Acquiring Digital Skills For Effective Service Delivery of E-Resources by Library Professionals in Public Higher Institutions in Imo State, Nigeria
Acquiring Digital Skills For Effective Service Delivery of E-Resources by Library Professionals in Public Higher Institutions in Imo State, Nigeria
Abstract
Acquiring digital skills by librarians in public higher institutions for effective service delivery
in Imo State, Nigeria were examined with the view to ascertain the various digital skills
possessed by the librarians, determining the ways of acquiring the skills and the challenges to
the acquisition of the skills. The study adopted descriptive survey design, the study covered
four (4) public higher institutions in Imo State with population of 98 professional and para-
professional librarians. Purposive sampling technique was used to select the 4 higher
institutions in Imo State. Rating scale was adopted as instrument for data collection which was
in line with the research questions. Data collected were analyzed using descriptive statistics.
The result of the study revealed that the most digital skills possessed by the librarians is having
knowledge of computer operation , creating new word process document and social
networking. The results also showed that colleague’s assistance is the most method of
acquiring digital skills, followed by attending computer training, self study and use of diverse
technologies. More so, the result showed that poor ICT infrastructures, lack of funds and lack
basic skills in the use of ICT, poor internet connectivity and telecommunication, as well as non-
digital library course in the LBS curriculum are seen as challenges in acquiring digital skills.
The research therefore concluded that all librarians in institutions of higher learning should
as a matter of necessity acquire different digital skills for effective service delivery. The study
recommended that Government and management of higher institutions should provide funds
for training and re-training of librarians for effective services delivery in institution of higher
learning.
Introduction
Today there is a global trend in information resources management among library staff
with emphasis drifting from paper to e – resources as a result of advances in information
technology. The fact that print forms of information resources are characterized by high
cost , bulkiness , slow in delivery ,scarcity etc have made many libraries transform their
resources through digitization processes from paper to electronic sources (Nwachukwu
Asiegbu & Igwesi, 2010). Adegbore (2011) stated that academic librarians now use digital
skills for better service delivery and for satisfying diverse user’s needs as these skills
have no physical boundary; More so, these skills have round the clock availability,
multiple access e.g.; many users can access the same information at the same time, and
can be reproduced without tear and wear as observed in paper resources.
Digital skills also have the advantage of networking ability, space saving, cost saving
with very friendly user search and retrieved interface (Baro,Obaw and Aduba, 2019) .
Therefore, librarians ought to develop their skills to enable them operate effectively in
the digital environment hence , saving in storage devices, retrieving information saved
77
in a system, scanning and uploading data and images, printing data, sending and attaching
e-mails, typesetting etc are various necessary basic skills needed by librarians to operate
in a given digital environment
The acquisition of digital skills for e-resources have become more and more vital due
to the paradigm shift from paper to online education. Although, Ambrose and Ogunbodede
(2022 ) opined that e-resources have numerous advantages as it allows remote access to
various online resources, it also have some disadvantages as it is computer-based and
thus need information literacy skills for searching, retrieving and uses . Information
literacy skill is an important skill that enables one to effortlessly search and critically
evaluate the huge amount of information accessibility due to sudden increase of
information (Adeleke, 2016).
Librarians are no longer just the guardians of books; they are information providers in an
environment that is constantly changing where information needs to be gathered very quickly
and effectively. The librarians that can survive in this environment are those that have acquired
the digital skills effectively and proactively to a broad spectrum of contemporary challenges
that focused on speed, cost and quality of information (Abbas, 2014). Acquisition of digital
skills increases self efficiency which in turn influence ICT acceptance. The librarians are
therefore expected to acquire additional skills to enable them work efficiently within the
contemporary library world for qualitative service delivery to the library users. It was based on
this assertion that this work acquiring digital skills by the librarians in public higher institutions
for effective service delivery was embarked upon.
Statement of the Problem
As a result of new and emerging technologies today, there is a fundamental shift from
traditional information environment to e-environment. Library resources are now selected,
organized, processed, accessed and disseminated to the user communities through various
digital skills such as social networking, online cataloguing, printing of document etc.
It is unfortunate that despite the fact that we are in a digital era of information, most librarians
lack the requisite expertise to maneuver the current ICT facilities available with the view to
navigating into the wealth of information resources available everywhere on the web and other
specialized databases. The librarians therefore do not utilize the available facilities to deliver,
provide and disseminate information resources to the end users.
The use of educational software, digital gadgets and resources are now being made available
to the librarians hence the influx of information globalization and the use of digital technology
has made the world a global village where access and use of digital skills has become a common
practice. Despite all these, there is still lack of utilization of digital literacy skills by librarians
as most of them lack skills on how to operate and manage the available digital facilities hence
the need for this research.
Purpose of the Study
The main purpose of this study is to examine digital skills acquired by the librarians in public
institutional libraries in Imo State for effective service delivery. The study specifically intended
to:
1. To ascertain various digital skills possessed by librarians in public higher institution in
Imo State.
2. To determine ways of acquiring digital skills by the librarians for services delivery, and
3. To identify the challenges to the acquisition of digital skills by librarians.
78
Research Questions
The following research questions were posed to guide the study:
1. What are the various digital skills possessed by the librarians in public institutions in
Imo State?
2. What methods can be adopted in acquiring digital skills by the librarians for effective
service delivery?
3. What are the challenges in acquiring digital skills by the librarians?
79
the use of application software such as creating a new word processor document , printing of
documents, ability to use world wide web, etc. Choi (2006) opined that in traditional library
skills and knowledge, digital librarians are expected to possess additional knowledge and skill
to work within the digital information world. Therefore, educating digital librarians who are
competent to work in the dynamic and complex digital environment has become a high priority
(Ezema, Ugwuanyi & Ugwu, 2014) .Although Honey, Culp and Speilvogel (2005) is of the
view that librarians required digital skills that will encourage them to communicate
effectively using online platforms , analyze and interpret data, understand computational
modeling , engage in problem solving and ensure security etc . Librarians should possess skills
that are appropriate to support their intellectual ability for effective services delivery.
Ways of acquiring digital skill for services delivery cannot be overemphasized. The efficiency
of any library no matter the types depends to a large extent on the competency of its staff.
Adomi and Famola (2013) pointed that Professional development is an important component
of ongoing librarian’s education and is very critical to performance of their roles. He continued
by saying that one of the ways is by continuation of acquisition of knowledge that has been
met by either formal education or on- the -job training and off –the- job training based on where
the training is taking place . On –the –job training is in form of demonstration, lecture,
simulation , mentoring , discussion, regular staff meeting, literature research etc while off-the-
job training takes place outside the normal working environment in form of further education
and career development, conference and seminars, short course, professional contribution,
experimentation etc. Eke (2011) further identified that digital skill for services delivery can be
acquired through conference , workshop, and seminars attendance, on-the-training, mentoring,
formal professional education, publications, on-going postgraduate programmes etc.
Furthermore, American Library Association (2012) stressed that librarians should possess the
variety of skills – technical and cognitive, having the ability to communicate, evaluate, and
create digital information in a wide variety of formats, able to use diverse technologies
appropriate and effective to information, interpret results, and judge the quality of that
information. Khan and Bhatti (2020) stated that there is need for continuing education in the
modern information environment, stressing that education and training must become a
continuous life long process to keep abreast with change a professional which is becoming
increasingly complex and specialized. Also, Srivastava (2004) pointed out that Librarians need
opportunities for higher education and opportunities for attending conferences.
Challenges to the acquisition of digital skills include poor development of technology,
infrastructure, poor attitude of librarians, poor internet connectivity and telecommunication
infrastructure, lack of competent trainers for digital skills, none availability of digital library
course, lack of funds, and lack of commitment from management to send staff for further
courses. Tanawade (2011) stated that incompetence on the side of Librarians, many of them
lack self –reliance in the face of growing information technology for services delivery, this
problem slows the delivery of services and also delays productivity. Sahabi and Elvis (2021)
stated that lack of basic skills in the use of information technology has become bottleneck for
better library services, Anira (2011) added that librarians who do not have advanced ICT skills
cannot provide effective office services, based on that any librarian who do not have skills
especially ICT skill has a problem in providing digital library services in this digital age. The
strength of any library lies on the information resources provided by both printed and online.
Sahabi and Elvis (2021) opined that funds are needed to manage the services in the library but
the level of Government support to education sector is totally not enough. That is why Nawalu
(2000) emphasized that the problems with computer application in African libraries include
80
81
followed by creating a new word process document and social networking which ranked second
with 3.2 each, other important digital skills possessed by the librarians are printing of
document, ability to use World Wide Web, record preservation by electronic means, online
searching, and record management with mean scores above 2.50 each.
Research Question Two: What methods can be adopted in acquiring digital skills by librarians
for effective services delivery?
Table 2: Methods of Acquiring Digital Skills
S/N Item Statements SA A D SD MEAN REMARKS
1 Continuation of knowledge 28(112) 38(114) 20(40) 12(12) 2.8 Positive
(formal education)
2 Self study /informal 34(136) 40(120) 24(48) - 3.1 Positive
education
3 Ability to communicate - 15 (45) 40(80) 43(43) 1.7 Negative
4 Interpretation of result - 29 (87) 43(86) 26(26) 2.0 Negative
5 Use of diverse technologies 43(172) 29 (87) 16(32) 10(10) 3.0 Positive
6 Technical and cognitive 24 (96) 29 (87) 25(50) 22(22) 2.5 Positive
methods
7 Trial and error method 26(104) 40(120) 12(24) 20(20) 2.7 Positive
8 Attending - 20 (60) 43(86) 35(35) 1.8 Negative
workshops/conferences
/seminars
9 Attending computer training 49(196) 39(117) 10(20) - 3.3 Positive
10 Colleague’s assistance 50(200) 44(132) 4 (8) - 3.4 Positive
Grand mean 2.57 Positive
Table 2 above shows results on methods of acquiring digital skills by librarians, the result
reveals that continuation of knowledge which is formal education, self- study informal
education, use of diverse technologies, technical and cognitive methods, trial and error method,
and colleague’s assistance ranked above 2.5 each. From the table colleague’s assistance is the
most method for acquiring digital skills, followed by attending computer training, self-study
/informal education, use of diverse technologies etc.
Research Question Three: What are the challenges in acquiring digital skills by the librarians?
Table 3: Challenges in acquiring digital skills by the Librarians
S/N Item Statements SA A D SD MEAN REMARKS
1 Poor internet connectivity 60(240) 22(66) 14(28) 4 (4) 3.4 Positive
and telecommunication
2 Lack of funds 56(224) 39(117) 3(6) - 3.5 Positive
3 Poor ICT infrastructures 67(268) 19(57) 12(24) - 3.6 Positive
4 Lack of commitment from 7(24) 40(120) 19(38) 32(32) 2.2 Negative
the management to send staff
for further course
5 Lack of basic skills in the use 37(111) 7(14) - 3.5 Positive
of ICT 55(220)
6 Irregular power supply - 18(54) 8(16) 72(72) 1.4 Negative
7 Non- digital library course in 48(192) 32(96) 11(22) 7 (7) 3.2 Positive
LIS curriculum.
8 Poor development of 30(120) 26(78) 22(44) 20(20) 2.7 Positive
technology in Nigeria
Grand mean 2.9
Table 3 shows the results analysis of challenges in acquiring digital skills by the librarians.
Poor ICT infrastructures with mean score of 3.6 ranked the highest followed by lack of funds
and lack of basic skill in the use of ICT with 3.5 each, poor internet connectivity and
82
83
definitely close the gap of non acquisition of digital skills and hence lead to effective services
delivery.
Way Forward
From the outcome of the findings, the following way forward are made:
1. The various higher institutions in particular and indeed the government in general
should make funds available to librarians for digital development.
2. Librarians in higher institutions should be proactive in acquiring digital skills for
effective services delivery
3. All the stakeholders should make concerted efforts to minimize the challenges faced in
the acquisition of digital skills for library services delivery.
References
Adeleke, A.A (2016). Digitalization capacity and skills of academic libraries in Nigeria.
Retrieved on 20/08/2023 at http://wireDSpace.wits.ac.za/bitstream/handle/10539/
20526/ICADLA.
Adegbore, A. M. (2011). University faculty use of electronic resources: A review of recent
literature. PNLA Quarterly the official publication of the pacific Northwest library, 1-11
Abbas, K.D (2014). From techno-illiterate to techno- literate Era: Nigerian Academic
Librarians in perspective. International Journal of Humanities and Social
Sciences.45(1).
Abid, H. (2023). The role of digital skills in academic libraries. Pakistan Observer
Adomi, E. E. & Famola, M.O (2013) Training and development of cataloguers in National
library of Nigeria, Journal of Nigerian Library Association, 46 (1), 90-98.
Ambrose, K. & Ogunbodebe, S. E. (2022). Undergraduate use of electronic resources amid
the COVID-19 pandemic lockdown. Library Philosophy and Practice (e-journal) 6434
Amkpa, S.A & Abba, T. (2009). Factors inhibiting the implantation of Information and
Communication Journal of (ICTs) in Nigerian University libraries. Journal of
information and communication technology, 6(1). Retrieved from www. ajoi.info. com.
American Library Association (2012). Digital literacy, libraries and public policy: Report of
the American library Association digital literacy task force.
Anyira, E.I. (2011) One among the twelve: How library professional s constitute a serious
challenges to the provision of library services in the 21st century. Library Philosophy
and Practice, 12(4), 121-132.
Baro, E.E., Obaro, O. G. & Aduba, E. D. (2019). An assessment of digital literacy skills and
knowledge–based competencies among librarians working in university libraries in
African. Digital Library Perspective, 35(3/4), 172-192.
Bawden, D. (2008). Digital literacy. from http://www.scitopics.com/digital literacy. html
accessed on 10/09/2023.
Bell, T. & Shank, J. (2008). Digital literacy, Definition and resources. What is digital literacy?
http://cleach. Wordpress.com/what-is –digital-Accessed on 10/09/2023
84
Choi, Y. & Rasmussen, E. (2006). What is needed to educate future digital librarians: A study
of current practice and staffing patterns in academic and research libraries. D-lib
Magazine, 12(9).
Honey, M., Culp, K.M. & Speilvogel, R. (2004). Critical Issue: Using technology to improve
students achievement, New York: North Central Regional Education Laboratory.
Ezema, I.J, Ugwuanyi, C.F & Ugwu, C.I. (2014). Skills requirement of academic librarians
for the digital library environment in Nigeria: A case of University of Nigeria, Nsukka.
International Journal of Library and Information Science, 3(1), 17-31.
Elkin, J. (1914). The role of LIS schools and departments in continuing professional
development. Librarian Career Development, 2(4); 19-23.
Eke, H. N. (2011) An empirical study of impact of Nigerian Library Association (NLA)
Conference attendance on librarians, Professional development. In proceedings of the
49th National conference and AGM of Nigerian library Association, Awka, Anambra
State, Nigeria. 118-139.
Eyerinmene, J. F. & Onuh, N. S. (2022). Acquisition of 21st century Librarianship skills by
librarians in Public University library in Bayelsa and Rivers State of Nigeria. Library
Philosophy and Practice (e-journal)
Khan, S. A. & Bhatti, R. (2020) Factors affecting digital skills of University librarians for
developing and managing digital libraries: An Assessment in Pakistan. Library
Philosophy and practice (e-journal) 4230.
Mohammed, K.S & Elvis, E.O (2021). Academic library and challenges of services delivery in
Nigerian Universities in the digital Era. Journal of Information and Knowledge
management. 12(2), 51-61.
Mulat, T & Nataraja, M. (2020) Digital literacy skills among library professionals in Jimma
University libraries. Library Philosophy and Practice (e-journal) 4629 https://digital
commons .unl.edu/ lib phil/prac.
Nawalu, K.I.N (2000) Managing information for development in the 21st century
www.eric.gov/EricWebPortal /record detail.
Nwachukwu, V. N., Asiegbu, F.N & Igwesi, U (2010) . ICT training skills for librarians:
Bedrock for effective application in Nigerian University Libraries. Benue journal of
Library Management and Information Science, 1(1), 22-27.
Sahab, M. K & Elvis, E. O. (2021). Academic library and challenges of services delivery in
Nigeria Universities in the digital Era. Journal of Information and Knowledge
Management, 12(2), 51-61.
Srivastawa, (2004). Opportunities for professional development of Librarians: A study of level
of satisfaction among librarians of institutions of higher education in JIPUE. ILA
Bulletin, 40(4), 31-34.
Tanawade, M. S. (2011). Effective interpersonal skills for library management Indian streams.
Research Journal, 1(1), 1-4.
Ugwuanyi, F. C. (2009). Information and Communication Technology (ICT) literacy among
academic librarians in Enugu State. Information Technologist, 6(1).
85