ليان نار
ليان نار
org
DOI: 10.13189/cea.2020.080528
1
Department of Science, University of Home Economics, Pakistan
2
Department of Family and Consumer Sciences, University of Home Economics, Pakistan
3
Architecture Section, Aligarh Muslim University, India
Received July 30, 2020; Revised August 31, 2020; Accepted September 29, 2020
not only stress on the quality of food but also prefer the A restaurant, appropriate light is required to look at the
ambience to attract customers. The two restaurants present food at its best by the customer. The conclusion is that all
in Shalimar Tower hotel, were selected, named, Jasmine efforts are for the customer to be satisfied [25][26].
restaurant and Lahore View restaurant. The reason to select Therefore, the restaurant required to light each table
the restaurants was the alterations were regularly being individually, to create its own ambience [27]. Light can
made in the interiors of the restaurants but not being make the place cool and calm for the enjoyment of the
analyzed. The objectives were set to find out the services and experience. Customers speak more politely
connection between customer gratification and ambient and delicately when lights are dim [28]. Light can be one of
factors such as color, light and cooling, given below: the most dominant physical features which influence the
To analyze the impact of demographic characteristics most in the restaurants [29]. Light is also the impression
on customer’s satisfaction. which a restaurateur wants to create [27]. The light can
To find out the relationship between color, cooling distinguish the place to have a unique experience than in
and lights in the restaurants on customers’ any other place. The pioneer of the light research, Flynn,
gratification. Hendrick, Spencer, Martyniuk, investigated the impact of
light on customer feelings and attitude so that light will
play a role as an ambient attribute [30][31][32].
2. Literature Review
2.4. Customer Gratification and Ambient Cooling
The literature is all about the ambient features and their
The challenge of maintaining a business includes diverse
linkage to the customer gratification.
temperature and individuals' varying desires which must be
understood and accomplished [26]. There are a lot of
2.1. Customer Gratification and Ambient Conditions requirement in a restaurant such as proper ventilation,
water purification, appropriate temperature etc. but the
The customer gratification is a relationship between result must be in form of satisfied diners with appropriate
professional benefits and administrative strategies to fulfil ambience. The constant temperature can provide a
customer demands. Increasing significant level of client consistent patron behavior [26]. Restaurateurs use air
satisfaction is critical to organizations in light of the fact conditioning method to maintain the temperature of
that fulfilled clients and to utilize a wide scope of restaurant. The temperature imbalance can damage the
administration [15][16][17][18]. Customers are the sole overall impact of a restaurant because the customers would
explanation behind the presence of business foundations not like too hot or cold according to climate outside and can
[19]. Lim suggests that, clients’ final gratification can have eventually damage the restaurant image. These outcomes
critical impact associated with ambient conditions inside in lost revenue, in this manner, the parity must be
the eating place [20]. Researchers have distinguished accomplished through cooling. Huang et al explored on the
ambient settings as a condition that influence impression of impacts of surrounding cooling on item inclinations and
human reactions related to surroundings [21][22]. budgetary basic leadership. Results featured that agreeable
Surrounding conditions envelop a variety of foundation encompassing cooling impact shopper inclination for
qualities of the earth, for example, design, temperature, similarity. Clients have no indistinguishable physical and
color, light, commotion, music, and aroma [3][4][5]. enthusiastic marks, in this way, restaurateurs should locate
a shared belief where the larger number is content. This can
2.2. Customer Gratification and Ambient Color result in the loss of revenue or profit. The uniformity is
required through constant temperature studied the effects
The utilization of appropriate colors in interiors of a of ambient low or required temperature to be preferred on
restaurant can make the place practically feasible and items’ likeness and money decisions. The results
acceptable to the customer and can impact of restaurant highlighted that the constant temperature provides comfort
incomings [23]. Bright colors, in general impress and to the customers and impact on their preferences.
arouse emotions while deep warm and casual light shades Customers are always not satisfied on one choice which
appear to advance leisure and repose [24]. The hues are seems difficult to achieve but restaurateurs must stress on
differentiated into hot and light colors like red, orange and the preferences of majority of the people [33].
yellow are considered to be hot while cool colors are green,
blue and violet. Hot colors show people, the imprint of hot
agreeable conditions [11]. The cool colors also, make 3. Research Methodology
comfortable places which contribute in customer The causal research design was studied to find out the
appreciation [23]. cause and effect relationship of customer gratification and
ambience [34]. The population was the customers of all the
2.3. Customer Gratification and Ambient Light restaurants who offer regular alterations in their interior
Civil Engineering and Architecture 8(5): 1019-1027, 2020 1021
1: Null hypothesis: There is no correlation between gratification and cooling has an AVE of 0.649 and 0.771
income and age of customers and dine in frequency which is clearly higher than the value of their combined R
Alternative hypothesis/: There is significant correlation square. Similarly, on pair wise comparisons, it can be
between income and age of customers and dine in easily seen that the AVE for the constructs is higher than
frequency the R square values of two constructs. This ensures that the
2: Null hypothesis: There is no association between questionnaire has discriminant validity.
demographic characteristics (gender/income) and
Table 2. R square values of customer gratification, ambient color, light
customer’s gratification and cooling
Alternative hypothesis: There is significant association
Customer
between demographic characteristics (gender/income) and Variables
Gratification
AC AL AC
customer’s gratification. CG 1
3: Null hypothesis: Cooling, Color and Lightning in
AC 0.812 1
restaurant have no significant impact on customer’s
gratification AL 0.701 0.449 1
Alternative hypothesis: Cooling, Color and Lightning in A CL 0.649 0.456 0.278 1
restaurant have significant impact on customer’s
gratification
5. Demographic Characteristics
4. Data Analysis and Interpretations The sample of 354 customers had the following
demographic characteristics
The data analysis is represented in tabular form, where
the customer gratification was dependent variable and Table 3. Gender Distribution of the Respondents
color, light and cooling were independent variables. Some Gender Frequency Percentage (%)
of the abbreviations are assigned to the constructs in tables, Female 167 47.2
given below:
Male 187 52.8
Customer Gratification = CG, Ambient Color= AC,
Ambient Light= AL, Ambient Cooling=ACL Total 354 100.0
respondents. It can be seen that about 85% of the So the null hypothesis is accepted.
respondents were less than 55 years of age.
Table 8. Chi-Square Test
Correlations between dine in frequency, age and income
are calculated to find out the relationship between them Asymptotic Exact Exact
Value df Sig. Sig. Sig.
Table 6. Correlations between Dine in Frequency, Age and Income (2-sided) (2-sided) (1-sided)
Pearson
Dine in .629a 1 .428
Age Income Chi-Square
Frequency
Continuity
Pearson
1 -.007 .087 Correction .445 1 .505
Correlation
Age b
Sig. (2-tailed) .890 .102
a. 0 cells (0.0%) have expected count less than 5. The minimum
N 354 354 354 expected count is 39.16.
Pearson
-.007 1 .540**
Correlation
Income 6.2. Income and Customers Satisfaction
Sig. (2-tailed) .890 .000
N 354 354 354
Null Hypothesis: There is no association between
Pearson
.087 .540** 1 income and customer’s satisfaction
Dine in Correlation
Frequency Sig. (2-tailed) .102 .000 Alternative Hypothesis: There is association between
N 354 354 354 income and customer’s satisfaction.
**. Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).
Table 9. Income*satisfaction Cross Tabulation
The Table 6 indicates the value correlation coefficient Not Satisfied Satisfied Total
between age and dine in frequency is 0.087 which is Low income 5 15 20
insignificant, concluding that there is no significant Middle income 51 152 203
correlation between age and dine in frequency while the high Income 27 104 131
correlation between income and dine in frequency is 0.54 Total 83 271 354
which is highly significant (p value=0.00) and positive
concluding as the income increases, the dine in frequency The Table 9 indicates the cross tabulation of income and
satisfaction. It can be seen that most respondents are
also increases.
satisfied and responses are distributed between the three
income groups.
6. Test of Association Table 10. Chi-Square Test
customer’s satisfaction The Table 10 indicates the value of chi square =0.932
H4 There is association between gender and customer’s which is statistically insignificant (p=0.628>0.05) which
satisfaction. indicates that customer’s satisfaction is not associated with
Table 7. Gender * satisfaction Cross Tabulation their income.
Not Satisfied Satisfied Total
6.3. Binary Logistic Regression Model to analyze the
Female 36 131 167
Impact of Cooling, Lightning and Color Ambience
Male 47 140 187 on Customer’s Gratification as a Mode to Increase
Total 83 271 354 Revenue
The table 7 indicates the cross tabulation of gender and The study targets at analyzing effect of cooling lights
satisfaction. It can be seen that most respondents are and color ambience on the customers’ satisfaction as a
satisfied and responses are homogeneously distributed mode to increase revenue.
between the two gender groups. The model has three predictors color light and cooling
The table 8 is indicating the value of chi square =0.629 ambience and one binary dependent variable Y=
which is statistically insignificant (p=0.428>0.05) which CG=Gratification/satisfaction where
indicates that customer’s satisfaction is not associated with Y=0 for unsatisfied customer
the gender. Y=1 for satisfied customers
1024 Analysis of Interior Design of Restaurants with Reference to Ambience and Customer Gratification
We denote p=P(Y=1) and assume a linear relationship The table 11 indicates that the logit model is significant
between predictors and the log odds of the event y=1 as p values are 0.00 which is less than the pre-assumed
(satisfaction), then the model can be written as alpha 0.05.
Table 12. Model Summary
-2 Log Cox & Snell R Nagelkerke R
Step
Where AC= Color, likelihood Square Square
AL= Light 1 302.342a .210 .316
ACL= Cooling a. Estimation terminated at iteration number 5 because parameter
𝛽𝛽0, = Constant estimates changed by less than .001.
𝛽𝛽1 , 𝛽𝛽2 𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎 𝛽𝛽3 are the coefficients of C, L and CL The Table 12 indicates the summary of the model with
respectively. Cox and Snell value or R square =.210 which is showing
The odds can be obtained by exponentiation of the the model prediction also the Nagelkerke R square value of
log-Odds 0.316 which is also good for logit models.
The Table 13 indicates the results of the testing of the
coefficients of the logistic regression model, it can be seen
The data were analyzed using SPSS and the following that all the three coefficients if cooling lightning and color
results are obtained are statistically significant. The constant is also found to be
significant thus all the predictors have significant impact
Table 11. Omnibus Tests of Model Coefficients on the customer’s gratification
Chi-square Df Sig. The logit model is given as
Step 1 Step 83.244 3 .000
Block 83.244 3 .000
Model 83.244 3 .000
Figure 1. Histogram predicted probabilities of customer satisfaction using the binary logistic model
is considered as most impacting element on human as one Satisfaction in the Restaurant Industry; Case Study of
can only see food properly in light. The light is also Debonairs Pizza Outlets in Botswana. International Journal
of Science and Research, 6(2), 1825-1833, 2017.
considered as most significant encompassing variable as it
permits the customers’ capacity to see the food in its most [2] W. Kasapila, Young adult’s satisfaction regarding dining
ideal manner. Along these lines, the executives ought to experience in casual dining restaurant in Hatfield, Pretoria,
guarantee that when structuring the eatery light, each table 2006.
ought to have its very own climate regarding the light as [3] M. J. Bitner, Servicescapes: The impact of physical
this prompt client satisfaction. surroundings on customers and employees. Journal of
The three hypotheses were formulated to test the results Marketing; Volume 56(2):57–71, 1992.
so it was found there is significant correlation between [4] V. A. Zeithaml, and M.J. Bitner, Services marketing:
income and age of customers and dine in frequency and Integrating customer focus across the firm, (3rd Ed.). Boston,
there is significant association between demographic New York: Mcgraw-Hill, 2003.
characteristics (gender/income) and customer’s
[5] M. S. Omar, H. F. Ariffin, R. Ahmed, The Relationship
gratification along that Cooling, Color and Lightning in between Restaurant Ambience and Customers’ Satisfaction
restaurant have significant impact on customer’s in Shah Alam Arabic Restaurants, Selangor. International
gratification. Results showed that there is a positive Journal of Administration and Governance. 1 (4) Special,
relationship between customer gratification and light. Ayaz 1-8. ISSN 2077-4486, 2015.
[6], Farooq and Ahmed [7], Farooq et al [8] Flynn et. Al [6] S. Ayaz, Comparison of Two Aesthetical Lighting Plans in
[32] and [33] also concluded the similar results which Moderate Upscale Restaurants on Patron Turnover Rate
supported the study that ambient light also positively (PTOR). Sci. Int. (Lahore), 27 (4), 3575-3578,2015 ISSN
impacts on customers’ feelings, behavior and gratification. 1013-531,2015.
These results suggest that Shalimar restaurants must stress [7] S. Farooq, A. Ahmed. Designed Lighting Plan and its
more on light levels in the interiors. The opportunity to Impacts on Patron Turnover Rate in the Restaurants.
modify the temperature in the restaurants for customers Sci.Int.(Lahore), 28 (6), 203-206, 2016.
raises its value. The study also showed that there is a
[8] S. Farooq, M. Khan, A. Ahmed Employees Comfort Level in
positive connection between room cooling and client
Existing Lighting at Arfa Software Technology Park (ASTP):
delight. This is in accordance with other researchers’ A Case Study. Sci.Int.(Lahore), 31 (5), 785-788, 2019.
discoveries, Motoki, et al, Sharifi and Huang et al inferred
that surrounding cooling decidedly influences client [9] R. L. Oliver, Satisfaction: A behavioral perspective on the
delight [25][26][34]. Generally, it is considered that the consumer, The McGraw-Hill Companies Inc., New York,
1997.
taste of food is the main factor to attract customers in the
restaurant business but the ambience is also having strong [10] Y. Jordaan, M. Prinsloo, Grasping service markets, 2001.
influence on customer gratification [19][20]. Nonetheless,
[11] J. Kivela, R. Inbakaran, J. Reece. Consumer research in the
this exploration finding infers that restaurant supervisors restaurant environment, P a r t 1: A conceptual model of
can depend on surrounding conditions additionally as a dining satisfaction and return patronage, International
reason for client gratification [21][22]. This examination Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management; Volume
approved that if interior ambience is improved it can also 11(5):205-222., 1999.
upgrade customer gratification in the restaurant experience. [12] T. Y. Choi, R. Chu. Determinants of hotel guests satisfaction
The results of binary regression were also significant and and repeat patronage in the Hong Kong Hotel industry;
positive showing that improvement in color, lightning and International Journal o f Hospitality Management; Volume
cooling improves the overall customer’s gratification 3(20): 234-244, 2001.
which eventually leads to the increase in revenue of [13] C. Park, Efficient or Enjoyable. Consumer value of eating
restaurants [6][7][8]. out and fast food restaurant consumption in Korea;
In accordance with the above outcomes, it is International Journal of Hospitality Management; Volume
recommended that restaurants ought to connect more into 1(23), 2004.
exercises, for example, upgrading or altering the light so as [14] S. Khan, S. M. Hussain, F. Yaqoob. Determinants of
to light up the space more. In addition, the analyst suggests customer satisfaction in fast food industry; International
that the outlet ought to have appropriate color choice as this Journal of Management and Strategy; Vol. 3(4): 78-88,
urges client to participate in drive purchasing. The 2012.
temperature should be balanced to arrive at the ideal level [15] R. T. Rust, A. J. Zohoric, Customer satisfaction, customer
through cooling. retention and market share, Journal of Retailing, 1993.
restaurant industry: An exam of the transaction specific [27] A. E. Ciani. A study of how lighting can affect a guest's
model. Journal of Services Marketing; UNLV Gaming dining experience. Lowa State University, Graduate Thesis
Research and Review Journal, 7(1):21-31, 2006. and Dissertation. Digital Repository@ LAwa State
University. Retrieved May 30th 2014 from
[18] K. Ryu, S. Jang, The effect of environmental perceptions on lib.dr.iastate.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2435&context
behavioral intentions through emotions: The case of upscale =etd
restaurants. Journal of Hospitality of Tourism Research,
Volume (56) :72.79, 2007. [28] A. Yuksel, F. Yusel, Measurement of tourist satisfaction
with restaurant services: A segment based approach. Journal
[19] R. J. Varey. Internal marketing: a review and some of Vacation Marketing, 9(1): 52-68, 2002.
interdisciplinary research challenges. International Journal
of Service Industry Management, 1995.. [29] G. R. Steffy. Architectural Lighting Design (3rd Ed.). New
York, NY: J. Wiley and Sons, 2008.
[20] H. Lim. Understanding American customer perceptions on
Japanese food and services in the U.S. Unpublished master's [30] J. E. Flynn. A study of subjective responses to low energy
thesis, University of Nevada, Las Vegas, 2010. and nonuniform lighting systems. Lighting Design and
Application, 7 (2), pp. 6-15, 1977.
[21] R. Gifford. Light, decor, arousal, comfort and
[31] J. E. Flynn, G. J. Subisak. A procedure for qualitative study
communication: Journal of Environmental Psychology; Vol.
of light level variations and system performance. Journal of
8(3), 1988.
IES, 8(1), 28-35, 1978.
[22] J. Baker, L. L. Berry, A. Parasuraman, The marketing impact [32] J. E. Flynn, C. Hendrick, T. Spencer, O. Martyniuk. A guide
of branch facility design; Journal of Retail Banking; Volume to methodology procedures for measuring subjective
10(2):33–42, 1988. impressions in lighting. Journal of Illuminating Engineering
Society (8), 95-110, 1979.
[23] D. L. Kurtz, K. E. Clow. Services marketing. Wiley, 1998.
[33] S. Farooq, F. Zubair, M. Arif Kamal. Assessment of
[24] N. Stroebele, J. De Castro. Effect of ambience on food intake Lighting Design of Restaurants with Reference to its
and food choice. Nutrition, 20(9), 821-838, 2004. Aesthetics and Function, Civil Engineering and Architecture,
Horizon Research Publishing, USA, 8(4), 714-720, 2020.
[25] K. Motoki, T. Saito, R. Nouchi, R. Kawashima, M. Sugiura,
Light colors and comfortable warmth: Cross modal [34] X. Huang, M. Zhang, M. K. Hui, S. R. Wyer. Warmth and
correspondences between thermal sensations and color conformity: The effects of ambient temperature on product
lightness influence consumer behavior, Food Quality and preferences and financial decisions. Journal of Consumer
Preference, 72, 45-55. 2019. Psychology https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcps.2013.09.009,
2013.
[26] S. Sharifi. When more pain is better: Role of need for
uniqueness on service evaluations of observable service [35] J. F. Hair, R. E. Anderson, R. L. Zatham, W. C. Black..
recovery, International Journal of Hospitality Management, Multivariate data analysis (5th ed.). UK: Prentice Hall
2019. International, 1998.