Maintenance of Widowed Daughter-in-Law
/ Legal Articles / By legalupanishad
This article on ‘Maintenance of Widowed Daughter-in-Law u/s 19 of Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act‘ was written by an intern at Legal Upanishad.
Introduction
Maintenance fundamentally means support to someone who is unable to maintain and sustain herself or himself. Predominantly in India, women are not
able to maintain and sustain themselves after the divorce or the death of a husband due to constraints and diminutions they face in society. This makes it
harder for women to sustain themselves and looking at the constraints and restrictions women face parliament has passed a law regarding this. Hindu
Adoption and Maintenance Act, 1956 which governs the law concerning maintenance.
For this article, our concern would be the maintenance of the widowed daughter-in-law which is governed by Section 19 of the Hindu Adoption and
Maintenance Act, 1956 (HAMA). Under section 19 of HAMA, the widowed Hindu wife is entitled to maintenance from her father-in-law to the extent that
she is not able to sustain and maintain themselves from earnings or property.
Maintenance of Widowed Daughter-in-Law
Where the widowed daughter-in-law is unable to sustain and maintain themselves from her income or estate or has no estate of herself or is not able to
secure maintenance from the property of her husband or her mother or father then she is entitled to the maintenance from her father-in-law under
section 19(1) of HAMA. Nonetheless, section 19(2) of HAMA states that where the father-in-law has no means to provide maintenance to the widowed
daughter-in-law from his property then the obligation stated under section 19(1) ceases to be enforceable. In addition, the widowed daughter-in-law’s
maintenance right would cease to exist after her remarriage.
Right of Maintenance of Widowed Daughter-in-Law:
Maintenance of the widowed daughter-in-law can be met up from the estate where the deceased husband had a share in the estate. To plead section 19
the deceased husband should have a share in the estate. In Raj Kishore Mishra v. Smt. Meena Mishra, the court decided that the father-in-law is under no
obligation if he does not have sufficient means to provide maintenance through his coparcenary estate.
It is crucial to note that the daughter-in-law would have no right to claim the ownership of the property self-acquired by the deceased husband’s parents.
In Satpal v. Suman and Ors. It was stated that maintenance of the widowed daughter-in-law from the salary of the father-in-law would be inconsistent
with section 19(2) of the Act. As the husband has no share in the father’s salary, the widowed wife would also have no share.
Under the old Hindu law, an uncodified daughter-in-law had the right of maintenance against the self-acquired property of the father-in-law but it is
important to consider that section 4 of the act which provides for a non-obstante clause would be having the overriding effect and the aforesaid rule
would cease to exist subsequent to the enactment of the HAMA. Mother-in-law would not have any legal liability to support and provide finance for her
daughter-in-law from her own estate or possessions.
In Venubai v. Laxman Lahanuji Rambhad, the court stated that it is important to understand that section 19 is a whole scheme in itself laying down
obligation and its enforceability, and sections 19(1) and 19(2) are not independent of each other. Under section 19 the daughter has a right that
corresponds to the obligation of the father-in-law.
Maintenance of Widowed Daughter-in-Law
Maintenance of Minors with the Widowed Daughter-in-Law:
In a Hari Ram Hans v. Smt Deepali & Ors. judgment by Punjab and Haryana High Court, it was held that under section 19 of HAMA the word ‘widow’ would
also include minor children living with her and are entitled to maintenance.
In Smt. Raina v. Hari Mohan Budhaulia case the honorable Allahabad High Court held that the petitioner widowed daughter-in-law and her two minor
daughters are also entitled to maintenance from her father-in-law as she had no means to maintain herself and her daughters and the father-in-law had
the sufficient means to maintain her along with her two daughters.
The high court also quashed the impugned order passed by the court below saying the court should not go into the provision’s technicalities but consider
the act’s intention while enacted.
Section 19(2) of HAMA:
It is important to understand the scope and meaning of Section 19(2) as it mentions the coparcenary property in the ownership of the father-in-law
through which he would be providing maintenance to his widowed daughter-in-law. In Nand Kishore Lal vs Shrimati Chanchala Lal, the court stated that
the coparcenary property refers in the section would consist of ancestral property or joint acquisition. Sub-section (2) of Section 19 has the meaning that
is only extended to the ancestral property.
Conclusion
Women’s social and economic condition in Indian society is often fragile and weak due to the constraints and restrictions they face in an overwhelmingly
patriarchal society. This makes women dependent and after the separation or the death of the husband, the women become unable to maintain
themselves. Looking at the aforesaid situation the parliament has passed an appropriate law known as the Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act, 1956
(HAMA) which governs the maintenance rights of a wife and widowed daughter-in-law.
As Section 19 of HAMA further clarifies the stand of the law regarding the rights of maintenance of women. As the law protects and safeguards the
interest of widowed women in a case where she is unable to sustain and maintain themselves after the death of their husband. In this course of events, it
becomes obligatory for the father-in-law to provide maintenance to the widowed daughter-in-law and as well to the minor children thus they can sustain
themselves.
Reference:
Salil Tiwari, [S. 19 Of Hindu Adoptions & Maintenance Act] “Widow” Would Include Minor Grandchildren Staying With Mother: Punjab & Haryana HC,
Law Beat, 7 January 2023, available at: https://lawbeat.in/news-updates/s-19-hindu-adoptions-maintenance-act-widow-would-include-minor-
grandchildren-staying-mother-punjab-haryana-high-court#:~:text=Synopsis,own%20earnings%20or%20other%20property
Basit Amin Makhdoomi, Minor Children Of Widowed Daughter-In-Law Entitled To Maintenance U/S 19 Hindu Adoptions And Maintenance Act:
Punjab & Haryana High Court, LiveLaw, 6 January 2023, available at: https://www.livelaw.in/news-updates/punjab-haryana-high-court-widow-
daughter-in-law-minor-children-maintenance-father-in-law-section-19-hindu-adoptions-and-maintenance-act-218287
← Previous Post Next Post →
Contact Us and avail the best assignment help for students available online!
JOIN OUR WHATSAPP GROUP
Our Latest Articles
How Divorce Specialist Lawyers Handle High-Stakes Cases?
6 September 2024
Divorce is rarely simple, however when huge resources, high-profile people, or complex relational intricacies are involved, the stakes are considerably
higher. High-stakes divorce from cases require a degree of mastery and key reasoning that goes past the conventional. In Chennai, divorce from expert
legal advisors is exceptional to deal with these difficult cases, guaranteeing that their clients’ advantages are safeguarded constantly. This is the way top
divorce lawyers in Chennai explore the intricacies of high-stakes divorces. Far reaching Case Investigation The most vital phase in dealing with a high-
stakes divorce is an exhaustive examination of the case. Divorce from expert… Read more
PCI Hosting: A Cornerstone of Data Privacy Compliance
3 September 2024
Article title: ‘PCI Hosting: A Cornerstone of Data Privacy Compliance’ Introduction The Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI DSS) is a crucial
framework designed to protect sensitive cardholder data and ensure secure transactions. As data breaches become increasingly common, and global data
privacy regulations such as GDPR, CCPA, and HIPAA tighten their grip, maintaining compliance with these standards has never been more vital. PCI hosting
emerges as a pivotal solution, enabling organizations to align with these stringent regulations, safeguard customer data, and fortify their security posture.
Understanding PCI DSS PCI DSS is a set of security standards created to… Read more
What To Look For In A Criminal Lawyer? Check Here
9 July 2024
Selecting the best criminal lawyer requires assessing a number of important factors. The choice of criminal defense attorney can make all the difference in
how a case turns out. With the significant risks involved, having an informed and skilled lawyer at your side can really pay off. The right attorney from the
list of criminal lawyers in bangalore will help their client navigate the complexities of the criminal justice system by recognizing legal nuances and offering
strong defense tactics. Good Reputation and Professionalism A lawyer’s reputation and professionalism are crucial indicators of their reliability. Seek out
an attorney known for… Read more
New Hit and Run Law in India: Understanding the Controversy and Protests
7 March 2024
This article on ‘New Hit and Run Law in India: Understanding the Controversy and Protests’ was written by Tosani Lal, an intern at Legal Upanishad. I.
INTRODUCTION Hit and run refers to the act of a driver causing an accident and fleeing the scene without providing assistance or identifying themselves.
[1] The action is widely condemned due to its potentially severe consequences for victims and the lack of accountability it entails. Hit and run incidents
often result in serious injuries or fatalities, leaving victims and their families devastated. The new hit and run law in India, implemented under the
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita,… Read more
Supreme Court Ruling on Electoral Bond Scheme
20 February 2024
In this article, we will delve into the recent landmark ruling by the Supreme Court of India in the case of Association for Democratic Reforms v. Union of
India.
May we help you?
Name *
First Last
Email *
Contact Number *
Assignment Type *
Essay, article, moot court memorial, dissertation, research paper, etc.
Message *
Topic, deadline, word count or any other guidelines.
Please provide the topic, deadline, word count/ number of pages, or any other important guidelines related to your assignment.
SEND MESSAGE
Search...
Categories
Career Guidance by Legal Upanishad (22)
Guest Post (1)
Law Assignment Help (15)
Legal Articles (578)
Archives
September 2024 (2)
July 2024 (1)
March 2024 (1)
February 2024 (1)
January 2024 (7)
December 2023 (13)
November 2023 (10)
October 2023 (19)
September 2023 (15)
August 2023 (18)
July 2023 (21)
June 2023 (21)
May 2023 (25)
April 2023 (23)
March 2023 (22)
February 2023 (22)
January 2023 (22)
December 2022 (43)
November 2022 (44)
October 2022 (50)
September 2022 (39)
August 2022 (32)
July 2022 (28)
June 2022 (24)
May 2022 (15)
April 2022 (12)
March 2022 (6)
February 2022 (5)
January 2022 (18)
December 2021 (22)
November 2021 (7)
October 2021 (11)
Join Our Community
Enter your email address to register to our newsletter subscription delivered on regular basis!
Enter your email
SUBSCRIBE
Copyright © 2024 Legal Upanishad
