Artículo 20 - Rheology of Flocculated Clay-Guar Gum Suspensions. Amarasinghe, Abelev, 2015
Artículo 20 - Rheology of Flocculated Clay-Guar Gum Suspensions. Amarasinghe, Abelev, 2015
4, OCTOBER 2015
Abstract—In this paper, artificial flocs, similar to the ones that aqueous suspension at the sediment-water interface, which is re-
are found in a recently deposited cohesive seabed, were prepared ferred to as “fluid mud” in some cases [1]–[3], or deposited on
using Ca-montmorillonite and kaolinite (two of the most abun- the seafloor, representing the most recent addition to the consol-
dant clay minerals), guar gum (a polysaccharide closely resem-
bling natural marine organic matter), and artificial sea water, in idating sediment layer. Understanding the viscous behavior of
order to investigate the effect of the composition on their rheolog- this type of material is important in many applications of ocean
ical response. Shear rate effects on viscosity of these suspensions engineering. The applications range from remote acoustic sed-
were also systematically addressed. These effects typically have a iment identification and classification to the prediction of the
strong influence on the overall rheological response of materials amount of impact and subsequent burial during placement, re-
incorporating any polymeric substance. It was found that the ad-
dition of guar gum, even as little as 5% relative to the clay con- trieval, or movement of objects on, near, or in these cohesive
tent, increases the viscosity of the floc suspensions significantly. The seafloors. The erosion and hydrodynamic transport parameters
higher the guar-gum and clay content, the greater is the viscosity of these flocs also largely depend on their viscous properties and
of the floc suspensions, within the guar-gum loading range investi- settling velocity. The settling velocity of flocs is primarily deter-
gated in this study. The floc suspensions with higher solid content mined by the size, solid concentration, and the density distribu-
were found to exhibit a slight shear thinning behavior, apparently
due to the breakdown of the floc structure under high shear stress. tion of the flocs [4]. Floc breakup and aggregation during turbu-
This behavior is more pronounced in montmorillonite floc suspen- lent flow depend on the equilibrium floc size, the residence time
sions than in the kaolinite suspensions due to the differences in of the floc in the turbulent water column, and the characteristics
the clay mineral surface charge properties and surface-to-mass ra- of the turbulent flow [5]. Floc strength and overall suspension
tios. We explore different rheological models in their applicability viscosity properties are major factors in attaining equilibrium
to describing the observed viscous response and conclude that a
cross-type formulation may be most appropriate. conditions during turbulent flows.
During the formation of flocs in saline marine environments,
Index Terms—Montmorillonite, kaolinite, guar gum, viscosity,
a variety of organic matter is aggregated together with clay par-
flocculation, rheology.
ticles. Decomposition of terrestrial plants and weathering of
clay rich soils and bedrocks deliver substantial amounts of or-
I. INTRODUCTION ganic and inorganic material to large river systems [6]. This or-
ganic matter and clay particles, transported by the rivers, are dis-
R ECENT marine sediments are highly heterogeneous and charged into the lagoons and estuaries. Significant flocculation
complex materials, in which mineralogy, organic matter and aggregation of these materials may start as these materials
type and composition, salinity, and depositional characteristics mix with seawater. Changes in the physico–chemical proper-
have a strong influence on the mechanical properties such as ties of these constituents continue to take place as a result of
viscosity. Understanding the viscous behavior of newly formed progressively increasing salinity of the sea water in the estuary
cohesive marine sediments, composed of flocculated matter, is compared to the fresh water in the river. Often, these suspended
important in many applications such as penetration of heavy ob- sediments settle within 5 km from the coastline due to floccula-
jects in the cohesive seafloors, hydrodynamic transport of surfi- tion and aggregation of the particles [7], although longer trans-
cial seafloor sediments, drag forces on seafloor surface and sub- ports offshore could be expected under stronger flow conditions.
surface vessels, and acoustic properties, among others. In addition to the terrestrial organic matter, marine organic
Viscosity of clay suspensions is expected to be influenced matter is also incorporated into flocs, especially in environments
by the presence of organic matter either in aggregated or un- with rapid primary productions. Whereas the terrestrial organic
aggregated forms. Clay and organic materials are present as an matter, such as humic acid, tends to retard flocculation, the ma-
rine organic matter is enriched in polysaccharides and thus tends
to encourage flocculation [8], [9].
Manuscript received January 30, 2014; revised June 21, 2014; accepted
November 12, 2014. Date of publication January 12, 2015; date of current To predict the viscous behavior of flocculated marine sed-
version October 09, 2015. This work was supported by the Office of Naval iment suspensions, a comprehensive understanding of the
Research/Naval Research Laboratory (ONR/NRL) and National Research
relative effects of the different types of organic matter and
Council (NRC) Research Associateship under Grant N00173-08-2-C-005.
Associate Editor: M. Richardson. various clay minerals is required. A systematic study, inves-
P. M. Amarasinghe was with the National Research Council, Naval Research tigating these effects by varying one parameter (e.g., clay
Laboratory, Washington, DC 20375 USA.
mineral, clay concentration, or organic matter type and concen-
A. Abelev is with the Naval Research Laboratory, Washington, DC 20375
USA (e-mail: [email protected]). tration, salinity, etc.) at a time is therefore required. The current
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/JOE.2014.2375632 work, as part of a broader inquiry into the rheological and the
0364-9059 © 2015 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission.
See http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information.
AMARASINGHE AND ABELEV: RHEOLOGICAL BEHAVIOR OF ARTIFICIAL FLOCCULATED CLAY/GUAR-GUM SUSPENSIONS 875
micromechanical response of individual flocs and floccular suspensions into larger aggregate particles with a greater set-
suspensions, investigates how the charge neutral guar gum, a tling velocity. However, these flocculated particles tend to be
polysaccharide that closely resembles natural marine organic very porous and may break apart when sheared by vigorous
matter, and two of the most abundant in nature clay minerals mixing.
affect the rheological properties of the floccular suspensions. In this work, we focus our attention on studying the coagu-
A preliminary study conducted earlier focused on the mor- lation and flocculation of clay and guar gum as a function of
phological analysis of the flocs which were prepared using Xan- the relative composition and clay mineral type in ionic solution.
than gum as the organic material [10]. In general, the floccu- Two methods were tested for floc preparation, imposing variable
lation behavior of clay sediments depends on the type of the degrees of shearing in the suspensions during mixing. The flocs
clay mineral and organic matter, as well as the ionic strength were imaged and characterized optically, using a microscope. A
(salinity) of the water via the mechanisms of the colloidal in- series of rheological experiments were then conducted with the
teraction forces. For instance, xanthan gum is more effective goal of establishing the dependence of viscosity of these suspen-
than chitin in promoting flocculation of montmorillonite [11]. sions on floc composition, floc formation processes, and testing
Meanwhile, addition of humic acid to clay mixtures inhibits conditions.
the aggregation of Na-montmorillonite particles [8]. In general,
the amount of organic matter present in sediments suspensions II. EXPERIMENTAL
greatly influences the mechanical properties, such as viscosity A. Materials
and yield stress [39].
Ca-montmorillonite (STx-1) and kaolinite (KGa-1b), repre-
In this study, we systematically investigate different methods
senting two of the most abundant clay minerals found in nature,
of controlled preparation of artificial marine clay/guar-gum floc
were obtained for this study from the Clay Mineral Society
suspensions and conduct a series of rheological tests on the re-
(Chantilly, VA, USA). Ca-montmorillonite is a 2:1 phyllosili-
sulting material. We also attempt to describe the influence of
cate. The atomic structure of montmorillonite clay mineral is
floc compositions such as clay concentration, guar-gum content
composed of an octahedral sheet, which is sandwiched between
(relative to clay content and absolute), and the ionic strength of
two tetrahedral sheets, as shown in Fig. 1. These structures
the water on the viscous behavior and the shear flow charac-
are called tetrahedral–octahedral–tetrahedral (TOT) layers. To
teristics of floc suspensions, as a function of the applied shear
form clay particles, several of these TOT layers were stack one
rate. This type of comparison will help to reveal the roles of dif-
above another with an interlayer space gap between them. For
ferent constituents, such as organic materials and clays, on the
dry clays the interlayer distance is about 1 nm [16]. Normally,
overall rheologic behavior of suspended cohesive oceanic sed-
clay layers are negatively charged due to isomorphous substi-
iments. A concise version of the current study can be found in
tution. The negative charges of the layers are balanced by the
[12]. The term “organic matter” will also be used to refer to the
cations that occur in the interlayer. The cations that occupy
guar-gum component of our simulated marine sediment suspen-
the interlayer in Ca-montmorillonite are calcium. The cation
sions throughout the remainder of the paper.
exchange capacity and the surface area of Ca-montmorillonite
are 91.5 meq/100 g and 753.5 m /g, respectively [16]. The
A. Coagulation and Flocculation atomic structure of kaolinite clay mineral is composed of an
octahedral sheet and a tetrahedral sheet. The layers are called
Double-layer repulsive, van der Waals attractive, and inter- tetrahedral–octahedral (TO) layers. Hydrogen bonding between
layer forces are the most prominent physico–chemical forces layers results in formation of kaolinite clay particles. The cation
acting on clay particles [13]. Electrolyte solutions decrease the exchange capacity and the external surface area of kaolinite
double-layer repulsive forces acting on any two particles [14]. A are 2–10 meq/100 g and 10–30 m /g, respectively [16]. Miner-
decrease in the double-layer repulsive force results in a decrease alogical and chemical analysis of STx-1 and KGa-1b clays can
in the distance between particles. This process is called coagula- be found in several baseline studies [17]–[19].
tion. An addition of organic material may bridge the OH groups Guar gum, obtained from MP Biomedicals (Santa Ana, CA,
of clay particles, which leads to a flocculated structure [15]. Co- USA), was used as the organic material that represents a typical
agulation and flocculation are the mechanisms that make clay microbial extracellular polysaccharide, abundant in the marine
876 IEEE JOURNAL OF OCEANIC ENGINEERING, VOL. 40, NO. 4, OCTOBER 2015
Fig. 3. Comparison of the MMT flocs created using (a) 25-PSU and (b) 35-PSU salinities.
C. Preparation of Floc Suspensions for Rheological Analyses of excess (unassociated) guar gum in the suspension. The goal
was to study the effects of flocculation on the mechanical
In many natural river sediments, it is believed that clay min- properties of the resulting suspensions as opposed to the uni-
eral fragments may come in contact with most organics before formly distributed but unaggregated mass of clay and organic
the river reaches the estuarine plume zone, where the mixture components. In this preliminary work, clay, guar gum, and
encounters increased water salinity [25]. Therefore, to mimic salt water were mixed using a magnetic stirrer as well as a
this natural process, the clay (particle sizes smaller than 2 m) Brookfield R/S Rheometer with the double gap attachment.
and guar gum were mixed first, and then the salt water was intro- In this latter case, the exact shearing conditions are known and
duced to the mixture during the preparation of floc specimens. In can be controlled, which is not the case with magnetic stirrers,
this study, the flocs that were created using montmorillonite are which create irregular and nonuniform turbulent flows in the
referred to as MMT flocs and the flocs that were created using container. To find out the most suitable mixing rate—those
kaolinite are referred to as KOL flocs. that create more stable floccular structures—mixtures were
A complete set of preliminary tests was performed on suspen- sheared in the rheometer with several shearing rates ranging
sions prepared using the montmorillonite clay mineral. How- from 1 to 800 s , and the resulting flocs were examined under
ever, due to that study's preliminary nature and limited scope, the microscope. Fig. 4 shows the comparison of the size and
as well as lower surface activity in KOL suspensions versus morphology of the resulting MMT flocs that were prepared
the MMT ones, only the latter were tested. These preliminary using the magnetic stirrer and the rheometer methods. This
studies also included an investigation of the effect of salinity on preliminary work also indicated that shearing the mixtures in
the morphology of the MMT-floccular suspension, since salinity the rheometer with a rate of 50 s , which corresponds to a
may influence the yield stress of sensitive clays [26], [27]. In this linear velocity of 2.1 cm/s (0.07 ft/s), tends to produce larger
preliminary work, three floc suspensions were prepared with and denser flocs. The magnetic stirrer technique did not result
the salinity set to 5, 25, and 35 practical salinity units (PSU) in larger flocs and did not appear to aggregate as much of
and keeping the guar gum and the montmorillonite clay con- the guar gum into the floc structures, leaving a larger amount
tents constant at 17% and 83% by weight, respectively. Size of material unabsorbed. Fig. 4 also shows that very low and
and morphologies of the resulting flocs were then examined very high mixing rates in the rheometer did not yield distinct
under the microscope. Fig. 3 shows the comparison of the MMT (large) and well-formed floc structures either, thus, the choice
flocs created using 25- and 35-PSU salinities. It was found that of a moderate mixing velocity of 50 s .
the suspensions prepared with 35-PSU salinity (typical for sea Once the optimal mixing rates were established, the prelim-
water) resulted in larger and denser floccular structures. There- inary work was extended to determine the optimum shearing
fore, the salinity was kept constant at 35 PSU for the remainder (or mixing) time. Thus, the floc suspensions were sheared at
of this study, as we were studying other floc suspensions' com- rate of 50 s for different durations. Results showed (Fig. 5)
positional effects on the rheological properties. that shearing the flocs for 5–10 min tends to produce larger and
A literature review indicates [28] that the mixing rates, denser flocs. Literature survey [31], [32] as well as our micro-
used in the preparation of the suspensions, affect the resulting scopic observations of flocs revealed that longer mixing times,
floc size. Typical river flow velocities range from 3 to 180 in excess of these limits, do not change the size and morphology
cm/s (0.1–6 ft/s) [29]. Normally, the sedimentation of river of the flocs significantly These findings show that the exact and
transported material takes place when the river velocities are uniform shear fields within the suspension can be imposed and
between 0.48 and 30 cm/s (0.016 and 1 ft/s) [30]. A prelim- that the magnitudes of the velocities imposed comply with those
inary study was conducted to find the most effective mixing typically found in riverine environments. It was thus decided to
technique that creates larger flocs and leaves the least amount make all the floc specimens by mixing the ingredients at a rate
878 IEEE JOURNAL OF OCEANIC ENGINEERING, VOL. 40, NO. 4, OCTOBER 2015
Fig. 4. Comparison of the MMT flocs created using (a) the magnetic stirring technique and the rheometer mixing technique at constant shear rates of (b)
1 s , (c) 50 s , and (d) 800 s .
of 50 s for 25 min in the double gap attachment of the Brook- and 0.469 ft/s), respectively. These velocities are within the
field rheometer. range of the typical river flow velocities [29] but may be higher
The current study pursues several goals in attempt to system- than some low-energy littoral environments where some cohe-
atically investigate the rheological behavior of floccular sus- sive, fine-grained sediment deposition may occur. The interest
pensions, including: 1) the effects of two different clay min- in these higher linear velocities (or corresponding shear rates)
erals (Ca-montmorillonite and kaolinite); 2) total clay concen- is also in addressing problems typical of object–seafloor inter-
tration, used in floc formation; 3) total guar-gum concentration action, including free-fall penetration and burial, object drag
(defined as percentage of the clay mass); and 4) a wide range of through the suspended mud layer, or resistance to seafloor traffi-
the strain rates imposed on these floccular suspensions during cability by bottom (or near-bottom) machines, mechanisms, and
shear. To accomplish these goals, three sets of floccular suspen- unmanned vehicles or crawlers. Since these velocities are higher
sions were prepared from each clay mineral type using three than the flocs' settling velocities [4], any error due to settling of
different clay concentrations: 1, 3, and 5 g/L. To understand flocs on the bottom of the measuring system is thus minimized.
the effect of guar-gum content on the viscosity of the floc sus- Rheometer experiments were performed as soon as the sus-
pensions, varying amounts of guar gum were added to each of pensions were placed in the attachment and the duration of the
the three sets of clay concentrations mentioned above. Since the testing period was kept at 5 min or below. Test results show that
percent of organic matter in typical marine sediments may vary the viscometer measurements become stabilized (reach a steady
anywhere between 0% and 15% [33] of the total mass of solids state condition) within close to 1 min. No significant fluctua-
in suspension, we selected several guar-gum-to-clay ratios (by tions in the measurements occur during the rest of the testing
weight), including: 0%, 1%, 3%, 4%, and 5%. This range of time. This observation is also believed to indicate insignificant
solids concentrations of 1–5 g/L is rather typical in suspensions floc settling to the bottom of the attachment. To avoid any turbu-
such as fluid mud [34]. The salinity of all the floc suspensions lent flow or vortices occurring between the two walls, the max-
was kept at a constant value of 35 PSU, representing a typical imum shear rate implemented was set as 1000 s based on both
ocean environment. Reynolds and Taylor criteria, as discussed further in Section III.
All the tests were conducted using the constant shear rate Before the experiments, the authors noted considerable
mode of the instrument. The shear rates used in this study were roughness of the cylinder walls and decided that no additional
250, 500, 750, and 1000 s , which correspond to linear veloci- roughening was needed to mitigate any possible wall-slip
ties of 11.73, 23.47, 35.20, and 46.94 cm/s (0.117, 0.234, 0.352, effects. In general [35], this wall slip is most pronounced in
AMARASINGHE AND ABELEV: RHEOLOGICAL BEHAVIOR OF ARTIFICIAL FLOCCULATED CLAY/GUAR-GUM SUSPENSIONS 879
Fig. 5. Comparison of the MMT flocs created with different shear times: (a) 3 min, (b) 5 min, (c) 10 min, and (d) 25 min.
highly viscous fluids. In our case, the floc concentrations were TABLE I
very low as were the overall viscosity values of the suspensions CONSTITUENTS OF THE FLOCCULAR SPECIMENS FOR KAOLINITE
AND MONTMORILLONITE SUSPENSIONS
tested. The combination of these two considerations led us
to believe that any errors due to a possible wall slip were
insignificant.
Nomenclature of the floc specimens was set as follows. The
first number indicates the concentration of clay (MMT or KOL)
in grams per liter in the specimen. The second number indicates
the weight percentage of guar gum relative to the weight of the
clay. The third number represents the salinity of the specimen
in practical salinity units. Thus, for example, a specimen la-
beled “1-5-35” will have clay concentration of 1 g/L, guar-gum
concentration of 0.05 g/L (or 5%, relative to clay content), and
salinity of 35 PSU. Table I lists the specimens prepared for this
study as well as their individual constituents for both, MMT-
and KOL-based floccular suspensions.
TABLE II
TAYLOR AND REYNOLDS NUMBERS FOR WATER AND 1-0-35 KOL-FLOC SUSPENSION
(3)
where , and are the angular velocity in radians per Fig. 6. Variation of viscosity of water in the shear rate range of 250–2400 s .
second or sec , the radius of the bob in millimeters, the den-
sity of the fluid in kilogram per cubed meter (kg/m ), and the
viscosity of the fluid in Pascal-second (Pa s), respectively. is
the ratio between the cup diameter and the bob diameter.
The critical Taylor number is 41.2 [36], [38]. The Reynolds
number is given by
Fig. 7. Variation of shear stress with time for the 5-5-35 floc specimens sheared
(4) at constant shear rates of (a) 250 s and (b) 1000 s .
Fig. 8. Relative viscosity values of the MMT-floc suspensions. (a)–(d) Floc suspensions containing 0%, 1%, 4%, and 5 % guar gum relative to the weight of the
clay.
Fig. 9. Comparison of the size and morphology of the MMT flocs with (a) 1-5-35 and (b) 5-5-35 compositions.
values for 200–300-s time interval, for added measurement Fig. 9. The flocs are larger and appear denser in the 5-5-35
reliability. specimen compared to the 1-5-35 specimen. Denser flocs may
The relative viscosity values of the floc suspensions were dissipate larger shearing energies, resulting in elevated viscous
calculated by taking the ratio between the viscosity of floc properties compared to the smaller and more loosely associated
specimens and the viscosity of water at a given shear rate. flocs. A slight shear thinning behavior is observed with the floc
Fig. 8 shows the relative viscosity values of the MMT-floc suspensions with higher clay and guar-gum concentrations. As
suspensions. Fig. 8(a)–(d) represents the floc suspensions can be seen in Fig. 8(c) and (d), floc suspensions with higher
containing 0%, 1%, 4%, and 5% guar gum relative to clay MMT concentrations (e.g., 5-5-35, 5-4-35, and 3-5-35) exhibit
content, respectively. Although little flocculation is visible higher viscosity values when sheared at lower shear rates. The
in the microscopic images (not included), it can be observed viscosity then starts to decrease with increasing shear rate. An
in Fig. 8(a) that the contribution of the clay fraction to the image of the floc specimen 5-5-35 after applying 1000-s shear
viscosity is insignificant when there is no guar gum present in rate is shown in Fig. 10. In comparison to the image that was
the suspensions. The highest viscosity is observed when the taken before applying shear [Fig. 9(b)], the flocs appear broken
guar-gum content is at 5% of the clay content, by weight. It is into smaller subparts. As the shear rate increases from 250 to
evident that increasing the amount of the organic component 1000 s , larger flocs break up into smaller flocs, resulting in
to 5% results in the higher overall viscosity of the floc suspen- lower viscosity values of the suspension.
sions. This observation may be attributed to the greater amount
of material present, naturally increasing the overall viscosity C. Viscosity of KOL-Floc Suspensions
of the suspensions. Comparison of the size and morphology Fig. 12 shows the variation of the relative viscosity of the
of the flocs for the 1-5-35 and 5-5-35 suspensions is given in KOL-floc suspensions. Fig. 12(a)–(d) represents the floc sus-
882 IEEE JOURNAL OF OCEANIC ENGINEERING, VOL. 40, NO. 4, OCTOBER 2015
Fig. 11. Shear rate versus shear stress for (a) MMT-floc suspensions and (b)
KOL-floc suspensions prepared with 5-g/L clay concentration. The linear re-
gression for the water is shown as a dotted line.
Fig. 12. Relative viscosity values of the KOL-floc suspensions. (a)–(d) Ffloc suspensions containing 0%, 1%, 4%, and 5 % guar gum relative to the clay
weight, respectively.
Fig. 13. Comparison of the size and morphology of the 5-4-35 KOL flocs in suspension (a) before and (b) after shear at 1000 s .
Fig. 15. Apparent Bingham viscosity as a function of relative guar-gum content and total clay content for two clay minerals: (a) MMT and (b) KOL.
Fig. 16. Apparent Bingham viscosity as a function of total guar-gum content and total clay content for two clay minerals: (a) MMT and (b) KOL.
It may be illustrative to show that the overall increase in seen in MMT versus KOL suspensions are due to the higher
guar-gum content is not the sole contributing factor to the ob- surface charge densities of the clay minerals and possibly to the
served changes of the apparent viscosity. For this purpose, we higher surface area-to-clay volume characteristics that result in
could plot the apparent Bingham viscosity values not versus the the stronger guar-gum-to-clay mineral bonds developing during
guar-gum-to-clay ratio as before, but versus the total guar-gum flocculation, in turn resulting in the higher overall resistance to
content, present in the suspensions. Fig. 16 shows such an ex- shearing.
ample. There are noticeable changes in trends that occur at some To summarize, we can state that the suspensions tested do
critical guar-gum content value—demonstrating, perhaps, a bi- not appear to exhibit any true yield stress—the kind that can be
linear nature of response. Additionally, we notice that these measured at very low, essentially static, shear rates (perhaps on
changes in trends no longer occur at the same value of the ab- the order of 0.01–1.0 s [38]), which were beyond the reso-
scissa. This would suggest that not only the overall availability lution capacity of our instrument for these very low resistance
of the guar gum in the suspensions, but also the combination suspensions. In this case, the more appropriate model of de-
of the clay mineral presence and the availability of guar gum scribing the rheological response of these suspensions could be
in the suspension to produce the floccular structures that are, in the cross model for shear thinning fluids or a somewhat sim-
fact, responsible for the overall rheological effects described, plified Sisko equation [38]. These formulations include a dedi-
are important. As noted before, the more pronounced effects cated shear thinning constant, among other material constants,
AMARASINGHE AND ABELEV: RHEOLOGICAL BEHAVIOR OF ARTIFICIAL FLOCCULATED CLAY/GUAR-GUM SUSPENSIONS 885
and generally describe viscosity as a decay function from the incorporated into floc structures (as suggested by microscope
initial (static or low rate viscosity) to the final (very high observations) is incorporated at much lower binding potential
strain rate) viscosity that is much easier detached (bonds/flocs fractured) during the
suspension shearing process.
(6)
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
where and are material constants (cross constant and cross The authors would like to thank Dr. P. Valent, associate ed-
exponent). Again, since the actual determination of the very low itor Dr. M. Richardson, and three anonymous reviewers for pro-
rate viscosity was not possible due to device limits and the very viding constructive comments on this manuscript.
low shear resistance of the highly dilute suspensions under con-
sideration, we did not attempt an actual model fit. Such an ex- REFERENCES
ercise would be speculative in this case. [1] G. P. Allen, J. C. Salomon, P. Bassoullet, Y. Du Penhoat, and C. de
Grandpré, “Effects of tides on mixing and suspended sediment trans-
port in macrotidal estuaries,” Sedimentary Geol., vol. 26, pp. 1–3, 1980.
IV. SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION [2] R. Kirby and W. R. Parker, “Distribution and behavior of fine sediment
in the Severn Estuary and inner Bristol Channel, UK,” Can. J. Fisheries
Artificial floc suspensions were prepared using Ca-montmo- Aquatic Sci., vol. 40, pp. 83–95, 1983.
rillonite, kaolinite, guar gum, and sea salt to investigate the ef- [3] J. T. Wells, C. E. Adams, Jr., Y. A. Park, and E. W. Frankenberg, “Mor-
phology, sedimentology and tidal channel processes on a high-tide-
fect of the constituents and the shear rate on the rheological range mudflat, West Coast of South Korea,” Mar. Geol., vol. 95, pp.
behavior of the flocs. Fifteen different floc suspensions from 111–130, 1990.
each clay type were prepared by mixing three different clay [4] M. J. Fennessy, K. R. Dyer, and D. A. Huntley, “INSSEV: An instru-
ment to measure the size and settling velocity of flocs in situ,” Mar.
concentrations with five different guar-gum concentrations and Geol., vol. 117, pp. 107–117, 1994.
35-PSU salinity water. The flocs were examined under an op- [5] J. C. Winterwerp, “A simple model for turbulence induced flocculation
tical microscope. The produced Ca-montmorillonite flocs were, of cohesive sediment,” J. Hydraulic Res., vol. 36, pp. 309–326, 1998.
[6] M. Dagg, R. Benner, S. Lohrenz, and D. Lawrence, “Transformation
in general, larger in size than the Kaolinite flocs. of dissolved and particulate materials on continental shelves influenced
Viscosity of these floc suspensions was measured by im- by large rivers: Plume processes,” Continental Shelf Res., vol. 24, pp.
posing shear forces with four different (and constant) shear rates 833–858, 2004.
[7] M. J. Devlin and J. Brodie, “Terrestrial discharge into the great barrier
from 250 to 1000 s . Microscopic imaging was carried out to reef lagoon: Nutrient behavior in coastal waters,” Mar. Pollution Bull.,
investigate the morphology of the flocs. It was found that both vol. 51, pp. 9–22, 2005.
MMT- and KOL-floc suspensions exhibit somewhat similar [8] Y. Furukawa, J. L. Watkins, J. Kim, K. J. Curry, and K. R. H. Bennett,
“Aggregation of montmorillonite and organic matter in aqueous media
viscous behavior with increasing organic matter content. The containing artificial seawater,” Geochem. Trans., vol. 10, p. 2, 2009.
addition of organic materials changes the viscous behavior of [9] T. Ayukai and E. Wolanski, “Importance of biologically mediated re-
clay suspensions significantly. The higher the organic content, moval of fine sediments from the fly river plume, Papua New Guinea,”
Estuarine Coastal Shelf Sci., vol. 44, pp. 629–639, 1997.
the higher is the viscosity of the floc suspensions. The floc [10] A. Abelev, “Examination and manipulation of clay aggregates—Initial
suspensions that have higher clay and organic contents exhibit inquiry,” Naval Res. Lab. (NRL), Washington, DC, USA, NRL Tech.
slight shear thinning behavior, especially above approximately Rep. NRL/FR/7420-11-10, 2011, 33 pp.
[11] Y. Furukawa and J. L. Watkins, “Effect of organic matter on the floccu-
3%–4% organic matter content for the highest clay concentra- lation of colloidal montmorillonite: A modeling approach,” J. Coast.
tion tested. This behavior can be attributed to the breakdown of Res., vol. 28, pp. 726–737, 2012.
floccular particles under high shear force. The shear thinning [12] P. M. Amarasinghe and A. Abelev, “Rheological behavior of floc-
culated suspensions of artificial marine cohesive sediment,” in Proc.
behavior is less pronounced in KOL-floc suspensions. The MTS/IEEE OCEANS Conf., San Diego, CA, USA, Sep. 23–27, 2013.
reason could include the lack of larger or denser flocs, present [13] A. Anandarajah and P. M. Amarasinghe, “Discrete element study of
in the KOL-floc suspensions as compared to the MMT-floc the swelling behavior of NA-montmorillonite,” Geotechnique, vol. 19,
pp. 173–183, 2012.
suspensions. Shear thinning behavior was not observed at lower [14] K. Ma and A. C. Pierre, “Colloidal behaviour of montmorillonite in the
organic matter and clay concentrations. In fact, a very mild presence of Fe ions,” Colloids Surfaces, vol. 155, pp. 359–372, 1999.
shear-thickening effect may be seen at low clay concentrations. [15] P. Mpofu, J. Addai-Mensah, and J. Ralston, “Investigation of the effect
of polymer structure type on flocculation, rheology and dewatering be-
At very lower clay concentrations, all the suspensions behave haviour of kaolinite dispersions,” Int. J. Miner. Process., vol. 71, pp.
in essentially Newtonian manner. 247–268, 2003.
Evaluation of rheological models suggested that the nature of [16] H. Van Olphen, An Introduction to Clay Colloid Chemistry. New
York, NY, USA: Wiley Interscience, 1977, p. 70 and 255.
viscous response of the floccular suspensions tested lies not only [17] S. J. Chipera and D. L. Bish, “Baseline studies of the clay minerals
in the overall amount of guar gum used in sample preparation, society source clays: Powder x-ray diffraction analyses,” Clays Clay
but also in the combination of guar-gum and clay mineral con- Minerals, vol. 49, pp. 398–409, 2001.
[18] A. R. Mermut and A. F. Cano, “Baseline studies of the clay minerals so-
tent, expressed as constant guar-gum-to-clay ratio, by weight. ciety source clays: Chemical analyses of major elements,” Clays Clay
This fact stresses the importance of flocculation mechanisms on Minerals, vol. 49, pp. 381–386, 2001.
the rheological response and suggests that certain changes in be- [19] J. E. Kogel and S. A. Lewis, “Baseline studies of the clay minerals
society source clays: Chemical analysis by inductively coupled
havior may occur after some critical value of guar-gum-to-clay plasma-mass spectroscopy (ICP-MS),” Clays Clay Minerals, vol. 49,
is reached, especially evident in MMT suspension. The actual pp. 387–392, 2001.
reason behind this change in the trends may be assumed to lie [20] R. P. Gambrell, G. Zhang, R. Nugent, and L. Land, “Physical, chem-
ical, and biological evaluation of the application of biodegradable poly-
in the nature of guar-gum-to-clay binding, after some satura- mers to restoring coastal wetlands,” Coastal Restoration and Enhance-
tion value. We speculate that the additional guar gum, even if ment Through Science and Technology (CREST), 2010, 63 pp.
886 IEEE JOURNAL OF OCEANIC ENGINEERING, VOL. 40, NO. 4, OCTOBER 2015
[21] J. Wang and P. Somachandran, “Study of galactomannose interaction [37] S. I. Pia, “On turbulent flow between rotating cylinders,” Ph.D. disser-
with solids using AFM, IR and allied techniques,” J. Colloid Interface tation, Eng. Appl. Sci. Dept., California Inst. Technol., Pasadena, CA,
Sci., vol. 309, pp. 373–383, 2007. USA, 1939, 90 pp.
[22] B. Zhang, H. Su, X. Gu, X. Huang, and H. Wang, “Effect of structure [38] T. G. Metzger, The Rheology Handbook. Hanover, Germany: Vin-
and charge of polysaccharide flocculants on their flocculation perfor- centz Network GmbH & Co KG, 2006, p. 176.
mance for bentonite suspensions,” Colloids Surfaces A, vol. 436, pp. [39] R. W. Faas and S. I. Wartel, “Rheological properties of sediment
443–449, 2013. suspensions from Eckernforde and Kieler Forde Bays, Western Baltic
[23] A. Alemdar, N. Öztekin, N. Güungüor, Ö. I. Ece, and F. B. Erim, “Ef- Sea,” Int. J. Sediment Res., vol. 21, no. 1, p. 24, 2006.
fects of polyethyleneimine adsorption on the rheological properties [40] Y. Furukawa, A. H. Reed, and G. Zhang, “Effect of organic matter
of purified bentonite suspensions,” Colloids Surfaces A, vol. 252, pp. on estuarine flocculation: A laboratory study using montmorillonite,
95–98, 2005. humic acid, xanthan gum, guar gum and natural estuarine flocs.,”
[24] A. Abelev and P. Valent, “Strain-rate dependence of strength of the Geochem. Trans., vol. 15, no. 1, p. 1, 2014.
Gulf of Mexico soft sediments,” IEEE J. Ocean. Eng., vol. 28, no. 1, [41] Cannon Instruments, Inc., Private Communication 2013.
pp. 25–31, Jan. 2012.
[25] M. Preda and M. E. Cox, “Chemical and mineralogical composition of
marine sediments, and relation to their source and transport, Gulf of
Carpentaria, North Australia,” Mar. Syst., vol. 53, pp. 169–186, 2005.
[26] J. Locat and D. Demers, “Viscosity, yield stress, remolded strength, and
liquidity index relationships for sensitive clays,” Can. Geotech. J., vol.
25, pp. 709–806, 1988.
[27] S. W. Jeong, J. Locat, and S. Leroueil, “The effect of salinity and shear Priyanthi M. Amarasinghe received the Ph.D. de-
history on the rheological characteristics of illite-rich and Na-montmo- gree in geotechnical engineering from North Dakota
rillonite-rich clays,” Clays Clay Minerals, vol. 60, pp. 108–120, 2012. State University, Fargo, ND, USA, in 2009. Her doc-
[28] P. Ofori, A. V. Nguyen, B. Firth, C. McNally, and O. Ozdemir, “Shear- toral research involved effect of clay-fluid molecu-
induced floc structure changes for enhanced dewatering of coal prepa- larinteractions on mechanical properties of expansive
ration plant tailing,” Chem. Eng. J., vol. 172, pp. 914–923, 2011. clay minerals.
[29] K. Schulze, M. Hunger, and D. Doll, “Simulating river flow velocity As a Postdoctoral Fellow and a Research Scien-
on global scale,” Adv. Geosci., vol. 5, pp. 133–136, 2005. tist, she was also involved in molecular modeling of
[30] H.-P. Kozerski, “Determination of areal sedimentation rates in rivers clay minerals using molecular dynamics and discrete
by using plate sediment trap measurements and flow velocity—Settling element method. Recently, as a Research Scientist at
flux relationship,” Water Res., vol. 36, pp. 2983–2990, 2002. Brimrose Corporation, Baltimore, MD, USA, she has
[31] Y. Yuan and R. R. Farnood, “Strength and breakage of activated sludge been working collaboratively with the U.S. Naval Research and Army Research
flocs,” Powder Technol., vol. 199, pp. 111–119, 2010. Laboratories on characterization of semiconductor materials for IR imaging
[32] J. Labille, F. Thomas, M. Milas, and C. Vanhaverbeke, “Flocculation technology.
of colloidal clay by bacterial polysaccharides: Effect of macromolecule
charge and structure,” J. Colloid Interface Sci., vol. 284, pp. 149–156,
2005.
[33] L. Burone, P. Muniz, A. M. S. Pires-Vanin, and M. Rodrigues, “Spatial Andrei Abelev received the M.Sc. and Ph.D. degrees
distribution of organic matter in the surface sediments of Ubatuba Bay in civil engineering with expertise in soil mechanics
(Southeastern—Brazil),” Anais da Academia Brasileira de Ciências, from the Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD,
vol. 75, pp. 77–90, 2003. USA, in 2001.
[34] P. A. Traykovski, P. L. Wiberg, and W. R. Geyer, “Observations and He has been a Civil Engineer and a Research
modeling of wave-supported sediment gravity flows on the Po prodelta Scientist at the Naval Research Laboratory (NRL),
and comparison to prior observations from the Eel shelf,” Continental Washington, DC, USA, since 2005. He conducts
Shelf Res., vol. 27, pp. 375–399, 2007. experimental, theoretical, and numerical studies
[35] B. J. Medhi, A. A. Kumar, and A. Singh, “Apparent wall slip velocity of behavior and structure of marine and terrestrial
measurements in free surface flow of concentrated suspensions,” Int. sediments under various loading conditions, remote
J. Multiphase Flow, vol. 37, pp. 609–610, 2011. sensing characterization of terrain properties, and
[36] G. I. Taylor, “Stability of a viscous liquid contained between two ro- air-borne and in situ exploration of sea ice structure and properties. Prior to
tating cylinders,” Philosoph. Trans. Roy. Soc. Lond. A, vol. 223, pp. NRL, he was a Research Scientist at the University of Southern Mississippi,
289–343, 1923. Stennis Space Center, MS, USA.