See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/267807909

Teachers' Perceptions on the Blended Learning Environment for Special

Needs Learners in Malaysia: A Case study

Article · January 2011

CITATIONS READS

3 1,986

6 authors, including:

Anuar Mohd Yusof Esther Gnanamalar Sarojini Daniel

University of Malaysia, Kelantan University of Malaya
31 PUBLICATIONS 203 CITATIONS 84 PUBLICATIONS 458 CITATIONS

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Wah Yun Low Kamarulzaman Ab. Aziz

University of Malaya Multimedia University
475 PUBLICATIONS 7,188 CITATIONS 93 PUBLICATIONS 879 CITATIONS

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

All content following this page was uploaded by Wah Yun Low on 17 November 2014.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.

 2011 2nd International Conference on Education and Management Technology
IPEDR vol.13 (2011) © (2011) IACSIT Press, Singapore

Teachers’ Perceptions on the Blended Learning Environment for

Special Needs Learners in Malaysia: A Case study

Anuar Mohd Yusof 1, Esther Gnanamalar Sarojini Daniel 2, Wah Yun Low 3, and Kamarulzaman Ab.
Aziz 4
1
Institute of Graduate Studies, University of Malaya. Malaysia
2
Faculty of Education, University of Malaya, Malaysia
3
Faculty of Medicine, University of Malaya, Malaysia
4
Faculty of Management, Multimedia University, Malaysia
1
Abstract. The recent transformation of Malaysia’s education system, among others, had highlighted the
importance of special education. This can be seen in the integration of special education into a number of
selected mainstream national schools. The selected schools were provided space and facilities for the special
needs education. Moreover, Malaysia had been promoting the utilization of Information communication
technology (ICT) for special education. This blended learning environment is the focus of this paper. The
blended learning environment and the usage of ICT for the special education are still in the early stages. This
study aims to investigate teachers’ perceptions on blended learning for special needs learners. Interviews
were conducted to collect related information on teachers’ perceptions on the blended learning in the selected
school. The benefits and challenges of implementing blended learning for special education are also
discussed.
Keywords: Information Communication Technology (ICT), Special Education, Blended Learning.

1. Introduction
The transformation of Malaysia’s education system has highlighted the importance of special education.
The significance was clear as special education was specifically mentioned in the Ninth Malaysia Plan
unveiled in EPU (2006); “The Special Education Integration Programme was expanded to integrate children
with special needs into the normal school environment. Under this programme, the national curriculum was
adopted for visually and hearing impaired children in primary and secondary schools. An adaptive
curriculum was used for children with learning disabilities”(p. 242). This has led to the integration of special
education into a number of selected mainstream national schools. The selected schools were provided space
and facilities for the special needs education. According to the Ninth Malaysia Plan (EPU, 2006),
“Educational opportunities for children with special needs will be expanded by opening special classes in
regular schools to enable these children to adapt to the normal school environment. To improve the quality of
teaching and learning, more teachers will be trained and the curriculum for special education will be further
improved”(p. 255). Moreover, the transformation process included the utilization of Information
communication technology. In the Ninth Malaysia Plan, EPU (2006) was stated that, “During the Plan period,
the Program Pembestarian Sekolah (Smart School Programmes) refers to the process of leveraging on all
existing ICT initiatives such as the smart school project, computerization project, utilising ICT in the
teaching and learning of Science and Mathematics in English, SchoolNet and MySchoolNet to enhance the
quality of education. This program will be implemented in all primary and secondary schools to enable

1+
Corresponding author. Tel.: + 60199696600;
E-mail address: [email protected] .
29
teachers to integrate ICT in teaching, learning and management”(p. 255) This also included special education.
In order to realise the transformation, the Malaysian government allocated RM 45.1 billion (US$15 billion).
The focus on ICT in the Malaysian education system can also be seen in the Multimedia Super Corridor
initiative. The MSC Malaysia Smart School Flagship initiative responds to the need for Malaysia to make the
critical transition from an industrial economy to a knowledge-based one. The objective is to produce a
technologically literate and thinking workforce, which is well able to perform in a global environment and
use information-age tools and technology to improve productivity. The Ministry of Education, with Telekom
Smart School Sdn. Bhd. acting as the industrial counterpart, heads the Smart School initiative. The project’s
implementation plan was divided into four phases; i) Pilot project (1999 – 2002), ii) Post pilot project (2002
– 2005), iii) Making all schools smart (2005 – 2010), and iv) Consolidate and stabilize (2010 – 2020)
(MDeC, 2009). According to the plan, the smart school programme was to be implemented beyond the initial
88 schools to all schools in the country between 2005 till 2010. This project benefitted from the largest
allocation from the Seventh Malaysia Plan – RM 401.1 million (US$133 million)
According to the Malaysian policies on ICT in education which also has a focus on the special education,
teaches are encouraged to implement the ICT as their routine by listing out the four key elements as below
(MOE, 2010):
• ICT tools and devices such as screen readers and ‘embosses’ will be part of the ICT infrastructure
provided to schools for the students with special needs.
• Teachers in schools for students with special needs will be trained and sensitized to issues specially-
related to the use of ICT in teaching students with special needs.
• All teachers’ in schools for students with special needs will be provided with ICT-enabled methods
during their professional development.
• Web-based digital repositories should be deployed to address the lack of availability of resources for
students with special needs.
In the year 2010, the Ministry of Education revised the policy on the utilization of ICT in education. The
revised strategy included the adoption of a new teaching approach - blended learning. Blended learning
incorporates face to face learning with ICT as the mediated-tools (Graham, in press; Reay, 2001; Rooney,
2003). ICT or e-learning tools provide a supportive learning experience (Graham, in press; Reay, 2001;
Rooney, 2003). Given the importance placed on ICT and special education, it is the belief of the authors of
this paper that an investigation of the impact of the latest strategy – blended learning – from the various
stakeholders would be beneficial. Thus, this study aims to investigate the teachers’ perceptions on blended
learning for special needs learner. Teachers are the most important stakeholders involved other than the
students themselves. The paper will discuss the benefits of the blended learning environment and explore
how it affects the teaching methods for special education. Specifically, the paper will investigate the
teachers’ opinions in relation to the blended learning approach, and then the benefits and its challenges will
be discussed.

1.1. Sampling
Purposive sampling was applied in this study. Four schools were selected according to location (rural
and urban) and also whether the schools were designated as smart schools or normal schools. Teachers were
chosen based on the teachers’ experience with using ICT to conduct classes by using the pre-question. The
pre-questions will identify the teachers’ background on ICT. It involved twenty teachers in difference type
of school in Melaka’s schools in Malaysia. The scenario in Melaka with difference types of school had been
chose as a case study.
The teachers were given time to spontaneously share their knowledge and experience conducting lessons
for the special needs student by using the ICT as a platform in their teaching through interviews. The
questions were based on the usage of ICT in their class in terms of teaching students how to use ICT, how to
learn using ICT and finally actually how the students used ICT. Their answers were recorded for the further
analysis.

1.2. Instrument
30
 Qualitative data collection techniques were employed. These were observations and spontaneous
interview sessions among teachers who teach Special Education classes and teachers who were involved
teaching ICT to the students. Interviews were conducted to collect related information on teachers’
perceptions on blended learning in the selected schools having special education which is also called
Intergrasi Pendidikan Khas (Integration of Special Education). Most of the questions were related on what
the factors that influence the blended learning environment might be based on the teachers’ experiences and
knowledge on blended learning environment for special needs learners.
The observation had done spontaneously to watch the teacher conducting the class using the ICT and
contents which involved teaching to the students. Within the observation, the question will be asked to
identify what factors that affect the 3C element in implement the digital content (Ponter & Brown, 2007;
Yusof & Aziz, 2010; Yusof & Hin, 2009).

2. Findings & Discussion

The overall elements that emerged from the interview data has been defined according to the 3C
(Connect, Confidence, and Content) strategies when implementing the blended learning environment as put
forward by (Ponter & Brown, 2007; Yusof & Hin, 2009). This has been conceptualized into a model based
on the comment by teachers involved in the interview session (please refer to the fig.1). Most of the
questions were related to factors that influenced the blended learning environment as revealed by teachers’
experiences and knowledge on blended learning environment for special needs learners.

2.1. Conceptual Model

The study defined there the several factors and elements emerging from the observation and interview
data. Most of the factors depend upon the important of 3C strategies that influence the usage of ICT by
converting the conventional approach to blended learning approach: 1) Connection 2) Content and 3)
Confidence (Ponter & Brown, 2007; Yusof & Hin, 2009). According to the fig.1 the conceptual model
defines the three part key strategy that is with connected several factors that influence the special education
learning environment. Based on the teachers’ perceptions, the conceptual model has defined the content
which consists of the standards, elements, tasks and assessment that need to be taken into consideration when
applying the blended learning environment. Moreover, the connectivity on network connection, ICT facilities
and infrastructure as well as accessibility are also key factors that emerged in the connection strategies. The
study had identified culture as the factor that influences the confidence of people to handle the blended
learning environment. Moreover, the experience and knowledge that they acquire enhances their confidence
to implement ICT as the medium of their teaching. The study also revealed that three key words can depict
the experience with activities integrating ICT among special learners namely Know, Learn and Use. Know is
defined as the initial stage the people only know about what ICT is.. Then they learn about it and then learn
how to operate it. Finally, they will use it among their students by teaching them or use the ICT in the
classroom. The experiences can be repeated based on the sharing of knowledge and experience among
teacher and students.

31
 Fig. 1: Conceptual Model of Blended Learning in Special Education

2.2. Challenges
There are several factors shown in the model that defined challenges in learning environment according
to the teachers’ perceptions. They had shared that, they have limited content on ICT based materials to apply
and implement in the learning environment. These also included the lack of digital resources suitable for
special needs learners, the non-digitalized assessment and tasks. Moreover, the elements of interactivity are
limited in the learning environment. In terms of connection, the space and the facilities for special education
is still limited. Moreover, it has been assumed that the special needs learners had limited confidence to use
the ICT facilities and to operate it. The teachers felt that they could not the ICT facilities in learning because
they lacked the skill and experience to operate the ICT facilities. “Although access to ICT is not a problem;
teachers felt they lack the necessary skills to integrate ICT”(Ngah & Masood, 2006, p. 238). The
government has provided the facilities, however, the teachers are unable to utilise it.

2.3. Benefits
In term of benefits of a blended learning environment, the teachers felt that ICT will give them the
opportunity to enhance their computer literacy skills. They might only know what it is, but they can learn
and use it in their teaching. Moreover, it wills build-up teacher creativity to build their own learning
environment that suits the students. For example, the animation project helped the special needs students to
learn a new skill and enhance their attention and motivation (Yusof & Aziz, 2010; Yusof & Song, 2010).
According to previous research by Mayer & Moreno (2002), Mayer’s principle had shown the benefit of
using the multimedia as the tool help enhance student engagement. He also stated the guideline to ensure the
suitable elements in the multimedia content (Mayer & Moreno, 2002; Yusof & Aziz, 2010). The use of ICT
helps them to minimize the use of paper, and the activities on a computer can be repeated.

3. Conclusion and Future Research

In conclusion, the case study on the teachers’ perceptions in blended learning helps to identify the key
factors according to the 3C strategies. Moreover, the conceptual model helps to understand the relationship
between teachers’ experience, learning environment, and the policies of government influence in the use of
blended learning environment in the Malaysian classroom for special needs students. With the latest
32
 technologies, the learning environment can be more dynamic with the use of edutainment by integrated
game-based, augmented reality, and other elements of edutainment (Song & Yusof, 2010; Yusof, Daniel,
Abdullah, & Aziz, 2010). This research can be replicated in various ways in the future perhaps on a bigger
scale in order to further improve the conceptual model as a guideline and reference for other researchers. The
case study was in involved the four selected school in difference types which involved twenty teachers had
been observe and interviewed in state of Melaka, Malaysia. The further research will be implement it in other
state of Malaysia to define the pattern of blended learning environment in term of culture, teaching method
and learning environment.

4. Acknowledgements
Alhamdulillah, our heartfelt thanks goes to Ministry of Education, Division of Special Education,
headmasters, teachers for this support and involvement in this reviewed. Moreover, thank you to the
Bahagian Teknologi Pendidikan (BTP Melaka) had share the related data for the study. We also thank you to
anonymous reviewers for their suggestions and constructive criticism for improving this paper.

5. References
[1] EPU. (2006). The Ninth National Plan. Retrieved April, 28, 2011, from
http://www.epu.gov.my/html/themes/epu/html/rm9/english/Chapter11.pdf
[2] Graham, C. R. (in press). Blended Learning System: Definition, Current Treads, and Future Directions. In C. J.
Bonk & C. R. Graham (Eds.), Handbook of blended learning: Global Perspectives, local designs. San Francisco,
CA: Pfeiffer Publishing.
[3] Mayer, R. E., & Moreno, R. (2002). Animation as an Aid to Multimedia Learning. Educational Psychology
Review, Vol. 14, No. 1, March 2002 87-99.
[4] MDeC. (2009). The Smart School: Roadmap 2005 – 2020 (Vol. 2nd Edition). Kuala Lumpur: MDeC.
[5] MOE. (2010). Policy on ICT in Education Malaysia.
[6] Ngah, N. A., & Masood, M. (2006). Development of ICT Instructional Materials Based on Needs ldentified by
Malaysia Secondary School Teachers. Paper presented at the Proceedings of the 2006 Informing Science and lT
Education Joint Gonference, Salford, UK.
[7] Ponter, D., & Brown, L. (2007). Creating A Digital New Zealand: New Zealand’s Digital Content Strategy
Retrieved July 6, 2009, from http://www.digitalstrategy.govt.nz.
[8] Reay, J. (2001). Blended learning - a fusion for the future. Knowledge Management Review, 4(3), 6.
[9] Rooney, J. E. (2003). Blending learning opportunities to enhance educational programming and meetings.
Association Managment, 55(5), 26-32.
[10] Song, H., & Yusof, A. M. (2010). A Current Review of the Use of Mobile Technology to Enhance Learning and
Communication Among Children with Developmental Disabilities. Paper presented at the EDULEARN10
Conference, Barcelona, Spain.
[11] Yusof, A. M., & Aziz, K. A. (2010). Creative Industries In Education: The Creativity Of Teaching Method Using
Animation. Paper presented at the ICERI 2010: International Conference of Education, Research and Innovation,
Madrid, Spain.
[12] Yusof, A. M., Daniel, E. G. S. A., Abdullah, S. L., & Aziz, K. A. (2010). A Current Review Of The Use Of
Edutaiment Applications To Promote Alternative Approaches In Addressing Adhd. Paper presented at the 2011
International Conference on e-Commerce, e-Administration, e-Society, e-Education, and e-Technology (e-CASE
& e-Tech 2011), Tokyo, Japan.
[13] Yusof, A. M., & Hin, H. S. (2009). eSekolah: The Usability of School Management Application in Primary
Schools from Malaysia’s Perspective. Paper presented at the 13th APEID International Conference, Hangzhou,
Republic of China.
[14] Yusof, A. M., & Song, H. (2010). E-Project Based Learning Using Animation in Primary Schools. Paper
presented at the EDULEARN10 Conference, Barcelona, Spain.

33

View publication stats