Argyll and Bute Council

Development Services

Delegated or Committee Planning Application Report and Report of handling as

required by Schedule 2 of the Town and Country Planning (Development Management
Procedure) (Scotland) Regulations 2008 relative to applications for Planning Permission
or Planning Permission in Principle

Reference No: 11/01066/MFF

Planning Hierarchy: Local Development
Applicant: Lakeland Marine Farms Ltd.
Proposal: Relocation of Ardmaddy fish farm - comprising 12 No. 100m
circumference cages plus installation of feed barge
Site Address: Port Na Morachd, Seil Sound

DECISION ROUTE

Local Government Scotland Act 1973

(A) THE APPLICATION

(i) Development Requiring Express Planning Permission

• Formation of Marine Salmon Fish Farm comprising 12 No. 100m circumference

cages, walkways, mooring grid and associated lines,
• Installation of feed barge;
• Installation of underwater lighting.

(ii) Other specified operations

• Servicing from existing shore bases at Loch Craignish and Croabh Haven;
• Removal of 18 No. 24m x 24m steel cages from existing site at Ardmaddy North
and relinquishment of lease.

(B) RECOMMENDATION:

It is recommended that permission be granted subject to:

i) a pre-determination hearing be convened in response to the number and

complexity of the representations received;

ii) the conditions and reasons set out in this report.

(C) CONSULTATIONS:

Scottish Environment Protection Agency (27.07.11 & 11.12.12) – In order to address

the likelihood of significant effects upon the Firth of Lorn Special Area of Conservation
(SAC) SEPA will require to undertake a Habitats Directive ‘appropriate assessment’ as
part of its Controlled Activities Regulations (CAR) licence application, and until this
process is completed it is not possible to say whether the biomass proposed will be
licensable under CAR. Subsequent response in 2012 confirming that a CAR licence
has been granted and supplying a copy of the ‘appropriate assessment’ undertaken by
SEPA in support of that consent.

Comment: Pollution control is exercised by SEPA and government advice to planning

authorities is not to seek to use the planning process to duplicate other regulatory
regimes. Where multiple consents are necessary there is no prescribed order in which
they should be obtained. However, in view of the importance of potential pollution
effects upon protected habitats and species in this particular case, and given the large
numbers of representations to the planning application being related to pollution issues,
the applicants were advised by planning officers to agree to this planning application
being held in abeyance, in order to allow them to pursue a CAR licence application in
advance of the determination of the planning application, so that that the consequences
of pollution could be assessed by the appropriate agency and conclusions reached,
outwith the planning process. An application was duly submitted and processed by
SEPA, who undertook a Habitats Regulations ‘appropriate assessment’ in the
consideration of that application. In view of the number of adverse third party
representations to the CAR licence application, the intended decision by SEPA was the
subject of review by Scottish Ministers before being issued. No intervention in the
intended course of action arose as a consequence of this and a CAR licence was duly
granted.

Scottish Natural Heritage (28.08.11 & 26.02.13) – in view of the likely significant
effect on the Firth of Lorn Special Area of Conservation the planning authority is advised
to undertake an ‘appropriate assessment’ having regard to the conservation objectives
of the SAC addressing the transport of organic wastes and chemotherapeutants from
the site. Further comment will be made once the AA has been concluded.

In terms of European protected species the proposal has the potential to affect otters
and cetaceans. It is not expected that the site would affect otters significantly. The
deployment of acoustic deterrent devices to deter seals could have consequences for
porpoises as whilst research indicates that they will avoid areas where ADD’s are in
operation (but will return once they are switched off), continuous operation could have
the effect of excluding them from the Sound. SNH consent should therefore be required
for the deployment of ADD’s at this location. Whilst the faunal analysis of the seabed
shows a relatively diverse and abundant community no benthic impacts prejudicial to
national interests have been identified. Predators such as seals, otters and pisciverous
birds are common in this locality. The applicant considers that double nets are
impractical in this location due to strong tidal currents and SNH concurs that tensioned
nets with anti-chafe panels as employed at many other sites will be sufficient to
minimise risk of escapes. The applicant’s predator control plans and risk assessments
require some updating (subsequently completed). Whilst there are no salmon rivers
within 15km, sea trout will frequent the area year round. Sea lice treatments to SSPO
Code of Good Practice Standards and operation in accordance with the local Farm
Management Agreement will minimise impacts on wild fish, as will the intended use of
well boats for chemical treatments, rather than the more traditional tarpaulin method
employed at the existing site. White cluster anemone is present in the vicinity of the site
and the SEPA CAR assessment should address consequences for this Priority Marine
Species.

In terms of landscape impacts as the proposal does not affect any national designations
SNH has no objections on landscape, visual or recreational/amenity grounds. Localised
impacts could be reduced by repositioning the barge to the south end of the site where it
would be better screened by higher ground on Torsa to the west. Whilst the area is
frequented by tour boats, yachts and kayaks and the development will give rise to
localised impacts these are not considered to be such that they will significantly affect
the overall experience of the Sound and the wider Firth of Lorn.

Following the production of the Council’s draft ‘appropriate assessment’ SNH has
confirmed its satisfaction with the content.

Comment: The option of relocating the feed barge to the southern end of the site has
been resisted by the applicants, as for operational reasons a barge location at the least
exposed end of the site is preferable as it presents less risk to containment in the event
of the barge moorings being compromised in storm conditions. The applicants have
however agreed to reduce the scale of the barge from 26m x 18 m to 14m x 10m in
order to lessen its visual impact and amended plans to that effect have been submitted.

Marine Scotland Science (02.08.11) – No objection. Note the intention to use well
boats for sea lice treatments and the potential to use Wrasse as a supplementary
means of lice control. There are no major Atlantis salmon fisheries within 15km so wild
salmonids in this area are likely to be marine phase sea trout throughout the year and
migrating salmon. Provided the site is operated in accordance with the existing Farm
Management Agreement for the area, in accordance with the SSPO Good Practice
Guidelines and the necessary steps are taken to control lice numbers and to maintain
equipment to minimise risk of escapes, then impacts upon wild fish will be minimised. It
is recommended that it should be a condition of any consent that the existing site at
Ardmaddy North is relinquished.

Argyll & District Salmon Fishery Board (11.07.11) – No specific objections but it is
noted that the development involves a significant increase in biomass and that it would
be preferable for this to be maintained in the initial period following relocation to enable
the applicant to demonstrate that SSPO Code of Good Practice sea lice levels can be
achieved. In the event of an approval, it should be a requirement that the current site be
closed and the lease surrendered.

Historic Scotland – response awaited.

Northern Lighthouse Board (08.07.11) – no objection but advice given as to

navigation marking and lighting requirements.

Royal Yachting Association – have indicated verbally that they have no comment to
make in respect of the planning application and that they will reserve any comment for
the Marine Licence application as and when that is submitted.

Clyde Fishermen’s Association (21.07.11) – object to further development of the

wider fish farming industry in general and this application in particular due to the
adverse consequences of pollution in the marine environment and the general
unsustainability of farming fish.

Mallaig & North West Fishermen’s Association – no response

Council’s Marine & Coastal Manager (10.08.11) – the scale of the existing and
proposed sites are similar in terms of surface equipment area and the characteristics
and designations of the landscape are similar for both sites although the proposed site
occupies a more confined section of the sound, where its visual presence may be
increased. The RYA sailing route hugs the west side of the channel and the proposed
site does not conflict with this. The Marine Licence process will address navigational
issues. Risk to wild salmonids is unlikely to significantly increase if the Farm
Management Agreement continues to be adhered to and the proposed mitigation is
implemented, given that Marine Scotland considers the modelled availability of sea lice
treatment to be sufficient for the biomass proposed. SEPA’s CAR licence process will
include consideration of potential effects on the Firth of Lorn SAC. Three seal haul outs
are within 2km although the applicant’s three sites around Shuna are closer to larger
haul outs. The use of Acoustic Deterrent Devices in narrow water bodies may restrict
the use of the area by cetaceans and advice should be sought as to whether a licence
from SNH would be required for their deployment.

Council’s Biodiversity Officer (25.07.11) – no objection but further comment sought

about potential effects upon marine species. Concern that the proposal will reduce the
width of the channel available for dolphin and porpoises.

Scottish Wildlife Trust (26.09.11) – objects to the development on the grounds that in
the absence of an Environmental Impact Assessment there is insufficient information to
enable the required Appropriate Assessment in terms of implications for the Firth of Lorn
Special Area of Conservation, and therefore the process is unsound. The SAC is of
international conservation importance and the wildlife it supports is of tourism value. For
development to proceed, it must be concluded beyond reasonable scientific doubt that
the implications for the protected rocky reef habitat and the species it supports will not
have an adverse impact on the integrity of the SAC. Failure to employ double nets and
the consequent need to employ acoustic deterrent devices or the licenced shooting of
seals, would not lead to seal shooting as a ‘last resort’, as legislation requires. Porpoise
dolphin and otter use the sound regularly and would be disturbed by the deployment of
ADD’s. Local wild salmon and sea trout stocks have collapsed in recent years and sea
lice associated with the development will be likely to adversely affect these protected
species. The transport of organic waste and chemotheraputants from the site to the
SAC would be contrary to its conservation objectives and would adversely affect the
integrity of the designation. Given the presence of rock reefs and complex tides,
conventional deposition modelling is not an appropriate method for predicting likely
effects. Priority Marine Features such as white cluster anemone to the north of the site
are likely to be affected reducing their value as dive sites contrary to the interests of the
tourism economy.

Kilninver & Kilmelford Community Council (14.02.13) – have objected to the

proposal on the grounds that the development will cause noise light and water pollution,
and lead to rubbish being washed up on local beaches. It is also considered that the
development will disadvantage the local tourism economy and could pose a threat to
navigation and the interests of wild fish. The community support smaller scale
aquaculture developments but consider that this is too prominent and conspicuous site
for the scale of development proposed.

Seil & Easdale Community Council (04.08.11) – have objected to the proposal on the
grounds that the area is one of scenic value and of importance to yachts, tour boats and
other recreational craft, which collectively support the local tourism economy. The
presence of the farm would narrow the channel and make it more difficult to avoid the
rocks off Torsay Island (sic). There is concern locally that the development will not be in
the interests of wildlife tourism, and also that consent for additional pollution is being
sought given the expense of the Seil waste water treatment scheme. It is recognised
that the Council has to balance economic arguments with the environmental disbenefits
of the proposal, but that in this case protection of the environment should prevail. If the
development proceeds, consideration should be given to reducing projection out into the
channel, reducing the impact of the feed barge, using double netting as opposed to seal
scarers and control over lighting.

Luing Community Council (02.08.11) – object in terms of concerns they have as to

the effects of the proposal upon wildlife, tourism, sailing and recreational activities due
to pollution in the vicinity of Luing and the Firth of Lorn Special Area of Conservation.
 Luing is heavily dependent upon tourism which is a key provider of employment on the
island unlike fish farming. They urge that an environmental impact assessment and
appropriate assessment should be used to inform the decision.

(D) HISTORY:

The site benefits from a Crown Estate lease for a mussel farm (AR-3-6-17) although the
site is not currently equipped. No objection was raised by the Council to that
development (03/00843/MFF).

A Crown Estate lease is in place for a salmon farm to the north of the site at Ardmaddy
North (AR-3-6-6). This is currently equipped by 18 No. 24m x 24m steel cages.

The application site benefits from a CAR licence CAR/L/1099909 granted in December
2012.

It is intended that the proposal will supersede the shellfish site and that the lease for
nearby fin fish site, which is also in the control of the applicants, would be relinquished
and the equipment removed, in the event that this larger replacement farm at Ardmaddy
South is consented.

(E) PUBLICITY:

The proposal has been advertised in the local newspaper (14.07.11 and 25.08.11) with
the publicity periods having expired on 15.09.11.

(F) REPRESENTATIONS:

(i) Representations received from:

Objections to the proposal have been received from 814 third parties along with
8 supporters and 2 neutral representations. Names and addresses of those having
submitted representations are listed in an Appendix this report. The grounds of
objection and support are summarised below. It should be noted that a very high
proportion of the objections take the form of standard template letters and e-mails.

Support for the proposal

• Aquaculture is an industry of the future and regulation in Scotland is amongst the

highest in the world;

• Fish farming is a valued component of Argyll’s and Scotland’s economy providing

opportunities for growth in a region where other opportunities are limited;

• The development presents opportunity to maintain or create jobs, both directly and
indirectly;

• Fish farming produces a valuable product in the global market place, is one of our
few export success stories and should be supported;

• The unscientific clichés advanced by objectors are misleading and inaccurate.

When reviewing public comments please remember that many, including young
people, are dependent on the aquaculture sector.
Objections to the proposal

Application documentation and procedure

• The scale of the site relative to the existing site has been misrepresented by the
applicant who has advanced it as a reduction whereas in practice it represents an
enlargement. It is requested that the location of the site should be marked by buoys
for the purposes of any committee site inspection;

• The Planning Authority have described the proposal as a relocation of an existing

site whereas it is actually a new enlarged site. It cannot be legitimately regarded as
a relocation given the difference in scale;

• The applicants refer to the site having an existing use as a mussel farm whereas
the site is not in use and has not been in use previously for this purpose;

• The application ought to have been accompanied by an Environmental Impact

Assessment;

• The application ought to be subject to ‘appropriate assessment’.

Comment: The application has been described by the applicant as a relocation as the
intention is that it should be a replacement for their existing fish farm at Ardmaddy.
Likewise, it was advertised by the Planning Authority as a ‘relocation’ so as not to
mislead interested parties into believing that a second farm was proposed in the locality
of the existing site. In order to clarify that the proposed development is intended to be
an enlarged facility (rather than a straight replacement for the equipment at the existing
site), the proposal was advertised a second time, in order to make entirely clear the
nature of the equipment proposed.

The aggregate area of the surface equipment is a reduction in that at the existing site,
although the extent of the overall surface area of the site is greater, as circular cages
have larger intervening areas of water than the more compact arrangement of square
pens found at the existing site.

Although the site has not been equipped for mussel farming it maintains a Crown Estate
licence for such and would be capable of being so used without the requirement for
further consent. The existence of the licence and the ability to occupy the site in
accordance with the terms of the lease is a material planning consideration.

The proposal was ‘screened’ for the requirement for an Environmental Impact
Assessment by the Planning Authority in advance of the application being submitted.
Following consultation with interested bodies such as SEPA, SNH and Marine Scotland
it was determined that as a relocation and enlargement of an existing site, an
Environmental Statement would not be required in this particular case.

To satisfy the requirements of the Habitats Regulations, an ‘appropriate assessment’

has been carried out by the Planning Authority drawing upon the conclusions of the
appropriate assessment undertaken by SEPA in the processing of their CAR licence.
This appears at Appendix B to this report.

Objections founded on planning policy considerations

• The development would be harmful to a designated Area of Panoramic Quality and

the Firth of Lorn Marine Consultation Area which are designations intended to
 protect the local environment.

Comment: Consideration of the effect of the development on the landscape and

seascape of Seil Sound is required in the context of that associated with the current fish
farm equipment. Local Plan policy LP ENV 10 accords the scenic qualities of the area
regional importance. However fish farms are commonly located in scenic designation in
Argyll, including National Scenic Areas which are accorded higher status in landscape
terms. The development plan status of the area is not such as to preclude development
but requires careful consideration of the landscape implications of development. The
Firth of Lorn Marine Consultation Area is one of biodiversity interest prompting
consultation with Scottish Natural Heritage. It is not a development plan designation
which presumes for or against development.

Objections related to pollution considerations

• The doubling of biomass will increase the problems presented by the existing farm
and will threaten sensitive marine ecosystems. Sites of this scale should be
located further offshore and inshore sites should be operated at reduced stocking
densities with enhanced containment;

• The site will produce large quantities of faecal waste well in excess of the produced
by the local community and this should be considered in connection with that
produced from consented fish farm sites in the area in terms of its cumulative
consequences for the environment;

• The proposal will lead to excesses of nitrates, phosphates and other pollutants will
contribute to a return to inappropriate levels of pollution in the Sound (in part
addressed by the Seil wastewater treatment works). Given the £11m spent on
upgrading the sewage treatment system for the small community at Seil in order to
improve water quality in Seil Sound, it is perverse to countenance such an
additional polluting form of development.

• Although a CAR licence has been granted by SEPA, they do not have the
resources to regularly monitor sites so the industry is largely self-regulating which
is worrying. There is reason to suspect that SEPA’s conclusions were flawed being
based on the application of a standard computer model which may not relect the
specific local conditions.

• The applicants existing site has in the past been graded ‘unsatisfactory’ due to
impacts on the seabed extending beyond SEPA’s allowable zone for deposition
about the cages. Whilst the applicant and SEPA consider that the new site exhibits
better characteristics this conclusion relies on modelling which is not suited to
contained stretches of water with wide variations in speed and direction. As
modelling did not appear to represent actual experience at the existing site, there is
doubt about its reliability here.

• The means by which mass and routine fish mortalities are to be disposed of has
not been addressed as part of the application;

• The applicants have in 2006 previously pleaded guilty and have been fined £1000
for overstocking a site at Shuna.

Comment: Concerns regarding the polluting effects of development and the associated
consequences for habitats and species appear to be the principal grounds for objection
to the application. Although there is multiple consenting regime applicable to fish
farming, there is no prescribed order in which those consents should be obtained.
Given that these concerns related to issues controlled by SEPA under separate
regulation, and having regard to the government cautioning planning authorities against
the improper duplication of other consenting regimes, it was considered appropriate in
this case that these matters of public concern be addressed in the first instance via a
CAR licence application, in order to confirm the consentability of the development from
a pollution control perspective before going on to determine the planning application
with reference to those matters material to the application. It should be borne in mind
that part of the driver for this application is to move operations away from the site at
Ardmaddy North to a location which is more favourable from a SEPA pollution control
point of view.

The applicants have concurred with this approach, and further to extensive public
representation to the CAR licence application which followed, following review of the
matter by Scottish Ministers at the end of 2012 a CAR licence was subsequently issued
by SEPA. That consent permits maximum biomass to be held on the site and licences
permissible quantities of chemical treatments for use at the site. Although third parties
continue to express doubt as to the reliability of SEPA’s conclusions in the matter, the
granting of the CAR licence is a matter of record and its validity cannot be questioned
as part of the adjudication of this planning application. SEPA has addressed the
capacity of the receiving environment to absorb the cumulative impact of multiple fish
farm sites and the associated consequences of designated habitats and species as part
of its assessment of the CAR licence application and has undertaken an ‘appropriate
assessment’ relative to the pollution consequences upon the nearby Firth of Lorn SAC.

Reference is made to the apparent conflict between the additional pollution associated
with this proposal and the costly waste water improvements implemented at Seil. These
were borne out of European obligations upon Scottish Water and were driven by
problems related to bacterial levels affecting shellfish waters, not by nitrogen or
phosphorous enrichment. Human waste and fish farm waste are not therefore directly
comparable in terms of their effects on the marine environment.

The disposal of fish mortalities on a routine basis or in the event of mass mortalities is
not subject to planning control. This is an operational matter for the applicants and is
regulated by SEPA (as waste) and by the Council’s animal welfare officers (animal by-
products). Typically, small scale mortalities are dealt with by way of incineration locally
with larger quantities being disposed of by specialised contractors at sites licenced to
handle this category of waste.

The track record of the applicants in the operation of other sites is not a material
planning consideration. Infringement of the terms and conditions of site licences is a
matter for SEPA to enforce as necessary.

Objections in respect of marine and nature conservation interests

• The site will give rise to adverse consequences for wild salmonids, common and
grey seals and cetaceans and would therefore be contrary to the interests of
biodiversity;

• The site is located too close to the Firth of Lorn Special Area for Conservation and
the seal haul out in Cuan Sound;

• Disrespect for the marine environment to the detriment of marine life and its habitat
shows a lack of human compassion;

• The use of Acoustic Deterrent Devices to scare predators away will also affect
 cetaceans, such as the porpoises which are often seen in the Sound. These are
protected by legislation and distress and adverse effects upon their hearing cannot
be ruled out. The use of locally triggered devices over short periods could still pose
a problem in that regard;

• Failure by the applicants to employ double netting presents prospect of wildlife

entanglement, presents greater risk of escapes to the detriment of wild fish and
leads to the unnecessary use of seal scarers and avoidable seal shooting.
Development which poses a threat to seals and their pups ought to be rejected;

• The Seal Protection Action Group opposes the shooting of seals and believes that
non-lethal predator strategies should be adopted;

• The Salmon & Trout Association objects on the basis that the development is likely
to have an adverse impact upon migratory salmon and on sea trout as a result of
sea lice propagation and escapes of farmed fish. No expansion of production
should be allowed unless closed containment units are employed;

• As an ex local fisherman I have experienced the negative impact of fish farm

development on the environment over the last twenty years and development of
this type should be located further off shore;

• The developer should be required to underwrite independent monitoring of affected

ecosystems;

• There is evidence of chemical treatments at fish farms proving harmful to shellfish

populations.

Comment: The consequences of the presence and operation of the site upon marine
habitats and species are clearly important issues for third parties, arising in part from
the pollution consequences of development, but also from other matters such as sea
lice propagation from farmed to wild fish, risk of escapes, deployment of acoustic
deterrent devices and the prospect of seal shooting. Neither Scottish Natural Heritage,
Marine Scotland nor the District Salmon Fishery Board have raise objections to the
proposal on nature conservation grounds. The Habitats Regulations ‘appropriate
assessment’ found at Appendix B has concluded that the proposal will not affect the
integrity of the nearby Firth of Lorn Special Area of Conservation, which supports the
conclusion reached by SEPA in their assessment of the preceding CAR licence
application.

The consequences of the development for cetaceans and seals is clearly an emotive
issue. The applicant’s experience is that the tensioned netting system proposed at this
site will provide adequate containment and protection against predators; a position
which is accepted by SNH. It reflects current industry practice across Scotland and the
applicant’s practice at other sites in Argyll including sites in proximity to seal haul outs.
The applicants do not routinely use acoustic deterrent devices (ADD’s) and currently
have none deployed on their sites across Argyll. Only one of their sites has been fitted
with ADD’s in recent years and that was for a temporary period as part of a university
research project. However, in order to secure ‘Freedom Foods’ accreditation the ability
to deploy ADD’s as an option is required as it is necessary to demonstrate that in the
event of persistent attacks by a rogue seal, all non-lethal methods have been employed
in preference to recourse to seal shooting. SNH have requested a condition requiring
details to be approved of the type and means of deployment of ADD’s should they
become required at some point in the future. In terms of seal shooting, this is licenced
by Marine Scotland and is not a material planning consideration. Annual returns to the
Scottish Government indicate that in 2012 one seal was shot at the applicant’s existing
site at Ardmaddy. No seals have been shot at that location this year to date.

In terms of wild fish, the site is not close to important salmon rivers, although will be
subject to the presence of salmon in the migration season and sea trout on a year
round basis. The view of Marine Scotland is that provided the applicants adhere to the
Scottish Salmon Producer’s Organisation ‘Code of Good Practice’ (it is a requirement to
demonstrate compliance to maintain membership) and treatment is available in
sufficient quantities to control sea lice to CoGP standards, then the interests of wild fish
should be adequately protected. Given that a CAR licence has already been granted it
is already known that sufficient licenced treatments are available to the applicants at
this site. The applicants propose to use a combination of in-feed treatments and well-
boat treatments. The latter are to be employed in preference to net shallowing and in
situ treatment, and this will improve efficacy and reduce the quantities of pollutants
released into in the marine environment.

Objections in relation to landscape, visual and amenity considerations

• The height of the net structure above the cages and the installation of a concrete
feed barge give the development an industrial appearance;

• This development is proposed in a sensitive area of natural beauty where the

barge, underwater lighting and the extent of the mooring area will impair views. It
would be a dereliction of duty to sacrifice natural beauty to commercial interests;

• The south east coast of Seil Sound is unspoiled and identified by SNH as Craggy
Coastline. There is a long established walking route from Ardmaddy to Loch Melfort
which affords magnificent views. Development of this nature, which would not be
countenanced on land, would be an act of environmental vandalism;

• Lighting will be intrusive given the absence of light sources in the area and the fact
that indirect glow will affect a much wider area dependant on atmospheric
conditions, even if the direct effects of light are localised or not significant at sea
level;

• Noise from the feed barge generator would be intrusive in an area of low ambient
noise, particularly as it would operate at night as well as during the day. Low
frequency noise would be propagated long distances across open water. Generator
noise from the site at NW Shuna can be heard at Toberonochy 3 miles distant on a
calm night;

• The development will contribute to flotsam which is washed up on local beaches;

• The occupier of Kilbrandon House, Seil demands a report on the sound and visual
impact on the property.

Comments: Given the location of the site within a designated Area of Panoramic Quality
which accords the value of the landscape/seascape regional status, it is necessary to
give consideration as to the visual and landscape effects of the development relative to
the site to be removed from within the same designation, and the prospect of a mussel
farm being located within the application site in accordance with the Crown Estate lease
already held for such. This is addressed in Section C of Appendix A below. Site lighting
is confined to one navigation light on the proposed feed barge plus underwater lighting
for maturation purposes. The latter would not be visible at a distance nor at close
quarters from sea level, as such underwater lighting is generally only visible from
elevated vantage points. Given the absence of transport routes or occupied buildings
along the adjacent coastline it will not present an issue at this site, as locations
overlooking the site will not be frequented during the hours of darkness. The feed barge
proposed is a type in use by the applicants at other locations in Argyll. The modern type
of generator employed is contained within the concrete structure of the barge and from
experience at those locations is not audible other than at close quarters.
Notwithstanding the low background ambient noise levels which would be a feature of
still nights, the distance to sensitive receptors is such that noise nuisance would not
produce amenity issues of significance associated with the operation of this site.
Kilbrandon House is approximately 2km distant from the application site, which would
move approximately 0.9km further away from that property than the existing site.

Objections in relation to recreation and tourism interests

• The development will adversely affect local tourism related employment which is
founded upon wildlife and the environmental and scenic qualities of the area. By
comparison fish farm related employment is negligible;

• Scotland’s landscapes are already being devalued by wind turbines, power lines,
inappropriate forms of rural development, shellfish and fin fish farms so a lot more
common sense is required before such developments are allowed to go ahead;

• This is an area of scenic beauty and an iconic passage for vessels transiting from
south to north. The presence of the fish farm will degrade the area as a location for
recreational sailing;

• The development will damage an important sheltered dive site and wildlife tourism;

• The proposal will restrict access to the beach at Port na Morachd used for picnics
and boat trips;

• The area will loose its unspoilt qualities and its attraction for kayaking and
swimming;

• The Scottish Canoe Association objects on the grounds that the development will
impede navigation and contribute to pollution to the detriment of the recreational
resource and the tourism potential of this scenic location.

Comment: It is for Members to weigh the balance between the economic and
employment advantages of the development against any adverse consequence which
the presence of the development might have for established tourism related
employment. Although the development will have localised impacts, these would be
offset in part by the loss of existing adverse effects as a consequence of the removal of
the existing site. There is no definitive research which leads to the conclusion that the
presence of fish farms in Scottish waters has thus far proven to be an acknowledged
deterrent to tourism, although given the importance of scenery as a tourism resource in
Argyll & Bute it is to be expected that inappropriately located sites may deter visits by
persons sensitive to the presence of such activities. SNH have not objected on the
grounds that the development would be prejudicial to the landscape and associated
recreational qualities of the area.

Objections in respect of navigation interests

• The development poses an unwelcome impediment to navigation given that Seil

 Sound is already a difficult passage constrained by numerous hazards and a strong
tide.

• Sailing to windward through the channel is challenging and the site will make this
impossible in some circumstances other than under power. Not all boats have
engines and to use them unnecessarily is wasteful.

• An unmarked rock at the entrance to the sound causes yachts to give it a wide
berth.

• The buoyed area will be so large that it will effectively halve the width of the
entrance to the Sound making navigation difficult for the less experienced.

Comment: Issues relating to navigation would be considered by Marine Scotland as

part of the Marine Licence required for the deployment of equipment in the water. As
this is a separate regulatory regime, technical matters relating to navigation are not
material planning considerations as such, although to the extent that they might have
consequences for the tourism and recreational potential of the area they have an
indirect bearing on the acceptability of the development. Whilst the seabed area of the
application site is extensive (in order to contain the limits of the mooring arrangements)
the surface equipment and the buoys around that equipment present much less of an
obstruction to navigation, particularly as the Northern Lighthouse Board do not require
the outer anchor points to be marked by buoys. There is a requirement for workboats
and larger well-boats to be able to access the site for servicing purposes. Although
there is some narrowing of the sound as a result of the equipment, the width of the
channel is still at least 420 metres at its narrowest point. It should be borne in mind that
any north-south transiting boat traffic would have to negotiate the much narrower Cuan
Sound between Seil and the Isle of Luing.

Objections is relation to the principle of marine salmon farming

• The farming of fish in cages is a form of ‘battery farming’ which is environmentally

irresponsible and unethical in terms of animal welfare, and which devalues the
scenic landscapes within which it is situated;

• Fish farm pose highly destructive effects upon both their immediate and wider
environments;

• They are not a solution to over-fishing as small fish are taken to produce food for
farmed fish and the fish produced are not fit for human consumption due to
contamination with chemicals;

• Underwater organisms are part of a finely balanced ecosystem which are fatally
threatened by pollution associated with fish farming;

• There is an urgent need for world-wide standards to control fish farm escapes in
the interests of maintaining wild fish stocks;

• The economic benefits of fish farming are overstated, particularly given the largely
foreign ownership of companies (in this case Polish). Shameless profiteering
should not be allowed to go ahead against the interests of the environment.

Comment: Consideration of the merits of this application requires to be confined to the

site specific circumstances of the case. Whilst there are those who regard marine fish
farming as being an unsustainable and environmentally harmful form of development as
 a matter of principle, it is a legitimate form of development supported by the Scottish
Government who have targets for the development of the industry as a growth sector in
the national economy and as valued source of employment within economically
deprived rural areas of the country.

Suggested matters to be addressed by conditions in the event permission is granted

• Should permission be given, conditions should be imposed to require double

netting, no use of seal scarers, no shooting of seals, no increase in biomass, low
visibility equipment, a requirement to keep the site ‘clean’, and controls over
lighting.

Comment: Whilst control over deployment of ADD’s, appearance of equipment and

lighting are capable of being controlled by way of planning condition, matters controlled
by other bodies such as biomass (SEPA) and seal shooting (Scottish Government) are
not matters which could be the subject of competent planning conditions.

NOTE: Committee Members, the applicant, agent and any other interested party should note
that the consultation responses and letters of representation referred to in this report, have
been summarised and that the full consultation response or letter of representations are
available on request. It should also be noted that the associated drawings, application forms,
consultations, other correspondence and all letters of representations are available for viewing
on the Council web site at www.argyll-bute.gov.uk

(G) SUPPORTING INFORMATION

Has the application been the subject of:

(i) Environmental Statement: No – the development has

been the subject of a
negative EIA screening
opinion having regard to the
views of consultees and the
presence of the existing
farm which is to be removed
in the event that this
development proceeds

(ii) An appropriate assessment under the

Conservation (Natural Habitats) Regulations Yes – this form Appendix B
1994: to this report.

(iii) A design or design/access statement: No

(iv) A report on the impact of the proposed Yes – Site and

development eg. Retail impact, transport Hydrographic Report, and
impact, noise impact, flood risk, drainage Chemotherpeutant
impact etc: Modelling for bath and in-
feed treatments.

(H) PLANNING OBLIGATIONS

Is a Section 75 agreement required: No

(I) Has a Direction been issued by Scottish Ministers in terms of Regulation 30, 31 or
32: No

(J) Section 25 of the Act; Development Plan and any other material considerations
over and above those listed above which have been taken into account in the
assessment of the application

(i) List of all Development Plan Policy considerations taken into account in
assessment of the application.

‘Argyll and Bute Structure Plan’ 2002

STRAT DC 5 – Development in Sensitive Countryside

STRAT DC 7 – Nature Conservation and Development Control

STRAT DC 8 – Landscape and Development Control

‘Argyll and Bute Local Plan’ 2009

LP ENV 1 – Impact on the General Environment

LP ENV 2 – Impact on Biodiversity

LP ENV 6 – Impact on Habitats and Species

LP ENV 10 – Impact on Areas of Panoramic Quality (APQs)

LP ENV 12 – Water Quality and Environment

LP ENV 19 – Development setting, layout and design

LP CST 2 – Coastal Development on the Undeveloped Coast

LP AQUA 1 – Shell Fish and Fin Fish Farming

Expresses general support for fish farming subject to there being no significant adverse
effect on a range of specified considerations; those relevant in this instance being:

1. Communities, settlements and their settings;

2. Landscape character, scenic quality and visual amenity;
4. National Scenic Areas and Areas of Panoramic Quality;
5. Statutorily protected nature conservation sites, habitats or species, including
priority species and important seabird colonies along with wild fish populations;
6. Navigational interests
8. Sites of historic or archaeological interest and their settings
9. Recreational interests
11. Existing aquaculture sites
12. Water quality

In the case of marine fish farming this support is further conditional on the proposals
 being consistent with the other policies of the Development Plan and Scottish Executive
Strategic Framework Guidelines.

Appendix A – Sustainable Siting and Design Principles

(ii) List of all other material planning considerations taken into account in the
assessment of the application, having due regard to Annex A of Circular 4/2009.

Scottish Planning Policy (2010)

Circular 6/1995 ‘European Protected Species, Development Sites and the Planning
System’ and revised Scottish Government Guidance June 2000

Circular 1/2007 ‘Planning Controls for Marine Fish Farming’

Scottish Executive – ‘Locational Guidelines for the Authorisation of Marine Fish Farms
in Scottish Waters’ (2003 and updated June 2009 and December 2012)

‘A Fresh Start – the Renewed Strategic Framework for Scottish Aquaculture’ (2009)

‘Guidance on Landscape/Seascape Capacity for Aquaculture’ (SNH 2008)

‘Siting & Design of Marine Aquaculture Developments in the Landscape’ (SNH 2011)

‘Argyll & Firth Of Clyde Landscape Character Assessment’ (SNH 1996)

‘Argyll & Bute Local Biodiversity Action Plan’ Argyll & Bute Council

(K) Is the proposal a Schedule 2 Development not requiring an Environmental Impact

Assessment: Yes

(L) Has the application been the subject of statutory pre-application consultation
(PAC): No

(M) Has a sustainability check list been submitted: No

(N) Does the Council have an interest in the site: No

(O) Requirement for a hearing (PAN41 or other): Yes - it is recommended that a pre-
determination hearing be convened in response to the number of representations
received from third parties and the complexity of the issues raised.

(P) Assessment and summary of determining issues and material considerations

The proposal seeks permission for the installation of a marine finfish development of 12
No. 100m circumference (32m diameter) cages and a feed/service barge to be utilised
for the production of farmed salmon.
The application site is located to the eastern side of Seil Sound close inshore to the
coast of the Degnish peninsula which also forms the north coast of Loch Melfort. It is
situated to the east of the small island of Torsa which lies to the east of Cuan Sound off
the north-east coast of the Isle of Luing.

The site lies off an area of remote, largely inaccessible and uninhabited land, where it
would be most readily experienced from boat traffic negotiating the Sound, or at a
distance from coastal properties south of Balvicar on the Isle of Seil. The site currently
benefits from a Crown Estate shellfish lease for mussel rafts, although it is not equipped
for production. The nearest fin fish site is operated by the applicants some 900m to the
north at Ardmaddy. This comprises a block of steel cages which it is proposed to
remove should this enlarged and more modern facility be consented. The proposal
therefore constitutes a relocation which also involves an increase in licenced peak
biomass from 1,300 to 2,500 tonnes. There are no other finfish farms in Seil Sound, the
nearest sites being well removed within Loch Melfort and around the coast of Shuna to
the south.

The proposal when submitted in 2011 prompted significant public objection in relation to
the anticipated pollution effects of the development and the associated consequences
for marine habitats and species. Pollution control in respect of marine fish farm
developments is exercised by the Scottish Environment Protection Agency (SEPA)
through the Controlled Activities Regulations (CAR licence) rather than by the Council.
Planning Authorities are cautioned in government advice against attempting to duplicate
other regulatory regimes, so other than pollution consequences for wild fish (which are
not subject to SEPA control), the remaining pollution effects of this development are not
material considerations for the planning application process. Likewise it is SEPA who
consent permitted biomass to be held at the site and not the Council. With this situation
in mind, the applicants agreed to the suggestion from officers that in this particular case
it would be appropriate for this planning application to be held in abeyance pending the
submission and determination of a CAR licence application by SEPA, so that issues
surrounding pollution could be addressed in the first instance, without leading to
inappropriate demand from third parties for these to be addressed as part of the
determination of this planning application.

In the event, a CAR licence application was pursued, and despite third party opposition
prompting consideration of the matter by Scottish Ministers, no intervention on their part
took place and SEPA proceeded to issue a CAR licence in respect of this 2,500 tonne
site towards the end of 2012. Subsequent to that, the determination of the planning
application is now being pursued.

The site lies outwith but adjacent to the Firth of Lorn Special Area of Conservation
(SAC), the closest point of which lies at Cuan Sound which is 1.8km away. Where a
development proposal is not connected with the management of a Natura site for nature
conservation, is likely to have a significant effect on the site (either alone or in
combination with other plans or projects), or effects are unknown, then the ‘competent
authority’ assessing the merits of a development proposal (in this case the Planning
Authority) is required to carry out an ‘appropriate assessment’ in order to evaluate
anticipated effects on the conservation objectives of the designated site. This applies
equally to developments located outwith designations which have the potential to impact
upon qualifying interests within the designations, as it does to those developments
proposed within designated areas. In such circumstances, only when it is concluded
‘beyond reasonable scientific doubt’ that the development under consideration will not
adversely affect the integrity of the designation, may permission be granted. In all other
circumstances permission must be refused (other than in the specifically excepted
cases where no alternatives exist, or there are imperative reasons of overriding public
interest for development to proceed).
SEPA as ‘competent authority’ in respect of the CAR licence process conducted their
own ‘appropriate assessment’ prior to the granting of the licence for this site, which
concluded that the proposal would not compromise the nearby SAC designation.
Although SEPA’s assessment is a matter of record, as the planning process
commenced prior to SEPA’s consideration of the matter, it remains incumbent upon the
Planning Authority to conduct its own ‘appropriate assessment’ as part of the planning
application determination process. This can be found at Appendix B to this report. It
draws on SEPA’s conclusions (which are annexed to the appendix) as well as advice
provided by Scottish Natural Heritage. This concludes that impacts from solids flux, sea
lice treatments and nutrients are calculable, and having regard to modelling results and
accepted environmental standards, the development proposed will not adversely affect
the integrity of the SAC in light of its conservation objectives.

Neither SNH, SEPA, Marine Scotland, nor the District Salmon Fishery Board have
raised objections to the proposal. Objections have however been lodged by the Clyde
Fishermen’s Association, the Scottish Wildlife Trust, and adjacent Community Council’s

Scottish Planning Policy indicates the national importance of aquaculture in the context
of rural areas and that fish farming should be supported in appropriate locations, subject
to environmental considerations being assessed. Carrying capacity, landscape, natural
environment, historic environment and potential for conflict with other marine users,
including fishing and recreational interests, and economic factors will be material
considerations in assessing acceptability. Planning Authorities are cautioned not to
duplicate controls exercised by SEPA and Marine Scotland in their assessment of
proposals.

Government policy is to support the expansion of marine fish farming where it can take
place in environmental sustainable locations, where it does not exceed the carrying
capacity of the water body within which it is to be located and where it does not give rise
to significant adverse effects upon nature conservation, wild fish, historic environment or
other commercial or recreational water users. The intention of this proposal is to
enable the replacement of a first generation fish farm with more modern equipment in a
more hydrographically favourable location, whilst also taking the opportunity to expand
capacity. Despite the increase in biomass, the surface area of the cages would reduce
marginally, although the less compact layout of circular rather than square cages would
lead to an overall increase in the extent of surface footprint.

It has already been demonstrated to SEPA’s satisfaction that the development can
operate without compromising recognised water quality standards and that discharges
from the site will not affect the integrity of nearby European protected habitats. The
location of the site between the largely unpopulated coasts of Degnish and Torsa are
such that it will not exert influence over the land to any degree beyond that already
associated with the nearby site which it is intended to replace. Both sites lie within the
same local plan designated Area of Panoramic Quality. Sensitive receptors on land on
the Seil coast to the north would benefit from the intended relocation of the site
southwards at increased separation. The site would however be relocated to a narrower
section of the Sound, which would bring those navigating the Sound closer to the
equipment. However the proposal would reduce the number of consented aquaculture
sites from one shellfish and one finfish site to the single site proposed, so any increased
visual impact would be offset by this reduction in the number of sites. Whilst the width of
the navigational channel will be reduced, at 420m this would not be to the extent that it
would frustrate navigation. This aspect would be addressed separately by the Marine
Licence process.

Significant representation against the proposal has been received, primarily on grounds
 that the development would increase pollution and pose a threat to protected habitats
and species. The extent and complexity of the issues raised are such as to warrant a
local hearing prior to the determination of the application.

(Q) Is the proposal consistent with the Development Plan: Yes

(R) Reasons why Planning Permission or Planning Permission in Principle Should be

Granted:

The proposal involves the establishment of a new marine finfish farm, which would
entail the de-equipping of an established farm to the north of the site and the
relinquishment of the lease, and which would supersede an undeveloped but consented
shellfish farm within the application site. It would maintain the number of finfish farms in
Seil Sound at a single site. Whilst the development would occupy a narrower section of
the Sound and would occupy a larger overall footprint, other than for the addition of a
feed barge, the aggregate surface equipment area would remain similar to that at the
existing site. The landscape and visual consequences of the development relative to the
existing position are considered acceptable, whilst the separation from sensitive
receptors avoids unacceptable amenity conflicts. Navigation of the Sound will remain
unimpeded and recreational interests will not be seriously prejudiced. The pollution
consequences of the development in combination with other fish farm developments
upon the protected habitats of the Firth of Lorn SAC have been assessed by means of
‘appropriate assessment’ and it has been determined that this proposal will not
adversely affect the integrity of this European marine designation. The proposal satisfies
the provisions of the development plan and there are no other material considerations,
including matters raised by consultees and third parties, which would outweigh the
presumption in favour of development established by the plan.

(S) Reasoned justification for a departure to the provisions of the Development Plan

Not applicable

(T) Need for notification to Scottish Ministers or Historic Scotland: No

Author of Report: Richard Kerr Date: 29th February 2013

Angus Gilmour
Head of Planning and Regulatory Services
CONDITIONS AND REASONS RELATIVE TO APPLICATION 12/00904//MFF

1. The development hereby permitted shall not be carried out other than wholly in
accordance with the following plans and details unless previously approved in writing
by the Planning Authority:

• Application Form dated 13.06.11;

• Plan 1 of 9 – current and proposed site locations and layout;
• Plan 2 of 9 – location plan 1:10,000;
• Plan 3 of 9 – location plan 1:25,000;
• Plan 4 of 9 – Admiralty chart indicating mooring containment area;
• Plan 5 of 9 – site layout plan;
• Plan 6 of 9 – cage sections;
• Plan 7 of 9 – net specifications;
• Plan 8 of 9 – feed barge specifications (amended 18.12.12);
• Plan 9 of 9 – feed barge appearance (amended 18.12.12).

Reason: For the purpose of clarity, to ensure that the development is implemented in
accordance with the approved details.

2. The stocking of the farm hereby approved with fish shall not take place until the fish pens
walkways, associated structures and moorings have been removed from the existing site
at Ardmaddy North (0.9km north of the consented site) and evidence has been
presented to the Planning Authority that the existing Crown Estate lease has been
relinquished in order to prevent subsequent re-equipping of that site.

Reason: Consent for this development is granted solely on the basis that this development
will replace the existing operation. Occupation of this site in association with the existing
site would produce unacceptable cumulative impacts as a result of the presence and
operation of multiple sites in inappropriately close proximity which would exceed the
carrying capacity of the receiving environment.

3. In the event that the development or any associated equipment approved by this
permission ceases to be in operational use for a period exceeding three years, the
equipment shall be wholly removed from the site thereafter unless otherwise agreed in
writing by the Planning Authority.

Reason: In the interest of visual amenity and to ensure that redundant development does
not sterilise capacity for future development within the same water body.

4. In the event of equipment falling into disrepair or becoming damaged, adrift, stranded,
abandoned or sunk in such a manner as to cause an obstruction or danger to navigation,
the developer shall carry out or make suitable arrangements for the carrying out of all
measures necessary for lighting, buoying, raising, repairing, moving or destroying, as
appropriate, the whole or any part of the equipment.

Reason: In the interest of visual amenity.

5. All lighting above the water surface and not required for safe navigation purposes should
be directed downwards by shielding and be extinguished when not required for the
purpose for which it is installed on the site.

Reason: In the interest of visual amenity.

6. The finished surfaces of all equipment above the water surface including the feed barge
and surface floats and buoys associated with the development hereby permitted
(excluding those required to comply with navigational requirements) shall be non-
reflective and finished in a dark recessive colour in accordance with colour schemes to
be agreed in advance in writing by the Planning Authority (by way of BS numbers or
manufacturer’s specifications) unless otherwise agreed in advance in writing by the
Planning Authority.

Reason: In the interest of visual amenity.

7. No deployment of Acoustic Deterrent Devices shall be permitted at the site unless the
model intended for use and the means of its use have been submitted to and approved
in writing by the Planning Authority, following consultation with Scottish Natural Heritage.
Thereafter deployment shall only take place in accordance with the duly approved
details unless any subsequent variation thereof is agreed in writing by the Planning
Authority.

Reason: In the interests of nature conservation.

NOTES TO APPLICANT

• This permission shall only last for a period of three years from the date of this decision
notice unless the development is started within that period.

• In order to comply with Sections 27A(1) of the Town and Country Planning (Scotland)
Act 1997, prior to works commencing on site it is the responsibility of the developer to
complete and submit the attached ‘Notice of Initiation of Development’ to the Planning
Authority specifying the date on which the development will start. Failure to comply with
this requirement constitutes a breach of planning control under Section 123(1) of the
Act.

• In order to comply with Section 27B(1) of the Town and Country Planning (Scotland)
Act 1997 it is the responsibility of the developer to submit the attached ‘Notice of
Completion’ to the Planning Authority.

• In terms of condition 1 above, the council can approve minor variations to the approved
plans in terms of Section 64 of the Town and Country Planning (Scotland) Act 1997
although no variations should be undertaken without obtaining the prior written
approval of the Planning Authority. If you wish to seek any minor variation of the
application, an application for a non material amendment (NMA) should be made in
writing to Planning Services, Whitegates Office, Whitegates Road Lochgilphead, PA31
8SY which should list all the proposed changes, enclosing a copy of a plan(s) detailing
these changes together with a copy of the original approved plans. Any amendments
deemed by the Council to be material, would require the submission of a further
application for planning permission.

• The applicant should have regard to the navigational marking requirements of the
Northern Lighthouse Board as set out in their consultation response.

• The deployment of Acoustic Deterrent Devices at this site may be subject to a

requirement for a licence to be obtained in advance from Scottish Natural Heritage in
respect of disturbance to cetaceans, in addition to the requirements of condition 7
 above. Early consultation with SNH over the matter of the prospective deployment of
ADD’s is recommended.

APPENDIX A – RELATIVE TO APPLICATION NUMBER: 09/00905/MFF

PLANNING LAND USE AND POLICY ASSESSMENT

A. Location, Nature and Design of Proposed Development

The applicant in this case is Lakeland Marine Farms Ltd (part of the Meridian Group)
who currently operate a number of finfish farming sites across Argyll including an
existing site at Ardmaddy (referred to as Ardmaddy North for the purposes of this
application). That site is a first generation farm comprising 18 No. 10m deep 24m x
24m square metal cages, projecting 1.4m above the surface, with bird exclusion nets
and several sheds mounted on the walkway structures, but without a feed barge. It
provides an aggregate cage surface area of 10,368m2 within an overall occupied
surface area of 13,440m2, secured within a seabed a mooring area of 145,000m2. It
has a licenced maximum biomass of 1,300 tonnes. The applicants seek to replace that
equipment whilst at the same time expanding the productive capacity of the farm, and
in so doing have identified a hydrographically more favourable site 900m to the south,
which would lend itself to the increased biomass proposed.

The proposed site (referred to as Ardmaddy South for the purposes of this application)
lies on the same side of the Sound some 900m to the south of the location of the
current equipment. The site is located off the west coast of the Deignish peninsula at
Port na Morachd, about 1km to the north of Deignish Point and on the opposite side of
the Sound to the small island of Torsa. The proposal is to equip the site with 12 No.
100m circumference circular cages grouped together in a 6 x 2 rectangular mooring
grid, producing a slightly reduced aggregate area occupied by surface equipment that
at Ardmaddy North at 9,549m2, within a larger 179,800m2 mooring area (580m x
310m). The cages would be fitted with a centrally supported top net structure giving an
overall maximum height of 2.6m at the cage centre point. The site would have a
maximum biomass of 2,500 tonnes - 1,200 tonnes greater than the existing site at
Ardmaddy North. The main difference in the appearance of the site will be accounted
for by its less compact format due to the bigger gaps between circular cages, and the
addition of a feed barge at the north end of the cage group. It will therefore occupy a
larger area of water (cage grid within a buoyed support structure of 100m x 300m),
despite the fact that the surface area of the equipment within this overall area will be
less than that of the pens at the present site.

The application site already benefits from a Crown Estate lease for a shellfish farm
comprising 6 No. 10m2 mussel rafts within a 55,000m2 mooring area, although the site
is not currently equipped for production. It is intended that the proposal will supersede
the shellfish site and that the lease for the Ardmaddy North site would be relinquished
and the equipment removed, in the event that this larger replacement farm at
Ardmaddy South is consented.

The proposed cages comprise circular polyethelyene flotation rings approx.1.2m high
above the waterline with a diameter of 32m, from which 15m deep nets will be
suspended. The cages will be fitted with a ‘hamster wheel’ top net support 2.6m high
which will enable the fitting of 25mm mesh nets over the cages for the purpose of
excluding pisciverous birds. The nets are fitted with false bottoms (seal blinds) to deter
predator attacks from below, and are held in tension, again to resist predation. The
cages will be secured in place by a rectangular 100m x 300m mooring grid with
mooring lines and rock anchors used to secure the position of the grid relative to the
seabed. The site will be aligned SW - NE parallel to, and close inshore to, the mainland
coast. The feed barge originally proposed was 18m x 26m in area although this has
since been reduced by way of amended plans showing a much smaller barge 14.0m x
10.5m in area and 5.3m in height maximum, dependent upon the quantity of feed held.
The barge comprises four silos, a generator, maintenance and crew accommodation. It
will be finished in a recessive colour with generator noise only audible at close
quarters. The site will be staffed by 3 to 4 full-time employees plus 2 part-time staff and
will safeguard the jobs currently associated with Ardmaddy North. Deliveries to the site
will be by sea from Lakeland’s existing shore base at Loch Craignish. Personnel
transfers will take place by boat from a staff facility at Croabh Haven. Underwater
lighting would be used to control maturation and maximise growth December to May
every second year with 2 No, 1,000w lights being used 5m beneath each cage. These
would be powered by the feed barge generator and would produce a surface glow only
visible at close quarters or from elevated vantage points. Other lighting on the site, with
the exception of navigational requirements, would be restricted to essential
requirements so as to avoid unnecessary illumination on the site.

The section of the Sound to which the site is to be relocated is narrower than that
occupied by the equipment at Ardmaddy north being some 700m wide at this point and
narrowing off to the south due to the presence of the island of Torsa. The nearest fish
farm site is that at Ardmaddy North (to be relinquished) with the next nearest sites
either being within Loch Melfort or off the north coast of the island of Shuna, some 5km
to the south. Seil Sound is ‘unclassified water’ for the purpose of Marine Scotland’s
Locational Guidelines for fish farms in marine waters, as it is a complex open water
body which does not suit the modelling used to inform the guidelines (which relate
more to sealochs which are most susceptible to cumulative impacts). In view of this the
applicant has undertaken nutrient enrichment modelling which has been accepted by
Marine Scotland and by SEPA in their ‘appropriate assessment, which in turn informs
the conclusions of the Councils own assessment.

The site lies within Management Area 16d (Seil Sound to Loch Craignish). There is no
Area Management Agreement in place for this location at the moment due to the
decision of wild fish interests to withdraw from the former Lower Lorn AMA. The
applicants are, however, part of the Lower Lorn Farm Management Agreeement with
Kames Fish Farm which ensures synchronous stocking and treatments between the
two companies actively farming in this area. The intended peak biomass (fish tonnage)
for the overall site is 2,500 tonnes. The stocking density would be 17.4kg per m3 max.
The production cycle of the farm would be 22 months with 2 months left fallow to assist
in benthic (sea bed) recovery.

The site would be operated in compliance with the Scottish Salmon Producers
Organisation’s ‘Code of Good Practice Guidelines for Scottish Finfish Aquaculture’.
This sets out more than 300 main specific compliance points which cover all aspects of
finfish good practice including:

• Fish Health – good husbandry and harvesting operations;

• Protecting the environment – including sea lice management and containment
standards;
• Welfare and husbandry – breeding and stocking density;
• Detailed annexes giving further technical guidance on good practice, including
the National Lice Treatment Strategy, Integrated Sea Lice Management,
Containment, and a Veterinary Health Plan.

The applicants have provided details of their Emergency Mortality Removal and
Escapes Contingency procedures, manufacturers’ site specific attestations for
equipment, nets and moorings, their Veterinary Health and Biosecurity Plan and their
Predator Risk Assessment and Predator Control Plan. With regard to predator control,
 it is noted that the ES states that Acoustic Deterrent Devices (ADDs) would only be
deployed in circumstances where the site becomes subject to attempted predation. As
a last resort in the event of persistent rogue seal activity, the shooting of seals may
take place in accordance with a Scottish Government licence already held by the
company.

B. Natural Environment - Fresh Water, Marine Environment and Biodiversity.

The provisions of Policies STRAT DC 7, LP ENV 2 and LP ENV 6 all seek to resist
development which is considered likely to result in a significant adverse impact upon
internationally, nationally or locally important habitats and/or species.

The application site is not located within any European or national nature conservation
designations. Whist the proposal lies outwith the Firth of Lorn Special Area of
Conservation (SAC) it is within potential influencing distance of the SAC, the nearest
point of which is some 2km away at Cuan Sound, and for that reason a Habitats
Regulations ‘appropriate assessment’ has been carried out in respect of qualifying
interests of this European marine site. The Sound is also frequented by species of
nature conservation interest including seals and wild salmonids, for which development
of the type proposed could have consequences in terms of displacement or deterrence.
Salmon and Sea Trout are vulnerable to interaction with farmed fish and both a UK
BAP and the A&B LBAP species and included in the Argyll & Bute Local Biodiversity
Action Plan. The Sound also host to white cluster anemone, which is a Priority Marine
Feature.

Seabed (Benthic) Impacts:

The development will affect seabed conditions as a consequence of the deposition of

organic matter in the form of faeces. Furthermore, although the industry has made
advances in the reduction of waste food as a result of more sophisticated feeding
regimes, waste food also contributes to seabed deposition. This can take the form of
localised smothering of the seabed as well as more distant deposition arising from the
propagation of waste matter from the site. The quantity and the extent of deposition are
influenced by the tonnage of fish held, hydrographic and bathymetric conditions.
Seabed impacts are regulated separately by SEPA via the CAR licence process, which
determines maximum biomass with regard to the carrying capacity of the particular site.

The applicants have provided a benthic survey, a visual assessment and a modelling
assessment in support of their proposal, all of which have been considered by SEPA
as part of their CAR licence application and which have helped inform SEPA’s
conclusions in respect of their ‘appropriate assessment’. The seabed below the
proposed site comprises firm mud, shell and gravel which supports a diverse range of
mollusc, crustacean and echinoderm. There are no specifically designated habitats
below or in the immediate vicinity of the site. Modelling has been used to predict a site
specific Allowable Zone of Effect (AZE) in order to demonstrate compliance with
SEPA’s requirements. This indicates that there will be localised enrichment with high
dispersal at what is regarded to be a moderately flushed site. SEPA has accepted this
conclusion along with the fact that there will be low cumulative impact as the next
nearest site is 2.5km distant. The CAR licence which was issued at the end of 2012
addresses the discharge consequences of the development in terms of smothering as
well as chemical treatments and cumulative nutrient enrichment.

SNH and SEPA are both content with the benthic surveys undertaken by the applicant
and neither have objections to the proposal on the grounds of unacceptable benthic
impacts.
Water Quality Impacts:

Enrichment of water by nutrients released from salmon farms can cause an

accelerated growth of algae and higher forms of plant life to produce an undesirable
disturbance to the balance of organisms and the quality of water.

This site is located at the SE entrance to Seil Sound which is subject to tidal currents
producing a moderately flushed site, and modelling indicates that waste dispersal will
be into the deeper water of the Sound as well as to Loch Melfort and Shuna Sound.
Estimated nutrient enrichment is well below the threshold of 50% above the OSPAR
and UTAG reference levels, and consented sea lice treatments have been set in the
CAR licence for the site at a level which will not breach SEPA’s Environmental Quality
Standards. Whilst localised impacts are anticipated from particulate and dissolved
wastes, modelling results indicate that these, when considered cumulatively with other
consented sites, will not result in a significant deterioration in the quality of the
receiving water body; a position accepted by SEPA in the issuing of a CAR licence for
the biomass sought by the applicants.

Neither Marine Scotland Science nor SEPA have raised objection to the proposal in
respect of the predicted impact of the development upon water quality.

Interaction with Predators:

Salmon farm predators are generally piscivorous birds and seals, with the latter tending
to be the most frequently encountered predators on marine farms in Scotland. The
presence of sea cages may attract higher concentrations of predators to the locality of
the site, although good husbandry and hygiene procedures will help to reduce the
attraction of predators. Tensioned netting on fish cages prevents and deters both seals
and diving bird attacks, although regular removal of mortalities from the bottom of the
nets and regular maintenance of the nets to maintain their integrity is necessary to
avoid attempts at predation. Top nets are to be installed on the cages to avoid
predation by birds from above the waterline. Bird nets require to be maintained to a
high standard and properly tensioned eliminate the opportunity for birds to become
entangled or to be able to enter the cage. The fish cages themselves are to be
manufactured to current industry standards, with a net specification, tensioning
arrangements, false bottoms and an installation, inspection and maintenance regime to
meet the SSPO ‘Code of Good Practice’ requirements. It is clearly in the operator’s
interest to ensure that equipment is specified and maintained in a manner to ensure
containment of the farmed fish. Site specific equipment attestations have been supplied
to confirm that, in the respective manufacturer’s opinions, the equipment intended for
use on this site is suitable and sufficiently durable to be deployed having regard to the
characteristics of in the particular marine environment proposed.

The ES does not identify any major colonies of predators in the vicinity of the
application site, although there are recorded haul outs within 2km at Cuan Sound and
Scoul Eilean. The Environmental Statement concludes that proposed use of good
husbandry (mortality and moribund fish removal) and hygiene practices based on
experience at other sites, coupled with the use of tensioned nets and top nets will be
sufficient to deter predators at the proposed site. In the event of persistent predator
activity, the applicants wish to maintain that option to deploy Acoustic Deterrent
Devices (ADD’s) to scare away seals in order to avoid to resorting to the shooting of
seals. Technology has improved in recent years with devices available which are more
effective than previous systems and are more localised and targeted in their impact.
SNH have asked that deployment of ADD’s be subject to their approval via planning
condition. Only in extreme circumstances would resort be made to the shooting of
seals under government licence. The applicants already hold a Seal Management
Licence for their 9 sites on the west coast, including Ardmaddy North, to which they
would request this proposed site by way of an addition in the event that planning
permission is granted. During 2012 one seal was shot in connection with the
applicant’s farm at Ardmaddy North.

Scottish Natural Heritage has not raised objection to the proposal on the grounds of
unacceptable consequences for potential predators or impacts on non-target wildlife.

Interaction with Wild Salmonids:

Farming of salmon in the marine environment can give rise to well-known

consequences for wild fish as a result of disease transmission, sea lice propagation
and escapes which can lead to competition and inter-breeding, with consequences for
the genetic dilution of native wild stocks. The potential for escapes (as with predator
control) can be reduced by having an equipment specification determined by site
specific wave and climate analysis so as to ensure that it is fit for purpose. An
associated inspection and maintenance regime is then required to ensure on-going
containment integrity. Predator control plans, and escapes contingency plans, as
submitted by the applicant, are also important elements in risk management.

Although containment risks can be managed, they cannot however be eradicated and
there remains a residual risk that an unforeseen event can propagate escaped farmed
fish in large numbers into the uncontrolled marine environment. Escapes of farmed
stock are generally low, but can occur through equipment failure, predation, operator
error, severe weather or foul play. By adherence to the SSPO ‘Code of Good Practice
Guidelines’ the applicant seeks to minimise this residual risk as far as is practicable.
Likewise, via good husbandry practices, regular inspection and the administration of
medicines in accordance with veterinary health plans, outbreaks of disease which
could have consequences for wild fish can be managed.

The most intractable issue influencing the interaction between farmed salmon and wild
fish species is that of sea lice transmission. Farmed fish are routinely hosts to parasitic
sea lice, the numbers of which require to be controlled in order to assure the health of
farmed fish and to avoid lice propagation into surrounding waters. Wild salmon can be
exposed to sea lice from fish farms close to salmon rivers during their migration
periods, whilst sea trout tend to remain in coastal waters throughout the year, so are
potentially at greater risk. In this case there are no major wild salmon fisheries within
15km of the site.

The applicant proposes to control sea lice in accordance with current industry practice,
via the use of in-feed treatments and well-boat administered bath treatments, whilst
adopting good management practices such as single year stocking and synchronous
stocking, fallowing and lice treatment with other sites within the Lower Lorn Farm
Management Agreement. All sea lice bath treatments are intended to be carried out on
board well-boats (rather than the more traditional method of net shallowing) which is a
superior method, in terms of control over exposure time and dosage to ensure the
effectiveness of those treatments. It also enables more than 50% reduction in the use
of chemotherapeutants over treatment administered within cages. The applicants are
also trialling the use of wrasse as a means of biological control over sea lice hosted on
farmed salmon, which again presents opportunity to reduce the administration of
chemical controls. .
However effective the control measures are in practice, it is an inevitable consequence
of holding fish in such quantities that significant numbers of sea lice will be propagated
from the site. How these are dispersed will depend on local factors such as wind
direction and residual current. The distribution of farm derived lice in the marine
environment is not well understood although it is known that in favourable conditions
they can travel considerable distances from source.

In addition to sea lice propagation, failure of containment can lead to escapes which
pose a threat to wild fish due to competition or through breeding. The applicants
consider that their tensioned net systems are appropriately specified so as to be fit for
purpose at the site and that they are accompanied by appropriate management
measures and predator control arrangements to minimise the prospect of escape
events. None of the applicant’s fish farm sites in Argyll have to date been the subject of
mass escapes.

The conclusion of the applicant’s supporting information is that the site will not
prejudice wild fish interests. The applicants have stated that they have not had sea lice
problems with the existing site at Ardmaddy North and sea lice treatment already
consented by SEPA is suitable to allow efficacious treatment of lice populations at this
enlarged site in accordance with recognised standards.

Neither Marine Scotland nor SNH have objected to the proposal on the grounds of the
threat posed to wild salmonids. The District Salmon Fishery Board have not objected
subject to removal of the existing site, but have expressed their preference for the site
to operate on the basis of reduced biomass in order for effective treatment to be
demonstrated. Given the capital investment in an enlarged facility such as this, a
conditional obligation for under-stocking would not be a reasonable planning
requirement.

Impact upon Species and Habitats of Nature Conservation Importance:

No species or habitats of nature conservation importance were identified by the

applicant’s submitted seabed survey within the predicted depositional footprint of the
proposed farm. The presence of white cluster anemone (a Priority Marine Feature)
150m north of SPA’s Allowable Zone of Effect (AZE) has been pointed out by the
Scottish Wildlife Trust. This has been accounted for by SNH in their response to
SEPA’s CAR licence consultation, with the view being expressed that whilst localised
changes to the structure of the colony may occur as a result of the operation of the
farm, these are unlikely to affect the long-term viability of the species at this location or
its overall conservation status in the context of north Argyll.

There are no nature conservation designated sites (SSSI’s or SAC’s) in the immediate
vicinity of the proposed farm, although it does lie within a Marine Consultation Area
defined by Scottish Natural Heritage in view of the overall quality of the marine
environment. The closest designated site is the Firth of Lorn SAC to the west of Cuan
Sound and the Isle of Luing identified for its rocky reef habitat. The SAC covers open
water to the west of Seil and Luing and waters around Scarba and to the north of Jura,
but excludes the more enclosed waters of Seil Sound, Shuna Sound and Loch Melfort.
A map of the designated area appears in the ‘appropriate assessment’ at Appendix B.

Covering an area of approx. 210km2 the Firth of Lorn SAC has been designated for its
rocky reef habitats which support an exceptional marine biodiversity, with associated
communities and species which are amongst the most diverse in both the UK and
Europe. Conservation objectives for the SAC are to avoid deterioration in the qualifying
interest (rocky reefs) thereby ensuring that the integrity of the designation is
maintained. Although at a distance from the designated SAC, there may be potential
 for the proposed development to affect the designated area by means of the deposition
of organic waste and by chemotherapeutants transported into the designated area by
tidal currents. The proposed fish farm has the potential to affect qualifying interests in a
number of ways. Firstly, from smothering as a result of the transport and deposition of
solids; secondly, due to toxicity from the exported residues of chemical treatments; and
thirdly, from the cumulative impact of the development with other sites within
influencing distance of the SAC.

Where a development has the potential to give rise to significant effects upon the
qualifying interests of a European Natura designation, the ‘competent authority’
considering the merits of any development proposal within, or within influencing
distance of, the designated area is required to undertake ‘appropriate assessment’, if it
considers that it presents the possibility of significant environmental effects upon that
designation. Where a likely significant effect is anticipated, development may only
proceed if the ‘appropriate assessment’ concludes beyond ‘reasonable scientific doubt’
that the integrity of the SAC will not be compromised. In all other circumstances to
satisfy the requirements of the Habitats Directive, permission must be refused (other
than in the specifically excepted cases where no alternatives exist, or there are
imperative reasons of overriding public interest for development to proceed).

Interaction between the site and the SAC designation in terms of the transport of
organic waste and chemotherapeutants has been reviewed by SEPA by way of a
Habitats regulations ‘appropriate assessment’ in association with their CAR licence
process. An ‘appropriate assessment’ on behalf of the Planning Authority drawing
heavily upon the conclusions reached by SEPA, can be found at Appendix B to this
report. In reaching its own conclusions as set out in that appendix, the Council has
consulted both with SEPA and SNH for their views on the matter. Dispersal modelling
accepted by SEPA indicates that solids and in-feed chemical residues will be
predominantly exported via Cuan Sound into a dispersive environment where
additional amounts will not be such as to breach Environmental Quality Standards
(EQS) set by SEPA, or to compromise the conservation objectives of the SAC.

The Planning Authority’s ‘appropriate assessment’ has considered the likely

environmental effects upon habitats and species associated with the SAC and has
concluded that the proposal both in isolation, and in combination with other consented
sites, will not have an adverse effect on the integrity of the site, in the light of its
conservation objectives.

Scottish Natural Heritage has not raised objection to the planning application or the
SEPA CAR licence on the grounds of unacceptable consequences for marine
mammals, otters, the priority marine feature ‘white cluster anemone’ or the qualifying
reef habitat of the SAC

Conclusion

The proposal is considered consistent with Local Plan Policy LP AQUA 1 (5 and 12)
and other relevant development plan policies insofar as it would not significantly
prejudice water quality and associated biodiversity interests.

C. Landscape/Seascape Character

The application site lies inshore in a relatively remote location off the west facing coast
of the Degnish peninsula. From the land the site would be visible from the west facing
slopes above the coast, but there is no road access to this area, no overlooking
habitation and little public access appears taken to this area other than for the path
between Loch Melfort and Ardmaddy which is set well back from the coastline behind
the high ground overlooking the site. The opposing coast is formed by the eastern side
of the small island of Torsa. There is no habitation on the east facing coast of the
island, and there are unlikely to be few sensitive receptors affected. The site would be
visible, but at a distance in excess of 2km, from a handful of isolated properties to the
north-west on the Isle of Seil, which can be found close to the coast and to the south of
Balvicar. There will be some limited visibility from the land either side of the Cuan Ferry
but remaining visibility from Luing would be from the largely unpopulated east coast,
other than for long distance visibility, end on to the site, from Toberonochy at over 5km
away. The existing site at Ardmaddy North lies closer to the closest properties south of
Balvicar than the location of the proposed site, which lies at an increased distance from
any habitation. Any disbenefit arising from the enlarged site, including the additional
impact of a feed barge would be largely offset by the removal of the existing equipment
closer to Seil. Both the existing fish farm at Ardmaddy North and the proposed site lie
adjacent to areas designated as ‘sensitive countryside’ and ‘Areas of Panoramic
Quality’ by the adopted local plan, so share the same development plan context.

The ‘Area of Panoramic Quality’ accords the locality a scenic designation of regional
status. The provisions of Policies STRAT DC 8 and LP ENV 10 seek to resist
development which is considered to have a significant adverse impact upon the key
landscape characteristics of these designations. Both the mainland and the islands
either side of Seil Sound are identified as falling within the ‘Craggy Coast and Islands’
landscape character type, identified by Scottish Natural Heritage as having a small
scale diverse topography within a distinct seascape context which provides a unifying
element. The more inaccessible sections of coast exhibit a sense of isolation and
naturalness which is less apparent on the more inhabited stretches of coast. The APQ
recognises the panoramic value of the seascape and the views to and from the islands.

The intended location lies close inshore and parallel to the coast, where it would benefit
from a dark coloured and elevated landscape backdrop, whilst the equipment is low-
lying and to be finished in a recessive colour. This meets with SNH good practice
guidance on the location and design of marine aquaculture development. Most
terrestrial receptors (roads, transport routes, frequented public locations) would be at a
significant distance from the equipment which would not assume importance in its
landscape setting when appreciated from such locations. The lack of access being
routinely taken to the isolated stretch of coast on the mainland immediately above the
site is such that there will be few receptors taking closer quarter views down into the
equipment.

The primary effect upon the perception of the landscape/seascape of Seil Sound will be
in terms of those transiting the Sound by boat. Seil Sound is a body of enclosed water
which is frequented by recreational boat traffic and a recognised cruising route. Yachts,
tour boats and kayaks currently pass the existing site at Ardmaddy North, so their
experience of the Sound is already influenced by the presence of aquaculture
equipment. Although the proposed site is larger in extent and the Sound is narrower in
the vicinity of the proposed site, there will be a small reduction in the aggregate surface
area of the equipment and the round cages proposed are less visually intrusive that the
existing square cages, which form a more compromising block with less intervening
water. Whilst a feed barge is proposed, and this is an additional element not present at
Ardmaddy North, the applicants have reduced the scale of that proposed significantly in
order to limit the impact of this structure. Feed barges are now an almost standard
requirement in the servicing of modern marine fish farm operations and it would be
unrealistic to expect a site of this nature not to include one. Provided that the model
selected is finished in a recessive colour it will not be an unacceptable element of the
development.
 The proposal would also remove the prospect of the existing shellfish lease being
taken up for the siting of mussel rafts on the application site. The removal of the
equipment form Ardmaddy North in favour of the proposed development would mean
that there would still be one fish farm to be passed by boat traffic at the southern end of
the Sound. Despite the revised location and the altered appearance of the equipment,
there would be overall little change in the perception and the appreciation of
landscape/seascape from the water, with aquaculture retaining a presence in the
locality by way of a single finfish farm, well removed from the next closest aquaculture
site, so that cumulative impact does not become unacceptable in landscape or visual
terms.

Scottish Natural Heritage are of the opinion that the landscape and visual effects of the
development will be localised. Whilst it has been suggested that the impact of the feed
barge could be reduced by repositioning it to the southern end of the site, where it
would benefit from screening by the higher part of the island of Torsa, the applicants do
not consider this to be desirable operationally as their practice is to site barges on the
less exposed ends of sites, where in the event of storm damage, the threat to the
integrity of the cage group is less. The applicant’s response has been to downsize the
scale of the intended barge in its originally proposed location as an alternative means
of addressing this suggestion.

Conclusion

The proposal complies with Local Plan Policy LP AQUA 1 (2 and 4) and other relevant
development plan policies insofar as it would not significantly prejudice landscape
character, visual amenity or designated areas of scenic quality. In view of the absence
of other aquaculture in the immediate locality, and the intention to remove equipment
from the existing site at Ardmaddy North in the event that permission is granted, the
development does not present any cumulative impact issues of concern.

D. Other Marine Users

The development of the proposed site would entail the relinquishment of the existing
Crown Estate lease for the fish farm site at Ardmaddy North. This would release new
ground for inshore creel fishing once the seabed has had opportunity to recover from
the presence of an operational farm. The Sound is not used for trawling. Although the
Clyde Fishermen’s Association has objected to the development their objections tend
to be founded around the growth of the aquaculture sector in general and the perceived
unsustainability of the industry rather than upon specific shortcomings associated with
the location of the application site or the details of the proposal.

The proposed site is located in a narrower section of the Sound than the current site
and the proposed mooring area extends further out into the Sound than the area which
is the subject of the current Crown Estate shellfish lease area. Despite that, the
equipment is to be located close inshore to the east of existing navigational and RYA
cruising routes, which will ensure that the surface equipment and the associated
moorings do not impinge upon access into and out of the south of the Sound by boat.
Navigational implications of the development will be considered separately by Marine
Scotland under the marine licencing procedure. It should be borne in mind that whilst
the seabed foot print of the mooring area is extensive at 580m x 310m, around a third
of the seaward end of the mooring lines will be on the seabed rising up to the cage
mooring grid which is supported by riser buoys 8m out from the cages. Therefore
navigation relatively close to the cage group is possible, and indeed the installation has
been designed to afford sufficient draught for a large well boat to service the farm and
for workboats to come alongside the cages.
 Conclusion

The proposal complies with Local Plan Policy LP AQUA 1 (6 and 11) and other relevant
development plan policies insofar as it would not significantly prejudice navigation and
the continued exploitation of traditional fishing ground.

E. Noise

Noise associated with the development will arise from the operation of workboats and
other vessels associated with the fish farm, plus noise from the generator within the
concrete feed barge. Given the absence of local habitation or other sensitive receptors,
and the transient nature of other boat traffic, this will not present a problem in terms of
the operation of the site. The applicants already utilise the type of feed barge intended
to be employed at this site and experience of that in operation is such that it is evident
that generator noise will not pose a threat to amenity.

F. Transport

As with the existing site at Ardmaddy North, there will be no need for access to the
locality of the site by road. Servicing and deliveries will be undertaken by boat from the
applicant’s existing shore base in Loch Craignish. Personnel will take access by small
boat from an existing facility adjoining the marina at Craobh Haven. Stocking and
harvesting of fish, and treatment of sea lice, will take place by larger vessels.

G. Conclusion

The proposal has given rise to considerable public objection. Concerns have been
expressed by 3rd parties in terms of pollution of the water environment, impact upon
habitats and species, and in view of the presence of the equipment in terms of
landscape character, navigating interests and the experience of those transiting the
Sound by boat. The extent of the issues raised regarding pollution and the extent of its
suggested consequences for nature conservation prompted the application being held
in abeyance for some considerable time, in order to afford the applicant opportunity to
address these matters and for them to be assessed in detail by SEPA. Given that
pollution issues are largely the remit of SEPA, and having regard to the government
position that Planning Authorities should not seek to duplicate other regulatory regimes,
it is inappropriate that those matters which are properly the responsibility of SEPA
should be revisited as part of this application.

Of those other matters which fall within the remit of the Planning Authority none have
been identified which point to the need to withhold planning consent. The proposal is,
in part, a relocation of an existing site, and also an enlargement of production capacity.
It enables the removal of first generation equipment and the use of more modern
techniques in a site which is better flushed and which presents opportunity to hold
increased biomass without breaching SEPA’s environmental quality standards. It would
maintain a single presence of aquaculture development at the southern end of the
Sound and would enable an increase in production capacity without seriously
prejudicing any of the considerations which are material to the determination of the
application. In those circumstances it can be considered to be compliant with Local
Plan Policy LP AQUA 1 and other relevant development plan policies, and there are no
other material considerations identified of such magnitude as to warrant other than
planning permission being granted in conformity with development plan policy.
 APPENDIX 11/1066/MFF: NAMES & ADDRESSES OF REPRESENTEES

OBJECTORS:

Miss Samantha Croll 0/1 11 Barrington Drive

Glasgow
G4 9DS 31/07/2011 O
Martin McNally 0/2 6 Roness Drive
Glasgow
G52 1HB 12/09/2011 O
Mr William Todd 0/2 Flat
61 Fergus Drive
Glasgow
G20 6AH 23/11/2011 O
Mr Terence Hollis 1 Cairns Place
1 Cairns Place
Dollar
FK14 7LH 18/07/2011 O
Andrea Jack 1 Cedar Grove
Cardross
Dumbartonshire
G84 5JW 01/08/2011 O
Mr Stephen Jowett 1 Church Road
Altofts
Normanton
Wakefield
WF6 2NN 18/07/2011 O
Dr Douglas Wilcox 1 Colonsay Drive
Newton Mearns
Glasgow
G77 6TY 07/09/2011 O
Mr Richard Bath 1 East Hermitage Place
Edinburgh
EH6 8AA 18/07/2011 O
Mr Oliver Jay 1 Felkington Farm Cottages
Berwick Upon Tweed
TD15 2NR 07/09/2011 O
Mr Stephen Milner 1 High Street
Eydon
Northamptonshire
NN11 3PP 20/07/2011 O
Mr Richard Wesley 1 Kilbrandon Cottages
Balvicar
Oban
PA34 4RA 20/07/2011 O
C Jade 1 Mahonia Drive
Langdon Halls
Basildon
Essex
SS16 6SD 05/08/2011 O
Mrs Susan Clarke 1 Mc Calls Terrace
Oban
PA34 4JE 21/07/2011 O
Rosanna Salter 1 Rock Farm Cottage
Nettlestead
Maidstone
Kent
ME18 5HT 22/08/2011 O
Hugo Salter 1 Rock Farm Cottages
Gibbs Hill
Nettlestead
Maidstone
Kent
ME18 5HT 22/08/2011 O
Monica Patnain 1 Sophia Square
London 03/08/2011 O
 SE16 5XL
Mr Keith Morris 1 West View
Church Road
Grange over Sands
LA11 7RB 26/07/2011 O
Mrs Deborah Chopping 10 Burywick
Harpenden
AL52AE 25/07/2011 O
Mrs Rita Summers 10 Napier Road
Monton
Eccles
Salford
M30 8AG 22/07/2011 O
Kay Griffin 10 Roseworth Crescent
Newcastle
NE3 1NR 12/09/2011 O
Nathan And Nicola Brown 10 St Marys Close
Roughton
Norfolk
NR11 8QF 03/08/2011 O
David Maseska 1000 Chestnut Drive
Longmount
Colorado
USA
80503 03/08/2011 O
Kristen Maseska 1000 Chestnut Drive
Longmount
Colorado
USA
80503 03/08/2011 O
Judy Murphy 101 Flatford Place
Kidlington
Oxford
OX5 1TG 30/09/2011 O
Dr Anthony Beck 102 Potovens Lane
Wakefield
WF1 2LQ 06/09/2011 O
Mr Juan Rodriguez Dominguez 105 Dewi Clos Saint
Cardiff
CF11 9EX 19/07/2011 O
Dr Stella Pytharouli 107 Rottenrow
Glasgow
G40NG 19/07/2011 O
Carole Thomas 108 Eaton Road
Appleton
Abingdon
Oxon
OX13 5JJ 30/09/2011 O
Alex Dimopoulos 109 Cleveland Road
North Sheilds
Tyne And Weir 19/08/2011 O
B A Laroult 109 Cleveland Road
North Sheilds
Tyne And Weir 16/08/2011 O
J A Lamont 109 Cleveland Road
North Sheilds
Tyne And Weir
NW29 0PF 16/08/2011 O
Morven Hughes 109 Cranbrook Road
Bristol
BS6 7DA 01/09/2011 O
Mrs Dorothy Kisielewski 10Allanbank Road
Kinbuck
Dunblane
FK15 0NH 18/07/2011 O
Mr And Mrs P Hires 11 Balvicar
Isle Of Seil
Oban
ARGYLL 01/08/2011 O
 PA34 4TF
Dr Tony Bennett 11 Cairnbaan Cottages
Cairnbaan
Lochgilphead
PA31 8SJ 28/07/2011 O
Ms Jill Watkins 11 Church Lane
Walthamstow Village
London
E17 9RN 20/07/2011 O
Mr Angus Morrison 11 Coolin Drive
Portree
IV51 9DN 21/07/2011 O
Jean L Alexander 11 Cullipool Village
Isle Of Luing
By Oban
PA34 4UB 04/08/2011 O
Miss Kathleen Cowie 11 Donmouth Road
Aberdeen
AB23 8DT 02/08/2011 O
Mrs Vivienne Merrick 11 Eldridge Close
Pendeford
Wolverhampton
WV9 5PX 18/07/2011 O
Tim Wray 11 Hoole Road
Broomhill
Sheffield
S10 5BH 03/08/2011 O
Mrs Alison Wray 11 Hoole Road
Sheffield
S10 5BH 01/08/2011 O
Mr Cliff Pearn 11 Oak Apple Close
Saltash
Cornwall 19/07/2011 O
Miss Rachel Godden 11 Scotland Hill
Sandhurst
GU47 8JR 14/07/2011 O
Robert Godden 11 Scotland Hill
Sandhurst
Berks
GU47 8JR 16/08/2011 O
S Goridge And S Eldnoye 11 St Aethans Drive
Burfhead
Moray
IV30 5GP 03/08/2011 O
Dr Kate Dunn 11 Woolliscroft Ave
Newcastle
ST5 0NR 02/08/2011 O
Mr John Whitley 111 Divinity Road
Oxford
OX4 1LW 18/07/2011 O
Mr Robin Gallamore 112 Derby Road
Melbourne
Derby
DE73 8FL 03/08/2011 O
J Currie 115 Town Way West
Towyn
LL22 9LF 12/09/2011 O
Mr Fraser Robertson 1173 Gallowgate
Glasgow
G31 4EG 03/08/2011 O
Sheila Brook 11A Hazelmore Avenue
Newcastle Upon Tyne
NE3 5QL 05/08/2011 O
David Brook 11A Hazelnut Avenue
Newcastle Upon Tyne
NE3 5QL 22/08/2011 O
Mr Adrian Lough 12 Dundrenann Cottages
Edinburgh
EH16 5RG 06/09/2011 O
Dr Fiona Lough 12 Dundrennan Cottages
Edinburgh
EH16 5RG 03/10/2011 O
Mrs Helen Butland 12 Forde Close
Newton Abbot
TQ12 5NN 17/07/2011 O
L Bradshaw 12 Maida Grove
Fulford Road
York
YO10 4EU 16/08/2011 O
Mr Robert Ferguson 12 Polmont Road
Laurieston
Falkirk
FK2 9QY 07/08/2011 O
Jean Rhoades 12 The Greens
Glencruitten Road
Oban
Argyll
PA34 4DD 16/09/2011 O
Andrea Sturniolo 125 Clarence Road
London
E5 8EE 01/09/2011 O
Miss Pamela Mcleish 1-29 Esplanade Court
Corran Esplanade
Oban
PA34 5PW 21/07/2011 O
Miss Nicola Simmons 13 Broadwater Gardens
Orpington
BR6 7UQ 18/07/2011 O
Mrs Jackie Simmons 13 Broadwater Gardens
Orpington
BR6 7UQ 18/07/2011 O
Mrs Dawn Crowe 13 Roselea Drive
Glasgow
G62 8HE 26/07/2011 O
Mr David Rillie 13 Wanless Court
Musselburgh
EH21 7QU 19/07/2011 O
Mr Tom Gallagher 13, Moor Rd
Cartland
Lanark
ML117RE 24/07/2011 O
Mrs Alison Tamea 133 Seaton Road
Hemel Hempstead
HP3 9HU 19/07/2011 O
Mr Hug Kerr 14 Brierie Aveonue
Crosslee
Johnstone
PA6 7BQ 12/09/2011 O
Ms Christine Page 14 Brucehaven Road
Limekilns
Dunfermline
KY11 3HZ 08/09/2011 O
S Teefer 14 Cnoc A Challtuinn
Clachan Seil
By Oban
Argyll
PA34 4TR 03/08/2011 O
Diane McVeigh 14 Tor Close
Waterlooville
Hampshire
PO7 8SU 12/09/2011 O
Mr Paul Stanier 14, Collinbourne Close
Trentham
Stoke-on-Trent
ST4 8GU 03/08/2011 O
Ms. Franka Leehr 14/8 Roseneath Place
Edinburgh
EH9 1JB 18/07/2011 O
Mr Stephen Miller 143 Craig Street
Darlington
DL3 6H 17/07/2011 O
Name Illegible 144 Bewdley Hill
DY11 6BT 26/08/2011 O
Neil Weddell 147 Riverstone Way
Northampton
NN4 9QW 16/08/2011 O
Dr Inglis Lamont 148 Sinclair Street
Helensburgh
G84 9AT 21/07/2011 O
Susan Wharton 15 Balvicar
Seil Island
Oban
Argyll
PA34 4TF 03/08/2011 O
Miss Pamela Ocampo 15 Bruce Road
Glasgow
G41 5EN 18/07/2011 O
Sheila Urquhart 15 Geils Avenue
Dumbarton
G82 2QJ 25/07/2011 O
Mrs Kim Morgan 15 Hutton Avenue
Hartlepool
TS26 9PW 17/07/2011 O
A Dechmilemot 15 Parker Streeet
Dundee
UK
DD1 5RZ 03/08/2011 O
Miss Rosanna Forbes 15 Randolph Crescent
Edinburgh
EH2 7TT 18/07/2011 O
Jenny Underwood 15 Thornhill Terrace
Sunderland
SR2 7JL 20/10/2011 O
Mrs Maggie Bowie 15 Victoria Street
Alloa
FK10 2DZ 19/07/2011 O
MR Mark Patton 15 Waincliffe Crescent
15 Waincliffe Crescent
Leeds
LS11 8EU 18/07/2011 O
Miss Seonaid Reid 15/1 Orchard Brae Gardens
Edinburgh
EH4 2HQ 26/07/2011 O
Mr David Robinson 154 Belper Lane
Belper
Derbyshire
DE56 2UJ 23/07/2011 O
Ian Whyte 16 Combie Court
Glencruitten Road
Oban
Argyll And Bute
PA34 4BY 26/07/2011 O
Mr Trevor Taylor 16 Fairway Gardens
Pendine Park
Gwersyllt
LL11 4XB 18/07/2011 O
J Walford 16 Fife Road
Darlington
DL3 7SY 05/08/2011 O
Pauline McCluskey 16 Rivermead Road
Exeter
EX2 4RL 05/08/2011 O
Mr Jock Souter 16 Tinto Drive
Cumbernauld
G68 9BF 19/07/2011 O
Mt Tony Walsh 16, Eagle Terrace
Woodford Green IG8 9AT 16/08/2011 O
Miss Kirsty Dunn 16/3 Chancelot Terrace
Edinburgh
EH6 4SS 18/07/2011 O
Mr Timothy Elliott 16/3 Chancelot Terrace
Edinburgh
EH6 4SS 18/07/2011 O
Miss Kristine Bird 17 Bouverie Street
Flat 3/3
Glasgow
G14 0PD 20/07/2011 O
Ian Poyner 17 Fir Grove
Whitehill
Bordon
Hants
GU35 9ED 12/09/2011 O
Professor Jeremy Cresswell 17 Kestrel Road
Newburgh
Ellon
AB41 6FF 07/01/2012 O
Miss Caroline Warburton 17 Landel Street
Markinch
KY7 6AG 25/07/2011 O
Mr Martyn Tunstall 17 North Gyle Park
Edinburgh
EH12 8LE 05/09/2011 O
Jill And Brian Hallett 17 Strone Close
Botley
Oxford
EX2 9SQ 30/09/2011 O
Ms Deanna Austin-Crowe 17 Townend Cresc
Stoke Goldington
Bucks
MK168NU 03/08/2011 O
Mr James Doonan 170 Beeches Road
Clydebank
G81 6JH 24/07/2011 O
Mary Doonan 170 Beeches Road
Clydebank
G81 6JH 03/08/2011 O
Mr Stephen Hines 174B Iverson Road
London
NW6 2HL 17/07/2011 O
Mr Matthew Mercer 175 West Point
Wellington Street
Leeds
LS1 4JL 18/07/2011 O
Viktor Bale 18 Harvester Close
Greenleys
Milton Keynes
MK12 6LE 12/09/2011 O
Ms Pamela Harrison 18 Leslie Road
Dorking
RH4 1PS 18/07/2011 O
J Carr 18 Main Street
Lambley
Nottingham
NG4 4PN 22/08/2011 O
Mr Gary Henshaw 18 Queens Avenue
Ilkeston
DE7 4DL 18/07/2011 O
L G Speers 18 Scaribrick Close
Maghull
Merseyside
L31 9PG 02/09/2011 O
J Speers 18 Scarisbrick Close
Maghull
Merseyside
L31 9PE
01/09/2011 O
Sandra Speers 18 Scarisbrick Close
Maghull
Merseyside
L31 9PE 01/09/2011 O
Brain Heaton 18 Toberonochy Village
Oban
Argyll
PA34 4UE 01/08/2011 O
Mr Charlie Fayers 18 Villiers Lane
Oxford
OX4 4HY 16/07/2011 O
Mr. David Llewelyn 183 Churchill Drive
Glasgow
G11 7EY 09/08/2011 O
Mrs Ruth Llewelyn 183 Churchill Drive
Glasgow
G11 7EY 09/08/2011 O
Graham Sparshott 19 Inverewe Place
Dunfermline
Fife
KY11 8FH 16/08/2011 O
Carina Sparshott 19 Inverewe Place
Dunfermline
Fife
KY11 8FH 16/08/2011 O
Miss Christine Birch 19 Queensway
Sunbury On Thames
TW16 6HA 20/07/2011 O
Pat Leach 19 Toberonochy
Oban
Argyll
PA34 4UE 03/08/2011 O
Mr John Planck 19 Wheal Regent Park,
Carlyon Bay
St Austell
PL25 3SP 19/07/2011 O
L MacDonald 192 Cedar Drive
Perth
PH1 1RJ 26/08/2011 O
Neil MacDonald 192 Cedar Drive
Perth
PH1 1RJ 26/08/2011 O
Jan Veale 1A Girdlestone Road
Headington
Oxford
OX3 7LZ 30/09/2011 O
Alex Gibson 1A Girdlestone Road
Oxford
OX3 7LZ 30/09/2011 O
Nigel Scriven 2 Alt Na Blathaich
Loch Eck
Dunoon
Argyll
PA23 8SG 25/07/2011 O
Miss Wendy Underwood 2 Brandon Road
Wordwell
Bury St. Edmunds
IP286UL 03/08/2011 O
Miss Joanne Millett 2 Bryn Road South
Ashton In Makerfield
Wigan
WN4 8QR 18/07/2011 O
Mrs Alison Laurie 2 Corum Place
Blackford
Auchterarder 12/10/2011 O
Miss Diane Elliott 2 Cruachan Buildings
Lochawe
Dalmally
PA33 1AJ 19/07/2011 O
Ms Fiona Maguire 2 Cuddy Lane
Edinburgh
EH10 4TQ 09/09/2011 O
Mrs Mary Williams 2 Dewberry Close
Stourport on Severn
DY13 8TB 19/07/2011 O
Ms Myra Kinghorn 2 Ely Close
Crawley
RH10 5JL 18/07/2011 O
Elaine Plenderleith And Hugh 2 Fyne Road
Plenderleith Broughty Ferry
Dundee
DD5 3JF 16/08/2011 O
Greg Walton 2 Great Calcroft
Pershore
Worcestershire 03/08/2011 O
Joshua J Walton 2 Great Calcroft
Pershore
Worcestershire
WR10 1QS 03/08/2011 O
Sam Walton 2 Great Calcroft
Pershore
Worcs
WR10 1QS 03/08/2011 O
Mrs Myra Waddell 2 Kilbrandon Cottages
Balvicar
Seil
PA34 4RA 03/08/2011 O
Mr Martin Waddell 2 Kilbrandon Cottages
Balvicar, Isle of Seil
PA34 4RA 03/08/2011 O
Mr Neal Setterington 2 Kirklands Villas
Baildon
D176HJ 03/02/2013 O
Miss Mary Watson 2 Magdala Mews
Edinburgh
EH12 5BX 25/07/2011 O
Mr Charlie Hussey 2 Magdala Mews
Edinburgh
EH12 5BX 25/07/2011 O
Ms Belinda Magee 2 Mount Hey
Somerton
TA11 7PG 19/07/2011 O
Mrs Elizabeth Minton 2 New Hall
Bouth
Ulverston
LA128JJ 18/07/2011 O
Mrs Sarah Bealey 2 St Georges Cottages
South End, Damerham
Fordingbridge
SP6 3HP 18/07/2011 O
Miss Shirley Robson 2 St Pancras Close
Dinnington
Sheffield
S25 3RX 10/09/2011 O
Mr Christopher Ashley 2 Yew Tree Villas
Hare Lane
chester
CH3 7EG 29/07/2011 O
Mrs Caragh Ashley 2 Yew Tree Villas
Hare Lane, Pipers Ash
Chester
CH3 7EG 29/07/2011 O
Ms Helen Jones 2, Kirkhill Court
Broxburn
EH52 6HS 03/10/2011 O
V Robinson 2/1 4 Craiglea Drive
Edinburgh
EH10 5PA 16/08/2011 O
Mr Ben Byrne 2/1 46 Bentinck Street
Glasgow
G3 7TT 18/07/2011 O
Mrs Gail Mackay 2/3 North Leith Mill
Edinburgh
EH6 6JY 24/07/2011 O
Mr Andrew McWilliams 20 Church Street
Ainsworth
Bolton
BL2 5RT 18/07/2011 O
mrs Susan Johnston 20 Creag Bhan Village
Oban
pa34 4bf 23/07/2011 O
Mrs Elaine Telfer 20 Davies Drive
Alexandria
G83 0UH 20/07/2011 O
Ms Ronnie Mcleod 20 Ferryfield Gardens
Alexandria
Dunbartonshire
G83 0TB 28/07/2011 O
Mr And Mrs Kitson 20 Hunters Grove
Hunters Quay
Dunoon
Argyll
PA23 8LQ 12/09/2011 O
Mr Michael Whitley 2001 Route De Corps
Saint Martin D'Uriage
38410 19/07/2011 O
Mrs. Sheila Costigan 201 Crook Ave.
La Grande OR, USA
97850 20/07/2011 O
Dr Bandana Malhotra 205 Clarence Lane
London
SW15 5PZ 01/08/2011 O
Miss Sudeshna Choudhury 205 Clarence Lane
London
SW15 5PZ 26/07/2011 O
Mrs Dplali Choudhury 205 Clarence Lane
London
SW15 5PZ 27/07/2011 O
Mr Jamie Inglis 21 Aird's Crescent
Argyll Square
Oban
PA34 5SJ 31/08/2011 O
Mrs Emma Inglis 21 Aird's Crescent
Argyll Square
Oban
PA34 5SJ 31/08/2011 O
Master Hamish Inglis 21 Airds Crescent
Oban
PA355SJ 31/08/2011 O
Jeremy Inglis 21 Airds Crescent
Oban
Argyll
PA34 12/08/2011 O
Ms Katrin Josepeit 21 Aird's Crescent
Oban
PA34 5SJ 11/08/2011 O
Mr Robbie Wightman 21 Clifford Road
North Berwick
EH39 4PW 26/07/2011 O
Mrs. Deborah Mcdonald 21 Lindisfarne Road,
Newcastle upon Tyne
Newcastle upon Tyne
NE2 2HE 03/08/2011 O
B A Fothyill 21 Weald Close
Brentwood
Essex
CM14 4QV 05/08/2011 O
Paul Beckett 21 Weald Close
Brentwood
Essex
CM14 4QV 05/08/2011 O
Phillip Gate 21/5 Steads Place
Edinburgh
EH6 5DY 12/09/2011 O
Alan Hinchliffe 210 Rainhill Road
Rainhill
Merseyside
L35 4LD 16/08/2011 O
Laura Hinchliffe 210 Rainhill Road
Rainhill
Merseyside
L35 4LD 16/08/2011 O
Mr Bill Gray 22 Branziert Road North
Killearn
G63 9RF 07/09/2011 O
Ms Dawn Kelly 22 Cell Barnes Lane
St. Albans
AL1 5RA 27/07/2011 O
Dr Alan McLelland 22 Corlic Way
Kilmacolm
PA13 4JD 18/07/2011 O
Birgit Whitmore 22 Cullipool
Luing
PA34 4UB 03/08/2011 O
Mr Alastair Currie 22 Edinburgh Road
Biggar
ML12 6AX 28/01/2013 O
Mr Justin Williams 22 Embleton Road
Lewisham
London
SE13 7DH 18/07/2011 O
Miss Patricia Hughes 22 Hazel Road
Bradmore
Wolverhampton
WV3 7HB 18/07/2011 O
Mrs Julie Keetley 22 Iona Drive
Trowell
Nottingham
NG9 3RF 19/07/2011 O
Name Illegible 22 Neville Crescent
Acton
Wrexham
LL12 7HE 25/08/2011 O
Alex Wellbelove 220 Tonbridge Road
Wateringbury
Maidstone
Kent
ME18 5NX 22/08/2011 O
Mr Jim Anderson 224 High Street
Linlithgow
EH49 7ES 18/07/2011 O
Mr David Burns 23 Clive Rd, Highcliffe
23 Clive Rd
Christchurch
BH23 4NX 18/07/2011 O
Ms Wendy Axford 23 Clive Road
Highcliffe
Christchurch
BH23 4NX 18/07/2011 O
R Farrell 23 Foulsykes Road
Cambusnethan
Wishaw 03/08/2011 O
Mrs Joanne Davenport 23 Kingsmuir Avenue
Preston
PR2 6AG 21/07/2011 O
Mrs Victoria Colville 24 Mill Cottage Park
Newtownards
BT22 2FF 18/07/2011 O
E Vincent 24 Preston Avenue
ME30 2BS 16/08/2011 O
Catherine Vincent 24 Preston Avenue
North Sheilds
Tyne And Weir
NE30 2BS 16/08/2011 O
Emma Nicole Vincent 24 Preston Avenue
North Sheilds
Tyne And Weir
NE30 2BS 16/08/2011 O
Lucy Gladden 24 The Larches
Faversham
Kent
ME13 7SQ 05/08/2011 O
Robert Gladden 24 The Larches
Faversham
Kent
ME13 7SQ 05/08/2011 O
Miss Emma Williams 24/6 Milton Street
Edinburgh
EH8 8HE 18/07/2011 O
Miss Lucy Smith 240 Coteford Street
London
SW17 8NL 18/07/2011 O
Mr David Simpson 25 Majors Loan
Falkirk
FK1 5QG 24/07/2011 O
Ian McIntyre 25 Stravaig Walk
Paisley
PA2 0RX 11/10/2011 O
Anna Dalliniort And Ben Dalliniort 25 Toberonochy
Isle Of Luing
Oban
Argyll
PA34 4UE 05/08/2011 O
Rev. Mr. Derek Corner 254 Lime Crescent
Abronhill
Cumbernauld
G67 3PH 17/07/2011 O
Ms Judith Wilson 26 Clarence Street
Edinburgh
EH3 5AF 02/08/2011 O
Ms Jeanette Tsang 27 Guildford Grove
London
SE10 8JY 19/07/2011 O
Dr Rosalind Glasspool 27 Banavie Road
Glasgow
G11 5AW 23/07/2011 O
Miss Isabel Miguelez 27 Baxter Park Terrace
Dundee
dd4 6nr 27/07/2011 O
Mr James Watson 28 Sandwell Crescent
Kirkcaldy
KY1 1GH 05/09/2011 O
Sam Johnson 29 Barclay Park
Aboyne
Aberdeenshire
AB34 5JF 05/08/2011 O
Mr Francis Connelly 29 Colquhoun Road
Milton
Dumbarton
Glasgow
G82 2TH 03/08/2011 O
Mrs Caroline Gwilliam 29 Hilltop Road
Whyteleafe
CR3 0DF 03/08/2011 O
Mrs H Cameron 3 Ardloch Cottages
Glenburn Road
Ardrishaig
Argyll
PA30 8EU 12/09/2011 O
Jeremy Iles 3 Barrhill Close
Great Barr
Birmingham
B43 6LS 03/08/2011 O
Ms Katryn Mercer 3 Brookside
Sutton
Ely
Cambs 18/07/2011 O
Miss Laura Gamble 3 Chesnut Avenue
Radley College
Abingdon
OX14 2HS 18/07/2011 O
Mrs Margaret MacLachlan 3 Claymhor, Hillview Drive
Corpach
Fort William
PH33 7LS 21/07/2011 O
Mr Willie Fulton 3 Drinishader
Isle Of Harris
HS3 3DX 18/10/2011 O
Mr Richard Goodson 3 High Grizebeck
Grizebeck
Kirkby-in-Furness
LA17 7XJ 18/07/2011 O
Mr Ben Mitchell 3 Kilmun Court
Dunoon
pa23 8sf 20/07/2011 O
Ms Lindsay Gilmour 3 Lyppiatt Road
Bristol
BS5 9HW 01/08/2011 O
Mrs Anne-Marie Geoffrion-Pfeil 3 Rue De Walbourg
Schiltigheim
F 67300 18/07/2011 O
Holly Abrol 3 Ryefield Close
Solihull
West Midlands
B91 1PP 16/08/2011 O
James Robertson 3 St Michaels Knowe
Garelochhead
Helensburgh
G84 ODQ 25/07/2011 O
Mr Peter Mackie 3 Stanley Avenue
Wallasey
CH45 8JN 03/08/2011 O
Mr Andrew Newton 3 The Avenue, Southlands
Haxby
York
YO322PD 18/07/2011 O
Mr Michael Long 3 Walkers Mount
Meanwood
Leeds
LS6 2SD 20/07/2011 O
Donald Manson 3 West Street
Dunoon
Argyll
PA23 8EB 08/08/2011 O
Miss Eala Williams 3 Whin Bank
Clachan Siel
Oban 03/08/2011 O
Miss Elodie Megaoui 3/1 Coinyie House Close
Edinburgh
EH1 1NL 18/07/2011 O
Mr Julien Valentin 3/1 Coinyie House Close
Edinburgh
EH1 1NL 18/07/2011 O
Mr Tom Learoyd 3/2, 3 Dowanside Road
Glasggow
G12 9YB 01/08/2011 O
Miss Amy Ferguson 3/6 Warrender Park Terrace
Edinburgh
EH91JA 24/07/2011 O
Miss N Tobin 30 Cornwall Road
Manchester
M437PR 18/07/2011 O
Mr Peter Dutton 30 Toberonochy
Island of Luing
By Oban
PA34 4UE 22/07/2011 O
Guy Lidbury 31 North St
Maldon
Essex
England
CM9 5HH 05/08/2011 O
Ms Anita Machin 310
Design House
Manchester
M4 1BH 18/07/2011 O
Mrs Carolyn Evans 310
Yewdale
Skelmersdale
WN86ES 26/10/2011 O
Mr Alan Hawkins 32 Barr Mor View
Kilmartin
PA31 8UN 20/07/2011 O
Mrs C Cardy 326 Millfield Hill
Erskine
PA8 6JN 17/07/2011 O
Mr MIke Redhead 34 Derrymore Road
Willerby
HU10 6ES 04/08/2011 O
Miss Heather Hutchings 34 Drakeley Court
Aubert Park
London
N5 1TT 03/08/2011 O
David Milburn 34 Newquay Close
Nuneaton
Warwickshire
CV11 6FH 03/08/2011 O
Mr Boyd Tunnock CBE 34 Old Mill Road
Uddingston
Glasgow
G71 7HH 02/09/2011 O
Gerry Taylor
3446 Plymouth Road Victoria B.C. Canada 12/09/2011 O
Ms Elke Braun 35 Weavers Way
Tillicoultry
FK13 6BD 02/08/2011 O
Mr Paul Branney 36 Millar Street
Carnoustie
DD7 7AT 28/07/2011 O
Mrs Wendy Kirby 36 Rowallan Road
London
SW6 6AG 22/07/2011 O
Mrs Lois Skilleter 36, Skipton Road
Ilkley
LS29 9EP 10/09/2011 O
Mr Larry Rumbol 37 Daniells Walk
Lymington
SO41 3PP 18/08/2011 O
Mrs Nele Andersch 37 Daniells Walk
Lymington
SO41 3PP 18/08/2011 O
Ms Colette Coleman 37 Hawthorne Gardens
Hockley, Essex
SS5 4SW 18/07/2011 O
Mr Alan Smith 37 High St.
Dunbar
EH42 1EW 14/09/2011 O
Miss Doune Fairfax 37/4 William Street
Edinburgh
EH3 7LW 19/07/2011 O
Miss Jo Fowler 38 Kinneil Drive
Bo'ness
EH510LY 17/07/2011 O
Belcho Petrov 38 Norbroke Street
London
W12 0QX 10/08/2011 O
Mr Stephen Mawdsley 388 Newchurch Road
Rawtenstall
Rossendale
BB47SN 18/07/2011 O
Mr Roy Morrison 39 Blackhill Drive
Helensburgh
G84 9AF 24/07/2011 O
Mrs June Morrison 39 Blackhill Drive
Helensburgh
G84 9AF 22/07/2011 O
T Cunliffe 39 St John Street
Newton Le Willow
Merseyside
WA12 9NW 16/08/2011 O
L Cunliffe 39 St John Street
Newton Le Willows
Merseyside
WA12 9NW 16/08/2011 O
Dr Denise Cowley 39 Toberonochy
Toberonochy Village Luing
Oban
PA34 4UE 17/07/2011 O
Mrs Bryony Wells 3a Fairfax Road
Leeds
LS11 8SY 20/07/2011 O
Miss Hannah James 3A Stone Villas
Leeds
LS6 4AA 18/07/2011 O
Dr Emeka Mosanya 3c Welbeck Mansions
London
NW6 1QX 19/07/2011 O
Ms Melanie Berard 3F2 34 Spottiswoode rd
Edinburgh
EH91BL 19/07/2011 O
Mr Eamonn Corking 4 Belgrave Road
Billericay
CM12 0TX 09/08/2011 O
Clare E Metcalfe 4 Coppy Bridge Drive
Rochdale
Greater Manchester
England 26/08/2011 O
Daniel Robinson 4 Cranley Drive
Edinburgh
EH10 5PA 16/08/2011 O
Ian Callaghan 4 Delamore Way
Oxford
OX2 9HZ 11/10/2011 O
Mr James Macleod 4 Lonan Drive
Oban
Oban
Argyll And Bute
PA34 4NN 19/07/2011 O
Mr Paul Douch 4 Marsh Lane, Somerleyton
Lowestoft NR32 5QX 27/07/2011 O
B Currie 4 St Georges Crescent
RHYL
Wales 12/09/2011 O
Prof Roger Waigh 4 The Meadows
Helensburgh
G84 9EG 19/07/2011 O
Mrs Tina Avery 4 Toberonochy
Isle of Luing
PA34 4UE 25/07/2011 O
Dr Brice Avery 4 Toberonochy
Isle of Luing
EH9 1LW 21/07/2011 O
Ms Jennifer Willis 4/31 Forrest Rd
Edinburgh
EH1 2QP 19/07/2011 O
Bret Hopping 40 Fir Copse Road
Parbrook
PO7 5HZ 12/09/2011 O
Mrs G Ringrose 40 Gadebridge Lane
Hemel Hempstead
HP1 3HF 25/07/2011 O
Mrs Isabel Carter 41 Leeds Old Road
Heckmondwike
WF16 9AA 25/07/2011 O
Mr Philip Carter 41 Leeds Old Road
Heckmondwike
WF16 9AA 25/07/2011 O
Mr Neil Kennedy 41 Marlborough Avenue
Glasgow
G11 7BP 13/08/2011 O
Mrs H R Graham 41 Toberonochy Village
Toberonochy
Isle Of Luing
PA34 4UE 03/08/2011 O
Ms. Sara Reader 410 N Monroe
Gardner
60424 18/07/2011 O
Mr. Sean Nore 412 34th St
West Des Moines
50265 08/09/2011 O
Mr Hugh Gray 42 Cullipool
Isle of Luing
Oban
PA34 4UB 04/08/2011 O
Ms Alessia Kockel 42 Mersham Drive
London
NW9 9PN 18/07/2011 O
Mr Roderick Millar 42 Moray Place
Edinburgh
EH3 6BT 19/07/2011 O
Mr Stuart McLoughlin 43 Church Road
Trull
Taunton
TA3 7LG 21/07/2011 O
Ms Melanie McLoughlin 43 Church Road
Trull
TA3 7LG 20/07/2011 O
U Richardson 43 Fairstead
Birch Green
Skelmersdale
Lancashire
WN8 6RB 16/08/2011 O
W Richardson 43 Fairstead
Birch Green
Skelmersdale
WN8 6RB 16/08/2011 O
Miss Edna Ewan 44 Eastside Drive
Westhill
AB32 6QN 17/07/2011 O
Mr John Lowe 44 Woodside Drive
Forres
IV36 2UF 25/07/2011 O
Mrs Ann Turner 45 Hillhead
Coylton
Ayrshire
KA6 6JT 13/09/2011 O
Ms. Sara Macdonald 46 Bentinck St.
Glasgow
G37TT 18/07/2011 O
Mrs Sheila Johnson 46 Cleveland Place
Peterlee
SR8 2PA 18/07/2011 O
Mr Joe McIntyre 46 MacLeod Drive
Helensburgh
G84 9QU 25/07/2011 O
Mrs Cathy McIntyre 46 MacLeod Drive
Helensburgh
G84 9QU 25/07/2011 O
Ms Geraldine Joaquim 46 Sturt Road
Haslemere
GU27 3SD 18/07/2011 O
Mr Stephen Tame 46 West Street
Devon
TQ13 7DU 18/07/2011 O
Miss Meilisa Blackham 47 Hampton Hill
Wellington
Telford
TF1 2ER 17/07/2011 O
Mrs Sheila Blackham 47 Hampton Hill
Wellington
Telford
TF1 2ER 17/07/2011 O
C J Holby 47 Manor Road
South Woodham Ferrers
Essex
CM3 5PT 16/08/2011 O
K Holby 47 Manor Road
South Woodham Ferrers
Essex
CM3 5PT 16/08/2011 O
Mr Peter Tickle 47, Brown Lees Road
Biddulph
Stoke-on -trent
ST8 6PJ 03/08/2011 O
Miss Nicola McMurtrie 48 Edmund Kean
East Kilbride
G74 3RG 29/07/2011 O
Mr David Dougal 49 Balfour Street
Edinburgh
EH6 5DP 16/09/2011 O
Mr & Mrs John and Fiona Watson 49 Broompark Drive
Newton Mearns
Glasgow
G77 5DZ 22/08/2011 O
Mr Greg Rust 49 Hayes Hill
Bromley
BR2 7HN 22/07/2011 O
Mr Colin Thirlwall 49 London Road
Godmanchester
PE29 2HZ 23/08/2011 O
D Mitchell 493 Lodge Lane
Solihull
West Midlands
B92 8NT 16/08/2011 O
J Mitchell 493 Lodge Lane
Solihull
West Midlands
B92 8NT 16/08/2011 O
Mr James Heward 5 Benvoullin Gardens
Oban
PA34 5DL 19/07/2011 O
Mr Graham Muir 5 Calside Avenue
Paisley
PA2 6DD 22/07/2011 O
Margarithe Haffner 5 Church Path
Chiswick
W4 5BL 26/08/2011 O
Mr Roddy Campbell 5 Drinishader
Harris
HS33DX 19/10/2011 O
Dr Mark Steer 5 Elberton Road
Olveston
BRISTOL
BS35 4DD 18/07/2011 O
S E Oaly 5 Matthews Yard
Reepham
Norfolk
NR10 4NF 16/09/2011 O
Mr Kim Ley 5 Mount Close
Bristol
BS36 2DD 18/07/2011 O
Mr Frank Ford 5 Pennine View
Glasson Dock
Lancaster
LA2 0AS 26/07/2011 O
Miss Victoria Ashton 5 Randle Drive
Sutton Coldfield
b75 5lh 02/08/2011 O
Mrs Susan Eldred 5 Stanhope St
Hereford
HR4 0HA 03/08/2011 O
Mr Chris Eldred 5 Stanhope St
Hereford
HR4 0HA 03/08/2011 O
Martha, Molly And S Eldred 5 Stanhope Street
Hereford
HR4 0HA 03/08/2011 O
Mr Thomas Wilson 5 Stellhead
Avenue
New Cumnock
KA18 4JT 20/07/2011 O
Reverand Frank Front 5 Toberonochy
Oban
PA34 4UE 26/07/2011 O
Ms Janine Ogilvie 5 Tynemouth way
Heaton
Newcastle
NE6 2RZ 19/07/2011 O
Miss Harriet Carp 5 Webbs Road
London
SW11 1XJ 22/07/2011 O
Mr Henry Procter 5, The Sycamores,
Glossop
SK13 2BS 18/07/2011 O
Claire Matson 50 Bellahouston Drive
Glasgow
G52 1HQ 12/09/2011 O
Dr Jeremy Bass 51 Tinto Road
Newlands
GLASGOW
G43 2AH 26/07/2011 O
Mr Paul Leitch 51 Woodhall Bank
Edinburgh
EH13 0HL 14/09/2011 O
A McNally 52 Fen End Lane
Spalding
Lincs PE12 6AD 12/09/2011 O
R McNally 52 Fen End Lane
Spalding
Lincs
PE12 6AD 12/09/2011 O
Miss Cherie Bettison 52 Glen Gardens
Callander,
FK17 8ES 19/07/2011 O
Mr Stephen Outhwaite 52 Woodlands Drive
Harrogate
HG2 7AX 16/08/2011 O
Mr John Hanmer 52, Broomleaf Road,
Farnham,
GU9 8DQ 17/05/2012 O
Name Illegible 53 Churchfields
Milltown
Dublin 14
Republic Of Ireland 26/08/2011 O
Mr Richard Gonzalez 535 Portswood Road
Southampton
so173sa 02/08/2011 O
Mr Daniel Sidoli 54 Halstead Road
Winchmore Hill
London
N21 3DS 19/07/2011 O
Mr Ben Burns 54 Thames Close
Hampton
TW12 2ET 19/07/2011 O
Mr Craig Muirhead 57 Hopefield Road
Blackburn
EH477HX 18/07/2011 O
Mr David Pearson 58 Cambridge Road
Crosby
Lverpool
L23 7TZ 04/08/2011 O
Mr Duncan Macdonald 58 Cloan Crescent
Bishopbriggs
Glasgow
G64 2HW 16/08/2011 O
Roy And June Stove 6 Acha
Balvicar
Near Oban
PA34 4RJ 03/08/2011 O
Mr Charlie Tomlinson 6 Buckingham Street
Hillhead
Glasgow
G12 8DL 25/07/2011 O
Mr Simon Gurney 6 Cross Rd
Leamington Spa
CV32 5PB 19/07/2011 O
Mr Barry Carter 6 Elm Court
Elmdon
Saffron Walden
CB11 4NP 18/07/2011 O
Andrew Forrester 6 Havelock Road
Croydon
Surry
CR0 6QP 03/08/2011 O
Daniel And Celia Hughes 6 High Street
Dollar
Scotland
FK14 7AY 01/09/2011 O
Mr David Shenton 6, Ninian's Rise
Kirkintilloch
Glasgow
G66 3HU 03/08/2011 O
Miss Weronika Chaberko 6/3 Montague St
Edinburgh
EH8 9QU
18/07/2011 O
Sindy Lau 61 Finisterne Parade
Port Marine
Portishead
BS20 7JY 16/09/2011 O
Andrew Hill 61 Finisterne Parade
Portmarine
Portishead
Bristol
BS20 7JY 16/09/2011 O
Michael Walsh 61 Maes Y Wennol
Miskin
Pontyclun
CF72 8SB 10/08/2011 O
Belinda Faulkner 61 Princes Street
Stone
Staffordshire
ST15 8HY 05/08/2011 O
Ricardo Telmo Fernandes 61 Princes Street
Stone
Staffordshire
ST15 8HY 05/08/2011 O
Mr Chris Owen 63 Bath Road
Eastington
Stonehouse
GL10 3AY 07/09/2011 O
D Griffin 63 Beswick Gardens
Rugby
Warwickshire
CV22 7PR 10/08/2011 O
R B Griffin 63 Beswick Gardens
Rugby
Warwickshire
CV22 7PR 10/08/2011 O
Name Illegible 63 Carlton Way
Glazebrook
Warrington
WA3 5BG 16/08/2011 O
T Entwistle 63 Carlton Way
Glazebrook
Warrington
WA3 5BG 16/08/2011 O
Mr Ian Sharpe 63, Black Butts Lane
Walney Island
Barrow-in-Furness
LA14 3JZ 26/07/2011 O
Alison Barnes 67 Simonside Terrace
Heaton
Newcastle UponTyne
NE6 5LF 12/09/2011 O
Mrs Marian Hollings 670 Bolton Road
BRadford
BD3 0ND 10/08/2011 O
Mrs Jennifer Petrie 68 Auchmithie
Arbroath
DD11 5SQ 18/10/2012 O
Pamela Hughes 7 Ballaig Avenue
Bearsden
Glasgow
G61 4HA 03/08/2011 O
Roger Hughes 7 Ballaig Avenue
Bearsden
Glasgow
G61 4HQ 03/08/2011 O
Mrs Peggy Mack 7 Blackhouse Avenue
Newton Mearns
Blackhouse Avenue
G77 5HU 22/07/2011 O
Jonathon Ashworth 7 Clarence Grove
Leeds LS18 4LA 20/10/2011 O
Mr Jamie Dyer 7 Cooper Cottages
Barrock
Thurso
KW14 8SZ 17/07/2011 O
Mrs Cheryl Power 7 Foxgrove Avenue
7 Foxgrove Avenue
Beckenham
BR3 5BA 18/07/2011 O
Mr Kurt Leech 7 Grangeway
Handforth, Wilmslow
SK9 3HY 18/07/2011 O
Declan And Mairead Currie 7 Grosvenor Avenue
Rhyl
Wales
LL18 4HA 12/09/2011 O
Mr Anthony Howard 7 Herontye Drive
East Grinstead
RH19 4LR 18/07/2011 O
K E Mallalratt 7 Myrtle Street
Retford
Nottinghamshire
DN22 7BS 10/08/2011 O
Mr John Travers 7 Park Place
Thackley
BD10 0TG 26/07/2011 O
Libby Lawes 7 Queens Road
Clevedon
BS21 7TH 19/07/2011 O
Paul Goddard 7 Roy Avenue
Ipswich
Suffolk
IP3 8LN 03/08/2011 O
Mr Alex Campbell 7 Rufford Grove
Bingham
Nottingham
NG13 8RH 03/08/2011 O
Mr Michael Walters 7 St James Close
Baildon
Shipley
Bradford
BD17 6HF 20/07/2011 O
Mr Bill Waugh 7 Thorne Court
North Berwick
EH39 4RU 26/07/2011 O
Amanda Fairclough 7 Time Park
Prescot
L35 7NU 01/09/2011 O
Mrs Julia Galbraith 7 Toberonochy
Isle of Luing
Oban
PA34 4UE 29/07/2011 O
Mr Robert Fraser 7
Langhill Farm Cottages
Roslin
EH25 9ST 18/07/2011 O
C Wilson 71 Moore Close
Claypole
Newark
NG23 5AU 26/08/2011 O
A E Wilson 71 Moore Close
Claypole
Newark
Notts
NG23 5AU 26/08/2011 O
J Wilson 71 Moore Close
Claypole
Newark
Notts
NG23 5AU 26/08/2011 O
Mr Gregory Chauvet 73 Hanson Street
Glasgow
G31 2HF 18/07/2011 O
Mr Roger Green 73 Leigh Hall Road
Leigh-on-Sea
SS9 1QZ 01/09/2011 O
Ms Joy Williams 74 Albion Street
Wirral Citizens Advice Bureau
Wallasey
CH45 9JH 18/07/2011 O
Leigh Gordon 74 Angle Park Terrace
Edinburgh
EH11 2JP 03/08/2011 O
Mr Colin Iain Macrae 75 Riddochhill Road
Blackburn
EH477EZ 03/08/2011 O
Graham Batty 76 Cardinal Avenue
Boreham Wood
Herts
WP6 1SH 05/08/2011 O
Andy McDonald 76 Simonside Terrace
Heaton
Newcastle Upon Tyne
NE6 5LF 12/09/2011 O
Mr Carl Wright 77 Oawood Road
Bricket Wood
AL2 3QB 19/07/2011 O
Name Illegible 78 Springwood Avenue
Stirling
FK8 2PE 26/08/2011 O
Miss Shona Forbes 79 Hollinhall Street
Greenacres
Oldham
OL4 3EH 18/07/2011 O
Mr Stephen Lee 8 Ash Lane
Wells
BA5 2LU 20/07/2011 O
Agnes M M Connelly 8 Balvicar
Isle Of Seil
By Oban
Argyll
PA34 4TF 01/08/2011 O
Mrs Carol Ramsey 8 Belmont Close
Branton
Doncaster
DN3 3PU 18/07/2011 O
Ms A Otto 8 Harwill Grove
Churwell
Leeds
LS27 7QH 19/07/2011 O
J And G Hallan 8 Hill View
Whailey Bridge
High Peak
Derbyshire
SK23 7BG 01/08/2011 O
Miss Judith Wroe 8 Jennings Avenue
Salford
M5 3JR 19/07/2011 O
Mr Owen Merrick 8 Johnstone Street
Alva
FK12 5AE 03/09/2011 O
Miss Sanccia Thomas 8 Kingfisher Brae
Livingston
EH54 6UD 02/08/2011 O
Mr Peter Wrate 8 Kirkhill Drive
Oldmeldrum
AB51 0FP 23/07/2011 O
Evie Weir 8 Phoenix Court
Chertsey Road 16/08/2011 O
 Lower Feltham
Middlesex
TW13 4RN
Lee Weir 8 Phoenix Court
Chertsey Road
Lower Feltham
Middlesex
TW13 4RN 16/08/2011 O
J Taylor 8 Robin Hood Close
St Johns
Woking
GU21 8SS 26/08/2011 O
Mrs Linda Brown 8 Seaview Terrace
Easdale
Oban
PA34 4RG 21/07/2011 O
Mrs R D Reading 8 Stafford Street
Helensburgh
G84 9JU 03/08/2011 O
Sylvia Jordan And Colin Jordan 8 Sundown Avenue
Littleover
Derby
DE23 1GY 16/09/2011 O
Heather Noble 80 Hutton Avenue
Hartlepool
TS26 9PR 26/08/2011 O
Ian Noble 80 Hutton Avenue
Hartlepool
TS26 9PR 26/08/2011 O
Miss Heather Forbes 80 North Bughtlinside
Edinburgh
EH12 8YB 17/07/2011 O
Mr Shaun Ritchie 81 Haberdasher Street
London
N16EH 03/08/2011 O
Miss Karen Davies 83 Folly Lane
Swinton
Manchester
M27 0DB 17/07/2011 O
Naomi Burgoyne 84 Martin Close
Deancross Street
London
E1 2QT 01/09/2011 O
Mr Ciaran Hoy 84/6 Hawthornvale
Edinburgh
EH6 4JX 16/07/2011 O
Miss Fern Lear 85, Sunningdale Close
Warrington
WA5 4NS 18/07/2011 O
Mr Daniel Lear 85, Sunningdale Close
Warrington
WA5 4NS 18/07/2011 O
Mr Michelle Lear 85, Sunningdale Close
Warrington
WA5 4NS 18/07/2011 O
Mr Robin Lear 85, Sunningdale Close
Warrington
WA5 4NS 18/07/2011 O
Mr John Mark Mitchell 87/5 Restalrig Road South
Edinburgh
EH7 6JD 08/09/2011 O
Ms Barbara Nock 89 Braehead Cresent
Stonehaven
ab39 2pp 18/07/2011 O
Alison Reynolds 89 Saville Road
Whiston
Rotherham
South Yorkshire
S60 4DZ 12/09/2011 O
John Reynolds 89 Saville Road
Whiston
Rotherham
South Yorkshire
S60 4EE 12/09/2011 O
Nick Gilmour 9 Balvicar
Seil
PA34 4TF 01/08/2011 O
Dr Tom Hurst 9 Bristol Ave
Manchester
M19 3NU 25/07/2011 O
Mr Adam Cheetham 9 Buttercup Avenue
Donisthorpe
Swadlincote
DE12 7RR 30/07/2011 O
Mrs Kate Harris 9 Buttercup Avenue
Donisthorpe
Swadlincote
DE12 7RR 30/07/2011 O
Claire MacLeod 9 Citadel Crescent
Stromness
Orkney
KW16 3EL 03/08/2011 O
M Mawld 9 Citadel Crescent
Stromness
Orkney
KW16 3EL 03/08/2011 O
Ms Susan Yates 9 Clough Lane
Grasscroft
Odham
OL4 4EW 30/07/2011 O
William Jones 9 Elleniheich
Fasdale
Oban
Argyll
PA34 08/08/2011 O
Ms Janet Harbidge 9 Princes Street
Stirling
FK8 1HQ 29/07/2011 O
Mr Osbert Lancaster 9 Sandford Gardens
Edinburgh
EH15 1LP 22/07/2011 O
Mr Martyn Webster 9 Whittingehame Drive
GLASGOW
G12 0XS 16/08/2011 O
Mr Paul DAnaleze 91 Fotheringay Road
Glasgow
G41 4LH 25/07/2011 O
Mr Gordon Laing 93 Falkirk
FK2 9DH 20/07/2011 O
Mr Frederick Mckenna 93 Hardshaw Street
St Helens
WA10 1JR 18/07/2011 O
Dr Nicola MacLeod 97 Lower Granton Road
Edinburgh
EH5 1ER 16/07/2011 O
Ms Vicky Stirling 9A St Vincent Street
Edinburgh
EH3 6SW 19/07/2011 O
Mrs Pat Blunsden Achabeag
Cuan Rd
Balvicar
PA34 4RJ 18/07/2011 O
Neil J McLean Achaleven Farm
Connel
Oban
PA37 1PF 03/08/2011 O
Ms G W Stewart Achnaseilach
Clachan Seil 01/08/2011 O
 By Oban
Argyll
PA34 4TJ
K W Butler Achraich
Clachan Seil
By Oban
Argyll
PA34 4TN 05/08/2011 O
Annika Niellweweme Address Illegible 22/08/2011 O
C Derriks Address Illegible 22/08/2011 O
Christopher Dimonpaulos Address Illegible 16/08/2011 O
David Carmichael Address Illegible 10/08/2011 O
Ellen De Baare Address Illegible 16/08/2011 O
Eva Arents Address Illegible 26/08/2011 O
Fam Van Leyenhurst Address Illegible 16/08/2011 O
Freeh Van Der Engel Address Illegible 03/08/2011 O
Hannah Link Address Illegible 01/09/2011 O
Jaap De Baare Address Illegible 16/08/2011 O
Jane Maskell Address Illegible 02/09/2011 O
Jelmer Krom Address Illegible 22/08/2011 O
Jenny Underwood Address Illegible 26/07/2011 O
Jirgen Rembold Address Illegible 01/09/2011 O
Lorene Korper Address Illegible 22/08/2011 O
Maxi Rembold Address Illegible 01/09/2011 O
Miguel Fausino Address Illegible 10/08/2011 O
Weiner Allee Address Illegible 16/08/2011 O
Miss F Morrison Air Tir
Balvicar
Isle Of Seil
PA34 4TF 01/08/2011 O
Mrs Ann Wilson Aite Fois
Clachan Seil
Oban
PA34 4QZ 25/07/2011 O
Ms Tina Jordan Alltbeath, Musdale Road
Kilmore
Oban
PA34 4XX 20/07/2011 O
Name Illegible Alma
Cullipool
Isle Of Luing
Argyll
PA34 4TX 05/08/2011 O
Thiis Houmans Amberhout 46
1507 EE Zaandam
The Netherlands 03/08/2011 O
Mr Murdoch Baxter Ampfield
Clachan Seil
By Oban
PA34 4TL 29/07/2011 O
Mrs Janice Baxter Ampfield
Clachan Seil
By Oban
PA34 4TL 03/08/2011 O
Sheila Downie An Cala
Isle Of Seil
Argyll
PA34 4RF 02/08/2011 O
Richard Pierce An Cala
South Cuan
Isle Of Luing
PA34 4TU 18/08/2011 O
Ms Carol Collis An Fhuaran
Clachan Seil
An Fhuaran
Oban
PA34 4TL 01/08/2011 O
Mr Mike Williams Annesbrook
2 Dewberry Close
Stourport-On-Severn
DY13 8TB 18/07/2011 O
Mrs Denys Mathieson Appin House, appin, argyll
Appin
PA38 4BN 04/08/2011 O
Dr Peter Thorpe Ar Baile
Clachan Seil
PA34 4TJ 28/07/2011 O
Dr Vivien Johnston Ard Shona
Blackmill Bay
Luing
PA34 4TZ 01/08/2011 O
Baba Gana Kasim Ard Shona
Blackmill Bay
Luing
By Oban
PA34 4TZ 04/08/2011 O
James Lawson Arden-Beag
7 Station Road
Craigendoran
Helensburgh
G84 7BG 25/08/2011 O
Christian Taylor Ardencaple House
Isle Of Seil
Oban
Argyll
PA34 4TN 04/08/2011 O
Name Illegible Ardencaple
Isle Of Seil
By Oban
Argyll
PA34 4TN 04/08/2011 O
Mrs K Prichard Ardene
Harrietfield
Perth
PH1 3TD 20/07/2011 O
Mr Andy Thornton Ardenlinne
Ganavan Rd
Oban
PA34 5TU 24/07/2011 O
Mrs Marjie Thornton Ardenlinne
Ganavan Road
Oban
PA34 5TU 24/07/2011 O
Mrs Sabina Struthers Ardmaddy Castle
Balvicar
Oban
PA34 4QY 26/07/2011 O
Mr A J Struthers Ardmaddy Castle
Oban
PA34 4QY 26/07/2011 O
Charles Struthers Ardmaddy Castle
By Oban
Argyll
PA34 4QY 05/08/2011 O
Frances Hill Ardross
Clachan Seil
Oban
PA34 4TL 02/08/2011 O
E B Haran Ardtun
Clachan Seil
Oban
Argyll
PA34 4TL 03/08/2011 O
I E Davies Ardtun
Clachan Seil
Oban 03/08/2011 O
 Argyll
PA34 4TL
A Gardiner Ardtun
Clachan Seil
Oban
PA34 4TL 02/08/2011 O
Mr Maurice Wilkins Arduaine Garden
Arduaine
Oban
PA34 4XQ 01/08/2011 O
Mrs Elizabeth Maclean Aros Ard
Croft Road
Oban
PA34 5JN 20/07/2011 O
Mrs Linda Lancaster Ashbeck
Brow Edge Road
Backbarrow
LA12 8QT 18/07/2011 O
Miss Elspeth Campbell Asknish Cottage
Arduaine
by Oban
PA34 4XQ 25/07/2011 O
Georgina M C McCrae Auchnagoul Cottage
Inveraray
Argyll
PA32 8XT 03/08/2011 O
Mr. Kees Rodenburg BadabrieTramore
Banavie
Fort William
PH33 7LX 17/07/2011 O
S Brown Ballachan Farmhouse
Isle Of Seil
By Oban
Argyll 01/08/2011 O
Mr Ian Provan Balliemore
Castleton
Lochgilphead
PA32 8RU 27/07/2011 O
Mr Jamie Mellor Barndromin Farm
Knipoch
Oban
PA34 4QS 22/08/2011 O
Antoinette N M Mitchell Barochreal
Kilninver
By Oban
PA34 4UT 28/07/2011 O
Antoinette NM Mitchell Barochreal
Kilninver
Oban
Argyll And Bute
PA34 4UT 21/02/2013 O
Nigel A Mitchell Barochreal
Kilninver
Oban
Argyll And Bute
PA34 4UT 21/02/2013 O
Jim Bell Basement Flat
15 Hampton Park
Bristol
BS6 6LG 03/08/2011 O
Liz Newton Basement Flat
15 Hampton Park
Bristol
BS6 6LG 03/08/2011 O
Mr Graham Johnston Beck House
April Rise
Macclesfield
SK10 3PJ 23/07/2011 O
Mr John Landale Berandhu
Appin
PA38 4DD 08/09/2011 O
Mrs. Xandra Van Der Knaap Boomweidelaan 69
Schore
4423AN Netherlands 19/07/2011 O
Mrs A P Bevis Braefoot Farm
Balvicar
Isle Of Seil
Oban
Argyll And Bute
PA34 4RA 26/07/2011 O
Mr Michael Handley Bragleenbeg
Kilninver
Oban
Argyll And Bute
PA34 4UU 15/08/2011 O
Miss Philippa Handley Bragleenbeg
Kilninver
PA34 4UU 15/08/2011 O
Dr Elizabeth Henderson Braidhurst Cottage
Kirk Brae
Helensburgh
G84 8NP 19/07/2011 O
Mr John Gould Brown Edge Road
Buxton
Sk17 18/07/2011 O
Mrs J Gould Brown Edge Road
Buxton
SK17 18/07/2011 O
Mrs Helen Smith Brunstane Gardens
Penicuik
EH26 9AA 10/09/2011 O
Linda Broeliema Burg De Bordesstr 74
1404 G2 Bussum
The Netherlands 03/08/2011 O
Mr Ian Ross Burnbank
Ardbroilach Road
Kingussie
PH21 1JX 26/07/2011 O
Ms Alison Prince Burnfoot
Whiting Bay
Isle of Arran
KA27 8QL 18/07/2011 O
Mr Andrew Nicol Bute Estate
Mount Stuart
Rothesay
PA20 9LR 27/07/2011 O
Mr. Robert Jonsen c/o McNaughton
41 Plann Road, Knockentiber
Kilmarnock
KA2 0EN 29/07/2011 O
Dr Andy Walker C/o Scottish Anglers National Assocaition Ltd
The Pier
Loch Leven
Kinross
KY13 8UF 16/08/2011 O
Alistair Walker Cairn Ryan
Chapel Brae
Braemar
Aberdeenshire
AB35 5YT 05/08/2011 O
Catriona Walker Cairn Ryan
Chapel Brae
Braemar
Aberdeenshire
AB35 5YT 05/08/2011 O
Judge Jeremy Duerden Caladh
17 Lower Cribden Avenue 23/07/2011 O
 Rossendale Lancs.
BB4 6SW
Dr I Ramsay Calzieveg
Braco
Perthshire
FK15 9RD 26/08/2011 O
Sandra Allan Calzieveg
Braco
Perthshire
FK15 9RD 26/08/2011 O
Mr Robert Fleck Camusdarach
Kilmelford
PA34 4XA 03/12/2011 O
D S Nicol Carraig
Clachan Seil
By Oban
Argyll
PA34 4TL 01/08/2011 O
Mr Jon Close Carsaig House
Tayvallich
Lochgilphead
PA31 8PN 21/07/2011 O
Mrs Christine Irvine Ceol Mara
Glencoe
Ballachulish
PH49 4HS 21/07/2011 O
Mrs M Ann And Mr D Manson Ceol Mara
3 West Street
Dunoon
Argyll And Bute
PA23 8EB 03/10/2011 O
Mr John Jordan Chequerfield Close
Castleford
WF10 5NY 18/07/2011 O
Philip Maskell Church Feild
Fawley
Henley-On-Thames
Oxfordshire
RG9 6HZ 02/09/2011 O
Ms Simone Van Dijl Cluain
Cullipool, Isle Of Luing
Oban
PA34 4UB 03/08/2011 O
Brenda McGeoch Cluin Siar
Cullipool
Isle Of Luing
Oban
PA34 4TX 03/08/2011 O
Wendy And John Mattingley Cluny House
Aberfeldy
Pethshire
PH15 2JT 03/08/2011 O
Mr Peter Stott Coille Dharaich
Kilmelford
PA34 4XD 25/07/2011 O
Mr David Stott Coille Dorroch
Degnish Road
Kimelford
PA34 4XD 30/07/2011 O
Mrs Helen Glennie Coireseileach Clachan Seil
Seil
Oban
PA34 4QZ 27/07/2011 O
Mr David Glennie Coireseileach
Clachan Seil
Oban
PA34 4QZ 20/07/2011 O
Mrs Linda Battison Cologin
Lerags Glen
Oban
PA34 4Se 20/07/2011 O
Mrs Maureen N Jackson Cooraddie
Colintraive
Argyll
PA22 3AT 01/08/2011 O
Miss Sue Sayer Copperleaf Cottage
Phillack Hill, Phillack
Hayle
TR27 5AD 17/07/2011 O
F E Bisp Coquet Lodge
Balvicar
By Oban
Argyll
PA34 4TF 04/08/2011 O
J Bisp Coquet Lodge
Balvicar
By Oban
Argyll
PA34 4TF 04/08/2011 O
Mrs Dorothy Henderson Corrish
84 Bullwood Road
Dunoon
Argyll
PA23 7QL 01/08/2011 O
Mr Stephen Whitley Corrymoor Farm
Stockland
Honiton
EX14 9DY 21/07/2011 O
Alistair McIntyre Craggan
Shore Road
Garelochhead
Helensburgh
G84 0EJ 18/08/2011 O
Mrs Ellen-Ann Novak Craig Breck Farm
North Kessock
By Inverness
IV1 3XG 21/07/2011 O
Mrs Sandra Boardman Craigroyston
Dalmally
PA33 1AA 21/07/2011 O
Claire Grierson Creag Dubhan
Connel
By Oban
PA37 1PF 03/08/2011 O
Isla Grierson Creag Dubhan
Connel
Oban
Argyll
PA37 1PF 03/08/2011 O
Dr Louise Reid Cruach Scarba
Clachan Seil
Oban
Argyll
PA34 4TL 01/08/2011 O
Christina M Wills Cuan Ard
Cuan Ferry
Isle Of Seil
Oban
Argyll
PA34 4RB 03/08/2011 O
Dr Kerry Caldock Culzean
Rockfield Road
Oban
PA 34 5 DH 18/07/2011 O
Harry T Powell Cumbrae
Grosvenor Crescent 04/08/2011 O
 Connel
Oban
Argyll
PA37 1PQ
Mrs. Elly Post Curieplaats 65
Rotterdam the Netherlands
3069 HA 02/08/2011 O
Mr Post Curieplaats 65
Rotterdam
3069 HA 18/07/2011 O
Daniel Smith Dale House
The Green
Whiston
South Yorkshire
S60 4JD 12/09/2011 O
Marie Smith Dale House
The Green
Whiston
South Yorkshire
S60 4JD 12/09/2011 O
Mr Andrew Blair-Smith Dalmore House
Knipoch
By Oban
PA34 4QT 26/07/2011 O
Mrs Shelley Newton-Carter Dalvey
Blairgowrie
PH10 7PZ 21/07/2011 O
Cath And Eric Strachan Dargo
Achaleven Road
Connel
Argyll 03/08/2011 O
R J MacKay Dunara
Connel
Argyll
PA37 1PH 08/08/2011 O
Miss Emma Ainsley Dunaverty
Easdale
by Oban
PA34 4RF 31/07/2011 O
Mrs Jean Ainsley Dunaverty
Easdale
By Oban
PA34 4RF 31/07/2011 O
Mr David Ainsley Dunaverty
Easdale
Oban
PA34 4RF 16/07/2011 O
Mr Donald Rice Dundonnell House
Dundonnell
IV23 2QW 03/08/2011 O
Tim Goodwin Dunfillan
Cuan Ferry
Seil
Oban
PA34 4RS 25/07/2011 O
D And W P Pearson Dunvegan
Cnoc A' Challtuinn
Clachan Seil
Isle Of Seil
Oban
Argyll And Bute
PA34 4TR 26/07/2011 O
R Barrett Eaj Mhor
Clachan Seil
By Oban
PA34 4TR 01/08/2011 O
Dr J P Moss Ealachan Bhana
Clachan Seil
Oban 02/08/2011 O
 PA34 4TL
K L Barrett And Roger E Barrett Eas Mhor
Cnoc - A - Chaltuinn Road
Clachan Seil
Isle Of Seil
By Oban
PA34 4TR 01/08/2011 O
Mrs Sheila Potts East Coilleard
Appin
PA38 4BA 23/07/2011 O
Mr Orlando Pritchard-Barrett Easter Campsie Farm
Glenalmond
Ph13RX 20/07/2011 O
Mr Michael Heseltine Easter Campsie Farmhouse
Glenalmond
Perth
PH1 3RX 18/07/2011 O
Stephen Adam Eastwood
Donaldson's Brae
Kilcreggan
G84 0JB 01/08/2011 O
F Macrae EH47 7EZ 03/08/2011 O
Dr Rolf Johannessen Elleray, Shore Road
Kilcreggan
Helensburgh
G84 0HG 23/07/2011 O
MR Steven Proudfoot Elmer
Landscove
Newton Abbot
TQ13 7LZ 22/07/2011 O
R M Chipchase Fascadale
Dalriach Road
Oban
Argyll
PA34 5EQ 08/08/2011 O
David Fraser Fasgadh
Clachan Seil
Argyll
PA34 4TJ 01/08/2011 O
Mrs Diane Scaife Fearnach House
Kilmelford
Oban
PA34 4XD 24/07/2011 O
Anne Hughes Fearnoch
South Cuan
OBAN
Argyll
PA34 4TU 13/09/2011 O
N Robertson Ferniehirst
Ganavan Road
Oban
Argyll And Bute
PA34 5TU 26/07/2011 O
C J Hughes Ferry House
South Cuan
Luing
Oban
Argyll
PA34 4TU 16/09/2011 O
Mr Richard Downes Fieldgarth
Birthwaite Road
Windermere
LA231BF 18/07/2011 O
Mr Glynn Brook Fingland Farm Cottage
Wigton
CA7 5EN 22/07/2011 O
Dr George Hannah Finlaggan
Clachan Seil
Oban 02/08/2011 O
 PA34 4TL

Mrs Julia Hannah Finlaggan

Cachan Seil
Oban
PA34 4TL 02/08/2011 O
Alison Godden Flat 1 Courtyard Mews
105 Boulton Lane
Alvaston
Derby
DE24 0FF 16/09/2011 O
Fatima Ferrer Flat 1/2
54 Larchfield Avenue
Glasgow
G4 9YH 16/08/2011 O
Mr Max MacLeod Flat 1-1
23 Polwarth Street
Glasgow
G12 9UD 06/08/2011 O
Mr Nigel Schofield Flat 16 Holyrood Court
Prestwich
Manchester
M25 1PG 24/07/2011 O
Marina Johnston Flat 2/1
4 Denby Street
Glasgow
G3 7TJ 16/08/2011 O
Andrew Bush Flat 2/2
764 Pollockshaws Road
Glasgow
G41 2AE 03/08/2011 O
Mr Richard Yeomans Flat 4
9 Shirecliffe Lane
Sheffield
S3 9AD 22/07/2011 O
Jordan Ellison Flat 44
Rottrill Gardens
Marron Place
London
E8 1NG 01/09/2011 O
Mr Nathan Molyneaux Flat 7 Velocity West
5 City Walk
Leeds
LS11 9BG 18/07/2011 O
Sylvia And David Willis Fulmar
4 Meikle Aiden Brae
Kilcreggan
Helensburgh
Argyll And Bute
G84 0JD 02/08/2011 O
Edna Whyte Gallery House
Cullipool
Isle Of Luing
Oban Argyll
PA34 4TX 03/08/2011 O
Mrs Astrid Van Der Kraan Glenbeg
Kilmelford
PA34 4XA 31/07/2011 O
Mr Stephen McLaughlin Glencairn
Leithen Road
Innerleithen
EH44 6NJ 18/07/2011 O
Mrs Louisa Leader Glencarse House
Perth
PH2 7LF 24/07/2011 O
Mr Hugh Whittle Glenfeochan House
Kilmore
PA34 4QR 22/08/2011 O
Mr TJB Sinclair Glenshellach
Cnoc A' Challtuinn
Clachan Seil
Isle Of Seil
Oban
Argyll And Bute
PA34 4TR 26/07/2011 O
Mrs Pamela Forsyth Glenview
Wyndham Road
Innellan
PA23 7SH 07/09/2011 O
Mr and Mrs D & J Morgan God's House Farm
Harts Lane, Ardleigh
Colchester
CO7 7QQ 04/08/2011 O
Mr David Martin Green Acre
Halterworth Lane
Romsey
SO51 9AD 07/09/2011 O
P Morris Green Farm
Blackberry Lane
Coventry
CV2 3JS 16/08/2011 O
C A Steninger Green Farm
Blackberry Lane
Coventry
CV2 3JS 16/08/2011 O
Miss L Monk Greenfield Court
Balfron
G63 0QG 18/07/2011 O
Mr Martin Whitmore Grianan
South Cuan
Isle of Luing
PA34 4TU 05/08/2011 O
Mrs Rosalind Whitelaw Grieves Cottage
Whitfield
West Linton
EH46 7AX 17/07/2011 O
Mrs Edith Anderson Guisachan House Alma Road
Fort William
PH33 6HA 02/08/2011 O
Mrs Sofie Van Veen Harderwijkerweg 167
Nunspeet
8071 EP 18/07/2011 O
N S Hunt Heather Cottage
Dove Street
Ellastone
Ashbourne
Derbyshire
DE6 2GY 11/10/2011 O
Mr Kevin O'Farrell Heir Island
Heir Island
Skibbereen
1234567 09/09/2011 O
Anne Sophie Schipper Hellendoorn
The Netherlands 22/08/2011 O
Ralph Kempers Hellendoorn
The Netherlands 22/08/2011 O
Frances Arnold Heugh CLose
Stamfordham
Northumberland
NE18 0NH 12/09/2011 O
Mr David Nattrass High Street House
Morland
Penrith
CA10 3AS 18/07/2011 O
Ms G Jones Hill of Bandodle
Inverurie
AB51 7NN 26/07/2011 O
Mr. Eddie Palmer Hillhead Farmhouse
North Mains of KInnettles
Forfar
Angus 10/09/2011 O
Mr Chas Warren Holly Cottage
Stanton upon Hine Heath
Shrewsbury
SY4 4LW 03/08/2011 O
Tiery Somer Hollytree Cottage
Toberonochy
Isle Of Luing
Oban
Argyll
PA34 4UG 19/08/2011 O
Mrs Sue Fenton House Plot At The Anchorage
Whinbank
Clachan Seil
PA34 4TW 05/08/2011 O
Mr Paul Dix In der Ebene 11
Gerbrunn
D-97218 17/07/2011 O
Mrs A Van Beckhoven Indigoblauw
4
Zoetermeer
2718jz 18/07/2011 O
Mr Luke Alexander Inn at Ardgour
Ardgour
Fort William
PH33 7AA 20/07/2011 O
M Breslin Innish
Clachan Seil
Oban
Argyll
PA34 4QZ 02/08/2011 O
Irene Breslin Innish
Clachan Seil
Oban
PA34 4QZ 02/08/2011 O
James And Else Mellor Innishail
Clachan Seil
Isle Of Seil
By Oban
PA34 4TJ 01/08/2011 O
F Thiller Inshaig House
Isle Of Seil
Argyll
PA34 4RF 26/08/2011 O
Mr George Houston Iolair Mhara
Acha, Balvicar
OBAN
PA34 4RJ 27/07/2011 O
Drs Walter Vendel Kamperweg 167
Wapenveld
8191 KC 18/07/2011 O
Robert Batten Keepeers Cottage
South Cuan
Isle Of Luing
Oban
PA34 4TU 03/08/2011 O
Mr Ian Tegner Keepers Cottage
Kilninver
Oban
PA34 4UT 16/08/2011 O
Mr Ian Tegner Keepers Cottage
Kilninver
Oban
Argyll And Bute
PA34 4UT
21/02/2013 O
F Batten Keepers Cottage
South Cuan
Oban
PA34 4TU 03/08/2011 O
Donald N McVean Kennels Cottage
Eredine
Dalmally
Argyll
PA33 1BP 01/08/2011 O
Mr Thomas Herion Kermelberg 25
Herdecke
D-58313 16/04/2012 O
The Hon. Michael Shaw Kilbrandon House Balvicar
Oban
PA34 4RA 28/07/2011 O
Dr Angus McCoss Kilbrandon House
Balvicar
Isle Of Seil
Oban
Argyll And Bute
PA34 4RA 21/02/2013 O
T L Nelson Kilmaronaig
Connel
PA37 1PW 22/08/2011 O
Alexandra Nicholson Kilninver House
Kilninver
Argyll
PA34 4UT 07/09/2011 O
Rebecca Nicholson Kilninver House
Kilninver
Argyll
PA34 4UT 07/09/2011 O
Mr Ewan Kennedy Kinloch
Degnish Road
Kilmelford
PA34 4XD 25/07/2011 O
Mr Ewan Kennedy Kinloch
Degnish Road
Kilmelford
PA34 4XD 22/07/2011 O
Mr. Donald Hutchison Kinlochlaich House,
Appin,
PA38 4BD 22/07/2011 O
Dr Ian Collins Kirkhill
Kippen
FK8 3DY 27/07/2011 O
Ms Joanne Porter Kirkliston
Edinburgh
EH29 9AD 26/07/2011 O
Mrs Maggie Cole Knowehead Cottage
Hightae
Lockerbie
DG1 1JL 18/07/2011 O
Miss Elina Soininen Kokkakatu 4 A 16
Turku
20810 04/08/2011 O
Mr. R. Doffer Koningsspil 16
Wieringerwaard, The Netherlands
1766 KV 23/07/2011 O
Mrs Jennie Stoop Kruizemunthof 6
Barendrecht
2991HG 30/07/2011 O
Mrs Claire Wood La Linnhette
Corpach
Fort William
PH33 7NL 21/07/2011 O
Mr Thomas Eeles Little Mill Cottage
Great Ashfield
Bury St Edmunds IP31 3HJ 23/08/2011 O
Mrs Shirley Dalziel Little Rahane Farm
Rahane
Helensburgh
G840QW 22/07/2011 O
Miss Jan Roylance Llidsey Road
Chichester
PO20 3SU 23/07/2011 O
R M Tapply Loch Caol Cottage
Bunessan
Isle Of Mull
Argyll And Bute
PA67 6DX 26/07/2011 O
Mr Daniel McArthur Long House
Cockermouth
CA13 9TG 17/07/2011 O
Mrs Elaine Heseltine Carp Lower Leigh Farm, TokesLane
East Knoyle
SP3 6EY 18/07/2011 O
Mr W Taylor Lynn Dee
Ganavan Road
Oban
PA34 5TU 26/07/2011 O
Mr Andrew Whitley Macbiehill Farmhouse
Lamancha
West Linton
EH46 7AZ 18/07/2011 O
Mr Ludwig Muendlein Maingasse 10
Sommerhausen
D-97286 17/07/2011 O
Mrs Annette Elgert Maingasse 10
Sommerhausen
D-97286 17/07/2011 O
Mr T Horrocks Market Hill
Georgemas
Halkirk
KW12 6UU 23/07/2011 O
Leonard V McGeoch Master Mariner Rtd
Cluain Siar
Cullipool
Isle Of Luing
PA34 4TX 03/08/2011 O
Bruce Clayton Merrick Cottage
Main Street
Forest Hill
Oxon
OX33 1DZ 03/08/2011 O
Mrs Jane Brooke Merricks Farm
Langport
TA10 0NF 20/07/2011 O
Geoff Bisp Millpark House
Soroba Road
Oban
Argyll And Bute
PA34 4JF 02/08/2011 O
Gillian Bisp Millpark House
Soroba Road
Oban
Argyll And Bute
PA34 4JF 03/08/2011 O
Miss Cara Naden Millview
Thorney
Langport
TA10 0DR 21/07/2011 O
Norman Bissell Mo Dhochaidh
51 Cullipool
Isle Of Luing
Oban
Argyll
PA34 4UB 03/08/2011 O
Dr Stephen Dury Moorfield House
The Hill
Langport
TA10 9PU 18/07/2011 O
Dr Marlene Buchy Moorfield House
The Hill
langport
Ta109PU 19/07/2011 O
Mr Keith Mac Lean Morvargh
Isle of Seil
Oban
PA34 4TJ 18/07/2011 O
Elizabeth C Lyons Morven
Cullipool
Isle Of Luing
Oban
PA34 4TX 03/08/2011 O
Mr Grant Wastle Nettlebush
Drumelzier Place
Broughton
ML12 6JD 18/07/2011 O
Nic Mim No 8 Tinto Place
Edinburgh
EH6 5FJ 03/08/2011 O
C Smith No Address 03/08/2011 O
A Henderson No Address Given 02/08/2011 O
Anna Beckett No Address Given 21/08/2011 O
Barbara Smith No Address Given 01/08/2011 O
Catherin Macrae No Address Given 18/08/2011 O
Colina MacInnes No Address Given 01/08/2011 O
D Windsor No Address Given 14/11/2011 O
Dr C J Stevens No Address Given 30/09/2011 O
Etonella Christlieb Ouwehand No Address Given 25/07/2011 O
Glen Mackie No Address Given 18/08/2011 O
Harry Maskell No Address Given 02/09/2011 O
J Davies No Address Given 02/08/2011 O
J Dickman No Address Given 02/08/2011 O
Jean Wolfe No Address Given 02/08/2011 O
Keith Rogers No Address Given 03/08/2011 O
M E Sandilands No Address Given 01/08/2011 O
Monica Haynes No Address Given 02/08/2011 O
N Windsor No Address Given 14/11/2011 O
Name Illegible No Address Given 04/08/2011 O
P E Millward No Address Given 02/08/2011 O
Rosie And LJ And M And S Nichols No Address Given 05/08/2011 O
Tom Masket No Address Given 02/09/2011 O
Zora King No Address Given 04/08/2011 O
Alistair Henderson Old Clachan Farmhouse
Clachan Seil
By Oban
PA34 4RH 02/08/2011 O
R Henderson Old Clachan Farmhouse
Clachan Seil
By Oban
PA34 4RH 02/08/2011 O
Sarah F G Henderson Old Clachan Farmhouse
Clachan Seil
By Oban
PA34 4RH 02/08/2011 O
Andrew And Susan Durley Olrig
Clachan Seil
By Oban
Argyll
PA34 4TL 03/08/2011 O
Mr Barry Deakin Overtheway
Godshill
Fordingbridge SP6 2JX 01/09/2011 O
Mr Robin Harvey Penwith
Ceum Dhun Righ
Benderloch
PA37 1ST 02/08/2011 O
Miss G J Williams Pintalia
Appin
Argyll And Bute
PA38 4BA 26/07/2011 O
Mr Duncan Monteith-Hodge Pole Position Internet Services Ltd
4 George Street
Oban
Argyll 18/07/2011 O
Cynthia Kirpins Prins Bernhardlaan 146M
2032 ZE Haarlem
The Netherlands 03/08/2011 O
Sebastiaan Koperberg Prinsbernhardlaan 146M
2032 ZE Haarlem
Netherlands 03/08/2011 O
Master Dylan Inglis Raera Farm
Kilninver
Oban
PA34 4UT 31/08/2011 O
Mr James Inglis Raera Farm
Kiilninver
Oban
PA34 4UT 17/08/2011 O
Mr Christopher Liversedge Ravenswood
Kilmelford
PA34 4XD 31/10/2011 O
Mrs Karen Liversedge Ravenswood
Kilmelford
PA34 4XD 30/10/2011 O
H Blakeney Reay Cottage
Clachan Seil
By Oban
PA34 4TL 02/08/2011 O
Mr David Bridge Redesdale House
Skipness
Tarbert
PA29 6YG 19/07/2011 O
Mrs Mary Barnes Rhumore
Drimnin
By Oban
Argyll
PA80 5XZ 26/07/2011 O
Mrs Marion Brown River Vale 24 Drummie Road
Devonside
Tillicoultry
FK13 6HT 18/07/2011 O
Mr Alexander Smart Riverdale, Barran
Kilmore
Oban
PA34 4XR 20/07/2011 O
Mrs B Boston Rose Cottage
Apeton
Church Eaton, Stafford
ST20 0AE 26/07/2011 O
Mr Roger Wright Rudha Croise
Loch Eck
Dunoon
PA23 8SG 21/07/2011 O
Mrs Samantha Jarvis Rye Green
Rye
Puriton
TA7 8BZ 18/07/2011 O
Mr Paul Knight Salmon & Trout Association
Fishmongers' Hall
London
EC4R 9EL 18/07/2011 O
Mrs Elizabeth Ustic School House
Lillingstone Dayrell
Buckingham
MK18 5AP 18/07/2011 O
Dr Kevin Butt School of Built and Natural Environment
Preston
PR1 2HE 18/07/2011 O
Mr Andrew Ottaway Seal Protection Action Group
PO Box 2673
Lewes
BN8 5BZ 25/07/2011 O
Mrs Elizabeth Evans Shore Cottage
Pirnmill
Isle of Arran
KA27 8HP 18/07/2011 O
Ms Jools Bond South Allington House
South Allington
Kingsbridge
TQ7 2NB 28/07/2011 O
Mike Barlow South Cuan
Isle Of Luing
PA34 4TU 03/08/2011 O
Mrs Christine Ferrie Stanton Villa
Camus na ha
Fort william
ph33 7nn 21/07/2011 O
Mr Barry Johnson Stonechat
Mill Lane, Well
Bedale
DL82RX 18/11/2011 O
Mr Richard Ellis Stoneleigh
Thong Lane
Netherthong, Holmfirth
HD9 3EE 18/07/2011 O
Mr Christopher Bromley Stranraer
Carlidnack Lane
Falmouth
TR11 5HE 07/09/2011 O
Mr Jeffrey Banks Strathview Station Road
Abernethy
Perth
PH2 9JS 11/09/2011 O
Mr Gordon Rothero Stronlonag
Glenmassan
Dunoon
PA23 8RA 22/07/2011 O
Mr Anthony Hammock Strumhor
Connel
Oban
PA37 1PJ 20/07/2011 O
Mrs Olga Hammock Strumhor
Connel
Oban
PA37 1PJ 17/07/2011 O
Mr Michael Barlow Sunnybrae
South Cuan, Isle of Luing
Oban
PA34 4TU 18/07/2011 O
Mr. Jack Tempel Swarte Liester 16
Hippolytushoef, the Netheralnds
1777 DT 18/07/2011 O
Mrs. Lilian Verheijen Swarte Liester 16
Hippolytushoef, the Netheralnds
1777 DT 18/07/2011 O
Mrs. Christine Metcalfe Taigh a Luana
Loch Avich
Taynuilt
PA35 1HJ 10/08/2011 O
Mrs Caroline Dingwall Tail Farm
Fowlis Wester
Perth
PH7 3NL 21/07/2011 O
Ms Carol Williams Tancrey
Crieff
PH7 4EA 06/09/2011 O
Mrs Phylis Malcolm Tapsalteerie Cottage
Cullipool
Isle Of Luing
PA34 4UB 04/08/2011 O
Mr Kenneth Campbell The Bank House
10 Main Street
Doune
FK16 6BJ 01/08/2011 O
Mr C D Rose The Bothy Achnaclach
Clachan Seil
Isle Of Seil
Oban
Argyll And Bute
PA34 4TL 26/07/2011 O
Name Illegible The Coach House
Ardmaddy
By Oban
Argyll
PA34 4QY 04/08/2011 O
Mr Nick Barberton The Cottage
woodgreen
fordingbridge
SP62AR 26/07/2011 O
Mr Pol Berguis The Cottage
Forteviot
Perth
PH2 9BT 28/07/2011 O
Erin Inglis The Cottage
Raera Farm
Kilninver
Oban
Argyll
PA34 4UT 10/10/2011 O
Jemma Inglis The Cottage
Raera Farm
Kilninver
Oban
Argyll
PA34 4UT 05/09/2011 O
Justin Brooks The Cottage
Raera Farm
Kilninver
Oban
Argyll
PA34 4UT 05/09/2011 O
Ms Syann Van Niftrik The Cottage
Woodgreen
Fordingbridge
Hants 22/07/2011 O
Dr Jennifer Joy The Croft
Off Haygate Road
Wellington, Telford
TF1 2BW 08/08/2011 O
Mr James Robertson The Four Hollies
Barrack Road
Comrie
PH6 2EQ 25/07/2011 O
Mr Alasdair Steele The Haven
Clachan Seil
Seil Island
PA34 4TN
20/07/2011 O
Douglas Curley The Haven
Clachan
Seil
Oban
PA34 4TN 01/08/2011 O
Mr Allan Eunson The Mews
Torryburn
Kintore
AB51 0XP 30/08/2012 O
Alan Morton The Old Bakehouse
High Street
Denford
Northants
NN14 4EQ 22/08/2011 O
Heather Morton The Old Bakehouse
High Street
Denford
Northants
NN14 4EQ 22/08/2011 O
Prof. Hugo Lentmann The Old Boathouse
Loch Feochan
Oban
PA34 4SF 30/07/2011 O
A R Wands The Old House
Clachan Seil
Oban
PA34 4TL 02/08/2011 O
Hugh Martin The Old House
Clachan Seil
Oban
PA34 4TL 02/08/2011 O
Mr Simon Smith The Old Manse
Dalriach Road
Oban
PA34 5JE 02/08/2011 O
John Jess And M M MacDonald The Old Post Office
1 Breadalbane Terrace
Clachan Seil
PA34 4TL 02/08/2011 O
Mrs Judy Lawson The Old Rectory
Jacobstowe
Okehampton
EX20 3RQ 19/07/2011 O
Mr Henry Middleton The Old Shop
Enford
Pewsey
SN9 6AR 27/08/2011 O
Dr Sue Baker The Rookery
Rookery Road
Blackmore
CM4 0LG 18/07/2011 O
Mrs Janet Perkins The Roost, Leiston Road
Middleton
Saxmundham
IP17 3NS 02/08/2011 O
Mrs Karen Renouf The Shielin
Keillour
Methven
PH1 3RA 20/07/2011 O
Mr Bill Jackson The Smithy, Auchnasaul
The Smithy, Auchnasaul, by Clachan Seil
Oban
PA34 4RH 18/07/2011 O
Lasta King The Swallows
South Cuan
Oban
Argyll
PA34 4TU 04/08/2011 O
Mr Dave Blackham The Tea Gardens
Framilode Passage
Saul
GL2 7LF 17/07/2011 O
Mr Teresa Watts The Tea Gardens
Framilode Passage
Saul
GL2 7LF 17/07/2011 O
Mr Charles Clover The Well House
High St, Dedham
Colchester
CO7 6AB 18/07/2011 O
Ms Catherine Pendreigh The Whins
Ferry Road
Tayinloan
Argyll PA29 6XQ 20/07/2011 O
Mrs Cicely Gill The Yellow Land
Whiting Bay
Isle of Arran
KA27 8PZ 19/07/2011 O
Mrs Valerie Bichener Thornloe Guest House
Albert Road
Oban
PA34 5EJ 21/07/2011 O
John S C Taylor Tigh Innis
Balvicar Bay
Isle Of Seil
PA34 4TE 02/08/2011 O
Mrs Susan Harris Tigh Na Bata
Kilmelford
Oban
PA34 4XA 25/10/2011 O
Mr Mark Carter Tigh na Mara
Bonawe
Oban
PA47 1RL 15/07/2011 O
Mrs Iris Bell Tir Aluinn
Clachan Seil
By Oban
PA34 4TL 03/08/2011 O
Dr Kerry Schofield Tor Cottage
South Brent
TQ10 9HB 03/08/2011 O
Ms Valerie Shakeshaft Tor View
South Brent
Devon
TQ10 9HB 21/07/2011 O
Mr Graham Shakeshaft Tor View
Wrangaton
South Brent Devon
TQ10 9HB 29/07/2011 O
Mr Nicholas Shakeshaft Tor View
Wrangaton
South Brent
TQ10 9HB 22/07/2011 O
Ann Reid Torbeag
Clachan Seil
Oban
Pa34 4TJ 03/08/2011 O
Stuart Reid Torbeag
Clachan Seil
Oban
PA34 4TJ 03/08/2011 O
E Abrol Torosay
Cameron Road
Fort William
PH33 6LH 16/08/2011 O
Mr David Woodhouse Torr Buan house
ULva ferry 17/07/2011 O
 Isle of Mull
PA73 6LY
Mr Mark Struthers Torsa Farmhouse
C/O Ardmaddy Castle
By Oban
PA34 4QY 26/07/2011 O
Mr And Mrs J P Colston Traigh Mhor
Clachan Seil
Isle Of Seil
Oban
Argyll And Bute
PA34 4TJ 26/07/2011 O
M Brown Trevelyan College
Durham University
Durham
DH1 3LN 01/09/2011 O
Mr Mike Forsyth Trinity Cottage
Lempitlaw
Kelso
TD5 8BN 05/09/2011 O
Mr Antony Watkins Tuckers Hill
Frog Lane
Langport
TA10 0NE 09/08/2011 O
James Dinsmore Tulloch Beag
Kilmelford
By Oban
Argyll
PA34 4XA 27/07/2011 O
Mr. Kurt Bourdeaux Vooruitgangsstraat 15
Harelbeke
8530 18/07/2011 O
Mrs Carol Sturrock Wedgewood
Higher Heath
SY13 2HR 04/08/2011 O
Dr Alan Pickering Wellbeck
Pump lane
Springfield, chelmsford
Cm1 6ta 05/08/2011 O
Mrs Susan Turner Werner-Friedmann-Bogen 38
Munich
D-80993 02/08/2011 O
Mr Anthony Compson West Street Farmhouse
Walsham le Willoows
Bury St Edmunds
IP31 3AP 31/08/2011 O
Ms Johanna Storm Rusu Westcroft House
Hebden Bridge Road
Oxenhope, Keighley
BD22 9QJ 18/07/2011 O
Mr John Widdaker Westgate House
Milburn
Penrith
CA10 1TW 27/07/2011 O
John And Flora Anderson Westrioch
Campbeltown
Argyll
PA28 6NT 03/08/2011 O
Mr John Wilson Willowburn
Clachan Seil
Oban
PA34 4TJ 01/08/2011 O
Mrs Alice Wilson Willowburn
Clachan Seil
Oban
PA34 4TJ 01/08/2011 O
Ellie Fidler Woodleigh
Wood Lane
Stanmore Middlesex HA7 4JY 05/08/2011 O
SUPPORTERS:

Mr Michael Stanford 11B Calton Ave

Campbeltown
PA28 6NB 20/02/2013 S
Mr D Fowler 22 St Clair Way
Ardrishaig
Lochgilphead
PA308FB 14/12/2011 S
Mr Ian Armstrong 3 Ardconnel Villa
Rockfield Road
Oban
PA34 5DH 23/01/2013 S
Miss Rosa Downing 48 Soldierstown Road
Aghalee
Craigavon
BT 67 0ES 31/07/2011 S
Master Corey Choudhury- Reid 76 Crestway
London
SW15 5DD 03/09/2011 S
Mr Robin MacLean Morvargh
Clachan Seil
By Oban
PA34 4TJ 28/07/2011 S
Fusion Marine Ltd The Marine Resource Centre
Barcaldine
By Oban
Argyll
Scotland
PA37 1SE 11/02/2013 S
Inverlussa Marine Services Ltd Craignure
Isle of Mull
PA65 6BD 06/03/13 S

OTHER REPRESENTATIONS:

Mr Glenn King 1 St Marys Close

Offton
Ipswich
IP8 4RZ 22/07/2011 R
Mr Joe Kerr West Bank House
West Bank Road
Ardrishaig
PA30 8HB 23/07/2011 R