J Rser 2017 10 013
J Rser 2017 10 013
A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T
Keywords: India receives sun's energy over 300 days a year most of the time. About 5000 trillion kWh per year sun's energy
Solar energy is incident over India's land area. Theoretically, a small fraction of total incident solar energy can meet the entire
PV country's power requirements. There are many government schemes to promote solar power generation. The
BIPV government of India initiated solar PV/BIPV policies to encourage industries and individuals to use solar energy
Power
powered systems for electricity generations. This article provides an overview of the solar energy status and
Energy policy
application of BIPV system in India. It includes an assessment of the region's solar energy potential and solar PV/
BIPV installed capacity. This paper gives a brief description barriers and challenges facing solar BIPV devel-
opment in India. This study also provides the solar PV/BIPV policies and recommendations with reference to the
Indian context.
1. Introduction been presenting a regular economic expansion over the past decade.
The power sector is along with the highest growing industries [7]. To
One of the greatest renewable energy sources of energy is solar meet up its current and upcoming energy requirements, India will have
energy, abundant, environmentally friendly and can be harnessed for to raise its installed solar PV capability [8] substantially. A vital way for
domestic uses. A photovoltaic device converts solar energy into electric this cooperation is India's Jawaharlal Nehru National Solar Mission
potential [1]. The application of photovoltaic technologies resolves the (JNNSM). At the similar time, higher ambitions are around the corner.
problems like green house gas emissions and climate change. Also, solar This includes a recently future PV/BIPV solar energy goal of 100 GW in
energy is secure, clean and suitable. Problems of energy shortage and 2022 [9]. The government of India has recognized the solar PV energy
environmental pollution have become more prominent, leading to division as an industry with planned significance, and it will contribute
worldwide attention on solar PV energy [2]. India has a second largest a vital role in the future energy security of India. BIPV system is
population in the world with estimated figure of 1.26 billion people [3]. growing every year [10]. Several BIPV companies, such as Schott solar,
An additional population of 600 million people is expected by the year Sanyo, Sharp and Sun-tech are operating on novel BIPV products for
2050. There are roughly 300 million citizens, first and foremost in rural facades, skylights, and windows [11]. Execution of Feed-in Tariff and
areas of India, with no access to electricity grid [4]. Consequently, other government schemes for solar energy have gained recognition all
access to electricity grid as well as 24/7 accessibility of electricity is the over the globe. Western Europe has the major sale of BIPV products,
main focus of the Indian Government. In India, the rise in income, in- and in recent times there is a vital growth in Eastern Europe [12].
novation of infrastructure and services and changing life styles are an Within subsequent five years, there may be broader recognition of BIPV
aid to increase the per capita electrical energy demand [4]. Primary product technologies in further part of the world including Europe, Asia
energy utilization in the nation has more than doubled between the Pacific, Latin America, and South Africa. Presently, there is a challenge
years 1990 and 2013, attaining an expected gross generation of about for solar production worldwide [13]. Solar photovoltaic installations
931 billion kWh per year [5]. This makes India the fourth leading en- can be mounted on the building skin resulting the chances to unite
ergy user in the world after China, the USA, and Russia. India's yearly electricity production with additional functions of the building re-
per capita electricity utilization by 2014 is about nearly 900 kWh, sources. Following the merits of building integration, various countries
which is one-third of the worldwide average [6]. This evidently in- set targets for solar PV in building sector since PV integration in
dicates the potentially higher energy requirement shortly. India has building facades shows a considerable growth in urban solar PV
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: [email protected] (A.K. Shukla), [email protected] (K. Sudhakar).
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2017.10.013
Received 8 January 2017; Received in revised form 15 August 2017; Accepted 26 October 2017
1364-0321/ © 2017 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Please cite this article as: Shukla, A.K., Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews (2017), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2017.10.013
A.K. Shukla et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews xxx (xxxx) xxx–xxx
2
A.K. Shukla et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews xxx (xxxx) xxx–xxx
2.2. Status of BIPV system Where, EPV=Energy value of photovoltaic system, BPV,out=Building
photovoltaic output (kWh), QE=Utility energy charge ($/kWh),
There is a huge market potential for the BIPV yield throughout the COPPV=Capital and operating costs of the PV energy supply system.
world. Already there is developed the market in the bigger part of the
nations in Europe i.e. France, Switzerland, Germany, Italy, and Spain 3.2. BIPV as an energy demand management technology
[32]. The worldwide market of BIPV was valued at 1201 MW in 2010
and is expected to increase at a 56% compound annual growth rate to In this configuration, BIPV system is applied as a demand man-
reach a capacity of 11,392 MW in 2015. The current BIPV product agement device. For allowing the system to operate as a dispatchable
market is shown in Fig. 5. About 20% of BIPV installation are façade peak shaving technology, it needs the addition of a moderate amount of
mounted and remaining 80% are rooftops mounted [32]. energy storage to the BIPV system [20].
BIPV technology is new to Indian development and companies such The energy value of the demand can be estimated from Eq. (2) [30]:
as Tata BP Solar, and Moser Baer Solar Ltd are pioneers in im- Edemand = [EUd (BPV , out + Bb, out ) + EPV ] − COPPV (2)
plementing this technology. Since solar PV modules used in BIPV sys-
tems forms a part of the building, sufficient amount of building material Where, Edemand=Energy demand management value of a PV peak-
can be saved. Since limited structures are not necessary for BIPV sys- shaving system, Bb,out=Battery bank output (net of round trip losses) at
tems; manufacturer cost of such system is less compared to solar PV time of building peak demand (kW), EU,d=Utility demand
systems. BIPV technology involves deployment of straight up space in The Bb, out term represents the output of the battery bank at the time
the building is subjected to its peak demand. It is a function of battery
3
A.K. Shukla et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews xxx (xxxx) xxx–xxx
Initial cost of the BIPV for the determination of the payback period.
Eq. (3) is used to estimate the energy value of a BIPV system con-
figured as emergency power and demand management source of a
building [30]:
ES = [(BE , power − CE , power ) + Edemand] − ∆CPV (3)
The economic benefit of providing backup power from the BIPV 3.5. Selection criteria for BIPV
system can be expressed as the excluded cost associated with the pur-
chase and operation of conventional emergency power systems (which Appropriate selection criteria are first set before an actual selection
includes the system components such as inverters, a control circuit, and of BIPV system (Fig. 7). The BIPV project developers normally adopt
battery storage) [22]. In this case, the proprietor or user has already standard selection criteria before the Implementation of the project.
identified the necessities of utilizing the emergency backup power Further, this also assists the developer in determining the effectiveness
source for the building. Thus, the only additional investment cost owing of the particular choice. The practical feasibility of BIPV application in
to the BIPV module, module structure, and installation cost are con- the construction projects depends on several factors such as location
sidered. The costs of an emergency backup source are excluded from and advancements of BIPV Technology in the nearby areas. The ar-
the building economic performance criterion [23]. The payback cri- chitecture design of the building is another essential criterion. This
terion of BIPV service system mainly depends on the capital costs of the criterion is foremost in deciding the outline of the project based on 3D
PV module rather than the array costs plus the balance of systems costs drawing. The project cost will determine the actual economic feasibility
consistent with the above assumption. Similarly, this approach also of the whole project and its appropriateness in the present economic
excludes the tax savings, energy savings and cost savings from the scenario of the country. The cost of BIPV technologies will influence the
4
A.K. Shukla et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews xxx (xxxx) xxx–xxx
Table 3
Applications of BIPV products.
project duration and quality of constructing the building with BIPV. The ➣ Human Resource Barriers
next criteria for evaluation will be the building cost. The profit and the ● Lack of technical experts and marketing professionals in BIPV
net saving of the BIPV building project are based on the building cost. sectors.
The estimation of the building cost will provide a target for the pene- ● Limited in-house resource capacity for data gathering, analysis,
tration of building into the appropriate market segment. The project and project management.
developer will either tender the BIPV project by providing the specifi- ● Lack of proficiency in Planning, commissioning, operation, and
cation and scope of work or subcontracting the project to other agency. maintenance of solar PV/BIPV projects.
This again depends on the capability of the main project developer of
the BIPV project and the subcontractors. The life cycle benefits of the ➣ Information Barriers
BIPV project is attributed to the maintenance of the building. ● Lack of quality information about PV resource and technologies,
BIPV, equipment suppliers and potential financiers.
● Inadequate training and capacity building.
4. Barriers and policy challenges of BIPV development in India ● Insufficient information available on BIPV for policy making and
mobilizing civil society.
Despite the enormous potential and benefit of using solar energy,
there are several barriers to overcome both at the national and regional ➣ Technical Barriers
levels. One of the main challenges is less interest shown by the users for ● Lack of standardized technology
Installation of solar PV and BIPV owing to its huge initial investment ● Limited local manufacturing of specialized equipment.
costs and high payback period [23]. ● Limited capacity in technological advancements of solar Products
The following are the barriers and challenges in solar BIPV tech- to provide reliable power.
nologies [20,22]:
5
A.K. Shukla et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews xxx (xxxx) xxx–xxx
➣ Economic Barriers security and by targeting a larger goal of attaining energy self-suffi-
● Small economies of scale, long payback period and high initial ciency [23]. The JNNSM is one of the several initiatives under the
capital costs. National Action Plan on Climate Change(NAPCC) which focuses on the
● High installation cost at the user end. gradual shift from conventional sources to a renewable source of en-
● Limited information on market potential. ergy. The JNNSM targets to harvest solar energy on a large scale, to
create a strong manufacturing base for solar energy, employment gen-
➣ Policy Barrier eration and the long term sustainability of the Indian solar power sector
● Low priority is given to BIPV in national planning and weak [24]. The National Manufacturing Policy identifies solar energy sector
implementation structure. as an industry with strategic significance along with defense, aerospace,
● Weak energy policy. and telecom and classifies it as a strategic industry under the special
● Lack of subsidies and benefits for BIPV. focus sectors. JNNSM has three phases, spanning 15 years that corre-
● The absence of feed in tariff arrangement. spond with India's five-year plans. The short-term objective targets to
● Lack of incentives for private sector participation and conflicting ensure an enabling framework for investment in solar energy [20]. Two
policies across states. recent announcements by the government of India were key in ensuring
that India attains its ambitious PV and BIPV targets [22]:
The regulatory framework and developer's requirement has to be
considered before implementation of the BIPV projects. Hence there is a • The rejection of the proposal to impose anti-import duties on the
need to look deeper into the various drivers, enablers and barriers imported solar PV and BIPV module.
which drive the selection criteria. All the three factors (drivers, enablers • The proposed ambitious new target of 100 GW installed capacity by
and barriers) are interconnected. The enablers are the factors which are 2022.
important, however it doesn’t significantly govern the BIPV im-
plementation. On one hand, the barriers are the factors that hamper the The current domestic capacity is attainable to meet the revived
progress of BIPV projects. On the other hand, the drivers are the factors JNNSM targets. Indian Government recently decided not to impose anti
that help to overcome the barriers to implement the BIPV project. Based clearance duties on the import of solar BIPV modules. However, the
on the developers perceptive, lack of promotion, lack of incentive, government did announce to support the Indian manufacturers in the
Limited expertise and implementation readiness are the various barriers form of domestic procurement from public sector companies [21].
(Fig. 8). Despite facing several barriers, the developers have identified Some of the major central government players related to solar BIPV
some drivers to overcome the barriers. Promotion and Incentives are listed is shown in Table 4
mutually advantageous and complement each other. Furthermore, Other key points the government mentioned would address are:
these incentives will encourage the developers and as a result, it will
speed up the growth of the BIPV projects. Not only it will assist in the o Increased focus on rooftop segments;
promotion of BIPV but also reduce the burden of the principal loan o Streamlining of policy implementation processes;
amount needed by the building buyers [34]. o Increase availability of a power evacuation infrastructure;
o Main focus on large scale projects (Solar farms and Solar park);
o Enforce Renewable Energy Purchase Obligations.
5. Future prospects of PV and BIPV in India
Bridge to India, a renowned consulting firm in the renewable energy 6. Policy recommendation
sector, has estimated the deployment of solar PV installations in India
till the year 2024 [29]. Having classified the systems by scale (Re- BIPV system needs policies modified to the situations surrounding
sidential, Commercial & Industrial), the firm projects the deployment this particular technology rather than broader support aimed at solar
potential of rooftop solar BIPV system and ground mounted i.e. land energy system. As energy falls mainly under Indian government, these
based solar PV utility scale systems for the next ten years (Fig. 9). strategies options are mostly aimed at regional judgment makers [24].
India's energy policy has been designed by its need to ensure energy However, the central government has a facilitative role to play in
6
A.K. Shukla et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews xxx (xxxx) xxx–xxx
7
A.K. Shukla et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews xxx (xxxx) xxx–xxx
• India has launched several programs like Digital India, Clean India,
Energy Rev 2015;43:621–34.
[6] Shukla AK, Sudhakar K, Baredar P. A comprehensive review on design of building
Green India etc to transform the entire energy scenario of the integrated photovoltaic system. Energy Build 2016;128:99–110.
[7] Mekhilef S, Barimani M, Safari A, Salam Z. Malaysia's renewable energy policies and
country through wider applications of the solar PV. However sig-
programs with green aspects. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2014;40:497–504.
nificant investment in R & D and BIPV installation are yet to start. [8] Shukla AK, Sudhakar K, Baredar P. Simulation and performance analysis of 110
• The Indian government has introduced several policies, missions kWp grid-connected photovoltaic system for residential building in India: a com-
parative analysis of various PV technologies. Energy Rep 2016;2:82–8.
and ambitious targets to promote solar PV in large scale. However
[9] Abdmouleh Z, Alammari RAM, Gastli A. Recommendations on renewable energy
public participation and acceptance of the technology are the major policies for the GCC countries. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2015;50:1181–91.
issues hindering the growth. [10] Shukla AK, Sudhakar K, Baredar P. Exergetic assessment of BIPV module using
• At the state and national level, solar PV/BIPV installation in the parametric and photonic energy methods: a review. Energy Build 2016;119:62–73.
[11] Shaikha PH, Nor NBM, Sahitoa AA, Nallagownden P, Elamvazuthi I, Shaikh MS.
residential, commercial and Industrial sector can drive economic Building energy for sustainable development in Malaysia: a review. Renew Sustain
growth and energy security through technological innovation and Energy Rev 2016. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2016.11.128.
diversification. [12] Solangi KH, Islam MR, Saidur R, Rahim NA, Fayaz H. A review on global solar
• A new PV roadmap with clear pathways and priorities addressing incident on horizontal and tilted surface at Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh India. Am
Eurasia J Agric Environ Sci 2015;15:129–39.
several problems like a high share of PV in the energy portfolio and [16] Cheng CL, Jimenez Charles S Sanchez, Lee Meng-Chieh. Research of BIPV optimal
suitable solutions such as Nano DC grid and Smart grid technologies tilted angle, use of latitude concept for south orientated plans. Renew Energy
may be needed. 2009;34:1644–50.
•
[17] Shukla KN, Sudhakar K, Rangnekar S. Comparative study of isotropic and aniso-
Much more collaborative efforts between central government, state tropic sky models to estimate solar radiation incident on tilted surface: a case study
government, and the civic community is needed to ensure the de- for Bhopal, India. Energy Rep 2015;1:96–103.
velopment of the solar PV industry as a whole. [18] Sudhakar K, Srivastava T. Energy and exergy analysis of 36W solar photovoltaic
•
module. Int J Ambient Energy 2013:770799. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/01430750.
The majority of the small and medium sized solar PV installers focus 2013.
on PV installations on residential, industrial and institutional roof- [19] Kumar BS, Sudhakar K. Performance evaluation of 10 MW grid connected solar
tops. Solar rooftop PV installations had seen extensive development, photovoltaic power plant in India. Energy Rep 2015;1:184–92.
[20] Shukla KN, Sudhakar K, Rangnekar S. Mathematical modelling of solar radiation
in some of the Indian states like Tamil Nadu Rajasthan and Gujarat, incident on tilted surface for photovoltaic application at Bhopal, M.P., India. Int J
etc. Ambient Energy 04/2015. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/01430750.2015.102383.
• BIPV technologies have also been indicated for specific applications, [21] Bertrand SL, Rosenbloom D, Meadowcroft J. A strategy for building-integrated
photovoltaic's in Canada. Rev 2012;2.
like a residential building, petrol stations, airport building and car [22] New solar PV business opportunities between the Netherlands and India.
parking structures. BIPV technologies may see a rise with the plans RijksdienstVoorOndernemend Netherland, Final report March; 2015.
of the Indian government to set up 100 smart cities all over the [23] Shaikh PH, Nor NBM, Nallagownden P, Elamvazuthi I, Ibrahim TA. Review on
optimized control System for building energy and comfort management of smart
country.
•
sustainable buildings. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2014;34:409–29.
Meanwhile, the central and state governments should encourage [24] Kwong QJ, Ali YA. Review of energy efficiency potentials in tropical buildings
BIPV research and development investments to drive cost reduction Perspective of enclosed common areas. Renew Sustain Energy Rev
and financial growth. A major thrust of research and development in 2011;15:4548–53.
[25] Hashim H, Ho WS. Renewable energy policies and initiatives for a sustainable en-
BIPV technologies is essential to lower the generation rate and en- ergy future in Malaysia. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2011;15:4780–7.
able a competition with the conventional energy based options. [26] Yang L, Lam JC, Tsang CL. Energy performance of building envelopes in different
• Learning from other developed nations in Europe and US, India can climate zones in China. Appl Energy 2008;85:800–17.
[27] Abdul RM, Teong LK. Energy for sustainable development in Malaysia: energy
be a worldwide leader in solar PV/BIPV installation. With an am- policy and alternative energy. Energy Policy 2006;34.15:2388–97.
bitious solar assignment and positively evolving BIPV policy, the [28] Haris AH, Ding J. The final report on the renewable energy policy and action plan;
nation will rightly adorn the handle of Solar India in the near future. 2009.
[29] Sharma SS. The relationship between energy and economic growth: empirical evi-
dence from 66countries. Appl Energy 2010;87.11:3565–74.
8
A.K. Shukla et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews xxx (xxxx) xxx–xxx
[30] Byrne J, Alleng G, Zhou A. Economics of building integrated PV In China. Shanghai, [33] Goh KC, Yap ABK, Goh HH, Seow TW, Toh TC. Awareness and Initiatives of
China: The Pacific Energy Center (China) and Environmental Market Solutions, Inc. Building Integrated Photovoltaic (BIPV) implementation in Malaysian Housing
(U.S.); 2001. Industry. Procedia Eng 2015;118:1052–9.
[31] 〈www.tatapowersolar.com/Projects/BIPV-solar-project〉. [34] Shukla AK, Sudhakar K, Baredar Prashant, Mamat R. BIPV in Southeast Asian
[32] Shukla AK, Sudhakar K, Baredar P. Recent advancement in BIPV product technol- countries –opportunities and challenges. In Renewable Energy Focus
ogies: a review. Energy Build 2017;140:188–95. 2017;21:25–32. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ref.2017.07.001.