Sanitasi Sekolah Dan Kesehatan Siswa
Sanitasi Sekolah Dan Kesehatan Siswa
                                                                                                           ly
                                                                                 water supply, drinking water supply, rest room, sanitary facilities,
                                                                                 toilet/ latrine, hand washing facilities, cleaning policy, clean and
                                                                                                   on
                                                                                 functional toilet, Water Sanitation and Hygiene Programs, and the
 Correspondence: Anita Dewi Moelyaningrum, Doctoral Program of                   knowledge of sanitation. The effect of health-related school sanita-
 Public Health, Faculty of Public Health, Universitas Airlangga, Kampus          tion was gastrointestinal illness, diarrhea, cholera, dehydration,
                                                                                              e
 C, Jl. Mulyorejo, Surabaya, Jawa Timur, 60115, Indonesia.                       cavities in teeth, undernutrition, stunting, soil-transmitted
 Tel.: +62.315920948- Fax: +62.315924618.
 E-mail: [email protected]
                                                                                      us
                                                                                 helminths, intestinal parasitic infection, toothache, decay missing,
                                                                                 filled permanent teeth status, and health status of students.
                                                                                      Conclusions. School sanitation affected the student health sta-
                                                                                 al
 Key words: health status; school sanitation; students.                          tus, absenteeism at school, and students’ concentration. Sanitation
                                                                                 facilities are suggested to include laws and policies.
                                                                             ci
 Contributions: all authors contributed to the design of the study, draft-            School sanitation is a concern of the global community.
                                                    om
 ing, review, and editing. ADM, builds the idea, presentation, and analy-        Therefore, it is one of the goals in the Sustainable Development
 sis of data; SK, HBN, LS, analyzed the data; SM, FE, build the method.          Goals (SDGs). The SDGs had seventeen goals that should be
 All the authors approved the final version to be published.                     reached in 2030. The vision for drinking water, sanitation, and
                                             -c
sanitation. The pandemic COVID-19 teaches us how the impor-                        Sanitation programs are often tried implementation at schools
tance of school sanitation to support the sustainability of school            to improve the achievement of sanitation. Some research was an
activity, including sanitation facilities. Poor school sanitation is          analysis of school sanitation with intervention. The sanitation pro-
still a problem around the world. There are only three-quarters of            gram is called Fit For School (FIT).9 They tried to analyze the
secondary schools (74%) and two-thirds of primary schools (66%)               implementation of the FIT program, integrating school health and
globally had basic water services in 2019, and only 57% of schools            water, sanitation, and hygiene intervention which had implementa-
had a basic hygiene service, while 25% neither had hand hygiene               tion in the 3 countries, i.e. Indonesia, Cambodia, and Lao PDR.
facilities nor water at the school premises.7                                 The non-randomized clustered controlled trial and follow-up of
     The objective of this research is to identify school sanitation, the     two years in the public elementary schools involved 1847 children.
determinant of disease of school students related to school sanitation,       Another school sanitation program is called School garden.10 The
and the student health status related to school sanitation. It will encour-   programs analyzed intervention programs, including the school
age improvements in school sanitation which can further accelerate            garden, nutrition dan water, sanitation and hygiene (WASH),
the achievement of SDGs goals number 3, 4, and 6 in 2030.                     which involved 682 children aged 8-7 years from two schools ran-
                                                                              domly allocated to one or three interventions.
                                                                                    The school’s sanitation can improve student health. Some
                                                                              research analyses the association between water, sanitation, and
Materials and Methods                                                         hygiene (WASH) services and the health status of basic-level stu-
     The research was primarily based on a literature review.                 dents ranging from sixth to eighth grades. The method we’re using
     The first stage is identification, screening, eligibility and            is the causal-comparative research design. There were two groups
included (Figure 1). Reference books were published, as well as               consisting of 2 schools; each group improved and unimproved
academic articles, books, and websites related to the keywords.               WASH facilities at school. The 768 respondents were analyzed in
Data were found from search engines PubMed, Science Direct and                univariate, bivariate, and multivariate.11 The other research with an
                                                                              analysis of 1,869 schools was conducted in Kampala, Uganda,
                                                                                                    ly
Springer, and google scholar. Boolean technic was used to define
the keywords. The database used for the searching within these                with a cross-sectional design and conducted the cross-sectional
                                                                                            on
documents were School Sanitation, Health, and Students. Data                  survey, which was analyzed with a Poisson regression model to
were found from search engines PubMed, Science Direct,                        identify the factor of water, sanitation, hygiene, and health status
Springer, and Google scholar. The literature review of this search            of students (see Table 1).12
                                                                                      e
was done by the publication range in 2019-2022. The article
should be in full text (n=1.503), and then the language should be             School sanitation
                                                                               us
international and open access. The search data were conducted on                   Basic water is substantial in life. People couldn’t have a decent
8 October 2022, and acquired 7 articles that meet predefined crite-           life without water. Schools should provide water for students all
                                                                         al
ria.                                                                          the time while they are at school. Basic drinking water and water
                                                                              for sanitation are important things to decrease transmitted diseases.
                                                                    ci
Results                                                                       resources, and also the lack of access to sanitation on hygiene and
     Sanitation and hygiene support each other. Hygiene didn’t                health.13
                                                       m
implement without sanitation facilities. School sanitation facilities              The other research showed that said that rinse free handwash-
                                                                              ing, such as using hand rub, hand sanitizer, gel, and foam reduces
                                            om
absenteeism at school, there is a small beneficial effect over tradi-                               water in the school restroom affected students’ condition. The rest-
tional hand washing with running water and soap and also it can be                                  room should be clean every time. The policy of cleaning the sani-
harmful to health and the environment.15-17 Hand washing with                                       tation facilities had an important thing in the sustainability of san-
running water and soap is the best way to control the transmitted                                   itation facilities. The policy had the main role of making the sani-
disease, especially at school. The lack of water is the reason why                                  tation facilities clean. The cleaning policy, which supports sanita-
the students didn’t wash their hands after using the toilet.18                                      tion, was very important. The research showed that undernutrition
    School is the place where students spend a lot of time every                                    was associated with the lack of a school restroom cleaning poli-
day. They interact with friends, objects, and the environment at                                    cy.22 The policy is important to the sustainability of the program
school. The frequency of hand washing is important. Some                                            sanitation.23 Poor planning impacts the sanitary service.24 Many
research showed that hand washing with soap could reduce the dis-                                   factors influence the making of water policy, such as interests,
ease,19 and the frequency of handwashing also correlates with a                                     access to information, habits, and customs.25 Sometimes, the exist-
decrease in the disease.20,21 The water for handwashing should be                                   ing policy is not effective in promoting appropriate sanitation.26
required for the quantity and quality of clean water.                                               School sanitation programs help the sanitation implemented well.
    The restroom was an important facility at school. The lack of                                   Programs should be supported with policy.
Table 1. The school sanitation, disease, and health status relate to school sanitation.
No            Title                                  Author                Population            School sanitation                  Consequence                            Health status
Pubmed
1. Rinse free hand wash for Zachary Munn et al. 30,747 participants Water supply Poor handwashing Students gastrointestinal
                                                                                                                                                 ly
              reducing absenteeism among                                                                                                                                   Illness
              preschool and school children
                                                                                                                                  on
              Science Direct
2.            Diarrhea, malnutrition,                Stephanie             15 public schools,    Water supply                       Poor handwashing                       Diarrhea
              and Dehydration associated             O Sangalang et al.     primary and
                                                                                                                        e
              with school water sanitation                                 secondary
              and Hygiene in metro Manila,
              Philippines: Across sectional study
                                                                           schools students
                                                                                                            us                      Handwashing with soap                  Diarrhea, Cholera
                                                                                                                                    before eating and defecation
                                                                                                 al
                                                                                                                                    Lack of water in the school restroom   Dehydration
                                                                                                 Cleaning policy                    Lack of cleaning policy                Undernutrition
                                                                                                ci
                                                                                                                                    at school restroom
                                                                            er
Springer
              resource-limited setting
4.            Fit for school-based water             Denise                1847 children         Clean and functional                                                      Soil-transmitted
                                                  on
              Cambodia, Indonesia,
              and Lao PDR
                                                                                                 Lack of WaSH                                                              Decay, missing, and Filled
                                                                                                                                                                           Permanent Teeth (DMFT)
5.            Nutritional and health status          Sharesta et al.       682 children          Water, sanitation, hygiene         Intestinal parasitic infection,
              of children 15 months after                                   aged 8-7 years       (WASH) program                                                             parasitic infection, anemia,
              integrated school garden, nutrition,                                                                                                                         stunting, intestinal
              and water interventions:                                                                                                                                      protozoa infection,
              a cluster-randomized                                                                                                                                         soil trans, and mitted
               control trial in Nepal                                                                                                                                       helminth infection
    Google Scholar
6.            Effect of School water                 Sharma et al.         768 students          Water sanitation and sanitary      Improve hand hygiene practice          Health students status
              sanitation and hygiene                                                             hygiene Facilities
              on health status among
              basic level students in Nepal
7             Water, Sanitation and Hygiene          Ssekamate             1,869 school          Safe drinking water and sanitation facilities                              Oral health (cavity, toothache)
               Behaviours and the oral health
              status of school-going adolescent
              boys and young men in
              Kampala Uganda                                                                     Lack of wash                                                              Cavities cause mental health
     Using the randomized controlled trial in 12 schools,10 four         learning at school. The dehydration condition in students makes
schools were compared with a School garden (SG) program which            the immune drop and it increases the risk of disease. Basic drink-
specific education about fruit and vegetable, four schools with SG       ing water is a human right for all, including the students, while
programs coupled with nutrition, health, and WASH intervention,          they do their activities at school.
four schools control. The data showed that the SG and control                Diarrhea, stunting, and undernutrition in the students correlate
increased in parasitic infection, anemia stunting, intestinal proto-     with the number of the rest room and toilets at school.22 School
zoa infection, and soil-transmitted helminth infection. The other        restrooms had many functions. Children who did not wash their
program Fit for Schools in Cambodia, Indonesia, and Lao PDR,             hands with soap and water after using the toilet were likely more
showed that the school-based water, sanitation, and hygiene pro-         exposed to fecal, so the risk of infection increased. The diarrhea
gram could reduce the DMFT index and cavity.9,27                         infection makes students dehydrate and increases the risk of mal-
     There are many factors that influence students when using san-      nutrition, weight loss, and stunted growth; consequences of infec-
itation facilities. The research using the Structural Equation Model     tion include school absence and increased risk of school dropout.
analysis showed that the cleanliness of the toilet is significant for    Student dehydration shouldn’t happen in the students. Dehydration
toilet behavior (path coefficient, 0.81).28 The cleanliness makes it     has many effects. It can cause fatigue 176 (44.78%), lack of focus
comfortable when using the toilet. The toilet is the basic sanitation    171 (43.5%), headache/dizziness 160 (40.71%), lightheadedness
that should be existence at school. Some schools didn’t have an          117 (29.7%), muscle weakness 98 (24.94%), rapid breathing 90
adequate number of toilets and lack of knowledge and awareness           (22.9%), and muscle cramps 64 (16.28%).35
of water towards poor hygiene behavior.29                                    The school restroom had affected the health of students. The
     The qualitative interview with students aged 16-18 years said       prevalence of dehydration among school children is high,36 and
that toilets were dirty, insecure, and unpleasant.30 It makes the stu-   severely dehydrated during a school day,37 even extremely high
dents refrain from drinking during school and it will be affected the    during school time.38 Water consumption among students is low.39
student’s health. Furthermore, students remained constantly jump-        Dehydration impacted students’ cognitive performance.40 At
                                                                                              ly
ing up and down or moving to withhold urine and stool.                   school, dehydration was associated with the lack of water in a
     The school sanitation programs were expected to improve             school restroom, and the risk of diarrhea, stunting, and undernutri-
                                                                                       on
school sanitation. Two articles showed that school program sanita-       tion decreased as the number of school restrooms.22 Other research
tion reduces disease in school students.9,10                             showed that stunting correlates with sanitary facilities and water
     The sustainability of school sanitation programs should be          treatment.41
                                                                                 e
fully supported by the policy. The revamped toilet made the great-           Water was the basic sanitation that should be available all the
est gains in students’ attitudes toward the toilet facilities.31 The
program for operation and maintenance (O&M) in a public school
                                                                          us
                                                                         time for students at schools. Without having water to wash their
                                                                         hands or flush the toilet, students may have been more exposed to
in the Philippines showed that intervention schools had a higher         feces. Consequences of fecal exposure include diarrhea, which can
                                                                    al
percentage of usable toilets and were fully clean than control           cause helminth infection. Other research showed that poor sanita-
schools. It means that the program of school sanitation can stimu-       tion in school might cause helminth infection.42
                                                               ci
late reaching water, sanitation, and hygiene service.32                      The health status of students correlates with school sanitation.
                                                                         The analysis showed that students from unimprovement facilities
                                                    er
Discussion                                                               than a quarter of students had a cavity in their teeth and missed
                                         om
    The student’s disease can cause a lack of school sanitation.         school cause of toothache.12
There were seven articles that showed the correlation between stu-
dent disease and school sanitation. There were gastrointestinal ill-
                                    -c
infection, cavities in students, DMFT index, and health students             The school’s sanitation included water supply, safe drinking
status. Diarrhea correlates with poor hand washing at school in the      water, cleaning policy, toilet function, sanitation and hygiene pro-
students.22 Students not washing their hands in school was signif-       grams, water sanitation and hygiene facilities, which correlate to
                       N
icantly associated with increased odds of diarrhea (OR 1.77, 95%         student health such as students’ gastrointestinal illness, diarrhea,
CI = 1.18 to 2.65). The insecure water increases the incidents of        dehydration, oral health, undernutrition, stunting, soil-transmitted
diarrhea among children.33                                               helminths, parasitic intestinal infection, anemia, cavities, DMFT
    Poor hand washing among students is due to the difficulties in       status.
finding water for washing their hands at schools. The lack of water
at schools makes the students have more diarrhea and increase
absenteeism at school. Diarrhea affects 2.39 billion people global-
ly and caused 1,655,944 deaths in 2016.34 The program of Water,          References
Sanitation, and Hygiene at school (WaSHS) reduces parasitic              1. UNDP. Sustainable Development Goals. The SDGs in Action.
intestinal infection cavities DMFT index.9,10,27 The Sustainability         United Nations Development Programme, https://www.undp.
of school sanitation programs correlated with disease. Dehydration          org/sustainable-development-goals (2022).
is associated with the lack of water in school restrooms.22 Basic        2. Njambi E, Magu D, Masaku J, et al. Prevalence of Intestinal
drinking water also should be provided at school. The measure-              Parasitic Infections and Associated Water, Sanitation, and
ments via urine-specific gravity/urine test strips in the students          Hygiene Risk Factors among School Children in Mwea
showed that dehydration is a condition caused by the loss of too            Irrigation Scheme, Kirinyaga County, Kenya. Epub ahead of
much fluid from the body. It happens when you are losing more               print 2020.
fluids than you are taking in, and your body does not have enough        3. Megatsari H, Laksono AD, Moelyaningrum AD. Diarrhea
fluids to work properly. Students should have good conditions for           Prevalence in East Java, Indonesia: Does Access to Sanitation
      and Health Behavior Ecologically Related? Indian J Forensic            Epub ahead of print 2021.
      Med Toxicol 2021;15:1276-83.                                       20. Haque M. Handwashing in averting infectious diseases:
4.    Bitew BD, Woldu W, Gizaw Z. Childhood diarrheal morbidity              Relevance to COVID-19. J Popul Ther Clin Pharmacol
      and sanitation predictors in a nomadic community. Ital J               2020;27:e37-e52.
      Pediatr 2017;43:91.                                                21. Anderson-Carpenter KD, Tacy GS. Predictors of social dis-
5.    Wolf J, Prüss-Ustün A, Cumming O, et al. Systematic review:            tancing and hand washing among adults in five countries dur-
      Assessing the impact of drinking water and sanitation on diar-         ing COVID-19. PLoS One 2022;17:e0264820.
      rhoeal disease in low- and middle-income settings: Systematic      22. Sangalang SO, Prado NO, Lemence ALG, et al. Diarrhoea,
      review and meta-regression. Trop Med Int Heal 2014;19:928-             malnutrition, and dehydration associated with school water,
      42.                                                                    sanitation, and hygiene in Metro Manila, Philippines: A cross-
6.    Karon AJ, Cronin AA, Cronk R, et al. Improving water, sani-            sectional study. Sci Total Environ 2022;838:155882.
      tation, and hygiene in schools in Indonesia: A cross-sectional     23. Kedia M. Sanitation policy in India–designed to fail? Policy
      assessment on sustaining infrastructural and behavioral inter-         Des Pract 2022;5:307-25.
      ventions. Int J Hyg Environ Health 2017;220:539-50.                24. Kennedy-Walker R, Amezaga JM, Paterson CA. The role of
7.    UNICEF and WHO. Progress on drinking water, sanitation and             power, politics and history in achieving sanitation service pro-
      hygiene in school: special focus on COVID-19, UNICEF.                  vision in informal urban environments: a case study of Lusaka,
8.    Munn Z, Tufanaru C, Lockwood C, et al. Rinse-free hand wash            Zambia. Environ Urban 2015;27:489-504.
      for reducing absenteeism among preschool and school chil-          25. Helga G, Joost D, Paul BJ, et al. Power relations in the co-cre-
      dren. Cochrane Database Syst Rev; 2020. Epub ahead of print            ation of water policy in Bolivia: Beyond the tyranny of partic-
      2020.                                                                  ipation. Water Policy 2022;24:569-87.
9.    Duijster D, Monse B, Dimaisip-Nabuab J, et al. ‘Fit for school’    26. Muia Mutua JK, Agwata JF, Anyango S. Effectiveness of san-
      - a school-based water, sanitation and hygiene programme to            itation policy instruments in Mavoko Municipality of
                                                                                                   ly
      improve child health: Results from a longitudinal study in             Machakos County, Kenya. Cogent Environ Sci 3. Epub ahead
      Cambodia, Indonesia and Lao PDR. BMC Public Health                     of print 2017.
                                                                                           on
      2017;17:1-15.                                                      27. Ssekamatte T, Matovu JK, Ndugwa Kabwama S, et al. Water,
10.   Shrestha A, Schindler C, Odermatt P, et al. Nutritional and            Sanitation and Hygiene Behaviours, and the Oral Health Status
      health status of children 15 months after integrated school gar-       of School-Going Adolescent Boys and Young Men in
                                                                                     e
      den, nutrition, and water, sanitation and hygiene interventions:       Kampala, Uganda. Epub ahead of print 2022.
      A cluster-randomised controlled trial in Nepal. BMC Public
      Health 2020;20:1-19.
                                                                              us
                                                                         28. Shao T, Zhao J, Hu H, et al. Analysis of factors affecting stu-
                                                                             dents going to school toilets in a rural primary school in China.
11.   Sharma MK, Adhikari R. Effect of School Water, Sanitation,             BMC Public Health 2021;21:1-11.
                                                                         al
      and Hygiene on Health Status Among Basic Level Students’ in        29. Ganguly L, Satpati L. Sanitation and hygiene status among
      Nepal. Environ Health Insights; 16. Epub ahead of print 2022.          school students: A micro study on some selective schools of
                                                                   ci
12.   Ssekamatte T, Matovu JKB, Kabwama SN, et al. Water,                    North Dumdum municipality area, West Bengal. Int Res J
      Sanitation and Hygiene Behaviours, and the Oral Health Status          Public Environ Heal 2019;6:127-31.
                                                         er
      of School-Going Adolescent Boys and Young Men in                   30. Norling M, Stenzelius K, Ekman N, et al. High School
      Kampala, Uganda. Epub ahead of print 2022.                             Students’ Experiences in School Toilets or Restrooms. J Sch
                                                        m
13.   Dube B, January J. Factors leading to poor water sanitation            Nurs 2016;32:164-71.
                                              om
      hygiene among primary school going children in Chitungwiza.        31. Senior E. We love our school toilets: involving primary school
      J Pub Health Africa 2012;3:25-8.                                       students in improving their school toilets. Glob Health Promot
14.   Munn Z, Tufanaru C, Lockwood C, et al. Rinse-free hand wash            2014;21:23-8.
                                                                         32. Duijster D, Monse B, Marquez M, et al. Improving Toilet
                                        -c
      and harmful effects: a review. J Egypt Public Health Assoc             ship between water insecurity, hygiene practices, and inci-
      2022;97:6.                                                             dence of diarrhea among children from rural households of the
16.   Mahmood A, Eqan M, Pervez S, et al. Since January 2020                 Menoua Division, West Cameroon. J Public Health Africa; 10.
      Elsevier has created a COVID-19 resource centre with free              Epub ahead of print 2019.
      information in English and Mandarin on the novel coronavirus       34. Troeger C, Forouzanfar M, Rao PC, et al. Estimates of global,
      COVID- 19 . The COVID-19 resource centre is hosted on                  regional, and national morbidity, mortality, and aetiologies of
      Elsevier Connect , the company’s public news and informa-              diarrhoeal diseases: a systematic analysis for the Global
      tion.                                                                  Burden of Disease Study 2015. Lancet Infect Dis 2017;17:909-
17.   Dhama K, Patel SK, Kumar R, et al. The role of disinfectants           48.
      and sanitizers during COVID-19 pandemic: advantages and            35. Shaheen NA, Alqahtani AA, Assiri H, et al. Public knowledge
      deleterious effects on humans and the environment. Environ             of dehydration and fluid intake practices: variation by partici-
      Sci Pollut Res 2021;28:34211-28.                                       pants’ characteristics. BMC Public Health 2018;18:1346.
18.   Ashu EW, Siysi VV, Shey ND. Water , sanitation , and hygiene       36. Rauf S, Lestaluhu SA. The Effects of Water Provision and
      practices in secondary schools in the Buea Health District of          Education on Students ’ Hydration Status , Cognitive Abilities
      Cameroon. J Public Heal Epidemiol 2021;13:254-61.                      , and Fine Motor Function in A Full-Day Primary School.
19.   Beale S, Johnson AM, Zambon M, et al. Hand Hygiene                     2022;16:334-42.
      Practices and the Risk of Human Coronavirus Infections in a        37. Kozioł-Kozakowska A, Piórecka B, Suder A, et al. Body com-
      UK Community Cohort [version 2; peer review: 2 approved].              position and a school day hydration state among polish chil-
    dren—a cross-sectional study. Int J Environ Res Public Health          Their Drinking Behavior. Egypt J Community Med
    2020;17:1-12.                                                          2021;39:94-104.
38. Aphamis G, Stavrinou PS, Andreou E, et al. Hydration status,       41. Torlesse H, Cronin AA, Sebayang SK, et al. Determinants of
    total water intake and subjective feelings of adolescents living       stunting in Indonesian children: Evidence from a cross-sec-
    in a hot environment, during a typical school day. Int J Adolesc       tional survey indicate a prominent role for the water, sanitation
    Med Health 2021;33:1-7.
                                                                           and hygiene sector in stunting reduction. BMC Public Health
39. Ahmeda AF, Al-Ahmadi TF, Alotaibi AF, et al. The awareness
    of water intake and its correlation with BMI among students            2016;16:1-11.
    attending national and international secondary schools in          42. Agustaria G, Fazidah AS, Nurmaini N. The relationship of
    Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. Libyan J Med 2021;16:0-6.                        gender, school sanitation and personal hygiene with helminthi-
40. Ibrahim HS. Effect of Hydration Status of School Children on           asis at juhar karo regency in North Sumatera Province,
    Cognitive Performance and Impact of Health Education on                Indonesia. Open Access Maced J Med Sci 2019;7:3497-500.
                                                                                             ly
                                                                                     on
                                                                               e
                                                                        us
                                                                  al
                                                             ci
                                                   er
                                                  m
                                        om
                                   -c
                           on
                      N