ORN 17 Road Safety Education in Primary Schools
ORN 17 Road Safety Education in Primary Schools
Subsector: Transport
Theme: TI: Reduce accidents and increase road safety in rural and urban areas
This document is an output from a project funded by the UK Department for International Development (DFID) for the benefit
of developing countries. The views expressed are not necessarily those of the DFID.
This document was prepared by Gill Murray and Jill Guy, both consultant teachers, whilst working for the Transport Research
Laboratory, Overseas Centre. The Project Manager was Ivan Sayer.
The authors wish to acknowledge the numerous schools, teachers and children whose help was invaluable. The authors are particularly
grateful to Mr L Clocuh, Director, Regional Education Office, Mrs P Anson-Yevu, Assistant Director, Accra
Metropolis District Education Office and Mr J Amegashie, Director, National Road Safety Secretariat.
Overseas Road Notes are prepared principally for road and transport authorities in countries receiving technical assistance
from the British Government. A limited number of copies is available to other organisations and to individuals with an
interest in roads overseas, and may be obtained from:
Overseas Centre
Transport Research Laboratory
Crowthorne, Berkshire, RG45 6AU
United Kingdom
Limited extracts from the text may be reproduced provided the source is acknowledged. For more extensive
reproduction, please write to:
Programme Director,
Overseas Centre,
Transport Research Laboratory.
CONTENTS
Page Page
Curriculum links 10
1. INTRODUCTION
FACTS
• Road accidents are a primary and growing cause of death and injury to children in developing countries.
• Road Safety Education is limited in developing countries, but the Transport Research Laboratory's research has
demonstrated that this can be a cost effective remedial measure if the principles of good practice are followed.
1
WHY IS ROAD SAFETY EDUCATION IMPORTANT?
FACTS
• 500,000 people are killed in road accidents each year, and 350,000 of these are in developing countries.
• Road accident fatalities in a number of African and Asian countries are increasing annually.
• Pedestrian accidents are a particularly serious problem in developing countries. For example, in Africa 42 per cent of the
road accident fatalities are pedestrians compared with only 20 per cent on average in Europe and the United States of
America.
1.8 The road and traffic environment affects our lives in a using education as one means of addressing the problem. Any
profound way on a daily basis, whichever country we live in, country should, like Ghana, be aware of its accident pattern
whether we are adults or children. before it can take remedial measures. In general, casualties
increase as children get older and become more exposed to
1.9 Children in developing countries spend much of their traffic. In Ghana child casualties are mostly in the 6-10 year old
time as pedestrians and are extremely vulnerable road users. age group, as are most deaths. Other studies have shown that
Road Safety Education, improved driver behaviour, males have a higher pedestrian casualty rate per head of
engineering measures and good practice measures need to be population than females, and this is also true of Ghana. In most
taken to reverse this fact. Ghana has begun this task. European countries accidents to pedestrians tend to happen
close together on local roads in areas where visibility is
1.10 Ghana has a particularly serious pedestrian accident obscured. In Ghana most pedestrian accidents happen on urban
problem, pedestrians representing 43 per cent of road accident roads away from junctions. The resource `SAFE WAYS' is an
fatalities of which 47 per cent were children. Ghana's Ministry example of a good practice measure written in the knowledge
of Transport and Communications is aware of the of the country's accident pattern.
characteristics of its accident pattern, and is
2
Policy makers WHY DO CHILDREN HAVE ACCIDENTS?
They need to be aware of the problems and be able to 1.13 The nature of children is to be impulsive and unreliable.
implement solutions through policy making at ministerial level.
They find it hard to give their attention to two activities at once,
Teachers and often they are absorbed in play perhaps making them less
able to understand real life situations.
They need to receive initial teacher training, and in-service
training in Road Safety Education in order to give planned 1.14 They have limited experience.
educational opportunities to their pupils.
It should be remembered that children develop skills only
Parents gradually - they have not been alive for very long!
They need to set a safe example, protect and educate their 1.15 They are smaller than adults.
children.
Their vision is restricted because of their lack of height. Their
Infrastructure authorities perception is immature.
They need to consider children, particularly as pedestrians, 1.16 They are often unsupervised or poorly supervised by
when planning and developing roads. their parents.
Official road safety body 1.17 Various studies confirm these points: they found that
children display:
For Road Safety Education to be effective there needs to be a
national commitment at all levels, indicated in the diagram • poor powers of perception, concentration, attention,
above, and a means of ensuring that all efforts are coordinated memory, and physical and emotional control
into a cost effective programme. This national commitment can
be facilitated by a national body responsible for • poor knowledge and understanding of traffic
communication, co-ordination and publicity within the road
safety field. It is important to ensure, however, that any such • poor behavioural patterns in the traffic environment.
organisation does not just exist in name only, but is effective
and dynamic. 1.18 These characteristics apply to all children both from
developed and developing countries.
1.12 Ghana is fortunate to have the benefit of a powerful
national committee (National Road Safety Committee) as its
official body. It is active in a variety of road safety fields and
has an overview of policy and practice.
3
HOW CAN ACCIDENTS BE PREVENTED?
1.19 Road accidents can be prevented in four main ways, has introduced a scheme on a trial basis to improve accident
namely the four E's. prevention and reduce accidents.
Engineering - by altering the environment. 1.23 To encourage the transfer of suitable technology in this
field TRL has published `Towards Safer Roads in Developing
Enforcement - by imposing laws. Countries - a road safety grade for planners and engineers'
(TRRL, 1991). It gives examples of good and bad practices
Encouragement - by the use of publicity campaigns. around the world, and highlights the fact, that many underlying
general principles for planning and engineering affecting safety
Education - by gaining and using knowledge. are, to some extent, universal.
4
reduction in accidents. On similar roads with no patrols to inform the driving public of the vulnerability of children.
accidents rose by 37%. However, police presence at signalised The NRSC is responsible for many other media areas
junctions in Kenya and Pakistan showed drivers having little encouraging road safety awareness. Recently it has produced a
regard for police presence in terms of the proportion of drivers video and a flip chart for use in schools and designed bill board
passing red signals and stopping for pedestrians waiting to use posters to promote the use of seat belts and motorcycle helmets.
zebra crossings. The Committee also features regularly on television and in the
newspapers to convey safety messages and produces
1.26 In Accra, Ghana, traffic police hold regular training and information leaflets for distribution at work places and
instruction sessions for traffic violators. Apprehended drivers churches.
attend police headquarters for corrective training lessons by a
police instructor. Public transport drivers allowing passenger Education
overloading have their vehicles impounded for a limited time
and are fined. 1.29 Road accidents can be prevented by acquiring and using
knowledge. It is recognised that Road Safety Education
Encouragement programmes should be graded and structured developmentally
and that teachers need guidelines on what and how to teach.
1.27 Encouragement is the role of publicity which attempts to Such programmes need to be relevant to the particular
inform and educate road users with a view to persuading them developing country, although fundamental principles of Road
to change their behaviour to make accidents less likely. There Safety Education underlie all good practice.
are many channels through which encouragement can take
place e.g. newspapers, radio, television, magazines, books, 1.30 Engineering, enforcement, encouragement and edu-
tapes, films and videos, leaflets, posters and stickers. Often cation give a framework in which a road safety team is capable
many of these media are used to promote a road safety of co-ordinating and integrating a wide range of road safety
campaign based on an agreed chosen problem area. improvements. At a strategic level it is important that Road
Safety Education as a remedial measure is planned and
1.28 In Ghana the National Road Safety Committee (NRSC) developed within this multi-disciplinary context. The remainder
is the springboard for most road safety publicity, choosing one of this document focuses on the development and
or two topics a year to focus upon. For example a campaign implementation of Road Safety Education as an effective
`Save the Child' was launched in 1995 accident prevention measure.
5
2. ROAD SAFETY EDUCATION Representation should come from disciplines such as edu-
- A NATIONAL POLICY cation, police, health, highways and transport, and the national
road safety body, if such an organisation exists. The size of the
MAKING ROAD SAFETY EDUCATION committee should be restricted to 12 - 20 people (see Appendix
WORK AT A NATIONAL LEVEL B).
2.1 For progress to be made nationwide in accident and In Ghana the National Road Safety Committee (NRSC) has
injury prevention road safety has to be designed as a national assumed the leading role in Road Safety Education. Education
goal with efficient management structures set up at national as is one part of its function.
well as at local levels.
STEP 3 - Forming Policy and Delivery Structure
2.2 The diagram below shows in a very simplified way how "In order that Road Safety Education be really effective it
Road Safety Education can reach primary school children by requires a clear structure within a recognised curriculum with a
following 5 steps. It requires commitment, co-ordination planned, sustained and coherent programme of learning" (DOT,
and communication at all levels to reach implementation. 1995). Therefore the policy and aims of Road Safety Education
need to be decided by the multidisciplinary committee referred
STEP 1 - Collecting information to in STEP 2.
Information needs to be collected and collated when assessing a
country prior to implementing a suitable Road Safety Education Details of content should be written by curriculum specialists
programme. A co-ordinator needs to be appointed for this based upon the core Children's Learning Objectives suggested
purpose. Ideally this person should be appointed by one of the in Chapter 4.
ministries responsible for children's safety e.g. Education,
Health, Transport. They should have an education background A feasible delivery structure needs to be carefully thought out
since it will be their responsibility to assemble the Road Safety and agreed upon, in the light of the information gathered.
Education Committee mentioned in STEP 2. Cultural and religious considerations also need to be made
when thinking about delivery. For example, a country might
Figure 2.1 'Organisational Inquiries' illustrates key areas to have a strong network of women's groups which is an
be addressed, key people to be visited and key questions to be established way of passing on health and safety messages.
asked by the co-ordinator. Successful transference of Road Safety Education for primary
children in the UK is through teachers in schools.
Figure 2.2 `Organisational Model' displays the information
gathered from Ghana. With thus background information a Ghana has begun to follow good practice by:
country can begin the task of developing a structure to make
Road Safety Education work. (See Figures 2.1 and 2.2). • producing a policy report for Road Safety (Crown Agents,
1995). The Report suggests that the best approach to Road
STEP 2 - Creating a Road Safety Education Committee Safety Education in Ghana is to develop institutional
A Road Safety Committee for education needs to be created by provision in formal education, i.e. through curriculum
people with the power to generate change. development, and also to utilise non-formal education
methods such as publicity.
6
• planning to establish Road Safety Committees iii the Ghana it is proposed to use NRSC staff as resource persons in
larger cities and in each region, and by appointing 10 teacher training colleges.
regional Road Safety Officers to assist with the delivery
of Road Safety Education through teachers in primary STEP 5 - Monitoring and Evaluating
schools. The monitoring and evaluation of Road Safety Education
should take place at all levels, for example at school as well as
STEP 4 - Implementing the Policy at ministerial level. Road Safety Education is difficult to
Government ministries need to accept the recommendations of monitor and evaluate, because it is impossible to decide
the Road Safety Education Committee and introduce policies to whether an accident would have happened with or without an
enable implementation at national and local level. educational input. However it is important that the Road Safety
Implementation at local level to primary aged children is Education Committee be assured that the expenditure is
usually through teachers in schools, but can be through the bringing an adequate return in terms of greater knowledge and
police, health workers, or community groups such as women's safer behaviour, which should lead to reduced accidents in the
groups or churches. long term. It is advisable that one person with a research
background should be appointed to have an overview of the
Both the UK and Ghana have taken the education route. If an monitoring and evaluation.
adequate school system is in place the education route is
recommended with support from other disciplines. It is Ghana's According to the Policy Report for Road Safety (Crown
intention through the National Road Safety Committee to give Agents, 1995) the NRSC will link with the University of Ghana
some in-service training to teachers. to carry out specified in-depth research and suggest ways of
monitoring and evaluating publicity and education initiatives.
In order to facilitate the inclusion of Road Safety Education in
the school curriculum teacher training colleges will need to be
encouraged to include it in their programmes. In
7
8
Fig. 2.1 Organisational inquiries for road safety education (RSE)
Fig. 2.2 Organisational MODEL for Road Safety Education (RSE) ref Ghana
9
3. ROAD SAFETY EDUCATION
(RSE) - THE CURRICULUM RSE should be PRESENTED frequently
WHAT ARE THE KEY POINTS IN TEACHING 3.5 Children behave more safely immediately after some
ROAD SAFETY EDUCATION? training and less safe some months later (Limbourg and Gerber
1981). This shows the importance of presenting Road Safety
3.1 There are 5 important points (`the 5 Ps') to remember Education frequently.
when teaching children road safety. They can be summarised as
follows. It should RSE should have a PLACE in the school
timetable
• begin PRE-SCHOOL
3.6 Road Safety Education must have a proper place in the
• be PRACTICAL school timetable. It must be decided where it belongs:
3.3 Research has shown that practical training is essential if 3.7 In Ghana Road Safety Education is at present in the Life
pedestrian behaviour of young children is to be improved. Skills syllabus, and the `SAFE WAYS' programme as a whole
Theoretical teaching in a classroom situation has been shown to could be used there. Parts of the `SAFE WAYS' programme
improve knowledge without affecting the child's behaviour also link with other subject areas in the Ghanaian curriculum as
near roads. shown below.
RSE should follow the PRINCIPLES of child 3.8 The most important thing is that Road Safety Education
development exists somewhere in the school timetable and it is identified.
3.4 To begin with a very young child should be prevented by 3.9 Ghana has begun to address these issues. At present
an adult from going near roads, and eventually the young some Road Safety Education is in the Life Skills syllabus of
person is competent alone in a busy traffic environment. To their national curriculum (see Appendix D). More Road Safety
move the child from one extreme to the other teachers have to Education is being planned for the future and is likely to appear
use their knowledge of the principles of child development. For in the proposed new Environment curriculum.
example a child under 6 years old cannot put himself /herself in
someone else's position; so it is difficult to imagine whether a 3.10 Two new resources are to be introduced:
driver can see him/her or not. The child under 11 years old
finds it difficult to focus on the relevant and ignore the 1) ‘SAFE WAYS’ written by TRL for DFID, is for
irrelevant - so perhaps would be distracted by a friend calling teachers of upper primary school children.
out when he/she is trying to cross the road.
2) `Road Safety Education in Primary Schools'. A Guide
for teachers by the National Road Safety Committee.
10
Fig. 3.1 `Safe Ways' Road Safety Education Resource
11
4. ROAD SAFETY EDUCATION • child demonstrating good practice to adult
- CHILDREN'S LEARNING
OBJECTIVES • total independence with young person being the
decision maker.
ARE THERE UNIVERSAL OBJECTIVES FOR
CHILDREN LEARNING TO BE SAFER 4.2 Passive methods of Road Safety Education are known to
PEDESTRIANS? be poor. Recent research in the UK has shown that 5 and 7 year
old children had virtually no ability to separate safe from
4.1 In considering children's needs there should be a gradual dangerous places to cross (K Ampofo-Boateng and J
progression from total protection to total independence. This Thompson, 1993). This shows that practical learning in the real
involves interaction with parents/carers, teachers and peer road environment is vital. This approach has been used
groups with their importance varying at different times. effectively in both the UK (RoSPA. 1994) and Ghana (Sayer,
Children should move through the progression as follows: 1997), proving popular with teachers and pupils alike.
• total protection with adult leading child 4.3 Each stage builds upon and reinforces previous learn-
ing. Therefore only new objectives are set out below. The
• adult demonstrating good practice to child stages are only a guide and one must always be aware of an
individual's starting point.
12
13
14
5. ROAD SAFETY EDUCATION - EXAMPLES OF GOOD PRACTICE
GHANA
5.1 The SAFE WAYS programme presented school pupils in Accra with novel opportunities to learn, both in the classroom and
school compound, and in practical situations outside near real roads. The programme aimed to increase their road safety awareness
culminating in the children making safer journeys to and from school.
Plate 5.1) Upper primary school pupils in Accra participate in Road Safety Education using `SAFE WAYS'.
Plate 5.2) Primary school teachers in Accra participate in workshops before using `SAFE WAYS'.
15
Plate 5.3) A teacher in Ghana uses a poster discuss crossing the road safely with her class.
Plate 5.4) A poster based upon the National Road Safety Committee's flip chart used to discuss safe places to cross the road.
16
NEPAL puppets are cheap, transportable and easily made. After the
show a discussion takes place to test the children's under-
Nepal uses puppets to teach Road Safety Education standing. Then a demonstration is given with the help of
5.2 Nepal has changed drastically in recent years. Kathmandu teachers preferably near the roadside, or in the school grounds.
was virtually a village 30 years ago. The roads now carry a
mixture of bicycle, buses, lorries as well as ox carts and 5.5 This approach has apparently been very successful; not
rickshaws, with the additional hazards of many farm animals only have the children benefited but teachers and mothers have
moving along. also become involved through the demonstrations.
5.3 A road safety programme was implemented in 1992 PAPUA NEW GUINEA
because of the large number accidents. With illiteracy rates of
80% for women and 50% for men, puppets were chosen as a 5.6 Papua New Guinea has produced a road safety book
means of portraying road safety messages to children. Teams of called `Road Smart' aimed at school children.
men were recruited through the Scouts and trained to work in
designated areas. 5.7 A variety of road safety messages, rules and information
is contained within its 40 pages. They are presented in
5.4 The puppet show lasts about 20 minutes and deals with a appealing and exciting ways. (See Figure 5.1 below).
single problem e.g. running into the road. The
17
6. REFERENCES
AMPOFO-BOATENG K, THOMSON J A, and others, 1993.
A developmental and training study of children's ability to find
safe routes to cross the road. British Journal of Developmental
Psychology, Volume 11, Number 1, pp 31-45.
18
APPENDIX A: SUMMARY OF `SAFE WAYS'
Practical Work: Practice in walking and stopping takes place in the compound.
Homework: Learning is reinforced and the children are encouraged to pass on their knowledge to younger children.
Practical Work: This looks at what can be found on the footpath and road, and takes note of observations made from the
compound and/or near the road.
Classroom Work: Discussion takes place on what protected crossing places are, their names, and how to make use of them. The
Green Cross Code is featured.
Practical Work: This takes place in the compound or outside the school, and includes a demonstration of how to use
at least one of these crossings.
Homework: The personal use of crossings is considered especially on the journey to and from school. Passing on
knowledge to younger children is encouraged.
Classroom Work: There is a classroom discussion on how to choose the safest place to cross when no protected crossing places
exist.
Practical Work: Practice in the selection of a "safe" place, and crossing in a safe manner is carried out in the compound and/or
outside the school.
Homework: Using the Green Cross Code is included, and the importance of explaining it simply to younger children.
Classroom Work: Discussion takes place on the problems encountered on school journeys, and suggestions are made on how to
make routes safer. A large poster is studied for this purpose.
Practical Work: On the way home pedestrians are observed, and personal routes to and from school to home are considered
for their safety value.
19
APPENDIX B: AIDE MEMOIRS
20
21
APPENDIX C: PROPOSED COUNCIL MEMBERS FOR NATIONAL ROAD
SAFETY COMMITTEE IN GHANA
22
APPENDIX D: EXAMPLE FROM THE LIFE SKILLS SYLLABUS IN GHANA
23
OS-E
ISSN 0951 - 8797