Shoe Modifications in Lower-Extremity Orthotics : On at and Other
Shoe Modifications in Lower-Extremity Orthotics : On at and Other
ORTHOTICS*
Isidore Zamosky
INTRODUCTION
Originally shoes were a simple covering used to protect the foot from sharp
stones and thorns and from the uncomfortable vagaries of the weather.
As with other forms of body covering, it was not long before footwear became
embellished with decorative effects and acquired a function in overall
cosmesis and social acceptability. In terms of locomotion, however, the
shoe is basically a means of weight transfer to the ground. Today's shoe,
with its relatively light upper part, a stiff or thick sole and heel, and an
almost flat insole and outsole, provides the normal foot with adequate
support and purchase upon the ground.
*Based principally on lecture presented at VA-trainingcourses, New York University
Prosthetics Courses, and other seminars.
Zamosky: Shoe Modifications
With proper modifications, shoes can also be made to afford the deformed
foot protection, cosmesis, and better balance for standing and walking.
Indeed, the main purpose of all shoe modifications is the restoration of as
normal a gait and weight-bearing pattern as is possible for the patient.
Shoe modifications are even more important when fitting the person
who must wear a leg brace. A brace can be made to fit the patient beauti-
fully and to function perfectly, but its effectiveness will be lost if the ortho-
tist has overlooked the correct construction of the shoe or the factors
necessary for functional weight-bearing. With a poor shoe foundation, the
brace cannot be held in true alignment, and a leaning-tower-of-Pisa effect
will result from the tendency of the foot and leg to tilt the brace in the
direction favored by the residual pathology.
By redistributing body weight away from the sensitive areas of the foot
to the nontender parts, the orthotist strives not only to relieve his patient
of pain but also to achieve a well balanced weight-bearing pattern for him.
Ideally, weight bearing is distributed over the sole in a three-point pat-
tern, i.e., upon the apex of the plantar surface of the calcaneus, upon the
first metatarsal head, and upon the fifth metatarsal head (Fig. 1 ) . For
most of his orthopedic patients, however, the orthotist must resort to the
judicious use of shoe modifications tg achieve a three-point pressure pattern
on the sole of the foot.
SHOE CHECKOUT
shoe shank can be determined by holding the shoe in one hand and trying
to dorsiflex it with the other. If the shoe bends at the break without too
much depression behind that point, then the steel shank is correctly placed.
With the shoe shank properly placed (j/4-3/8 in. posterior to the break
of the shoe), dorsiflexion of the shoe on the foot will be congruent to that
of the metatarsophalangeal joints at rollover. If, however, the shoe shank
is placed anteriorly to the break of a low-quarter shoe, dorsiflexion will
force the quarters distally away from the foot, incurring a great degree
of undesirable piston motion in gait; with the more extensive instep and ankle
coverage of the chukka or high-quarter shoe, great pressure would be
borne at the instep of the foot. If, however, the shoe shank is placed
too far posteriorly from the break, dorsiflexion will force the longitudinal
arch of the shoe to depress and the weight-bearing heel surface to shift
toward the heel breastline. A footslap-type of gait in midstance, with
possible depression of the medial and lateral longitudinal arches of the
foot and ensuing pain, may result from those conditions. Placing the steel
shank at the breakline would greatly shorten the life of the shoe since
repeated dorsiflexion during ambulation would force the anterior edge of
the shank to perforate the outsole.
For brace wearers, it is absolutely essential that a solid sole material be
used. If crepe or composition rubber were used, the sole would compress
under vertical load, introducing undesirable pseudo plantar flexion-dorsi-
flexion and varus-valgus motions. The shoe should also include a steel
shank that extends from approximately midheel to the ball of the foot.
SHOE STYLES
The stock shoe comes in several styles, including the blucher, the bal,
the chukka, and the convalescent or postsurgical-type shoe (Fig. 4 ) . An
understanding of the makeup of these various styles will help the orthotist in
selecting the shoe that will be best for his patient's particular foot problems.
Blucher
The style of shoe that the orthotist most generally prefers his patient to
wear is almost invariably the laced blucher with plain toe (Fig. 4a). The
quarters of this shoe extend forward over the throat of the vamp, are loose
at the inner edge, and lace across the tongue, affording easy access for the
foot into the shoe. Whether the patient has a free or limited ankle joint, he
should have the easy access which the blucher-style upper affords.
Bal
Although it has front lacing, the bal (Fig. 4b) does not afford easy access
of the foot because the vamp is sewn over the quarters at the front of the
throat. The bal is usually prescribed only when there is no foot pathology
Bulletin of Prosthetics Research-Fall 1964
involved, as for example, in heel elevation, where leg shortening exists with-
out foot or ankle deformity.
Convalescent Shoe
A special variation of the blucher, called the convalescent or surgical
shoe (Fig. 4c), may be advisable after foot surgery or for the ankylosed foot.
The convalescent shoe has lacing to the toes, and the toecap is formed by
the extension of the tongue to the front of the outsole. Such a design pro-
vides easy entry for the foot that is spastic or that cannot be plantar flexed.
Since the patient with a stiff ankle joint or a completely ankylosed foot
cannot plantar flex without pain, he must don his shoe almost vertically,
with no moments toward plantar flexion. For such a patient, the con-
valescent high quarter with posterior closing is beneficial (Fig. 4d).
Shoe Uppers
The blucher and bal styles are available in both the low-quarter upper
( 1% in. below the malleoli) and the high-quarter upper (about 2 in. above
the malleoli) . A shoe with a three-quarter upper that goes to the apices of
the malleoli is called a chukka (Fig. 5 ) . The broad coverage of the foot
provided by both the chukka and high-quarter uppers helps to prevent pis-
ton motion during walking and so is excellent for limited or stiff joints.
(Piston motion is the term used to describe the upward movement of the
leg and foot working against the downward pressure of the brace and shoe
during the swing phase of gait. This action can produce a very painful
chafing of the calf.)
F I G U ~4.
E Shoe styles. ( a ) Blucher, ( b ) bal, ( c ) convalescent, and ( d ) -convalescent
with posterior closure.
Zamosky: Shoe Modifications
I
The chukka with lacing (Fig. 6a) is particularly effective for a foot with
scars that might be abraded by the top edge of a low-quarter shoe. The
chukka with strap and buckle (Fig. 6b) is often recommended for patients
with poor finger dexterity. A variation that further facilitates donning is
I
the low quarter with a clip fastener tongue (Fig. 6 c ) . When the tongue is
pushed forward, the patient can don his shoe by using a long shoe horn or
by pushing the toe tip against a wall. With his foot in the shoe, he need
then only tap the clip tongue closed, where it will remain secure until pushed
forward again for removal. Another variation that facihtates donning
is the low quarter with elastic goring on the medial and lateral sides of the
quarters. The use of elastic laces on the blucher-type low-quarter uppers
with a long shoe horn will also help the patient with poor finger dexterity,
or lack of hip flexion power, to don his shoes more easily.
Toe Design
The forepart of the shoe is designed in one of five variations: plain toe,
moccasin, straight tip, wing tip, or U-tip (Fig. 7 ) . The blucher and bal
are available in all five styles, but the chukka is made in only three: the plain
toe, straight tip, or the wing tip. The plain toe is the most practical type
for all orthopedic shoes since the absence of excessive stitching and overlays
allows a smooth inner shoe surface, which reduces the possibility of foot
abrasions. The other toe types are not generally recommended.
Although the plain toe and moccasin foreparts have no special decoration,
the straight, wing, and U-tips may have pinking, medallions, perforations,
or imitation foxing at the quarters. These designs are purely ornamental
in function.
motion, with limited motion, with solid or spring-loaded stops, or with free-
motion ankle joints.
The stresses applied to the shoe through the brace attachment tend to
distort the shoe, particularly in the longitudinal arch area. Since the stock
shoes purchased by most patients usually contain inferior sole materials and
either no shank, a wood shank, or a poor quality steel shank, proper rein-
forcement is necessary to prevent depression of the longitudinal arch.
Another cause for failure of the longitudinal arch of the shoe is the fact
that many prefabricated shoe attachments have narrow tongues with insuf-
I
ficient area for selecting rivet locations (Fig. 8a). The orthotist is forced
to rivet through the center of the steel shank causing a cross-sectional failure
in a short time.
I If the orthotist can-not prevail upon the manufacturer of prefabricated
brace attachments to provide broadened tongue areas for these attachments,
he can weld or braze a reinforcement plate over the tongue and heel of the
regular attachment, shaping the tongue of the plate broadly (Fig. 8b). The
broadened tongue affords sufficient area for the selection of rivet locations
which will bypass the steel shank lying beneath, thereby eliminating possible
perforation and failure of the steel shank.
The effects of shoe distortion caused by poor material or shank failure
are obvious. When the longitudinal arch of the shoe depresses sufficiently,
the patient may feel pain or discomfort in any or all of the tarsometatarsal
and talocalcanealcuboid joints; the subtalar and tibiotalar joints may also
be highly affected. T o relieve this discomfort, the patient tends to flex his
knee, reducing the stress on the brace and shoe but producing an unde-
sirable gait characteristic.
I t must also not be overlooked that in joining the heelbase and heel to the
exposed outsole and brace attachment, the orthotist shoemaker generally
drills holes into the attachment to assist in nailing. The holes are drilled
close to the edges of the anterior radii formed by the stirrup uprights and that
part of the stirrup in contact with the outsole. These points are normally
vulnerable to vertical load and are drastically weakened by the holes. With
limited-motion or rigid-stop ankle joints, a cross-sectional failure may be
expected to occur at those points after a comparatively short period of wear.
T o prevent such failures, epoxy cement or 41 10 Laminac Resin may be
used to join the heel and heelbase to the outsole and brace attachment with-
out drilling holes through the latter. These two plastic resin cements are
easy to apply with brush or dauber, and they hold the components securely
to one another.
SHOE MODIFICATIONS
The following components are listed in the order of the amount of support
they provide to effect medial longitudinal arch support and/or lateral
weight shift :
Internal External
1. Steel shank in shoe 6. Orthopedic heel (Thomas)
2. Cookie insole and insert 7. Thomas heel wedge
3. Navicular (scaphoid) pad 8. Medial sole and/or heel wedge
4. Longitudinal arch support 9. Medial shank filler
5. Long counter on medial side 10. Valgus strap
Foot Disabilities
Foot disabilities for which these components are used include medial pes
planus, pes cavus, and valgus. -
In medial pes planus, the medial longitudinal arch is depressed, causing
the navicular bone to become prominent and the forefoot to abduct. In
one type of pes planus, the foot is spastic with contracted tendons and
ligaments. The characteristics of another type, flaccid pes planus, are a
long slender foot with relaxed tendons and hypermobility of the articular
surfaces of all the joints. For the relief of pes planus, support and/or
elevation is necessary.
Pes cavus is characterized by medial and lateral longitudinal arches that
are high or "hollow" because of shortened extensor tendons of the dorsum;
the metatarsal arch, however, is depressed. This condition is often of
congenital origin but may also be residual from poliomyelitis, multiple
sclerosis, or cerebral palsy. Pes cavus requires support to prevent pain in
moments toward depression of the longitudinal arches.
Bulletin of Prosthetics Research-Fall 1964
In valgus (eversion, Fig. lOa), the lateral aspect of the plantar surface
of the foot is elevated with the medial longitudinal arch depressed; the
subtalar and tibiotalar ankle joints lean and stretch at their medial liga-
mentous connections, causing the medial malleolus to protrude. This
condition may be either spastic or flaccid and often requires both support
and weight shift. Figure 10 illustrates the position of the ankle and heel
when the foot is in valgus, normal, and varus positions.
Shoe Modifications
I . Steel Shank in Shoe. Most custom and stock orthopedic or high-
quality stock shoes contain a steel shank. If the shank is not positioned as
explained in the section on shoe checkout (Fig. 3 ) , it will not function prop-
erly. If the steel is poor in quality it will cause the depression of the longi-
tudinal arch of the shoe under weight bearing. The posterior terminus of
the steel shank should be at least in. posterior to the plantar apex of the
calcaneus, and extend anteriorly to a point % or % in. posterior to the break
of the shoe. The steel shank is often referred to as "the backbone of the
shoe." Its width is determined by the width of the shoe, weight of the
patient, type of brace and vocation of the patient. The average low- or
medium-priced stock shoe, rarely includes an adequate steel shank. I t is
therefore often necessary to remove the original shank and install a more
adequate support.
2. Cookie Insert or Insole. If a steel shank alone does not provide suffi-
cient support for the longitudinal arch of the shoe sole or foot, a cookie
insert may be indicated. The cookie is generally made of shoulder leather
Zamosky: Shoe Modifications
for rigidity, and is shaped to conform to the longitudinal arch of the foot
with the highest point of support in the area of the talonavicular joint
(Fig. 11). I t should extend from a point approximately 1f/4 in. posterior
to the heel breastline to approximately % in. posterior to the first metatarsal
head. The medial edge, which is feathered, should lie against the quarter
lining on the medial side of the longitudinal arch. The distal surface of the
cookie lies against the insole of the shoe. I t provides a more rigid support
when used with a long counter on the medial side. In the custom shoe or
the stock shoe with orthopedic features, the cookie insole is an integral part
of the shoe, being a modification of the insole.
'
A cookie insert may be applied at any time to any type of shoe. Available
commercially in various sizes, the cookie may be glued in permanently or in-
serted as a removable component.
3. Navicular Pad (Scaphoid) . Like the cookie, the navicular pad is also
designed to provide additional support for the longitudinal arch on the
medial side (Fig. 11). I t is installed in the same place in the shoe as the
cookie insert and, in general, has the same contour. I t also provides better
support if used with a long counter on the medial side. There are, however,
specific differences. T o provide a resilient support, the navicular pad is
made of compressible materials such as sponge rubber of various durometers,
and the rubber surfaces are covered with leather for comfort. The navicu-
lar pad is generally prescribed in cases where the patient cannot tolerate
the rigid support of a cookie.
4. Longitudinal Arch Support. This modification may be prescribed
in cases where broader areas of support are required, including the entire
plantar surface of the foot. In providing support for the medial longi-
tudinal arch, the broad extent of the arch support tends to shift the body
weight laterally and in some cases may preclude the use of a valgus strap.
Longitudinal arch support inserts may be procured commercially in a
variety of materials such as.metal, plastic, and leather. If necessary they
may be reshaped for final fitting by hammering, heating, and bending.
5. Long Counter on the Medial Side. The medial counter on the stock
shoe usually extends approximately 3/8 to j/2 in. forward of the breast of
the heel (Fig. 12). In the stock shoe with orthopedic features, it extends
approximately midway between the heelbreast and the break of the shoe,
Bulletin of Prosthetics Research-Fall 1964
68
Zamosky: Shoe Modifications
10.' Valgus Strap. The valgus strap applied medially is designed to pre-
vent the foot and ankle from assuming a valgus attitude (Fig. 16). I n
spasticity or muscle contracture, where the foot, even when unweighted, in-
termittently or constantly. assumes a valgus position, the strap functions to
maintain correct mediolateral alignment. The strap prevents the foot from
going into a valgus attitude by overcoming the action of the spastic or con-
tracted muscles; it may also be used in cases of mild spasticity and contrac-
ture of flaccidity where the foot assumes a v a l p s attitude only when bearing
weight.
T o be riiost effective the valgus strap should lift or help prevent depres-
sion in the following areas:
a. Medial anterior aspect of the talocalcaneal joint;
b. Talonavicular joint ;
c. Navicular first cuneiform joint;
d. First cuneiform base of the first metatarsal joint.
Therefore, the area of attachment for the distal end of the strap should
be from a point 1/2 in. posterior to the medial breastline (or j/2 in. plus
the length of the medial projection of a Thomas heel) to a point approxi-
mately 60 percent of the distance between the heel breast and the Geak
of the shoe.
For cosmetic reasons, however, the distal attachment of the strap is fre-
quently placed more posteriorly, extending anteriorly approximately to the
breastline of the heel. The reason for this posterior attachment is to posi-
tion equivalent amounts of rnaterial on either side of the brace uprights or
shoe attachment. I n this position, the force of the strap is applied primarily
in the area of the calcaneous and talus, and the effect on the foot is reduced
due to the relative motion between talus and navicular, navicular and first
cuneiform, and first cuneiform and base of the first metatarsal.
From its distal attachment, the strap extends proximally to a point about
1% in. above the apex of the medial malleolus, where it divides into an
anterior and posterior strap encircling the leg and the lateral brace upright,
and then buckles on the lateral side.
dulletin of Prosthetics Research-Fall 1964
Shoe Modifications
I . Long Counter on the Lateral Side. This modification helps prevent
depression of the lateral longitudinal arch by providing a rigid wall which
effectively restricts the movement of the foot into an attitude of varus. To
provide the maximum effective support, the anterior extent of the counter
should terminate at a point just posterior to the fifth metatarsal head. The
long counter can be simulated by gluing a prefabricated or preshaped half-
counter into a stock shoe, but the shoe must be wide enough to allow for this
modification. The extended counter can be covered with a thin leather
skin for comfort.
2. Lateral Heel Wedge Insert. If the long counter does not provide
sufficient lateral support, a lateral heel wedge insert may be indicated
(Fig. 17). This modification raises the lateral longitudinal arch and shifts
Zamosky: Shoe Modifications
the body weight toward the medial side of the foot. It may, in some flaccid
cases, obviate a varus strap.
The wedge is placed inside the shoe with the thickest section beneath the
lateral weight-bearing point of the calcaneus. When properly fabricated
and installed, the insert should provide additional support in the area of the
base of the fifth metatarsal; by so doing, it will also afford slight support at
the plantar protuberance of the cuboid bone. If it does not provide such
support, some of its effectiveness is lost through the relative motion between
the bones of the midfoot and the forefoot.
Although sponge rubber in varying durometers is frequently used, other
materials such as leather and cork are also suitable. The basic material is
usually covered with thin leather or plastic sheeting, and the insert may be
permanently glued or left removable.
to the break of the shoe to the anterior tip of the sole, with its highest point
slightly behind the head of the fifth metatarsal. Its medial extension is
governed by the total elevation of the wedge and the need for very gradual
feathering. As it slopes medially, however, it ~rovidesadditional support
for the heads of the fourth and third metatarsals.
c. Sole-and-heel wedge. Both sole and heel wedges are prescribed in
cases where the lateral aspect of the foot bears too much weight and in cases
of severe varus or depression of the lateral longitudinal arch. A sole-and-
heel wedge is often used in conjunction with a long counter on the lateral
side and/or a heel wedge insert to augment the desired medial weight shift
effect. The lateral heel-and-sole wedge may be applied in the same manner
as the medial sole-and-heel-wedge; it too offers more support when applied
as a unit.
4. Reverse Orthopedic Heel ( T h o m a s ) . As.discussed earlier, orthopedic
heels are obtained commercially as half heels in a variety of sizes. Their dis-
tinguishing feature is the anterior projection of the medial side of the heel
breasting. When applied to the heel base, they provide support for the
medial longitudinal arch. When used to support the lateral longitudinal
arch, a "left" orthopedic heel is simply used on the right shoe and vice versa;
for this reason they are called reverse orthopedic (Thomas) heels (Fig. 18).
The projection of the reverse orthopedic heel extends approximately in.
anterior to the normal heel breastline and is located beneath the lateral
prominence of the base of the fifth metatarsal. I t therefore provides support
in the areas of the calcaneocuboid and cuboid-base of the fifth metatarsal
joints.
5. Lateral Shank Filler. The lateral shank filler is prescribed in cases
where the patient's weight requires additional support for the lateral longi-
tudinal arches of the foot and shoe. With the characteristic shape of the
medial shank filler, the lateral shank filler eliminates the void existing be-
tween the ground and the lateral plantar surface of the longitudinal arch
of the shoe (Fig. 19). By the application of additional height, elevation and
medial weight shift can be provided for a depressed lateral longitudinal
arch and/or varus condition involving calcaneocuboid, cuboid-base of fifth
metatarsal joints, and the subtalar and tibiotalar joints.
This shank filler extends from the lateral breastline anteriorly to the head
of the fifth metatarsal, at which point it is feathered into the level of the
outsole at the break of the shoe. Medially it can extend from the breastline
to a point deemed necessary to afford adequate longitudinal arch support.
This extent would be carried anteriorly to a point at the line of metatarsal
heads, where it too would feather into the level of the outsole at the break
of the shoe.
6. Lateral Flaring of Sole and Heel. In such conditions as painful anky-
losis of unsuccessful arthrodesis of the tibiotalar, subtalar, talonavicular,
Zamosky: Shoe Modifications
outsole. In the stock shoe, the outsole must be detached from the welt, and
the welt removed from the insole and upper joint, extending from an area
% in. anterior to the lateral heel breastline up to the lateral anterior end of
the toe. Welting wide enough to afford an adequate flare, spliced at the
terminals of the above-described areas, should be hand-stitched or McKay-
machine stitched to the upper and insole. T o apply this modification, the
heel and heelbase must first be removed and then replaced. The void
existing between the ground and the medial aspect of the sole, from toe to
midshank, should be filled in to allow for the addition of the outsole so that
with the proper flare on the lateral aspect of the outsole, a close-to-normal
weight-bearing pattern is achieved. Here too, lateral wedging should be
excluded to prevent a moment toward valgus, and the medial longitudinal
arch should be adequately supported.
A long rigid counter on the lateral side, extending anteriorly to the fifth
metatarsophalangeal joint, can be installed to afford a strong retaining wall.
The lateral shank filler mentioned earlier can also be used with a flare.
c. Flaring the sole and heel. If it is necessary to prevent varus along the
entire lateral aspect of the foot, both heel and sole may be flared (Fig. 20).
This can be accomplished as described for each of the segments individually.
If the required lateral flare is so e~tensive~as
to distort under weight bearing,
another outsole may be applied over the first for added strength. In this case
it is also necessary to add another sole to the sound side to maintain equal
leg lengths.
d. Varus strap. The varus strap (Fig. 2 1) applied laterally is designed to
prevent the foot from assuming a varus attitude. In spasticity or muscle
FIGURE20. Lateral flaring of sole and FIGURE2 1. Varus corrective strap; dor-
hecl. Top: plantar view; bottom; ted line indicates most effective place-
lateral view. ment.
Zamosky: Shoe Modifications
contracture, where the foot, even when unweighted, intermittently or con-
stantly assumes a varus position, the strap functions to maintain correct
mediolateral alignment by overcoming the action of the spastic or contracted
muscles. I t may also be used in cases of mild spasticity and contracture or
flaccidity where the foot assumes a varus attitude only when bearing weight.
T o be most effective the varus strap should lift or help prevent depression
in the following areas :
a. Lateral anterior aspect of the talocalcaneal joint;
b. Calcaneocuboid joint;
c. Cuboid base of the fifth metatarsal joint.
Therefore, the area of attachment for the distal end of the strap should
v2
be from a-point in. posterior to the lateral breastline to a point approxi-
mately 60 percent of the distance between the heelbreast and the break
of the shoe.
As for the valgus strap, cosmetic reasons often dictate a design of lesser
effect. In the varus strap the effect would be reduced primarily to lifting
or preventing depression at the talocalcaneal joint and the talocuboid joint.
From its distal attachment, the strap extends proximally to a point ap-
proximately 1f/2 in. above the apex of the lateral malleolus, where it divides
into an anterior and posterior strap encircling the leg and the medial brace
upright, buckling on the medial side in a convenient position for the patient.
Foot Disabilities
In pes cavus, the extensor tendons of the dorsum are shortened, causing
the longitudinal arches to become high or "hollow" and also causing the
proximal phalanges of each toe to dorsiflex while the middle and distal
phalanges plantar flex. The dorsiflexion of the proximal phalanges
Bulletin of Prosthetics Research-Fall 1964
forces the metatarsal arch to depress so that all the heads are in ground
contact. Callosities usually develop on the plantar skin surfaces of these
heads, and pain ensues.
Fractures of the metatarsal bones often result in the formation of callous
tissue during healing. When weight is borne upon the plantar tissue that
is sandwiched between the thickened bone and the tread area, pain ensues.
If the periosteum is penetrated by the fracture, bone tissue may grow in
irregular shapes and project beyond the surface of the remaining bone and
periosteum. Such a bone projection, called exostosis, causes pain when
pressed against plantar tissue. If securely held by fibrous tissue, a mal-
union in a metatarsal bone may be comfortably supported by a metatarsal
arch support.
If bursitis (the inflammation of fluid-filled bursa1 sacs that develop at
frictional areas between tissues) develops at the metatarsophalangeal joints,
relief of tenderness is obtained by proper metatarsal support padding.
Morton's toe is a condition in which the first metatarsal bone is congen-
itally short. In comparison, the normal length of the second metatarsal seems
excessive and upsets the proper three-point weight-distribution pattern. The
weight-bearing area is reduced to the area between the second and fifth
heads and the apex of the calcaneus. The head of the second metatarsal
consequently becomes quite painful s i n c ~it is not structured to bear so
much weight, especially in rollover of the stance phase or toe spring at
pushoff, which requires a great amount of plantar flexor strength. Support
and elevation helps to relieve pain of this condition.
Plantar warts (calloused tissue appearing like small callosities when
trimmed) expose a rather deep-rooted growth, resulting in a needle-sticking
type of sensation. These warts seem to grow between and under the heads
of the metatarsals; they are also found growing elsewhere on the plantar
surface of the foot. I t has been said that a virus infection is the causative
factor in the growth of plantar warts. Proper padding will help to relieve
this condition.
Hallux valgus occurs when the first metatarsal is abducted and the pha-
langes are adducted, producing a displacement of the great toe toward the
other toes. This disability is often caused by the wearing of narrow or
pointed-toed shoes. Where manipulation is painful and surgery is contra-
indicated for medical reasons, the deformity must be accommodated in an
outflare-type of lasted shoe. Where manipulation is not painful, an inner-
mold with padding to realign the hallux, placed in a straight inner-border
last, will relieve the condition.
Hallux rigidus is a deformity characterized by a gait pattern with a
heel strike that is more lateral than normal and with a weight shift to
the lateral border of the foot and shoe during advance into midstance. At
the midstance phase, the ankle is in slight voluntary varus with the midtarsal
and forefoot in enough supination to relieve the first MP joint of weight
i.
;c*-.;:
I,,
-. . :; - - .
-
.
-
-
- -
-. - 4.
2amosky: Shoe Modifications
bearing. The hallux rigidus deformity is caused by an overgrowth of bone
(exostosis), resulting from congenital origins, trauma, or arthritic joint
degeneration. The exostosis may develop at the base of the proximal phalanx
of the hallux, or at the first metatarsal head. As the exostosis grows into
a joint stop, movement of the first metatarsophalangeal joint becomes re-
stricted and painful. T o relieve the deformity, a medial longitudinal arch,
a properly fitted metatarsal support for the first metatarsal head, and a long
steel spring and rocker bar are needed.
Splayfoot is a deformity in which the metatarsal bones abduct from each
other medi~laterall~, at their head ends, and compress at the closely mated
articular margins of the tarsometatarsal joints, depressing the anterior meta-
tarsal arch. The degree of abduction and depression is dependent upon
the laxity of the intrinsic muscles (plantar interossei and the adductor hal-
lucis) of the foot. These muscles and their tendonous connectors normally
truss the metatarsal bones so that they form a dome-shaped anterior arch
and thus allow compressionless articulation to exist at the tarsometatarsal
joints. Bandaging or corseting the foot from the waist level up to the
tarsometatarsal joint level is the treatment generally administered this
deformity. A metatarsal pad may be included for relief, if necessary.
Splayfoot is characterized by a flatf~oted-typegait, in which the patient
carries out heel strike and midstance, but then precludes rollover and toe-off
by raising the foot horizontally from the ground. This type gait is a result
of pain experienced while trying normal rollover and toe-off. The plantar
flexors of the toes cannot be relied upon to perform normally in supplying
spring forces. With the malalignment of the metatarsal bones, the spring
forces necessary for toe-off would only further depress the anterior metatar-
sal arch, and pain would ensue. Another common problem with this
deformity is that the patient wears a stock shoe that is much too wide at the
ball of the foot, yet he will usually complain that his shoe is too tight; the
fact is that with proper corseting there is a great amount of space in the
shoe.
Shoe Modifications
1 . Regular Metatarsal Pad. By elevating the inner sole posterior to the
heads of the metatarsals, a metatarsal arch support helps to redistribute
weight bearing in that area. Regular metatarsal pads are availble com-
mercially in many sizes and are helpful in cases of moderate metatarsalgia
(Fig. 22c).
Dancer Pad. For more serious metatarsalgia conditions, however, the
broad shape and thickness of the dancer pad is more helpful since it provides
more support than the regular metatarsal pad (Fig. 22a, b). Sometimes
called "buttons" the dancer-type pad can be shaped to fit directly behind
each of the metatarsal heads (Fig. 22a) so that its feathered edge comes
under the surface of the metatarsal heads. This placement is particularly
Bulletin of Prosthetics Research-Fall 1964
beneficial for the flexible foot. With the rigid foot or pes planus, however,
the pad should be placed slightly more posterior to the metatarsal heads
in order to relieve the pressure on the heads. The shaping of the dancer
pad must conform to the soft tissues that cover the metatarsals, otherwise
tissue stretch occurs, which counteracts the intended benefits of pressure
relief. In fact, tissue stretch increases the sensitivity of prominent callosity
areas even though the callosities are being relieved of body-weight pressures.
Metatarsal Corset. Figure 22d, e shows a metatarsal corset, which is an
innovation that allows the patient to change footwear without removing
the arch support, thereby reducing the necessity of repositioning the meta-
tarsal pads several times a day. The corset utilizes either the regular meta-
tarsal pad or dancer pads and may be fastened by elastic, strap, or buckle.
The metatarsal corset can also be used for splayfoot since its trussing ele-
ments are lax enough to permit abduction of the metatarsal heads and
depression of the anterior metatarsal arch.
Insole Pads. The metatarsal insole is another type of arch support that
is generally used as a removable component. The pad is mounted on an
insert which is shaped to conform to the insole of the shoe, from the heel
to the area of midmetatarsal heads, where the insert feathers.
F I ~ W R22.
E Metatarsal pads. ( a ) Contoured dancer pad; (b) noncontoured dancer
pad; (c) regular metatarsal pad; ( d ) metatarsal corset, lateral view; and ( e ) meta-
.tarsal corset, plantar view.
78
Zamosky: Shoe Modifications
2. Levy Inlay. The Levy-type inlay is often used when the plantar sur-
face of the metatarsophalangeal or interphalangeal joints are hypersensitive
to pressure. The Levy component is made by cementing a sponge or foam-
rubber forefoot part to a combination arch support. Since the inlay is re-
movable, it can easily be adjusted whenever necessary.
The full innermold coverage of the Levy inlay is also utilized to treat
hallux valgus (bunion). A wedge-shaped pad made of resilient foam rub-
ber should be placed between the hallux and the second toe in order to
abduct the great toe and realign the first metatarsophalangeal joint toward
a normal attitude (Fig. 2 3 ) . A mittenlike sock with a separate section for
the great toe helps to prevent wrinkles from forming between the pad and
the toe.
3. Morton's T o e Extension. A toe extension is used to ease the painful
condition often resulting from an abnormally short first metatarsal bone
(Fig. 24). By raising the level of the first metatarsal bone and the phalanges
of the hallux, the extension restores the proper three-point weight-distribu-
tion pattern, i.e., the weight is distributed between the plantar apex of the
calcaneus and the first and fifth metatarsal heads.
For maximum effectiveness, Morton's toe insert should extend from the
heel to the tip of the hallux, passing qnd supporting the medial portion of
the longitudinal arch. The lateral extent of the insert should be feathered
at the medial peripheral line of the second toe, forming a sharp radius be-
tween the first and second MP joints. At the lateral end of the radius, the
insert should extend to the fifth MP joint. A properly fitted metatarsal
support should be installed to relieve the second metatarsal head and any
others requiring relief. The orthotist can fabricate this type of insert by us-
ing a semiprefabricated longitudinal arch support and adding the hallux
FIGURE23. Foot fitted with hallux val- FIGURE 24. Morton's toe extension
gus support on Levy-type insole and mit- (plantar view). Dotted line indicates
ten-like sock. metatarsal support to relieve pressure
on metatarsal heads.
79
Bulletin of Prosthetics Research-Fall 1964
extension. The choice of material depends upon the patient's weight and
the sensitivity of the deformity.
4. Metatarsal Bar. Now we come to the first of the external types of meta-
tarsal supports, the metatarsal bar, which is prescribed to relieve pressure
from the metatarsal heads (Pig. 25 a, b ) . I t may be used in place of insert
components when foot sensitivity restricts their use, or it may simply be used
to augment inserts for the nonsensitive foot. In a stock shoe, which has a
thin insole susceptible to reshaping by perspiration or moisture, the metatar-
sal bar should be applied as an overlay; if the bar were applied as a sandwich,
it would soon begin to rise within the shoe, reducing foot room and causing
pressure against the sensitive postmetatarsal area.
The metatarsal bar should be placed on the outsole with its thickest point
directly behind and parallel to the line between the first and fifth metatarsal
heads so that after heel strike in rollover, the weight is borne at the area
behind the metatarsal heads. rather than upon the heads. The anterior
extent of the mrtatarsal bar should taper about 1% in.; its posterior taper
may be shorter since it serves no function in pressure relief. As an overlay,
the metatarsal bar has the added advantage of being easily adjusted or re-
placed without damage to the outsole andwelt, thus prolonging shoe life.
5. Rocker Bar. The rocker bar (Fig. 25 c, d ) is more extensively used
than the metatarsal bar, particularly when improved gait function and a de-
gree of immobilization are desired for the ankle, tarsal, transmetatarsal,
metatarsophalangeal, or interphalangeal joints. Like the metatarsal bar, the
rocker bar is prescribed to relieve pressure from the metatarsal heads.
In stock shoes, the rocker bar should be installed as an overlay, with its
apex directly behind and in a line parallel to the first and fifth metatarsal
heads. The anterior of the rocker bar extends farther to the toe end of the
shoe than does the metatarsal bar. The exact extent is determined by the
height of the apex and the feathering. The extension of the wearline of the
sole toward the heel and the placement of the apex of the bar posteriorly, re-
duces the posterior and midfoot weight-bearing force appreciably during the
period of rollover and pushoff. Without the rocker bar, the weight-
bearing force would normally be applied to the metatarsal area during gait.
6. Denver Bar. The Denver bar (also called the Dutchman) is an-
other type of metatarsal support, usually made of leather and applied as an
overlay to the outsole by cementing or nailing (Fig. 25e, f ) . The posterior
extent of the bar can be increased or decreased, depending upon the degree
of pathology. Usually, the posterior face of the Denver bar is placed at
the plantar surface of the instep, i.e., directly beneath the transverse arch of
the foot at the tarsometatarsal joints. I t is important that the orthotist
achieve a balance between the shoe heelbreast and the Denver bar so that
Zamosky: Shoe Modifications
2
td
ds
s ::
56
QT
rn-
2;
5.z
12
--
2
- e
0.
:*-e
*
es
*
Q)*
24
. El
ZG
lil-
a .-
z '6?,
Bulletin. of Prosthetics- Research-Fall 1964
during rollover in the stance phase of gait, the transverse arch is raised. As
the transverse arch is elevated, the metatarsal bones.are pulled posteriorly
and the weight on the metatarsal heads is relieved. Should the,orthotist wish
to give support to the navicular bone or. to effect a lateral. weight shift,
he may extend the Denver bar posteriorly or elevate-the component.
7 . Long Steel Spring and. Rocker Bar. In: conjunction. with extended
brace attachment tongues and/or long steel springs, the rocker bar provides
firm support for the forefoot until lateinhthe stance phase, thus reducing the
support required of the toes (Fig. 26). When used with a .stiff-ankle brace
or a limiting plantar anddorsiflexion brace, the rocker bar also reduces mo-
tion in.the tibiotalar and subtalar ankle joints, talonavicwlar, calcaneocuboid,
and tarsometatarsal joints, making it helpful in relieving arthritic pains,
ankylosis, and other ankle and foot disabilities.
8. S A C H Heel. A soft heel simulating a SACH foot wedge used in con-
junction with the rocker bar provides a more natural gait from heel contact
to rollover to pushoff. The SACH foot wedge, which we refer to as a SACH
heel in orthotics., is comprised of .resilient materials, such as sponge, pedic,
or crepe rubbers of adequate durometers with a thin rubber heel.on top to
provide cushioning at heel contact. The depression occurring at heel con-
tact simulates plantar Rexion, .and in so doing causes earlier outsole contact
with the ground.
Internal External
1 . Steel shoe shank 4. Steel-reinforced tongue of brace at-
2. Long steel spring, if the metatarsal, tachment
phalangeal, and/or interphalangeal 5. Stiff or limited-motion ankle joints
joints are involved 6. SACH heel and rocker bar
3. Steel-reinforcing plate on insole 7. Medial and/or lateral shank filler
Foot Disabilities
Shoe Modifications
I . Steel Shank. A Steel shoe shank of at least 0.05-in. thickness with one
or more corrugated ribs and length, width, placement, and function as
described earlier, is the first prerequisite for proper shoe structure.
2. Long Steel Spring. Immobilization of the interphalangeal and meta-
tarsophalangeal as well as the tarsometatarsal joints can be achieved by sand-
wiching a long steel spring into the shoe, which prevents dorsiflexion. Like
the solid steel shank, the steel spring should be at least 0.05-in. thick and at
least l-in. wide. I t should be made of spring steel and sandwiched be-
tween the insole and the outsole. The long steel spring should extend from
a point 3/8 in. posterior to the insole rib at the toe end to a point approxi-
mately f/2 in. anterior to the lasted upper edge at the heel. The heel-to-toe
extension of the long steel spring prevents any dorsiflexion or plantar flexion
from occurring at the break of the shoe. T o increase the rocker action
in rollover, the steel spring can be made slightly convex, and this internal
curvature will lead to a more normal gait
- pattern.
-
The spring can most conveniently be installed when resoling of the out-
sole is necessary, otherwise, the shoemaker must open enough stitches between
the welt and sole at the toe, or at the posterior quarter-to-sole joint where
Bulletin of Prosthetics Research-Fall 1964
After the arch support is checked for proper length, the metatarsal pad is
checked for proper positioning (see section on metatarsal pad).
Forefoot Extension. To provide an insole filler to prevent anterior shift
of the arch support during wear, a forefoot extension piece can be made
of a thinned or split-belly center leather or equivalent material for the pur-
pose. If the metatarsophalangeal and interphalangeal joint plantar sur-
faces are calloused, scarred, or sensitive, then a soft foam or sponge rubber
surface is indicated. Soft forefoot pieces should generally be about 1/8 in.
thick and covered with thin skin leather or vinyl sheeting for smoothness
and comfort.
Such forefoot pieces can be spliced and cemented to the commercially
available prefabricated or semiprefabricated arch supports. If the orthotist
makes a wrap cast or shoe last of the patient, the forefoot, midfoot, and
"hindfoot" piece are in one unit, a type of inlay that provides truest con-
formity to the entire plantar surface of the foot; the inlay also includes the
features that have been installed to relieve, support, or elevate specific areas.
Heel pads. Heel cushions or pads can be added to any type arch support
to relieve sensitive plantar surfaces of the calcaneus or to relieve pressure
from a calcaneal spur. The sensitive plantar surface usually can be relieved
by a sponge-rubber pad shaped to fit the heel area of the shoe insole, with
feathering toward the midfoot area.' The calcaneal spur can be relieved
with a similar pad that has a concavity cut to fit directly beneath the spur.
T o prevent tilting the calcaneus anteriorly, heel pads or cushions should
be used with longitudinal arch supports.
Fitting Arch Support to Shoe
In fitting the arch support to the shoe, the orthotist must place the sup-
port in the shoe so that its heel edge rests against the distal posterior aspect
of the quarter lining of the shoe (Fig. 27b). This position must be main-
tained to insure replication of the conformity achieved during the support-
to-foot fitting phase; otherwise, even a slight anterior shift of the arch sup-
port may introduce pain.
There are fitting difficulties that result from poor last and upper styles.
Many times a completed arch support has to be thinned out or lengthened
to relieve pressure from a tight shoe or widened and thickened to fill up a
loosely fitted shoe. Since a metatarsal pad causes some spread and abduction
of the toes, a straight inner-border last rather than a pointed-toe shoe should
be selected. A blucher-style upper should be used when a metatarsal
arch support is necessary or the patient will find his shoe tight across the
lower instep (Fig. 27c).
Fabrication Methods
Methods of fabricating arch supports include (1) molding, (2) pressing,
and ( 3) hammering.
Bulletin of Prosthetics Research-Fall 1964
FIGURE27. Arch supports. ( a ) Fitting of arch support to foot; dotted line in-
dicates metatarsal pad placement; (b) fitting of arch support to foot in shoe; ( c )
wafer-type medial longitudinal arch support in shoe; ( d ) dorsal view of wafer sup-
port; ( e ) medial cutaway of wafer support showing wafer inserts.
HEEL ELEVATION
SUMMARY
Taloscaphoid, calcaneocuboid joints .............................. Long steel spring and high- Medial and lateral shank fillers,
(Chopart's). quarter uppers with rein- a rocker bar, and a SACH
forced sides. heel.
-
Subtalar, talocrural joints. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . High-quarter
uppers with re- SACH heel.
inforced sides.
Bursitis. .............................. Full-length innermold. ......... Long steel spring. ........... Metatarsal bar or rocker bar.
Calcaneal spur or pressure-sensitive heel Longitudinal arch support and . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . SACH heel.
tissue. heel cushion.
Equinus, iixed. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Heel elevation. ............... Cork heel elevation and heel- Rocker bar.
base elevation of other shoe.
Fractures, exostosis, hallux rigidus, or mal- Full-length innermold. ......... Long steel spring. ........... Rocker bar.
union.
-
Hallux valgus . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Full-length innermold.
Leg shortening. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Heel elevation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Cork heel elevation or heel- Rocker bar.
base elevator.
Metatarsal bone, shortening of the first. . Elevator support for hallux and
first metatarsal.
-
Pes planus:
Laterally. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Long
counter on lateral side; Reversed orthopedic heel.
lateral heel wedge; cookie or
scaphoid pad.
Medially . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Cookie or scaphoid pad and Orthopedic heel wedge. ..... Orthopedic heel.
longitudinal arch support.
Valgus, flaccid. ....................... Cookie or scaphoid pad; long Orthopedic heel; medial sole-
counter on medial side. and-heel wedge.
9
The severity of the foot disability determines the need of a single component or a combination of components. The modifications listed
P
in this table are those most commonly used with stock shoes, or stock shoes with orthopedic features. When two or more similar types are indi-
cated, the orthotist selects the modification most appropriate for his patient.
Zamosky: Shoe Modifications
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
For valuable information on the anatomy and biomechanics of the foot,
zs well as for constructive review of the entire paper, the author is deeply
indebted to Gabriel Rosenkranz, M.D., and C. F. Mueller, M.D., VA
Medical Consultants. Illustrations are the work of John Beagles of the
Testing and Development Laboratory of the VA Prosthetics Center.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
LEWIN,PHILIP: The Foot and the Ankle. Lea and Febiger, Philadelphia, 1940.
LOWMAN,C. L.: The Rocker Soled Shoe. Orthopedic and Prosthetic Appliance
J., 37-40, Dec. 1959.
MCILMURRAY, W. and GREENBAUM, W.: The Application of SACH Foot Principles
to Orthotics. Orthopedic and Prosthetic Appliance J., Dec. 1959.
MORTON, D. J. and FULLER, D. D.: Human Locomotion and Body Form. Williams
and Wilkins Co., Baltimore, 1952.
SCHUSTER, 0. F.: Foot Orthopaedics. Marbridge Printing Co., New York, 1927.
T H E AMERICAN ACADEMYOF ORTHOPAEDIC SURGEONS: Orthopedic Appliances
Atlas. Vol. 1 . Braces, Splints, Shoe Alterations. Ann Arbor, J. W. Edwards.
1952.
WHITMAN R.: Orthopaedic Surgery. Lea and Febiger, Philadelphia, 1919.
ZAMOSKY,I.: Arch Supports. Intra-VA Prosthetic Clerk Supervisor Course, VA
Prosthetics Center, New York.