Design Analysis of A Flood Water Reservoir To Mitigate Flood Spread in Bonny Local Government Area
Design Analysis of A Flood Water Reservoir To Mitigate Flood Spread in Bonny Local Government Area
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
Floods are a natural part of the hydrologic cycle. In some countries man can exploit
overflowing water to his benefit; in other place she fights against it unceasingly. What is the
Each flood is unique and has different causes; however, they can basically be divided into
five groups:
snow melt
Floods have many negative effects. Their primary effects include physical damage (damaged
structures, bridges, sewage systems, buildings, cars, etc.) and casualties (people and livestock
die due to drowning or subsequent epidemics and diseases). Their secondary effects include,
e.g. contamination of water, unhygienic conditions, the death of intolerant species of flora;
1
There are many flood protection methods, both active and passive. But we cannot generalize
their application, because each locality is different and many parameters affect the design.
1. decreasing the accumulated discharge. This can be provided by water structures, weir
3. instituting corrections and arrangements in the flooded area (e.g. planning, warning, rescue
services, etc.).
Flood protection is realized on bigger streams and rivers by dikes and water schemes, but
such solutions are ecologically and economically impossible on small streams. Therefore,
It is an effective water structure, which has no noisy effects on the environment and can even
be an aesthetic part of the countryside. It has to retain the flood wave and prevent an odd
amount of water from flowing outside the river bed. A village can be protected against the
static impacts of the water (overflowing) as well as the dynamic impacts (erosion, sediment
Floods can be devastating, and they are frequently compared to all other natural disasters
worldwide, because they have the highest number of casualties and the highest economic
losses. The worldwide average direct annual cost of natural disasters between 2000 and 2012
was roughly $100 billion (Kousky, 2015). The following facts are presented based on flood-
floods, one of every ten fatalities due to natural disasters are flood-related, and flooding is
2
responsible for one-third of overall economic loss ($250 billion worldwide over the last
fifteen years alone). A stark 95–97% of fatalities from natural disasters are caused by floods
in developing countries. At the same time, 90% of natural disasters include flooding, causing
a $6 billion annual loss in the world economy. The impact of floods can vary throughout the
population and industrial activities of both developed and developing countries (Hassanet al
2017; Manninget al 2017). However, some research studies support the severity of floods,
and in recent years, the frequency of floods has increased (Aronicaet al, 2012). Flood
situations tend to worsen with climate change, land subsidence, urbanization, and population
growth.
The blueprint of the Federal and State governments’ plans is yet to be released on how to
alleviate the sufferings of the flood-devastated people of Nigeria, especially those in Rivers
State. The 2012 flood disaster was a rehearsal compared to the just-gone 2022 flood
catastrophe. The flood came, and the people, especially those in the coastal areas of Rivers
State, were helpless, as they had nothing to prevent or curb the situation. All they could do
was save some of their properties, uproot their crops (mature and immature) as much as they
could, and get their family members and loved ones to safe havens. Unfortunately, some lost
their lives in the process, and who knows what will become the fate of the people if the
Nigerian government does nothing quickly about the situation and flood comes again in the
next few years, just like it came this year after the year 2012. Diverse health challenges also
arose during and even after the waters dried up. Emphatically, the waters may have dried up,
but the flood’s aftermath lives on and will continue for years. According to the World Health
Organization (2012), during the flood, there is an increased risk of infection of waterborne
diseases contracted through direct contact with polluted waters, such as wound infections,
3
dermatitis, conjunctivitis, and ear, nose, and throat infections. Therefore, there is need to
apply structural measures through the design of flood water reservoir and other non-structural
The aim of this research is to determine an appropriate design analysis approach for a flood
LGA.
Floods cause damage by depositing mud and debris after the floodwaters have finally
subsided and by the tremendous force of the moving water. Those who have never been
through a flood might not understand the perils of moving water. When the speed of the
running water doubles, the energy associated with it multiplies by a ratio of four, increasing
proportionately to the square of the speed. Flooding is frequently associated with water
moving more quickly than usual, partly due to the weight of more water upstream, which
causes an increase in the pressure gradient that drives the flow. Most often, the debris that the
flood waters carry—trees, cars, rocks, and buildings increase the flood’s potential for
destruction. When the seas are moving quickly enough, they can wash away everything in
4
their path and leave scenes of awful devastation in their wake. Hence this study will be
significant both to individuals, NGOs, private sector and government and its agencies in
order to be abreast with necessary measures to combat the flood menace in Bonny LGA and
The major limitation of the study is finance and as such this project sets a detailed theoretical
Flood
A flood is an overflow of water (or rarely other fluids) that submerges land that is
usually dry.In the sense of "flowing water", the word may also be applied to the
inflow of the tide. Flooding may occur as an overflow of water from water bodies,
such as a river, lake, or ocean, in which the water overtops or breaks levees, resulting
in some of that water escaping its usual boundaries, or it may occur due to an
Reservoir
water is collected and kept in quantity so that it may be drawn off for use.
5
CHAPTER 2
LITERATURE REVIEW
Flooding is a common occurrence in many parts of the entire mangrove belt of Nigeria and
fresh water especially at the high tide or during rainy season. Flooding also occurs in
floodplains of large rivers and many areas and town especially those located on flat or low-
ling terrain where adequate provisions have not been made for surface drainage or drainages
In the words of Jonkman and Kelman (2015), flooding is “the presence of water in locations
that are typically dry.” A flood is defined as a considerable increase in the water level in a
stream, lake, reservoir, or coastal area by the Center for Research on the Epidemiology of
Disasters (CRED) in 2019. Geoscience Australia (2013) defines flooding as an event that
happens when a typically dry area of the earth’s surface is submerged and covered in water as
a result of heavy rain or a water body overflowing. Additionally, flooding was defined by
metrological occurrences like earthquake activity. High tides co-occurring with heavy rains,
the building of temporary dams, and the breakdown of hydraulic and other control structures
According to Jonkman (2015), Ashley and Ashley (2018), and other sources, the most
prevalent types of flooding are riverine floods, which are brought on by the gradual buildup
6
of heavy rainfall, and flash floods, which are distinguished by high-velocity flows and short
warning intervals. However, Ahern et al. (2015) suggested that meals can be categorized
based on nature and cause (heavy rainfall, tidal solid movements, structural failure) (e.g.,
regularity, speed of onset, velocity, depth of water, spatial and temporal scale). Additionally,
according to Dewan et al. (2014), there are other sorts of floods, including coastal floods
brought on by storm surges, rain floods caused by inadequate drainage, monsoon floods in
the flood plains of major rivers, and flash floods from overflowing mountainous rivers.
Finally, Usman (2012) noted that despite not being the primary source of fatalities, river
flooding affects and uproots more people than any other natural disaster.
According to Hunt (2015), weather elements like heavy or prolonged precipitation, snowmelt,
or storm surges from cyclones, as well as significant human factors like a structural dam and
levee failures, changes to absorbent land cover with impervious surfaces, and insufficient
drainage systems can increase the intensity of floods. Although the consequences of floods
vary in intensity and scope depending on the topography, the level of human activity, the
amount of water present, and the stakeholders’ level of preparedness, they are always
incapacitating (Dalil et al., 2015). Flooding is perhaps the weather-related hazard with the
most significant global reach (Doswell, 2015). It can happen almost everywhere. A flood is
defined as water spilling onto normally dry terrain. Floods can occur in various ways that are
not directly tied to current meteorological conditions, although they are frequently associated
with heavy rainfall. So, to give a thorough account of floods, it is necessary to mention
processes that may have little to no connection to climatic phenomena. However, it is evident
that in the end, the water that causes floods has already fallen as precipitation at some point,
possibly in the distant past. Therefore, no matter what specific event produces the floods, the
7
primary cause of flooding ultimately stems from meteorological processes that produce
precipitation.
Floods cause damage by depositing mud and debris after the floodwaters have finally
subsided and by the tremendous force of the moving water. Those who have never been
through a flood might not understand the perils of moving water. When the speed of the
running water doubles, the energy associated with it multiplies by a ratio of four, increasing
proportionately to the square of the speed. Flooding is frequently associated with water
moving more quickly than usual, partly due to the weight of more water upstream, which
causes an increase in the pressure gradient that drives the flow. Most often, the debris that the
flood waters carry—trees, cars, rocks, and buildings increase the flood’s potential for
destruction. When the seas are moving quickly enough, they can wash away everything in
Even if the movement of the water does not directly harm objects, the effect of the water
itself can have a devastating impact on buildings and the things inside of them. For example,
books, furniture, photographs, electronic devices, and other items can all be harmed just by
possibly hazardous bacteria, and suspended sediment. This indicates that drinking water
water and additional long-term costs for restoring drinking water service to people in a
flooded area.
When floodwaters recede, mud and debris are left behind that can be expensive to clean up
and pose a health risk, especially if drowned wild and domestic animals’ remains are among
the debris. Floods can sometimes push wild creatures (including invertebrates of many kinds)
8
out of their natural habitats and into places that are nearby or already flooded. This can cause
Flooding is one of the natural processes that shape the earth, despite its significant
detrimental effects on people. One of the most fruitful places on earth is the floodplains that
line rivers and streams. For this reason, most of the so-called “cradles of civilization” are
located within floodplains (e.g., the Nile River and the Tigris–Euphrates River, among
others). Therefore, ever since humans have been in the path of these natural disasters, they
However, flooding is not entirely natural and threatens the ecosystem. Furthermore, due to
man’s propensity towards coastal areas and flood plains, flooding frequently has an
unfavorable impact on human activities and poses a risk when it does. Agbonkhese et al.
(2014) elaborated on the causes of flood disasters around the world, including:
Human Interaction with His Environment: As was already established, human contact
flooding. Undoubtedly, human activities are becoming a more significant factor in flooding.
Natural surfaces are being replaced as urbanization grows, which prevents water from easily
percolating into the ground. The result is that a significant amount of rainfall that would often
soak into the ground or be deflected by vegetation, delaying surface run-off into streams and
Bad Planning: Floods are also the product of poor design, and when humans have tried to
control the water resources available to them by building dams and other water control
9
structures, they have also failed, leading to floods. The 1988 Bagauda Dam collapse near
Kano had disastrous environmental effects; the widespread drainage system failures
throughout Nigeria, the encroachment of buildings on the flood plains of streams and rivers
running through towns and cities, and the deposition of waste materials in their courses are all
excellent examples.
Obinna et al. (2014) classify flood damage into direct and indirect, followed by tangible
and intangible. When floodwater comes into direct physical contact with people, property,
businesses losing production due to the flood (Obinna et al., 2014). Substantial damages
are those that are quantifiable in money, whereas intangible damages are those that are
However, the impact of flood can be discussed using the following subheadings, as
Economic Damage: Obinna et al. (2018) noted in their article on the effects of flooding
among residents living along Taylor Creek in the Orashi region of Rivers state, Nigeria,
that the area’s ongoing flooding has an impact on residents’ social and economic
environments because it destroys agricultural farmland and seeds stored for replanting,
which leads to a decline in food production and income loss for many in the affected
communities. Many assume that unpleasant effects will inevitably result once flooding is
mentioned. Flooding has both beneficial and harmful effects. Some authors have talked
about the detrimental effects, while others have talked about the beneficial ones.
10
According to Barinweni et al. (2012), flooding seriously harms local biodiversity, public
health, and property. Rapid run-off that results in soil erosion and the destruction of
flood lasts for a very long period, it impairs agricultural activities. It causes traffic
congestion in areas with low-raised routes, endangering the safety of the nation’s food
supply. Floods can affect different land uses and drainage systems. Flooding damages
urban and rural infrastructure, including public buildings and hydroelectric/thermal power
plants, which results in enormous financial losses and disruption and exacerbates the
Flooding can cause loss of livelihood, production, and other long-term economic effects
that can force the afflicted population to relocate or be displaced, as stated by Ekanem et
al. (2014).
Disease Outbreak: In the just experienced 2022 flood disaster, for example, the people
of Rivers State suffered and are continuing to suffer the scorching negative impact of it.
For instance, mosquitoes reproduce in or near stagnant or slowly flowing water and
drains. Waterborne illnesses, including typhoid fever, cholera, leptospirosis, and vector-
borne illnesses like malaria, dengue, and dengue hemorrhagic fever, can spread due to
flooding’s harmful effects on physical health. Waterborne illnesses are illnesses brought
on by drinking contaminated water. Most often, pollutants like sewage, human and
animal waste, pesticides and insecticides, fertilizers, oil, asbestos, and rusted building
11
illnesses are illnesses brought on by drinking contaminated water. Examples include, but
are not limited to, typhoid fever, cholera, diarrhea, dermatitis, conjunctivitis, and wound
In a routine data study on typhoid and paratyphoid fever risk factors by Vollaard et al.
(2014), it was found that flooding increased the outbreak of typhoid and paratyphoid
among responders. On health, flooding has had a negative impact. In a case-control study
by Sur et al. (2018) on a severe cholera outbreak following floods, it was revealed that the
severe flooding in Louisiana, Pre-hospital and Disaster Medicine, it was discovered that
falls. A total of 124 households were sampled at random for the study.
diseases are caused by direct and indirect contact with the contaminants, whether by
direct food intakes, vector insects like flies, dirty hands, dirty plates, or other utensils.
Additionally, the pollutants can seep into groundwater and sanitary sewer lines through
the ground. Additionally, due to flooding, sewage treatment facilities backed up into
homes and low-lying areas, and malfunctioning equipment may be overburdened with
filthy run-off waters and sewage. Private sewage disposal systems can become a source of
infection and illness when they break or overflow. Private wells can also be severely
2005). In this way, diseases like cholera, typhoid, and dysentery, which can be deadly,
12
can spread due to unclean drinking and washing water, poor sanitation, and poor sewage
treatment. Basic hygiene, or having access to clean, safe water and toilets, is essential to
disorder, and suicidal thoughts are some of the mental health effects of floods. The effects
of flooding and its aftermath on people’s mental health can be very diverse.
Reacher et al. (2014) conducted a case-control study on the health effects of flooding,
comparing the reported gastrointestinal and other illnesses and mental health in flooded
and non-flooded households through telephone interviews with 227 cases (house flooded
and 240 controls (non-matched) using interview guide for data collection and analysis
were done using descriptive statistics. They discovered that adults whose homes were
flooded experienced mental distress four times more frequently than those whose homes
disaster preparedness or service delivery have not thoroughly addressed the psychosocial
effects of floods; however, the primary evidence is related to common mental illness,
post-traumatic stress disorder, and suicidal ideation (World Health Organization, 2011).
Stanke et al. (2012) further stated that flooding is exceptionally stressful and that the
tension lasts long after the water has subsided. Numerous epidemiological research
revealed that flooding could cause common mental problems (such as anxiety and
Ahern et al. (2015). Additionally, the Pitt Review (2007) discovered that tension, anxiety,
13
According to Gray’s (2016) research on the long-term impacts of experiencing floods, the
and a sense of loss of home, as well as loss of social contact and strain on personal
relationships. Additionally, the overleaf pictures depict some of the negative impacts of
Growth of Settlements: On the flip side, flooding appears to have some positive
impacts. According to Backinsal (2016) and Chisolm (2019), floods can cause settlements
to grow, and in most situations, the settlements start along the river. According to
Robinson (2019), flooding has improved the existence and growth of agricultural
Robinson (2019) adds that city life spread from ancient Egypt and Mesopotamia through
the Mediterranean Sea, with the flooding of associated rivers very helpful. The earliest
towns appear to have grown up in the great river low lands of the near and middle east,
Robinson (2019) says. Observable morphological features, such as those found between
Aboh and Samabiri in the lower Niger and those along the river Amazon and its
tributaries, can equally occur due to flooding to develop settlements and support their
inhabitants, according to Faniran and Jeje (2013). This is true even in non-deltaic
environments.
phenomenon that we should try our best to regulate. However, flood waters can be highly
vital for many ecosystems if they are contained and appropriately managed.
14
There are various studies on flood water systems for flood control in the literature. Acanal et
al. (2000) proposed a six-stage operation policy for routing floods with return periods from
1.01 year up to the probable maximum flood (PMF) for dams having a gated spillway. They
showed regardless of the size and timing of any incoming flood, the proposed six-stage
Cheng and Chau (2004) used fuzzy iteration methodology for developing an integrated plan
for flood management in reservoirs in China and developed a flood-control software for real-
Karaboga et al. (2007) presented a control method based on fuzzy logic controller and Tabu
Search (TS) algorithm for operation of spillway gates of a reservoir during maximum
probable flood event. TS algorithm was employed to optimally determine the rule base of a
fuzzy controller.
Ngo et al. (2007) used simulation and optimization techniques for optimal operation of a
reservoir in Vietnam. They used Shuffled Complex Evolution (SCE) technique for
optimization and MIKE 11 simulation model for calculating water level in downstream river.
In their optimization model, objective function was formulated to maximize the water level in
Wei and Hsu (2009) presented a methodology to establish a set of optimal operation release
rules which were tree-based rules for real-time flood control on a multipurpose multi-
reservoir system. They reported that the derived rules can be used to determine the optimal
Cheng et al. (2008) applied the technique of decision tree analysis to determine the optimal
reservoir release and tradeoff judgment of reservoir operations between flood control and
15
water supply according to economic efficiency. They used Muskingum method for flood
routing.
model to determine the optimal hourly releases from reservoirs under the estuary tidal effects
during typhoon periods, for basin-scale flood control. In this study, the proposed channel
level routing developed from the feed-forward back-propagation neural network is employed
genetic algorithm (GA) and k-nearest neighbor (K-NN) algorithm for the development of
Valeriano et al. (2010) coupled a physically based distributed hydrological model with a
heuristic optimization algorithm for joint dam operation to reduce the flood peaks
downstream. The developed system was applied to the upper Tone River in Japan, and the
results indicated that the proposed integrated operation can effectively reduce a flood peak,
Kumar et al. (2010) adopted folded dynamic programming (FDP) for developing optimal
reservoir operation policies for flood control in case study of Hirakud Reservoir in Mahanadi
basin, India. They applied the Muskingum method as a hydrological flood routing method.
Li et al. (2010) presented a novel multi-objective shuffled frog leaping algorithm (MOSFLA)
to the multi-objective optimization problem. This algorithm can generate a solution set with
uniform spread and good convergence for the problems with two conflicting objectives,
including minimizing the highest reservoir water level and minimizing the peak flood
16
discharge. A historical review and major developments in the application of optimization
models for optimal operation of multi-reservoir systems in flood conditions can be found in
Malekmohammadi (2010).
There are some points that may help to clarify the contributions of this paper:
The existing studies about flood-control reservoirs such as mentioned papers are
of flood-control structures are sparse or unavailable especially in Rivers State. The present
17
CHAPTER 3
3.1 Materials
Computer system
Bonny Island is approximately 40km South of Port Harcourt and on the leeward side of the
Areas of Rivers State, Nigeria (Figures 2 and 3) Grand Bonny, Finima, Opusunju, Kala
Sunju, Green Iwoama and Kalaibiama are the major communities that make up the Island.
The Island lies on the Lat. 4o27N and Long 7o10E with an estimated population of
270,000[18]. The Island has a relatively flat topography on an elevation of 3.05 atmospheric
mean sea level with a total land area of 214.52m 2[19] with about 70% of its size suffering
from tidal flooding and land subsidence. The geology of the area comprises basically of
alluvial sedimentary basin and basement complex. The sub strata of the island consist mainly
According to[20] Bonny Island has lost about 1,793.24 km 2 of coastline between 1986 and
2006 with a greater percentage (76.62%) of this loss occurring between 1986 and 2001
18
coinciding with the massive constructions of NLNG, expansion of Shell export terminal and
Bonny Island is basically a rain forest vegetation area with brackish mangrove forest
vegetation established at the banks of the Bonny River and its tributaries. The greater
northern half up to the east of Bonny Town, next to the Opobo Channel is mainly mangroves,
and lies just above sea level (Figure 3). The southern part lies higher and contains typically
(degraded) freshwater swamp forests, in some places mixed with mangrove, open swamp, dry
land rainforest or dune slacks[21]. The southern Atlantic coast of Bonny Island encompasses
a beach ridge barrier and a sandy beach. The coastal situation is characterized by a large, 20
km wide, offshore sand bank: the Bonny Bar. It protects the coastline against ocean currents
The tidal flood on Bonny Island causes inundation on the coastal settlement. The sea water
area is extending to the land (as a result of the accompanying coastal erosion) leading to the
3.2 Methods
The design and construction of an efficiently functional reservoir that fulfils the needs and
purpose to its beneficiaries is the primary goal of this project. A well defined design process
will greatly increase the probability of creating a reservoir for flood control that will satisfy
this goal. The following are factors to consider when designing a pneumatic water pumping
machine.
1. Needs Analysis: In determining needs for specific facility, the designer must perform
a comprehensive and detailed analysis. Often part of a larger water supply plan, a
19
pumping machines and water reservoirs within a specific area, analysis of specific
problems such as location or deficiency of low pipe born water supply, human
population, and distance from the machine to the reservoir must be considered.
2. Safety: As public safety expectations are increasing all over the world, reservoir-dam
give information about the consequences of dam failure. Therefore, in cases where
flood analysis must be undertaken, even, for small reservoir-dams. Rescue action
3.2.1.1. DESIGN STRENGTH: The design strength of any material depends on its ability to
sustain a load without undue deformation or a failure. The tension or compression test
is primarily used to determine the relationship between the average normal stress and
3.2.1.2 DESIGN WEAKNESS: Design weakness simply points to the potency of the
materials used for the construction. There are strength limitations related to the
material which makes it not capable of carrying certain amount of load at a given
period of time. This weakness makes the material vulnerable to cracks, deformation,
or failure.
20
3.2.1.3 APPLICATION: Engineering materials have been used or applied in various aspects
in our society today and these materials have provided friendly solutions to a myriad
developments in the very materials we use for both the everyday objects in our life
and for more exotic applications. For example, the automotive, building, offshore and
Innovations in these fields often require materials that must meet contradictory,
nearly impossible demands. Materials that are strong and heat resistant but flexible,
material which entails the ability of metal to be plastically deformed to shape it into a
desired geometry. In order to plastically deform a metal, a force must be applied that
will exceed the yield strength of the material. Basically, it will compress, stretch, and
bend a small amount. The magnitude of the amount will be directly proportional to
the force applied. Also the material will return to its original geometry once the force
is released (elasticity).
3.2.1.5 MACHINING AND JOINING: An engineering material used for construction must
machining of such materials can be done using various machines such as the lathe
machine, drilling machine, milling machine, etc. In the same vein, joining of materials
Dam construction
21
Dam construction is often complex and requires a wide range of professionals from different
disciplines.
Civil engineers are generally responsible for determining the best type of dam for the site,
They will consult with engineering geologists and hydrologists on the technical details of the
site and the required specifications dependent on the amount of water involved.
Mechanical engineers will be contracted to design the necessary pipework, valves and
floodgates.
Geotechnical engineers will determine whether the rock or soil below the proposed dam is
strong enough to accommodate the weight and for determining possible permeability.
In very broad terms, the typical sequence of events for dam construction is as follows:
River diversion
Water flowing in a river or stream is diverted to create a dry area in which to construct the
dam.
Lower flows will be capable of diverting through tunnels or channels built around the side of
Higher flows may be too difficult to divert using separate channels, so instead a dry pit is
formed on one side of the river, leaving the other side open for water to flow through. The
dam is constructed in sections, with dry areas built in sequence. Openings are provided in the
Foundations
22
The foundation is built below the original ground level, with weaker soils or rock removed
and replaced with stronger materials if necessary. Cracks and fissures in the rock foundations
must be filled with grout to stop water leakage. Holes are drilled into the rock and grout
Concrete dams will need a large quantity of ready concrete, so a concrete batching plant is
often built on site. Concrete is then transferred to the dam either using a system of conveyor
belts or using trucks and cranes. The traditional method of placing the concrete is to pour it
into a formwork mould made in the required shape of the dam. The dam is built upwards 1-2
m at a time, and the concrete left to cure before the next section is formed on top. An
alternative method is to spread a concrete mix and compact it down using rollers. The dam is
raised in steps of around 600 mm at a time. Low concrete walls on the upstream and
downstream faces are formed first, with concrete then spread in thin layers in between the
Embankment dams are constructed in a series of thin layers from the bottom upwards.
Bulldozers spread fill material in a thin layer, usually 300 mm thick if using earth, or up to 1
m thick for rock-fill. The core of the dam is also constructed in layers so that it maintains the
same height as the rest of the dam. A protective layer is formed on the upstream face once the
full height has been achieved. This protects against wave damage and often provides
waterproofing.
Post-construction
23
Once the dam has been constructed the reservoir can then be filled, if it has not been during
construction (in the case of high flow rivers). Valves and floodgates must be extensively
24
3.3 Design Analysis/Calculations
Low Hazard Potential.—Dams in rural or agricultural areas where failure may damage farm
failure may damage isolated homes, main highways or minor railroads, or interrupt service of
• High Hazard Potential.—Dams where failure may cause loss of life or serious damage to
homes, industrial and commercial buildings, important public utilities, main highways, or
railroads.
Evaluating dam failure with the water surface elevation of the reservoir at the dam crest or
the peak reservoir stage resulting from the probable maximum flood (PMF). The minimum
peak discharge of the breach hydrograph, regardless of the technique used to analyze the
25
The peak discharge value determined by using principles of erosion, hydraulics, and sediment
transport may be used in lieu of the peak discharge computed using the equations presented.
26
Principal Spillway Design Hydrographs
The runoff from a storm duration of not less than 10 days will be used for sizing the principal
spillway. The return period for design precipitation amounts depends on the dam’s hazard
potential classification, purpose, size, location, and type of auxiliary spillway. Figure 2–1
below shows minimum return period principal spillway hydrologic criteria by hazard
potential classification.
The following geologic and geotechnical investigation to determine the site conditions and
dam features that require special attention include, but are not limited to;
27
Soils with Dispersive Clays
Soils containing dispersive clays are extremely erosive. Dams constructed using dispersive
clays are vulnerable to internal erosion failures and require special design considerations.
Geologic investigations for soils containing dispersive clays require special sampling
procedures. This includes obtaining many discrete samples and preserving the samples at
Karst
Karst terrain requires detailed evaluation of potential subsidence, seepage, and leakage in the
dam foundation and reservoir floor. Thoroughly evaluate these issues as they have significant
impact on the design, construction, cost, performance, and safety of the structure.
Collapsible Soils
Evaluate the potential of moisture deficient, low density, unconsolidated materials to collapse
on saturation or wetting. Collapsible materials are often associated with deposits, such as
alluvial fans, terraces, and aeolian soils. If the potential for collapsible soils exists, perform
extensive site investigations and testing to provide quantitative information for design and
construction. Obtain and test undisturbed samples that are representative of the collapsible
material.
Liquefaction Susceptibility
Soil liquefaction typically occurs in recent deposits of loose sand and silty sand located below
the water table; however, gravels and low plasticity silts may also liquefy. Assess
groundwater conditions and the occurrence and extent of potentially liquefiable soils that
28
DESIGN OF PRINCIPAL SPILLWAYS
Hydraulics
Design the principal spillway to carry the planned flow for expected headwater and tail water
Risers
Drop inlet principal spillways require risers to maintain the reservoir pool level at or near the
inlet crest elevation during low-flow periods; establish full pipe flow using as low a head
over the crest as practical; and operate without excessive surging, noise, vibration, or vortex
action at any reservoir stage. This requires the riser to have a larger cross-sectional area than
the conduit. NRCS standard covered risers have an inside width equal to the width diameter
(D) of the conduit and an inside length equal to three times the width D of the conduit (D ×
3D cross section).
Use special riser designs for spillways having maximum conduit velocities more than 30 feet
per second and for spillways having conduits larger than 48 inches in width or diameter.
Generally, while like standard risers, these designs require a special elbow and transition at
the junction of the riser and conduit and may require special design of the inlet. Consider
hydraulic model testing if the maximum total head on the spillway is more than 75 feet or the
Conduits
The design the conduit is straight in alignment. If required, modify alignment using
watertight angle changes at joints or by special elbows having a radius equal to or greater
than the conduit diameter or width. Provide thrust blocks of adequate strength when using
29
special pipe elbows. Design thrust blocks to distribute the thrust due to change in direction
for the maximum possible discharge. Install drop inlet conduits with enough slope to ensure
free drainage to the outlet of all parts of the conduit (including camber) at the time of
All conduits under earth embankments must support the external loads. They must withstand
the internal hydraulic pressures without leakage under full external load and settlement. They
must convey water at the design velocity without damage to the interior surface of the
conduit.
Design principal spillway conduits under earth dams to support fill heights greater than the
height later due to a change in dam classification or to incorporate additional storage for
and procedures.
Conduit diameter
repair, and to reduce plugging potential. Use a 36-inch minimum inside diameter for designs
30
• Low Hazard Potential Dams.—The minimum inside diameter of the principal spillway
conduit is 30 inches, unless a joint extension safety margin of at least 1.5 inches is used, in
which case the minimum diameter is 18 inches for maximum fill heights up to 50 feet at the
spillway conduit is 30 inches, unless a joint extension safety margin of 1.5 inches is used, in
• High Hazard Potential Dams.—The minimum inside diameter of the principal spillway
conduit is 30 inches.
The minimum inside diameter of the principal spillway conduit for low hazard potential dams
is 18 inches for heights up to 50 feet at the centerline of the dam and 24 inches for heights
greater than 50 feet, and 24 inches for all significant- and high hazard potential dams. The
conduit and cradle or bedding must rest directly on firm bedrock thick enough so that there is
essentially no foundation consolidation under the conduit. Under these conditions, the cradle
Consider the potential for hazard potential classification upgrade during the life of the
The use corrugated steel or welded steel pipe principal spillway conduits for single-purpose
low hazard potential dams with the product of storage times effective height of dam less than
10,000 acre-ft2.
31
In each case, the following limitations apply:
• Provision for replacement if the materials will not last for the design life of the structure
• Pipe structurally strong enough to withstand outside loads and hydraulic pressure
• Pipe watertight
Corrugated steel pipe must be polymer-coated with watertight connecting bands. Design the
minimum gage based on 35 feet of fill over the pipe. Design welded steel pipe conduits as
rigid pipe. When placing joints between lengths of welded steel pipe, provide a joint
extension safety margin of 1.5 inches for conduits on a yielding foundation. Protect welded
steel pipe by an exterior coating or by an exterior coating of coal tar-epoxy paint. Joints
between lengths of corrugated steel or welded steel pipe, other than welded joints, must be
electrically bridged on the outside of the pipe with insulated copper wire, number 6 American
wire gage or larger, securely attached to the uncoated pipe metal at both sides of the joint.
The wire should have a tough, waterproof insulation designed for direct burial, with a rating
of at least 600 volts. Thoroughly coat bare wire and exposed pipe metal at the points of
connection with a coating equivalent to the original pipe coating to prevent the entry of
moisture.
Designs for the use of steel pipe require soil investigations for resistivity and pH of the
subgrade and backfill materials adjacent to the conduit. Measure the resistivity using
32
Joints
Conduit joints must be designed and constructed to remain watertight under maximum
anticipated hydrostatic head and maximum probable joint opening. Use a margin of safety of
Trash Racks
Trash racks will be made to provide positive protection against clogging of the spillway
under any operating level. The average velocity of flow through a clean trash rack is not to
exceed 2.5 feet per second under the full range of stage and discharge. Compute velocity
If using a low-level reservoir outlet with a trash rack or a ported concrete riser to keep the
sediment pool drained, the trash rack or riser must extend above the anticipated sediment
elevation at the riser to provide for full design flow through the outlet during the design life
of the dam. The velocity through the net area of the trash rack above the maximum sediment
elevation must not exceed 2 feet per second when the water surface in the reservoir is 5 feet
trash racks is made on drain outlets to protect against trash that may reduce capacity or
Antivortex Devices
All closed-conduit spillways designed for pressure flow must have adequate antivortex
devices.
33
AUXILIARY SPILLWAYS
Where a design does not include an open channel auxiliary spillway, provide a closed-conduit
auxiliary spillway. Closed spillways must pass the freeboard hydrograph without overtopping
the dam, clogging the riser inlet, or restricting the passage of trash through the conduit elbow.
• For low hazard potential dams with a product of storage times the effective height of the
dam of less than 10,000 acre-ft2, the closed-conduit cross-sectional area must be 12 ft2 or
• For dams with drainage areas of 10 square miles or less (except those covered above), the
• For dams with drainage areas greater than 10 square miles must have a minimum
unobstructed cross-sectional area of each opening of the conduit of 40 square feet. Any other
area of each opening of 80 square feet. The ratio of width to height in both cases must be
A closed-conduit auxiliary spillway may also serve a dual purpose as a principal spillway.
34
CHAPTER 4
In this project, hydrographs of floods with different return periods was computed using
calibrated hydrological model of the watershed and were considered as the inputs of
II, the following parameters were used. The initial population was set to 10000; maximum
number of generations was equal to100; crossover probability = 0.9; and mutation probability
initial population (multi-reservoir systems with different heights) and continued to reach
different offspring for attaining the Pareto front solutions. Obtained results showed that the
Investment costs and potential damage costs for the first and the final offspring (Pareto front)
are shown in Fig. 4.1. Each point in this figure represents a multi-reservoir system with
certain height for each reservoir. On the right-hand side of the line with natural status
(without dam), there are some points (multi-reservoir options) that show not only they do not
reduce expected annual flood damage (EAD), but also they intensify the flood damage costs
by synchronizing the floods coming from different tributaries. The presented algorithm
moves toward solutions minimizing the EAD and construction costs in the search space.
As can be seen in Fig.4.1, solutions in the final offspring have less cost than the first
offspring; at the same time, for these solutions, the EAD costs of the basin is also less than
the first offspring. In fact, each solution in Bonny Island is an optimum design having unique
investment cost. Thus, decision makers can assign the optimum design of flood-control multi-
reservoir for each investment cost level. In decision making, one might be interested in
35
important that after obtaining many solutions which are true Pareto optimal with wide range,
to reduce the large set of solutions to a few representative solutions. To achieve this point,
various clustering algorithms are available. In the present study, a simple clustering algorithm
based on Euclidian distance was used to reduce the large number of final Pareto solutions to a
few representative solutions. Figure 4.2 shows the final solutions after clustering of Bonny
Island.
Based on results in fig 4.3, there is no need to construct any design 4 and 3 due to low
performance of the dam as shown in this result. On the other hand, dam construction in sub-
basins of Design 1 to 4 can efficiently mitigate the floods in downstream reaches. The effects
of optimal designs of multi reservoirs on reducing the peak of flood with return in years have
been shown.
Design No. 1, that is, the most expensive plan, has the most effects on reducing the peak of
floods and vice versa, Design No. 4 has the lowest. There is a compromise between
investment cost and expected peak flood reduction (expected flood damage cost) to select the
final optimal design. The final optimal design of multi-reservoir system in the basin is
36
selected among the Pareto solutions based on decision criteria. Decision criteria may be
37
CHAPTER 5
5.1 Conclusion
appreciably higher than that of the other flood-control options. The minimization of the
investment costs may be recognized as the principal objectives of design. On the other hand,
the final design of multi-reservoir system should prevent the flood crests from the different
tributaries being synchronized and efficiently mitigate the flood peaks of main rivers in the
watershed.
To attain these goals in this research, an algorithm was presented based on simulation-based
optimization approach. In proposed algorithm, the numerical model was used to calculate the
potential flood damages under the conditions that flood-control multi-reservoirs with
different heights exist in the watershed. Using the numerical model as a simulation model
provides a flexible tool to consider the interaction of the various dams that was analysed
Simulation model was coupled with the use python software in which multi-objective
optimization model was used to provide the optimal Pareto solutions between two conflict
objectives of minimizing the investment costs and the potential flood damage costs. The
application of proposed model to a small watershed in Bonny Island that showed optimum
designs obtained by model can efficiently reduce the flood peaks in a wide range from 10 to
For the case study, the location of reservoirs already was determined based on field studies,
but the proposed framework can also be developed to obtain the optimal location of multi-
reservoir system in the watershed just by defining the new variables in optimization model.
38
5.2 Recommendation
Designing a floodwater reservoir to mitigate flooding is a complex and critical task that
environmental impact, and community needs. Identifying potential sites for the reservoir
assess soil conditions and determine the feasibility of constructing a reservoir at the chosen
site for Bonny Island are some of the recommendation that will be stated for future research.
i. The study revealed that if unchecked the flooding problems in Bonny Local government in
ii. The study also reveals ways to mitigate the spread of flood using both structural and non-
39
REFERENCES
Acanal N, Yurtal R, Haktanir T (2000) Multi-stage flood routing for gated reservoirs and
conjunctive optimization of hydroelectricity income with flood losses. J Hydrol Sci
45(5):675–688
Agbonkhese, O., Agbonkhese, E. G., Aka, E. O., Joe-Abaya, J., Ocholi, M., & Adekunle, A.
(2014). Flood menace in Nigeria: Impacts, remedial and management strategies. Civil
and Environmental Research, 6(4), 71-88.
Ahern, M., Kovats, R. S., Wilkinson, P., Few, R. & Matthies, F. (2015). Global health
impacts of floods: Epidemiologic evidence. Epidemiologic Reviews, 27, 36-46.
Aronica, G.T.; Candela, A.; Fabio, P.; Santoro, M. Estimation of flood inundation
probabilities using global hazard indexes based on hydrodynamic variables. Phys.
Chem. Earth Parts A/B/C 2012, 42, 119–129. Available online:
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1474706511000568(accessed on 15
June 2020). [CrossRef]
Ashley, S. T. & Ashley, W. A. (2018). Flood fatalities in the United States. Journal of
Applied Meteorology and Climatology, 47, 805-818
Bakinsale, R. P. (2016): Land, Air and Ocean, Gerald Duckworth and Co. Ltd London.
Bariweni, P. A., Tawari, C. C & Abowei, J. F. N. (2012). Some environmental effects of
flooding in the Niger Delta Region of Nigeria. International Journal of Fisheries and
Aquatic Sciences, 1 (1), 35-36.
Center for Disease Control and Prevention (2005). Disinfecting wells following an
emergency. fact sheet. CDC Publishing
Center For Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters (2019). International disasters data
base. http://www.em-dat.net/.
Cheng C, Hsu N, Wei C (2008) Decision-tree analysis on optimal release of reservoir storage
under typhoon warnings. J Nat Hazard 44:65–84. doi:10.1007/s11069-007-9142-1
Cheng CT, Chau KW (2004) Flood control management system for reservoirs. Environ
Model Softw 19:1141–1150
Chisolm, M. (2019). Rural settlement and land use: An essay in location. Hutchinson and Co.
(Publisher) Ltd.
Dalil, M., Mohammad, N. H., Yamman, U. M., Husaini, A. & Mohammed, S. E. (2015). An
assessment of flood vulnerability on physical development along drainage channels in
40
Minna. Niger State, Nigeria. African Journal of Environmental Science and
Technology, 9(1), 38-46
Dewan, T. H., Rahman, M. A. & Miah, S. (2014). Report of the workshop on environmental
change and sustainability development (in press). Pawan Press.
Doswell, C. A. (2015). Flooding. University of Oklahoma Press.
Ekanem, E. J., Kopada, M. & Musa, L. (2014). Community participation in flood disaster
management: A function strategy for vulnerable communities. Proceedings of the 2nd
International Conference on Flood and Erosion Prevention, Protection and Mitigation.
Sodave Classic Publication, Port Harcourt, Nigeria, 131.
El-Sayed, B. B., Arnot, D. E., & Mukhtar, M. M. (2017). A study of the urban malaria
transmission problem in Khartoum. Acta Tropica, 75, 163-71.
Faniran, A. & Jeje, I. K. (2013). Humid tropical geomorphology. Longman Group Ltd.
Geoscience Australia (2013). What is flooding?
http://www.ga.gov.au/hazards/flood-basics/what.html
Gray, S. (2016). Long-term health effects of flooding. Journal of Public Health, 30(4), 353-
259.
Hassan, F.; Hamdan, M.A.; Flower, R.J.; Shallaly, N.; Ebrahem, E. Holocene alluvial history
and archaeological significance of the Nile floodplain in the Saqqara-Memphis region,
Egypt. Quat. Sci. Rev. 2017, 176, 51–70. [CrossRef]
Jonkman, S. N. & Kelman, I. (2015). An analysis of the causes and circumstances of flood
disaster death. Journal of Disaster, 29(1), 75-97.
Jonkman, S. N. (2005). Global perspectives on loss of human life caused by floods. Journal
of Natural Hazards, 34(2), 151-175
Kousky, C. Who holds on to their flood insurance. Common Resour. 2015.
Kumar DN, Baliarsingh F, Raju KS (2010) Optimal reservoir operation for flood control
using folded dynamic programming. Water Resour Manag 24:1045–1064
Li Y, Zhou J, Zhang Y, Qin H, Liu L (2010) Novel multi objective shuffled frog leaping
algorithm with application to reservoir flood control operation. J Water Resour Plan
Manag ASCE 136(2):217–226
Loster, T. Flood trends and Global Change. In Proceedings of the EuroConference on Global
Change and Catastrophe Risk Management: Flood Risks in Europe, Laxenburg,
Austria, 6–9 June 1999.
41
Malekmohammadi B (2010) Optimal operation model for river-reservoir systems based on
flood risk management. PhD thesis, Faculty of civil engineering, Tehran University,
Iran
Malekmohammadi B, Zahraie B, Kerachian R (2009) A real-time operation optimization
model for flood management in river-reservoir systems. Nat Hazards 53:459–482.
doi:10.1007/s11069-009-9442-8
Manning, J.G.; Ludlow, F.; Stine, A.R.; Boos, W.R.; Sigl, M.; Marlon, J.R. Volcanic
suppression of Nile summer flooding triggers revolt and constrains interstate conflict in
ancient Egypt. Nat. Commun. 2017, 8, 900. [CrossRef][PubMed]
Ngo LL, Madsen H, Rosbjerg D (2007) Simulation and optimization modeling approach for
operation of the HoaBinh reservoir, Vietnam. J Hydrol 336:269–281
Obinna, V. C., Gobo, A. E., & Obinna, R. O. (2014). Socio-economic and health impacts of
the 2012 flooding in parts of the Niger Delta and policy implication. Proceedings of the
2nd International Conference on Flood and Erosion Prevention, Protection and
Mitigation. Sodave Classic Publication, Port Harcourt, Nigeria, 323.
Obinna, V. C., Weje, I. I., & Eli, Z. E. (2018). Perennial flooding and coping strategies of
residents along Taylor Creek Channel in the Niger Delta Region, Nigeria. The
International Journal of Humanities & Social Studies, 6(10), 169-177.
Ogden, U., Walden, G. I., & Taiwan, H. P. (2016). Long-term health effects of flooding.
Journal of Public Health, 30(4), 353-259.
Oyebande, L. (2014). Integrated flood management and mitigation options for Nigeria.
Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Flood and Erosion Prevention,
Protection and Mitigation. Sodave Classic Publication, Port Harcourt, Nigeria, 19-23.
Pagasa, D. (2013) Causes and types of floods.
http://kldiat.dost.gov.ph/genmet/floods/causes_floods/consequences.aspx
Pitt Review (2007). Learning lesson from the 2007 floods.
http://www.chiefscientist.gid.gov.au/publiations/undestanding
floods/consequences.aspx
Plate, E.J. Flood risk and flood management. J. Hydrol. 2002, 267, 2–11. Available online:
http:// www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/B6V6C-46HBKF8-
4/2/93f2763765cd0bad006fed4cfc6fa5c1(accessed on 15 June 2020). [CrossRef]
Reacher, M., McKenzie, K. & Lane, C. (2014). Health impacts of flooding in Lewes: A
comparison of reported gastrointestinal and other illness and mental health in flooded
42
and non-flooded households. Journal of Communicable Diseases and Public Health, 7,
56-63.
Robinson, H. (2019). Morphology and landscape. University Tutorial Press Limited.
Stanke, C., Amlot, R., Nurse, J. & Williams, R. (2012). The effects of flooding on mental
health: Outcomes and recommendations from a review of the literature. London Health
Protection Agency
Sur, D., Dutta, P. & Nair, G. B (2018). Severe cholera outbreak following floods in a
Northern District of West Bengal. Indian Journal of Medical Research, 112, 178-82.
Usman, I. (2012). A survey of the area vulnerable to flood and the mitigation strategies
accepted by Akari community, Niger State, Nigeria. A Master Degree Thesis submitted
to the Centre of Disaster Risk Management and Development Studies. Federal
University of Technology, Minna.
Valeriano OCS, Koike T, Yang K, Yang D (2010) Optimal dam operation during flood
season using a distributed hydrological model and a heuristic algorithm. ASCE J
Hydrol Eng 15(7):580–586
Vollaard, A. M, Ali, S. & Van-Astem, H. A. (2014). Risk factors for typhoid and paratyphoid
fever in Jakart, Indonesia. Journal of American Medical Association, 291, 2607-15.
Wei C, Hsu N (2008) Multireservoir flood-control optimization with neural-based linear
channel level routing under tidal effects. Water Resour Manag 22:1625–1647.
doi:10.1007/s11269-008-9246-8
Wei C, Hsu N (2009) Optimal tree-based release rules for real-time flood control operations
on a multipurpose multireservoir system. J Hydrol 365:213–224
World Health Organization (2011). Climate change: Fact and figures. WHO Regional Office
for Europe
43
APPENDIX A
PYTHON CODE
upper bounds for detecting water in HSV color spacelower_bound = np.array([90, 100,
maskcontours, _ = cv2.findContours(mask,
"__main__":image_path = "path_to_your_aerial_image.jpg"water_extent_percentage =
approximately{water_extent_percentage:.2f}%"
44