Module 5 (R&S)
Module 5 (R&S)
Testing is the practice of administering written, oral or other tests as a means of determining
the suitability or desirability of a job applicant. He premises is that is scores on a test
correlate with job performance, and then it is economically useful for the employer to select
employees based on scores from that test.
According to Lee J. Groonbach “A test is a systematic procedure for comparing the behaviour of two
or more persons”.
Milton M. Blum has defined test as “a sample of an aspect of an individual’s behaviour, performance
and attitude”.
Pre-employment tests are used to screen job applicants and can include testing of cognitive
abilities, knowledge, work skills, physical and motor abilities, personality, emotional
intelligence, language proficiency, and even integrity. Drug testing can also be utilized as
part of the pre- employment process.
The following tests are generally conducted to test the aptitude and intelligence of
candidates:
An ability test is a test to check an individual's ability to perform a certain kind of job. It
usually tests the individual for certain skills or whether he is capable of acquiring those skills
Also called as ‘ACHIEVEMENT TESTS’. ―Tests of verbal and numerical ability, with
questions on vocabulary, similarities, opposites, arithmetical calculations, etc. are referred to
as intelligence tests.‖ A questionnaire is prepared with objective type questions evaluated
through computers.
Knowledge and proficiency in language (English or Hindi) can also be tested through ability
tests. People who score high on these tests have the ability to absorb, interpret and analyze
business information quickly and perform well at work.
Intelligence tests usually represent the candidate’s Intelligence Quotient (IQ) which can
be numerically expressed as follows:
IQ represents the mental ability of a person, with reference to his age. Higher the IQ, higher
is the ability of the person to perform well on the job. If the organisation has employees with
high IQ, it facilitates the training and learning process. These tests are conducted individually
for each job activity as a particular test may be valid for a particular job activity only.
Intelligence is often measured with individually administered tests like the Stanford-Binet
Test or the Wechsler Test. Employers can administer other IQ tests such as the Wonderlic
to groups of people. Other intelligence tests include the Kaufman Adolescent and Adult
Intelligence Test, the Slosson Intelligence Test, the Wide Range Intelligence Test, and
the Comprehensive Test of Nonverbal Intelligence.
a) Clerical Ability Test: It is a paper-and-pencil clerical test assessing clerical speed and
accuracy. It is a 50-item test with a 30-minute time limit. Clerical Ability tests are part of the
selection process in jobs such as: clerks, receptionists, secretaries and more.
b) Mechanical Ability Test: The test of Mechanical Comprehension tests the applicant
understands of basic mechanical principles. It may reflect a person‘s aptitude for jobs—like
that of machinist or engineer—that require mechanical comprehension. Other tests of
mechanical aptitude include the Mechanical Reasoning Test and the SRA Test of Mechanical
Aptitude. The revised Minnesota Paper Form Board Test consists of 64 two- dimensional
diagrams cut into separate pieces. It provides insights into an applicant‘s mechanical spatial
ability; you‘d use it for screening applicants for jobs such as designers, drafts people, or
engineers.
c) Mental Ability Test: Cognitive (Mental) tests include tests of general reasoning ability
(intelligence) and tests of specific mental abilities like memory and inductive reasoning.
d) Specific Cognitive Abilities: There are also measures of specific mental abilities, such as
inductive and deductive reasoning, verbal comprehension, memory, and numerical ability.
Psychologists often call such tests aptitude tests, since they purport to measure aptitude for
the job in question.
e) Physical Ability Test: Physical abilities tests measure muscular strength, cardiovascular
endurance, and movement quality. An example of a test that requires all three again comes
from the city of Columbus. The test mimics carrying firefighting equipment (e.g., hose, fan,
oxygen tanks) up flights of stairs in a building. Equipment must be brought up and down the
stairs as quickly as possible in the test. The equipment is heavy, so muscular strength is
required. The climb is taxing under limited breathing, so cardiovascular endurance is
necessary. The trips up and around the flights of stairs, in full gear, require high degrees of
flexibility and balance. Some have argued that such tests are the single most effective means
of reducing workplace injuries.
Physical abilities tests are becoming increasingly common to screen out individuals
susceptible to repetitive stress injuries, such as carpal tunnel syndrome. Another reason to use
physical abilities tests for appropriate jobs is to avoid injuries on the job. Well-designed tests
will screen out applicants who have applied for positions that are poorly suited to their
physical abilities. Thus, fewer injuries should result.
Tests of physical abilities include static strength (such as lifting weights), dynamic
strength (like pull-ups), body coordination (as in jumping rope), and stamina.
Lifeguards, for example, must show they can swim a course before they’re hired.
2. Aptitude tests:
These tests judge the aptitude of a person to accept future jobs. They explore a person‘s
potential to perform present and potential organizational tasks. People differ in their ability to
do certain tasks and aptitude tests measure this ability to explore their potential to work.
―Aptitude tests can measure specific abilities or aptitudes (for example, spatial ability,
manual dexterity, numerical ability, verbal ability) and are used to gauge the person‘s
potential.‖ Every individual differs in his ability to perform organizational tasks and,
therefore, these tests enable the manager to know the skills and competence of the candidates
to work on the job.
Mechanical aptitude tests: They measure the ability of a person to learn a particular type
of mechanical work. These tests helps to measure specialized technical knowledge and
problem solving abilities if the candidate.
3. Personality tests:
4. Performance tests:
These are on-the-job tests. The candidates perform the job for which they are being
considered. They are also known as ―in-tray‖ tests as candidates work on a representative
sample of the work. The data entry operator, for example, may be asked to type a page to
judge his proficiency in typing. Though these tests are costly, they help in selecting the most
suitable candidate for the job.
They measure the candidate‘s competence in terms of accuracy and efficiency to carry out the
specific tasks. However, since these tests are based on simulation (created work
environment), certain factors and information that would be actually present on the job but
are missing in the simulation models, may negatively affect the performance of the
candidates.
5. Psychomotor Test
Psychomotor or skills tests: They are those, which measure a person‘s ability to do a
specific job. Such tests are conducted in respect of semi- skilled and repetitive jobs such as
packing, testing and inspection, etc.
Psychomotor Test are used for determining the precision, coordination, control, dexterity and
reaction time for candidates in the hiring process. It not only assesses the mechanical
performance of the candidate but also their ability to understand and follow instructions and
perform motor responses.
This kind of tests is widely used for deciding the best candidate for surgeons or pilots etc.
The test measures the candidate‘s reaction time, multitasking capacity and coordinating
abilities. The evaluator
rates the candidate‘s performance against a predefined benchmark. This is standardized for
all applicants.
Example:
In a manufacturing facility, a candidate is placed in a high speed assembly line. They are
asked to perform a task for a certain time period. This gives the employer an idea of the
efficiency and fastness of the employee.
Interest Test: This is conducted to find out likes and dislikes of candidates towards
occupations, hobbies, etc. such tests indicate which occupations are more in line with a
person‘s interest.
Recruiters report that over 50% of job applicants do not meet the basic qualifications. Each
job requires a unique skill set and personality type. To help ensure that your job applicants
1. Validity
Though many assessments are well-endorsed and reputable, not all tests are accurate
indicators of the traits they claim to measure or of future job performance. Employers need to
be able to demonstrate that the test‘s results accurately correspond to job performance before
making it a determining factor in hiring.
2. Consistency
Pre-employment tests are not always reliable and consistent measures of a given skill. If a test
is reliable, a candidate who takes the test today will receive roughly the same score if they
take it a week from now. When tests are inconsistent, they cease to be valid measures of
future job performance. Each test should be proven for reliability before it is implemented.
(b) Tests are not always suitable measures of selection. A candidate may spoil his test but
may still be suitable for the job.
The Big Five are a reduced set of many more specific traits.
The Big Five are very stable over time, and there is even research to suggest a strong genetic
basis of the Big Five traits (roughly 50% of the variance in the Big Five traits appears to be
inherited). Because job performance is a broad concept that comprises many specific
behaviors, it will be best predicted by broad dispositions such as the Big Five. In fact, some
research evidence supports this proposition. Measures of personality traits can be surveys,
projective techniques, or interviews. Most personality measures used in personnel selection
are surveys. There are several survey measures of the Big Five traits that are used in
selection.
The Personal Characteristics Inventory (PCI), is a self-report measure of the Big Five that
asks applicants to report their agreement or disagreement (using a ―strongly disagree‖ to
―strongly agree‖ scale) with 150 sentences. The measure takes about 30 minutes to complete
and has a 5th- to 6th-grade reading level.
Another commonly used measure of the Big Five is the NEO Personality Inventory (NEO),
of which there are several versions that have been translated into numerous languages
A third alternative is the Hogan Personality Inventory (HPI), which also is based on the
Big Five typology. Responses to the HPI can be scored to yield measures of employee
reliability and service orientation. All three of these measures have shown validity in
predicting job performance in various occupations.
Many comprehensive reviews of the validity of personality tests have been published. Nearly
all of the recent reviews focus on the validity of the Big Five. Although there has been a
debate over inconsistencies in these studies, the largest scale study revealed the following:
1. Conscientiousness predicts performance across all occupational groupings.
2. Emotional stability predicts performance in most occupations, especially sales,
management and teaching.
3. Extraversion predicts performance of salespeople.
Job simulations
Job simulations can take many different forms, such as in-person assignments, online
exams, take-home assignments, role-playing, presentations or even virtual simulations.
In-basket exercises: “Here, the candidate is required to complete certain tasks such
as responding to emails, taking phone calls and handling grievances within a set
amount of time. Often, these exercises are best for administrative and managerial
positions.”
Group exercises at assessment centres are measuring your ability to work in a team,
contribute, delegate, and solve problems. Assessors are looking for candidates who can
listen to other people's ideas, be positive, and articulate their own ideas.
Here are the most common activities that occur during a group interview:
General interview questions.
Case studies.
Practical tasks.
Role-playing exercises.
Group presentations.
History of Testing in Occupational Selection:
PSYCHOMETRICS TEST:
Psychometric tests are assessment tools used to objectively measure an individuals
personality traits, aptitude, intelligence, abilities and behavioral style.
Psychometric assessments are widely used in career guidance and employment to match a
persons abilities and personality to a suitable career or role.
A psychometric test is designed to measure cognitive ability and indicates the potential of
a candidate to excel in a specific position or career.
PERSONALITY ASSESSMENT
Personality Assessment is a proficiency in professional psychology that involves the
administration, scoring, and interpretation of empirically supported measures of personality
traits and styles in order to:
Refine clinical diagnoses;
Structure and inform psychological interventions; and
Increase the accuracy of behavioral prediction in a variety of contexts and settings
(e.g., clinical, forensic, organizational, educational).
Low
Dislikes structure and schedules
Makes messes and doesn't take care of things
Fails to return things or put them back where they belong
Procrastinates important tasks
Fails to complete necessary or assigned tasks
Extraversion
People who are low in extraversion (or introverted) tend to be more reserved and have less
energy to expend in social settings. Social events can feel draining and introverts often
require a period of solitude and quiet in order to "recharge."
High
Enjoys being the center of attention
Likes to start conversations
Enjoys meeting new people
Has a wide social circle of friends and acquaintances
Finds it easy to make new friends
Feels energized when around other people
Say things before thinking about them
Low
Prefers solitude
Feels exhausted when having to socialize a lot
Finds it difficult to start conversations
Agreeableness
This personality dimension includes attributes such as trust, altruism, kindness, affection, and
other prosocial behaviors.People who are high in agreeableness tend to be more cooperative
while those low in this trait tend to be more competitive and sometimes even manipulative.
High
Neuroticism
High
Experiences a lot of stress
Worries about many different things
Gets upset easily
Experiences dramatic shifts in mood
Feels anxious
Struggles to bounce back after stressful events
Low
Emotionally stable
Deals well with stress
Rarely feels sad or depressed
Doesn't worry much
Is very relaxed
The Birkman Method reveals four key perspectives of every person: Motivation, Self-
Perception, Social Perception, and Mindset. In understanding these perceptions and
how they influence each other, individuals can better understand the emotions and actions
that drive their life.
Motivation:
Birkman’s data on Motivation measures passion and interest for different roles and
initiatives in the workplace, and is described through the Birkman Interests.
This aspect of The Birkman Method measures broad interest themes that are
characteristic of many occupations. Birkman Interests provide awareness into the
activities that foster greater engagement and enjoyment and those which can drain
one’s energy and result in fatigue.
Motivation is a critical factor in finding a fulfilling career path, being engaged in the
workplace, and ensuring long-term workplace satisfaction.
Self-Perception
Self-Perception reveals how we see ourselves and drives much of how we show up
in the world around us.
It’s driven largely by how we have learned to use certain styles to get positive results
in past situations.
We report this as Usual Behavior, and what is measured on the assessment is typically
how a person feels they approach tasks, manage relationships, and contribute to their
community.
Social Perception
Social Perception is an individual’s underlying context or filter used to determine if a
current situation or environment feels comfortable for the individual. Because
this is a measure of an internal state, it is not always apparent to others how someone
will act (or react) when circumstances change.
Reported as Needs, this information allows a person to anticipate their reaction to new
or changing situations in their lives, and thus avoiding the resulting Stress Behavior
that might result if they do not manage these expectations. These Needs and
expectations are an invisible driving force behind an individual’s behavior.
Social Perception
Social Perception is an individual’s underlying context or filter used to determine if a
current situation or environment feels comfortable for the individual. Because
this is a measure of an internal state, it is not always apparent to others how someone
will act (or react) when circumstances change.
Reported as Needs, this information allows a person to anticipate their reaction to new
or changing situations in their lives, and thus avoiding the resulting Stress Behavior
Mindset:
Birkman Mindset data provides insights into an individual’s belief system concerning
themselves and others.
Birkman addresses specific aspects of Mindset that address interpersonal,
intrapersonal, and work alignment of individuals. On a macro-level, these meta-scales
allow individuals to see new ways of thinking and confront the pros and cons of their
perspectives.
These perspectives dive deep into an individual’s subconscious and help explain
the why behind one’s actions and behavior patterns.
Four colors are used to depict individual styles and fundamental differences between
people:
Red = Doer
Doers are action-focused. They enjoy hands-on work, project management and solving
practical problems. However, doers can sometimes be aggressive or hard to reason with if
their needs are not met.
Green = Communicator
Communicators enjoy working with people. They excel at selling, pitching, counseling,
teaching and other vocations which require working with people. Communicators often have
a natural confidence and make friends easily. They often need praise to excel and can appear
argumentative if their needs are not met.
The circle (needs) and square (stress behavior) fall within the blue quadrant (thinker).
Therefore, this person may find problems difficult to cope with and could require extra
support from the people around them.
The diamond (usual behavior) falls within the yellow quadrant (analyzer). Therefore, this
person’s behavior is task-oriented and they tend to be more introverted in their approach.
2. Areas of Interest
The Birkman Basics Report also scores you based on your interests. High scores indicate
things you enjoy and low scores vice versa. Your interests may translate to actual skills or
they may just represent things that motivate you (and in turn make you a more productive
employee). For example, if you score 75% in literary interests, you probably enjoy reading
and writing.
In this section, your results are compared to employees working across 22 job families. The
report then suggests the job families you may be best suited to and also specific job titles. For
example, if you are suited to a construction and extraction occupation, you may enjoy a
career as an electrician.
This section is more suited to individuals who take the test to explore potential careers, rather
than employers during their hiring process.
We all want to feel engaged and satisfied with our jobs and the Birkman test is designed to
ensure you find the perfect fit for your personality.
MYERS-BRIGGS
In developing the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator [instrument], the aim of Isabel Briggs Myers,
and her mother, Katharine Briggs, was to make the insights of type theory accessible to
individuals and groups. They addressed the two related goals in the developments and
application of the MBTI instrument:The identification of basic preferences of each of the four
dichotomies specified or implicit in Jung's theory. The identification and description of the 16
distinctive personality types that result from the interactions among the preferences."
By discovering your needs, you can make better choices for yourself personally and in
your career. If you’re the type of person who thrives on social interaction, you may
want to pursue a career that involves collaboration, team-work, or working with the
public. When you have a better understanding of yourself and what fuels you, you’ll
be more productive and happier. For example, you may discover that “social service”
is your lowest interest. If this is the case, you can stop feeling guilty about not
wanting to volunteer and instead donate a portion of your paycheck.
the Birkman Method also provides the Forer Effect – the descriptions are so
insights on the underlying stress factors vague that they could be about a lot of
and needs of each individual, making it different people
clear what you need to be happy, healthy,
and successful.
they lack information about what you can Birkman makes it easy to understand
do to make yourself more successful or be what changes you need to make and how
the best version of yourself to go about implementing them right
away.
Birkman offers more specific career MBTI type, which aren’t super specific to
recommendations based on your each individual
individual needs, motivators, personality,
and more. Its recommendations are far
more tailored and customized to you.
3. Affection
1. Inclusion is defined by the relationships one prefers to form with others. It explains
the extent of which an individual enjoys or feels an aversion to being involved and
invited by others. It can be the amount of recognition they prefer to receive or
acknowledgement for a job well done or their preference to be invited to an after-hours
work event. This word can also be associated with how much attention a person
prefers to have from others.
2. Control is a word that can often carry a negative connotation, but in reference to the
definition for this assessment, this word has to do with a preference for having an
influence over others. It deals with a person’s preference for making decisions and
amount of responsibility one may want to have. Most people who score high in this
area have a keen power of persuasion and are professional leaders.
3. Affection is a word which is often misunderstood when used in the context of the
FIRO-B. Many believe the definition of this word to mean a felling of love or strong
attachment. However, Schultz used this word to describe individuals interpersonal
need for simple one-on-one relationships. It has to do with the want to know others on
a personal level or how much an individual prefers to share their personal life with
others. It has to do with the warmth of their demeanor and how supportive or
empathetic an individual prefers to be and receive. Most individuals who score high in
this area are known to be open with others, as well as, supportive of other’s needs.
Each area is also modified by two further factors:
Expressed Behavior
Wanted Behavior
In short, Expressed Behavior is related to how comfortable we feel about exhibiting a
behavior toward other people. Wanted behavior, on the other hand, is related to the
level we want other people to exhibit a behavior toward us.
Each category receives a score ranging from 0 to 9. Based on your score, each
section will fall into one of three categories:
0-2 Low
3-6 Medium
7-9 High
In addition to scores and descriptors for each section of the FIRO-B Test, the
FIRO-B Profile will also provide you with overall scores along with descriptive
text based off of your results for:
Inclusion
Control
Affection
Expressed
INTEGRITY/HONESTY TESTS
An integrity test is a specific type of personality test designed to assess an applicant's
tendency to be honest, trustworthy, and dependable.
A lack of integrity is associated with such counterproductive behaviors as theft,
violence, sabotage, disciplinary problems, and absenteeism. Integrity tests have been
found to measure some of the same factors as standard personality tests, particularly
conscientiousness, and perhaps some aspects of emotional stability and agreeableness.
Overt integrity tests (also referred to as clear-purpose tests) are designed to directly
measure attitudes relating to dishonest behavior.
They are distinguished from personality-based tests in that they make no attempt to
disguise the purpose of the assessment.
Overt tests often contain questions that ask directly about the applicant's own
involvement in illegal behavior or wrongdoing (e.g., theft, illicit drug use). Such
transparency can make guessing the correct answer obvious. Applicant faking is
always a concern with overt integrity tests. The score results from such tests should be
interpreted with caution.
Considerations
Integrity tests have been shown to be valid predictors of overall job performance as
well as many counterproductive behaviors such as absenteeism, illicit drug use, and
theft;
GRAPHOLOGY TEST:
It is designed to analyze the handwriting of individual. It has been said that an individual‘s
handwriting can suggest the degree of energy, inhibition and spontaneity, as well as disclose
the idiosyncrasies and elements of balance and control.
Polygraph Test: Polygraph is a lie detector, which is designed to ensure accuracy of the
information given in the applications. Department store, banks, treasury offices and jewelers
shops, that is, those highly vulnerable to theft or swindling may find polygraph tests useful.
Medical Test: It reveals physical fitness of a candidate. With the development of technology,
medical tests have become diversified. Medical servicing helps measure and monitor a
candidate‘s physical resilience upon exposure to hazardous chemicals.
SKILLS ASSESSMENT
Skill assessment tests are the tests created to measure and evaluate candidates' and
employees' skills needed for successful job performance. Skills assessments aren't
focused on measuring knowledge (like job knowledge tests do) or personality traits
(like most of psychometric and personality tests).
How to create a skill assessment in 5 simple steps
Figure out what to test. Skill assessments should be about just that – skills. ...
Case studies
Practical tasks
Role-playing exercises
Group presentations
3. Validity and
4. Reliability.
2) Taking notes
It's virtually impossible to remember everything each candidate tells you during interview -
so take notes as you go. The candidate will expect you to...
3) Building rapport
Numerous surveys have shown that around 50% of candidates generally don't like interviews.
If you take the time to make them feel at ease and relaxed throughout, you will be far more
likely to gain a better understanding of them during the interview stage, and make a better
decision when it comes to the eventual hire.
4) Summarise back
One of the single most powerful interviewing techniques is to repeat anything the candidate
tells you back to them and demonstrate empathy for any emotions they display or describe.
7) Be an ambassador
During the entire interview process you should look to represent your business as well as you
possibly can. The way you handle your interviews will play a critical role in attracting the
best candidates in future.
Perhaps the most important aspect of successful interviewing is knowing what you’re
looking for in a candidate.
Make sure that you have a detailed job description and person specification that sets out what
you really want from the person. Try to avoid jargon. If you haven’t written the particulars
yourself, speak to the person who did and make sure you understand exactly what they
meant.
Read the applications for all the candidates that you will be interviewing.
Ideally, you should score each candidate against the criteria in the person specification.
Scores out of five are usual, where five is excellent and one is ‘does not show this at all’.
If you’re holding a panel interview, the panel needs to meet beforehand and discuss
interview tactics.
Ideally, the interviewers (or panel) should carry out the short-listing for the interview,
comparing the individual members’ scores for each candidate and agreeing on a panel score.
The panel then need to agree what questions should be asked and who is going to ask which
questions, or cover which areas. It’s also helpful to discuss which areas are most important in
case some areas have to be left unexamined.
Finally, the panel needs to agree what a ‘good’ answer to any particular question will look
like, and how far they are prepared to probe to try to obtain one.
When you meet the candidates make eye contact, offer a handshake and smile at them.
Understand that they are probably feeling quite nervous.
Your role, as the interviewer, is not to trip up the candidates. You’re there to find out if they
can do the job or not.
Invite the candidate to sit down, and indicate a chair. It stops them worrying about
what they should do.
One interviewer will generally lead the interview, they should:
Introduce the members of the interview panel and outline the process of the interview.
Explain broadly what the interview is going to cover and who is going to ask
questions. It is also useful to explain what other members of the panel will be doing:
making notes, observing, or perhaps adding supplementary questions.
Start off the process with a simple question such as ‘Tell us what you do in your
current job’.
3. Presentations
If you have asked the candidates to prepare a presentation, start with that.
You can then ask them for more details about aspects of their presentation that you found
either interesting or concerning. Set aside at least 10 minutes for questioning after the
presentation.
Candidates can also be asked to do a written test. It is helpful to have the results of the tests in
front of you during the interview so that you can ask them about anything that emerges.
Asking Questions
Hypothetical Questions
Many interview processes use a candidate presentation to explore this area, for example
asking candidates to present on what they see as the first five issues to be addressed in the job
and how they would go about doing so.
Personal Awareness
These questions are designed to explore the fit between the candidate’s needs and what the
job or organisation can offer. For example, you might ask the candidate to tell you what
motivates them, or what strengths they bring to the job. Good questions of this type ask the
candidate to rank their requirements or strengths. This enables you to assess how personally
aware they are, and also whether you can provide the necessary motivation and/or use their
strengths.
As a general principle, the person asking the questions should focus on the candidate
while they are answering. Watching their body language, and listening carefully to what
they’re saying.
Don’t try to make notes while the candidate is answering the question; you can do that once
they’ve finished. In a panel interview, the other members of the panel should make notes as
the question is being answered, but making sure that they too are listening and aware of the
candidate’s body language.
Each panel member or interviewer should score the candidate on each criterion as the
interview progresses.
You can always amend an earlier assessment, but after 45 minutes you won’t remember the
earlier answers clearly enough to do all the scoring at the end.
For the same reason, the panel should also discuss each candidate immediately after they
have left the room and agree their scores against the criteria.
4. Making A Decision
Your final decision should be based on the scores you have given each candidate.
If, when you get to the end of the process, one or more interviewers feels that the ‘wrong’
candidate has emerged as successful then it’s helpful to examine why this is so. Have you
missed a key job skill? Or was there something that they said which should have resulted in a
lower score?
It’s fine to revisit the process and come up with a different answer, as long as you can justify
it in the event of an appeal by the candidate. At this stage, the role of the independent
assessor, if there is one, is to ensure that the process is fair to all candidates.