Preventing Weight Regain After Weight Loss (Anton y Perri, 2025)
Preventing Weight Regain After Weight Loss (Anton y Perri, 2025)
FIGURE 25.1 A typical pattern of weight change observed in lifestyle treatment without follow-up
intervention. (Based on data from the Weight Loss Maintenance Trial [10]).
http://e.pub/q7ttidenuwfu3u7j0bh5.vbk/OEBPS/xhtml/c25.xhtml 21/11/2024
Chapter 25 - Preventing Weight Regain after Weight Loss Page 2 of 11
http://e.pub/q7ttidenuwfu3u7j0bh5.vbk/OEBPS/xhtml/c25.xhtml 21/11/2024
Chapter 25 - Preventing Weight Regain after Weight Loss Page 3 of 11
unfavorable cost-benefit ratio, coupled with negative thoughts and feelings and a lack of support from others, may lead to an
abandonment of the entire weight-control effort [17, 33, 34].
In the following sections, we provide brief descriptions of selected randomized clinical trials (RCTs, published between January
1, 2016, and July 1, 2021) that examined the effects of interventions designed to enhance long-term weight outcomes. We focus
on trials that included: (a) a lifestyle core to produce initial changes in diet and physical activity, (b) randomized assignment to
an experimental intervention/maintenance program or an appropriate control/comparison condition, (c) an initial weight loss
>5% of baseline weight, and (d) a follow-up conducted >12 months from baseline (see Table 25.1).
TABLE 25.1 Randomized Trials of Interventions Designed to Enhance Maintenance of Lost Weight
Intervention type
Diet and exercise interventions
Initial Randomized Follow-up at end of
Study Sample Additional follow-up
treatment conditions maintenance program
Mean Mean Mean Mean
N BMI Months change Months
Retention change
Months
Retention change
Author from from from
(total) (kg/m2) from (%) from (%) from
baseline baseline baseline
atbaseline baseline baseline baseline
Carter et al. 137 35.0 3 –6.3 kg Intermittent energy 12 70% –7.1 kg 24 61% –4.4 kg
[36] restriction (overall)
37.0 3 –5.2kg Continuous energy 12 –4.6 kg 24 –3.6 kg
restriction
Christensen 153 34.0 16 –10.3 kg Intermittent use of 52 70% –9.6 kg None NA NA
et al. [37] low-calorie diet
(810 kcal/day) for 3
periods per year,
each lasting 5
weeks
32.6 –10.6 kg Availability of 52 71% –8.9 kg None NA NA
formula diet
products as
substitutes for 1-2
meals per day
Kaikkonen 120 35.7 3 –9.1ab kg Behavioral treatment 9 75% –8.7a kg 24 70% –5.5ab kg
et al. [41] (overall)
36.1 3 a
–9.2 kg Behavioral treatment 9 a
–10.0 kg 24 77% –8.5a kg
+ exercise (0–3 mo)
36.5 3 –6.1b kg Behavioral treatment 9 –6.9a kg 24 73% –4.4b kg
+ exercise (6–9 mo)
36.9 3 –0.8c kg Control 9 0.0b kg 24 63% 0.9c kg
Madjd et al. 71 33.7 (overall) 6 –8.5 kg Hypocaloric diet + 18 77% –10.2a kg None NA NA
[39] water
6 –7.6 kg Hypocaloric diet + 18 81% –7.8b kg None NA NA
diet beverage
Raben et al. 2223 35.7 2 –11.0* kg High protein/low 34 52% (overall) range across None NA NA
[43] (overall) glycemic index diet four groups
+ high-intensity = –4.6 to
exercise –4.9 kg
http://e.pub/q7ttidenuwfu3u7j0bh5.vbk/OEBPS/xhtml/c25.xhtml 21/11/2024
Chapter 25 - Preventing Weight Regain after Weight Loss Page 4 of 11
Intervention type
Diet and exercise interventions
Initial Randomized Follow-up at end of
Study Sample Additional follow-up
treatment conditions maintenance program
Mean Mean Mean Mean
N BMI Months change Months
Retention change
Months
Retention change
Author from from from
(total) (kg/m2) from (%) from (%) from
baseline baseline baseline
atbaseline baseline baseline baseline
35.1 2 High protein/low 34 None NA NA
glycemic index diet 34
+ moderate
intensity exercise
35.0 2 Moderate None NA NA
protein/moderate
glycemic index diet
+ high-intensity
exercise
35.7 2 Moderate 34 None NA NA
protein/moderate
glycemic index diet
+ moderate
intensity exercise
Washburn et 235 31.8 3 -9.7 kg 150 min/wk of 15 74% (overall) –8.6 kg None NA NA
al. [42] moderate-to-
vigorous intensity
exercise
32.1 3 –9.4 kg 225 min/wk of 15 –6.2 kg None NA NA
moderate-to-
vigorous intensity
exercise
31.7 3 –9.3 kg 300 min/wk of 15 –6.5 kg None NA NA
moderate-to-
vigorous intensity
exercise
Extended care interventions
Befort et al. 172 33.5 6 –12.2* kg Group phone 18 87% –8.9a kg None NA NA
[48] counseling
34.5 6 –13.2* kg Newsletter 18 92% –8.3b kg None NA NA
comparison
Coughlin et 745 33.6 6 –7.9 kg Personal 36 94% ~–4.2a kg 66 83% ~ –2.9a kg
al. [51] contact—active
34.1 –7.9 kg Personal 36 94% ~–4.2a kg 66 84% ~ –3.6a kg
contact—control#
34.1 6 –8.2 kg Self-directed care 36 93% ~ –2.9b kg 66 84% ~ –1.6b kg
Dutton et al. 108 34.93 4 –7.5 kg Clustered campaign 16 87% –7.3a kg None NA NA
[47] maintenance
program
35.26 4 –7.6 kg Self-directed care 16 89% –5.4b kg None NA NA
http://e.pub/q7ttidenuwfu3u7j0bh5.vbk/OEBPS/xhtml/c25.xhtml 21/11/2024
Chapter 25 - Preventing Weight Regain after Weight Loss Page 5 of 11
Intervention type
Diet and exercise interventions
Initial Randomized Follow-up at end of
Study Sample Additional follow-up
treatment conditions maintenance program
Mean Mean Mean Mean
N BMI Months change Months
Retention change
Months
Retention change
Author from from from
(total) (kg/m2) from (%) from (%) from
baseline baseline baseline
atbaseline baseline baseline baseline
34.5 6 –10.2 kg Behavioral therapy + 18 75% –12.4 kg None NA NA
physical activity
emphasis
35.1 6 –10.5 kg Standard behavioral 18 64% –10.2 kg None NA NA
therapy
Daubenmier 194 35.4 6 –5.2 kg Lifestyle (diet + 18 76% –5.0 kg None NA NA
et al. [54] exercise) treatment (overall)
+ mindfulness
35.6 6 –4.0 kg Lifestyle (diet + –3.2 kg None NA NA
exercise) treatment
only
Knauper et 172 28-45 (range) 12 –10.6 kg Enhanced (habit 24 57% –4.9 kg None NA NA
al. [52, formation) Diabetes
53] Prevention Program
intervention
12 –6.0 kg Standard Diabetes 24 69% –2.5 kg None NA NA
Prevention Program
intervention
Lillis et al. 162 37.5 12 –8.9 kg Acceptance-based 24 78% –4.3 kg None NA NA
[55] behavioral
intervention
37.7 –9.7 kg Standard behavioral 79% –2.6 kg None NA NA
treatment
Lillis et al. 102 34.5 3 –10.3a kg Acceptance 6 94% –9.8a kg 24 79% –7.0a kg
[56] commitment
therapy workshop +
3 monthly phone
calls + weekly
emails during
months 4 to 6
34.2 3 –10.0a kg Self-regulation 94% –9.1a kg 24 79% –4.0ab kg
workshop + 3
monthly phone calls
+ weekly emails
during months 4 to
6
34.4 3 –7.1b kg Weekly emails during 71% –6.2b kg 24 59% –1.1b kg
months 4 to 6
(control group)
Technology-enhanced interventions
Conroy et 194 30.9 12 (prior to -9.0 kg Electronic-Health 12 Not reported –8.4 kg 24 83% –6.9a kg
al. [61] start of (verified Record-based
trial) during weight-
prior year) management tools
and tracking +
personalized health
coaching
29.8 12 (prior to –10.2 kg Electronic Health 12 Not reported –8.3 kg 24 81% –5.3b kg
start of (verified Record-based
trial) during weight-
prior yr) management tools
and tracking only
Hagerman 301 28–45 (range) 6 6.1 kg Web-based 18 77% 5.0 kg 30 73% 3.8 kg
et al. [60] intervention +
professional
counseling via
email (months 6
–18)
6 5.1 kg Web-based 18 72% 4.9 kg 30 67% 4.1 kg
intervention plus
peer-led discussion
board (months 6
–18)
6 5.6 kg Web-based 18 81% 4.7 kg 30 76% 4.2 kg
intervention only
Jakicic et al. 471 31.5 6 –8.6 kg Technology-enhanced 24 76% –3.5b kg None NA NA
[64] behavioral
treatment
30.9 6 –8.0 kg Standard behavioral 24 73% –5.9a kg None NA NA
treatment
http://e.pub/q7ttidenuwfu3u7j0bh5.vbk/OEBPS/xhtml/c25.xhtml 21/11/2024
Chapter 25 - Preventing Weight Regain after Weight Loss Page 6 of 11
Intervention type
Diet and exercise interventions
Initial Randomized Follow-up at end of
Study Sample Additional follow-up
treatment conditions maintenance program
Mean Mean Mean Mean
N BMI Months change Months
Retention change
Months
Retention change
Author from from from
(total) (kg/m2) from (%) from (%) from
baseline baseline baseline
atbaseline baseline baseline baseline
Sniehotta et 288 30.9 <12 –12.6 kg Technology-mediated, 12 91% –10.8 kg None NA NA
al. [62] low-intensity
maintenance
program (e.g.,
wirelessly
connected scales +
text messages)
30.8 <12 –14.4 kg Lifestyle advice via 12 92% –12.6 kg None NA NA
newsletter
Young et al. 92 33.0 (overall) 3 –7.3 kg Gender-tailored 9 83% (overall) –7.6a kg 39 71% (overall) –4.3 kg
[63] maintenance
program delivered
via text messages
and emails with
videos
3 –7.4 kg Control (no resources) 9 –5.8b kg 39 –3.8kg
Conroy et 194 30.9 12 (prior to –9.0 kg Electronic-Health 12 Not reported –8.4 kg 24 83% –6.9a kg
al. [61] start of (verified Record-based
trial) during weight-
prior year) management tools
and tracking +
personalized health
coaching
29.8 12 (prior to –10.2 kg Electronic Health 12 Not reported –8.3 kg 24 81% –5.3b kg
start of (verified Record-based
trial) during weight-
prior yr) management tools
and tracking only
Pharmacological interventions
Lundgren et 195 37.0 (overall) 2* –13.1 kg Liraglutide + 14 92% ~ –16.5a kg None NA NA
al. [68] (overall) moderate-to-
vigorous intensity
exercise
2* Liraglutide + usual 14 84% ~ –13.8ab kg None NA NA
physical activity
2* Placebo + moderate- 14 83% ~ –11.1b kg None NA NA
to-vigorous
intensity exercise
2* Placebo + usual 14 82% ~ –7.0c kg None NA NA
physical activity
Manning et 221 37.5 4 –7.1 kg Cabergoline 28 92% –2.4 kg None NA NA
al. [65]
37.3 4 –7.3 kg Placebo 28 88% –2.5 kg None NA NA
Rubino et 803 34.5 5 –11.1 kg Semaglutide (68 16 99% –18.2a kg None NA NA
al. [66] weeks) + lifestyle
counseling (16
monthly sessions)
34.1 5 –11.1 kg Semaglutide (20 16 97% –5.0b kg None NA NA
weeks) followed by
placebo (48 weeks)
+ lifestyle
counseling (16
monthly sessions)
Wadden et 611 38.1 16* –17.1a kg Semaglutide + NA NA NA None NA NA
al. [67] intensive lifestyle
counseling (30
sessions)
37.8 16* –5.9b kg Placebo + intensive NA NA NA None NA NA
lifestyle counseling
(30 sessions)
http://e.pub/q7ttidenuwfu3u7j0bh5.vbk/OEBPS/xhtml/c25.xhtml 21/11/2024
Chapter 25 - Preventing Weight Regain after Weight Loss Page 7 of 11
two non-consecutive days/week) or to a continuous restriction diet (1200–1500 kcal/day on all days). Over the course of 24
months, both approaches produced similar changes in body weight.
Christensen and colleagues [37] examined the effects of intermittent low-calorie dieting in older adults with knee
osteoarthritis. Participants who previously achieved a mean weight loss of 10.5 kg were randomized to either an “intermittent”
diet (810 kcal/day), consisting of three, 5-week weight-loss intervals per year, or to a “regular” diet group with daily use of 1–2
meal replacements. Over the course of 3 years, weight regains in both conditions were relatively small, and the between-group
difference was not significant.
A topic of popular debate centers on the assertion that artificially sweetened beverages increase hunger and contribute to
weight gain [38]. If so, a reduction in diet drink consumption might assist in weight management. Madjd and colleagues [39]
randomly assigned women who were regular consumers of diet drinks either to continue their consumption of diet beverages or
to substitute water for diet drinks. During a 12-month maintenance period, the group that substituted water achieved a small but
significantly greater additional weight reduction than the diet beverage group.
Few trials have demonstrated improved long-term weight changes based on randomized assignments to different exercise
prescriptions [40]. Kaikkonen and colleagues [41] examined whether the addition or timing of 3 months of a supervised circuit
(resistance) training might improve weight-loss outcomes. Participants were assigned randomly to behavioral treatment (a)
without exercise, (b) with supervised circuit training during months 0–3, (c) with supervised circuit training during months 6–9,
or to (d) a no-treatment control group. All three active treatments (groups a, b, and c) produced greater weight changes than the
control group. The introduction of exercise during months 0–3 resulted in better long-term weight changes than the exercise
introduced during months 6–9. However, the inclusion of exercise failed to improve short- or long-term weight outcomes versus
behavioral treatment without exercise.
Washburn and colleagues [42] tested the effects of different levels of moderate-to-vigorous intensity exercise to reduce weight
regain following an initial three-month, weight-loss intervention. Participants who achieved a clinically meaningful weight loss
(>5% of baseline weight) were randomly assigned to one of three 12-month conditions that included behavioral treatments plus
150, 225, or 300 min/wk of exercise. Higher volumes of exercise failed to produce better weight loss maintenance.
In a multi-center trial that employed a two-by-two (diet by exercise) design, Raben and colleagues [43] randomized adults
with prediabetes to one of two diet conditions (high protein/low glycemic index versus moderate protein/moderate glycemic
index) crossed with two exercise conditions (high versus moderate intensity). Over the course of 3 years, no significant effects on
body weight were observed for diet or exercise or the interaction of diet and exercise.
http://e.pub/q7ttidenuwfu3u7j0bh5.vbk/OEBPS/xhtml/c25.xhtml 21/11/2024
Chapter 25 - Preventing Weight Regain after Weight Loss Page 8 of 11
participants who had previously received extended care via personal contacts to receive an additional 30-month program or no
further intervention. Participants who received the additional contacts did not experience any incremental weight-loss benefit
compared to those who had no further contact. Nonetheless, a small but statistically significant weight-loss advantage for
randomization to the in-person contact condition from the original trial was detected at the 66-month follow-up assessment.
http://e.pub/q7ttidenuwfu3u7j0bh5.vbk/OEBPS/xhtml/c25.xhtml 21/11/2024
Chapter 25 - Preventing Weight Regain after Weight Loss Page 9 of 11
In a trial that provided a maintenance program tailored to men, Young and colleagues [63] randomized participants who had
lost >4 kg to a control group that received no additional resources or to a 6-month, gender-tailored maintenance program that
included a DVD containing weight-loss maintenance lessons, a self-monitoring log book, a pedometer, and free access to
websites for self-monitoring of diet and physical activity, coupled with weekly motivational text messages. No significant
between-group differences were evident at 1- or 3-year follow-ups.
Jakicic and colleagues [64] tested the hypothesis that compared with a standard treatment, a technology-enhanced weight-loss
intervention would result in greater long-term weight loss. Young adults (between the ages of 21–35 years) who completed
lifestyle treatment were randomly assigned to a “standard” intervention with web-based self-monitoring of diet and physical
activity or to a “technology-enhanced” intervention that included a wearable device and accompanying web interface to monitor
diet and physical activity. Contrary to the researchers’ hypothesis, the standard program demonstrated a significantly larger mean
weight loss at month 24 than the technology-enhanced intervention (5.9 versus 3.5 kg, respectively).
25.4 CONCLUSIONS
The findings from RCTs reviewed in this chapter generally support the AHA/ACC/TOS Guidelines [1], which recommend that
programs for the prevention of weight regain include a reduced-calorie diet, a high level of exercise, extended care by a trained
interventionist, and ongoing self-monitoring of weight and energy intake.
http://e.pub/q7ttidenuwfu3u7j0bh5.vbk/OEBPS/xhtml/c25.xhtml 21/11/2024
Chapter 25 - Preventing Weight Regain after Weight Loss Page 10 of 11
25.4.2 Exercise
The Guidelines recommend high levels of aerobic physical activity (>200 min/wk) for weight loss maintenance [1]. However,
much of the evidence supporting this recommendation is correlational in nature, showing that higher levels of exercise are
associated with greater maintenance of lost weight [40]. RCTs that prescribe higher levels of exercise commonly fail to show
effects based on randomized assignment, often due to poor adherence by participants to the regimen they were prescribed [40]. In
the current review, prescriptions for high-intensity exercise [43], higher volumes of exercise [42], and the inclusion of resistance
training [41], all failed to produce improvements in long-term weight loss.
25.4.4 Self-Monitoring
Ongoing monitoring of weight, food intake, and physical activity is commonly associated with long-term success in weight
management [1, 3, 7]. Technological innovations have the potential to facilitate the tracking of key weight-management
behaviors [58, 59]. However, two RCTs [62, 64] failed to show the benefits of low-intensity technologies or wearable devices for
ongoing monitoring of diet or weight. Ongoing tracking alone may not be sufficient to enhance maintenance. The use of EHRs to
deliver personalized coaching produced significantly better maintenance of lost weight compared with the use of EHRs for
tracking without coaching [61]. Interestingly, the addition of professional guidance via email or group support via message
boards did not enhance the maintenance of weight loss for participants in a web-based lifestyle intervention [60] nor did the
inclusion of a technology resource pack that included access to a website for tracking diet and exercise combined with
motivational text messages [63]. Thus, the promise of technology-based interventions to enhance the maintenance of weight loss
largely remains unfulfilled.
25.4.6 Pharmacotherapy
The use of the centrally acting pharmacological agents, cabergoline [65] did not improve the maintenance of weight loss, but the
use of GLP-1 receptor agonists, liraglutide [68] and semaglutide [66, 67] did. These agents increase insulin production and slow
gastric emptying, thereby increasing satiety and decreasing appetite. The RCTs of semaglutide yielded particularly impressive
results, each with mean weight losses >17 kg after 68 weeks [66, 67]. The effects and side effects associated with longer-term
use of semaglutide have yet to be determined. Nonetheless, the success of semaglutide as a maintenance agent, as well as a
component of initial treatment, represents a significant advance toward the prevention of weight regain.
25.5 SUMMARY
This selective review of recent RCTs provides support for the effectiveness of two distinct approaches to weight-loss
maintenance. Structured programs of extended care provided by trained interventionists can help participants sustain lifestyle
changes in diet and exercise and thereby reduce the regaining of lost weight. Alternatively, the ongoing use of semaglutide,
increases satiety, decreases appetite, and produces large short- and long-term weight losses. Collectively, the findings from this
review indicate that with appropriate intervention, the prevention of weight regain following weight loss is indeed achievable.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We thank Christian McLaren, Nancy Schaefer, Meena Shankar, and Pati Vial for their technical assistance in the preparation of
this chapter.
REFERENCES
http://e.pub/q7ttidenuwfu3u7j0bh5.vbk/OEBPS/xhtml/c25.xhtml 21/11/2024
Chapter 25 - Preventing Weight Regain after Weight Loss Page 11 of 11
http://e.pub/q7ttidenuwfu3u7j0bh5.vbk/OEBPS/xhtml/c25.xhtml 21/11/2024