Unit-13 Religious Specialists - Shamans, Priests and Prophets
Unit-13 Religious Specialists - Shamans, Priests and Prophets
13.0 Objectives
13.1 Introduction
13.2 Religious Specialists and the Sociology of Religion
13.2.1 Weber on Religion
13.3 The Priest
13.3.1 Weber's Understanding of the Priest
13.3.2 Priests and Priesthood : An Overview
13.3.3 Priests and Royalty
13.3.4 Priestly Qualifications
13.4 The Hindu Priesthood : An Example
13.4.1 Vedas
13 4.2 Brahmanas
13.4.3 Upanishads
13.4.4 Early Hinduism
13.4.5 Medievai and Modem Hinduism
13.4.6 Tribal Context
13.5 The Shaman
13.5.1 Weber on the Magician
13.5.2 The Shaman : A General Overview
13.5.3 The Functions and Role of a Shaman
13.5.4Organisation '
13.5.5 An Example : The Oraon Shaman
13.6 The Prophet
13.6.1 Weber on the Prophet
13.6.2 The Prophet : An Overview
13.6.3 Sathya Sai Baba : An Example
13.7 Let Us Sum Up
i 13.8 Key Words
13.9 Further Readings
t 13.10 Answers to Check Your Progress
I
I 13.0 OBJECTIVES
1 The present unit deals with the nature of religious specialists, focussing attention on
I three particular types: the shaman, the priest and the prophet. We hope that once
you have studied the unit, you will have gained some idea about the following
II the changes that have taken place in the nature of these specialists.
II 13.1 INTRODUCTION
II I This Unit is concerned with the nature of religious specialists. It is important for us
to briefly understand who'they are. As such, they are persons who because of
certain charismatic qualities they possess, are accorded the status of being
intermediaries of mediators between the world of the human and that of the divine
23
ltcligion and Related Aspects or magical. This act of mediation may either be performed by a single individual or
a group of individuals, where each performs a separate task. Such performances.
may occur on special ritual occasions, as a matter of daily routine, or during illness.
There are different kinds of specialists who derive their power from the functions
they perform, the doctrine they adhere to and by the nature of their following. To
name a few, we have priest found in temples, prophets such as Muhammad, cultic
leaders such as Sathya Sai Baba, shamans such as those found in Nepal and Tibet,
sectarian leaders like the late Swami Prabhupadji of the ISKCON, and so on.
The significance and role of these specialists varies from society to society, and it
is related to an extent to the nature of the religious system in the particular society.
The functions of the specialists are usually meant for achieving positive ends and
, benevolence, but often they may even be aimed at inflicting harm. We often find
men seeking the services of the specialists even when they are not required. Even
the assist mce of the exorciser, medicine man and magician are sought as a normal
routine. This unit will therefore deal with the development of three particular categories
of specialists, the priest, the shaman and the prophet, and their functions and social
significance. We will support our description wherever we can with examples.
Max Weber provided the necessary breakthrough. His comparative study of world
religions, which focused on theory of religious ideas, brought focus directly on
religious specialist as agent of social transformation or as conservation of tradition.
Weber wrote extensively on religions, its social consequences and the nature of
religious functionaries. Before we go on to detailed discussion on what Weber has
to say, we will have a look at how anthropologists have distinguished different
religious specialists.
Box 1
Anthropologists, who, unlike Weber, are less concerned wit'h the genesis of
religion as a force of social change or reinforcement have looked at shamans
Religious Speciaiists:
as part of the working of religious systems in simpler societies. The editors
Shamans, Priests and Prophets
A. Lessa and E.Z. Hog&devote a whole section to this aspect in their
Reader in Comparative Religion (1958). They find that shamans tend to
predominate in food-gathering societies. Where the shaman offers
personalised service to one or two individuals or a group whereas the priest,
according to them, is characteristic of more structurally elaborate food-
producing, or agricultural societies, where there are common ceremonials
or rites for the benefit of the whole community.
Other than the above mentioned functionaries, Weber also recognises the presence
in society of the religious leader or the prophet. The prophet could be the founder
of a world feligion such as Islam or a cultic figure such as Sathya Sai Baba in India.
Let us n ~ w examine each specialist independently.
The priesthood is based on a code of behaviour and ethics. They dedicate their life
Religion and Related Aspects to the task of communicating with the gods and are associated with either a place
of worship, a social group of a following of disciples. The development of a 'doctrine'
which involves the rise of a rational system of religious concepts and ethics is also
associated with them.
Jn simpler societies we find that not just priests but also magicians are associated
with the ability to communicate with the divine world. It is believed as such that
~)riestl~ood
is as old as religion itself.
In both prirthivc and advanced sociedes priests and magicians are functionaries
who through their\ specialised knowledge and powers, are associated with and
overconle malevolent and. benevolent forces. The need for such duality was
considered necessary so that the unknown s~pernaturalpowers would not be harmful
to the human; instead, they would bring prosperity and goodwill. These early religious
and magical practitioners who offered guidance in such matters, have been regarded
as the pioneers of an orgatlised priesthood. We find that in the early periods of
religious evolution there is no priesthood and men perform rituals or invoke the Gods
themselves. There are some people such as tribals of Melanesia and Australia who
Priests and related organiaatim (e.g. Church) are found in both qimple and complex
societies.
even today do the religious and magical rites themselves without the help of Religious Specialists:
intermediaries or specialists. Shamans, Priests and Prophets
Often in the early ages we find that in a collective group, one person would attain \
a certain significance in terms of his ability to deal with the supernatural or predict
certain events or even acquire an expertise in performing certain ritual acts. Such
a person would soon enough be regarded as an intermediary and gain priestly
functions. As an example, we find that in certain Dravidian tribes, the head of the
household would be the officiating priest at any type of family event. Before a
regular priesthood arose, we thus find that men, other than priests, performed
specialised functions. Into this category of specialists were also included those:
II i) who underwent ecstatic experiences by going into tr&es and then would make
predictions such as a darvesh:
I
It
ii) those who looked after places that have for some reason acquiredia sacred
significance and thus considered holy;
iii) those persons or 'holy men' who exercise some kind of religious authority by
performing miracles or curing illnesses.
I
Other than the above mentioned functionaries, magician too had a role to play in
the lives of the people, for both their well-being and for inflicting harm. Those
individuals who were able to exercise greater authority were the ones who over
time gained significant status and were able to gain respect. They gradually came
to form a category of specialists who officiated for individuals and groups and were
both respected and feared.
I Certain qualifications are laid down as being basic to priesthood. We mention here
some of them without going into details.
i)
.
The priest's primary fask is to mediate between the human and divine.
,
ReligionrtndWated Aspects iii) .The priests communicate with the divine through prayer, worship, rituals and so
on.
iv) Priests have to undergo initiation into the profession. A certain self training is
considered necessary.
v). The priests are expected to uphold their status through knowledge of natural
phenomena and the elements and may have an eccentric appearance. They are
also expected to be able to perform miracles.
vii) They are expected to maintain certain restrictions in their personal life particularly
in relation to the sexual realm, food and language.
It may finally be noted that both religious and magical practitioners are included into
the category of priests. While the magician uses magic spells and tries to coerce
the &own world of the supernatural, the religious functionary or priest brings about
the desired results by propitiating the unknown through religious rituals and
observances.
lb4.1 Vedas
h the Vedas we findW4it
mentioned that the social group of bmhmana was the
priwtly class. We find ,described in the Rig Veda the priestly activities of some of
the families of the Vedic tribes. In the Samhita, the title of brahmana is given to
that priestly class who {workedfor kings and wealthy nobles. These priests strictly
adhered to their occupation and were also believed to have a knowledge of medicine.
The Rig Veda also melptions subdivisions with& the priestly class, on the basis of
Eunctions and rituals pqrformed, such as the soma sacrifice. Two impo@$ggzpts
found mentioned are :
*. . W a n d make offerings to
a) the hotr or one who recites hymns to celebrate the.
them; --
b) the prashasft or on$ who makes the hotr recite his hymns.
The Rig Veda also mentions a third office, that of thepum&its, xilorwas the
domestic priest of either the k& or a n_qble.4 - k offefksi&d the king in other
activities as well. For ,wahple fiom Indian mythology we know of how both
Vishwamitra and ~ashhhtaserved their kings during the war.
13.4.2. Brahmanas
h .
In the Brahmana literature which includes the period up to 6th century B.C., the
priests are seen as a sTarate and hereditary class that was expected to maintain 1
its distance and purity others. Here also we find the priests performing
I
sacrifices and there ari& here within the'priestly class on the basis of
I
I functions performed. This period shows the functions of the pnmhita having
I
28 increased in sibificance.
It is however. the brahmin who is given more importance here and the best Religious Specialists:
offerings of a sacrifice would go to him, rather than the king and he had greater Sbilmfins,PrldandProphets
jurisdiction than the king.
13.4.3 Upanishads
By the time of the Upanishads, priestly functions had become more differentiated. ,
The priest now other then performing sacrificial functio~swas expected to engage
in philosophical studies and to take on disciples and pupils. The Upanishads also
specify the four stages of life or the ashramas that a Hindu had to follow. We refer
here to brahmacharya, grihastha, vanaprastha and sanyasa as the four phases
in a man's life.
temple.
n Relabed Aspects
~ e l i g k and Activity 1
What do you think are the priest's activities? Outline some of these activities
.
from your observation of a priest in your daily life.
These were Buddhism and Jainism. In these two religions also the role of the
priesthood and the order of monks was considered important.
.The temple priest became significant and came to look after the village temple
deity. There also arose a group of priests who concerned themselves primarily with
the imparting of knowledge and learning and came to be recognised as the guru.
Often the functions of the temple priest and the guru were combined along with
the ability to perform magic and miracles as among the left handed tantrics. These
individuals were both greatly feared and respected. Similar to the tantrics were the
ascetics who undertook penance and sought to achieve ecstatic states and salvation.
In the more recent context we find that the sacrifices of the Vedic period have lost
their significance and have been replaced by temple rituals and popular festivals
such as Holi, Deewali, Makarsankranti and so on. This period is also characterized
by the rise of religious movements such as the bhakti tradition where the priest
corresponds to the wandering poet, musician and teacher who challenges Hindu
orthodoxy. The brahmsn's as a priestly class came under criticism here.
From the 19th century onward, further change towards a unification of priestly
methods as well as religious teachings has occurred. We do continue to find temple
priests and family priests in most parts of India where the latter are usually present
on most life cycle events such as birth, marriage and death, to signify the well-being '
of the family.
We must keep in mind that here we are referring to 'priest' as a blanket term. In
fact there are different levels of competence and authority vested in different
practising priests.
Weber believes that the relationship between the human and the supernatural could
be expressed not just through religious worship assisted by a priest, but also through
magical chants or sorcery. Weber also points out that, it is in magic that prayer and
sacrifice have their origin. Sacrifice is seen as a major method of coercing the gods
into submission to a supplicant's needs. It was also seen as a method of directing
the anger of the gods towards another object. It is believed that the sacrificial rituals
of the Brahmans w&e magical in their intent and implication. however not all
sacrifices have magic or sorcery. 'The magician is understood by Weber as dealing
with evil spirits on an individual level. His efforts may have both positive and
negative consequences. The magician is usually self-employed though he may be
the member of a hereditaw caste or an organised guild. Rather than using a
specialised doctrine of knowledge, the magician may derive his influence by virtue
of personal gifts and knowledge of the supert~aturalworld. The magician can have
31
Religion andRelatedAspwts considerable power among his community and may be respected more out of fear
than faith. He does not necessarily have a following as the priests do.
Activity 2
Locate a travelling magician and enquire from him what he feels about his
work. Note down the important points of the conversation and share this
information with other students in your Study Centre.
Once greatly feared and misunderstood, today we find him using his abilities in
social and political spheres in simple societies. For long time in early anthropological
literature, he had a negative image of being a deviant. In later years*however his
significance as playing a psychological role, was recognised. In fact it has been
pointed out by the French structuralist, Claude Levi-Strauss, that the shaman provides
for the sick, a language that helps them to express their condition which they
normally would not be able to do.
a) either the oflice is hereditary or one's personality allows one to be chosen to the
office;
I
b) the shaman may have a peculiar mental state or even a physical shortcoming so
that he may be considered neurotic or epileptic;
There, the birch or pole is compared to the tree or pillar that stands at the
centre of the world and that connects the three cosmic zones - Earth,
Heaven and Hell.
to perform priestly functions and uses sacrifice as a central act in the process of
healing and divination. He also performs rituals of sacrifice and appeasement to the
gods or spirits once they have been forced to submit to the shaman's needs.
Finally, because of fear of the shaman and his powers, he acquires a charismatic
personality and qualities of leadership similar to a prophet. He may wear unusual
jewellery and clothing, wear his hair long and matted, paint his body with colour or
ash and cany either musical instruments or bones. His eccentric appearance and
qualities have often earned him the name of a neurotic and a trickster.
13.5.4 Organisation
As far as the hierarchic organisation ofthe shamans is concerned it is not as clearly
ideiitified as that of the priests. Within the community however, on the basis of the
power and control a shaman has over spirits, he has a particular ranks. They are
also classified in terms of whether they perform positive magic (or white magic)
in the well-being of a person or negative magic or black magic to make someone
ill. Accordingly, they -are either revered or feared and have higher or lower status.
A shaman does not undergo indoctrination in an institution as a priest does nut have
to master tests except those that are special to his functions.
33
Religion and Related Aspects 13.5.5 An Example :The Oraon Shaman-
As we have already mentioned, the shaman is closely associated with tribal life and
medicine. We take here the example of a tribe among whom the shaman has great
significance. We refer here to the Dravidian tribe of Oraons found in east India in
the Chota Nagpur plateau. The shamans here and the tribe in general, were first
studied by the Indian social anthropologist S.C. Roy, in the 1929s. The Oraons live
in a hilly and forested region. They practise agriculture and both men and women
share in farming. Their life is coloured by festivals and they have sacred groves for
their village deity. Important in the life of the Oraon is the bagat or the shaman.
His residence is identifiable by coloured flags on bamboo poles that stand outside
it. These flags represent the gods and goddesses, that are worshipped by the
bhagat. It also includes the flag of the special deity that enters the bhagat during
his trances, and helps him to heal and cure. The position of the bhagat is hereditary
and usually only one son or daughter is handed down the knowledge in a family.
Xn Oraon can become a shaman, only if he has special qualities that are recognised
by the person to whom he is apprenticed. The life of the bhagat is simple and strict
in matters of food and drink and is governed by the prescribed conduct and rules
of shamanic training.
The Oraon bhagat need not become a shaman by inheritance only. He may be
chosen by divine interventions, through a dream or a possession by a god who
infonns the chosen person of how to go about learning the knowledge to be a
shaman.
The bhagat usually deals with illnesses that come from demonic possession; or
illness or madness that comes from psychological stress. The treatment can be in
the form of a healing ritual or an exorcism, better known as jhar phook. These
rituals are of various kinds and extent, depending on the depth of a person's illness.
Thus the bhagat is seen to perform both rituals associated with good spirits and the
bad. They are seen not only to perform both rituals associated.with good spirits and
the bad. The are seen not only to cure and provide remedies for illness but much
of their success comes from faith healing and divination. The bhagat is also known
to go into trances and an ecstatic condition to reach the root of his patient's malady.
It may be pointed out here that the range of a shaman and his personal power vary
greatly from one societal context to another.
I
Ifwe look at the above example, even though discussed here briefly, we find that
the bhagat or shaman among the Oraon is very similar in his personality and life
to the'shaman described in general. Having considered the nature of the shaman
and his role in social life specific to simpler societies, let us now proceed to examine
I the nature of the prophet and prophecy as the final form of religious specialisation.
I
1) Briefly discuss what Weber's understanding of the magician is. Use about three
lines for your answer.
3) Briefly describe the shaman of Oraon. Use about four linesifor your answer.
Prophets also engage in healing and counselling. Weber points out that the prophet
i~suallydoes not belong to an organisation and neither does he receive economic
rewards for his ideas. He is not a professional and has a following of disciples or
a laity because they believe in his or' have faith in him. The prophet makes
prophecies which become often the guiding principles of a religious sect or cult or
even an entire religious movement. The prophet besides making prophecies, is a
teacher of religious and philosophical wisdom.
1'0 put it simply, the prophet may be seen as an individual who is an instrument for
carrying forward the will of god and he is obeyed because of the ethical nature of
his mission. He may also be a person who individually sets an example of attaining
salvation as did Buddha. This latter form of exemplary prophetism has been found
particularly in India.
Sai Baba receives this special status not because or any mission that he healis of
religion that he leads but as a consequence of the fact of his unusual capabilities
and charismatic p-ersonality. His bi,rth in 1926 in a village in Andhra Pradesh is seen
as divine because of the mysterious occurrences that took place then, such as a
cobra suddenly appearing under his bed. At the age of thirteen he is believed to
have suffered a seizure and then began performing miracles and later claimed to
be 'Sai Baba', the saviour of his people, and a reincarnation of the earlier saint, Sai
Baba of Shirdi.
In 1940 he broke away from his family and set out on a career as a holyman and
accepted devotees. He by now had begun performing the act of producing ash or
vibhuti and other items. Although be became famous for his miracles, he also
came to be known for his ability to cure and heal. In 1950, an ashram was
constructed in the village of his birth and he had come to be recognised all over
1ndiaas a god man, with a large following.
The important thing to note here is that his followers were there not because of
what he professed but because of their faith in him as a divine person. He is known
to go into trances and seizures to cure the illness of a devotee, by taking the illness
upon himself.
He has predicted that there will be one more incarnation of Sai Baba, after h ~ m ,
and also tells of the place he will be born in Karnataka next. He claims himself' to
be an incarnation of Shiva and Shakti and much of the cult symbolism revolves
around Shiva, though the cult and its membership'themselves are very ambiguous.
He remains the central charismatic authority of this cult and a modern day propliet
and guru who does not preach a doctrine. Those who believe in him, are his
devotees, and those who do not are not his devotees.
Check Your Progress 3 Religious Specialists:
Shamans, Priests and prophets
1) Who is a prophet? ~ x p l a i nin tive lines.
....................................................................................................................
2) Differentiate between a .priest and a prophet in five lines.
- -
.We have then proceeded to examine the major contribution made by Max Weber
to the sociology of religion as well as his specific ideas on the priest, magician and
prophet.
This; unit has also tried to deal with each specialist: priest shaman and prophet,
sepzrately, outlining the festures and functions of each. We have tried to show how
i
each of the specialists has significance within a given context and how each
associates with the layman differently. The purpose of examining these three different
kinds of roles is to show how mankind relates to the world of the divine arid
supernatural, differently. Finally, wherever we have been able to, we have tried to
support our presentation with examples from the Indian context. Our presentation
has rnowever been limited because the field is too diverse to be incorporated into
a few pages.
Brahmacharya : the first phase in a pious Hindu's life where is a bachelor engaged
in learning.
Sanyasa : the final stage of life when one renounces the material world.
Vanaprastha : the third phase of life when one, having completed, one's duties,
proceeds to the forest to meditate.
Madan, T.N. 1991. (ed.) Religion in India, Oxford University Press : Dellhi.
2) According to Weber the priest is one who performs mediatory functions directed
towards the world of the supernatural and divine. The priest belong:; to an
organisation or is related to an institution. He may even be attached to a family.
He undergoes indoctrination and organisational learning. He has to abide by certain
defined codes of behaviour. He is also expected to perform periodic rituals and
sacrifice for the propitiation of the divine or the Gods and Goddesses.
ii) (f)
iii) (a)
iv) (b)
v) (c)
vi) (e)
I check Your Progress 2 .. Religious :Specialists:
L Shamans, Priests and Prophets
1) Weber understands the magician as a specialist who uses his knowledge of the
supernatural, sorcery, miracle making and exorcism to cany out rituals and acts
that are both beneficial and harmful. He deals with evil spirits and tries to
overcome illness through his magical powers.
2) The shaman is a tribal magician and leader. He is known for his powers of
sorcery and exorcism and similar to those of the magician he performs both
positive rituals of well-being, and negative rituals of ill-being.
2) The difference between the priest and prophet is that while the priest is a
religious specialist who is attathed to an organisation and performs rituals on
behalf of others, the prophet is an independent person. He performs no rituals
I on behalf of people as such and is not a member of an organisation where there
are others like him although, he may lead one. Secondly while the priest inherits
his authority by birth in a family or through indoctrination and specialised
knowledge, the prophet's authority comes from his personal charisma.