Ayurvedic Management of Cervical Spondylosis Radiculopathy
Ayurvedic Management of Cervical Spondylosis Radiculopathy
net/publication/341130591
CITATIONS READS
0 3,870
3 authors, including:
All content following this page was uploaded by Sarvesh Kumar Singh on 04 May 2020.
ISSN
ISSN -2278-4292
0000-0000
S
A
International Journal of
H
www.ijhas.in
I
Website:
Abstract:
www.ijhas.in Radiculopathy, commonly referred as pinched nerve, refers to a set of conditions in which one or more
nerves are affected and their functioning is hampered. This phenomenon is termed as neuropathy.
DOI:
10.4103/ijhas.IJHAS_139_17 This can result in pain or more precisely in radicular pain. In a radiculopathy, the problem occurs at
or near the root of the nerve, shortly after its exit from the spinal cord. However, the pain or other
symptoms often radiate to the part of the body served by that nerve. The management available in the
current era of medicine is not satisfactory. Here, we are presenting a case of cervical spondylosis (CS)
radiculopathy which was treated with a combination of Panchkarma procedures and Ayurvedic oral
drugs. Greeva stambh was considered as the Ayurvedic diagnosis for the case. The treatment
protocol designed for the particular case was Panchatikta ksheera Basti (enema with medicated milk)
for 16 days along with Shalishastic pind sweda. The oral medication prescribed was Ashwagandha
churna (Withania somnifera Dunal), Shatavari churna (Asparagus recemosus Wild), Gokshur churna
(Tribulus terrestris L.) each in a dose of 2 g, Sarpgandha churna (Rauvolfia serpentina (L) Benth.
Ex Kurz) 1 grms, Shankha bhasma 500 mg with Luke warm water, Yograj guggulu‑3 tablet with
Dashmool kwath in a dose of 40 ml, Ashwagandha avaleha 10 g with lukewarm water. All these
drugs were prescribed for twice a day. Visual analog scale and range of motion were the parameter
used to assess patient and considerable improvement was noticed in the case after a month of
treatment which sustained in follow‑up duration of 2 months. The case study demonstrate that CS
radiculopathy may be successfully managed with Ayurvedic treatment.
Keywords:
Ayurveda, cervical spondylosis rediculopathy, Greevastambh, Panchkarma
104 © 2018 International Journal of Health & Allied Sciences | Published by Wolters Kluwer ‑ Medknow
Kushwaha, et al.: Ayurvedic management of cervical spondylosis radiculopathy
only due to vitiation of Vata dosha).[11] The symptoms of Table 1: Dashavidha Pariksha
Vata Vyadhi (~various neurological and musculoskeletal Physical examination Result interpretation
disorders) are Sankocha (constrictions of organs), Parva Prakriti Vatakapha
stambha (stiffness in joints), Asthi bheda (pain in bones), Vikriti Vataj Vikriti
Padi prastha shiroghraha (stiffness in lower limbs, back, Pramana (body proportion) Sama Praman (symmetrical)
and head) Spandana, and Gatrasuptta (numbness).[12] Here, Sara (purest form of tissues) Madhyam Sara
we are representing a case of CSR which was successfully Samhanan (medium body built) Madhyam (medium)
managed by Ayurvedic therapy. Satmaya Sarvasatmya (homologation for
all taste)
Satva ( mental strength) Madhyam
Case Report Aahar sakti (food activities and Madhyam (medium)
digestive power)
A 50‑year‑old female patient consulted in outpatient Vyayamsakti (capability of Heen (low)
Department of the National Institute of Ayurveda, Jaipur, physical activities)
with complaints of gradually progressive pain around Vaya (age) Madhyavastha
the neck region which radiated toward bilateral shoulder
joints and both upper limbs along with stiffness in neck examination, sensations of touch and temperature were
and shoulders since 4 years. The patient had restricted lost in the right tip of shoulder joint, position sense,
movement of neck and shoulder joints since 2 years and joint vibration senses were normal bilaterally.
after a traumatic injury which aggravated by prolonged On motor examination nutrition, power, tone, and
sitting and relieved in lying posture. She also suffered coordination of the upper and lower limbs were normal.
from intermittent numbness and tingling sensations Deep tendon reflexes and superficial‑reflexes were
in both upper limbs since a year. The patient had
normal. The patient had Babinski and Hoffman sign
undergone neurological and orthopedic consultation in
negative bilaterally and Spurling sign positive. All
IndoWestern hospital of brain and spine, Jaipur. Surgical
biochemical and laboratory finding were normal except
and conservatives management was recommended.
erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR). ESR was elevated
She was taking some painkiller and corticosteroids for
up to ‑ 75 mm/h. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)
pain management as prescribed by previous consultant.
of cervical spine that was done on 9 February 2013,
The prime aim of the patient to attend our outpatient
suggested posterior osteophytes at c 4–c 6 vertebral
department was to seek a better nonsurgical approach
bodies and c 5–c 6. Posterior osteophytic ridges and
of her aliment.
protruding disc caused moderate spinal canal stenosis
Case findings with narrowing of the left neural foramina with mildly
The case was admitted to female ward of Panchakarma indenting the theca. MRI scan on October 15, 2014
Department of National Institute of Ayurveda, Jaipur, revealed disc bulge at c3–c4, c4–c5, c5–c6, and c6‑c7, cord
on April 18, 2017, for the treatment. On physical compression at c5‑c6 due to disc bulge – which was
examination, the general condition of the patient was suggestive of CSR.
poor, blood pressure of the patient was 150/100 mmHg.
Pulse was 70/min and often irregular. She was anxious, Diagnostic focus and assessment
appetite was moderate, the tongue was coated, and The patient was known case of CSR, and it was
bladder habits were normal and constipated bowel. The confirmed by previously done MRI. Greevastambha was
patient was assessed on Dashavidha pariksha [Table 1] considered as Ayurvedic diagnosis which is included
patient had normal gait. The active movement of range in Urdhajatrugata roga [13] (disease above the neck
of cervical spine was restricted. Pain aggravated on region) and Nanatamaj Vatavyadhi.[11] Hereditary spastic
the movement of neck. On examination, flexion of paraplegia, frozen shoulder, primary spinal cord tumor,
the neck was 15°, extension was 10°, lateral flexion to muscle spasm, amytrophic lateral sclerosis, cervical
left side was 10°, lateral flexion to the right side was sprain and strain, neoplastic brachial plexopathy, spinal
10°, lateral rotation to the left side was 20°, and lateral cord infraction, and spinal sepsis pan coast tumors were
rotation to the right side was 25°. The visual analog the differential diagnosis of the case. The confirmatory
scale (VAS) scoring was 70. Tenderness was examined diagnosis of CSR was based on MRI finding of the case.
over c4,‑c5 c5‑c6, c6‑c7 vertebras, power of biceps and There was absence of Babinski sign and fasciculation
triceps muscles of both upper limb were normal, lumbar which differentiate it from amyotrophic lateral sclerosis.
spine movement was normal in range. Tenderness was Frozen shoulder was excluded from differential
absent. On neurological examination, higher functions, diagnosis on the base of physical examination. Muscle
consciousness, orientation of time, place, person, spasm, cervical sprain, and strain were rule out with
memory, and speech were normal. The patient was right Spurling test. Other conditions were excluded on the
handed. All cranial nerves were well intact. On sensory basis of MRI finding.
International Journal of Health & Allied Sciences - Volume 7, Issue 2, April‑June 2018 105
Kushwaha, et al.: Ayurvedic management of cervical spondylosis radiculopathy
106 International Journal of Health & Allied Sciences - Volume 7, Issue 2, April‑June 2018
Kushwaha, et al.: Ayurvedic management of cervical spondylosis radiculopathy
Table 4: Timeline age. These changes lead to cracks and fissures and
Years Incidence collapsing of intervertebral discs causing annulus
2012 Patient got trauma followed by neck pain to bulge outward. Annulus fissure and herniation
February 09, 2013 Posterior osteophytes are seen in c4-c6 may complicate chronic spondylotic changes. The
vertebral bodies and at c5-c6 posterior
cross‑sectional area of the canal is narrowed due to
osteophytic ridges and protruding disc
causes moderate spinal canal stenosis with annulus bulges. The uncinate process over rides and
narrowing of left neural foramina with mildly hypertrophy compromising the ventrolateral portion of
indenting the theca the foramen to disc degeneration marginal osteophytes
2014 Neck pain which radiated toward shoulders start developing changes lead to radiculopathy. Other
and right forearm started
conditions aggravated the changes by trauma and
October 15, 2014 Disc bulge at c3‑c4, c4‑c5, c5‑c6 and c6‑c7,
cord compression at c5‑c6 due to disc heavy work.[16,17] The disease has resemblance with the
bulge Greevastambh disease described in Ayurveda which is
2015 Stiffness in the neck region and restricted Urdhajatrugata roga and Nanatmak Vata Vyadhi. There
movement of neck are two type of pathology in Vata Vyadhi. First due to
2016 Numbness and tingling sensation started in the Kshaya of Dhatu (diminished of body tissue) and
the right upper arm and both shoulders
second due to Margaavrodha (obstructive pathology).[18]
2017 Admitted in National Institute of Ayurveda
Degeneration of vertebras and discs occurs mainly due
April 20, 2017 Shalishastic pind sweda, Panchatikta
ksheera basti, and combination of oral to Kshaya type of pathology in which Vata Pitta dosha
medication started are vitiated. Here, Asthi poshan chikitsa (nutrition to
April 15, 2017 Nasya and combination of oral drugs same bone tissue) is the main treatment to treat the condition.
as previous Chikitsa of Asthigata roga (treatment of musculoskelton
May, 2017 Patient had got relief from symptoms as disease) are Panchkarma, Tikta (bitter taste herbs) sadhit
pain, restricted movement, numbness, and
tingling sensation
ksheer basti along with oil and ghrita.[19] According to
May 24, 2017 Patient had discharged Charak, Basti[20] is best chikitsa for Vata and half chikitsa.[21]
August, 2017 Patient came with improved symptoms Arundatta, a commentator of classics of Ayurvedic text
mention that Tikta ksheera basti, is the combination of
Outcome measures and follow‑up Snigdha (unctuous) and Shoshana property. It pacifies
After completion of Panchkarma procedures, the patient the vitiated Vata dosha and produces the Khara guna
condition was reassessed. The patient had no giddiness (roughness property) in Asthi dhatu (bone tissue) so Tikta
and neck pain improved, VAS score decreased to 20 and ksheera basti promotes Asthi poshana (proper osteogenesis
stiffness improved. Flexion of the neck had improved and nourishment of bone).[22] Tikta rasa (bitter taste) itself
to 45° and extension to 40°. Lateral flexion to left side work as Twak mansa shthirikaro (increase the durability of
was improved to 30°. Lateral flexion to the right side muscle and skin) by which it gives strength to muscles
was improved to 30°. Lateral rotation to the left side was and ligaments of neck region.[23] Ashwagandha taila is
improved to 45°. Lateral rotation to the right side was used in basti. Ashwagandha is Balya (anabolic, provide
improved to 45°. Spurling sign was negative. The patient strength), Bramhana (nourishes the bone and muscles)
was discharged on 24 may 2017. The patient condition and Rasayana (immunomodulator).[24] Panchtikta ghrita
was stable in the follow‑up period of 2 months. Details had been used for its Tikta rasa (taste) and useful in Asthi
of patient case history and follow up is given in Table 4. dhatu chikitsa. This Yapana manner is suitable for healthy
persons, patients, and old age persons.[25] Shalishastic
Discussion pind swedan is mentioned in Vata vikara.[26] Bala moola
kwath which was used in Shalishastic pinda Sweda is
Intervertebral discs and their surrounding ligament having Balya property (provide strength).[27] Nasya used in
lose their normal elasticity and hydration with Urdhajatrugata roga. Nasya enter in head region and pacify
International Journal of Health & Allied Sciences - Volume 7, Issue 2, April‑June 2018 107
Kushwaha, et al.: Ayurvedic management of cervical spondylosis radiculopathy
108 International Journal of Health & Allied Sciences - Volume 7, Issue 2, April‑June 2018
Kushwaha, et al.: Ayurvedic management of cervical spondylosis radiculopathy
Academy Prakashan; 2008. p. 468. 28. Chaturvedi G. Siddhi Sthan. Charaka Samhita of Agnivesha
21. Chaturvedi G. Siddhi Sthan, Charaka Samhita of Agnivesha Elaborated by Charaka & Drudhabala Reprinted. Part‑2. Ch. 2.
Elaborated by Charaka & Drudhabala. Reprinted. Part‑2, Ch. 1. Shloka 22. Varanasi: Vidhyotini Vyakhya Choukhambha Bharti
Shloka 39. Varanasi: Vidhyotini Vyakhya Choukhambha Bharti Academy Prakashan; 2011. p. 986.
Academy Prakashan; 2011. p. 971. 29. Lochan K. Bhaisajya Ratnavali of Govinda Dasji Bhisagratna
22. Astanga Hridaya by Vagbhatta, with the Commentaries‘ Commented upon by Vaidya Shri Ambika Datta Shastri. 2006
Sarvangasundara’ of Arunadatta and Ayurvedarasayana of Edition. Verse No. 37. Vol. 2. Ch. 29. Varanasi: Chaukhambha
Hemadri, Arunadatta on Sutrasthana. Ch. 11. Shloka 31. Varanasi: Sanskrit Sansthana; 2006. p. 335.
Krishnadas Academy; 2000. p. 187.
30. Al‑Ali M, Wahbi S, Twaij H, Al‑Badr A. Tribulus terrestris:
23. Chaturvedi G. Sutra Sthan, Charaka Samhita of Agnivesha
Preliminary study of its diuretic and contractile effects and
Elaborated by Charaka & Drudhabala. Reprinted. Part‑1, Ch. 26.
Shloka 42. Varanarsi: Vidhyotini Vyakhya Choukhambha Bharti comparison with Zea mays. J Ethnopharmacol 2003;85:257‑60.
Academy Prakashan; 2008. p. 506. 31. Mohd J, Akhtar AJ, Abuzer A, Javed A, Ali M, Ennus T.
24. Chaturvedi G. Sutra Sthan, Charaka Samhita of Agnivesha Pharmacological scientific evidence for the promise of
Elaborated by Charaka and Drudhabala. Reprinted. Part‑1 Ch. 4. Tribulusterrestris. Int Res J Pharm 2012;3:403‑6.
Shloka 17. Varanasi: Vidhyotini Vyakhya Choukhambha Bharti 32. Douglas L. Rauwolfia in the treatment of hypertension. Integr
Academy Prakashan; 2008. p. 77. Med 2015;14:40-6.
25. Chaturvedi G. Siddhi Sthan, Charaka Samhita of Agnivesha 33. Bhavprakash Nighantu,The Indian meteria medica
Elaborated by Charaka & Drudhabala. Reprinted. Part‑2, Ch. 12, of Shri Bhavmishra, commentary by Prof.K.C. Chunekar
Shloka 21. Varanasi: Vidhyotini Vyakhya Choukhambha Bharti Guguchayadivarga chapter verse 187,Chaukhamba Bharti
Academy Prakashan; 2011. p. 1107.
Academy Prakashan Varanasi; 2013. p 379.
26. Chaturvedi G. Sutra Sthan, Charaka Samhita of Agnivesha
34. Mishra S. Bhaishjya Ratnavali of Kaviraj Shri Govind Das Sen
Elaborated by Charaka & Drudhabala. Reprinted. Part‑1, Ch. 14.
Shloka 25. Varanasi: Vidhyotini Vyakhya Choukhambha Bharti Elaborated edited with Siddhiprada Hindi Commentary. Shloka
Acedemy Prakashan; 2008. p. 286. 152‑157. 1st ed., Vol. 1, Ch. 29. Varanasi: Chaukhambha Surbharati
27. Chaturvedi G. Sutra Sthan, Charaka Samhita of Agnivesha Prakashan; 2005. p. 608.
Elaborated by Charaka & Drudhabala. Reprinted. Part‑1, Ch. 25. 35. Mikawa Y, Shikata J, Yamamuro T. Spinal deformity and
Shloka 40. Varanasi: Vidhyotini Vyakhya Choukhambha Bharti instability after multilevel cervical laminectomy. Spine (Phila Pa
Academy Prakashan; 2008. p. 466. 1976) 1987;12:6‑11.
International Journal of Health & Allied Sciences - Volume 7, Issue 2, April‑June 2018 109