DM Unit 4 and 5
DM Unit 4 and 5
Unit IV: Disaster Risk Reduction (DRR) - Disaster management cycle – its
phases; prevention, mitigation, preparedness, relief and recovery; structural
and non-structural measures, vulnerability and capacity assessment; early
warning systems, Post disaster environmental response
GENERAL
These activities are implemented at specific times, the length of any one phase
depending on the type of disaster, its breadth and scale. Therefore, one of the
key issues in disaster management planning is the allocation of resources at all
stages of the disaster cycle, which optimises the total effectiveness of risk
reduction activity and maximises the overall impact of disaster management.
2) During a disaster: to ensure that the needs and provisions of victims are met
and minimise suffering and
3) After a disaster: to achieve rapid and durable recovery which does not
reproduce the original vulnerable conditions.
The focus on emergency relief also depends on risk perception; that is, whether
there is belief that disaster could be avoided. If disasters were believed to be of
such a scale that it is believed, nothing could be done to reduce either the
phenomenon or the risk involved, and risk mitigation would not be pressed
for/attempted. However, once belief develops that disaster losses are
exacerbated by human agency, and could be curbed thereby, disaster risk
mitigation would be attempted.
Disasters, which occur globally with regular periodicity, are either natural such
as Floods, droughts, cyclones and earthquakes or human-induced such as
conflicts, riots, environmental and industrial accidents. Irrespective of whether
it is an 'act of God' or human-induced, disasters create mass destruction and
impede developmental work. The approach towards management of disasters
has undergone a radical change over the last few years. The ways of tackling
the occurrence of disasters, earlier have been reactive in nature. The course of
action basically used to be emergency management and provision of relief and
rehabilitation. Efforts are always directed towards bringing back the situation
to the normal. But presently, governments all over the world are adopting a
holistic approach to disaster management.
Phase 1: Prevention
Phase 2: Preparedness
Phase 3: Response
The steps that should be taken when disaster strikes are termed as response
and include:
Phase 4: Recovery
Recovery phase involves activities carried out to bring back normal situation in
the library by taking the following steps:
Rehabilitation
Reconstruction
Development
The processes covered by the disaster cycle can be illustrated through the case
of the Gujarat Earthquake of 26 January 2001. The devastating earthquake
killed thousands of people and destroyed hundreds of thousands of houses
and other buildings. The State Government as well as the National Government
immediately mounted a largescale relief operation. The help of the Armed
Forces was also taken. Hundreds of NGOs from within the region and other
parts of the country as well as from other countries of the world came to
Gujarat with relief materials and personnel to help in the relief operations.
Relief camps were set up, food was distributed, mobile hospitals worked round
the clock to help the injured; clothing, beddings, tents, and other commodities
were distributed to the affected people over the next few weeks.
Community awareness campaigns were carried out on dos and don‟ts for
different kinds of disasters. These told people what to do and what not to do
before, during and after a disaster. School safety programmes were taken up
under which, teachers, students and parents were trained on how to prepare for
a disaster and how to respond to one. Disaster management plans were
prepared for the state, districts, local areas and schools. A system of drills and
plan updating was established. All of this contributed to a higher level of
preparedness in the state.
Subsequently, hazardous events struck the state again. There was a cyclone
warning in 2004, which was responded to with a very efficient evacuation
implemented by the government and the NGOs. The community was already
aware of the evacuation plan and was trained how to react. Similarly, major
floods hit the state in June-July 2005. Once again, the role allocation was clear
to all the concerned stakeholders in the government as well as the NGOs and
the community too knew how to help the relief teams help them. Losses were
minimised, and the relief and rehabilitation process went off smoothly. This
case study shows how there was a disaster event during the earthquake,
followed by immediate response and relief, then by recovery including
rehabilitation and retrofitting, then by developmental processes. The
development phase included mitigation activities, and finally preparedness
actions to face future disasters. Then disaster struck again, but the impact was
less than what it could have been, primarily due to better mitigation and
preparedness efforts. The disasters were again followed by response and
recovery, and the cycle goes on.
The Risk Reduction is chronologically the latest paradigm for mitigating the
impact of disasters. The precursor to the Risk Reduction approach is the Total
Disaster Risk Management Approach (TDRM). Guzmann (2005) explains the
essentials of the approach. The TDRM approach is the immediate forerunner of
the Risk Reduction Framework, which is currently being emphasised. In the
Isephan Typhoon in 1959, Japan suffered heavy losses. A ferryboat sank in
Bangladesh in a cyclone on May 3, 2002, killing 450 passengers. These disasters
could have been prevented if close cooperation between concerned
organisations had been achieved Risk reduction can take place in two ways:
1) Long-term Mitigation
Mitigation embraces all measures taken to reduce both the effect of the hazard
itself and the vulnerable conditions in order to reduce the potency of a future
event. Therefore, mitigation activities can be focused on the hazard itself or the
elements exposed to the threat. Examples of mitigation measures which are
hazard specific, include; modifying the occurrence of the hazard, for example,
water management in drought prone areas, avoiding the hazard by siting
people away from the hazard and strengthening structures to reduce damage
when a disaster occurs. In addition to these physical measures, mitigation
should also be aimed at reducing the physical, economic and social
vulnerability to threats and the underlying causes for the same. Therefore,
mitigation may incorporate addressing issues such as land ownership, tenancy
rights, wealth distribution, etc. Some common mitigation measures are:
2) Short-term Preparedness
The mitigation measures that are employed to achieve the first two goals of
mitigation process, a reduction in the likelihood or acceptance of hazard, are
grouped into two primary categories: structural and non-structural.
Though these terms are almost universally used to differentiate between the
various options available to disaster managers, much disagreement exists
concerning the actual delineation of what makes structural or non-structural.
Here the structural mitigation is defined as a risk reduction method performed
through the construction or altering of physical environment by using
engineered solutions. Non-structural mitigation is defined as a measure that
reduces risk through the modification of human behavior or natural processes
without requiring the application of engineered solutions. It must be noted
that, while there are several mitigation measures that will clearly fit into one
category or the other regardless of the definition of the terms, there are also
many that could go either way, and may appear as one form in this text and
another form elsewhere.
Structural Mitigation
Structural mitigation measures are those that involve or dictate a necessity for
some kind of construction, engineering, or other mechanical changes or
improvements aimed at reducing hazard risk likelihood or consequence. They
often are considered at “man controlling nature” when applied to natural
disasters. Structural measures are generally expensive and include a full range
of regulation, compliance, enforcement, inspection, maintenance, and renewal
issues. Though, each hazard a unique set of structural mitigation measures that
may be applied to its risk, these measures can be grouped across some general
categories. The general structural mitigation groups to be described are:
Resistance construction
Building codes and regulatory measures
Relocation
Structural modification
Construction of community shelters
Construction of barrier, deflection, or retention systems
Detection systems
Physical modification
Treatment systems
Redundancy in life safety infrastructure
Non-structural Mitigation
Regulatory measures
Community awareness and education programs
Nonstructural physical modification
Environmental control
Behavioral modification
EARLY WARNING
Natural and technological hazards often result in disastrous events that can
profoundly impact societies. Hazards such as Flood, Cyclone, Tsunami,
Epidemics etc. or human made events such as industrial accidents, gas
leakages, and terrorism etc. have not only caused huge loss of life but also
The expression „early warning‟ is used in many fields to mean the provision of
information on an emerging dangerous circumstance where that information
can enable action in advance to reduce the risks involved. Early warning
systems exist for natural geo-physical and biological hazards, complex socio-
political emergencies, industrial hazards, personal health risks and many other
related risks. Nearly a million of people have been killed over the last decade in
disasters caused by storms, drought, floods etc. While some material losses
seem to be unavoidable especially in the case of large and infrequent disasters,
in many cases the loss of life could have been avoided. This was amply evident
during the Indian Ocean Tsunami 2004 which killed more than a quarter of
million of people in many countries.
The forecast generally is about predicting a future event such as rainfall, cloudy
conditions, intensification of a low pressure system, stock market etc. A
warning is different from the forecast in the sense that it carries a certain
amount of risk information that requires protective actions. Thus each forecast
need not necessarily be treated as a warning. For example a forecast such as
moderate rainfall on the next day does not automatically qualify to be a
warning its own. However if already the rivers are in spate and a flood like
situation is prevailing, forecast of a heavy Early Warning rainfall can imply a
warning. In essence, warning signifies a definite amount of risk to life and
properties and therefore merit urgent attention. There have been some debates
recently about qualities which are essential for a risk message to qualify as a
warning. For example, general forecast such as prediction of heavy rainfall,
flooding or possibility of a terrorist attack etc. unless sufficiently backed up
with more specific details such as which area, probable time of occurrence etc.
very little action can be taken. In such a case should such risk information be
considered as warning? This argument is mainly drawn from the usability
perspective of risk information i.e. can action be taken on the basis of a
warning. It also highlights the broad scope of the warning concept which often
can go beyond the event forecasted or warned.
Early Warning
population. This constitutes one of the key elements of any disaster risk
reduction strategy. It is important to note here that the ultimate goal of hazard
forecasting and early warning is to protect lives. An important debate in early
warning studies centers around how early is early enough? Such questions arise
mainly because of inadequate lead time available in case of some disasters
which have severe consequences such as earthquake and landslides. For
example, there have been some initiatives recently in establishing an
earthquake early warning system in Japan by taking advantage of the travel
time difference of primary and secondary seismic waves. Though there are
reports of success in such initiative, there are also questions such as if a small
available lead time can be useful for general public e.g. those who are in high
rise buildings to take protective measures like evacuation.
The radar can be utilized to find out the location of the cyclonic storm more
accurately when the system comes within radar range (approx. 400km). In
addition, the radar data also helps in estimating other parameters such as
convective cloud cluster, wind distribution, rainfall rate etc.
(2) Cyclone Alert: Issued at least 48 hours before the commencement of the
bad weather and when the cyclone is located beyond 500 Km from the coast
(3) Cyclone Warning: Issued at least 24 hours before the commencement of the
bad weather when the cyclone is located within 500 Km from the coast.
Information about time /place of landfall is indicated in the bulletin.
Confidence in estimation increases as the cyclone comes closer to the coast.
(4) Post landfall outlook: It is issued 12 hours before the cyclone landfall, when
the cyclone is located within 200 Km from the coast. More accurate and specific
information about time /place of landfall and associated bad weather indicated
in the bulletin. In addition, the interior distraction likely to be affected due to
the cyclone is warned in this bulletin.
Ministry of Home Affairs, New Delhi. When the system intensifies into a
cyclonic storm, the cyclone warning bulletins are issued every three hour. When
the system weakens or not going to affect Indian coast, a de-warning is also
issued to NDM Control Room. The cyclone warning bulletins are also passed on
to All India Radio, Television channels, Central/State Government
Authorities/District Collectors who are in constant touch with Cyclone Warning
Centers.
In the wake of massive loss of life during the Indian ocean tsunami of 2004, a
tsunami warning system has been now established by the Ministry of Earth
Sciences (MoES) in collaboration with Department of Science and Technology
(DST), Department of Space (DOS) and the Council of Scientific and Industrial
Research (CSIR). The National Tsunami Early Warning Centre has been set up at
Indian National Centre of Ocean Information Services (INCOIS), Hyderabad.
Tsunamigenic zones that threaten the Indian Coast have been identified by
considering the historical tsunamis, earthquakes, their magnitudes, location of
the area relative to a fault, and also by tsunami modeling. The tsunami early
warning system comprises a real-time network of seismic stations, Bottom
Pressure Recorders (BPR) and tide gauges to detect tsunamigenic earthquakes
and to monitor tsunamis.
The tsunami early warning centre receives real-time seismic data from the
national seismic network of the Indian Meteorological Department (IMD) and
other International seismic networks. The system detects all earthquake events
of more than 6 Magnitude in the Richter scale occurring in the Indian Ocean
within less than 20 minutes of its occurrence. Bottom Pressure Recorders (BPR)
installed in the Deep Ocean are the key sensors to confirm the triggering of a
Tsunami. The National Institute of Ocean Technology (NIOT) has installed 4
such BPR in the Bay of Bengal and the 2 BPR in Arabian Sea. In addition, NIOT
and Survey of India (SOI) have installed 30 Tide Gauges to monitor the progress
of tsunami waves. Integrated Coastal and Marine Area Management (ICMAM)
has customized and ran tsunami model for historical earthquakes to predict
inundation areas. These community-level inundation maps are extremely useful
for assessing the population and infrastructure at risk. INCOIS has also
generated a large database of model scenarios for different earthquakes that
are being used for operational tsunami early warning. Communication of real-
time data from seismic stations, tide gauges and BPR to the early warning
centre is very critical for generating timely tsunami warnings. Host of
communication methods are employed for timely reception of data from Early
Warning the sensors as well as for dissemination of alerts. Indian Space
Research Organization (ISRO) has made an end-to-end communication plan
using INSAT. A high level of redundancy is being built into the communication
system to avoid single point failures.
The District Administration is the focal point for field level organizations and
implementation of all government contingency plans related to disaster
management. Considerable powers have therefore been vested in the District
Collector to carry out operations effectively in the shortest possible time. The
District Administration is required to prepare in advance a contingency district
disaster management plan depending on the type of disasters likely in the
district. Contingency Plans are required to keep into account the type of
preparedness and the relief material required to be mobilized. The concerned
departments need to work together in a coordinated manner and provide an
efficient feedback and monitoring system to the District Collector.
District Relief Committee: The relief measures are reviewed by the district
level relief committee consisting of official and non-official members including
the local legislators and the members of parliament.
District Control Room: In the wake of natural disasters, a Control Room is set
up in the district to function as the district emergency management centre for
regular monitoring and coordination of the rescue and relief operations on a
continuing basis. It works round the clock and has very good communication
facilities.
Coordination: The Collector maintains close liaison with the Central
Government authorities available in the districts, such as, the Army, Air Force
and Navy, Ministry of Water Resources, Health etc. who supplement the efforts
of the district administration in the rescue and relief operations.
The Collector/Deputy Commissioner coordinates voluntary efforts by
mobilizing the non-government organizations capable of working in such
situations and also oversees proper distribution of the aid and relief material
received from outside the District.
RELEIF MEASURES
Establishment of Control
Military Assistance
Medical Services
Epidemics
Rescue and Salvage
Corpse Disposal
Deployment of Resources
Outside Relief
The military forces or defence forces or armed forces play a very important role
during disaster situation and also in the post-disaster scenario. Their main
assets are discipline, training, professionalism, specialized equipment,
resources and above all a minimum response time. Generally, they are called
upon to manage the following tasks:
Evacuation
Maintenance of essential services
Distributing of essential supplies in remove and marooned areas.
Transport of relief material
Medical aid
Management of relief camps
j. Territorial Army
Important point to note is that the Police Force is under control of the
respective State Administration while all the para-military Forces including the
"Civil Defence Organisation" are under the control of Government of India and
these are deployed to assist the local police whenever necessary. Apart from
their primary role as their name implies-e.g. BSF guards the borders, CISF takes
care of Central Public Sector undertakings including their security and fire
fighting, all the Para-Military Forces are deployed in the troubled areas or
during major national event like General/State Elections. The Coast Guard is a
special duty force for guarding the coasts and to deal with undesirable
activities such as smuggling on the coasts.
Special Role of air Force: During emergencies for heavy troop movement be it
Army Personnel or para-military forces - the Transport wing of Air Force is
called in, in a big way, The helicopters of Air Force are used for survey and
dropping of food packets together with rescuing of stranded people, especially
in flood situations. Air Force also has the responsibility of VIP/vVIP movement.
Special Role of Army: The local Army commander, anywhere in the country
has orders from Ministry of Defence, to assist the civil authorities during any
contingency. For this, however, only the District collector has-the authority to
requisition the aid of military, and that too in extreme emergencies, on a
written request. In riot-affected cities, places, Army Flag March - only parading
is arranged in order to deter anti-social elements indulging in further trouble
and to pacify common population by boosting their morale for peace and
assurance of their safety and security
Special Role of Navy: The Navy has a special role in the event of a disaster on
the sea or on coasts or in ports. Cyclones, storm surge or oil spill are the most
prominent among the disastrous events that could occur in these locations. In
discharge of their duties, the Navy is assisted by the Coast Guards.
Disasters due to the scale and extent they affect the population are a national
calamity and it becomes imperative that action to mitigate their adverse effects
be initiated quickly at the national level. It has been observed that over the past
few decades the frequency of disasters and their devastating effects have
increased manifold. Apart from other causes the burgeoning population,
growing infrastructure and the increased industrial activity have contributed
largely to this situation. Among the important reasons for the increased
vulnerability is the lack of coordinated efforts to manage disaster situations.
Precious time is lost in the authorities getting their act together to intervene. A
well organized predetermined structure becomes a prerequisite for a prompt
and comprehensive action to face disasters. Considerable progress has been
made in the recent past in government organization and division of
responsibilities in this regard.
1. National Level
in the wake of major disasters. The dimensions of the response at the level of
National Government are determined in accordance with the existing policy of
financing the relief expenditure and keeping in view the factors like:
1. The gravity of the situation,
2. The scale of the relief operations necessary, and
3. The requirements of Central assistance for augmenting the financial
resources at the disposal of the State Government.
Most of the States have Relief Commissioners who are in charge of the relief
measures in the wake of natural disasters in their respective States. In the
absence of the Relief Commissioner, the Chief Secretary or an Officer
nominated by him is in overalI charge of the Relief operations in the concerned
State.
4. NON-GOVERNMENTAL ORGANISATIONS
Disaster Management is a multi-disciplinary and multi-dimensional effort
requiring massive, large-scale and often long-term intervention at short notice.
In a vast and populous country like India, it is not feasible for only the
governmental machinery to undertake disaster management programmes
satisfactorily. Active and willing participation of the people is essential.
Nongovernmental organisations (NGOs) including the community based
organisations (CBOs) play an important effective role as a bridge between the
government and the people. The non-governmental sector, due to its linkages
with the community base and its flexibility in procedural matters, has an
advantage over governmental agencies in invoking the involvement of the
people at community level
3) Interest Groups
These are also NGOs, formed with the objective of sharing interests and
community service, such as the Rotary Club. However, such interest groups are
very active, and have come forward to help disaster victims in times of need.
Most of these groups have good financial resources. They can play a major role
in resource mobilization for relief aid land rehabilitation purposes.
These associations are formed by the local residents to look into the interests
of those living a shared community life in the area which may be rural or urban
or in big towns. As such, these associations are highly concerned about the
welfare of the local community, and need no external motivation to take active
part in disaster reduction. Thus, they can be a very useful tool for getting
across the message of community participation at the ground level and to
muster community's willing participation. They are very useful coordinating
disaster management efforts such as distribution of essential supplies or
providing local volunteers.
Religious bodies are one of the most important NGOs groups that come to the
immediate rescue and relief of the disaster victims. These bodies have a large
and dedicated following in the community. They also have control of the local
places of worship, which are usually strong structures built on high and safe
ground, and can serve as ideal shelters during disasters. Besides, they often
have infrastructure to feed mass gatherings, which becomes very useful in
times of disaster.
7) Educational Institutions
Educational institutions such as schools and colleges are also NGOs that play a
crucial role in disaster management. Their prime responsibility in this regard is
to spread awareness on natural disasters and preventive action needed to
minimize damage due to them, as well as on immediate relief and rescue
methods. Besides, these institutions have large buildings which can be used as
shelters for the victims in times of disaster.
8) Media
Most of the media, such as newspapers or the radio/TV channels that are not
owned by government come in the category of NGOs and they perform prime
function before, during and after disasters.
The various other functions that the NGOs may be expected to perform are
briefly enumerated below:-
Pre-Disaster Stage:
During Disaster:
Post-Disaster Stage:
5. INTERNATIONAL AGENCIES
The United Nations Centre for Regional Development provides training and
research in regional development and planning and related fields, for
developing countries. Its projects focus primarily on research and training, but
include advisory services and information dissemination components. Its
operation units include the Regional Disaster Prevention Unit (RDPU).
The WFP or World Food Programme provides targeted food aid, sometimes
linked to 'food for work' programme for construction of flood protection
structures and coordinates pre and post disaster emergency food aid. It also
runs its own publications programme.
The International Federation of Red cross and Red crescent Societies (IFRS)
assist programmes of the national Red-cross societies of various countries. In
India, they assist and work with the Indian Red Cross Society. IFRS also publish
a 'World Disaster Report' from its Geneva office.
Pre-Disaster Assistance
(i)Assistance in prevention/mitigation
During the disasters, the people have to act instantly. If a disaster occurs
without any warnings or predictions or at a large scale than predicted, the first
activity for an individual is to save the lives of dear and near ones, protect the
valuable documents and properties, and later should join others in rendering
all possible help to the unfortunate and the needy ones. All concerted action
should be taken together to prevent the loss of lives and property of the society
as a whole.
Be familiar with the types of disasters that are most likely to happen in
your area and discuss with your family.
Evolve ways of preparing for each type of disaster and discuss with your
family.
Find out how to help the elderly, expectant mothers, physically
challenged or children, if needed.
Enquire about the disaster plans at your work place, your children school
and other places where your family spends time.
If they do not have plans, persuade them to have. Fix two places to meet:
1. Right outside home in case of sudden emergency, like
a fire.
2. Outside neighbourhood in case you can't return home.
Keep the addresses and phone numbers of important places.
Have a friend from a place other than your place of living as "family
contact"
Discuss what to do in an evacuation.
Always keep emergency contact numbers.
Teach children how and when to call 100 or emergency medical service.
Show each family member how and when to turn off water, gas, and
electricity at the main switches.
Have adequate insurance coverage.
Have fire extinguishers and demonstrate its use.
Conduct periodically a home hazard hunt.
Get trained in first aid.
Collaborate with your neighbours, and share information special skills.
Cash
Compass
Screw Driver
Sanitary items
Tape
Matches in Waterproof Container
Plastic Sheeting
Flash Light.