816 (Corrosion Threats Handbook)
816 (Corrosion Threats Handbook)
in association with
Issued under licence to BP employees only.
IMPORTANT: This file is subject to a licence agreement issued by the Energy Institute, London, UK. All rights reserved. It may only be used in accordance with
the licence terms and conditions. It must not be forwarded to, or stored or accessed by, any unauthorised user. Enquiries: e: [email protected] t: +44 (0)207 467 7100
Acknowledgements
The Institute wishes to record its appreciation of the work carried out by Dave Moore of Lloyd’s Register EMEA for compiling this document and for
input of expertise into its detail and content and members of the Corrosion Management Working Group who provided valuable expertise through
meeting attendance and correspondence.
The origins of this document and further details of the Work Group can be found in the associated publication: Guidance for corrosion management
in oil and gas production and processing which is referenced throughout this document.
Foreword
This publication was compiled to enhance the awareness of corrosion for a large cross section of personnel within the oil and gas industry. It was
produced in parallel to the main guideline publication, Guidance for corrosion management in oil and gas production and processing which was
prepared following consultation with a large cross section of UK offshore operators, specialist contractors and independent verification bodies who
have a role in the control of corrosion.
This document is for guidance only, and while every reasonable care has been taken to ensure the accuracy and relevance of its contents, the Energy
Institute, its sponsoring companies, the document writer and the Working Group members, shall not be liable to any person for any loss or damage
which may arise from the use of any of the information contained in any of its publications.
This handbook may be reviewed from time to time and it would be of considerable assistance for any future revision if users would send comments or
suggestions for improvements to:
Controlling corrosion
It follows therefore that, without our intervention, the
metals from which facilities are fabricated will inevitably
return to the non-metallic compounds from which they
were extracted.
Recognising the indicators of degradation and
understanding the causes, forms the basis of the process by
which the threat of corrosion may be managed.
Corrosion control
METAL
The analogy with the fire triangle can be taken further in the
context of corrosion mitigation. A fire can be controlled by
removing any one of the three elements, e.g. a carbon dioxide
blanket to prevent oxygen access, or cooling with water to reduce
the energy. In the same way, corrosion may be controlled by
removing any one of the metal, water or corrodent components.
METAL + WATER + CORRODENT = CORROSION
Typical examples of these are:
s 2EPLACING STEEL WITH GLASS REINFORCED PLASTIC METAL + WATER + CORRODENT = NO CORROSION
pipework in seawater systems
s +EEPING INSULATION DRY TO PREVENT CORROSION UNDER
insulation
METAL + WATER + CORRODENT = NO CORROSION
s $EAERATING REMOVING OXYGEN FROM SEAWATER PRIOR
to downhole injection METAL + WATER + CORRODENT = NO CORROSION
s #OATING TO ISOLATE A METAL FROM WATER
The principle of removing at least one of the three necessary
components for corrosion lies behind most of the activities we
implement to control corrosion and is worth bearing in mind
when considering corrosion issues and mitigation measures.
Corrosion threats guide 5
The typical process and utility systems in upstream oil and gas The abbreviations used in
The abbreviations used to describe
the description section of the
production facilities are illustrated in the simplified process the threats are:
handbook are:
flow diagrams that follow. Typical corrosion threats for each General abbreviations Abbreviation Threat
of the systems are listed on each of the diagrams. Each threat CP Cathodic Protection Acid Acid Corrosion
is numbered, so that the number can be used to refer to the CRA Corrosion Resistant Alloy CO2 Carbon Dioxide Corrosion
Corrosion Under
description section of this guide. The description of each EI Energy Institute CUI
Insulation
European Federation of
threat shows typical examples of degradation morphologies EFC Crev Crevice Corrosion
Corrosion
and provides information on: the causes of the threats; how the HAZ Heat Affected Zone Eros Erosion
threat is manifested; which sections of the system are susceptible; Liquid Metal
LME Eros Corr Erosion Corrosion
Embrittlement
typical monitoring and inspection methods; and how the threat Magnetic Penetrant
MPI Ext Corr External Corrosion
Inspection
may be managed.
PW Produced Water F&F Fatigue and Fretting
More detailed information on these threats and their mitigation
QC Quality Control Galv Galvanic Corrosion
is given in the Energy Institute publication Guidance for corrosion
RBI Risk Based Inspection H2S Hydrogen Sulphide
management in oil and gas production and processing. Liquid Metal
SS Stainless Steel LME
Embrittlement
To differentiate between the main and less common threats
Ultrasonic Thickness Microbially Influenced
UT MIC
to each section of the plant, the major threats are highlighted Measurement Corrosion
WP Working Party O2 Oxygen Corrosion
in red.
SCC Stress Corrosion Cracking
RD 3TAGE
0HASE &LUIDS ND 3TAGE
ST 3TAGE 3EPARATION
3EPARATOR 3EPARATOR #OALESCER
#$ 3YSTEM
-ETERING
(YDROCYCLONES
Internal threats: downhole
CO2 / H2S / MIC / Galv / Weld / Groove / Crev
/ SCC / Eros / Eros Corr / Ext Corr / Acid %XPORT
0UMPING
External threats: downhole
Ext Corr / F&F $EGASSER#&5
./4%
OR STAGES OF
COMPRESSION PRIOR TO
DEHYDRATION 'LYCOL
2EGEN
&ROM
3EPARATION
$RY 'AS
ABOVE DEW 'LYCOL
POINT #ONTACTOR
-ETERING
4O 4O
3EPARATION 4O 3EPARATION
3EPARATION
Internal threats
Glycol regen.
CO2 / Acid
7ET 'AS NORMALLY NO FLOW &UEL 'AS %XPORT
#ONDITIONING
&IREWATER
3YSTEM 6ACUUM
0UMPS
&INE
&ILTRATION $EAERATOR
#OARSE OPTIONAL
&ILTRATION 5TILITY
5SERS
(EAT
%XCHANGERS
"OOSTER (IGH
0UMPS 0RESSURE
0UMPS
3EAWATER
,IFT 0UMPS
)NJECTION
# Threat Abbr’n # Threat Abbr’n
7ELLS
1. Carbon Dioxide Corrosion CO2 9. External Corrosion Ext Corr
2. Hydrogen Sulphide Corrosion H2S 10. Corrosion under Insulation CUI
3. Oxygen Corrosion O2 11. Stress Corrosion Cracking SCC
4. Microbially Influenced Corrosion MIC 12a. Erosion Eros
5. Galvanic Corrosion Galv 12b. Erosion Corrosion Eros Corr
Main threats are shown in red
6. Weld Corrosion Weld 13. Fatigue and Fretting F&F See Description section (pages 12-26) for
7. Grooving Corrosion Groove 14a. Misc. – Liquid Metal Embrittlement LME information on the threats.
8. Crevice Corrosion Crev 14b. Misc. – Acid Corrosion Acid
%XPANSION %XPANSION
Internal threats 6ESSEL 6ESSEL
O2 / MIC / Galv / Weld / Crev Internal threats
O2 / MIC / Galv / Weld / Crev
0ROCESS 0ROCESS
#OOLERS $UMP (EATERS
#- (EAT #OOLER (EAT
External threats -AKE 5P EXCHANGERS EXCHANGERS External threats
Ext Corr / CUI / F&F Ext Corr / CUI / F&F
37
#OOLING -EDIUM
3EAWATER (EAT 7ASTE (EAT
%XCHANGER 2ECOVERY
Internal threats #IRCULATION 5NITS
0UMPS #IRCULATION
Recirc pumps 0UMPS Internal threats
Eros Corr 37 Recirc pumps
Eros Corr
4URBINE
%XHAUST
7ATER
7ATER TO
$ISPOSAL
External threats 3AFE /PEN $RAINS
Safe open drains system
Ext Corr / CUI / F&F 6ENT
INSPECTION /
CAUSES OCCURRENCE SUSCEPTIBLE SYSTEMS MANAGEMENT
MONITORING METHODS
– Dissolved carbon –All water-wetted n !LL WATER CONTAINING – Process parameter – Corrosion resistant
dioxide, produces locations in hydrocarbon hydrocarbon processing monitoring, e.g. alloy
carbonic acid systems systems temperature, – Chemical inhibition
– Inadequate n 0IPEWORK STRAIGHTS pressure, dew point – See EI Guidance
corrosion inhibition o’clock)/bends/tees/ – UT Document. Appdx B,
reducers – Radiography Sections 1,6 and 13.
– Welds, heat affected – Corrosion probes/
zone and downstream of coupons
welds – Intelligent pigging
of pipelines
DEGRADATION
MORPHOLOGY
INSPECTION /
CAUSES OCCURRENCE SUSCEPTIBLE SYSTEMS MANAGEMENT
MONITORING METHODS
DEGRADATION
MORPHOLOGY
INSPECTION /
CAUSES OCCURRENCE SUSCEPTIBLE SYSTEMS MANAGEMENT
MONITORING METHODS
– Oxygen in an aqueous – All aerated water- – Water injection: – Process parameter – Oxygen removal
phase wetted locations pipework, vessels, pumps monitoring, e.g. $EAERATION OXYGEN
– Oxygen ingress e.g. at – Pipework – straights, and flowlines oxygen scavenger scavenging)
leaks bends, welds – Seawater system residual, flow rate – Leak prevention
– Under dosing – Vessels – Firewater system – UT AVOID OXYGEN
oxyscavenger – Exacerbated by deposits – Open drains – Radiography ingress)
– Inadequate UNDER DEPOSIT CORROSION – Heating and cooling – Corrosion probes / – Monitor oxygen
performance of medium coupons – See EI Guidance
mechanical deaeration document Appdx B,
7ATER INJECTION Sections 3, 6 and 7
systems)
DEGRADATION
MORPHOLOGY
General oxygen corrosion Oxygen corrosion at welds Oxygen corrosion at the inlet of a
deaerator tower
INSPECTION /
CAUSES OCCURRENCE SUSCEPTIBLE SYSTEMS MANAGEMENT
MONITORING METHODS
DEGRADATION
MORPHOLOGY
INSPECTION /
CAUSES OCCURRENCE SUSCEPTIBLE SYSTEMS MANAGEMENT
MONITORING METHODS
– Dissimilar metals in a – All plant, especially at: – Seawater systems are – UT – Materials selection
corrosive electrolyte – Welds particularly susceptible – Radiography – Weld consumable
–Incorrect weld n 3CREWED lTTINGS SMALL – Water injection selection/weld
metallurgy anode / large cathode – Hydrocarbon systems procedures
–Defects in noble metal combination) – Drains – Gasket selection
coatings – Some types of gasket – Electroless nickel plated – Use insulating gasket
pipework and vessels sets/ insulating spool
– Noble metallic coatings,
– Corrosion resistant alloy WHERE APPROPRIATE
e.g. nickel plated carbon
clad carbon steel vessels – Sacrificial spool /
carbon steel
– Under insulation coat cathode / CP
– Dissimilar metals in – See EI Guidance
pumps document Appdx B,
Section 5
DEGRADATION
MORPHOLOGY
DEGRADATION
MORPHOLOGY
Corrosion at weld heat affected Weld corrosion Corrosion at weld heat affected
zone zone
INSPECTION /
CAUSES OCCURRENCE SUSCEPTIBLE SYSTEMS MANAGEMENT
MONITORING METHODS
– Synergy of two – Centred on the 6 o’clock – Water injection pipework – Monitor parameters – Mitigate primary
or more corrosion position of horizontal / and pipelines influencing primary MECHANISMS #/2,
mechanisms , i.e. near horizontal pipelines – Production fluid mechanisms O2, MIC, erosion)
erosion, oxygen, pipework and pipelines. – Intelligent pigging – Materials selection
carbon dioxide, – See EI Guidance
microbial and H2S document Appdx B,
corrosion Section 3
DEGRADATION
MORPHOLOGY
INSPECTION /
CAUSES OCCURRENCE SUSCEPTIBLE SYSTEMS MANAGEMENT
MONITORING METHODS
– Differential – Flange/gasket – All systems, carbon – Difficult for flanges – Materials selection, e.g. gaskets,
concentration cell interfaces steel and stainless – Visual inspection, instrument tubing materials
– Under clamps on steel. Especially especially during – Weld overlay flange faces with
instrument tubing seawater systems maintenance corrosion resistant alloy
– Bolt/flange interfaces OXYGEN CONTAINING n 4EMPORARY PRESERVATIVES WAX
grease) on fasteners and tube
clamps
– Inhibitor impregnated clamps for
instrument tubing
– Inspection - planned and
opportunistic
– See EI Guidance document
Appndx B, Section 8
DEGRADATION
MORPHOLOGY
INSPECTION /
CAUSES OCCURRENCE SUSCEPTIBLE SYSTEMS MANAGEMENT
MONITORING METHODS
– Coatings degradation/ – Field applied coatings – All coated topsides – Visual inspection – Fabric maintenance
DAMAGE EG LACK OF especially susceptible pipework, vessels – Subsea - video – Materials selection,
fabric maintenance) to degradation – Structures inspection by ROV e.g. galvanised
– Inadequate surface – Carbon steel bolting / – Bolting and fittings – CP potential bolting
preparation prior to fasteners – Gratings and walkways monitoring and – Coat hot stainless
coating – Subsea structures and SURVEY 3UBSEA steels
– Pitting corrosion of
– Deposit build-up on components – Avoid deposit build-
stainless steel
pipework / vessels up
– Stress corrosion
– Incorrect materials – Cathodic protection
cracking of stainless
selection, e.g. carbon 3UBSEA
steel
steel bolting on stainless – Risk based inspection
flanges – See EI Guidance
document Appdx B,
– Inadequate cathodic
Sections 9, 14 and 15
PROTECTION 3UBSEA
DEGRADATION
MORPHOLOGY
INSPECTION /
CAUSES OCCURRENCE SUSCEPTIBLE SYSTEMS MANAGEMENT
MONITORING METHODS
– Wet insulation – CUI tends to be at 6 o’clock – Insulated pipework – Visual inspection – Avoid insulation
location on pipework / vessels and vessels across all – Strip and search where possible
– Damaged or missing
/ attachments; but can occur systems – Real time radiography – Effective coatings
Cladding
at any orientation – Heat traced – Thermography for and maintenance of
– Degraded seals on components wet insulation coatings
sheet metal – Higher probability and rate
– Pulsed eddy current – Fabric maintenance
cladding of corrosion on warm / hot – RBI
– Missing or damaged pipework – See EI Guidance
coating ª# TO ª# FOR CARBON STEEL document Appdx B,
– Chloride pitting and cracking Sections 10 and 14
of stainless steels – See also: EFC WP15
Corrosion Under
Insulation Guidelines
DEGRADATION
MORPHOLOGY
#ORROSION UNDER INSULATION CARBON Damaged cladding #5) WITH TELLTALE STAINING 6ESSEL
steel pipework) o’clock location)
INSPECTION /
CAUSES OCCURRENCE SUSCEPTIBLE SYSTEMS MANAGEMENT
MONITORING METHODS
– Chlorides in oxygenated – Internally and externally – Hot topsides stainless – Process parameter – Paint/thermally
environment acting on n 3TAINLESS STEEL 3## steel pipework and monitoring, e.g. sprayed aluminium
susceptible materials – Duplex stainless steel vessels temperature, – Materials selection
– May occur as an internal – High strength carbon – Subsea cathodically chloride – Follow weld
mechanism in absence steel protected duplex concentration procedures and QC
of oxygen at high stainless steel, e.g. – Eddy current – Temperature control
chloride levels and high manifolds, pipelines – Dye penetrant n #0 DESIGN SUBSEA
– Especially areas of stress n /VERPROTECTED #0 HIGH – UT – Diode control of CP
temperature
concentration, e.g. welds strength carbon steel – Radiography – See EI Guidance
– Impact of CP of duplex
or high residual stress 3UBSEA – Visual document Appdx B,
33 SUBSEA (YDROGEN
Induced Stress Cracking) Section 11
n $RY METHANOL TITANIUM
n !MINES CARBON STEEL IN
scrubbing systems)
DEGRADATION
MORPHOLOGY
INSPECTION /
CAUSES OCCURRENCE SUSCEPTIBLE SYSTEMS MANAGEMENT
MONITORING METHODS
– High fluid flow rates – Solids-containing fluids – Any system exposed to – Monitor process – Flow control
– Sand/solids/proppant – Pipework – straights, sand / solids production, parameters, e.g. flow – Sand management
n 3AND WASHING EG bends, welds especially: rate, solids prod’n – Well management
separators) – Vessels - Risers, rate – Erosion resistant
– Valves - Valves, – UT materials, facings
- 1st stage, test/ – Radiography and coatings
– Flow obstructions, e.g.
clean-up separators – Acoustic probes – Increase pipe
thermowells
- Produced water – Intrusive erosion diameter and/or
system probes bend radius
– Corrosion resistant – See EI Guidance
coupons document Appdx B,
Section12
DEGRADATION
MORPHOLOGY
Orifice plate erosion – High flow Erosion at a bend Eroded valve cage
rates and solids
INSPECTION /
CAUSES OCCURRENCE SUSCEPTIBLE SYSTEMS MANAGEMENT
MONITORING METHODS
– Combination of flow – All water-wetted – All systems especially: – Monitor process – Flow control
AND CORRODENT EG locations - Three phase systems parameters, e.g. – Sand management
carbon dioxide or –Especially locations – Produced water factors affecting – Well management
oxygen) of flow disruption / – Seawater / water primary mechanisms, – Erosion resistant
acceleration injection flow rate materials, facings
– Pipework – straights, – UT and coatings
bends, tees, welds, – Radiography – Increase pipe
valves, downstream of – Corrosion monitoring diameter and/or
pumps bend radius
– Vessels, especially – See EI Guidance
document Appdx B,
nozzles, areas of
impingement Section12
DEGRADATION
MORPHOLOGY
Erosion corrrosion of carbon steel Errosion corrosion of cunifer Erosion corrosion of stainless steel
#OPPER NICKEL ALLOY
INSPECTION /
CAUSES OCCURRENCE SUSCEPTIBLE SYSTEMS MANAGEMENT
MONITORING METHODS
– Inadequately supported – Small bore – All systems, especially at: – Visual inspection – Stress analysis
pipework PIPEWORK &ATIGUE - Pipe supports – Radiography – Review and modify
– Slug flow in pipework or – CRA pipework - Through wall – Vibration supports
vessels TENDS TO BE THINNER penetrations monitoring – Hydrodynamic
– Strong vibration sources, e.g. wall than carbon - Heat exchangers, modelling
reciprocating compressors STEEL n &ATIGUE baffles / tube – Risk based inspection
– Flexing of structures, – Fretting, e.g. pipe supports – Vibration monitoring
e.g. FPSO tanks and deck supports, deck /wall – Adhere to Energy
supports Institute Avoidance
penetrations, heat
– Acoustic resonance in gas exchanger pipe of vibration induced
systems fatigue failure
supports/baffles
– Inadequate chemical guidelines
injection quill design
– Thermal cycling
DEGRADATION
MORPHOLOGY
Fatigue crack of structural web Fretting pipework at a deck Fatigue fracture of small bore
penetration tubing
INSPECTION /
CAUSES OCCURRENCE SUSCEPTIBLE SYSTEMS MANAGEMENT
MONITORING METHODS
– Co-produced organic – Acidic Corrosion – Acidic corrosion – Acidic corrosion – Acidic corrosion
acids, e.g. acetic acid -All water-wetted locations - Hydrocarbon - UT - Corrosion resistant
– Glycol decomposition production - Radiography alloy
0IPEWORK STRAIGHTS
products systems, including - Corrosion probes - Chemical inhibition
o’clock)/bends/tees/
– Well acidisation and gas systems, /coupons – LME
reducers
returns glycol regen., – LME - Remove mercury
- Welds, HAZ and
- PW system - Dye penetrant/ - Materials’ selection
– Acidic production downstream welds
– Liquid Metal MPI – Production chemical
chemicals, e.g. scale – Liquid Metal Embrittlement Embrittlement corrosion
inhibitor, acetic acid,
- Copper alloys in the -Hydrocarbon - Correct use of
oxygen scavenger
presence of co-produced production injection quills
– Co-produced mercury mercury. - Switch off injection
systems, including
,IQUID -ETAL while plant is not
- Aluminium in the presence gas systems
%MBRITTLEMENT ,-% in use
of co-produced mercury
DEGRADATION
MORPHOLOGY
Corrosion by acidic production Corrosion caused by acetic acid ,-% OF BRASS 4UNGUM TUBING BY
CHEMICAL 3CALE INHIBITOR used to treat high naphthenic acid mercury
crude oil
Issued under licence to BP employees only.
IMPORTANT: This file is subject to a licence agreement issued by the Energy Institute, London, UK. All rights reserved. It may only be used in accordance with Corrosion threats guide 26
the licence terms and conditions. It must not be forwarded to, or stored or accessed by, any unauthorised user. Enquiries: e: [email protected] t: +44 (0)207 467 7100
energy Institute This publication has been produced as a result of
61 New Cavendish Street work carried out within the Technical Team of the
London W1G 7AR, UK Energy Institute (EI), funded by the EI’s Technical
Partners. The EI’s Technical Work Programme
t: +44 (0) 20 7467 7157 provides industry with cost effective, value adding
f: +44 (0) 20 7255 1472 knowledge on key current and future issues
e: [email protected] affecting those operating in the energy sector,
www.energyinst.org both in the UK and beyond.