DIFFERENCE BETWEEN AMERICAN CODE AND EGYPTIAN CODE
DIFFERENCE POINT EGYPTIAN CODE [LOADING CODE 2012] AMERICAN CODE [LOADING CODE ASCE7-05]
1) RIGID FRAME:-
1-A) Design CODE ECP01 AISC05-ASD
1-B) Fbrac 1 1
FULL BRACING (F)-Default Single Flange Brace
1-C) Flange Brace BOTH FLANGES (D)-Default Double Flange Brace (FOR WEB>=900 or/& FLGS>=225X10-250X8-200X12)use
Double Flange Brace
1-D) MIN. PLATE TH.
SECTION (250X5)WEB + (130X6 or 150X5)FLANGE (250X4)WEB + (125X5 or 150X5)FLANGE
KNEE CONNECTION K(V,S)04420/200X20 K(V,S)04420/200X15
INT. CONNECTION RS4420/200X15 (for frame up to 25.0m width) RS4416/200X12 (for frame up to 15.0m width)
BASE CONNECTION BR(BW)220/225X15 (for small frame up to 15.0m) BR(BW)220/225X15(for small frame up to 15.0m)
1-E) LOAD CODE ECP-2012 ASCE7-05
1-F) WIND WIND PRESSURE WIND SPEED(3second-gust)
1-G) GCP (ENCLOSED) "For Reference calculated up to slope 4:10 "For Reference Only calculated for slope 1.75:10
WIND LEFT C1= +0.80; C2= -0.80; C3=-0.50; C4=-0.50 C1= +0.26; C2= -0.87; C3=-0.59; C4=-0.52
WIND END C1= -0.70; C2= -0.80; C3=-0.80; C4=-0.70 C1= -0.63; C2= -0.87; C3=-0.87; C4=-0.63
WIND LEFT1 NA C1= +0.62; C2= -0.51; C3=-0.23; C4=-0.16
WIND END1 NA C1= -0.27; C2= -0.51; C3=-0.51; C4=-0.27
1-H) GCP (PARTIALLY) "For Reference calculated up to slope 4:10 "For Reference Only calculated for slope 1.75:10
WIND LEFT C1= +0.80; C2= -0.80; C3=-0.50; C4=-0.50 C1= -0.11; C2= -1.24; C3=-0.96; C4=-0.89
WIND END C1= -0.70; C2= -0.80; C3=-0.80; C4=-0.70 C1= -1.00; C2= -1.24; C3=-1.24; C4=-1.00
WIND LEFT1 NA C1= +0.99; C2= -0.14; C3=0.14; C4=+0.21
WIND END1 NA C1=+0.10; C2= -0.14; C3=-0.14; C4=+0.10
1-J) GCP (OPEN) "For Reference Only calculated for slope 1.75:10
WIND LEFT C1= +1.10; C2= -0.90; C3=-0.90; C4=-0.80 C1= +0.75; C2= +0.94; C3=-0.28; C4=-0.75
WIND END C1= -1.00; C2= -0.90; C3=-0.90; C4=-1.00 C1= -0.75; C2= -0.68; C3=-0.68; C4=-0.75
WIND LEFT1 C1= +1.10; C2= +0.90; C3=+0.90; C4=-0.80 C1= +0.75; C2= +0.14; C3=-0.99; C4=-0.75
WIND END1 C1= -1.00; C2= +0.90; C3=+0.90; C4=-1.00 C1= -0.75; C2= +0.68; C3=+0.68; C4=-0.75
1-K) Live Load Pattern Valid For MS-MG.. Column TO Column NA
1-L) LOAD COMBINATIONS 1.00 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 LIVE 1.00 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 LIVE
0.83 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 LIVE + 1.00 WIND + 1.00 Temp 1.00 1.00 DEAD + 0.75 LIVE + 0.75 TEMP
0.83 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 LIVE + 0.71 SEISMIC+ 1.00 Temp 1.00 1.00 DEAD + 0.75 LIVE + 0.75 WIND
1.00 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 WIND
1.00 0.60 DEAD + 1.00 WIND
1.00 1.00 DEAD + 0.75 LIVE + 0.53 SEISMIC
1.00 0.60 DEAD + 0.70 SEISMIC
2) ENDWALL:-
2-A) CODE ECP01 AISC05-ASD
0 (FOR FLUSH GIRTS ONLY) (Shallow=350:200) or 0 (FOR FLUSH GIRTS ONLY) (Shallow=350:200) or1
2-B) Fbrac
1 (FOR BYPASS GIRTS) (NOT USE Shallow) (FOR BYPASS GIRTS) (NOT USE Shallow)
TOP FLANGES (T) (FOR FLUSH GIRTS ONLY) or FULL TOP FLANGES (T) (FOR FLUSH GIRTS ONLY) or FULL
2-C) COLUMN BRACING
BRACING (F) (FOR BYPASS GIRTS+FL BRACE) BRACING (F) (FOR BYPASS GIRTS+FL BRACE)
2-D) RAFTER GCP = -0.80 (ENCLOSED & PARTIAL) GCP = -1.25 (ENCLOSED); -1.62(PARTIAL)-Slope 1.75:10
MINIMUM [WP * GCP] =± 0.48 KN/m2
[PRESSURE & SUCTION]
LOAD COMBINATIONS 1.00 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 LIVE 1.00 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 LIVE
0.83 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 LIVE + 1.00 WIND 1.00 1.00 DEAD + 0.75 LIVE + 0.75 WIND
1.00 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 WIND
1.00 0.60 DEAD + 1.00 WIND
2-E) P&B COLUMN GCP-P = +0.80 & GCP-S = -0.70(ENCLOSED) GCP-P = +0.63 & GCP-S = -0.63 (ENCLOSED)-Slope 1.75:10
(PARTIALLY)=(ENCLOSED ±GCPi PAGE-91) GCP-P = +1.00 & GCP-S = -1.00 (PARTIAL)-Slope 1.75:10
MINIMUM [WP * GCP] =± 0.48 KN/m2
[PRESSURE & SUCTION]
LOAD COMBINATIONS 1.00 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 LIVE 1.00 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 LIVE
0.83 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 LIVE + 1.00 WIND 1.00 1.00 DEAD + 0.75 LIVE + 0.75 WIND
1.00 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 WIND
1.00 0.60 DEAD + 1.00 WIND
PROVIDED BY THE DIAPHRAGM ACTION IN CASE OF
STABILITY PROVIDED BY X-BRACING UNDER ALL CONDITIONS (FLUSH GIRTS) AND X-BRACING USED IN CASE OF
(BYPASS GIRTS)
IN CASE OF USING X-BRACING (FLUSH GIRTS) IS :- IN CASE OF USING X-BRACING (FLUSH GIRTS)
MIN. COLUMNS DEPTH
400mm (DL 80X6) or 450mm (DL 100X8) IS :- 300mm (1-CABLE) or 350mm (2-CABLE)
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN CODES-ECP12-ASCE7 RV#00 1/2 18/4/2019
2-F) R.F. COLUMN GCP-P = +0.80 & GCP-S = -0.70(ENCLOSED) GCP-P = +0.81 & GCP-S = -0.90 (ENCLOSED)-Slope 1.75:10
(PARTIALLY)=(ENCLOSED ±GCPi PAGE-91) GCP-P = +1.18 & GCP-S = -1.27 (PARTIAL)-Slope 1.75:10
MINIMUM [WP * GCP] =± 0.48 KN/m2
[PRESSURE & SUCTION]
LOAD COMBINATIONS 1.00 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 WIND 1.00 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 LIVE
1.00 1.00 DEAD + 0.75 LIVE + 0.75 WIND
1.00 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 WIND
1.00 0.60 DEAD + 1.00 WIND
2-G) MIN. PLATE TH.
SECTION (250X5)WEB + (130X6 or 150X5)FLANGE (250X4)WEB + (130X6 or 150X5)FLANGE
INT. CONNECTION RS4420/200X15 RS4416/200X12
BASE CONNECTION BE(CE)220/225X15 BE(CE)220/225X15-BE(CE)416/200X12 UP TO 7m HT
3) COLD FORMED SEC.:- Asfad:"-ve Sign for (pressure, dead & Live) Asfad:"-ve Sign for (pressure, dead & Live)
3-A) CODE AISI 1986 AISI 2001-Slope 1.75:10
3-B) GIRT GCP-P = +0.80 & GCP-S = -0.70(ENCLOSED) GCP-P = +0.90 & GCP-S = -0.99int,-1.09ext (ENCLOSED)
GCP-P = +1.10 & GCP-S = -1.00(OPEN) GCP-P = +1.27 & GCP-S = -1.36int,-1.46ext (PARTIAL)
MINIMUM [WP * GCP] =± 0.48 KN/m2
(PARTIALLY)=(ENCLOSED ±GCPi PAGE-91)
[PRESSURE & SUCTION]
LOAD COMBINATIONS 1.00 1.00 WIND 1.00 1.00 WIND
3-D) PURLINS- GCP = +0.80 (ENCLOSED & PARTIAL) GCP-S = -1.38ext.,-0.98int. & GCP-P=+0.48(ENCLOSED)
GCP = ±0.90 (OPEN-CANOPY-ROOF EXTENSION) GCP-S = -1.75ext.,-1.35int.& GCP-P=+0.85(PARTIAL)
GCP-S = -1.19int,-1.79ext, GCP-P=+1.36int, +2.04 ext (Open-
monoslop)-Slope=1.32:10
MINIMUM [WP * GCP] =± 0.48 KN/m2
[PRESSURE & SUCTION]
LOAD COMBINATIONS 1.00 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 LIVE 1.00 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 LIVE
0.83 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 LIVE + 1.00 WIND 1.00 1.00 DEAD + 0.75 LIVE + 0.75 WIND
1.00 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 WIND
1.00 0.60 DEAD + 1.00 WIND
4) Sheeting:- Asfad:"-ve Sign for (pressure, dead & Live) Asfad:"-ve Sign for (pressure, dead & Live)
4-A) WALLS GCP-P = +0.80 & GCP-S = -0.70(ENCLOSED) GCP-P = +1.08 & GCP-S = -1.17int,-1.44ext (ENCLOSED)
GCP-P = +1.10 & GCP-S = -1.00(OPEN) GCP-P = +1.45 & GCP-S = -1.54int,-1.81ext (PARTIAL)
MINIMUM [WP * GCP] =± 0.48 KN/m2
(PARTIALLY)=(ENCLOSED ±GCPi PAGE-91)
[PRESSURE & SUCTION]
LOAD COMBINATIONS 1.00 1.00 WIND 1.00 1.00 WIND
4-B) ROOF GCP = -0.80 (ENCLOSED & PARTIAL) GCP-S = -1.88ext, -1.08int ,GCP-P=0.68(ENCLOSED)
GCP = ±0.90 (OPEN-CANOPY-ROOF EXTENSION) GCP-S = -2.25ext, -1.45int -GCP-P=1.05(PARTIAL)
GCP-S = -3.57ext.,-1.79,-1.19int (Open-monoslop) GCP-
P=2.72ext.,2.04,1.36int Slope=1.32:10
MINIMUM [WP * GCP] =± 0.48 KN/m2
[PRESSURE & SUCTION]
LOAD COMBINATIONS 1.00 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 LIVE 1.00 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 LIVE
0.83 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 LIVE + 1.00 WIND 1.00 1.00 DEAD + 0.75 LIVE + 0.75 WIND
1.00 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 WIND
1.00 0.60 DEAD + 1.00 WIND
5) PORTAL FRAME:-
5-A) CODE ECP01 AISC05-ASD
5-B)LOAD COMBINATIONS 1.00 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 WIND (wind main load) 1.00 0.60 DEAD + 1.00 WIND
1.00 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 WIND
6) BRACING:-
6-A) CODE ECP01 AISC05-ASD
6-B)LOAD COMBINATIONS 1.00 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 WIND (wind main load) 1.00 0.60 DEAD + 1.00 WIND
1.00 1.00 DEAD + 1.00 WIND
7) SAG RODS:-
Use sag rods at Roof, Side walls, End walls as follow:- Use sag rods at Roof, Side walls, End walls as follow:-
One row per bay up to bay spacing 8.0m One row per bay for bay spacing [8.5m - 9.5m]
7-A) SPACING
Two rows per bay for bay spacing [8.0m - 10.0m] Two rows per bay for bay spacing [9.5m - 10.5m]
Three rows per bay for bay spacing >10.00m Three rows per bay for bay spacing >10.50m
7-B) ROOF SLOPE For all Roof Slopes Use sag rods at Roof for roof slope more than 1.5:10
8) ROOF EXT.:
8-A)CODE ECP-2012 ASCE7-05-Slope 1.75:10
8-B)GCP GCP=±0.90 GCP-S=-1.75
8-C)PURLINS GCP=±0.90 GCP-S=-2.50ext. , -2.20int.(ENCLOSED)&(PARTIAL)
9) FASCIA.:- ECP-2012 ASCE7-05-Slope 1.75:10
9-A)GCP(BRACKET) GCP= ±1.30 (0.8(P)+0.5(S)) GCP-P=+1.5 , GCP-S=-1.00 -----( 6.5.12.2.4)
9-B)GIRTS GCP= ±1.30 (0.8(P)+0.5(S)) GCP=±1.53int. , ±1.63ext.(ENCLOSED) (PARTIAL)
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN CODES-ECP12-ASCE7 RV#00 2/2 18/4/2019
