4 - 1 Functional Hygienic Design
4 - 1 Functional Hygienic Design
Functional Hygienic
D i
Design
Advanced Hygienic Design
Processing Engineering School
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Wh & When
Why Wh
Functional Hygienic Design
Why?
y
Legal demands related to hygiene;
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Functional Hygienic
D i
Design
Production Demands
Food processing
Anything special?
Sequencing
Automatic interactions
Manual interactions
Phase logics
Alarm handling
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Food processing
Water hammer
Manual interference with sensors
Cleaning of tank outlets without pressure
Unique
q Valve Seat Cleaning g
Manual override
Possible to bypass manual overrides...
Calibration
Feed-back levels, Control levels, Mechanisation level
More?
M ?
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Phase Logics
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Interlock
Interlock is a summary of conditions e.g. cleaning
phase running, production phase running etc and other
conditions that will prevent a phase from starting.
RunningFault
RunningFault is a summary of conditions e.g. valve
fault, motor fault and other faults that will prevent a
phase from starting or if the phase is running, enter
held state. The RunningFault is also evaluated before
restart of a phase.
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
General automation
General
If any control module that affects the phase is set in manual mode,
the phase shall be interlocked. The interlock shall be possible to
b
bypass b
by authorized
th i d user.
Changed parameters shall take immediate effect in the program.
Alarm and hold functions must exist in phases if abnormal process
events occur.
Logging
Access levels
Production demands
Performance on filling/emptying
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Flush 1
Flush 1
These distances
must be very short
7
8
2
CIP Return
Flush 2 Production
line
Reclaim
Drain
Drain Line valve
Flush 3
Flush 3
Flush 3
3
5
Parameter name
1. FillToDrainAmount (emptying, source tank)
2. FlushToDrainAmount ((emptying,
p y g, source tank))
3. FillToDestAmount (production)
5. FlushToDestAmount (production)
7. FillToTankAmount (filling, dest tank)
Internal
8. FlushToTankAmount (filling, dest tank) AHD & AM / 2013
Flushes
Flush 1
Flush 2
Flush 3
Affecting hygiene if not working properly
Filli
Filling and
d flushing
fl hi off allll pipes
i shall
h ll b
be b
basedd on
amount. In parallel a timer will run. When either the
amount or time is attained, the filling or flushing is
finalised. Alarm when timer is attained.
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
e of liquids
Pre Flush Flush Final
rinse rinse
ProductB Flow
Mixture
ProductA ProductA
Drain
Drain
Drain
Reclaim
Reclaim
Reclaim
Reclaim
CIP Desti-
Product Product Product
nation
Return Tank 2 Tank 1 Tank 1
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Traceability levels
Example
If products from several road tankers are received
through the same reception line without flushing or
cleaning between
between, there are two volumes moving
through the line every time there is a product change.
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Traceability level 3
Reclaim
Batch 2 started
C01C01 C01C02
Reclaim
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Traceability level 3
C01C01 C01C02
C01C01 C01C02
A B
Batch 2 in full production R01X01
Conclusion:
Reclaim
Necessary to check
Water in product
Product/CIP safety – solutions & interlocks
Foreign material contamination
Product sequencing
Product change
g
Traceability demands
Automation error control – phase logics
Interface to external equipment
Critical control points
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Production
PFS for Production VG10&Line Stepp RUNNING
procedure:
HELD
Idle
WaitForSource
Description FillToDest
Cleaning pressure, Flush 2 and cleaning return FillToReclaim
functionality. The design element is located after Production
p
a valve cluster with non mixproof connections. ProdToDest
Automation system must check that the correct ProdToReclaim
proximity switches are activated when different FlushToDest G02Q0002 G02Q0002
paths are selected. Also the proximity switches G02Q0001 (2-3 seconds delay)
that should not be activated have to be G02Q0003 (5-6 seconds delay)
controlled. All functions are started from the Deactivation
deactivate G02Q0003
control room.
deactivate G02Q0001 (2-3 seconds
delay)
A pushbutton box with 3 buttons is needed deactivate G02Q0002 (5-6 seconds
Button 1 = Confirmation of performed connection delay)
for production “Production Request” (G01BG001) FlushToReclaim G02Q0002 G02Q0002
G02Q0001
Q ((2-3 seconds delay)
y)
Button 2 = Confirmation of performed connection
G02Q0003 (5-6 seconds delay)
for CIP of line 1 “CIP Request, line 1” V01BG001) Deactivation
Button 3 = Confirmation of performed connection deactivate G02Q0003
for CIP of line 2 “CIP Request, line 2”(V01BG501) deactivate G02Q0001 (2-3 seconds
delay)
deactivate G02Q0002 (5-6 seconds
d l )
delay)
FlushToDrain G02Q0002 G02Q0002
CIP Line 1 G02Q0001 (2-3 seconds delay)
G02Q0003 (5-6 seconds delay)
Line 2 Deactivation
Line 1 deactivate G02Q0003
deactivate
deact vate G02Q0001
G0 Q000 (2-3 ( 3 seconds
seco ds
delay)
deactivate G02Q0002 (5-6 seconds
delay)
Draining Internal
Completed AHD & AM / 2013
Idle
CIP (Cleaning)
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Functional Hygienic
D i
Design
CIP Recipes
Cleaning demands
Dependent on previous production
Product
P d t
–Proteins, fat
–Adhesiveness, cohesiveness, stickiness
Production parameters
–Time
–Temperature
Temperature
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Cleaning demands
Dependent on new production
Need of CIP
Need of disinfection Hot Water
Need of disinfection Chemical
Need of sanitary air in pipe&tank systems
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Recipe exercise
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Cleaning sequence
Pre-rinsing
with water at 50-60°C, to remove sugar and melt any fats. The
temperature should not exceed 60°C in order to avoid denaturing of the
proteins,
t i which
hi h th
then b
become much h more diffi
difficult
lt tto clean.
l
Cleaning with an alkaline detergent
to remove proteins and fats.
Rinsing with water
to remove any residues of the alkaline detergent.
Cleaning with an acidic detergent
to dissolve mineral salts and the deposits left by hard water. This is
repeated as often as necessary, depending on whether the surfaces
are hot or cold, the type of food and the water quality.
Rinsing with water
to remove any residues of the acidic detergent.
(Sterilisation or disinfection)
to kill bacterias or or other living organisms to a certain level
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Standard Recipes
Program 1 Program 2 Program 3
Caustic recipe Acid recipe Caustic & Acid recipe
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Design
g a CIP recipe
p for
Decide
Necessary steps
Temperatures
Times
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Design
g a CIP recipe
p for
Decide
Necessary steps
Temperatures
Times
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Functional Hygienic
D i
Design
CIP systems
Security level
NN/MMYY
CIP Systems
Re-use system
• Centralised CIP systems (recovery systems)
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Tetra Alcip
CIP liquid
q – Single
g path/single
p g use
Advantages
Advantages
Always new CIP liquids
Reduced consumptions
Inexpensive investment
Less load on waste water
system
Disadvantages
Disadvantages
High running cost
More expensive investment
High environmental load
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Centralised CIP
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Decentralised CIP
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Centralised or decentralised
CIP systems?
Centralised Decentralised
• Advantages • Advantages
– One control – Could be shorter p
piping
p g
– Handling of CIP liquids – Low losses of energy
at one location – Raw and processed separated
– Handling of product recovery
at one location
– Recovery of chemicals • Disadvantages
– One PLC at each CIP station
• Disadvantages – Detergent tanks in production
– Long piping – No recovery of chemicals
– Higher
g losses of energy
gy – Difficult recovery of product
– Two stations needed for raw
and processed
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Necessary to check
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Functional Hygienic
D i
Design
CIP parameters
Connecting
gpphysical
y reality
y to functionality
y
Securing correct recipe performance
Object oriented optimization
Achieving handling of mix phases
A hi i expected
Achieving t d performance
f
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
NCSD FCMT
CCSD
ACSD FCA
RWCSD
CDCSD
CIP Line
- Temperature
- Conductivity
C
PRTSD=
CIP Circuit
PRCSD= Recovery
WWTSD=
WWCSD
Drain Caust Chem
Neutr FW Acid RW
ic
CIP Line
- Pump Speed
-Flow Control
FTTA
CL Parameters CC Parameters FTTMT
AcidCondSortDelay (ACSD) FillCircleAmount (FCA)
CausticCondSortDelay (CCSD) FillCircleMaxTime (FCMT)
RinseWCondSortDelay (RWCSD)
FillToTankAmount (FTTA)
ProRecTurbSortDelay (PRTSD)
ProRecCondSortDelay (PRCSD)
FillToTankMaxTime (FTTMT)
WhiteWaterCondSortDelay (WWCSD)
WhiteWaterTurbSortDelay (WWTSD)
ChemDesCondSortDelay (CDCSD) Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
NeutrCondSortDelay (NCSD)
8 8 5 4 5 4
1 1 2
2
Chemical Caustic Product
Disinfectant
Acid 7 6 7 6
9 9 9 9
3
Drain
Drain
Drain
Drain
Drain
Drain
Chem Acid Caustic Product
tank tank tank Recovery
CL Parameters
P t CC Parameters 11 12
1. AcidCondSortLimit 11. MixZoneBackupAmount
2. CausticCondSortLimit 12. MixZoneBackupTime
3. RinseWCondSortLimit 13. PlugAmount
4. ProRecTurbSortLimit 14. AcidToDrainTime
5. ProRecCondSortLimit 15. CausticToDrainTime
6. WhiteWaterTurbSortLimit 16. ChemDisToDrainTime
7. WhiteWaterCondSortLimit
Internal
8. ChemDisCondSortLimit AHD & AM / 2013
9. NeutrCondSortLimit
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Functional Hygienic
D i
Design
Operational Qualification
Security level
NN/MMYY
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Operational qualification
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Findings
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Findings
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Findings
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Summary of findings
Aseptic transfer
• Valves on aseptic transfer line not properly cleaned
• Sand deposit found in aseptic tank
• High level in the aseptic tank during cleaning 1400
litres remaining during the first drainage
• Low concentration alarm during alkal cleaning, 3000
litres remaining in tank at the end of cleaning
• Alkali and acid solution mixed in aseptic tank
• Sample of final rinse water still contained 0,3% alkali
Root cause?
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Customer View
Energy Emissions
Raw materials
Salaries Products
Capital
Cleaning solution
Product losses Water losses
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013
Commissioning Tests
Performance Exercise
Internal
AHD & AM / 2013