ABES ENGINEERING COLLEGE, GHAZIABAD
Department of Electronics & Communication Engineering
Final Year Students Project Evaluation Report
(This report must be completed by the supervisor)
Presentationfor Rubric (R1/R2/R3/R4/R5/R6)
(R5-C1,C2,C3,C4,C5,C6) Session 2023-2024
SECTION 1:PROJECT DETAILS
Group No.:
Title of Project:
Project is based on: Software/Hardware/both-software & Hardware (Please tick appropriate)
Category of the project:Industry based/ Software based / Application based/ IT based /
innovative (for patent) based (Please tick appropriate)
SECTION 2: SUPERVISION
Has the students (group) had the minimum formal supervision of one meeting per
week? YES/NO
Has the student and supervisor maintained project tracker on the supervision? YES/NO
SECTION 3: CONFERENCE/PUBLICATION
Has the student attended any conferences during the year? YES/NO
If YES please give details:
Did the student present a paper? YES/NO
Has the student published/submitted paper for the publication? YES/NO
If YES please give details:
SECTION 4: PROGRESS
Please describe the project progress by writing the appropriate phrase below:
(4-Very good / 3-good / 2-satisfactory / 1-disappointing)
Please comment and indicate the concerned about the student.
Should the student be permitted to give their presentation for the review? YES/NO
(If no, please give the reasons):
Have you any reason, at this stage, to suppose that the student will not submit his/her
project & thesis within the prescribed period of time or the maximum period of study
If so, please give reasons and discuss with the head of the department.
-----------------
Evaluationof the students for the *Rubric based on their respective criteria.
(Project in-charge will fill the criteria marks during the presentation with the consent of Guide)
(4-Very good / 3-good / 2-satisfactory / 1-disappointing)
SN Student Name C1 C2 C3 C4 C5 C6
(MM=4) (MM=4) (MM=4) (MM=4) (MM=4) (MM=4)
Project completion? Yes/No (if no then indicate the % of the project completed):
Report completion? Yes/No (if no then indicate the % of the project completed):
Signature of Principal Supervisor with date Signature of Project In-charge
Signature of Assistant or Co-Supervisor(s) with date:
Any Other Comments if needed:
*Rubrics for B.Tech Final year project
Rub Statement/Purpose No of Sem
ric # criteria
R1 Project proposal evaluation: An ability to propose a project which is relevant to 4
7th
subject of engineering after detailed literature survey and technical feasibility (C1-C4)
R2 Project design: An ability to design the system components and process and identify
3
the engineering tools required with due consideration of assumptions and constraints 7th
(C1-C3)
and societal considerations
R3 First project review: An ability to use management skills and implement the project, 4
8th
manage problems encountered, work as a team and present the work progress (C1-C4)
R4 Final project review and evaluation: An ability to appreciate suggestions made in the
4
first review and manages resources with the constraints and presents the final version 8th
(C1-C4)
of the project.
R5 Project report review: Able to prepare a Project report which is consistent with 6
8th
standard technical report writing procedures. C1-C6)
R6 Review by the Guide: Ability to work as a team and contribute effectively with 3
8th
positive attitude. (C1-C3)
Total 24
Odd Semester First Presentation (R1): Evaluation Criteria
C1: Identification of a project proposal which is relevant to the subject of engineering and its purpose and need.
C2: Literature review
C3: Specifications of project, analysis of technical feasibility, criteria, constraints and assumptions:
C4: Cost analysis: Estimated cost of completing the project
Odd Semester Second Presentation (R2): Evaluation Criteria
C1:Methodology proposed for project design, implementation strategy and engineering tools required
C2:Technical knowledge and awareness about the project
C3:Communication skills (Written, oral and presentation skills)
Even Semester First Presentation (R3): Evaluation Criteria
C1:Review of design methodology used
C2:Project management skills
C3:Demonstration and presentation
C4:Individual and team work
Even Semester Second Presentation (R4): Evaluation Criteria
C1: Incorporation of suggestions
C2:Project Demonstration
C3:Analysis of problems encountered and remedial actions taken
C4: Impact on society and environment
Even Semester Third Presentation (R5): Evaluation Criteria
C1:Organization of report
C2:Figures, formatting, diagrams, graphs, tables and mathematics
C3:Description of concepts and technical details
C4: Discussions and Conclusions
C5: Bibliography
C6:Originality and plagiarism
Even Semester Forth Presentation (R6): Evaluation Criteria
C1:Positive attitude, commitment, team work and contribution
C2:Technical knowledge,awareness related to project
C3:Regularity and attendance
Semester No. of Rubrics No. of criteria Total points of Rubrics MM of Sessional marks
VII 2 7 28
VIII 4 17 68
Final Year Project 6 24 96
