Chapter 2
Chapter 2
LITERATURE REVIEW
materials of reading for young learners. The explanations of these parts are presented
below.
needs (Richards, 2001). Needs analysis is the pertinent approach in planning the
(1995), need analysis refers to the activities involved in gathering information that
will serve as the basis for developing a curriculum that will meet the learning
needs of a particular group of students. There are four categories of people may
become involved in a need analysis; the target group, the audience, the needs
According to Brown (1995), many of the needs that are initially perceived as
important may not turn out to be so. As a result, Brown (1995) suggests that the
need analyst should narrow the scope of the investigation base on the three
6
7
Firstly, situation needs versus language needs, situation needs concerns in the
human aspects while the language needs is information about the target linguistic
subjective needs, objectives needs are those needs determined by observable data
gathered about the situation, the learners, the language should be required by the
learners, while the subjective needs is the wants, desire and expectations
from a language needs perspective and spelled out the linguistic terms; phoneme,
morpheme, discourse markers while the learning processes position leans toward
needs specified from a situation needs in the affective domain such as motivation
and self-esteem.
In addition, the kinds of needs are also separated by Hutchinson and Waters
(1989) into two categories; the target needs and learning needs. Target needs are
the learner needs to do in the target situation while the learning needs are what the
learner to do in order to learn. They divided the target situation into three terms;
necessities, lacks and wants. Necessity is the type of need determined by the
demands of the target situations; what the leaner has to know in order to function
effectively in the target situation. Lacks is the gap between the target proficiency
and the leaners existing proficiency. Wants is also called the need of the learner
Learning needs is show how the learners learn the language item needed in the
target situation. In other words, the learning needs is the route to get into the
analyzing learning need through the specific questions; 1) why are the learners
taking the course?, 2) how do the learners learn?, 3) what resources are
available?, 4) who are the learners?, 5) where will the course take place and 6)
when will the course take place. In addition, learning need requires to be
experiences, whose the primary aim is to lead the learners to a particular state of
knowledge.
There are several steps in approach concerning the needs analysis need to be
information on; the situation in which language will be used and the
graduates to achieve. Their needs have been decided for them by those
concerned. Thus, the needs analysis includes the study of perceived and
learner should be able to do. This notion suggests that needs have to be
analyzing needs analysis. They are relatively easy to prepare, they can
They also can be used to elicit the information about different issues.
issues rather than questionnaire. They take a longer to conduct and only
because there are very few problems in language teaching that have not
The result of the needs analysis will consist of information taken from
different kinds. The list of the needs analysis provides little useful
(2001) stated that the result would still be impressionistic. However, the
and Judge, 2010). For Demuth (2013), perception is the study of the cognition.
Perception is being studied in order to get the better understand how people
make attributions about events and we see the reality through the interpretation
about what we see and we can call it reality (Langton, Robbins and Judge, 2010).
Furthermore, for Demuth (2013) to study the world means to study perceptions
and ideas we created and the world is mainly the world of perceptions, images or
ideas. Thus, when we want to study something, first we should know where,
when and how to meet and learn it. But that is not enough. John Locke (in
Démuth, 2013) and the entire epistemological tradition following him was
convinced that if we can find the answer to the question about sources and
There are two ways in processing perception; the bottom up processing and
top down processing (Démuth, 2013). In the bottom up processing, the system
takes in individual elements of the stimulus and then combines them into a
13
final perception is influenced by the content and quality of sensory input while in
the words and sentences constructed by the bottom-up process. Démuth (2013)
notes that the central of this approach is that in order to process sensory stimulus,
one needs to have prior experience or knowledge, or other influences which help
them to organize and form cognitive contents. The result of this study can be
many considerations. Howard and Major described there are six key factors that
teachers need to take into account when designing learning materials for their
students. The initial factor and the most important one is the learners. Teachers
have to know their learner well to connect the learner with the learning material
specific needs.
teachers need to be realistic in terms of material design and production within the
that it is the less exciting thing but still included in the important factor to be
considered. Teachers need to be aware of the restrictions that copyright laws place
downloaded from the internet for use in the classroom. This thing becomes
important when creating course materials that will be used by large number of
The fifth consideration is time. It is the important thing to make things in class
minimalize time-problem in the class, teachers have to share materials with other
teachers, working in a team to take turns to design and produce materials and
The sixth consideration is curriculum and the context. This is the significant
taught.it is the teachers’ responsibility to ensure that the goals and objectives of
Concerning the curriculum and the context, Indonesia has its own criteria in
No. 65 (2013) the learning materials should promote higher order thinking skills;
learning experience.
material and short reading passage. Some studies reported the strategy instruction
is effective. Tomlinson (2013) added the guided practice will help the students
described the needed of the post-reading test. Tomlinson (2013) proposed that
ability. The objective of these learning activities and techniques are to check,
To help the students ease the difficulty of the text, they need to translate the
print words into a speech. Adams (1994 in Tomlinson 2013) explained that the
text should be read left to right, line by line and word by word. That’s why there
2013). Tomlinson (2013) agreed that the text should be given far more weight in
reading pedagogy and materials production. He proposed that the text should be
lives.
previous theory that the students have to transfer the print words into a speech.
Reading requires learners to decode visual stimuli, chunk semantic and semantic
units. Extract meaning from the text and integrate it with their relevant memories
representation in the readers’ mind. The text should spark off all sorts of reaction
in readers’ mind. It should make the readers feel the text so they can visions its
17
color, size, appearance, texture and smell. If possible, the reading text should
make the readers feel some sort of the emotion going inside the story.
Fourthly is the materials should help learners experience the text first before
they draw attention to its language. Tomlinson (2013) believed the reading
materials should offer activities that help the learners focus on the content of the
representation.
the primary information presented, but not to be a central. (Ian cited in Laue
2010).
2.4. Syllabus
Nunan (1987) found some confusion over the terms ‘syllabus’ and
‘curriculum’ within the literature. In his book, Nunan gave clear line about the
(Candl1984 a cited in Nunan, 1987). Syllabuses on the other hand, are more
localized and are based on accounts and records of what actually happens at die
classroom level as teachers and learners apply given curriculum to their own
Syllabus is usually assumed is that part of the curriculum but not vice versa
(Dubin & Olshtain, 1986 cited in Krahnke, 1987). Syllabus is more specific and
more concrete than curriculum, and a curriculum may contain a number of syllabi
(Krahnke, 1987). For instance, a curriculum may cover an entire school year,
while a language teaching syllabus may make up only one part of the curriculum.
teaching and students’ learning; it can also define as a shareable plan, which
The syllabus purposes to specify the content of the lessons used to move the
learners toward the goals (Krahnke, 1987). The syllabus offers a 'route map' to its
users which have the potential to provide overall continuity and also particular
points of reference. It can indicate where we are going, where we are, and where
define the target language and the needs. Analyzing of students needs is important
to identify the gap between what students are able to do and what they need to be
learners are experiencing (Richards, 2001). The more specific we define them; the
down of subject matter into manageable units containing and entailing smaller
19
units. Sequencing on the other hand, involves marking out of subject matter along
Similar to Brumfit (1984), Nunan (1987) explained that in order to design the
syllabus, the syllabus designers have to start with analyze the language,
information of the learner and beliefs about the learning process itself. He gave
the clear description to the key question in relation to those three steps; relation to
perspective: ‘what does the learner want to do with the language?’ finally from a
acquisition?’
developing the learning framework for the subject material. Syllabus has to
include the subject identity, school identity, Kompetensi inti (KI), Kompetensi
dasar (KD), theme, main material, learning process, assessment, time allocation
Lulusan and Standar Isi for basic and intermediate education agrees with the
Teachers may follow the predesigned syllabus, but they also inevitably
it in his or her classroom (Brumfit, 1984). Brumfit sees that classroom is the
20
meeting place or point of interaction between students and teacher which will
language, the printed one is the second source, but as students become better in
their foreign language, they start to make the printed words as the main source of
Reading is included in the receptive skills. Receptive skills are the ways in
which people extract meaning from the discourse he see or hear (Harmer, 2007).
(Cook, 1989 cited in Harmer, 2007). Such knowledge is well known as schema.
such schematic knowledge is activated and people are able to recognize what they
see or hear because it fits into patterns that they already know (Harmer, 2007).
There are clear distinctions in the analysis of reading; top-down and bottom
up (Harmer, 2007). Top-down processing the reader gets a general view of the
reading passage by absorbing overall picture. This allows the schemata construct
the expectations of what they are going across. On the other hand, bottom-up
In their book, Scott and Ytreberg (2007) described the approaches in reading
for YL. The approaches of reading in their version fall into four categories;
phonics, look and say, and language experience approach. Phonics approach is
based on letters and sound, teachers teach the students about the letters of
Although phonics can become very complicated, it can be very useful way into
reading for those learners who are not familiar with the new alphabet. Secondly,
look and say, this approach based on words and phrases. In this category students
start to read the phrase one by one. Thirdly, whole sentence reading, teachers
teach recognition of whole phrases and sentences which have meaning in them.
child’s spoken language. Despite all of those approaches, Scott and Ytreberg
(2007) prefer the approach which concentrates on meaning from the beginning
and those approaches may use at some stage in the process of learning to read.
both extensive and intensive reading (Harmer, 2007). Harmer pointed out that it is
not enough to tell students to ‘read a lot’; teachers need to offer them programme
provide the interesting material to keep students engage. He described the teacher
Young learners are 7 to 12 years old children (Slatterly and Willis, 2001).
Ersöz (2007) argued young learners are 7 to 9 years old. According to Scott and
Ytreberg (2004) young learner is the stage for children at age 8 to 10 years old.
Young learners are developing world of knowledge (Ersöz, 2007), they can
construct their knowledge by him/herself. They also called as the active learner
and thinker (Piaget, 1970). Vygotsky (1962) on the other hand, has the different
view about constructing knowledge from Piaget. He argued that children is not an
alone learner, they don’t construct the language by themselves; they learn and
construct knowledge from other people which means children learn through social
interaction.
context (Pearson, 2009). The need of the first hand for YL makes them need
students to operate on their own. The good scaffolding will lead into children into
around them, while they emerging their curiosity they can learn indirectly, they
can take in information prompt from all sides, learning from everything around
them rather than only focusing on the precise topic they are being taught (Harmer,
and eagerness to make sense of the world. They will tackle the most demanding
tasks with enthusiasm and willingness. Despite of having the enthusiasm for
learning and curiosity, YL also tend to have low span interaction (Harmer, 2007;
As a result, teachers need wide range activities to keep the YL engage in the
learning (Harmer, 2007). Shin (2006) suggested that the activities in the language
learning should be fun and engaging. The learning must involve the visual, realia
contextually with the concrete experience (Pearson, 2009), this is the effective
2.7.1 Songs
process and music is a natural way for children to experience rich language in a
24
pleasurable way (Woodal and Ziembroski, 2012). Song can help students
enhanced their reading skill because it motivating and engaging (Bollinger, 2010).
Bollinger (2010) described how songs can enhance students reading ability in
alliteration and rhyme contain in one song. As children listen to it, they recognize
individual sounds within a word and notice the same sounds in different words.
Secondly, phonics, as they familiar with a song, they start to know how to
reading fluency, and music makes repeated practice enjoyable. In here, children
are able to experiment with grammatical rules and rhyming through song.
laced within simple melodies, will have their vocabulary increase. As we know,
Blodget (2000) suggests there are several requirements in selecting songs for
students; first, each song should have one primary and several secondary
grammar and vocabulary should be on or slightly above the level because songs
25
are pedagogically problematic if they are out of the taught context grammatically
because it can be the great jumping off point for patterned writing/parallel
sentences.
Forth, there should be pervasive and consistent use on only one verb tense
and inserted one new grammar but still serve as a trigger for writing lesson. Fifth,
the song must be agreeable to listen to. Means the song must be something that
students will respond to. Last, the song should invite kinesthetic movement,
2.7.2 Stories
have difficulty in knowing what is fact and fiction because the dividing line
between real world and imaginary world is not clear. As a results, Ellis and
can exercise the imagination and are useful tool in linking fantasy and the
Scott and Ytreberg (2004) specified that reading become the main
other world for children which very compatible with imaginative YL which
attempt to use their imagination and love to explore things (Harmer, 2007).
26
are motivating and fun and can help develop positive attitudes towards the
reading the story for YL, teachers will make students understand socio-
meaningful.
Fojkar et. al (2013) in their study showed that the teachers’ main selection
criterion for material is that the teachers believe their pupils will like the
books although the survey stated that they preferred adapted books to
of nine years of age and whether all activities give pupils an opportunity to
develop their language skills. On the other hand, Ellis and Brewster (2014)
suggest in selection of the material fall into ten considerations; level, literary
From all of the considerations above, teachers should not forget that
2.7.3 Games
significant advantages for children that include fostering reading ability and
through play sustains children`s attention span and develops their reading
28
skills. Playing games provide more opportunity for children to talk using
varied words.
the study conducted by Hayes and Raman (2013). This study conducted the
needs analysis in Madhya Pradesh. The aim of the needs analysis was to
generate data to enable the British council to identify the needs and
The needs analysis in this study aimed to assess the current language
levels, assess the existing curriculum framework and text books in relation to
these needs, explore the students and teacher beliefs about the usefulness of
the educational and socio-cultural context of the teachers and students work
and study.
questionnaire, students focus group meetings, and lesson observation form are
the instrument used in this study. These instruments were revised and
Regarding the perspectives on English, teacher and students clearly felt that
speak English in order to get respect in their society. In addition, students also
felt that English is important for their future careers. The classroom
observation showed that the frequently methods use in the class was teacher-
centered.
institute of social and political science (IISP) Jakarta. This study was aimed to
needs of the students. The focus of the need analysis will be refers to the
combining both qualitative and quantitative methods. The data obtained from
questionnaires and interviews. In addition, this study was used the domain
this study showed that it can be applied for students of journalism study
learning.