8 - Saxena Et Al 2020 An Evaluation of Yoga and Meditation To Improve Attention Hyperactivity and Stress in High School
8 - Saxena Et Al 2020 An Evaluation of Yoga and Meditation To Improve Attention Hyperactivity and Stress in High School
                                                                                          Anastasia Grieb, BS,1 Jafar Bakhshaie, MD, PhD,1 Alessio Simonetti, MD, PhD,1,4
                                                                                          Eric A. Storch, PhD,1 Laurel Williams, DO,1 and Lex Gillan, BS5
                                                                                          Abstract
                                                                                             Objective: Problems with attention and stress are common in children and predict academic difficulties and
                                                                                          other behavioral and emotional problems. Mind–body interventions such as yoga and meditation improve
                                                                                          attention and reduce stress. In this study, we examined the impact of Hatha yoga on attention and stress in ninth
                                                                                          graders.
                                                                                             Design: A total of 174 ninth graders from a Texas high school were enrolled in the study. Teachers assigned
                                                                                          students to a yoga group (YG) or control group (CG) based on their class schedule. The YG participated in 25-min
                                                                                          Hatha yoga classes twice weekly over 12 weeks (n = 123). The CG included 51 students. Student self-reports on
                                                                                          measures of inattention and hyperactivity (the strengths and weaknesses of ADHD [attention-deficit/hyperactivity
                                                                                          disorder] symptoms and normal behavior rating scale for ADHD) and stress (perceived stress scale) were obtained
                                                                                          at baseline and at 12 weeks.
                                                                                             Results: There were no significant differences in baseline levels of inattention ( p = 0.86), hyperactivity
                                                                                          ( p = 0.25), and perceived stress ( p = 0.28) between the YG and CG. Regarding inattention scores, there was a
                                                                                          significant interaction of group and time (b = -1.09, standard error [SE] = 0.30, p < 0.001). Pairwise t-tests
                                                                                          showed a significant reduction in inattention for the YG (d = 0.27) but a significant increase in inattention for the
                                                                                          CG. Regarding hyperactivity, there was no significant interaction of group and time (b = -0.43, SE = 0.26,
                                                                                          p = 0.1). Pairwise t-tests demonstrated a significant reduction in hyperactivity for the YG (d = 0.22), but not the
                                                                                          CG. The interaction of group and time was not significant in predicting the slope of change in perceived distress
                                                                                          (b = -0.93, SE = 1.19, p = 0.43). Pairwise t-tests did not show a significant reduction in perceived distress for
                                                                                          either group.
                                                                                             Conclusion: These findings suggest that Hatha yoga may improve attention and hyperactivity in high school
                                                                                          students.
                                                                                            1
                                                                                             Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, TX, USA.
                                                                                            2
                                                                                             Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Vanderbilt University Medical Center, Nashville, TN, USA.
                                                                                            3
                                                                                             Department of Psychiatry, University of Texas Health—McGovern Medical School, Houston, TX, USA.
                                                                                            4
                                                                                             Department of Neurology and Psychiatry, Sapienza University of Rome, Rome, Italy.
                                                                                            5
                                                                                             Institute for Spirituality and Health, Houston, TX, USA
                                                                                                                                                     701
                                                                                          702                                                                                                                SAXENA ET AL.
                                                                                          overall good health.10–12 In the West, Hatha yoga is the most        based yoga is fewer than 20 years old, and is oftentimes
                                                                                          popular practice.13                                                  inconclusive due to varying methodologies of studies. There
                                                                                             Given the accessibility of yoga (i.e., can be offered without     is no consensus on dose of yoga intervention across age
                                                                                          equipment) and its cost-effective nature (i.e., group format),       groups, fidelity of implementing the intervention, and the
                                                                                          schools are an ideal environment to incorporate this practice.       measurement of long-term outcomes. Even the highest
                                                                                          Children spend most of their day at school, so yoga practice can     quality studies yield both positive and negative results.17
                                                                                          be incorporated into the curriculum.3,14 There are over 36 yoga-        The aim of this study was to determine the impact of a
                                                                                          based programs utilized in more than 940 schools across the          Hatha yoga and meditation intervention on self-reported
                                                                                          United States. Across programs, the length (i.e., number of          measures of inattention, hyperactivity, and stress in ninth
                                                                                          weeks), number of sessions, session duration, and formality (i.e.,   graders. We hypothesized that in comparison with students
                                                                                          school-based vs. self-motivated) vary.1,15 However, the common       in the control arm, those receiving yoga for 25 min twice a
                                                                                          theme across programs include physical posturing, breathing          week for 12 weeks would report improved inattention and
                                                                                          exercises, relaxation techniques, and mindfulness practices.         hyperactivity and decreased stress.
                                                                                             Khalsa and Butzer1 reviewed 47 yoga studies conducted in
                                                                                          elementary, middle, and high schools primarily in India and          Methods
                                                                                          the United States. Comparison across studies was not possible
                                                                                          as yoga interventions differed in length, number of sessions,        Study participants
                                                                                          session duration, and curricula across schools—from formal              The local school district and the Institutional Review Board
                                                                                          curricula to instructors creating their own. Furthermore, the        (IRB) at Baylor College of Medicine approved this study. The
                                                                                          methodological quality was low to moderate; there were often         teachers assigned ninth graders to two groups, yoga group
                                                                                          small sample sizes and a lack of control group. Yet, the             (YG) or control group (CG), and selected those students in the
                                                                                          implemented yoga classes have yielded both positive and              second-period health science class to participate in the YG.
                                                                                          negative outcomes.                                                   The yoga classes took place in the morning during the students’
                                                                                             Serwacki and Cook-Cottone16 reviewed 12 quantitative              health science class, a required course for all ninth graders. The
                                                                                          school-based yoga studies and encountered similar method-            students enrolled in a health science class at a different time of
                                                                                          ological limitations. Yet, the school-based programs deemed          day constituted the CG.
                                                                                          beneficial for the students. Ferreira-Vorkapic et al.17 reported        Every student received a parental consent and a child as-
                                                                                          the usefulness of school-based yoga to be uncertain because          sent form that informed the minimal risks and that partici-
                                                                                          of few randomized controlled trials, methodological con-             pation is voluntary. Each student read and signed the assent
                                                                                          cerns, small sample sizes, lack of control groups, varying           form demonstrating their own understanding of and willing-
                                                                                          yoga interventions taught, and varying duration of yoga              ness to participate in the study. Parents of each student read
                                                                                          sessions. They found that positive and negative outcomes             and signed the consent form to approve their child’s partici-
                                                                                          often cancelled each other out.                                      pation in the study. Only those students with signed consent
                                                                                             Some studies suggest that yoga may improve inattention,           and assent forms were enrolled. In total, 184 students pro-
                                                                                          and early intervention techniques that diminish attention-           vided consent for the study. Demographics of our sample are
                                                                                          deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) symptoms are im-               given in Table 1. Of that group, 174 ninth-grade students
                                                                                          portant for favorable outcomes18; an 8-year longitudinal             completed the baseline and post measurements, with 123
                                                                                          study19 revealed that lower school retention rates, failure to       students in the YG and 51 students in the CG.
                                                                                          graduate secondary school, and lower level academic perfor-
                                                                                          mance were accurately predicted by inattention and hyperac-
                                                                                                                                                               Hatha yoga intervention
                                                                                          tivity symptoms. Sethi et al.20 found that 60 low-income high
                                                                                          school girls who participated in an integrated yoga module             The yoga classes consisted of 25-min sessions of Hatha
                                                                                          (IYM) for 5 days21 had improved attention. Similarly, Sheela         yoga and meditation, twice per week for 12 weeks. Each
                                                                                          YOGA BENEFITS IN HIGH SCHOOL                                                                                                703
                                                                                                            Table 1. Demographics                            Perceived stress scale. The perceived stress scale (PSS)
                                                                                                                                                          is a widely used instrument for measuring the perception of
                                                                                                                      Yoga group Control group            stress. This 10-item scale assesses the degree to which sit-
                                                                                                                       (N = 123),  (N = 51),              uations in one’s life are appraised as stressful. Items tap into
                                                                                                                         n (%)      n (%)           p
                                                                                                                                                          how unpredictable, uncontrollable, and overloaded respon-
                                                                                          Sex                                                             dents have found their lives within the past month. Scores
                                                                                            Female               74 (60.2)          38 (74.5)     0.07    on the PSS can range from 0 to 40: scores ranging from 0 to
                                                                                            Male                 49 (39.8)          13 (24.5)             13 are considered low stress, 14 to 26 moderate stress, and
                                                                                          Age (mean years – SD) 14.73 – 0.41       14.84 – 0.47   0.79    27 to 40 high perceived stress.34 The PSS had sufficient
                                                                                          Race                                                            internal reliability with a Cronbach’s a of 0.68. A mean
                                                                                            Asian                37 (30)            13   (26)     0.48    composite of perceived stress was subsequently created. The
                                                                                            African American     22 (18)            14   (27)             scale has high internal consistency and test–retest reliabili-
                                                                                            Caucasian            58 (47)            22   (43)             ty.34 Studies with children have used the PSS, but it is yet to
                                                                                            Other                 6 (5)              2   (4)              be statistically validated in children.25,35–38
                                                                                          Ethnicity
                                                                                            Hispanic or Latino   43 (35)            18 (36)       0.90    Yoga and meditation questionnaire
                                                                                            Not Hispanic         80 (65)            32 (64)
                                                                                              or Latino                                                      We created an IRB-approved self-assessment question-
                                                                                                                                                          naire for the yoga and meditation practice (Table 2), which
                                                                                            SD, standard deviation.                                       was distributed after the 12-week intervention. Our aim was
Downloaded by 45.184.151.66 from www.liebertpub.com at 09/09/24. For personal use only.
                                                                                          perceived helpfulness of yoga and meditation (a mean score            cant moderator effect for the perceived helpfulness and
                                                                                          derived from separate reports on yoga and meditation per-             home practice of intervention for the effect of time on in-
                                                                                          ceived helpfulness) and amount of yoga and meditation                 attention within the YG (b = 0.32, SE = 0.61, p = 0.59, and
                                                                                          practice at home (a mean score derived from separate reports          b = 0.10, SE = 0.23, p = 0.65, respectively).
                                                                                          on yoga and meditation practiced at home) were examined as               For predicting the change in the SWAN subscale of hy-
                                                                                          moderators of the relationships between the effect of time on         peractivity, after controlling for baseline levels of perceived
                                                                                          inattention and hyperactivity, after controlling for baseline         stress, there was no significant interaction of group and time
                                                                                          levels of perceived stress. Similar post hoc analyses were            (b = -0.43, SE = 0.26, p = 0.1). Pairwise t-tests demonstrated
                                                                                          conducted for perceived stress as a dependent variable with           a significant reduction in hyperactivity for the YG (t = 2.670,
                                                                                          no control variables. Cohen’s d41 was reported as estimates           p = 0.009; Cohen’s d = 0.22), but not the CG (t = -0.323,
                                                                                          of effect size.                                                       p = 0.748) (Fig. 2). Post hoc moderator analysis did not
                                                                                                                                                                support the moderator role of perceived stress (b = 0.03,
                                                                                                                                                                SE = 0.04, p = 0.43). Neither perceived helpfulness nor home
                                                                                          Results
                                                                                                                                                                practice of intervention moderated the effect of time on
                                                                                             Chi-square tests revealed no significant group differences         hyperactivity within the YG group (b = -0.14, SE = 0.56,
                                                                                          in gender ( p = 0.07), race, ( p = 0.48), or ethnicity ( p = 0.90).   p = 0.79, and b = 0.22, SE = 0.21, p = 0.30, respectively).
                                                                                          FIG. 1. SWAN rating scale for ADHD—inattention. At baseline, the average scores for the YG (2.11 – 2.001) and the CG
                                                                                          (2.06 – 1.964) were comparable ( p = 0.86). At week 12, the average scores of the YG (1.57 – 1.904) and the CG
                                                                                          (2.67 – 2.197) were significantly different ( p < 0.001). Within the YG, the average scores significantly decreased (d = 0.27).
                                                                                          Within the CG, the average scores significantly increased ( p = 0.013). ADHD, attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder; CG,
                                                                                          control group; SWAN, the strengths and weaknesses of ADHD symptoms and normal behavior; YG, yoga group.
                                                                                          YOGA BENEFITS IN HIGH SCHOOL                                                                                                 705
                                                                                                        Table 4. Yoga and Meditation                        yoga exercises should be practiced daily, there was no ob-
                                                                                                            Perceived Helpfulness                           jective way that assessed whether this practice occurred.
                                                                                                                                                            Fourth, objective ratings from teachers on student outcomes
                                                                                                                     Yoga was Yoga was                      were not assessed. Finally, our yoga class size was about 50
                                                                                                                      helpful NOT helpful TOTALS
                                                                                                                                                            students, whereas data from other studies suggest that
                                                                                          Meditation was helpful        49            16           65       smaller yoga classes (i.e., 10 or fewer students per class)
                                                                                          Meditation was                 8            14           22       yield improvements.43
                                                                                            NOT helpful
                                                                                          TOTALS                        57            30           87       Conclusions
                                                                                                                                                               Within these limitations, this study adds to the literature
                                                                                          et al.37 found no statistically significant differences in PSS    because it shows feasibility of a Hatha yoga practice in a
                                                                                          scores between yoga (n = 36) and PE-as-usual (n = 15)             school setting with positive outcomes for the students,
                                                                                          groups after 28 sessions over 10 weeks. Khalsa et al.25 also      particularly in improving inattention and hyperactivity.
                                                                                          did not find significant reductions in PSS scores in high         However, several important questions remain to be an-
                                                                                          school students (67 yoga and 33 controls) that participated       swered. Indeed, for the best possible benefits, the optimal
                                                                                          in two to three yoga classes per week.                            dose for the yoga intervention and frequency and duration of
                                                                                             Potential reasons for different findings across studies are    practice still need to be determined. Furthermore, use of
                                                                                          several. For instance, the frequency, amount, and duration of     more objective outcomes including both symptomology and
                                                                                                                                                            functional outcomes is needed. In summary, school is an
Downloaded by 45.184.151.66 from www.liebertpub.com at 09/09/24. For personal use only.
                                                                                             Results from the SWAN self-report were not in the                The authors acknowledge the certified yoga instructors
                                                                                          clinically significant range as none of the mean scores were      who taught the yoga curriculum to the students at the school.
                                                                                          above 6 (Table 3). Nonetheless, with the practice of Hatha
                                                                                          yoga, inattention and hyperactivity symptoms diminished.          Author Disclosure Statement
                                                                                          In a clinical context, Hatha yoga, if practiced consistently,        The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest
                                                                                          might be a tool that could delay or potentially prevent onset     to disclose.
                                                                                          of a clinical diagnosis of ADHD.
                                                                                             This study was not designed for clinical outcomes, but
                                                                                                                                                            Funding Information
                                                                                          can serve as a preliminary assessment of stress levels that
                                                                                          may warrant clinical intervention. All our students’ mean           No funding was received for this article.
                                                                                          scores fell in the moderate stress range (Table 3). With the
                                                                                          practice of Hatha yoga, the PSS scores from the YG did            References
                                                                                          decrease, whereas the scores from the CG increased, but
                                                                                          neither change was significant. Perhaps if their practice had      1. Khalsa SB, Butzer B. Yoga in school settings: A research
                                                                                                                                                                review. Ann N Y Acad Sci 2016;1373:45–55.
                                                                                          been extended past 12 weeks, the decrease in stress levels
                                                                                                                                                             2. Liehr P, Diaz N. A pilot study examining the effect of
                                                                                          may have reached significance.
                                                                                                                                                                mindfulness on depression and anxiety for minority chil-
                                                                                                                                                                dren. Arch Psychiatr Nurs 2010;24:69–71.
                                                                                          Limitations                                                        3. Zenner C, Herrnleben-Kurz S, Walach H. Mindfulness-
                                                                                             There are several limitations. First, students were not            based interventions in schools-a systematic review and
                                                                                          randomly assigned to groups. Second, students in the yoga             meta-analysis. Front Psychol 2014;5:603.
                                                                                                                                                             4. Beauchemin J, Manns J. Walking talking therapy. Ment
                                                                                          group only participated in 25-min sessions. Most studies
                                                                                                                                                                Health Today 2008;8:34–35.
                                                                                          have reported benefits from longer sessions. In our case,
                                                                                                                                                             5. Iyengar BKS. Light on the Yoga Sutras of Patanjali. Lon-
                                                                                          45 min were allotted for the yoga session, however the                don: The Aquarian Press, 1993.
                                                                                          transit time between classes shortened the available time for      6. Cramer H, Lauche R, Langhorst J, et al. Is one yoga style
                                                                                          yoga practice. Third, although it was emphasized that the             better than another? A systematic review of associations of
                                                                                                                                                                yoga style and conclusions in randomized yoga trials.
                                                                                                Table 5. Yoga and Meditation Continuation                       Complement Ther Med 2016;25:178–187.
                                                                                                                                                             7. Feuerstein G. The Yoga Tradition: Its History, Literature,
                                                                                                                         Will     Will NOT                      Philosophy and Practice. Prescott, AZ: Hohm Press, 1998:
                                                                                                                       continue   continue                      550.
                                                                                                                         yoga       yoga       TOTALS        8. Cramer H, Lauche R, Dobos G. Characteristics of ran-
                                                                                                                                                                domized controlled trials of yoga: A bibliometric analysis.
                                                                                          Will continue meditation        26          20           46
                                                                                          Will NOT continue                5          36           41           BMC Complement Altern Med 2014;14:328.
                                                                                            meditation                                                       9. Sharma M. Yoga as an alternative and complementary
                                                                                          TOTALS                          31          56           87           approach for stress management: A systematic review.
                                                                                                                                                                J Evid Based Complementary Altern Med 2014;19:59–67.
                                                                                          YOGA BENEFITS IN HIGH SCHOOL                                                                                                   707
                                                                                          10. Burley M. Hatha Yoga: Its Context, Theory, and Practice.       29. Swanson JM, Schuck S, Porter MM, et al. Categorical and
                                                                                              Delhi, India: Motilal Banarsidass Publishers Private Lim-          dimensional definitions and evaluations of symptoms of
                                                                                              ited, 2000.                                                        ADHD: History of the SNAP and the SWAN rating scales.
                                                                                          11. Hofmann SG, Andreoli G, Carpenter JK, et al. Effect of             Int J Educ Psychol Assess 2012;10:51–70.
                                                                                              Hatha yoga on anxiety: A meta-analysis. J Evid Based Med       30. Burton CL, Wright L, Shan J, et al. SWAN scale for ADHD
                                                                                              2016;9:116–124.                                                    trait-based genetic research: A validity and polygenic risk
                                                                                          12. Uebelacker LA, Tremont G, Gillette LT, et al. Adjunctive           study. J Child Psychol Psychiatry 2019;60:988–997.
                                                                                              yoga v. health education for persistent major depression: A    31. Lai KY, Leung PW, Luk ES, et al. Validation of the Chi-
                                                                                              randomized controlled trial. Psychol Med 2017;47:2130–             nese strengths and weaknesses of ADHD-symptoms and
                                                                                              2142.                                                              normal-behaviors questionnaire in Hong Kong. J Atten
                                                                                          13. Riley D. Hatha yoga and the treatment of illness. Altern           Disord 2013;17:194–202.
                                                                                              Ther Health Med 2004;10:20–21.                                 32. Lakes KD, Swanson JM, Riggs M. The reliability and va-
                                                                                          14. Weare K, Nind M. Mental health promotion and problem               lidity of the English and Spanish Strengths and Weaknesses
                                                                                              prevention in schools: What does the evidence say? Health          of ADHD and Normal behavior rating scales in a preschool
                                                                                              Promot Int 2011;26(Suppl. 1):i29–i69.                              sample: Continuum measures of hyperactivity and inat-
                                                                                          15. Butzer B, Van Over M, Noggle Taylor JJ, et al. Yoga may            tention. J Atten Disord 2012;16:510–516.
                                                                                              mitigate decreases in high school grades. Evid Based           33. Gurley J. Conners-Wells Adolescent Self Report Scale. In:
                                                                                              Complement Alternat Med 2015;2015:259814.                          Goldstein S, Naglieri JA, eds. Encyclopedia of Child Be-
                                                                                          16. Serwacki ML, Cook-Cottone C. Yoga in the schools: A                havior and Development. Boston, MA: Springer, 2011.
                                                                                              systematic review of the literature. Int J Yoga Therap 2012:   34. Cohen S, Kamarck T, Mermelstein R. A global measure of
Downloaded by 45.184.151.66 from www.liebertpub.com at 09/09/24. For personal use only.