The Influence of The Western Esoteric Tradition On The Development of The Scottish Rite Degrees - HGA
The Influence of The Western Esoteric Tradition On The Development of The Scottish Rite Degrees - HGA
To this day, the origins of the speculative craft of Freemasonry remain heavily veiled. The
corrosive sands of time have slowly eaten away pages of its history, while the dust of the past
gradually covered other pages, waiting to be brushed off. For centuries, masonic scholarship was
an idea of little consideration until, in 1886, when the world’s premier lodge of research was
formed under the name of Quatuor Coronati Lodge No. 2076. This lodge of research, along with
its publication, Ars Quatuor Coronatorum, started a ferment among the brethren which would
give birth to other bodies of research and scholarship. An example of such an organization is the
Grand College of Rites founded in 1932 in Washington, D.C. whose publication, Collectanea,
publishes the material from extant and defunct rites. Another is the Scottish Rite Research
Society, founded in 1991, whose publication is known as Heredom, which contributes to a wide
Despite decades of research by notable figures such as Albert G. Mackey, Robert F. Gould,
Arthur E. Waite, Arturo de Hoyos, and many others, we still only have a limited reach into the
past with which we can assemble the early history of Freemasonry. Thanks to individuals like
them and their work, we have enough information available to us that we can identify the various
ideas that Freemasonry and its degrees were built upon. While using operative stone masonry as
orders.1
Many of Freemasonry’s high degrees2 have their roots in the eighteenth century when there
was a fervent trend of creating new degrees. This is especially true of France and Germany
where at the time we can see over 1,200 new degrees being worked and created. Some of them
being frivolous yet some being highly influential to both the current Scottish Rite and York Rite
degrees. The purpose of this paper will be to touch on the development of Scottish degrees and
how, along their journey into a coherent system, they absorbed ideas from the western esoteric
tradition.
An esoteric tradition can be defined as any system or set of hidden teachings, whether they
are hidden by their nature of complexity, or whether hidden by a group, reserved only for the
initiated. Both of these definitions can, without a doubt, be applied to Freemasonry. While
Freemasonry is its own unique system, those who wrote and aided in the development of its
degrees usually ended up tincturing them with their own esoteric proclivities. This is especially
true of early high degree Freemasonry in France and Germany, and these influences can still be
1
Much is unknown about the evolution of Freemasonry from the medieval stone mason guilds to the
modern philosophical, fraternal and charitable organization it is today. There is some evidence in the texts known as
the Old Charges that trace elements of the Masonic tradition back to the late medieval period, but the details of this
transition are still high contested. Today we use the terms ‘operative’ and ‘speculative’ to differentiate between
practical stone masonry and Freemasonry as a fraternal organization, respectively.
2
A high degree is any beyond that of the 3rd degree of Master Mason, which is considered the highest
degree of Freemasonry. All degrees beyond that of the 3rd are considered appendant, interior or an expansion on the
first three.
The different esoteric streams in the west are usually built upon different mixes of
philosophy, religion3 and even regional folk practices. Esoteric traditions in the west are usually
hidden behind a veil of secrecy, which there are multiple reasons for.4 Being veiled, they are
usually separated from the mainstream exoteric practices and teachings and usually involve a
deep inner or mystical aspect. This usually involves learning about and utilizing the mysteries of
the Divine and immaterial forces, which often times can be termed as magic and has been a
In the late antique period, especially in and around Hellenistic Alexandria, there was no
shortage of cross-pollination occurring amongst the various spiritual and religious traditions. It’s
not uncommon to find papyri and codices from that time period on mentioning Christ, and in the
This sort of assimilation eventually evolved into a living tradition which we can see
manifesting within what is now called Hermeticism (or Hermetism).5 Hermeticism throughout
time absorbed new ideas as it had several revivals. For instance, during the renaissance after
Marsilio Ficino translated the Corpus Hermeticum into Latin, ideas such as Kabbalah,6 alchemy
3
Or theology.
4
The reasons for secrecy in esoteric traditions in the west is a very complicated subject. The main reason
usually given is that it is an element which survived from various times of persecution. While that is only part of the
puzzle, some others rely on the fact that typical or “profane” people would simply muddy the otherwise clear waters,
twist and misinterpret teachings and practices which otherwise would be handed from teacher to student properly in
a closed group. This sort of thinking is related to the verse in Matthew 7:6 where Jesus is quoted saying, “Do not
give what is holy to the dogs; nor cast your pearls before swine, lest they trample them under their feet, and turn and
tear you in pieces.” The idea of secrecy and closed groups most likely comes to us from the influence of ancient
Greek groups such as the Mithraic cults and Pythagorean communities who often held to strict rules of secrecy
regarding their teachings.
5
Hermeticism can be defined as a philosophy or system which is based on the teachings of the mythical
Egyptian sage, Hermes Trismegistus. The core texts of the Hermetic tradition are referred to as the Hermetica and
most have been compiled into what is called the Corpus Hermeticum, a compilation of writings extending as far
back as the second century CE. They are heavily influenced by Greek and Egyptian philosophy and incorporate
some elements of Abrahamic theology and Neoplatonism.
and Rosicrucianism7 began to be included under the Hermetic umbrella. Then another revival
occurred in western Europe, particularly in England during the Victorian era, where Hermeticism
picked up ideas such as tarot and more modern forms of magic. We can see this manifesting
amongst several secret societies of the time such as in the Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn
and the reorganized Martinist Order, both of which borrowed heavily from the Masonic lodge
format.
Alchemy itself has several parallels with Freemasonry. For starters they are both often
referred to as the Royal Art and as such employ the aid of the Divine in the spiritual and moral
betterment of the individual. This is represented through the allegory of starting with some crude
material, and through application of the provided tools, one ends up with a perfected stone.8 The
alchemists call this the Lapis Philosophorum (or Philosopher’s Stone),9 and the Freemasons call
this the Perfect Ashlar. Another parallel between both Freemasonry and Alchemy is that while
Freemasonry has both its operative (practical stone masonry) and speculative (philosophical and
ritualized Freemasonry) sides, alchemy has its outer (practical laboratory work) and inner
6
Kabbalah is a Hebrew word meaning ‘tradition’, or ‘to receive.’ It emerged in the medieval period and
evolved out of earlier forms of Jewish mysticism such as the Hekhalot or Merkabah traditions but included certain
Platonic themes. To try to define Kabbalah within the confines of this paper could only be reductionist, but to keep it
simple some themes involve in depth analysis of the mysteries of God, the Torah, and the relationship of these to the
cosmos and man.
7
Rosicrucianism began in the early 17th century at the publication of three mysterious manifestos which
stated the history and existence of some inaccessible group of protestant Christian mystics. This caused a stir in
Europe of people seeking them out and creating their own groups based on the manifestos. This created a great
expansion on the Rosicrucian ideas, which often are mentioned in parallel with alchemy and Hermeticism.
8
This idea of a perfected stone in both alchemy and Freemasonry refers to the individual beginning in a
state of crudeness and profanity, and through the work, eventually reaching illumination.
9
Franz Hartmann, Arthur Edward Waite, s.v. “Stone of the Philosophers,” in A Paracelsian Lexicon, 2nd
ed. revised, Alchemical Studies Series 10 (Sequim, WA: The Alchemical Press, Holmes Publishing Group LLC,
2005), 30-31.
(spiritual work) sides. The common theme here being that the inner path of self-betterment can
These parallels and Hermetic ideas were practiced and greatly acknowledged by many who
had an indelible influence on the development of the Scottish Rite degrees, which will be made
The origins of Scottish Freemasonry are easier to trace than that of the craft degrees and
thanks to research by brethren such as Alain Bernheim and Arturo de Hoyos we can look back
with a mild sense of certainty to its early beginnings. While there is still plenty of research to be
done in this field, enough scholarship has accumulated to elucidate the origins of what has been
called Scotch, Scotts, Scottish, or even Écossais Freemasonry.10 While some sources on the
history of the Scottish Rite Degrees tend to start at Estienne Morin and tread along the surface,
this paper will attempt to go a little further back in time and a little deeper into the influences.
Most sources state that the Scottish degrees originated in France, but this is only partially
true. This theory is due to some bits of misinformation that were perpetuated from book to book
and author to author. This is mainly because that was the extent of the history that had been
Out of all the systems and degrees of high degree Freemasonry that have existed throughout
time, the degrees styled as Scottish have the earliest pedigree. These early degrees can be traced
back to several lodges in England who were conferring them as early as 1733. Where the earliest
known reference we have to Scottish style degrees in France is from a set of general regulations
10
‘Écossais’ meaning ‘Scottish’ in French is the term used to describe Scottish style Freemasonry as it
developed in France.
adopted by the Grande Loge de France in 1743, the same day Louis de Bourbon, the Comte de
Clermont (1709-1771)11 was elected Grand Master. The 20th article of these regulations
proposes, in short, that anyone with the degree of Scots Master (maîtres Écossais)12 should not
While Scottish style Freemasonry did develop with great fervency in France, it is in fact the
Masonic Templar tradition that originated there. And while, geographically, Scotland had its
own Masonic goings on, we cannot say definitively whether or not any of these Scottish styled
degrees which were popping up were actually tied to Scotland in any way.14 Although we know
that some Scottish and Irish expatriates immigrated to France in the late 17th and early 18th
centuries, many of whom were Jacobites,15 it is not possible to say with absolute certainty if they
The first mention we have of Scottish style Freemasonry in England comes to us from Dr.
Richard Rawlinson’s 1733 manuscript list of lodges which has listed a “Scotch Mason’s Lodge.”
This lodge also shows up again in Pine’s engraved list of lodges in 1734 as “Scotts Masons
11
Louie de Bourbon was the Blood Prince of The Most Serene House of Bourbon-Condé.
12
In Harry Carr’s translation of Le Parfait Maçon, it is said about this degree that, “Instead of weeping over
the ruin of the temple of Solomon, as their brethren do, the Escossais are concerned with rebuilding it.”
13
Alain Bernheim, “Did Early ‘High’ or Écossais Degrees Originate in France?” Heredom, vol. 5
(Washington, DC: Scottish Rite Research Society, 1996), 87.
14
It is thought that the Scottish degrees popping up in England weren’t so much tied directly to Scottish
Freemasonry so much as they were to the idea of Scottish Freemasonry as it had a much higher reputation than
English Freemasonry did at the time. James Fairbairn Smith gives several in depth reasons for the Scottish label of
English high degrees in his The Rise of the Ecossais Degrees (Dayton, OH: The Otterbein Press, 1965).
15
The Jacobites were supporters of the exiled king James II of England (whose name is Latin is Jacobus).
They supported the restoration of the Stuart line to the throne of England and had many supporters in France at the
time.
16
Rex R. Hutchens, Pillars of Wisdom: The Writings of Albert Pike, revised ed. (Washington, DC: Scottish
Rite Research Society, 2016), 11.
Lodge,” which is numbered 115 and met at the Devil Tavern, Temple Bar in London, England.
This lodge shows up one last time in a 1735 Pocket Companion which states it continued to meet
at the Devil Tavern until 1736 when it moved to Daniel’s Coffee House and was erased in the
same year.17 Around this same time (1735-1750), we can see several Scottish degrees beyond
that of Master Mason being conferred in at least four different lodges in Southern England:
• A Lodge held at the Bear and Harrow in Butcher Row, Bath (1735)
• The Lodge of Antiquity held in Morning Bush tavern on Aldersgate St., London (1740)
• The old Lodge No. 1, held at the Goose and Gridiron, London (1740)
• A Lodge held at the Rummer, Bristol (1740)
• The Scotch H-d-m, or Ancient and Honourable Order of K-n-g (~1743)18
• A lodge held in Salisbury (1746)
There are also several foreign references to Scottish style degrees being worked outside of
The degrees conferred from the above-mentioned lists had titles such as Scotch Master
Mason, Excellent Mason, and Grand Mason; all of which were styled as Scottish degrees and as
17
James Fairbairn Smith, The Rise of the Ecossais Degrees, The Proceedings of the Chapter of Research of
The Grand Chapter of Royal Arch Masons of the State of Ohio, volume X (Dayton, Ohio: The Otterbein Press,
1965), 14.
18
An order that later gave birth to the Royal Order of Scotland. The earliest mention of this order we have
is from a newspaper clipping dated November 26, 1743, although it’s probable that it was in operation before that.
Alain Bernheim, “The Order of Kilwinning or Scotch Heredom, the Present Royal Order of Scotland.” Heredom,
vol. 8 (2000), 93.
19
Dr. James Edward Shum Tuckett, “The Origin of Additional Degrees.” Ars Quatuor Coronatorum, vol.
XXXII (London: Quatuor Coronati Lodge No. 20176, 1919), 30.
far as we know, were the first to do so. The influence of these degrees would possibly be the
seed for not only the Scottish Rite, but all subsequent high degrees and high degree systems.
For a long time, all of these degrees starting to pop up (beyond that of Master Mason)
were not yet codified or unified and were essentially disparate and varied often times from city to
city. The first organization of a high degree Scottish system into something coherent and
organized we can see came at the hand of the Parfaite Harmonie Loge d’Ecosse (1746) in
Bordeaux, of which Éstienne (Stephen) Morin was a founding member.20 Bordeaux was the city
in which Freemasonry got its start in Southern France with the establishment of Loge L’Anglise
(1732) whose founders were mostly made up of English, Scottish and Irish immigrants.21
Rite of Ramsay
Besides this handful of varying Scottish degrees, there is one dubious account of an even
earlier Scottish degree. This account is from the degree system supposedly propagated by
Chevalier Andrew Michael Ramsay (1686-1743). These degrees are stated to extend back as far
as 1728 in his rite22 of six (or sometimes stated as seven) degrees.23 This Rite of Ramsay, or Rit
de Bouillon, it seems merely existed within the story line of the traditional history of the Rite of
20
Smith, 24, 25.
21
Alain Bernheim, “Notes on Early Freemasonry in Bordeaux (1732-1769).” Ars Quatuor Coronatorum,
vol. 101 (London: Quatuor Coronati Lodge No. 2076, 1988), 33.
22
The terms, “rite,” “order” and “system” can be used interchangeably to describe an organized set of
degrees or grades which incorporate their own unique themes and teachings.
23
Milko Bogard, Of Memphis and of Misraim: The Oriental Silence of the Winged Sun, 5th ed. (Milko
Bogard, 2017), 8.
In Chevalier Ramsay’s famous oration supposedly given in 1737 before the Grand Loge
de France, he proposed a dubious origin story of Freemasonry rooted in the crusader knights.
This theory of his, even though not historically supported in any way, would be the push from
This masonic origin story proposed by Chevalier Ramsay in his oration stated that a
handful of crusader knights fleeing from persecution landed in Scotland and disguised
themselves as operative Freemasons. Thus, tincturing the Craft with their spiritual ideas and
practices. While there is seemingly no historical credibility in this story, similar to that of the
Larmenius Charter,24 it is part of what lead to the revival of the Templar tradition and other
The Rite of Strict Observance, which was the primary embryo for both Scottish and
Templar degrees, was founded in 1754 in Germany by Baron Karl Gotthelf von Hund (1722-
1776).
24
A document of disputed authenticity detailing the transmission of the lineage of Grand Masters of the
Knights Templar from Jacques de Molay to Johannes Marcus Larmenius, who latter supposedly penned the
manuscript in February of 1324. Then it lists the supposed 22 Grand Masters starting with Larmenius to Bernard-
Raymond Fabré-Palaprat in 1804. Fabré-Palaprat is who is often credited with reviving the Gnostic and Templar
traditions through his l’Ordre du Temple.
25
The craft degrees are numbered separate from the high degrees and are considered to comprise the whole
of Freemasonry, being; 1° Entered Apprentice, 2° Fellow Craft, and 3° Master Mason. They are the common thread
that is the primary landmark of all of Freemasonry and are usually practiced and conferred in a Symbolic or Blue
Lodge. Some high degree systems had their own versions of the craft degrees, but the themes are essentially the
same.
6°. Knight Templar26
7°. Professed Knight (a later addition)27
These degrees, it is noted, were nearly identical to those in Chevalier Ramsay’s fabled
rite. This Rite of Strict Observance, in its time, established over forty lodges and was met with
great success but was short lived. Von Hund and the order itself obtained their authority from a
group of ‘unknown superiors,’ who held the mysteries of the order. Not bringing enough people
into these mysteries is what essentially led to the order’s demise. The Strict Observance, being
influenced by Ramsay, was possibly the most important and integral puzzle piece which led to
the formation of, not only the Scottish Rite, but also any subsequent chivalric rites and degrees.
From its legacy sprang and splintered many other rites such as:
Order of Knight-Masons Elect Priests of the Universe (l'Ordre des Chevaliers Maçons
Élus Coëns de l'Univers) (1767), often referred to in short as the Élus Coëns, was an order
26
Arthur Edward Waite, The Secret Tradition in Freemasonry, vol. I, book I, § IV, 2nd ed (New Orleans:
Cornerstone Book Publishers, 2014), 120. States a possible variation on the 6°, which was a four-part subdivision.
The four parts being; Eques, Armiger, Socius, and Eques Professus or Grand Profès.
27
Arturo de Hoyos, Alain Bernheim, “The Rite of Strict Observance and Two High Degree Rituals of the
Eighteenth Century,” Collectanea, vol. 21, pt. 1, (Washinton, D.C.: Grand College of Rites, 2010). A variation on
the name of the 7° stated from a translation by de Hoyos and Bernheim is “Lay Brother.” It is likely that the degrees
changed and evolved over time, or that some of these variations are due to errors.
28
The word “magic” used in this context, and how it’s usually used within the context of the western
esoteric tradition, usually refers to a method of practice aimed at causing influence through the aid of supernatural
forces, spirits, or deity. This is usually performed in a ritualized or ceremonial fashion and is more often than not
deeply connected to religious or regional folk practices. Magic can be used as a blanket term for such a wide variety
of practices throughout regions and history that it would be impossible to confine its definition to a footnote.
29
While theurgy (divine-working) is often seen as being somewhere in the middle of magic (effecting the
outer world) and mysticism (effecting the inner self), it is really more so a tradition based in Neoplatonism,
especially laid out in the works of Iamblichus. It aims at an ascent of the soul or a perfecting of oneself with the aim
of eventual union with the Divine.
The degrees of the Order of Knight-Masons Elect Priests of the Universe consisted of:
The Clerks of Relaxed Observance30 (1767), which was, in a way, a schism of the Rite
of Strict Observance which was meant to fix the flaws which its founder, Johann August von
Starck (1741-1816), saw in the order and also to revive its spiritual or clerical side as a system of
the Knights Templar. It has been suggested that this order included teachings on alchemy and
magic but not much research has been done on it, nor its degrees published, so little is known
about it.
30
Arthur Edward Waite, A New Encyclopædia of Freemasonry, vol. 2, combined ed. (New York:
Weathervane Books, 1970), 144. Suggests this name was used in error by Ragon, where the more correct name was
“Clerks of the Strict Observance,” with an alternative name being, “Clerical Knights Templar” or “Clerici Ordinis
Templarii.”
5. Priest
The Rectified Scottish Rite (Rite Écossais Rectifie) (1778), which included within itself
a secret inner order known as the Order of Knights Beneficent of the Holy City (Chevalier
bienfaisant de la Cité sainte). This order was formed primarily by Jean-Baptiste Willermoz using
elements from both the Rite of Strict Observance and Pasqually’s Élus Coëns.31 It also did the
opposite of what The Clerks of Relaxed Observance did, and completely did away with any
Templar elements.
Really there are far too many to be listed here, and they come in all sorts of flavors
developed by their individual founders. And while perhaps you cannot draw a straight line of
direct lineage from the three above-mentioned bodies to that of Scottish Rite degrees, they
definitely had an influence on the periphery and in the minds of the individuals who helped
develop and write some of its degrees. It is without a doubt that high degree Freemasonry has
individuals such as Ramsay, Von Hund, Pasqually and Willermoz to thank for paving the way
31
Paul Rana, “OMS – Introduction to Martinism 1/5,” presented by the Ordre Martinistes Souverains
(OMS), January 5, 2018, lecture, 33:40 – 47:40, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-9md6qiLdBY.
32
This degree being referred to as Green Masonry.
Chapter of Clermont
Around the same time that Von Hund’s Rite of Strict Observance developed in Germany,
there was another body which sprang up around Paris called the Chapter of Clermont (Chapitre
de Clermont). Not much is known about the founding of this order, but it is certain that it was
operational by the time of 1754, if not before, and was founded by a Chevalier de Bonneville
somewhere around Paris. It is also worth mentioning that John Yarker affirms an earlier date of
1742 in which the order was active in Hamburg. Arthur Edward Waite also shares a similar
Some authors suggest that Von Hund was initiated into the Chapter of Clermont, thus
bringing over ideas from their degrees and adapting them into his own system, but there is not
enough evidence to prove this. Some Masonic historians, such as Alain Bernheim suggest the
Chapter altogether never even existed, citing a lack of evidence.33 Then we can see James
Fairbairn Smith in his book titled The Rise of the Ecossais Degrees providing ample evidence for
their existence. Nonetheless, there are multiple differing lists of degrees worked by the Chapter
The most common degrees suggested for the Chapter of Clermont consisted of:
33
Alain Bernheim, Estienne Morin et l’Ordre du Royal Secret, a lecture presented by Bernheim before the
Ars Macionica Research Lodge No. 30 (Grand Lodge of Belgium) in Brussels on November 28, 1998. It was
published in Ars Macionica, vol. 9 (1999).
34
Arthur Edward Waite, The Secret Tradition in Freemasonry, vol. I, book IV, § III, 2nd ed, 312-313. Waite
goes into detail on the variation of degrees of the Chapter of Clermont.
4°. Scottish Master Elect
5°. Knight of the Eagle
6°. Illustrious Templar
7°. Sublime Knight
It is worth addressing the common misconception that this body got its name from the
Jesuit College of Clermont, which it indeed did not. It is instead named after the French Grand
Master, Louis de Bourbon, the Comte de Clermont.35 This body was on the more exclusive and
less accessible side, filling their ranks with aristocrats, nobility, high ranking military officials
and other elite members of society. Because of this exclusivity, this body gave birth to another
Masonic system which instead believed in the equality of its membership regardless of their
social standing. This body was known as the Knights of the East, Princes and Sovereigns of
Masonry.
This latter body is what eventually became known as the Council of the Emperors of the
East and West.36 Like most rites and high degree systems mentioned, there is not much known
about the early days of this body. We can’t even say what degrees it began with or how it
evolved to include the 25 degrees it ended up with. What is certain is that it came into existence
around 1758 and that it carried over some degrees from another body called the Scottish Mother
It is thought that several of the degrees were either written or influenced by Baron Louis
Théodore-Henry Tschoudy and even possibly Dom Antoine Joseph de Pernéty, both prominent
35
Henry Wilson Coil, Coil’s Masonic Encyclopedia, 1st ed. (New York: Macoy Publishing and Masonic
Supply Company, 1961), 135.
36
An alternative name of this body was the Ancient Rite and Rite of Heredom or of Perfection.
alchemical and Hermetic authors. It is possible that these degrees had other origins but were used
by Tschoudy, who later injected into them his alchemical ideas.37 Since the early history of the
Council of the Emperors of the East and West is mostly unknown, it is hard to say for certain.
If the influence of Tschoudy and Pernéty in these degrees can be contested, at least we
can see their definite influence later down the line in Albert Pike’s rewriting of the Scottish Rite
degrees – which is when the flower of esotericism really bloomed within Scottish Freemasonry.
The degrees of the Council of the Emperors of the East and West consisted of:
37
This is especially true of the degree of Knight of the Sun which shows up in Tschoudy’s own system in
1754 and is explicitly alchemical. From then on out, it appears in various bodies as an alchemical degree, even in the
modern Scottish Rite. Whether it originated as such is unknown, but given the titles of the other degrees from the
Scottish Mother Lodge of Marseilles where it first appears, it is a safe bet to assume it was originally written using
alchemical themes.
11°. Illustrious Elect, or Chief of the Twelve Tribes
12°. Grand Master Architect
13°. Knight Royal Arch, or Royal Axe
14°. Grand Elect, Ancient Perfect Master, or Grand Elect Ancient
15°. Knight of the Sword, or of the East
16°. Prince of Jerusalem
17°. Knight of the East and West
18°. Rose Croix
19°. Grand Pontiff, or Master ad vitam
20°. Grand Patriarch Noachite, or Grand Patriarch
21°. Grand Master of the Key of Masonry, or Grand Master of the Key
22°. Prince of Libanus
23°. Knight of the Sun, Prince Adept, Chief of the Grand Consistory
24°. Illustrious Chief, Grand Commander of the White and Black Eagle, Grand Elect
Kadosh
25°. Most Illustrious Prince of Masonry, Grand and Sublime Knight Commander of the
Royal Secret, or Commander of the Royal Secret
Within the two above-mentioned systems, several things are clear: there is an explicit
exclusion of Templar degrees, and we can see the first Rosicrucian (Rose Croix) and alchemical
(Knight of the Sun) degrees included in a Masonic system. This is when the degrees we currently
know in the Scottish Rite really being to take shape from all previous influences.
Rosicrucian Influence
While the degree of Rose Croix may be the first Rosicrucian degree in a strictly Masonic
system, it is not the first meeting of Rosicrucian and Masonic ideas. The earliest mention of these
two ideas together is from Henry Adamson’s (1581-1637) poem titled, “Muses Threnodie: or
Mirthful Mournings on the Death of Mr. Gall,” published in two volumes in Edinburgh, Scotland
With this evidence, it is obvious that Masonic and Rosicrucian ideas were already
mingling in Scotland well before they were combined in a Masonic degree system. This
mingling happens again in a pamphlet from 1676 which states (in satire):
There is a clear suggestion of esotericism in these two quotes, which one would expect
from something tinged with Rosicrucian ideas. There is yet another mingling of these ideas
which must be mentioned because it combines not only Rosicrucian and Masonic ideas, but it
also ties into the mention of some Scottish and Écossais degrees and degree systems which were
mentioned previously. It is that of the Good Shepherd Lodge (Loge au Bon Pasteur) founded in
1750 by Jean Luc de Toux de Salverte in both Warsaw and Wilna, Poland.
This lodge and its grades were greatly influenced by not only the famous Rosicrucian
order from 1710 (and reformed in the late 1750’s), Gold- und Rosenkreutzer, but also possibly
even by Baron Louis Théodore-Henry Tschoudy and his L’Etoile Flamboyante (Order of the
Flaming Star) rite. Salverte, before establishing his order spent time in Metz, which is where
Tschoudy resided at that time. Salverte’s Good Shepherd Lodge and Tschoudy’s L’Etoile
Flamboyante rite also share a similar degree, that of Knight of the Sun (Chevalier du Soleil),
which we can see is included in both the degrees of the Scottish Mother Lodge of Marseilles and
This proves even more evidence of Scottish Rite degrees being built on clearly esoteric
ideas. When Albert Pike eventually rewrote the Scottish Rite degrees, he had the idea that he
wanted to return the degrees to their original esoteric forms. Whether or not he was aware of
degree systems like that worked by the Good Shepherd Lodge or the Gold- und Rosenkreutzer,
one cannot say for sure, but he definitely had a whiff of their legacy.
Alchemical Influence
While the terms ‘Rosicrucian’ and ‘alchemy’ were held as synonymous by certain
authors, they have mutually exclusive origins and meanings. It just so happens that Baron
Tschoudy cultivated both of these ideas into his rite. It’s not known for sure whether he wrote the
degrees for his order himself, whether his initiator and teacher Raimondo di Sangro wrote or
helped write them, or whether it was a group effort amongst several individuals. What current
38
Ian H. Gladwin, The Bon Pasteur Lodge – A Masonic Prototype for the Gold and Rose Cross? (2019),
http://www.pansophers.com/bon_pasteur/.
scholarship can say for certain is that they entered the scene riding on the wave of what is called
Egyptian Freemasonry. Raimondo di Sangro was Prince of San Severo and Grand Master of the
Naples based Grand Lodge. He was an alchemist, inventor, author, and artist living from 1710-
1771. He is also who is credited with starting what is known as Egyptian Freemasonry, or the
Traditional Egyptian Rite, around 1747 at his Naples lodge called La Perfetta Unione.
Unfortunately, none of his writings on these subjects exist, so our primary source material comes
to us from Tschoudy.
obedience. These degrees are very eclectic and include direct ingredients from many esoteric
streams including alchemy40, Hermeticism, ritual magic, theurgy, chivalry, and many other
The real interest here lies is in the influence of Tschoudy’s rite, often called the Order of
the Flaming Star, after his book L’Etoile Flamboyante.41 Really the name of his rite in unknown
but fortunately for us, the degrees have been published in French in a book called ‘Rituel des
isn’t known whether Tschoudy’s degrees had a direct influence on those of the Emperors of the
East and West or vice versa.42 Either way they are worth mentioning especially because their
39
The Rite of Memphis (1838) (95 degrees) was originally formed as a variation on Rite of Misraïm (1738)
(90 degrees). They later combined in 1881 under the banner of the Ancient and Primitive Rite of Memphis-Misraïm,
which has several different manifestations today.
40
While there are many variations on the Memphis-Misraïm degrees, the core degrees stay very similar.
The alchemy taught in some of the degrees often includes both inner (spiritual) and outer (laboratory) elements.
41
First published in 1754.
42
Mathieu G. Ravignat, Quest for a Lost Rite: The Origins, High Degrees and Spiritual Practices of
Traditional Egyptian Freemasonry, 1st ed. (self-published, 2021), 17.
alchemical influence can still be seen not only in Pike’s work, but in the Scottish Rite degrees to
this day.
Éstienne Morin
To see how these ideas made their way to Pike, reference must be made back to the
Council of the Emperors of the East and West and the various other high degree systems being
worked in Bordeaux in the mid to late 18th century. A lot of ink has been spilled over the links
between these various systems and the patent issued to Éstienne (Stephen) Morin. Even though
some of the facts are contested, what history can tell us is that a body of Morin’s called the
Council of Knights of the East along with several others such as the Council of the Emperors of
the East and West and the Scottish Mother Lodge of Marseilles merged under the Grand Lodge
of France.43 This grand lodge then issued the patent to Morin as Grand Inspector, “authorizing
and empowering him to establish perfect and sublime Masonry in all parts of the world,” which
Before Morin received his patent, there was an Écossais lodge which was formed by him
in Cap Francaise, San Domingo around 1748. Then a couple of years after receiving his patent,
43
Smith, 42
he created his own system of twenty-five degrees which he called the Order of the Royal Secret.
Under his new authority as Grand Inspector, he introduced his order first to Kingston, Jamaica in
1763, naming Henry Andrew Francken as Deputy Inspector. Francken being the one who
transcribed the famous Francken manuscripts which are the earliest documented writings of the
degrees. The first one was completed on August 30, 1771, less than three months before Morin’s
death.
44
The titles to these degrees are taken directly from a facsimile copy of the original 1783 Francken
manuscript. The 1783 Francken Manuscript, first ed., (Lexington, MA: Supreme Council, 33°, Ancient Accepted
Scottish Rite, NMJ, 2017).
45
Arturo de Hoyos, Freemasonry’s Royal Secret: The Jamaican “Francken Manuscript” of the High
Degrees, 1st ed. (Washington, DC: Scottish Rite Research Society, 2014), xix. “Many French lodges called this
degree Scotch Master of the three J.J.J.” The capitalizations and spelling present in the listed degrees are as they
appear in the 1783 Francken Manuscript.
25°. The Royal Secret, or the knights of St Andrews, and the Faithful guardians of the
Sacred Treasure
Shortly before Morin died, he created a grand chapter of his order in which he created six
Deputy Inspectors General who would further extend his Rite, Francken being one of these six.
Although French Écossais masonry first came to the United States in New Orleans, Louisiana in
1764 from a separate source, it didn’t last long and soon died out. Twelve years later, Francken
arrived in New York from the West Indies and propagated the degrees of the Order of the Royal
Secret starting in Albany, NY in 1776, where he issued a patent for a lodge called the Ineffable
Lodge of Perfection.46 While in New York, Francken appointed Moses Michael Hays as Deputy
Inspector General, who then in turn made eight other Deputy Inspector Generals in 1781.
These individuals were key in spreading the degrees of the Order of the Royal Secret
which would soon form into the Ancient and Accepted Scottish Rite of thirty-three degrees. This
new formation happened by the hands of gentlemen now known as, “The Eleven Gentlemen of
Charleston.” As this name suggest, in May of 1801, eleven men met at Shepheards Tavern in
Charleston, South Carolina and formed the first Mother Supreme Council, which by the time of
Albert Pike
The degrees of the Ancient and Accepted Scottish Rite would really come into their full
esoteric glory at the rewriting of Albert Pike. This task took him roughly two years from the time
he was appointed as a member of a special committee to rewrite the degrees, to the time he
46
Smith, 79.
finished, completing his revisions of the 4° – 32° in 1857. Before he put his touch on the degrees,
many of them were in a very crude state and the progression was less than organized.
Pike systematized and expanded the degrees and made them one coherent system as
The degrees of the Ancient and Accepted Scottish Rite rewritten by Pike in 1857
consisted of:
reading, liturgies, legendas and additional lectures.47 The additional lectures alone on the 4°-32°
he completed in 1871 which are known as the famous Morals and Dogma. He inserted into these
degrees ideas he drew from various sources, not only heavily from the western esoteric tradition,
but from the western philosophical tradition and various world religions. We can see clear
influences from the ancient mystery cults and religions, coming from the Egyptians, Greeks,
Hebrews, and more, manifesting through streams which have been variously touched on in this
paper.48 He even borrowed heavily from the French occultist Éliphas Lévi (1810-1875), often
lifting straight from his works, especially from his Dogme et Rituel de la Haute Magie (Dogma
Lévi himself was heavily influenced by prominent Rosicrucians and alchemists such as
Paracelsus, Robert Fludd, and Raymond Lull. With all of this in mind, it is clear that Pike
himself rekindled the flame of Masonic esotericism once developed by propagators of the French
and German high degrees of the 18th century. It is also certain that nearly everything mentioned
in this paper, can follow a common thread back to Chevalier Andrew Michael Ramsay and his
famous oration. Despite Ramsay’s oration being fraught with wishful facts, it would be one of
the most influential masonic events ever seen within its history.
47
All of these additional writings on the Scottish Rite degrees such as the readings, liturgies, legendas, and
additional lectures were published in separate volumes, but can now be found completely bound into one volume
with even more additional material: Arturo de Hoyos, The Scottish Rite Ritual Monitor & Guide, third ed. corrected
(Washington, DC: The Supreme Council, 33°, Southern Jurisdiction, 2010).
48
For further reading on the esoteric and philosophical ideas which influenced Albert Pike such as
kabbalah, alchemy, Rosicrucianism and gnosticism, I suggest further reading in Pillars of Wisdom: The Writings of
Albert Pike by Rex R. Hutchens. This subject was purposefully kept short because many, many pages could be
dedicated to it alone, as one will see once they open the pages of the above suggested book.
Bibliography
Ambelain, Robert. Martinism: History and Doctrine. Translated by Piers A. Vaughan. Self-
Published, 2002.
———. Templars & Rose Croix. Translated by Piers A. Vaughan. Self-Published, 2005.
———. “Did Early ‘High’ or Écossais Degrees Originate in France?” Heredom, vol. 5.
Washington, D.C.: Scottish Rite Research Society, 1996: 87-114.
———. “Estienne Morin et l’Ordre du Royal Secret.” Ars Macionica, vol. 9. 1999.
———. “The Order of Kilwinning or Scotch Heredom, the Present Royal Order of Scotland.”
Heredom, vol. 8. Washington, D.C.: Scottish Rite Research Society, 2000: 93-130.
Beyer, Dr. Bernhard. Das Lehrsystem des Ordens der Gold- und Rosenkreuzer. Germany:
Arbeitsgemeinschaft für Religions- und Weltanschauungsfragen, 1978.
Bogard, Milko. Of Memphis and of Misraim: The Oriental Silence of the Winged Sun: History of
the Egyptian Rites of Freemasonry, Its Rites, Rituals and Mysteries. Self-Published,
2017.
Churton, Tobias. The Golden Builders: Alchemists, Rosicrucians, and the First Freemasons.
New York: Barnes & Noble, 2002.
Clausen, Henry C. Clausen’s Commentaries on Morals and Dogma. Washington, D.C.: Supreme
Council, 33°, SJ, 1976.
Coil, Henry Wilson. Coil’s Masonic Encyclopedia. New York: Macoy Publishing and Masonic
Supply Company, 1961.
Copenhaver, Brian P. Hermetica: The Greek Corpus Hermeticum and the Latin Asclepius in a
new English translation with notes and introduction. Great Britain: Cambridge
University Press, 1992.
Croteau, Jeffrey, Alan E. Foulds, and Aimee E. Newell. The 1783 Francken Manuscript.
Lexington, MA: Supreme Council, 33°, Ancient Accepted Scottish Rite, Northern
Masonic Jurisdiction, 2017.
De Hoyos, Arturo and Alain Bernheim, “The Rite of Strict Observance and Two High Degree
Rituals of the Eighteenth Century,” Collectanea, vol. 21, pt. 1. Washington, D.C.: Grand
College of Rites, 2010.
———. The Scottish Rite Ritual Monitor and Guide. Washington, D.C.: The Supreme Council,
33°, Southern Jurisdiction, 2010.
———. Freemasonry’s Royal Secret: The Jamaican “Francken Manuscript” of the High
Degrees. Washington, D.C.: Scottish Rite Research Society, 2014.
———. Albert Pike’s Magnum Opus: A History and Facsimile Edition of Pike’s First Revision
of the Scottish Rite’s Rituals, 4°-32°. Washington, D.C.: The Scottish Rite Research
Society, 2019.
———. Masonic Formulas and Rituals. Transcribed by Albert Pike in 1854 and 1855.
Washington, D.C.: The Scottish Rite Research Society, 2010.
Fox, William L. Lodge of the Double Headed Eagle: Two Centuries of Scottish Rite
Freemasonry in America’s Southern Jurisdiction. Fayetteville: The University of
Arkansas Press, 1997.
Gladwin, Ian H. The Bon Pasteur Lodge – A Masonic Prototype for the Gold and Rose Cross?
Last modified March 4, 2019. http://www.pansophers.com/bon_pasteur/.
Hartmann, Franz and Arthur Edward Waite. A Paracelsian Lexicon. Alchemical Studies Series
10. Sequim, WA: The Alchemical Press, Holmes Publishing Group LLC, 2005.
Hutchens, Dr. Rex R. A Bridge to Light: A Study in Masonic Ritual & Philosophy. Washington,
D.C.: The Supreme Council, 33°, SJ, 2010.
———. Pillars of Wisdom: The Writings of Albert Pike. Washington, D.C.: Scottish Rite
Research Society, 2016.
Iamblichus. On the Mysteries. Translated by Thomas Taylor. San Diego, CA: Wizards
Bookshelf, 1984.
McIntosh, Christopher. The Rosicrucians: The History, Mythology, and Rituals of an Esoteric
Order. York Beach, Maine: Samuel Weiser, Inc., 1997.
Papus (Gérard Encausse). Elementary Treatise on Practical Magic: Adaptation, Practice, Theory
of Magic. Translated by Piers A. Vaughan. Bayonne, NJ: Rose Circle Publications, 2017.
Rana, Paul. “OMS – Introduction to Martinism 1/5.” Presented by the Ordre Martinistes
Souverains (OMS). January 5, 2018. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-9md6qiLdBY.
Ravignat, Mathieu G. Quest for a Lost Rite: The Origins, High Degrees and Spiritual Practices
of Traditional Egyptian Freemasonry. Self-Published, 2021.
Sédir, Paul. History & Doctrines of the Rose-Croix. Translated by Piers A. Vaughan. Self-
Published, 2006.
Smith, James Fairbairn. The Rise of the Ecossais Degrees. Proceedings of the Chapter of
Research of the Grand Chapter of Royal Arch Masons of the State of Ohio, vol. X.
Dayton, OH: The Otterbein Press, 1965.
Solis, Jean, ed. Rituel des grades alchimiques du baron Tschoudy. Bonneuil-en-Valois: Éditions
de La Hutte, 2009.
Stanley, Thomas. Pythagoras: His Life and Teachings. Los Angeles, CA: The Philosophical
Research Society, 1970.
Tuckett, Dr. James Edward Shum. “The Early History of Freemasonry in France.” Ars Quatuor
Coronatorum, vol. 31. London: Quatuor Coronati Lodge No. 2076, 1918: 7-30.
———. “The Origin of Additional Degrees.” Ars Quatuor Coronatorum, vol. 32. London:
Quatuor Coronati Lodge No. 2076, 1919: 30.
Uždavinys, Algis. Philosophy & Theurgy in Late Antiquity. Kettering, OH: Angelico Press,
Sophia Perennis, 2010.
Waite, Arthur Edward. A New Encyclopædia of Freemasonry. New York: Weathervane Books,
1970.
———. The Secret Tradition in Freemasonry. New Orleans: Cornerstone Book Publishers,
2014.
Waldenses, Vaughan, Ashley McFadden, Johann Valentin Andrae, A Rosicrucian, John Heydon,
and Others. A Rosicrucian Primer: Ancient Landmarks of the Rose Cross. Edmonds,
WA: Holmes Publishing Group, 1994.
Yarker, John. Speculative Freemasonry. A Historical Lecture upon the Origin of Craft and High
Grade Freemasonry. Sequim, WA: Holmes Publishing Group, 2003.