An Empirical Examinationof Relationship Between Emotional Attachmentand Attitudinal Brand Loyalty Towards Luxury Fashion Brands
An Empirical Examinationof Relationship Between Emotional Attachmentand Attitudinal Brand Loyalty Towards Luxury Fashion Brands
Kaur
DLSU Business & Economics Review (2016) 26(1): 70-80
RESEARCH ARTICLE
Abstract: The consumer feels more loyal to product he or she feels associated with, linked to, and loves. The emotional
attachment has significant influence on attitudinal loyalty. Measuring attitudinal brand loyalty can recognize potential users
who are susceptible in varying scenarios. The economic conditions of India are experiencing a positive change. The number
of high net worth individuals (individuals with investable assets of $1 million or more) in India has shown a noticeable
growth in past few years, according to the Asia-Pacific Wealth Report by Merril Lynch Global Wealth Management and
Capgemini. Asia-Pacific’s high net worth individuals’ population in 2010 has exceeded that of Europe, making it the second
largest market after North America. The media has played a vital role in positioning luxury in the public eye. India is likely
to become a US$4 billion luxury market industry by 2020, according to new estimates (2015) by Luxury Society. This study
aims to examine the empirical relationship of emotional attachment and attitudinal brand loyalty in the perspective of female
consumer towards luxury fashion brands. A cross sectional survey of 240 female customers of five global brands, namely,
Zara, Armani, Guess, Versace, and Calvin-Klein from four major cities of Punjab (India) was conducted. Regression and
Z-Test were used to analyze the data. The perceived significance of emotional attachment and attitudinal brand loyalty is
high in luxury fashion purchase. The emotional attachment positively enhances female consumers’ attitudinal brand loyalty.
Marketing strategy formulation needs special emphasis towards dimensions of emotional attachment, namely, referral influence,
connect with brand, pleasure, and tenderness. Further, they need to strengthen brand reputation, performance and feature
upgradation, purchase intention, and brand synchronization to win attitudinal loyalty in luxury fashion.
The scientific approach to marketing, along with they buy, why they buy it, how they buy it, when they
increased focus on market research, as well as insights buy it, from where they buy it, how often do they buy
on consumer behavior aspects, is the roadmap to it, how often they use it, how they evaluate it after the
sustainable success in present scenario. Consumer purchase and the impact of such evaluations on future
purchase behavior needs thorough examination of what purchases, and how they dispose of it (Schiffman &
Kanuk, 2004, p. 8). Four forces (psychological, social, Brand association creates long term bonding with the
cultural, and personal) act as drivers of consumer customers. The brand may act as social identification
purchase behavior. The increasing role of emotions and status symbol for some consumers, which help in
and feelings for a specific brand or product in buying determining strong consumer brand relationships (Rio,
decisions has been duly acknowledged in consumer Vazquez, & Iglesias, 2001).
research. In brand management, it can be translated into The focus, in brand management, remains upon
consumer brand relationship. It has gained significant representing a promised brand to customers. The brand
attention from both applied and academic perspectives. management aims to attain loyal customers and keep
Strong consumer-brand relationship enhances brand them contented for longer time.
loyalty for specific product or a brand. The strength
of brands even forces a consumer to pay a premium Emotional Attachment
price for a brand name. Consequently, financial value
of the company and the trade name increases, which Brand attachment refers to the extent to which
further leads to strengthening profits and goodwill a consumer is heartily connected to a person or a
(Park, Macinnis, & Priester, 2006). brand that shows their level of engagement to the
association and the level of sacrifices committed
Brand Management towards a relationship (Cheong, 2013; Loureiro,
Ruediger, & Demetris, 2012; Bouhlel, Mzoughi,
The brand act as a medium of social and cultural Hadiji, & Slimane, 2011; Schifferstein & Pelgrim,
reflection for consumers. The strength of consumer 2008; Bauer, Heinrich, & Martin, 2007; Aron &
brand relationships forms the basis for future purchases Westbay, 1996; Collins & Read, 1990; Sternberg,
of the consumers. The positive experience with the 1987). Attachment may vary in strength; stronger
brand encourages the consumer to even sacrifice and positive attachments are associated with stronger
more money for a loved brand (Loureiro, 2013). The and long-term feelings of connection, affection, love,
classification of brands, brand identities, and symbols and passion. Emotional attachment plays a vital role
also influence consumer brand relationships. All these in shaping the consumer brand responses with the
factors depend on the way consumers perceive a brand brand. When a consumer involves himself more to the
that is being classified and how it represents him brand, the future purchase intentions increase (Cheong,
powerfully (Schmitt, 2012). The emotional aspects 2013). Strong brand attachment has a positive effect
positively impact consumer brand relationship; the on brand relationship feelings. The love feelings for
strength of these aspects may vary. The self-concept a brand can strengthen trust for a brand, and when a
improves attitudinal loyalty, which further leads brand or product is trusted, the person feels emotionally
to emotional attachment towards a brand and love attached to him. Loyalty cannot be judged on the basis
for a brand. The brand, which expresses part of an of trust only, but it can be judged on the basis of love
individual, builds deeper relationships. The consumers feelings towards a brand. Enhanced passion and love
will ultimately stay loyal to only those brands which for a brand leads to trust and commitment (Loureiro
represents their identity, whom they feel emotionally et al., 2012). Brand identity plays significant role in
attached and which they feel passionate love (Hwang decision making of consumer for a brand (Bouhlel et
& Kandampully, 2012). The brand relationships are al., 2011). The attachments for brands are not formed
not only limited to emotional aspects but it also talks when consumer experienced different brands. For
about behavioral aspects as well. (Fournier, 2008). measuring product and brand attachment, a scale is
Brand awareness conditions consumer purchase developed which recognizes seven determinants of
pattern but brand knowledge does not influence future attachment: pleasure, memories, places, and occasions,
purchases directly. A positive image for the brand helps support of self-identity, life idea and utility. Out of
in building positive brand relationships and enhanced these seven variables, only two determinants are
satisfaction and brand trust (Esch, Langner, Schmitt, selected for measuring brand attachment, that is, past
& Geus, 2006). As for some consumers, when worth memories and pleasures which contribute positively to
of money spent on the brand is achieved, it creates attachment (Schifferstein & Pelgrim, 2008). Emotions
long term relationship with that specific brand. carry high values in consumer brand relationships.
72 A. Thakur & R. Kaur
pattern must be followed to create brand attachment Kandampully, 2012). The brand relationships are
through which a firm can take reasonable advantages not only limited to emotional aspects but it also
(Park et al., 2006). An outcome of previous research talks about behavioral aspects as well. Emotions and
on emotional attachment is a scale differentiated from behavior of consumers are two different feelings for
the measures of satisfaction, involvement, and brand the consumer (Fournier, 2008). In some context, brand
attitudes. The 10-item scale to measure emotional knowledge and brand relationships are combined and
attachment is categorized as affection, passion and studied together, as brand awareness lead to strengthen
connection (Thomson, Macinnis, & Park, 2005). consumer purchase pattern. But brand knowledge do
not influence future purchases directly. A positive
Influence of Emotional Aspects on Consumer-Brand image for the brand may help in building positive
Relationship brand relationship and enhanced satisfaction and brand
trust (Esch et al., 2006). As for some consumers, when
The consumer-brand relationship is an important worth of the money spent on the brand is achieved it
aspect in brand management. For every marketer, creates long-term relationship with that specific brand.
making loyal customers is the first goal, which helps Brand association brings loyal customers to the firm.
them in attaining stronger position in the market. The brand may act as social identification and status
A good experience with the brand will satisfy the symbol for some consumers, which help in determining
customer who helps in making deep relationships strong consumer brand relationships (Rio et al. 2001).
with the brand. When relationship becomes strong,
the consumer can sacrifice a premium price for a
brand without any promotional strategies adopted Objectives
by the company. Commitment may arise when
relationship becomes strong which further leads to We conducted this research to:
love and attachment towards brands (Sandra, 2013).
The connection and association between brands and • examine the association between attitudinal
consumers helps in identifying strong and deeper brand loyalty and emotional attachment;
relationships. Consumer acts as partners to their loved • measure the influence of emotional attachment
brands. The brands act as a social and cultural concept on attitudinal brand loyalty; and
for consumers. Close relationship towards a brand • study the perceived significance of emotional
leads to emotional connections. Past experiences with attachment and attitudinal brand loyalty for
the brands had a great impact on future purchases of luxury fashion brands.
the consumers. When consumers are satisfied with
their past experiences, they build strong relationships
with the brands and can sacrifice more prices for a Research Methodology
loved brand (Loureiro, 2013). The classification of
brands, brand identities, and symbols do influence The present study emphasizes on understanding
consumer brand relationships. All the factors seem association between emotional attachment and
to be dependent on consumer psychology as to how attitudinal brand loyalty and the influence of emotional
one perceives about a brand and represents him/her attachment on attitudinal brand loyalty. Standardized
suitably (Schmitt, 2012). The emotional aspects had scales on emotional attachment were adapted from
impacted positively on consumer brand relationship. Rubin (1970), Hatfield and Sprecher (1986), Thomson
One significant observation: the self-concept improves et al. (2005), and Sternberg (1986), and attitudinal
attitudinal loyalty which further leads to emotional brand loyalty scale was adapted from Kaynak,
attachment towards a brand and love for a brand. The Salman, and Tatoglu (2008) and Carroll and Ahuvia
brand, which expresses part of an individual, builds (2006) and after thorough literature review (Loureiro,
deeper relationships. The consumers will ultimately 2013; Cheong, 2013; Sandra, 2013; Xinting, Fangyi,
stay loyal to only those brands, which represent & Xiaofen (2013); Kesari & Srivastatava, 2012;
their identity, whom they feel emotionally attached Bouhlel et al., 2011; Senel, 2011; Loureiro, 2011;
and for which they feel passionate love (Hwang & Rio et al., 2001) and expert surveys, new dimensions
74 A. Thakur & R. Kaur
constituting constructs of attitudinal brand loyalty shopping from the selected stores. The female buyer,
(Brand Reputation, Performance and Features, Brand an emerging consumer segment in vari ous brands, has
Superiority, Preference, Willingness to Pay, Brand been ignored in previous brand management literature.
Endorsements, Brand Synchronization, Brand Faith, Moreover, the earning power of female consumer
Brand Intensity, Satisfaction) were included to widen has increased, and this female consumer group has
the scope of investigation (shown in Annex 1). The final appeared as an imperative consumer segment, even for
research instrument was assessed for reliability and luxury fashion brands. No preceding work has tested
validity and was found satisfactory. The evaluation of the absolute relationships of emotional attachment in
multi-item scale used in the research is the pre-requisite the context of brand relationship management with
to ensure accuracy and applicability with the aim to female consumers. To generate implications of specific
reduce the measurement error, that is, the variation segment, the study was restricted to females only.
in the information we sought and the information A self-administered, well-structured, pre-tested and
generated by the measurement process (Malhotra, undisguised questionnaire has been used for primary
2015). Hence, validity and reliability of constructs data collection. Instrument was divided into three parts,
have been tested to ensure the measurement accuracy Part I included the introductory questions related to
of instrument. The content or face validity has been brand ownership and usage pattern, shopping place,
tested from eminent academicians for examining purchase pattern, repeat purchase behavior, factors
whether the scale items adequately cover the entire considered while purchasing, sources of information,
domain of the construct being measured or not, factors motivating purchase, and family and friends
whereas reliability testing has been done to find out preferences. Part II included the questions related to
the extent to which a scale produces consistent results emotional aspects and attitudinal loyalty. Further, these
in repeated measurements. The internal consistency concepts have different statements (refer to Annex 1)
reliability has been computed by measuring coefficient which have been asked on five point Likert scale. Part
alpha or Cronbach’s alpha (α) based on averaging III contained the questions related to demographic
of all possible split-half coefficients resulting from profile: age, occupation, income, education and
different splitting of scale items through statistical qualification.
software. The rule of thumb that applies is that α>0.9 Demographic Profiling: About 79.2% respondents
(excellent), α>0.8 (good), α>0.7 (acceptable), α>0.6 were aged between 18-30 years, 17.5% were between
(questionable), α>0.5 (poor) and α <0.5 will be 31-40, 2.9% were between 41-50 years old and 0.4%
unacceptable (George & Mallery, 2011). The statistical were above 50. About 19.2% respondents have family
software SPSS has been used to find out Cronbach’s income below 4 Lacs per annum, 46.7% have family
alpha (α) as a measure of internal consistency for income between 4 Lacs-8 Lacs, 29.2% have family
various constructs used in the instruments. The value income between 8 Lacs-12 Lacs and 5% have above
of the Cronbach’s Alpha was 0.753 approving the 12 Lacs of annual family income.
instrument for detailed investigation. Data collected The selection of cities is on the basis of luxury
was analyzed with Regression and one sample Z Test. A fashion brands availability. The selected stores for the
cross sectional survey of 240 female customers of five sample are Guess, Zara, Armani, Versace, and Calvin
global brands, namely, Zara, Armani, Guess, Versace Klein (Fashion Revealed, 2013). Owing to constraint
and Calvin-Klein from four major cities (Jalandhar, of unavailability of few brands in selected cities, the
Amritsar, Chandigarh and Ludhiana) of Punjab (India) number of respondents varied for each of the selected
was conducted. The method of survey administration brands in each city (shown in Table I).
was personal interviews with the female buyers
Emotional Attachment and Attitudinal Brand Loyalty Towards Luxury Fashion Brands 75
Interpretation. The correlation matrix states that the Perceived Significance of Emotional Attachment
paired correlation among the emotional attachment and
attitudinal brand loyalty is more than .70, which shows Table 6 endorses the significance of all emotional
that there is a positive correlation between emotional attachment aspects in luxury fashion purchase with
attachment and attitudinal brand loyalty. high Z values and p value of 0.000 leading to rejection
of Ho in favor of alternative hypothesis. Minute
Regression. Dependent variable is attitudinal observation (Mean) endorses the prominent role of
brand loyalty and independent variable is emotional referrals, brand connect, pleasure, and tenderness
attachment. among all variables.
Table 4. Correlation and Regression Analysis Perceived Significance of Attitudinal Brand Loyalty
Bothra, N. (2013). Luxury, luxury brand and luxury market Loureiro, S.M.C. (2013). Consumer-brand relationship:
in India: From class consumers to closet consumers. Foundation and state-of-the-art. In A. Editor, & B.
Journal of Business and Management, 15(1), 18–27. Editor (Ed.), Book title (pp. xx-xx). Place of publication:
Carroll, B. A., & Ahuvia, A. C. (2006). Some antecedents Publisher. Retrieved from http://www.irma-international.
and outcomes of brand love. Marketing Letters, 17(2), org/chapter/consumer-brand-relationship/71079/
79–89. M. (2013). Rank 1: Top 10 Apparel Brands in the World 2013
Cheong, L. H. (2013). An exploration of antecedents and | MBA Skool-Study.Learn.Share. Retrieved from http://
consequences of brand attachment among a cross www.mbaskool.com/fun-corner/top-brand-lists/7708-
section of Malaysian consumers. Journal of Asian Social top-10-apparel-brands-in-the-world-2013.html?start=9
Science, 9(5). doi: 10.5539/ass.v9n5p263 Malhotra, N. K. (2015). Marketing research: An applied
Collins, N. L., & Read, S. J. (1990). Adult Attachment, orientation (6th ed.). India: Pearson.
working models, and relationship quality in dating Park, C. W., Macinnis, J. D., & Priester, J. (2006). Brand
couples. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, attachment: Constructs, consequences, and causes.
58(4), 644–663. Foundations and Trends in Marketing, 1(3), 191–230.
Esch, F. R., Langner, T., Schmitt, B. H., & Geus, P. (2006), Rio, A. B., Vazquez, R., & Iglesias, V. (2001). The effects
Are brands forever? How brand knowledge and of brand associations on consumer response. Journal of
relationships affect current and future purchases. Journal Consumer Marketing, 18(5), 410–425.
of Product & Brand Management, 15(2), 98–105. Rubin, Z. (1970). Measurement of romantic love. Journal
Fournier, S. M. (2008). Lessons learned about consumers’ of Personality and Social Psychology, 16(2), 265–273.
relationships with brand (2008-3). United States of S. (2013). Top 10 best luxury clothing brands in the world
America: University of Boston. - Listaka. Retrieved from http://listaka.com/top-10-best-
George, D., & Mallery, P. (2011). IBM SPSS statistics 19 luxury-clothing-brands-in-the-world/
step by step: A simple guide and reference. USA: Pearson Sandra, M. C. (2013), The remarkable consumer experience
Higher Education. of brands as drivers to a deep consumer brand-
Hatfield, E., & Sprecher, S. (1986). Measuring passionate relationship, Journal of Branding, pp.39-52.
love in intimate relationships. Journal of Adolescence, Schiffman, L. G., & Kanuk, L. L. (2004). Consumer
9, 384-410. behaviour (8th ed.). New Delhi, India: Prentice Hall of
Hwang, J., & Kandampully, J. (2012). The role of emotional India Private Ltd.
aspects in younger consumer-brand relationships. Schifferstein, N. J., & Pelgrim, P. H. (2008). Consumer-
Journal of Product & Brand Management, 21(2), product attachment: Measurement and design
98–108. implications. International Journal of Design, 2(3), 1-13.
Kaynak, E., Salman, G. G., & Tatoglu, E. (2008). An Schmitt, B. H. (2012). The consumer psychology of brands.
integrative framework linking brand associations and Journal of Consumer Psychology, 22, 7–17.
brand loyalty in professional sports. Journal of Brand Senel, J. (2011). An approach to measuring brand loyalty in
Management, 15(5), 336–357. the Turkish automotive sector. Journal of Economy and
Kearney, A. T. (2013). Research and analysis: Projected Society, 30(2), 137–154.
growth of luxury market in India. Retrieved from http:// Sternberg, R. J. (1987). Liking vs. loving: A comparative
www.atkearney.in/research-studies evaluation of theories Psychological Bulletin, 102(3),
Kesari, R., & Srivastatava, A. K. (2012). Retail luxury brand 331–345.
in India: Consumer market. International Journal of Sternberg, R. J. (1986). A triangular theory of love.
Marketing, Financial Services & Management Research, Psychological Review, 93(2), 119–135.
1(7), 218–228. Thomson, M., MacInnis, D., & Park, C. (2005). The ties that
Khare, A., & Handa, M. (2009).Role of individual self bind: Measuring the strength of consumers’ emotional
concept & brand personality congruence in determining attachment to brands. Journal of Consumer Psychology,
brand choice. Innovative Marketing, 5(4), 1-9. 15(1), 531–547.
Loureiro, S. M. C. (2011). Consumer’s love and willingness Xinting, R., Fangyi, S., & Xiaofen, J. (2013), A comparative
to sacrifice for brand. In A. Editor (Ed.), Proceedings analysis between brand attachment and similar constructs
of the title (pp. xx-xx). Portugal: University of like brand attitude. Proceedings of the International
Aveiro. Retrieved from https://www.researchgate.net/ Conference on Educational Research and Sports
publication/233925456 Education. China: Atlantis Press.
Loureiro, S. M. C., Ruediger, K. H., & Demetris, V. (2012).
Brand emotional connection and loyalty. Journal of
Brand Management, 20(1), 1–15. Retrieved from https://
www.researchgate.net/publication/233924863
80 A. Thakur & R. Kaur
Annex 1