
2012: 9). Thus this chapter will touch upon issues that have a wide relevance
for education. Authors, unsurprisingly, have also observed the apparent human
predisposition for storying: ‘stories appear to be there because stories are a
pervasive and perpetual human characteristic, like language, like play’ (Byatt
2004) and Le Guin writes: ‘For the story – from Rumpelstiltskin to War and
Peace – is one of the basic tools invented by the mind of man, for the purpose
of gaining understanding. There have been great societies that did not use the
wheel, but there have been no societies that did not tell stories’ (1985: 31).
Of old, storytellers were our teachers, we learn from stories in complex ways
and we can pass learning on as teacher-storytellers: ‘There are lots of things
that are vital to being human. Things like food, culture, warmth. The things that
are most vital, and most easy to overlook, are stories. [. . .] People that think
stories aren’t important – aren’t as important as breathing, aren’t as important
as warmth, aren’t as important as life – are missing the point’ (Gaiman 2014).
184 TEACHING ENGLISH TO YOUNG LEARNERS
We know that children need rich high-quality language input, which well-told
stories can offer, for second language (L2) teaching to play to their strengths –
particularly their aural perception and their ability to learn implicitly. The other
side of the coin is that minimal exposure in an input-limited, formal instructional
setting, with the few contact hours taken up by explicit language-teaching
activities, will remove any advantages children have as young learners (see
research reported in García Mayo and García Lecumberri 2003). As Kieran Egan
(1986: 22) maintains on teaching in the primary school, ‘focus on what they
most obviously can do, and seem able to do best’ (emphasis in the original).
It is therefore disappointing that the advice of teacher educators deeply
involved in teaching observation and action-researchers with sometimes
decades of highly valuable experience with storytelling in language teaching
(recent publications Wright 2009, Ellis and Brewster 2014, Heathfield 2014) is
largely ignored according to Garton, Copland and Burns: ‘One very noticeable
absentee from the list of frequently used activities is storytelling. [. . .] This
is surprising given their [stories] importance in the young learner literature,
particularly in books which provide practical advice to teachers’ (2011: 12). It
must therefore be concluded that pre-service teacher education does not yet
sufficiently provide teachers with the tools to become teacher-storytellers.
sound enters deeply into human beings’ feel for existence, as processed by
the spoken word. For the way in which the word is experienced is always
momentous in psychic life. The centering action of sound (the field of sound
is not spread out before me but is all around me) affects man’s sense of the
cosmos. (2002: 71)
186 TEACHING ENGLISH TO YOUNG LEARNERS
Teachers should be aware of the ‘centering action of sound’ and support the
rapt attention that storytelling can induce. I have seen this many times in
my observations of teaching practice; it can be magical. In the young-learner
classroom, the cinema circle, or semicircle around the teacher, provides
comfortable whole-group togetherness without the paraphernalia of desks,
pencil cases and school bags to distract from a trance-like immersion in a
well-told story. Fifty English language teachers in Slovenia who taught children
aged from eight to nine years took part in a study on their use of storytelling,
and reported that narratives are ‘a good source of language and a springboard
for follow-up activities, as well as generating a relaxed and safe learning
environment. Having pupils seated on the floor, in the form of a semi-circle,
further contributes to the pleasant atmosphere in the classroom’ (Dagarin
Fojkar, Skela and Kovač 2013: 26).
Oral storytelling is flexible and can and should be moulded to the
particular audience. This is a different performance act from the sharing
of a picturebook, for in the case of picturebook storytelling the book itself
and the pictures (which have another kind of magical power) can arrest
and focus the children’s attention through their continuous and repeated
presence. Storytelling is also different from acting, for when acting the
children and teacher-in-role (see Chapter 12) feel the emotions of the
characters. However, when the teacher is storytelling ‘while we may
sometimes become a character and show their emotion, for the most part
we are aiming to pass an emotion out to our audience – to make them
feel it’ (Tisdall 2013: 37). This chapter will also be examining the role of the
teacher as oral storyteller – for it is the teacher who decides the form of
each retelling, shaping the story to the audience, encouraging a response
and perhaps introducing a new element without disturbing the template-like
building blocks of storytelling.
Children do have a pre-existing story template, as do we all, suggesting
once again that humans have evolved as homo fabulans, or indeed as a
‘storytelling animal’ (Gottschall 2012). The template includes ‘a logically linked
series of events, a structure that includes a beginning, a middle and an end,
characters who remain the center of attention throughout, and to whom the
story happens, and a resolution that offers some form of resolution or release’
(Crago 2011: 211, emphasis in the original). Booker Prize winner Antonia Byatt
(2004) writes of a ‘narrative grammar’ of our minds: ‘An all-important part
of our response to the world of the tales is our instinctive sense that they
have rules.’
Therefore Cameron has rightly criticized the texts in English as a Foreign
Language (EFL) coursebooks that are called ‘stories’ when they do not adhere
to the archetypal story template: ‘Most often they lack a plot; instead of
setting up a problem and working towards its resolution, the characters just
ORAL STORYTELLING IN THE PRIMARY ENGLISH CLASSROOM 187
move through a sequence of activities. Teachers should not assume that such
non-stories will capture children’s imagination in the same way that stories
can do’ (2001: 162). Non-stories do not play to the children’s strengths,
for children have a desire ‘to find and construct coherence and meaning’
(Cameron 2001: 159). In fact this is exactly what stories can offer according to
Gale and Sikes: ‘Narratives provide links, connections, coherence, meaning,
sense’ (2006).
While oracy, a term coined in recent decades, has been used almost
exclusively in educational settings to describe students’ oral language as
something to be developed or improved – like literacy or numeracy – orality
[. . .] is a much older and broader term referring to the overall use of spoken
language, especially in a culture. Oracy is a word used to name a skill;
orality is a mode. (Bomer 2010: 205–206)
Perhaps the most important aspect of orality has been termed as ‘methods
of remembering’ (Bomer 2010: 207). This is crucial for the storyteller as well
as the audience and is extremely relevant for language teaching. Patterned
language is also to be found in literary texts such as novels, picturebooks and
poems – however, patterning is the essence of oral storytelling. The following
categories can be identified:
the analysis of a passage from Little Red Riding Hood in this volume
(S. Kersten 2015: 140–142). A rich use of epithets is also formulaic,
for example wicked witch, little cottage and big bad wolf. Well-known
examples from written texts are the Cheshire Cat, the yellow-brick
road and the Wild Wood.
And her throat was parched and her lungs were panting in the hot air, and
she fell to her knees and clung with trembling fingers as the stones began
to roll under her again. [. . .] up and up, until every muscle hurt, until she had
no breath left in her lungs, until she thought she was going to die; and still
she went on. (Pullman 1995: 68–69)
Teacher-storytellers
For vivid multisensory storytelling, the words are not the only consideration
(Wright 2013); special clothing such as a story jacket, puppets, sound effects,
props or realia can be helpfully involved. However, the art of what I will call
creative teacher talk is undoubtedly the area that needs most attention.
The teacher-storyteller employs a varied paralanguage involving expressive
prosodic features (pitch, tempo, volume, rhythm – including dramatic
pauses), exuberant intonation, gasps and, where suitable, even sighs. Some
storytellers employ exaggerated gesture and facial expressions, while others
have a quieter style. This will also depend on the story and the age of the
young learners; the younger the child, the more the storytelling (and classroom
discourse generally) should resemble repetitive child-directed speech.
Storyteller Heathfield (2014: 14) advises making good use of direct speech,
‘so you can play with the characters’ voices and mannerisms’. As Thornbury
(2002: 20) indicates, ‘The average classroom L2 learner will experience nothing
like the quantity nor the quality of exposure that the L1 infant receives (. . .)
Moreover, the input that infants receive is tailored to their immediate needs –
it is interactive, and it is often highly repetitive and patterned – all qualities that
provide optimal conditions for learning.’
Inexperienced teachers lack a repertoire of ritualized language and have
some difficulty in using patterned language, similar to child-directed speech,
in an impromptu yet cunningly regulated way. Frequent storytelling will supply
this practice and also enrich the classroom discourse; therefore teachers should
avoid the expediency of reading aloud simplified stories. Simplified stories
do not normally offer sufficient language patterning with connectedness and
salience through phonological and semantic repetition (Bland 2013: 8). Good-
ORAL STORYTELLING IN THE PRIMARY ENGLISH CLASSROOM 191
stress, pitch, tempo, volume and rhythm. However, the story progress can be
adjusted, as long as the basic template is maintained. Where necessary the
teacher can elaborate, with a slower speech rate, different gestures, additional
contextual cues, comprehension checks, clarification requests, repetition and
paraphrase.
In summary, storytelling gives the teacher authorial power to suit the
story to the audience: ‘telling a story should be used more often in the
young learner classroom, as it offers a shared social experience and creates
a relaxed classroom atmosphere. Furthermore, it is easier to verify pupils’
understanding of a story while telling the story, and it is also easier to adapt
the language or speed of delivery’ (Dagarin Fojkar, Skela and Kovač 2013: 26).
The rewards are more confidence for the teacher and pleasurable extensive
listening for the children. Extensive listening is highlighted by Tomlinson (2015:
283) and Mason (2013), whose studies have produced impressive results: ‘The
finding that story-listening is as effective as or more effective than traditional
methods is encouraging. Stories are far more pleasant and engaging than
traditional instruction, and students can gain other aspects of language from
stories, as well as knowledge’ (2013: 28). Repetition, however, remains key.
Elley (1989: 174) explored the significant vocabulary gains children achieved
incidentally through listening to stories and found the frequency of repetition
to be a feature that predicted which words would be acquired. Therefore the
next section will consider the variety of different steps that are possible in oral
storytelling.
FIGURE 10.1 Scaffolding through story and drama (Read 2008: 7).
I have chosen as my exemplar the well-known tale Three Billy Goats Gruff.
Some of the steps described below include drama strategies, and these are
described in detail in Chapter 12 on drama with young learners (Bland 2015c),
also with reference to Three Billy Goats Gruff. There is a recorded storytelling
of Three Billy Goats Gruff made available by the Oxford-based Story Museum,
which can be accessed, together with a written version and a story map, at
http://www.storymuseum.org.uk/1001stories/detail/83/the-three-billy-goats-
gruff.html. A recorded version is very useful for teacher preparation. However,
as explained earlier, the first and second storytelling (Steps 4 and 5 below)
should be live, with eye contact and the ability to react to the audience. Any
version of the tale can be altered to suit the age and competence of the class,
except for the building blocks of oral composition, such as Once upon a time,
and in this story the refrains trip-trap, trip-trap, trip-trap across the bridge as
well as the troll’s question to each goat: Who’s that trip-trapping across my
bridge? Billy goats are male goats (a female is a nanny goat); the fearful troll
can, of course, be a female troll.
194 TEACHING ENGLISH TO YOUNG LEARNERS
Step 5. Retell the story: The teacher retells the story and the children
all join in the refrains. The children might act the swinging bridge: little
swings for Little Billy Goat Gruff, swinging more with Middle Billy Goat
Gruff and wider swings for Big Billy Goat Gruff.
Step 6. Think from within the story: The drama strategies conscience
alley and collective role play are explained and exemplified with Three
Billy Goats Gruff in Chapter 12 on drama (2015c: 234–235). These allow
the young learners to use their own ideas and language. This valuable
stage takes up time, because the children often need language support
to express their ideas in English.
Step 7. Explore issues: Three billy goats cross the bridge in the
story – three is a magical number in fairy tales. How many stories can
the children name that feature three sisters or brothers, three friends,
three actions . . .? The maxim: If at first you don’t succeed, try, try
again might be taught and discussed.
Conclusion
This chapter has illustrated the important role of oral storytelling on many
levels, for L2 acquisition, for participation in an activity that is prosocial,
deeply satisfying and probably vital to humans and for education in the
wider sense of developing connected thinking and empathy. Importantly,
stories train the imagination to mentally represent alternative visions for the
future, for the story ‘is not just some casual entertainment; it reflects a basic
and powerful form in which we make sense of the world and experience’
(Egan 1986: 2). Teachers are encouraged to develop their creative teacher
talk skills, by engaging in oral storytelling; for according to Showalter (2003:
79), ‘Teaching is itself a dramatic art and it takes place in a dramatic setting.’
Finally, learners deserve some relaxation and pleasure in the school setting,
which stories for children promise: ‘We fill our heads with improbable happy
endings, and are able to live – in daydreams – in a world in which they are not
only possible but inevitable’ (Byatt 2004).
Notes
1 Stories from around the world, with audio recordings, may be found on the
following websites: http://www.storymuseum.org.uk/stories/audio-stories/
and http://www.worldstories.org.uk.
196 TEACHING ENGLISH TO YOUNG LEARNERS
References
Bauman, Richard (2005), ‘Performance’, in David Herman; Manfred Jahn and
Marie-Laure Ryan (eds), Routledge Encyclopedia of Narrative Theory, Oxford:
Routledge, pp. 419–421.
Bland, Janice (2013), Children’s Literature and Learner Empowerment. Children
and Teenagers in English Language Education, London: Bloomsbury.
Bland, Janice (2015c), ‘Drama with young learners’, in Janice Bland (ed.),
Teaching English to Young Learners. Critical Issues in Language Teaching with
3–12 Year Olds, London: Bloomsbury Academic, pp. 219–238.
Bomer, Randy (2010), ‘Orality, literacy, and culture: Talk, text, and tools in
ideological contexts’, in Dominic Wyse, Richard Andrews and James Hoffman
(eds), The Routledge International Handbook of English, Language and
Literacy Teaching, London: Routledge, pp. 205–215.
Boyd, Brian (2009), On the Origin of Stories: Evolution, Cognition, and Fiction,
Harvard: Harvard University Press.
Byatt, Antonia (2004), ‘Happy ever after’, Guardian, 3 January 2004. <http://www.
theguardian.com/books/2004/jan/03/sciencefictionfantasyandhorror.fiction>
[accessed 25 October 2014].
Cameron, Lynne (2001), Teaching Languages to Young Learners, Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
Cameron, Lynne (2003), ‘Challenges for ELT from the expansion in teaching
children’, ELT Journal, 57/2: 105–112.
Chambers, Aidan (2011), Tell Me. The Reading Environment, Woodchester:
Thimble Press.
Crago, Hugo (2011), ‘Story’, in Philip Nel and Lissa Paul (eds), Keywords for
Children’s Literature, New York: New York University Press, pp. 207–213.
Cron, Lisa (2012), Wired for Story, Berkeley: Ten Speed Press.
Currie, Mark (2011), Postmodern Narrative Theory (2nd edn), London: Macmillan.
Dagarin Fojkar, Mateja; Skela, Janez and Kovač, Pija (2013), ‘A study of the use of
narratives in teaching English as a foreign language to young learners’, English
Language Teaching, 6/6: 21–28. http://www.ccsenet.org/journal/index.php/elt/
article/viewFile/27258/16551 [accessed 27 November 2014].
Egan, Kieran (1986), Teaching as Storytelling, Chicago: University of Chicago
Press.
Elley, Warwick (1989), ‘Vocabulary acquisition from listening to stories’, Reading
Research Quarterly, 24: 174–187.
Ellis, Gail and Brewster, Jean (2014), Tell It Again! The Storytelling Handbook
for Primary Teachers (3rd edn), London: British Council. <http://www.
teachingenglish.org.uk/article/tell-it-again-storytelling-handbook-primary-
english-language-teachers> [accessed 27 November 2014].
Enever, Janet (2015), ‘The advantages and disadvantages of English as a foreign
language with young learners’, in Janice Bland (ed.), Teaching English to Young
Learners. Critical Issues in Language Teaching with 3–12 Year Olds, London:
Bloomsbury Academic, pp. 13–29.
Gaiman, Neil (2014), <http://www.storymuseum.org.uk/about-us/testimonials/>
[accessed 26 November 2014].
ORAL STORYTELLING IN THE PRIMARY ENGLISH CLASSROOM 197
Gale, Ken and Sikes, Pat (2006) Narrative Approaches to Education Research.
<http://www.edu.plymouth.ac.uk/resined/narrative/narrativehome.htm>
[accessed 26 November 2014].
García Mayo, Maria and García Lecumberri, Maria Luisa (eds) (2003), Age and the
Acquisition of English as a Foreign Language, Clevedon: Multilingual Matters.
Garner, Lori Ann (2005), ‘Oral-formulaic theory’, in David Herman; Manfred Jahn
and Marie-Laure Ryan (eds), Routledge Encyclopedia of Narrative Theory,
Oxford: Routledge, pp. 410–411.
Garton, Susan; Copland, Fiona, and Burns, Anne (2011), Investigating Global
Practices in Teaching English to Young Learners. <http://iatefl.britishcouncil.
org/2012/sites/iatefl/files/session/documents/eltrp_report_-_garton.pdf>
[accessed 1 October 2014].
Gottschall, Jonathan (2012), The Storytelling Animal. How Stories Make Us
Human, New York: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt.
Heathfield, David (2014), Storytelling with Our Students: Techniques for Telling
Tales from around the World, Peaslake: Delta Publishing.
Hoey, Michael (2015), ‘Old approaches, new perspectives: The implications of a
corpus linguistic theory for learning the English language (and the Chinese
language, too)’, in Tania Pattison (ed.), IATEFL 2014 Harrogate Conference
Selections, Faversham: IATEFL, pp. 12–20.
Jim Henson Company (2005), The Storyteller, <http://www.goodreads.com/
quotes/283681-when-people-told-themselves-their-past-with-stories-explained-
their> [accessed 17 November 2014].
Johnstone, Richard (2009), ‘An early start: What are the key conditions for
generalized success?’ in Janet Enever; Jayne Moon and Uma Raman (eds),
Young Learner English Language Policy and Implementation: International
Perspectives, Reading: Garnet Education, pp. 31–41.
Kersten, Saskia (2015), ‘Language development in young learners: The role of
formulaic language’, in Janice Bland (ed.), Teaching English to Young Learners.
Critical Issues in Language Teaching with 3–12 Year Olds, London: Bloomsbury
Academic, pp. 129–145.
Krashen, Stephen (2004), The Power of Reading. Insights from the Research
(2nd edn), Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.
Krashen, Stephen (2013), ‘Free reading: Still a great idea’, in Janice Bland and
Christiane Lütge (eds), Children’s Literature in Second Language Education,
London: Bloomsbury Academic, pp. 15–24.
Le Guin, Ursula (1985), Language of the Night. Essays on Fantasy and Science
Fiction, New York: Berkley Books.
Mason, Beniko (2013), ‘Efficient use of literature in foreign language education
free reading and listening to stories’, in Janice Bland and Christiane Lütge
(eds), Children’s Literature in Second Language Education, London:
Bloomsbury Academic, pp. 25–32.
Mason, Beniko and Krashen, Stephen (2004), ‘Is form-focused vocabulary
instruction worth while?’, RELC Journal, 35/2: 179–185.
Morpurgo, Michael (2014), <http://www.storymuseum.org.uk/about-us/
testimonials/> [accessed 26 November 2014].
Mourão, Sandie (2013), ‘Picturebook: Object of discovery’, in Janice Bland and
Christiane Lütge (eds), Children’s Literature in Second Language Education,
London: Bloomsbury Academic, pp. 71–84.
198 TEACHING ENGLISH TO YOUNG LEARNERS