Reading skills
Analysis and Evaluation
Drawing out inferences, understanding implications, developing significance, and examining other
points of view from a text, whether it's fiction or non-fiction, requires critical reading and thinking
skills. Here's a step-by-step guide to help you with this process:
Active Reading:
Start by reading the text attentively. Take your time and make sure you understand the basic content
and context of the text.
Identify the Main Idea:
Determine the main idea or thesis of the text. What is the author trying to convey or argue for? This
is crucial for understanding the context.
Recognize Supporting Evidence:
Identify the evidence and arguments the author uses to support their main idea. These are often
found in the form of examples, statistics, anecdotes, or quotes.
Infer Implicit Information:
Look for information that the author implies but doesn't explicitly state. This includes implied
assumptions, conclusions, or emotions.
Example 1 - Short Story:
Text: "She gazed at the abandoned puppy, tears welling up in her eyes."
Implicit Information: The author implies that the character is feeling sadness or compassion toward
the puppy. The reader can infer that the character might be considering adopting or helping the
puppy.
Example 2 - News Headline:
Headline: "Company Reports Record Profits, CEO Celebrates."
Implicit Information: The headline implies that the CEO is pleased with the record profits. The reader
can infer that the CEO is likely proud of the company's success.
Example 3 - Dialogue:
Conversation:
Person A: "I didn't get the job."
Person B: "Don't worry; you'll find something better."
Implicit Information: Person B implies that they believe the job wasn't suitable or fulfilling for Person
A. The reader can infer that Person B is trying to provide reassurance and encouragement.
Example 4 - Poem:
Text: "The autumn leaves fell, covering the ground in a golden blanket."
Implicit Information: The poet implies a sense of beauty and transformation in the falling leaves. The
reader can infer that the change of seasons is seen as a picturesque and natural process.
Example 5 - Essay:
Text: "The city's traffic congestion has reached critical levels."
Implicit Information: The author implies that the traffic congestion is a significant problem for the
city. The reader can infer that this problem may have multiple negative consequences, such as
increased commute times and air pollution.
Consider the Implications:
Think about the implications of the author's argument or narrative. What might happen if the
author's claims are true or if the events in the story continue along the same trajectory?
Example 1 - Argument: The author argues that the government should increase funding for public
schools.
Implication: One implication of this argument is that increased funding could lead to better
educational resources, which, in turn, might improve the quality of education for students. Another
implication is that without increased funding, schools may continue to struggle, potentially leading
to a decline in educational outcomes.
Example 2 - Narrative: In a fictional story, the author describes a character who consistently lies.
Implication: One implication of the character's habitual lying could be that they might face
consequences or challenges in their relationships and personal life due to a lack of trust. Another
implication is that their lies may eventually catch up with them, leading to a significant turning point
in the story.
Example 3 - Argument: The author argues that the use of renewable energy sources is essential for
addressing climate change.
Implication: An implication of this argument is that a transition to renewable energy sources could
reduce greenhouse gas emissions and slow down the pace of climate change. Conversely, if society
continues to rely on non-renewable energy sources, the environmental consequences may worsen.
Example 4 - Narrative: In a science fiction story, the author depicts a world where advanced AI
technology controls every aspect of daily life.
Implication: One implication of this narrative is that reliance on AI for everything could lead to loss of
personal freedom and privacy. Additionally, it might create a dystopian society where humans are
disempowered and technology holds all the power.
Example 5 - Argument: The author argues that a particular healthcare policy should be implemented
to provide universal access to healthcare.
Implication: An implication of this argument is that universal healthcare may lead to improved
overall health outcomes for the population and reduced healthcare-related financial burdens. On the
other hand, implementing such a policy could have financial and logistical implications for the
healthcare system and the government budget.
Examine the Author's Perspective:
Reflect on the author's point of view, values, biases, and goals. Consider how these factors might
influence the text.
Example 1 - Author's Perspective:
Text: An article arguing for stricter environmental regulations.
Author's Perspective: The author is an environmental scientist.
Analysis: Knowing the author's perspective helps us understand that they likely have a deep
understanding of environmental issues and a strong motivation to protect the environment. This
informs the author's support for stricter regulations.
Example 2 - Author's Values:
Text: A novel where the main character sacrifices their own happiness to help others.
Author's Values: The author believes in the importance of selflessness and altruism.
Analysis: The author's values are reflected in the actions and decisions of the protagonist,
emphasizing the theme of selflessness in the narrative.
Example 3 - Author's Biases:
Text: An op-ed on a controversial political issue.
Author's Biases: The author has a strong political bias toward one side of the issue.
Analysis: Recognizing the author's bias helps readers understand that the article may present a one-
sided view of the issue, potentially omitting or downplaying opposing arguments.
Example 4 - Author's Goals:
Text: A product review for a popular gadget.
Author's Goals: The author is affiliated with a tech company that manufactures a competing product.
Analysis: The author's affiliation suggests a potential conflict of interest and a goal to promote their
product while downplaying the features of the gadget they are reviewing.
Example 5 - Author's Historical Perspective:
Text: A history textbook discussing a particular event in the past.
Author's Historical Perspective: The author is from the country where the event occurred.
Analysis: The author's nationality may influence their interpretation of the historical event,
potentially emphasizing certain aspects or viewpoints based on their cultural background.
Identify and Analyze Literary Devices (For Fiction):
In fiction, authors often use literary devices like symbolism, foreshadowing, irony, and metaphors to
convey deeper meanings. Identify and analyze these elements to draw out inferences and
significance.
Symbolism:
Text: In "To Kill a Mockingbird," a mockingbird is a symbol of innocence and moral goodness.
Analysis: The mockingbird represents characters like Tom Robinson and Boo Radley, who are unjustly
harmed by society, emphasizing the loss of innocence and the moral consequences of prejudice.
Foreshadowing:
Text: In "Romeo and Juliet," the prologue hints at the tragic fate of the titular characters.
Analysis: The prologue's foreshadowing sets the tone for the entire play, alerting the audience to the
impending tragedy and creating suspense.
Irony:
Text: In "The Gift of the Magi," a poor couple sacrifices their most prized possessions to buy gifts for
each other, only to find that the gifts are no longer useful.
Analysis: The irony lies in their selfless acts, which result in bittersweet humor and a poignant
commentary on the nature of love and sacrifice.
Metaphor:
Text: In "Animal Farm," the farm animals' rebellion against the humans is a metaphor for the Russian
Revolution and the rise of communism.
Analysis: The use of animals as metaphors allows the author to explore complex political and social
themes in a more accessible and allegorical way.
Personification:
Text: In "The Wind in the Willows," the river is personified as a wise and serene character.
Analysis: Personifying the river adds a deeper, almost spiritual dimension to the story, emphasizing
the connection between nature and human experiences.
Allusion:
Text: In "The Great Gatsby," the green light at the end of Daisy's dock alludes to the American Dream.
Analysis: The allusion to the American Dream connects Gatsby's longing and ambition to a larger
cultural and historical context, adding depth to the story.
Simile:
Text: In "The Road," the author describes the ash-covered landscape as "like the end of the world."
Analysis: This simile helps the reader envision the post-apocalyptic setting and emphasizes the
bleakness and despair of the story's world.
Allegory:
Text: "The Chronicles of Narnia" series by C.S. Lewis is an allegory of Christian theology and morality.
Analysis: The entire series serves as an allegorical exploration of Christian themes, using a fantastical
world and characters to convey deeper religious and moral meanings.
Relate to Personal Experience:
Think about how the text relates to your personal experiences, beliefs, or knowledge. This can help
you make connections and draw out inferences.
Consider Other Perspectives:
Imagine how people with different backgrounds, beliefs, or experiences might interpret the text.
What might they agree or disagree with, and why?
Example 1 - A Political Speech:
Text: A political speech advocating for stricter immigration policies.
Consider Other Perspectives:
A liberal-leaning person might disagree with the speech, emphasizing the importance of immigration
as a source of cultural diversity and economic growth.
A conservative-leaning person might agree with the speech, focusing on the need to protect national
security and uphold the rule of law.
An immigrant or refugee may interpret the speech with fear or concern about their own situation,
seeing it as potentially threatening to their well-being.
Example 2 - A Classic Novel:
Text: "Pride and Prejudice" by Jane Austen.
Consider Other Perspectives:
A feminist reader may highlight the challenges faced by women in the 19th century and the
importance of Elizabeth Bennet's independence.
A traditionalist may appreciate the novel's portrayal of societal norms and values.
A modern reader may view the story through the lens of social class and inequality.
Example 3 - A Scientific Research Paper:
Text: A research paper on climate change.
Consider Other Perspectives:
An environmental scientist may agree with the findings and emphasize the urgency of climate action.
A climate change skeptic may disagree with the paper's conclusions and question the methodology.
A policymaker may consider the paper when drafting environmental legislation, focusing on the
potential impact on the economy and industry.
Example 4 - A Cultural Document:
Text: A religious text, such as the Bible or the Quran.
Consider Other Perspectives:
A devout follower interprets the text as divine guidance and moral principles.
A secular humanist may view it as a historical and literary document.
A scholar might analyze the text for its cultural and historical context.
Example 5 - A Historical Account:
Text: A historical account of a significant event, such as the American Civil War.
Consider Other Perspectives:
A Southern American may have a different interpretation of the Civil War compared to a Northern
American.
A historian from another country might view it within a global context.
An African American may see the war's implications for the abolition of slavery.
Summarize and Synthesize:
After you've thoroughly read and analyzed the text, summarize its main points and your key
inferences. Try to synthesize your understanding of the text's significance.
Example 1 - News Article:
Text: A news article about a recent natural disaster.
Summary: The article reports on a devastating earthquake that struck a coastal town, resulting in loss
of life, property damage, and the need for emergency relief efforts.
Synthesis: The earthquake's impact underscores the vulnerability of coastal communities to natural
disasters and highlights the importance of disaster preparedness and humanitarian response.
Example 2 - Short Story:
Text: A short story about a struggling artist finding inspiration in unlikely places.
Summary: The story follows an artist who, through a chance encounter with a street performer,
discovers a new perspective on life and regains artistic inspiration.
Synthesis: The narrative emphasizes the transformative power of unexpected connections and the
ability of art to transcend life's challenges.
Example 3 - Academic Research Paper:
Text: An academic paper on the effects of social media on mental health.
Summary: The paper presents findings indicating a strong correlation between excessive social
media use and increased levels of anxiety and depression in young adults.
Synthesis: The research highlights the need for responsible social media usage, especially among
younger generations, to mitigate potential negative impacts on mental health.
Example 4 - Self-Help Book:
Text: A self-help book on achieving personal goals and overcoming obstacles.
Summary: The book offers practical advice on setting achievable goals, building resilience, and
maintaining motivation.
Synthesis: The book's guidance encourages readers to take proactive steps in their lives, fostering
personal growth and success.
Example 5 - Opinion Piece:
Text: An opinion piece on the importance of renewable energy adoption.
Summary: The author argues that transitioning to renewable energy sources is crucial for mitigating
climate change and reducing environmental impact.
Synthesis: The piece underlines the urgency of transitioning away from fossil fuels, emphasizing the
long-term benefits for the planet and future generations.
__________________________________________________________________________________
