Naltrexone-Bupropion Obesity Guidance
Naltrexone-Bupropion Obesity Guidance
Your responsibility
The recommendations in this guidance represent the view of NICE, arrived at after careful
consideration of the evidence available. When exercising their judgement, health professionals are
expected to take this guidance fully into account, alongside the individual needs, preferences and
values of their patients. The application of the recommendations in this guidance are at the
discretion of health professionals and their individual patients and do not override the
responsibility of healthcare professionals to make decisions appropriate to the circumstances of
the individual patient, in consultation with the patient and/or their carer or guardian.
Commissioners and/or providers have a responsibility to provide the funding required to enable
the guidance to be applied when individual health professionals and their patients wish to use it, in
accordance with the NHS Constitution. They should do so in light of their duties to have due regard
to the need to eliminate unlawful discrimination, to advance equality of opportunity and to reduce
health inequalities.
© NICE 2020. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- Page 2 of
conditions#notice-of-rights). 17
Naltrexone–bupropion for managing overweight and obesity (TA494)
Contents
1 Recommendations ...................................................................................................................................................... 4
Price ................................................................................................................................................................................................... 5
Analysis ............................................................................................................................................................................................ 8
Other considerations.................................................................................................................................................................. 14
Conclusion ...................................................................................................................................................................................... 15
© NICE 2020. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- Page 3 of
conditions#notice-of-rights). 17
Naltrexone–bupropion for managing overweight and obesity (TA494)
1 Recommendations
1.1 Naltrexone–bupropion is not recommended within its marketing authorisation
for managing overweight and obesity in adults alongside a reduced-calorie diet
and increased physical activity.
Obesity is very common in England, affecting about 30% of the population. Current management
for overweight and obesity is lifestyle measures alone, lifestyle measures with orlistat or bariatric
surgery.
Clinical trial evidence shows that naltrexone–bupropion with lifestyle measures is more effective
than lifestyle measures alone, but its long-term effectiveness is unknown.
The estimate of cost effectiveness for naltrexone–bupropion with lifestyle measures, compared
with lifestyle measures alone, is highly uncertain because of uncertainties in the modelling
assumptions. Large numbers of people could be eligible for treatment which could potentially be
long-term, leading to high overall costs for naltrexone–bupropion. Therefore, in these
circumstances more certainty is needed that naltrexone–bupropion will provide value for the NHS.
© NICE 2020. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- Page 4 of
conditions#notice-of-rights). 17
Naltrexone–bupropion for managing overweight and obesity (TA494)
2 The technology
Marketing authorisation
2.1 Adjunct to a reduced-calorie diet and increased physical activity,
Naltrexone–bupropion (Mysimba) is indicated for the management of weight in
adult patients (aged 18 and over) with an initial BMI of
Treatment should be stopped after 16 weeks if the patient has not lost at least 5% of
their initial body weight.
Price
2.3 Acquisition cost (excluding VAT) £73.00 per pack of 112 tablets (source:
company's submission). Costs may vary in different settings because of
negotiated procurement discounts.
© NICE 2020. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- Page 5 of
conditions#notice-of-rights). 17
Naltrexone–bupropion for managing overweight and obesity (TA494)
3 Committee discussion
The appraisal committee (section 4) considered evidence submitted by Orexigen Therapeutics and
a review of this submission by the evidence review group (ERG). See the committee papers for full
details of the evidence.
© NICE 2020. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- Page 6 of
conditions#notice-of-rights). 17
Naltrexone–bupropion for managing overweight and obesity (TA494)
Duration of treatment
Treatment for obesity is likely to be recurrent or ongoing
3.5 The patient expert explained that people who are overweight or obese can be
caught in a cycle of weight loss and regain, which can be psychologically
distressing. The clinical expert noted that when people stop treatment they do
© NICE 2020. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- Page 7 of
conditions#notice-of-rights). 17
Naltrexone–bupropion for managing overweight and obesity (TA494)
not continue to lose weight and many will regain weight. The clinical expert also
noted that long-term treatment with naltrexone–bupropion is likely to be
necessary for many people, to maximise the likelihood of maintaining weight
loss. The committee concluded that this would likely lead to long-term or
recurrent treatment with naltrexone–bupropion for many people.
Analysis
A full intention-to-treat analysis is more appropriate
3.6 The committee had concerns over the use of a modified intention-to-treat (ITT)
analysis and noted this included people who had at least one post-baseline
measurement of weight while on the study drug. This removed around 20% of
people from the analysis, whereas the full ITT population included as many
people as possible from the point of randomisation into the trial (including all
people who dropped out, whether or not a post-baseline weight measurement
was taken). The ERG explained that a modified ITT analysis could bias results in
favour of naltrexone–bupropion, because drop-out before the first assessment
point could have been as a result of people stopping treatment because of
intolerance or adverse events related to the study drug. The committee agreed
that the full ITT analysis was more appropriate for decision-making.
Trial results
Trials showed that naltrexone–bupropion is more effective than
placebo
3.7 The committee considered the key clinical evidence presented by the company,
which came from 4 contrave obesity research (COR) trials done in the US. All
were double-blind randomised trials with either placebo or
naltrexone–bupropion given as an adjunct to standard care (lifestyle measures):
• COR-I included people who were obese or overweight. At week 56, the modified ITT
results showed a mean percentage reduction in weight with naltrexone–bupropion of
6.1% compared with 1.3% with placebo.
• COR-II included people who were obese or overweight. At week 28, the modified ITT
results showed a mean percentage reduction in weight of 6.6% with
naltrexone–bupropion compared with 2.1% with placebo.
© NICE 2020. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- Page 8 of
conditions#notice-of-rights). 17
Naltrexone–bupropion for managing overweight and obesity (TA494)
• COR-BMOD included people who were obese or overweight but everyone had an
intensive standard management regimen. At week 56, the modified ITT results showed
a mean percentage reduction in weight of 9.7% with naltrexone–bupropion compared
with 5.5% with placebo.
• COR-DM included people who were obese or overweight and who had type 2
diabetes. At week 56, the modified ITT results showed a mean percentage reduction in
weight with naltrexone–bupropion of 5.1% compared with 1.8% with placebo.
The committee considered that the trials were all good quality but were of short
duration. The company presented the results for the modified ITT population and the
committee was aware of the limitations of this analysis (see section 3.6). The
committee noted that in the full ITT analysis in the clarification response,
naltrexone–bupropion was also more effective than placebo in all 4 of the COR trials. It
also noted that there was a smaller effect in the trial of people with type 2 diabetes
(COR-DM). The clinical expert explained that a smaller effect has been shown in
obesity drug trials of patients with type 2 diabetes and the reason is not fully
understood. The committee concluded that the results showed naltrexone–bupropion
to be more effective than placebo in all the COR trials but that the long-term
effectiveness of naltrexone–bupropion was unknown.
© NICE 2020. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- Page 9 of
conditions#notice-of-rights). 17
Naltrexone–bupropion for managing overweight and obesity (TA494)
People who are overweight are not well represented in the trials
3.9 The marketing authorisation for naltrexone–bupropion is for people who are
overweight (BMI of 27 kg/m2 to 30 kg/m2) with a comorbidity, and for those who
are obese (BMI over 30 kg/m2). The committee noted that only a small
percentage of patients in the trials were overweight. It heard from the clinical
expert that this is representative of the clinical population most likely to be seen
by the health service in England, because people who are obese are more likely
to seek help. Therefore, the committee concluded that the appraisal should
focus on people who are obese because there is very limited data to inform a
decision on people who are overweight.
© NICE 2020. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- Page 10 of
conditions#notice-of-rights). 17
Naltrexone–bupropion for managing overweight and obesity (TA494)
The company recognised the limitations of implementing the model in Excel and
using DICE. After consultation, the company re-implemented the DES model in
Visual Basic for Applications, increased the number of simulations, and
extended the probabilistic analyses to explore the main input parameters. The
committee heard from the ERG that the revised model ran more efficiently and
that the ERG was able to reproduce similar results. The ERG believed that the
company's validation of the model, comparing the old and new implementations
in terms of the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) and other outcomes,
gave confidence in the results. The committee concluded it was satisfied that
the model was fit for purpose and the results are appropriate for decision-
making.
Model assumptions
The baseline characteristics reflect the population under
consideration
3.12 The company's initial model used sources other than the trials to estimate some
of the baseline characteristics, such as proportions of current smokers and
people with type 2 diabetes. The ERG preferred the COR trials as its sources for
the baseline characteristics. The committee recalled its earlier conclusion that
the trial population was representative of the population seen in practice in
England (see section 3.8) and therefore agreed with the ERG that the baseline
characteristics in the model should reflect those in the COR trials. In response
to consultation, the company incorporated the committee's preference and the
committee was satisfied that the model reflected a population that would be
seen in England.
Using data from the COR-I and COR-DM trials and a full ITT
analysis to inform time-to-treatment discontinuation is
appropriate
3.13 The company's estimates for time-to-treatment discontinuation (TTD) were
based initially on the results from the pooled COR trials and the indirect
treatment comparison with orlistat, which also used the modified ITT
population. The committee reiterated its views about the inappropriateness of
using a modified ITT population (see section 3.6). The ERG commented that it is
inappropriate to pool the data because of statistical and clinical heterogeneity
© NICE 2020. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- Page 11 of
conditions#notice-of-rights). 17
Naltrexone–bupropion for managing overweight and obesity (TA494)
between the trials. COR-II had an earlier assessment point than the other trials
(28 weeks rather than 56 weeks) and COR-BMOD had a more intensive
standard care regimen. Because such intensive standard management is
unlikely to be seen in practice (section 3.8), the committee agreed with the
ERG's view that COR-BMOD should be considered separately to the other
regimens and that it was inappropriate to pool data from the COR trials because
of statistical and clinical heterogeneity. The committee also noted that to derive
the TTD for orlistat, the estimates for naltrexone–bupropion TTD were scaled
to orlistat treatment at an earlier assessment point. It heard from the ERG that
scaling could lead to bias in favour of naltrexone–bupropion and it preferred to
remove the scaling and use the full ITT analysis. The committee agreed with the
ERG's reasoning that applying a scaling factor may lead to bias. In its response to
consultation, the company accepted the committee's preference to use only the
COR-I and COR-DM trials to inform TTD and removed the scaling factor for
naltrexone–bupropion to orlistat. The company also used the full ITT analysis to
estimate TTD. The committee was satisfied that the TTD estimates are
appropriate for decision-making.
© NICE 2020. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- Page 12 of
conditions#notice-of-rights). 17
Naltrexone–bupropion for managing overweight and obesity (TA494)
Cost-effectiveness results
Naltrexone–bupropion may not be an appropriate use of NHS
resources
3.15 The committee noted that the ICER for naltrexone–bupropion with standard
management compared with standard management alone is £23,750 per
quality-adjusted life year (QALY) gained. It also noted that the model showed a
small incremental benefit for naltrexone–bupropion (a QALY gain of 0.0434).
Because of the small QALY gain, the committee expected that the ICER would
be very sensitive to changes in the QALY estimate. It noted the company
estimated that an additional 0.009 incremental QALY benefit would reduce the
ICER to below £20,000 per QALY gained, and it considered that this showed the
sensitivity of the ICER to small changes in the QALYs. The committee considered
that the ICER was uncertain for a number of reasons. It recalled that the model
was unable to capture episodes of retreatment, which the committee had
concluded is a likely scenario for many people (see section 3.5), and it was
unclear how this would affect the ICER. It also recalled that there is uncertainty
about how to model weight regain after treatment has stopped (see
section 3.14) and that the effect of different approaches on the modelling
results was unclear, but the company's approach was likely to favour
naltrexone–bupropion (see section 3.14). The committee concluded that the
combination of these factors means that there is considerable uncertainty
about the true ICER for naltrexone–bupropion.
3.16 The committee referred to section 6.3.3 of NICE's guide to the methods of
technology appraisal. This states that above a most plausible ICER of £20,000
per QALY gained, judgements about the acceptability of the technology as an
effective use of NHS resources take into account a number of factors including
the degree of certainty around the ICER. The committee concluded that there is
© NICE 2020. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- Page 13 of
conditions#notice-of-rights). 17
Naltrexone–bupropion for managing overweight and obesity (TA494)
3.17 The committee also referred to section 6.2.14 of the guide, which states that the
committee 'will want to be increasingly certain of the cost effectiveness of a
technology as the impact of the adoption of the technology on NHS resources
increases. Therefore, the committee may require more robust evidence on the
effectiveness and cost effectiveness of technologies that are expected to have a
large impact on NHS resources.' The committee recalled the high prevalence of
obesity (see section 3.1) and that, as a consequence, there was potential for the
impact of introducing the treatment to be large. The committee recognised the
high unmet need for pharmacological treatments but, recognising the
potentially large impact on NHS resources, it took a cautious approach in
making its recommendations. Because of the uncertainty around the ICER, the
potentially large patient population and long duration of treatment, the
committee needed to be certain that naltrexone–bupropion will provide value
to the NHS. Therefore, it was unable to recommend naltrexone–bupropion as a
cost-effective treatment for use in the NHS.
3.18 The committee was aware that the company believed that the cost
effectiveness of naltrexone–bupropion was inherently underestimated because
its model captured only 3 obesity-related diseases (myocardial infarction, stroke
and type 2 diabetes), whereas weight is a known risk factor for many other
diseases. Also, the company's model did not include the increased risk of death
after a myocardial infarction or stroke or the relationship between BMI and
mortality risk beyond the first 15 years of the time horizon. The committee
accepted that the effects of these on the cost-effectiveness estimates were
unknown and ideally would have been included in the company's model.
However, the committee was not persuaded that this would change its
conclusions about the cost effectiveness of naltrexone–bupropion.
Other considerations
Naltrexone–bupropion is considered an innovative technology
3.19 The committee recalled that naltrexone–bupropion offers a different
mechanism of action to current treatment (orlistat) and may be better tolerated
than orlistat (see section 3.2). The committee accepted that
© NICE 2020. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- Page 14 of
conditions#notice-of-rights). 17
Naltrexone–bupropion for managing overweight and obesity (TA494)
Conclusion
3.20 The committee noted that the ICER for naltrexone–bupropion with standard
management compared with standard management alone was £23,750 per
QALY gained. It identified a number of uncertainties around the modelling
assumptions and considered that there is considerable uncertainty about the
true ICER for naltrexone–bupropion. It noted that the patient population is
potentially very large and treatment is long-term. Because of the uncertainty
about the true ICER and the potentially high impact on NHS resources, the
committee needed to be certain that naltrexone–bupropion will provide value
to the NHS. Therefore it was unable to recommend naltrexone–bupropion as a
cost-effective treatment for use in the NHS.
© NICE 2020. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- Page 15 of
conditions#notice-of-rights). 17
Naltrexone–bupropion for managing overweight and obesity (TA494)
Committee members are asked to declare any interests in the technology to be appraised. If it is
considered there is a conflict of interest, the member is excluded from participating further in that
appraisal.
The minutes of each appraisal committee meeting, which include the names of the members who
attended and their declarations of interests, are posted on the NICE website.
Hamish Lunagaria
Technical Lead
Zoe Charles
Technical Adviser
ISBN: 978-1-4731-2649-7
© NICE 2020. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- Page 16 of
conditions#notice-of-rights). 17
Naltrexone–bupropion for managing overweight and obesity (TA494)
Accreditation
© NICE 2020. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- Page 17 of
conditions#notice-of-rights). 17