Orthodontists' Guide to Brodie Bite
Orthodontists' Guide to Brodie Bite
                                                                    Seminars in Orthodontics
                                                                                   journal homepage:
A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T
Keywords:                                                   This narrative review describes the different diagnostic, prognostic, management aspects and complications of the
Brodie bite                                                 Brodie Bite. A current literature review was completed to identify relevant case reports, case series, and reviews
Three-dimensional approach                                  about the Brodie Bite. Brodie Bite cases, fortunately, are not frequent. A checklist for this malocclusion is pre-
TADS
                                                            sented. Additionally, a description of the advantages of an early diagnosis will be discussed to avoid its progres-
Fixed and functional appliances
Disocclusion
                                                            sion to a more complex clinical scenario. The importance of solving the Brodie Bite before correcting any other
                                                            simultaneous malocclusion problem is stressed. Emphasis is given on a three-dimensional diagnosis and planning.
                                                            Different management mechanics are presented - ranging from TADS to fixed and functional appliances. Alterna-
                                                            tive disocclusion methods are also discussed. It is noted that some cases benefit from a combined surgical ortho-
                                                            dontic correction. Finally, periodontal issues and difficulties are addressed.
 * Corresponding author at: Division of Orthodontics, Department of Dentistry, University of Alberta, College of Health Sciences. Faculty of Medicine and Dentistry. 5-
528 Edmonton Clinic Health Academy. Edmonton, AB, Canada, T6G 1C2
   E-mail address: [email protected] (C. Flores-Mir).
https://doi.org/10.1053/j.sodo.2023.12.008
    Please cite this article as: C. Weinstein et al., A three-dimensional perspective on Brodie Bite’s diagnosis, planning, treatment alternatives, and
    complications, Seminars in Orthodontics (2023), https://doi.org/10.1053/j.sodo.2023.12.008
JID: YSODO
                                                       ARTICLE IN PRESS                                                            [m5GeS;January 9, 2024;3:04]
                                                                                2
JID: YSODO
                                                        ARTICLE IN PRESS                                                               [m5GeS;January 9, 2024;3:04]
Fig. 2. Single premolar scissor bite identified during the eruption of permanent          Fig. 3. Single premolar Brodie bite identified in full permanent dentition.
teeth.
as the main cause of the problem. Today we know that by clinical obser-               buccal tipping in the maxillary arch and lingual tipping in the mandibu-
vation of the gingival margins. We can determine how much each arch                   lar arch, chances of extrusion are greater.Therefore, the severity of the
is affected and ultimately dictate the treatment mechanics for each case.             Brodie Bite will increase.
Fig. 5 shows a scenario, in which each arch must be evaluated separately                  The Brodie Bite can also appear after rapid palatal expansion. Fre-
with enough mouth opening to visualize the upper and lower teeth                      quently narrow deficient maxilla has buccally tipped upper first perma-
completely. Three different vertical scenarios can occur. The first sce-               nent molars and lingualized lower first and second molars, especially in
nario is the upper arch extrusion with relative normal levelling of the               the absence of clinical crossbites, as a dental compensation to the trans-
lower arch. A second scenario will present a relatively levelled upper                verse skeletal deficiency. When palatal expansion is done, an iatrogenic
arch with an extruded lower arch. Finally, both upper and lower arches                Brodie Bite can easily develop because of the mentioned abnormal tor-
can be vertically over-erupted.                                                       que in the molars. In these cases, compression mechanics need to be
                                                                                      applied to the upper posterior teeth and uprighting of lingualized lower
Transverse component                                                                  posterior teeth needs to be made.
                                                                                          Fig. 6 shows a bilateral Brodie Bite was developed after expansion,
    The maxillary arch width will determine the extent and speed at                   more severe on the right than on the left side. Aligners were used to
which the vertical problem develops. If the dentoalveolar bone is in a                decompensate the lower arch and correct buccal upper tipping.
more buccal position, occlusion has a lower chance of naturally restrain-             Anterior ramps, lingual to the incisors, were used to disoclude the
ing the vertical migration of the segment involved in the Brodie Bite.                molars. The buccal crossbite was corrected during the first stage of
The wider the maxilla to the mandible, the higher the chance of develop-              treatment in nine months. Fig. 7 shows a failed skeletal expansion is
ing a buccal crossbite with an important overlap percentage. The degree               shown. Only the right side expanded. A unilateral Brodie Bite devel-
of tooth buccal inclination is another aggravating factor. The greater the            oped consequently.
                                                                                  3
JID: YSODO
                                                           ARTICLE IN PRESS                                                                [m5GeS;January 9, 2024;3:04]
                                                                                      4
JID: YSODO
                                                         ARTICLE IN PRESS                                                                 [m5GeS;January 9, 2024;3:04]
    Fig. 9 shows a patient was diagnosed early with a skeletal Class II                Assessment and checklist
facial pattern with bilateral buccal crossbites. Clear aligner treatment
was chosen to correct the malocclusion. A symmetrical midline was                          With the purpose of doing a complete evaluation of the different
noted. After six months into treatment, the Brodie Bite was corrected.                 variations of Brodie Bites and affected segments, the use of a Brodie
The patient’s arch form and alignment were improved, even though the                   Bite Checklist is suggested in this article for extraoral, intraoral,
skeletal problem was left for a later surgical correction once growth was              functional, and radiographic characteristics. The aspects of the clini-
finished.                                                                               cal exam that can be affected in a unilateral Brodie Bite are listed in
    The microesthetic evaluation generally provides more information                   Table 1 & Fig. 11. As noted, the facial exam in many patients does
on this syndrome. Some anatomical factors such as dental midline evalu-                not suggest this malocclusion. This checklist covers the transverse
ation, leveling of the gingival margins, and buccal/lingual tipping will               and vertical planes of space during the intraoral exam. Dental mid-
help diagnose this malocclusion and determine which arch is more com-                  line relationships and inclinations must be recorded in the trans-
promised and the treatment strategy to be used. Identifying functional                 verse plane. Occlusal-gingival tooth positions must be observed
mandibular shifts also provides important diagnostic information in the                vertically. By looking at the gingival shape and contour, a
transverse plane since it influences facial asymmetry.5,11 A typical uni-
lateral Brodie Bite description will include canting of the occlusal plane
down on the affected side and a mandibular deviation to the opposite
side on closure resulting in a degree of dental midline shift.5 Fig. 10
shows a diagrammatic representation presents a normal scenario and
changes a unilateral Brodie Bite generates.
Fig. 8. A. patient presented with a right scissor bite B. Skeletal Class II with
mandibular asymmetry. C. A “False Brodie Bite” is evidenced when an antero-            Fig. 9. A. Patient was diagnosed early with a skeletal Class II facial pattern with
posterior correction is made by bringing the models into occlusion. D. A night-        bilateral buccal crossbites and symmetrical midlines. B. Clear aligner treatment
time splint was used during adolescence for retention purposes to avoid                was chosen to correct the malocclusion. C. The Brodie Bite was corrected in six
extrusion, dental compensations, canting of the occlusal plane and mandibular          months. Arch form and alignment improved. The skeletal correction was left for
shift, while the patient waits for a surgical correction.                              a later surgical procedure.
                                                                                   5
JID: YSODO
                                                                ARTICLE IN PRESS                                                                  [m5GeS;January 9, 2024;3:04]
  Chin Deviation
  Asymmetric Smile: Higher               Asymmetric Smile: Lower Commissure
    Commissure
Intraoral
Radiographic Analysis
  TMJ Images
  Normal condylar size                   Larger condyle in case of hyperplasia
  Reduced posterior joint space          Even joint spaces of forward condylar position
                                         Chewing difficulty
  Panoramic Film
  Wider interocclusal space              Narrower interocclusal space (extrusion)
                                                                                              Fig. 12. Patient with a left unilateral Brodie Bite. The extraoral picture presents
  Apices closer to mandibular            Apices distant from mandibular border
                                                                                              a slightly noticeable occlusal cant at the level of the upper canines, higher on the
    border
                                                                                              right side.
                                                                                          6
JID: YSODO
                                                          ARTICLE IN PRESS                                                                [m5GeS;January 9, 2024;3:04]
Fig. 13. A. Initial lateral right and left intraoral images. B. Gingival contours       Fig. 16. A. Occlusal views of treatment mechanics with TADS and occlusal
were traced to visualize their vertical migration on the Brodie bite side. Both         ramps on the non-affected side. B. Diagram (courtesy of Dr. Viviane Tinoco) rep-
upper and lower teeth were extruded, and therefore the gingival margins are at          resents a single central upper TAD used in the palate for transverse and vertical
a more occlusal level compared to the contralateral teeth.                              correction of the left upper molars. In the mandible, an interradicular TAD was
                                                                                        used with the same objective.
                                                                                        protrusion with buccal shelf TADs. Lower space was opened with coils
                                                                                        to restore a congenitally missing lower incisor. This was the third ortho-
                                                                                        dontic treatment for the patient, and a lower premolar had been previ-
                                                                                        ously removed. A decision was made to reopen the space with nitinol
                                                                                        coils as well. Figs. 16−20 show the finished case with a well-balanced
                                                                                        face, centered midlines, and a transverse and vertical correction of the
                                                                                        Brodie Bite. The patient was referred to the restorative dentist for lower
                                                                                        implant placement.
Fig. 15. A. Initial panoramic film taken routinely with upper and lower teeth
separated. B. Teeth and interocclusal space tracing shows teeth are extruded.
There is a smaller interocclusal space on the Brodie bite side.
lingually. The scissor bite was corrected with TADS and occlusal ramps
on the non-affected side. A single central upper TAD was used in the pal-
ate for transverse and vertical correction of the left upper molars. In the             Fig. 17. Lower teeth were controlled from incisor protrusion with buccal shelf
mandible, an interradicular TAD was used with the same objective. The                   TADs to achieve the complete solution of the case. Implants were treatment
Brodie Bite correction was accomplished in 6 months. To achieve the                     planned for reconstruction of the congenitally missing lower incisor and previ-
complete solution of the case, lower teeth were controlled from incisor                 ously extracted premolar.
                                                                                    7
JID: YSODO
                                                           ARTICLE IN PRESS                                                             [m5GeS;January 9, 2024;3:04]
                                                                                                         Fig. 18. The finished case shows Brodie bite correction, cen-
                                                                                                         tered midlines, leveled occlusal planes and spaces for future
                                                                                                         restorative work.
Management alternatives
Biomechanical considerations
                                                                                      8
JID: YSODO
                                                                 ARTICLE IN PRESS                                                                         [m5GeS;January 9, 2024;3:04]
Fig. 22. Andrew’s transverse analysis of element III. On the Brodie side, a torque correction of 2 mm. to the buccal of the lower molars was considered. Therefore, the
initial fossa-to-fossa measurement increases from 37.5 mm to 39.5 mm. A torque correction of 2 mm towards the palate was made in the upper arch. So, the initial mea-
surement from the palatal cusp to the palatal cusp decreases from 46 mm. to 44 mm. Hence, a difference of 44 - 39.5 = 4.5 mm. of maxillary transverse excess was
determined. (previously published in J Clin Orthod MS 23193 accepted for publication − reproduction authorized by J Clin Orthod editor).
Table 2
Summary of proposed Brodie Bite management alternatives depicted in the literature.
  King et al.         AJODO, April 2004       Case Report Permanent               A full-coverage maxillary    Midsymphyseal osteotomy      Full correction          Surgery was required
                                                                                    splint                       and mandibular distraction   achived.                 with the extra cost
                                                                                                                 osteogenesis.                                         and morbidity
                                                                                                                                                                       involving surgery.
  Yun et al.          AJODO, December         Case Report Permanent               Was achieved through         Fixed appliances with finger    Non-surgical conserva- Method for single
                        2007                                                       molar intrusion with the      spring using indirect          tive treatment with    tooth or two teeth.
                                                                                   spring.                       anchorage from a minis-        excellent occlusal     The cost of the tad
                                                                                                                 crew.                          results.               and fabrication of
                                                                                                                                                                       screw.
  Imada et al.        Journal of Cranioman-   Case Report Primary                 Upper fixed constriction    None                             Conservative early     None noted.
                        dibular Practice,                                           orthodontic appliance                                       approach. Allowing
                        April 2008                                                  reduced his upper dental                                    normalization of
                                                                                    arch width. A lingual                                       growth.
                                                                                    arch appliance with a
                                                                                    finger spring was placed
                                                                                    to expand his lower den-
                                                                                    tal arch laterally.
  Chugh et al.        AJODO, May, 2010        Case Report Permanent               A maxillary removable      0.40” expanded arch in round Non-surgical conserva- Required use of High-
                                                                                    plate.                     tubes in lower molar            tive approach        pull headgear and
                                                                                                               bands. Combined with                                 crosselastics.
                                                                                                               crossbite elastics. Using a
                                                                                                               high pull headgear as
                                                                                                               anchorage.
  Jung.               AJODO, April 2011.      Case Report Permanent               Posterior biteblock.       Upper molar intrusion against Non-surgical conserva- Facial profile convex
                                                                                                               upper buccal and palatal        tive option.         after treatment.
                                                                                                               tads. Lower molar upright-
                                                                                                               ing against vestibular inter-
                                                                                                               radicular tads.
  Park et al.         International Journal   Case Report Permanent               Series of aligners         Aligner allows disoclussion.    Conservative         Single molar correc-
                         of Orthodontics,                                                                                                      approach.            tion.
                         Summer 2011.
  Pinho               JCO, September 2011.    Case series   Primary in 3 cases,   Screw incorporated into      Posterior Bite Block           Conservative early     None noted.
                                                              permanent in one      posterior cemented bite                                     approach. Allowing
                                                              case.                 block expansion appli-                                      normalization of
                                                                                    ance, intraarch elastics                                    growth.
                                                                                    to cemented button,
                                                                                    crossbite elastics.
  Suda et al.         AJODO, January          Case Report Permanent dentition.    None. Throught orthog-       Posterior mandibular subapi-   Improved facial        Surgical Costs and
                        2012.                                                       nathic surgery bone seg-     cal osteotomy to correct       appearance.            morbidity.
                                                                                    ments were moved.            mandibular right premo-
                                                                                                                 lars and molars. That were
                                                                                                                 moved by using a lingual
(continued)
                                                                                            9
JID: YSODO
                                                                 ARTICLE IN PRESS                                                                              [m5GeS;January 9, 2024;3:04]
Table 2 (Continued)
(continued)
                                                                                             10
JID: YSODO
                                                                ARTICLE IN PRESS                                                                       [m5GeS;January 9, 2024;3:04]
Table 2 (Continued)
skeletal maturity.10 Myofunctional therapy and oral screens were used                               Fig. 23 shows a simple power arm extension was added to the first
in a reported case.20                                                                           molar to pull the premolar in the scissor bite palatally. Just 1.5 months
    Different orthodontic treatment methods are suggested for correcting                        was enough to correct the problem. Fig. 24 shows a minor raise in the
scissor bites. Among them: maxillary constriction plates, intermaxillary                        bite with occlusal bite turbos on the day of appliance placement. The
elastics, quad-helix, transpalatal arch, fixed bonded bi-helix appliances,                       Brodie Bite was corrected during the levelling and aligning process.
extractions, lip bumper, mandibular lingual holding arches, Frankel                                 Arch constriction in the upper arch is also possible when treating
functional (FR-2) appliances, distraction osteogenesis procedures,                              Brodie Bite patients.14 Intra-arch medium to heavy rubber bands,
orthognathic surgery. These treatments can improve masticatory func-                            changed daily, can be used to collapse two single teeth buccally dis-
tion, esthetics, occlusion, and overall periodontal condition.12                                placed in opposite quadrants in the upper arch, bringing them into align-
                                                                                                ment. This approach will likely work better for two upper second molars
Non-skeletally supported management alternatives                                                than multiple teeth or a posterior buccal segment.21
                                                                                                    Some published examples are briefly discussed here. A maxillary
    Appliances that work with a functional component, such as lip bum-                          constriction spring was incorporated into a posterior bite plate. After
per and Frankel 2, are a choice when a tongue or muscular imbalance is                          nine months of constriction. The lower arch was worked up to
identified. Functional mandibular appliances help reduce the transverse                          .018" × .025" stainless steel archwire with cross-elastics on the left side
discrepancy when the mandible is positioned forward.3 The Frankel 2                             for uprighting the first molar.22 An intra-arch elastomeric chain extend-
appliance has the advantage that it can be customized either for bilateral                      ing twice its length to correct a buccally displaced upper second molar
or unilateral treatments. Lip bumpers address the tongue versus the                             with the help of a transpalatal arch as anchorage has been published as
cheek functional equilibrium. In a growing patient, an orthopedic appli-                        a valid approach.23 Another reported alternative is a slow maxillary con-
ance can be used to advance the mandible, followed by fixed mechano-                             traction appliance followed by fixed appliance treatment. This strategy
therapy to finish the occlusion on the corrected skeletal bases.10                               was used in a child with a maxillary asymmetric dentition 10 mm wider
Treatment selection becomes a personal decision by the orthodontist,                            than normal for his age.24 Another option is a constricting spring.10 The
and each procedure has pros and cons.3,13,15 Some management strate-                            use of a hyrax expander in an open position to produce palatal constric-
gies might be considered non-invasive alternatives to surgical treatment;                       tion by narrowing the maxilla bilaterally has a higher risk of creating a
their limitations include excessive extrusive force requirements on the                         contralateral posterior crossbite on the non-affected side. To avoid this
anchor teeth and a need for patient compliance. To avoid these dental                           undesired effect, the lab prepares an appliance with an expansion screw
side effects in scissor bite correction, temporary anchorage devices                            which is narrowed gradually as treatment progresses. Special care to
(TADs) have begun to be used in recent years.13 When the Brodie Bite is                         strengthen the non-Brodie side anchorage is important. The anterior sec-
identified early when the eruption occurs, simple fixed appliance                                 tion can be included with the non-Brodie side, covering it with more
mechanics can be used for correction.                                                           acrylic than in the compromised side where the constriction is desired.14
                                                                                           11
JID: YSODO
                                                       ARTICLE IN PRESS                                                               [m5GeS;January 9, 2024;3:04]
    Different rubber band mechanics have been proposed for Brodie Bite                   Fig. 25 shows a diagram of the different biomechanical approaches
correction: including intermaxillary cross elastics, multibracket applian-           for the upper arch. In the first scenario, when the extrusion is pure, with-
ces, transpalatal arches and lingual arches with intramaxillary elastics.            out any inclinations, two TADs should be placed. One in a buccal posi-
These mechanics can generate extrusive forces on the second molars in                tion and the other one in a palatal position.13 Upon activation, the
both arches, possibly inducing an undesirable reduction in the overbite,             resultant intrusive force should pass through the center of resistance of
clockwise rotation of the mandible, and premature contacts. This situa-              the tooth. Elastic chains must be engaged from both buccal and palatal
tion is especially undesirable in high-angle cases.15,16 To avoid increas-           attachments to the TADS. To secure the elastic chains, a wire through
ing lower facial height, it is important to maintain the vertical height of          the contact point connecting two adjacent molars in buccal crossbites
teeth by using devices with a relatively intrusive effect.2 Rubber bands,            was placed with cured composite on the occlusal surfaces. In this way
especially cross intermaxillary elastics, can be used as a complementary             two teeth can be intruded with two TAD.15 The second scenario requires
mechanism for skeletal anchorage.5 Unfortunately, intermaxillary elas-               extrusion in addition to buccal tooth inclination. One TAD located in the
tics depend on excellent patient cooperation for a successful                        palate will probably be enough to add both a palatal and intrusive com-
treatment.15,16                                                                      ponent to achieve the correction. Finally, a third scenario is character-
                                                                                     ized by a molar in an extruded as well as a lingually inclined position. In
                                                                                     this case, mechanics for correction require two steps. First a TAD needs
Skeletally supported management alternatives                                         to be placed buccally to upright the tooth and position it in the center of
                                                                                     the bone. During a second stage a TAD needs to be placed in the palate
    Skeletal anchorage is an effective, non-compliant correction for Bro-            to proceed with bodily intrusion with a vertical vector along the center
die Bite, which can be obtained with minimum undesirable side                        of resistance.
effects.15,16 Currently, it is considered the gold standard in related treat-            Fig. 26 shows a diagram of the different biomechanical approaches
ment mechanics. Adequate selection of anatomical insertion sites, length             for the lower arch. Mechanics in the lower arch have less variability
of screws and physical characteristics need to be considered to avoid                since teeth involved in the Brodie Bite are always expected to be lin-
temporary anchorage device failure. As most Brodie Bites require a mix-              gually inclined. The difference is whether they are leveled to the occlu-
ture of vertical and transverse corrections, successful intrusive move-              sal plane or extruded. For pure lingual inclination correction, the head
ments of large segments must be considered. Applying adequate force                  of the TAD needs to be at the level of the occlusal plane so that the vector
when activating skeletal anchorage is a must.25                                      of movement produces verticalization of the tooth. Variations can be
                                                                                12
JID: YSODO
                                                     ARTICLE IN PRESS                                                                [m5GeS;January 9, 2024;3:04]
made in the length of the buccal-shelf screw. A longer TAD is suggested            position is beneficial since it can provide adequate space to upright the
so that the head of the screw is closer to the wire level or to approximate        entire buccal segment with one bone screw. Conversely, inter-radicular
FA point of the anatomical crown. Therefore, the intrusive vector is               TADs quickly interfere with the nearby teeth’ movement, and frequent
smaller. If teeth are lingually inclined and extruded, then the head of the        replacement is necessary.5 When indicated, the extra radicular mini-
TAD needs to be below the occlusal plane. For an activation vector to              screw can be placed with the head close to the occlusal plane and in a
have both a verticalizing and intrusive component TADS can be placed               buccal position relative to the center of rotation of the molar root. This
in an interradicular position.                                                     is advantageous for the inclination correction of the molar since a more
    There are biomechanical differences between using an interradicular            buccal and less intrusive force is generated compared with a TAD in an
compared to an extra radicular mandibular buccal shelf mini-screw in               interradicular position.26 The clinician can screw the buccal shelf TAD
the lower arch for Brodie Bite correction. There are more benefits favor-           deeper when a more intrusive force component is needed.
ing a mandibular buccal shelf bone screw compared with interradicular                  Figs. 27 and 28 shows a unilateral Brodie Bite on the left side. An
bone screw. The possibility of a prominent head that can retain elasto-            upper anterior bite plate was used as a disocclusion strategy to raise the
meric chains, which can efficiently upright a mandibular segment is an              bite. Mini-screws were placed for Brodie Bite correction. This was
advantage. If anatomy permits, an extra-alveolar TAD can be placed up              accomplished in 6 months. Fig. 29 shows TADs that were initially placed
to 10 mm to the buccal aspect of the lingually tipped molars. This                 too close to the affected teeth; therefore, they had to be repositioned.
                                                                              13
JID: YSODO
                                                         ARTICLE IN PRESS                                                                [m5GeS;January 9, 2024;3:04]
Figs. 30 and 31 show the rest of the treatment involved solving the den-                with intra-arch elastics to cemented buttons and crossbite elastics.28
tal Class II with infrazygomatic TADs and detailing and finishing proce-                 Fixed appliances and a lower lingual arch with anterior and posterior
dures. The total treatment time was 35 months.                                          palatal mini-screws were used to improve bilateral scissors bite. Upper
    The extraction of a single tooth in a scissor bite with replacement by              and lower anterior mini-screws were also used to address anterior deep
an adjacent tooth or by future implant placement is considered a viable                 bite.29 A strategy combining fixed appliances with upper premolar
treatment alternative.2 Fig. 32 presents this type of case with the Brodie              extractions and an Andressen activator was also reported.30 Finally,
Bite involving only one tooth. The tooth was severely lingualized, with a               fixed orthodontic appliances, TADS and crossbite elastics were used
significant degree of tooth mobility. It failed to upright with a TAD. A                 simultaneously.31
decision was made to extract it and replace it with a future implant.
    Additional management strategies have been published in the litera-                 Disocclusion strategy
ture underlying these principles. Fixed appliances with a finger spring
using indirect anchorage from a mini-screw.27 A screw was incorporated                      Mechanics for Brodie Bite cases are generally planned to address the
into a posterior cemented bite block expansion appliance in conjunction                 scissor bite during the first 7-8 months of treatment and continue the
                                                                                        case with the other required corrections. Sometimes an extreme vertical
                                                                                        overlap on the affected side makes it impossible to place orthodontic
                                                                                        Fig. 29. A. TADs were placed too close to the teeth, which limited the amount of
Fig. 28. Left side Brodie bite. Longitudinal cone-beam cuts on the teeth’ long          tooth movement. An upper bite plate was used to disoclude the bite. B. Both
axis to visualize compromised teeth’ position and bone support. (previously pub-        TADs had to be moved for further movement: buccally in the lower arch and pal-
lished in J Clin Orthod MS 23193 accepted for publication − reproduction                atally in the upper arch. (previously published in J Clin Orthod MS 23193
authorized by J Clin Orthod editor).                                                    accepted for publication − reproduction authorized by J Clin Orthod editor).
                                                                                   14
JID: YSODO
                                                         ARTICLE IN PRESS                                                                 [m5GeS;January 9, 2024;3:04]
attachments on the facial surfaces of the mandibular teeth.13 Therefore,                raised on the normal side. Creating enough clearance to upright lin-
Brodie Bite treatment generally requires disarticulating upper and lower                gually inclined and sometimes extruded lower posterior teeth with elas-
teeth to correct the buccal crossbite free of interferences and occlusal                tic traction to mini-screws correcting the scissor bite.2,13,32
trauma. The patient will have a Brodie and a non-Brodie side in a unilat-               Unfortunately, undesired intrusion may occur during scissor bite correc-
eral buccal crossbite. The occlusion on the non-Brodie side can be per-                 tion, generating problems (to be discussed in the complications section).
fectly normal and not affected. The disocclusion strategy should be as                  The disocclusion can be done with several different treatment strategies,
minimal as required to avoid altering the correct occlusion of the non-                 as seen in Table 2.
involved side.                                                                              Appliances to be used are an acrylic bite plate or a vacuum appliance
    Temporary bite raising during fixed orthodontic treatment is com-                    stabilizing normal occlusal contacts in the upper and lower arches. Other
monly obtained through removable occlusal appliances. However,                          appliances to open the bite are acetate plates with bite blocks on the side
patient cooperation is required since full-time use of the bite plate is                without scissor bite or modified Hawley bite plate appliances. The use of
required for approximately 7 to 9 months.12 Most frequently, the bite is                anterior bite planes as a simple method to disarticulate arches has also
                                                                                        been proposed.33
                                                                                            Upper palatal and lower lingual bonded bite turbos can also be used
                                                                                        on compromised teeth, contributing to raising the bite and helping with
                                                                                        the intrusion while the transverse correction is taking place. Bonding
                                                                                        with resin, the occlusal surface of the opposite side to provide the
Fig. 31. The left side corrected Brodie Bite. Upper and lower longitudinal cone-
beam cuts on the long axis of the involved teeth are presented to visualize the
buccal and palatal bone after the correction. (previously published in J Clin           Fig. 32. A. Brodie Bite involving only one tooth. B. The tooth was severely lin-
Orthod MS 23193 accepted for publication − reproduction authorized by J Clin            gualized, with a significant degree of tooth mobility. It failed to upright with a
Orthod editor)                                                                          TAD. A decision was made to extract it and replace it with a future implant.
                                                                                   15
JID: YSODO
                                                        ARTICLE IN PRESS                                                                [m5GeS;January 9, 2024;3:04]
necessary clearance has also been described.16 Ideally, the disarticulat-              almost always treated with dental compensations. However, research
ing strategy covers most teeth instead of loading a few with masticatory               has shown an inherent instability when intercanine width is expanded
forces. The goal is to prevent occlusal interferences when the mandibu-                dentally. Similarly, intermolar width might be unstable if expanded
lar posterior teeth are being moved buccally and simultaneously avoid                  excessively during orthodontic treatment. During distraction osteogene-
unwanted extrusion of the maxillary posterior teeth. Glass ionomer bite                sis, a transverse skeletal deficiency can be treated with mandibular wid-
turbos bonded on occlusal surfaces of the maxillary molars, and later                  ening when a true skeletal discrepancy is present.36
anterior bite turbos have been used as well for treating a Brodie Bite.34                   A combination of orthognathic surgery and orthodontic treatment is
    Figs. 33 and 34 show the treatment mechanics to solve the case pre-                sometimes used to address the mandibular and facial asymmetries. This
sented in Fig. 5, where bite turbos were bonded on the affected side,                  approach uses a 3-piece Le Fort I surgery to address the unilateral poste-
both in the upper and lower arch. Vertical compromise on the Brodie                    rior scissors bite. Occasionally combined with a midline split for maxil-
side was so severe that upper extrusion completely covered the lower                   lary constriction and a bilateral sagittal ramus osteotomy or mandibular
teeth. This bite-raising strategy helped both intrusion and inclination                symphyseal distraction.2,11,37 Upper segmental osteotomies can be
correction free of occlusal trauma. Upper teeth were moved lingually to                designed, as well as subapical mandibular surgery to relocate the
a TAD in the palate, and lower molars were activated as a segment to a                 affected segments.14 A scissors bite involving many teeth and a large
buccal shelf screw.                                                                    vertical overlap is very difficult to correct exclusively with orthodontic
    Aligners have also been used for disocclusion in situations of one                 therapy, especially for non-growing patients. However, surgical options
molar correction.35 Aligners can be an effective alternative to correct                are often rejected by patients.11
scissor bites, particularly if the patient refuses to use conventional fixed                 Different surgical approaches have been suggested in reported Brodie
appliances. Anterior bite ramps are incorporated during the virtual plan-              Bite cases. An extensive maxillary surgical case was treated with a 3-
ning as a bite-raising alternative. The problem is that aligners do not lift           piece Le Fort I osteotomy. The inter-molar maxillary width was reduced
the bite while not in the mouth. Fig. 35 shows another alternative is to               bilaterally during surgery. While maintaining the intercanine distance.
bond permanent bite ramps and design the plastic on top of them.                       The posterior segments were also managed vertically, solving the over-
                                                                                       eruption problem with segmental intrusion.7 Corticotomies followed by
Surgical treatment options                                                             rapid mandibular expansion to obtain inter-arch coordination were pro-
                                                                                       posed.38 Posterior mandibular subapical osteotomy was utilized to cor-
    It is important to consider surgery as a reasonable alternative to more            rect mandibular right premolars and molars on a Brodie Bite pattern.
complex Brodie Bite cases. Sometimes the surgery addresses other skele-                Teeth were moved by using a lingual arch appliance after the subapical
tal problems, but sometimes it is part of the Brodie Bite problem. Differ-
ent surgical treatment options for Brodie Bites depend mostly on the
patient’s age. Until recently, a mandibular transverse deficiency was
                                                                                       Fig. 35. A. Permanent bite ramps are bonded to upper incisors to ensure a bite-
Fig. 34. A. Schematic representation of the treatment mechanics. B. Upper teeth        opening strategy while aligners are not in the mouth. B. The plastic is designed
were moved lingually by elastic activation to a TAD in the palate.                     to fit and the plastic on top of them.
                                                                                  16
JID: YSODO
                                                      ARTICLE IN PRESS                                                                [m5GeS;January 9, 2024;3:04]
   Once the Brodie Bite is corrected, the lingual incline of the buccal                When the Brodie Bite is diagnosed early, periodontal consequences
cusp of the maxillary teeth and the lingual incline of the lingual cusp of          are minimal and most likely addressed through orthodontic movements
                                                                               17
JID: YSODO
                                                          ARTICLE IN PRESS                                                               [m5GeS;January 9, 2024;3:04]
                                                                                     18
JID: YSODO
                                                                     ARTICLE IN PRESS                                                                             [m5GeS;January 9, 2024;3:04]
CRediT authorship contribution statement                                                                 16. Ishihara Y, Kuroda S, Sugawara Y, Kurosaka H, Takano-Yamamoto T, Yamashiro T.
                                                                                                             Long-term stability of implant-anchored orthodontics in an adult patient with a Class
                                                                                                             II Division 2 malocclusion and a unilateral molar scissors-bite. Am J Orthod Dentofacial
    Carol Weinstein: Conceptualization, Data curation, Formal analysis,                                      Orthop. 2014;145(4 SUPPL).
Supervision, Writing − original draft, Writing − review & editing, Inves-                                17. Tambourrino R, Boucher N, Vanarsdall R, Secchi A. Tamburino transverse dimension:
tigation, Project administration. Miguel Hirschhaut: Conceptualiza-                                          diagnosis and relevance to Functional Occlusion. RWISO J. 2010:11–20.
                                                                                                         18. Fatima F, Fida M. The assessment of resting tongue posture in different sagittal skele-
tion, Data curation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Project                                                 tal patterns. Dental Press J Orthod. 2019;24(3):55–63.
administration, Writing − original draft, Writing − review & editing,                                    19. Andrews LF, Andrews WA. The six elements of orofacial harmony. Andrews J.
Supervision. Patricia Vergara: Investigation, Writing − review & edit-                                       2000;1:13–22. Mosby Inc..
                                                                                                         20. Simsuchin C, Chen Y, Huang S, Mallineni SK, Zhao Z, Hagg U, McGrath C. Unilateral
ing. Angelica de la Hoz Chois: Investigation, Writing − review & edit-                                       Scissor Bite Managed with Prefabricated Functional Appliances in Primary Dentition-
ing. Carlos Flores-Mir: Conceptualization, Data curation, Formal                                             A New Interceptive Orthodontic Protocol. Children (Basel). 2021;8(11):957.
analysis, Investigation, Supervision, Writing − original draft, Writing −                                21. Sharma V, Jaiswal M, Yadav K, Chaturvedi T. Rapid canine retraction view project
                                                                                                             corrosion behavior of dental implant and orthodontic materials view project [Inter-
review & editing.
                                                                                                             net]. 2016. Available from: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/325484551.
                                                                                                         22. Li H, Wang Q, Wu T. Nonsurgical treatment of unilateral scissor bite in a growing
                                                                                                             patient. J Clin Orthod. 2014;48(4):249–255.
Acknowledgements                                                                                         23. Reddy V, Reddy R, Parmar R. A modified transpalatal arch for correction of scissor
                                                                                                             bite. J Clin Orthod. 2012;46(5):308–309.
   Special thanks to Dr. Macarena Alvarado for providing us with a                                       24. Inada E, Saitoh I, Ishitani N, Iwase Y, Yamasaki Y. Normalization of masticatory func-
                                                                                                             tion of a scissors-bite child with primary dentition: a case report. J Craniomandibular
case. Dr. Viviane Tinoco for providing us with a diagrammatic scheme.
                                                                                                             Sleep Pract. 2008;26(2):150–156.
Also, Dr. Nadia Araneda for helping us with the reference management.                                    25. Burstone CJ, Choi K. Single forces and deep bite correction by intrusion. Editor. In:
                                                                                                             Huffman, ed. The Biomechanical Foundation of Clinical Orthodontics. 1st Edition Quin-
                                                                                                             tessence Publishing; 2015:89–116.
References                                                                                               26. Chen B, Chang CH, Roberts WE. Simple solution for brodie Bite with skeletal class II
                                                                                                             asymmetry. J Digital Orthodontics. 2021.
 1. Nojima K, Takaku S, Murase C, Nishii Y, Sueishi K. A case report of bilateral Brodie                 27. Yun SW, Lim WH, Chong DR, Chun YS. Scissors-bite correction on second molar with a
    Bite in early mixed dentition using bonded constriction quad-helix appliance. Bull                       dragon helix appliance. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2007;132(6):842–847.
    Tokyo Dent Coll. 2011;52.                                                                            28. Pinho T. Early treatment of scissor bite. J Clin Orthod. 2011;45(9):498–506.
 2. Du J, Shuang L, Qiao M, Ma L, Tuojiang W, Li H. Correction of severe unilateral scissor bite         29. Nakamura M, Kawanabe N, Adachi R, Yamashiro T, Kamioka H. Nonsurgical ortho-
    in growing class II patients [Internet]. 2018. Available from: www.jco-online.com.                       dontic treatment of a hypodivergent adult patient with bilateral posterior scissors bite
 3. Araujo E, Tanaka OM. The Brodie Bite: addressing a confounding orthodontic prob-                         and excesive overjet. Angle Orthod. 2019;89(2):333–349.
    lem. AJO-DO ClinCompan. 2021;1(4):232–244.                                                           30. Song G, Chen H, Xu T. Nonsurgical treatment of Brodie Bite assisted by 3-dimensional
 4. Brodie AG. Consideration of musculature in diagnosis, treatment, and retention. Am J                     planning and asessment. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2018;154(3):421–432.
    Orthod. 1952.                                                                                        31. Yasir YA. Non-surgical adult orthodontic treatment of a unilateral scissor bite. Int
 5. Lee SA, Chang CCH, Roberts WE. Severe unilateral scissors-bite with a constricted mandibu-               Orthod. 2022;20(3): 100667.
    lar arch: bite turbos and extra-alveolar bone screws in the infrazygomatic crests and mandib-        32. Venugopal A, Manzano P, Vaid N. Nonsurgical management of a severe atypical class
    ular buccal shelf. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2018;154(4):554–569.                                  II using miniscrew anchorage. Transpalatal Arch Intrusion Arch. 2023. [Internet]Avail-
 6. Sebbag M, Cavare A. Treatment of Brodie syndrome. J Dentofacial Anomalies Orthod.                       able from: www.jco-online.com.
    2017;20(1):109.                                                                                      33. Sharma VK, Jaiswal M, Yadav K, Chaturvedi TP. Correction of Scissors Bite with Modi-
 7. Kim KA, Yu JJ, Chen Y, Kim SJ, Kim SH, Nelson G. Surgery versus nonsurgery option                        fied Transpalatal Arch. Int J Orthod Milwaukee. 2016;27(4):29–30. Winter.
    for scissors bite treatment. Cranio- J Craniofac Surg. 2015;26(8):e726–e729.                         34. Lee S, Chang C, Roberts E. Severe unilateral scissors-bite with a constricted mandibu-
 8. Deffrennes G, Deffrennes D. Management of Brodie Bite: note on surgical treatment.                       lar arch: bite turbos and extra-alveolar bone screws in the infrazygomatic crests and
    Int Orthod. 2017;15(4):640–676.                                                                          mandibular buccal shelf. American J Orthod and Dentofacial Orthop. 2018;154(4):554–
 9. Song G, Chen H, Xu T. Nonsurgical treatment of Brodie Bite assisted by 3-dimensional                     569.
    planning and assessment. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2018;154(3):421–432.                        35. King JW, Wallace JC. Unilateral Brodie Bite treated with distraction osteogenesis. Am
10. Li H, Wang Q, Wu T. Nonsurgical treatment of unilateral scissor bite in a growing                        J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2004;125(4):500–509.
    patient [Internet]. 2014. Available from: www.jco-online.com.                                        36. Park JH, Kim TW. Correction of bilateral second molar scissors-bite during retention
11. Jung MH. Treatment of severe scissor bite in a middle-aged adult patient with ortho-                     phase. Int J Orthod Milwaukee. 2011;22(2):39–43.
    dontic mini-implants. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2011;139(4 SUPPL).                             37. Sakumoto T, Hayakawa K, Ishii T, Nojima K, Sueishi K. Bilateral scissor bite treated by
12. Chugh VK, Sharma VP, Tandon P, Singh GP. Brodie Bite with an extracted mandibular                        rapid mandibular expansion following corticotomy. Bull Tokyo Dent Coll. 2016;57
    first molar in a young adult: a case report. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2010;137                     (4):269–280.
    (5):694–700.                                                                                         38. Suda N, Tominaga N, Niinaka Y, Amagasa T, Moriyama K. Orthognathic treatment for
13. Keski-Nisula K, Lehto R, Lusa V, Keski-Nisula L, Varrela J. Occurrence of malocclusion                   a patient with facial asymmetry associated with unilateral scissors-bite and a collapsed
    and need of orthodontic treatment in early mixed dentition. Am J Orthod Dentofacial                      mandibular arch. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2012;141(1):94–104.
    Orthop 2003;.                                                                                        39. Jussila P, Krooks L, N€ap€ankangas R, P€akkil€a J, L€ahdesm€aki R, Pirttiniemi P, et al.
14. Baik UB, Kim Y, Sugawara J, Hong C, Park JH. Correcting severe scissor bite in an                        The role of occlusion in temporomandibular disorders (TMD) in the Northern
    adult. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2019;156(1):113–124.                                              Finland Birth Cohort (NFBC) 1966. Cranio - J Craniomandibular Pract. 2019;37
15. Hua X, Xiong H, Han G, Cheng X. Correction of a dental arch-width asymmetric dis-                        (4):231–237.
    crepancy with a slow maxillary contraction appliance. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop.                40. Shimazaki K, Otsubo K, Yonemitsu I, Kimizuka S, Omura S, Ono T. Angle Orthod..
    2012;142(6):842–853.                                                                                     2014;84(2):374–379.
19