0 ratings0% found this document useful (0 votes) 87 views14 pagesPB Reading and Writing MTL 1
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content,
claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
PRACTICAL STRATEGIES
Using Picturebooks to Empower
and Inspire Readers and Writers in
the Upper Primary Classroom
Kelly Booker | Literacy and Numeracy Field Officer, ACT
ABSTRACT
The Australian Curriculum: English highlights the importance of wsingy multi-modal
texts in our classrooms to allow children to connect with and appreciate literature, Picture
books provide students with opportunitics to interpret and evaluate texts ant then to create
their own multi-modal texts, This link between reading and writing can be highlighted
through the use of mentor text and when children begin to read like writersand have choice
around what they read and write, it becomes a powerful motivator
Bull Anstey note that students are being asked to interpret lingnistic, visual, auditory,
spatial, and gestural semiotic ystems that are becoming increasingly papular in new forms
of text (2010). Trpesraphy, the design of typefaces and the way that text is laid out on a
ge, is alo a feature worth considering. Through the use of picture books, children are able
to critically engage in author's message and consider what it will mean for their own texts.
Picture books are popular in the early years, but often these picture books are put aside
once children reach years 4-6. This paper will provide practical examples of how diverse
‘and controversial pictre books can be used to engage and inspire both reading and writing,
in the middle years, through an example of what happened in an upper primary classroom.
The semiotic sotems, the crafting of text and typography are discussed as students become
enriched through the literature and then produce their own picture books.
What are picturebooks?
Picturebooks may be familiar to all of us but what is a picturebook? Picturebooks *...represent
a unique visual and literacy artform that engages young readers and older readers in. many
levels of learning and pleasure’ (Wolfenbarger & Sipe, 2007). There may be several spellings:
picture book, picture-book or picturebook. The emphasis on the spelling picturebook has
been a deliberate one, The joining of the words represents the union of the text and art
(Wolfenbarger & Sipe, 2007), as the story depends on the interaction of the written text and
the image where there has been aesthetic intention by both author and illustrator (Arizpe
& Styles, 2003), Readers respond to each clement of the book and can form new meaning
from the text or the image or both,
‘What makes pictutebooks so intriguing is that the text and the images rarcly tell the exact
same story (Wolfenbarger & Sipe, 2007), In many picturebooks the images complement
the text and follow a similar story, giving more detail to characters, settings or conflicts.
However, there are books such as Come nmay from the water, Shirley by John Buriningham
Practical
Strategies
\
racy Learning:
the Middle Years
Volume 20
Number2
June 2012Practical
Strategies
Literacy Learning:
the Middle Years
Volume 20
Number2
June 2012
where the images attempt to tell a contradictory story from the text. On the left side of the
page the reader meets Shirley’s boring and bland parents and the right hand side of the page,
the reader secs Shirley’s imagination run wild. The reader must construct Shirley's dream as,
part of the story (Goldstone, 2002).
Nikolajeva & Scott (2001) suggest that there are five ways that text and images interact
there is no text attached to th
within picturebooks: 1. symmetry ~ the words and pictures are equal; 2. complementary
~ each element provides information; 3. enhancement ~ each extends the meaning of the
other; 4. counterpoint ~ the text and image tell a different story; and 5, contradiction ~ the
‘words and pictures assert the opposite of each other. This notion of how the text and images
‘work together or against each other can be useful to teachers who are engaging children in
picrurcbooks and wish to extend, challenge or focus their thinking.
Postmodern picturebooks
Postmodern picturebooks are books by authors and illustrators 4
‘who deliberately. work
against a linear story-telling pattern’ (Wollenbarger & Sipe, 2007, p. 275). Traditionally,
postmodernism is characterised by ‘the mocking of traditional art forms’ and today, many
authors and illustrators are experimenting with ways of mocking traditional picturebook
designs and characteristics (Swaggerty, 2009, p. 24).Goldstone (2002)
characteristics of these books that distinguish them from more traditional books:
nonlinearity, self referential, a sarcastic or mocking tone and an anti-authoritarian stance.
‘These characteristics will not all be present in any one book.
Nonlinearity is used where the author doesn’t follow the traditional sequential structure
entifies four
of a story and parts may be mixed up or absent (Swaggerty, 2009) as the reader moves
forward and backward through the text. The text also may have muhtple narratives present,
allowing for multiple genres or multiple characters telling differing narratives. Some authors
‘may include more information in the borders of the pages such as the Tales ofthe Dead series
by Stewart Ross and Richard Bonson. One Tiny Turtle by Nicola Davies and Jane Chapman
isa powerfull example of how a text can use two different social purposes for writing to tell
the same story. It challenges readers as they turn @ new page, as they are often tom between
which piece of text to read first. This picturebook tells the narrative of a Loggerhead turtle’s
lifecycle whilst also including facts written in an informative, explanatory style
Self-referential refers to the way the text and images depict the book itself being created.
Pantaleo (2004) notes that many of these books use devices that accentuate the fictional
state of the book. Illustrations often fall off the page, jump out at the reader and reveal the
fictional reality of the story (Swaggerty, 2009). Characters challenge the author's story and.
set out to create their own throughout the book. David Wiesner is well-known for creating,
selfreferential texts. In The Three Pigs, Wiesner sets out to re-create another version of The
Three Little Pigs, however, the pigs jump out ofthe story, fee to create their own adventure,
In Artand Max; Wiest
vwislom with an inexperienced artist, Max. Max, after convincing Art to help him, is trying,
to find inspiration for what to paint and Art suggests, Well... you could paint me.” Max gocs
about literally painting Art and as he tries to shake the paint off, Art loses his original colour
and later in the book becomes an outlined shape. The characters here are creating their own
story that seems to take a new turn on each page.
The mocking or sarcastic tone Goldstone (2002) refers to is playful not negative.
Fractured fairy tales are an obvious example ofthese texts and set out to challenge children’s
er sets out to tell the story of an accomplished artist, Art, sharing his
perspectives and allows the stories and characters to be questioned, ‘not merely followed in
a linear pattern’ (Wolfenbarger & Sipe, 2007, p. 276). The possibility for teachers to pursuethe interrelationships between the linear forms and the postmodern forms are vast. Jims and
‘the Beanstalk by Raymond Briggs follows the pattern of the linear story and the same giant
‘who stars in the linear story starts as the giant again, only now he is an old man with very
modem problems. Snow White in New York by Fiona French isan example of how an author
playfully sets out to tell the modernised story of Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs. In this
story, Snow White's stepmother likes to see herself in the New York Mirror newspaper and
demands her bodyguards take Snow White into the dark streets (© get rid of her. Snow
‘White finds seven jazz-men in a club where they ask her to sing with them, Before long,
Snow White’s stepmother finds out and she secretly drops a poisoned cherry into Snow
White's cocktail :xamples of these picturebooks and the connections with
here are mé
the original versions are very clearly made by the authors and illustrators so that the chil
can identify and connect with the characters. Intertextuality is popular with fairy tales, where
the story being told has been influenced by two or more Familiar texts. In Whar Really
Happened to Humpty? by Jeanie Franz Ransom and Stephen Axelsen, Humpty’s brother Joe
Dumpty doesn’t think Humpty Dyumpty’s fall was an accid
‘out the real story, seeking information from many nursery thyme and fairy tale characters,
including Little Miss Mutfet, Chicken Little and ‘Phe ‘Three Little Pigs.
The anti-authoritarian text refers tothe reader, authorand text notbeingasstraightforward.
as the reader expects. Goldstone (2002) suggests that the reader ‘enriches and supports the
storyline by infusing personal emotions and experiences but also actively creates parts of the
narrative” (p. 366). Often, the text isso brief that the reader is forced to allow the image to
tell the story. The reader is foreed to construct their own meaning, and is often left asking,
‘What does thisall mean?” (Swaggery, 2009). Tivestay by David Wi
t. He sets about trying to find
an almost wordless
sown connection
picture book that relies on the images to tell the story and the readk
to make sense of the story. Readers begin the story on “Tuesday evening, around eight?
and begin to see frogs on lily pads float into the sky. Readers follow the frogs’ adventures
throughout the night with Wiesner giving approximate times when certain things happen.
The story ends with police and detectives at a crime scene where the lly pads have been left
‘on the road. As the reader turns the final page, it reads ‘Next Tuesday, 7.58 pm” and there
is a new animal that begins to fl.
“These postmodern picturebooks allow deep, novel responses from children. They provide
playfll and insightful opportunities to develop literary understandings and comparisons with
other texts, Research by Sipe (2000) suggests that three impulses appear to guide children’s
responses to literature:
1. the hermeneutic impulse or the desire to know;
2. the personal impulse or the need to connect to one’s own lifes and
3. the aesthetic impulse where children can experience the story as if they were there.
Byallowing children to fulfil these impulses, teachers are encouraging children to respond
to and manipulate texts in imaginative ways so that the children become the ‘active agents
in the story rather than merely passive spectators of someone elses telling” (Wolfenbarger &
Sipe, 2007, p. 277),
Practical
Strategies
Literacy Learning;
the Middle Years
Volume 20
Number
June 2012Practical
Strategies
Literacy Learning:
the Middle Years
Volume 20
Number2
June 2012
Additional Postmodern Picturebooks to Use
Browne,A. (1998). Voices in the Park. Great Britain: Random House Children's Books.
Bland, N. (2009). The Wrong Book. Lindfield, Australia: Scholastic Press, Australia
Browne,A. (1970). Bear Hunt. London: Hamish Hamilton.
Forward. T. & Cohen, |. (2005). The Wolfs Story: What Really Happened to Litle Red Riding
Hood. London: Walker Books.
Macauley, D. (1991). Black and White. New York: Putnam.
Lehman, B. (2004). The Red Book. Boston, Massachusetts: Houghton Miffin Company.
Rutt, P-& Redlich,B. (2010). Tortoise vs Hare:The Rematch. London: Meadowside Books.
Scieszka, J. (1989). The True Story of The Three Lite Pgs. New York: Viking Kestral
Scieszka,J. (1991). The Frog Prince continued ... New York: Puffin,
‘Wate.M. (2007). Chester. Great Britain: Harper Collins Children’s Books.
‘Wild, M. & Spudvlas.A, (2006). Wooks in the Sitee. Pennsylvania, US: Front Street
Why use picturebooks? The Link to Curriculum
Literature has always been an important aspect of teaching, and recently there has been
fan increased focus and attention to how picture books are used in the classroom. First,
the NSW Quality Teaching Model (QTM) (2003) introduced the importance of picture
books by including Narrative as an element in Dimension 3, Significance. The QTM (2003)
believes that the
Use of narrative is high when stories are written, told, read, viewed or listened to help illustrare
cr bring to life the knowledge that students are addressing in the classroom, Narratives may
include personal stories, bibliographies, historical recounts, case studies, literary and cultural
tests and performances (p, 50).
However, the QTM (2003) does suggest that the significance of the narrative needs to
be high to be effective:
Narrative docs not inerease significance if the stories used are unconnected to the substance
‘of the lesson or unproductive in terms of student learning. Narrative may be high if there is
‘only one narrative present in the lesson as Jong as that narrative enhances the significance of
the substance of the lesson, Lessons may employ narrative as content (e.g. when students are
reading or listening to stories) or a8 a process (e
(pp. 50/51)
When students are writing oF telling stories).
The introduction of the Australian Curriculum: English brought literature to the
forefront of our thinking again with the explicit links to text in the Literature Strand, The
Australian Curriculum: English includes the following three sub-strands: Literature and
context, responding to literature, examining literature, creating literature,
‘Texts provide the means for communication, They can be writen, spoken or multimodal,
and in print or digital online forms. Multimodal texts combine language with other means
‘of communication such as visual images, souneltraek or spoken word, a in film or computer
presentation media. Texts provide important opportunites for learning about aspects of human
‘experience and about aesthetic vale, Many of the tasks that students undertake in and out
‘0f schoo! involve understanding and producing, imaginative, informative and persuasive texts,
media texts, everylay texts ancl workplace texts,
"The term ‘iterator’ refers ro past and present texts across range of cultural contexts that arevalued for their form and style and are recognised as having enduring or artistic value, While the
nature of what constitutes literary texts is dynamie and evolving, they are seen as having personal,
social, cultural and aesthetic value and potential for enriching stuclents? scope of experience,
Literature includes a broad range of forms such as novels, poetzy, short stories and plays; fition
for young adules and children, mukimodal tests such as film, and a variety of non-fiction. Literary
texts also include excerpts from longer texts. This enables a range ofiterary texts to be included
within any’one yea level for close study or comparative purposes,
English educators use many ways of categorising texts. The destriptions of texts used in the
Australian Curriculum: English are based on practical ag well as conceptual considerations, The
specific designation ofa strand labelled ‘literature’ is aimed ar encouraging teachers working at
all year levels not only to use texts conventionally understood as ‘literary’, but also to engage
students in examining, evaluating and discussing tests in increasingly sophisticated and informed.
“literary* ways. (hutp:/ Avwwaustraliancurriculum eddu.au/Englsh/Content-structure)
Putting theory into practice
At the beginaing of Term 3, 2011 I took over a Year 5 class which had experienced a very
disruptive start to the year including a series of relief and short term contract teachers. I was
‘excited by this challenge and was really looking forward to getting. to know these students
and gaining their trust.
After observing the Year 5 class for the first couple of days, I noticed that they were
disengaged and disconnected from their learning, particularly literacy learning, Most students,
chose a different book for silent reading each day and due to the teaching disruptions that
had happened previously, guided reading was not taking place regularly. T realised quickly
that I was going to need to motivate these students and get them to feel like learning was
worthwhile, Layne (2009) suggests that a complete, successful reader ne
is to develop the
five components of reading: first skill then interest, attitude, motivation and engagement.
There were several strategies 1 used, in sequential order, to motivate, engage and empower
this group of students,
Strategies
1. Engaging students through reading aloud
began to introduce the students to Cirele
ne strategies (Mosely, 2012) and as part of this
routine, [read a picture book to the class each morning, Fox (2001) suggests that we should
read aloud to children for as long.as they'll let us, even when they can read themselves. During,
read-alouds, children are able to experience a text that may be inaccessible or challenging.
to read independently. This experience aids comprehension, vocabulary development and
enjoyment (Miller, 2009). The class immediately became engaged during this time and were
‘eager to discuss the themes and their personal responses to the books. T didn't focus on a
particular theme, author or age appropriate text.
Reading aloud builds community, exposes children to books, authors, genres and
supports d
‘cloping readers. It also provides a model of a fluent reader and helps children to
develop and continue a love of reading, I wanted to ensure these students were read a variety
of picture books so that later in the year they would have experienced these texts ready t0
develop their own writing,
To benefit from reading aloud, children must listen and ‘build the world of the story in
their minds? (Calkins, 2001, p. 228). Calkins states, “Helping children think about texts i as
‘essential to the teaching of reading as it isto the whole of our lives, and the most powerful
‘way to teach this kind of thinking is through book talks based on read aloud books’ (p. 226).
“This time also allowed for vocabulary development as we discussed particular words the
Practical
Strategies
Literacy Learning:
the Middle Years
Volume 20
Number2
June 2012Practical
Strategies
Literacy Learning:
the Middle Years
Volume 20
Number2
June 2012
author had used and how effective they were. The students were not aware yet, but this was,
also a lead into their writing
“The most powerfll connection T witnessed during reading aloud and in discussion times
was that the students were connecting with a particular author or authors and read more
of their books later during silent reading, or in the library. Miller (2009) recommends that
teachers read more children’s books and take recommendations from our students on what
roduce children to authors that they may
we should read. Through reading aloud, we eai
never have known which will enable them to develop their own writing styles.
Some of the books I read are listed in the references,
2. Choice in the guided reading program
Guided reading was a routine that I set up from week one. Based on their running record
results from earlier in the year, I grouped the stuclents into groups of four. Atwell (2007)
strongly bel
wes that childeen must be given a choice when it comes to reading programs
in schools and I allowed each group to choose theit own books, On day three, I took the
‘whole class to the book room and allowed each group to browse the shelves. I pulled out
15 sets of texts and began to “sll” these books to the students. I read the blurb, I told them
about the themes of the books, humorous characters and why I enjoyed reading the book.
I would strongly encourage any teacher to read children’s books so that they can not only
sell the books to the students, but also so that you can have conversations with them as they
read the book.
“To do their best, they must be vitally interested in what they are reading” (Carbo, 2003),
Ultimately the children choose what they read, I began with the group of four choosing
the book, as the children learned to choose books based on interests. As adults, we choose
the books we want to read in numerous ways including recommendations, advertisements,
browsing a library or bookshop and knowledge of authors. Children must also learn these
‘ways of choosing books to read. Many children may turn to these methods naturally, others
may need guidance or support in using a variety of the above methods for choosing books
(Senior, 2008. p. 78). Mote reluctant readers may need high support early in this process
to find a book oF series of books that are entertaining and pleasurable to read. High interest
reading material may include bright and colourful magazines, The Guinness Book of World
Records, “choose your own adventure? books or humorous books such as Captain Underpants
and those written by Paul Jennings.
‘Once the children were familiar with choosing books, I allowed them to break out of
their groups and begin individual guided reading tasks. Many children began selling books
to their peers and I needed to create a waiting list for some of the books. It was 5
to sce not only the passion for reading present in the classroom but also the willingness and
$0 exci
engagement of the children during discussion times. These conversations that I had with
the students during guided reading time helped me to get to know each of the children and
their thought processes. It allowed me to identify reading and comprehension strategies
the student was using and which strategy would help them next. The deep thinking that
occurred about authorial details, such as, ‘Why did the author use the word ‘ginormous?
stead of the word ‘enormous’? or ‘Why did the author create this character? What is their
role in the storyline?” highlighted the students’ engagement and level of self: motivation.Picturebooks that were Read to the C!
Aniberg.A. & Ingman, B, (2007). Previousy. London: Walker Books.
Applegate, C. 8 Huxley, D. (2000). Rain Dance. Hunters Hill, NSW: Margaret Hamilton
Books.
Baker, J. (2000). The Hidden Forest. London: Walker Books.
Base, G. (2010). The Legend of the Golden Snail Victoria, Australia: Penguin Viking
Blabey.A. (2009). Stonley Paste. Victoria, Australia: Penguin Viking
Blabey.A, (2008). Sunday Chutney. Victoria, Australia: Penguin Viking
Danalis, J & Danas S. (2009). Schumann the Shoeman, Queensland, Australia: University
of Queensland Press.
French,}-&Whatley B. (201 |) Flood Linfield, Australia: Scholastic Australia,
French, J. & Whatley, B. (2010). Queen Victor's Underpants. Sydney. Australia: Harper
Collins Publishers.
Greder,A. (2007). The Island. Crows Nest,Australia:Allen & Unwin
Greder,A. (2010). The City. Crows Nest, Auseralia:Allen & Unwin
Marsden, |. & Ottley, M, (2009). Home and Away. Sydney, Australia: Lothian Children’s
Books.
Millard, G. & King, S. M. (2008). Applesauce and the Christmas Miracle. Sydney, Australia:
ABC Books
Riddle, T: (2008). ving the Magicion.Victoria, Australian: Puffin Books
Riddle, T. (2008). Nobody owns the moon Victoria, Australia: Penguin Viking
‘Tan, S. (2008). Erie. In Tales from outer suburbia. Crows Nest, Australia:Allen & Unwin,
‘Tan, S. (2000), The Rabbits. Sydney, Australia: Lothian Children’s Books.
‘Tan,S. (2001). The Red Tree. Sydney, Australia: Lothian Children’s Books.
Thompson, C. & Davis, S (2008). Fearless. Sydney. Australia: Harper Collins Publishers
Australia,
Thompson, C. (2006). Norman and Brendo. Victoria, Australia: Lothian Books.
Thompson, C. (1992). The Paperbag Prince. London: Red Fox.
Thompson, C. (2003). The Vion Mon, Sydney, Australia: Hachette Children's Books
Australia,
Tsuchiya, Y, (1988). Fitfal Elephants: A true story of animals, people and war: Boston:
Houghton Miffin Company.
Wild, M. & Brooks, R. (2009). Old Pig. Crows Nest, Australa:Allen & Unwin,
Wild, M. &Vivas, (2004). The Very Best of Friends, Lindfield, Australia: Scholastic Australia
Wild, M. & Yeo,A. (201 1). Vampyre. Newtown, Australia: Walker Books
3. Modelled enthusiasm for books and provided resources
1 quickly recognised that silent reading was a daily wasted activity as the children were
choosing different books cach day, the books currently in the room were filling apart and
looked uninviting and the children saw this time asa social opportunity. Research by Krashen
(2004) has conchided that no single literacy activity has a more positive effect on student
comprehension, vocabulary knowledge, spelling, writing ability and overall academic
achievement than free voluntary reading.
Each day [ allowed 20 minutes of silent reading time and the students knew that this was
Practical
Strategies
Literacy Learning
the Middle Years
Volume 20
Number2
June 2012Practical
Strategies
Literacy Learning:
the Middle Years
Volume 20
Number2
June 2012
their time to choose their own books to read. I talked constantly about ‘being in the reading
zone’ (Atwell, 2007) and forgetting about where you were and falling into the book. I
used the time T read the children picturebooks as an example of this and T encouraged the
children to experience ‘the zone? whilst [read to them. I gave the students permission to,
‘fall’ into the books and live the experiences of the characters. This became so effective that
1 offen heard sighs and grunts when I asked the children to put their books away after the
could take sheir book home to finish
20-minute period. [ had children asking me if the
reading them, and others asking if they could take their books to the library at lunchtime,
Ofcourse I agreed to all of these requests, not wanting to squash the engagement they had
finally discovered.
During this time T often read to model to the students, and as T began to get to know the
students T began to connect with them by talking with them about their interests, From this,
connection Twas able to recommend appropriately when the search was on fora new book. I
often asked other students in the class to tell another student about a book that they had just
finished reading. I didn’t restrict the students to chapter books. Many of the students chose
to read picture books during this time. Due to their reading. ability, they were often able to
read three or four picture books during this 20-minute period. Often they chose the book I
had read to them that morning or the week before, but many began to explore the range of
picture books that were available to them. Some of the more popular books were fractured,
fairy tales, Colin Thompson books, humorous poetry books, Shaun Tan books, wordless
picture books where they could ereate their own stories, and non-fiction books with titles
such as Predator Shomdown by Scholastic.
Selling books to the students worked for almost the whole class, except for Todd. One
afternoon I was having a conversation with Todd, about what he might like to choose to
read. He said to me, ‘I don’t read books. ‘The only book I like is Tomorrow When the War
Began? (John Marsden). I think he thought he'd get a reaction from me trying to persuade
him to read a book but I just said, ‘Oh Todd, I love that book! I have a copy at home so I'll
bring it in tomorrow for you to read.’ That afternoon I raced home to find my copy of the
book. It was well worn and didn’t look appealing at all. T was convinced that I was going to
change Todd’s perspective on reading, so I went and bought another copy that afternoon.
Th
few months ca
copy had the cover of the movie on the front of the book, which had been released a
cr. As I handed it to Todd the next morning I'll never forget the look of
surprise on his face, I’m not sure if he was surprised that I had remembered or that I had
handed him his favourite book, a brand new copy. From that moment on, ‘Todd read this,
book during guided reading and during silent reading. Interestingly, once he had finished.
the book, his peers were selling him books that they had read and Todd began to read the
Bear Grylls non-fiction series,
As an avid reader, I own an amazing collection of picture books and children’s chapter
books. 1 was constantly buying new books and bringing them in to share with the class.
Layne (2009) suggests we set up a ‘Hot Reads’ table in the classroom to recommend books
and excite the children about new books. Each time I bought a new book, I would leave it
fon the corner of my desk. For the first few wecks a few students came to ask me about the
new book and asked if they could read it.I continued this practice and cach week, a few more
students became interested. By the end of Term 3, it was a race to see who could get to my
desk first to read the new book I had bought, It was at this moment that I knew I had the
students engaged in reading.Connecting reading to writing
The next step for me was to try to anchor this enthusiasm for reading and transfer it to the
children’s writing, I wanted to link the texts they were reading and I was reading to them,
to their writing. Routman (2005) believes that teachers must connect reading and writing,
through literature by noticing what authors do, including student authors and how they use
words to get the intended message across.
Ifyou wane to be a writer, you must do nwo things above all others: read a Jot and write
alot (King, 2000, p. 164). I began to talk with the children about real authors, I showed
them Steven Herrick’s website and we listened and laughed along with him reading his
poetry online, We talked about Roald Dahl and how he kept a notebook to collect all of his
ideas in, and how one day when he was sitting on a bus he wrote in this notebook, ‘Write a
story about a friendly giant’ and years later, this became the BEG. Iwas trying to demystify
the writing, process and what it means to be an author. I always addressed the children as
authors and began to clue them in to finding great ideas for writing,
4 Every student isan author
Our job as teachers is not to teach writing but to teach authors (Frank, 1995). Every time a
student wrote in the classroom it was to ‘Write with the door closed, rewrite with the door
open’ (King, 2000, p. 56). The students began to look closely at the books that we had
read and they began to use the picturebooks as ‘mentor’ texts. That is, they asked questions,
found answers, looked closely at how the authors used descriptive language to convey a
ckly, the ehildeen had
message and began to link this to their own style of writing, Very qu
an idea for their pieturebooks and they were excited to write.
I began to take the students through the writing process that authors use to eventually
present their work to an audience, Frank (2002) suggests ten stages in the writing process:
‘The Writing Process ~ A 10 stage plan that works (Frank, 1995, pp. 96-103)
Romance Stages
1. The Motivation
“They always say they can’t think of anything to write? (Frank, 1995, p. 65), The motivation
stage is about the engagement or the sparks that make us want to write. It requires the
teacher to provide connections to experiences as our experiences are the catalysts that ignite
expression (Frank, 1995). Itis very difficult for us as adults to be given a blank pa
expected to write straight away without any input. Writing isn’t taught by saying, ‘Write
and then assessing what they already know how to do, It is taught by offering challenging,
directions, presenting patterns, and providing endless examples that open doors to original
exp
memories, experiences and discussions to help children form their ideas for writing,
and to be
sion (Frank, 1995). Within this stage teachers need to provide literature, questions,
2. Collecting Impressions
‘This stage is fast, fun and spontancous. It is critical to generating content, preparing.
for use at a later stage. The purpose of collecting impressions is not a plan for writing but
to simply collect thoughts, words, phrases and ideas. Individual or class notebooks can be
a great way to store all of these ideas. This stage can be compared to collecting a ‘seed?
in writer’s notebook (Fletcher, 2003) and it is important that the children know that not
everything they write down in this stage needs to be included in a piece of writing
Practical
Strategies
Literacy Learning:
the Middle Years
Volume 20
Number2
June 2012Practical
Strategies
Literacy Learning:
the Middle Years
Volume 20
Number2
June 2012
Draft Stages
3. Organising
Authors take a close look at the impressions and begin to sce what fits together and visually
represent ideas for a piece of writing. There is no one right way to do this as it will depend
on the individual writer, their age and ability. Frank cautions us not to overdo this stage ~ we
don’t want children to spend so much time on designing their web of ideas, that when it
comes time to write they are finished with the idea.
4, The Rongh Draft
This stage involves letting the children write! It is not the appropriate stage to think
consciously about spelling, punctuation or structure. The aim is to get all of those ideas
down. In my own experience asa teacher, once Ihave given children permission to just focus
on writing, not spelling and punctuation, I have watched children develop their confidence
in writing and their engagement inerease. [always remind children that I want them to write
the words that they want in the story, even if they cannot spell it. I never want a child to
‘write the word ‘big’ instead of ‘enormous’ because they can spell it, This restricts the flow of
\yriting as children are focusing on the editing instead of the writing development.
Response-Revision Stages
Author's Review
is the ‘author's chance to get the writing out into the light and see how it looks and
how it sounds’ (Frank, 1995, p. 100). This review is intended strictly for the author and
allows the children to ask questions such as, ‘Does it make sense”, ‘Is this my intended.
message?” and ‘Does it develop the way I want it to?” Frank (1995) suggests that reading
aloud to yourself is the best way to do this.
6. Sharing for Response
Author's in this stage can share their writing with the teacher or a small group to gauge
reactions, questions and feedback. It is vital that teachers explicitly show children how to
respond to authors, Author's need to understand that they get the final say in what changes
or what remains the same in their writing piece.
7. Editing and Revising
After receiving feedback and reading the piece out Jond to an audience, itis time for the
author to: make any other necessary adjustments to their writing. This stage is still in the
author’s hands. This is not where the teacher goes ahead and marks the work, instead, the
writer has control over the adjustments and ensures the intent is correctly perceived,
8. The Mechanics Check
‘Now is the time to check the draft for spelling, grammar, punctuation and structural errors.
‘Teachers can certainly help in this stage, however, I would try to do as much as possible with
the author, Frank (1995) advises that we should throw the red pen away, and instead use
pencil or another way to avoid writing on the children’s work.Back-to-Romance Stages
9. Polishing
Itis time to complete a final copy that is, polishing alter all the hard work of all the prior
stages. This stage should bring the author back to the romance stages again. The hard work
is now over and the final version of the writing, can be enjoyed. It may also be a time for the
author to begin co think about who co or where they might present their writing, This may
have been decided on prior to writing, but even if t has, are there other ways of presenting:
that this individual author may like to engage in?
10, Presenting
A powerfill way to engage children in writing is to ensure there is an intended purpose
prior to writing, The writing should reflect the intended audience and should be motivation
for the writing, Why share? Sharing is communicating, It allows authors to bring their
writing out into the li ‘ously
t which brings them back to the purpose for writing, As pr
mentioned, this sharing of student work is sharing literature which may then spark some
more impressions. Most important of all, this builds sel
nnfidence and writer’s esteem.
Cantions
Frank (1995) also gives us some cautions about the writing process:
+ Don’t always go through all ten stages
+ Do themall, some of the time
+ Ifyou think the final product is the most important, think again ~ the PROCESS is
the most important thing
+ Don’t skip the romance but don’t overdo the romance either
1, Publishing for an audience
Over a period of six weeks, the children began to write their own picture book using the
ten stages of writing (Frank, 1995), The intended audience was the children’s preschool
buddies, They wanted to read their picture books to their buddies at the end of the year. To
help romance the children, I took out a great pile of picture books and gave the children time
to read, explore and connect these stories to their own experiences or interests. Surprisingly,
they came up with many impressions and great ideas for a children’s picturcbook very quickly.
‘As the children were progressing through the ten stages of writing (Frank, 1995), the
picturebooks T read to them had a new purpose. I began to read to them picturebooks that
highlighted the semiotic systems (Bull & Anstey, 2010) and typography (Pantaleo, 2012).
‘The semiotic systems
Bull & Anstey (2010) allow us to think deeply about the five semiotic systems and what they
mean for us in a world where we are asked to read an inereasingly number of multi-modal
texts, The five semiotic systems are:
1, Linguistic ~ the vocabulary, generic structure and grammar of oral and written
language
‘Visual - colour, vectors and viewpoint of still and moving images
Audio ~ volume, piteh and rhythm of music and sound effects
Gestural - the movement, speed and stillness of facial expression and body language
Spatial ~ the proximity, direction, position of layout and organ
space (Bull & Anstey, 2010, p. 2),
ation of objects in
Practical
Strategies
Literacy Learning;
the Middle Years
Volume 20
Number
June 2012
aiPractical
Strategies
Literacy Learning:
the Middle Years
Volume 20
Number2
June 2012
I began to make my own connections with these semiotic systems through picturebooks.
After hearing Bull and Anstey speak at the ALEA National Conference in 2011, T began
to relook at the notes that T had made about certain picturcbooks that gave exemplary
examples of these semiotic systems and began to show them to the children. We speata long,
time looking through Bob Graham’s How to Heal « Broken Wing. In his text Graham shows,
us how designing a pieture based around point of view can dramatically change the readers/
jewers thoughts about a character and an event, The way Graham has drawn a bird in front
of the building from the view of the bird helps the reader to feel sympathy for the bird and
connect with how he must be feeling (p. 4).
The children were challenged by thinking about these systems as they very quickly realised,
that they needed to have the intended message clear in their own minds before beginning,
to design the graphics on the page. To help with this process, the children designed frames
in their books where they could practise drawing the designs for the pages. They received
feedback from the teacher as well as from their peers.
‘Typography
After reading an article about typography by Pantaleo (2012) in Literacy Learning: the
Middle Years, | began to change my ideas about publishing. Typography can be defined as
‘the art or process of printing from type ... the arrangement, style, or general appearance of
matter printed from type” (Guralnik, cited in Pantaleo, 2012, p. 38). There were so many
picturcbooks that had already explored this area and I ensued the children were exposed and
understood the effeet typography had on a published book. One of the fist picturebooks
that sprang to mind as I was reading the article was Fox by Margaret Wild and Ron Brooks.
‘The text type that they use and the way they have positioned the text on the page adds to the
unsettledness of the characters relationships with each other. “Ihick, textured paint in shades
of brown, peachy beige, and bluish grey, detailed in black line and frequent scratchboard like
technique, sets off the rich, fi
and danger that his presence engenders in Magpie” (Scheps, 2001).
Pantaleo (2012) also reminds us of another example of typography:
y tone of Fox’s fur and allows readers to sense the excitement
Jon Scieszka (198) has provided insights into the integral role of typography in The Stinky Chese
Man and Other Fairly Senpid Tales(1992). For example, Scieszka (1998) explained how the Red
en's red font ‘visually aecentuate{s] her annoying voice’ (p. 201), anel that the decision of the
book's designer, Molly Leach, 10 use ‘a classic font (Bodoni)” for the entire book, including the
‘manipulation of the font in unusual ways (expanding, shrinking, melting") emphasized “the fact
that these were classe fairy tales cold in an unconventional way’ (p. 201). (p-43)
When we came to the publishing stage, the children were excited to think about and use
the appropriate forms of the semiotic systems and typography in their writing. Some of the
children accentuated the key or big words by writing them in larger font and some children
began to think about what the text on the page actually felt like.
hey used smooth, wavy
lines of text for calm and composed parts of the text and hand, sharp lines with jagged edge
fonts for the harsh and unforgiving parts of'the text. It was dizzying at times to sce just how
engaged and motivated these reluctant readers and writers were. The feeling of satisfaction
and pride was evident in the body language the children displayed when sharing their books
with their preschool buddies at the end of the year.
Conclusion
Most of these strategies are not new to teachers, however it is good to be reminded of just
how powerlul they can be fora group of reluctant, disengaged children, Through the use ofpicturebooks, including postmodern picturebooks, we can excite children about the reading
process, the writing process and how these two processes can be linked together to provide
meaningful, contextual literary experiences.
References
Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA). Australian Curriculum
\3.0. Retrieved from: hnup://wwwaustraliancurriculum.edu.au/English/Content-structare on
12/04/12.
Bull, G. & Anstey, M. (2010). Evolving Pedagogics: Reading and writing in a multimodal world,
Victoria, Australia: Curriculum Press
Arizpe,E, & Styles, M, (2003), Children vending pictures: Interpreting visual texts. London: Routledge /
Falmer.
Calkins, L. (2001). The art of teaching reading. New York, NY: Longman.
Carbo, M. (2008). Achieving with struggling readers. Principal, NAESP, December 2003.
Fox, M. (2001). Reading magic: How your child can learn to read before school and other read aloud
‘miracles, Sydney; Pan Macmillan Australia,
Fletcher, R. (2008). A writer’ nosebook: Unlocking the writer within you. Great Britain: Harper Collins,
rank, M. (2002). [f you ve sry to teach kids bow 10 write... You've gorta bave this book! Victoria,
‘Australia: Hawker Brownlow
Gallagher, K. (2009). Readicide: How schools arc killing reading and what you can do abour it, Portland,
Maines Stemhouse,
Goldstone, B. P. (2002), Whaz up with our books? Changing picture book codes and teaching
implications, The Reading Teacher, 58, 362-369.
Jennings, P. (2008). The Reading Bug... and bow so belp your sbild catch i, Vitoria, Australia; Penguin
Books,
Krashen, S. (2004). The Power of Reding: Insights from the rsearch. Santa arora, CA: Libraries
Unlimited.
Layne, S. L. (2009). Igniting # pasion for readings Succesful strategies for building lifelong reader
Portland, ME: Stenhouse Publishers,
Miller, (2009). The Book Whisperer: Awakening rhe inner reader in every child. San Feanciscos Jossey-
Bass
Mosely, J (2012). Quality Citcle time Website, Retrieved from: http: //wwwccircle-time.co.uk/site/
home on 28/04/12.
Nikolajeva, M. & Scout, C. (2001). Hom picturebaots work.
Pantaleo, S. (2004). Young children interpret the metaictive
Journal of Early Childhood Literney, 4, 211-233.
Pantaleo, S. (2012). Middle Years Students Thinking With and About Typography in Multimodal
“Texts, Literacy Learnings the Midale Years, 20(1), 37 ~ 50.
Rourman, R (2008). Writing esensiale Raising expectasions and results while sioplifiing tenching.
Portsmouth, NH; Heineman
ew York: Garland.
Anthony Browne's Voices in the Park
‘Scheps, 8. (2001), From school library journal (review. Cahners Business Information, Ine. Retreived
from: hutp://wwwamazon.com/Fox-Maegaret-Wild /dp/1929132166 on 23/04/12.
Sipe, L. R. (2000). ‘The construction of literary understanding by frst and second graders in oral
response to picturebooks. In Handbvol of rearch in teaching literacy shrough the visual and
communicative arts, Malwa, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
‘State of NSW, Department of Education and Training Professional Support and Curriculum Directorate
(2008). A classroom practice guide in Quality Teaching in NSW Public Schools. Retrieved from:
htp:/ Awww neweastle.edu.auy/Resources/Schools /Education /Pedagogy/2006/Summaryor
Quality JanPoona pdf on 12/04/12,
‘Swaggerty, E, A, (2009) Using postmodern picture books in the classroom. In Children’s literavure in
he renting pregramme: An invieavion ro read. The International Reading Association,
‘Woltenbarger, ©. D. & Sipe, L. R. (2007). A unique visual and literary art foem: Recent reseach on
picturebooks. Review of Research: Language Arts, 84(3), 273-280).
Practical
Strategies
Literacy Learning:
the Middle Years
Volume 20
Number2
June 2012Practical
Strategies
Literacy Learning
the Middle Years
Veene 20
Nmter?
June 2012
Children’s literature cited
Burningham, J. (2000). Come Asnay frm rhe Ware, Shirley. London: Red Fox
Brigas, R. (1970). Jim and the Beanstalk. Canada: The Patnam & Grosset Group
Roald Dahl Website nap://wowwteachers. /vdeo /499
Davies, N. & Chapman, J. (2001). One Tiny Turtle, Massachusetts, USA: Candlewick Pres
French, (1989). Snow White in New Tork. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press
Graham, B. (2008). How 10 Heal a Broken Wing. London: Walker Books
Gel, B. (2010). Mision: Survinal~ Tracks ofthe Tiger. Grea Britain: Red Fox
Steven Herrick Website hnep:/ /wwstevenhertick.com.an/
Marsden, J. (2006). Tomarrow, When se Wir Began. USA: Scholasie Te
Martin, L. (2011). Predator Showdown: 30 Unbclcoably Aieseme Predator vs Predator Face-Ofpst New
York, NY: Scholastic
Ransom, J. F. (2008). What Really Happened so Humpiy? (From te files ofa ny-boiled detective).
‘Watertown, MA: Charesbride
Ross, §. (2006). Tiles of se Dead. Doing Kindersley Children: Great Britain
Scieszka, J. 8 Smith, L. (1992). Te Stinky Cheese Man anud Other Fairly Stupid Tales, New York
Viking
Wiesnes, D. (2001). The Tree Pins New Yotk, NY: Clarion Books.
Wiesnes, D. (1991). Tueway. New York, NY: Chrion Books.
Wild, M. & Brooks, R (2000). Fax: Crows Nest, Australia: Allen & Unwin
Wiesner, D. (2010). Art & Mas. New York: Clarion Books.
Kelly Booker is currently Field Officer at Macgregor Primary School in the ACT. She has
completed a Masters in Education and is completing her PhD in the area of struggling readers
Kellys research incerests lie in all aspects of literacy, parent education and ICT. Kelly is co-editor
of the ALEA journal Literacy Learning: the Middle Years