Aviation Holdover Timetables Guide
Aviation Holdover Timetables Guide
                                                               TABLE OF CONTENTS
 1.0         INTRODUCTION.............................................................................................................................. 2
 1.1        Purpose ............................................................................................................................................. 2
 1.2        Applicability ....................................................................................................................................... 2
 1.3        Description of Changes ..................................................................................................................... 2
 2.0         REFERENCES AND REQUIREMENTS.......................................................................................... 2
 2.1        Reference Documents ...................................................................................................................... 2
 2.2        Cancelled Documents ....................................................................................................................... 3
 2.3        Definitions and Abbreviations ............................................................................................................ 3
 3.0         BACKGROUND ............................................................................................................................... 3
 4.0         CURRENT STATUS ........................................................................................................................ 4
 5.0         ACTION............................................................................................................................................ 4
 6.0         FUTURE DISPOSITION .................................................................................................................. 4
 7.0         INFORMATION MANAGEMENT .................................................................................................... 4
 8.0         DOCUMENT HISTORY ................................................................................................................... 4
 9.0         CONTACT OFFICE ......................................................................................................................... 5
 APPENDIX A – SUPPLEMENT 1: HOLDOVER TIMETABLES FOR SAE TYPE II AND IV FLUIDS........ 6
 TABLE EG ..................................................................................................................................................... 6
 TABLE PG ..................................................................................................................................................... 7
 TABLE EG-90% ............................................................................................................................................ 8
 TABLE PG-90% ............................................................................................................................................ 9
 APPENDIX B – SUPPLEMENT 2: REGRESSION INFORMATION FOR SAE TYPE II AND IV FLUIDS 10
 TABLE RC EG ............................................................................................................................................ 10
 TABLE RC-PG ............................................................................................................................................ 11
             2016-2017 Supplemental Holdover Timetables and Regression Information for SAE Type II and IV Fluids
1.1 INTRODUCTION
(1)    This Advisory Circular (AC) is provided for information and guidance purposes. It describes an
       example of an acceptable means, but not the only means, of demonstrating compliance with
       regulations and standards. This AC on its own does not change, create, amend or permit
       deviations from regulatory requirements, nor does it establish minimum standards.
1.1 Purpose
1.2 Applicability
(1)    This document applies to TCCA employees and to all individuals, organizations and industries
       that are involved in aircraft winter operations and utilize the Transport Canada Holdover Time
       (HOT) Guidelines, Winter 2016-2017.
(1)    It is intended that the following reference materials be used in conjunction with this document:
       (a)        Aeronautics Act (R.S., 1985, c. A-2);
       (b)        Part VI, Subpart 02, Section 11 of the Canadian Aviation Regulations (CARs) — Aircraft
                  Icing;
       (c)        Part VI, Subpart 02 of the CARs, General Operating Flight Rules Standard (GOFR)
                  622.11 — Ground Icing Operations;
       (d)        Transport Canada Publication — Transport Canada Holdover Time (HOT) Guidelines
                  Winter 2016-2017;
       (e)        Transport Canada Publication — Holdover Time (HOT) Guidelines Regression
                  Information Winter 2016-2017.
       (f)        Transport Canada Publication (TP) 14052, Edition 02, April 2005 — Guidelines for
                  Aircraft Ground Icing Operations.
3.0 BACKGROUND
(1)    Section 602.11 of the Canadian Aviation Regulations (CARs) states, in part that: "No person shall
       conduct or attempt to conduct a take-off in an aircraft that has frost, ice or snow adhering to any
       of its critical surfaces"; and the associated General Operating Flight Rules Standard (GOFR)
       622.11, outlines the requirements of a Ground Icing Program (GIP), including the use of HOT
       timetables.
(2)    Transport Canada Civil Aviation (TCCA) annually publishes the HOT Guidelines to allow users
       (e.g. operators, service providers) to prepare and update their respective GIP for the upcoming
       winter season.
(3)    TCCA annually publishes the HOT Guidelines Regression Information allow users (e.g.
       operators, service providers) to prepare and update their respective GIP for the upcoming winter
       season.
(4)    Preliminary research findings collected in the winter of 2014-15 indicated that the HOT
       information for some of the aircraft de-icing/anti-icing fluids (ADF) listed in the HOT Guidelines for
       temperatures below -14°C in snow conditions did not meet the published times. Further
       evaluation was required in order to assess the magnitude of the potential safety risk.
(5)    Initial analysis from this evaluation in winter 2015-2016 confirmed that some of the ADF did not
       meet the published HOTs. Consequently, as safety measure TCCA published the 2016-2017
       HOT Guidelines with reduced holdover times for all Society of Automotive Engineers SAE Type II
       and Type IV fluids.
(1)    At the request of industry, TCCA and the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) re-examined the
       performance of ethylene glycol (EG) and propylene glycol (PG) based fluids and the theoretical
       performance of fluids at -18°C. The analysis determined that the historic snow holdover times
       (those published in the 2015-2016 HOT Guidelines) can be retained for:
       (a)        SAE Type IV EG based fluids in the below -14°C to Lowest Operational Use Temperature
                  (LOUT) temperature band; and
       (b)        SAE Type II and Type IV PG based fluids in the below -14 to -18°C temperature band.
5.0 ACTION
(1)    End users of the Winter 2016-2017 Transport Canada Holdover (HOT) Guidelines (e.g. air
       operators, service providers) are advised to incorporate the supplemental guidance provided in
       Appendix A to their GIP and operations manuals.
(2)    End users of the Winter 2016-2017 Transport Canada Holdover Time (HOT) Guidelines
       Regression Information (e.g. holdover time determination systems (HOTDS) manufacturers,
       eHOT application developers) are advised to incorporate the supplemental guidance provided in
       Appendix B into their GIP and operations manuals.
(1)    These changes are interim. Additional analysis and/or research will be carried out to determine
       appropriate long term solutions.
       Suggestions for amendment to this document are invited, and should be submitted via the same
       e-mail as above.
      Robert Sincennes
      Director, Standards
      Civil Aviation
TABLE EG
NOTES
1 Ensure that the lowest operational use temperature (LOUT) is respected. Consider use of Type I fluid when Type IV fluid cannot be used.
2 To determine snowfall intensity, the Snowfall Intensities as a Function of Prevailing Visibility table (Table 7) is required.
3 Use light freezing rain holdover times in conditions of very light or light snow mixed with light rain.
4 Use light freezing rain holdover times if positive identification of freezing drizzle is not possible.
5 No holdover time guidelines exist for this condition for 0°C (32°F) and below.
6 Heavy snow, ice pellets, moderate and heavy freezing rain, small hail and hail (Table 6 provides allowance times for ice pellets and small hail).
7 No holdover time guidelines exist for this condition below -10°C (14°F).
8 Refer to the fluid-specific HOT table in the document Transport Canada HOT Guidelines Winter 2016-2017, Original Issue: August 5, 2016 for the LOUT of each
   fluid. This information is also provided in Table 8 of the same document. If the LOUT is unknown, no holdover time guidelines exist below -22.5°C (-8.5°F).
9 Table 8 table in the document Transport Canada HOT Guidelines Winter 2016-2017, Original Issue: August 5, 2016 provides the glycol base information for each
   fluid. If the fluid base is unknown, assume it is propylene glycol for the purpose of determining holdover times.
CAUTIONS
• The only acceptable decision-making criterion, for takeoff without a pre-takeoff contamination inspection, is the shorter time within the applicable
   holdover time table cell.
• The time of protection will be shortened in heavy weather conditions, heavy precipitation rates, or high moisture content. High wind velocity or jet
   blast may reduce holdover time below the lowest time stated in the range. Holdover time may be reduced when aircraft skin temperature is lower than
   outside air temperature.
• Fluids used during ground de/anti-icing do not provide in-flight icing protection.
                          SAE TYPE II AND TYPE IV PROPYLENE GLYCOL BASED FLUID9 HOLDOVER TIME GUIDELINES
                                 FOR SNOW, SNOW GRAINS OR SNOW PELLETS BELOW -14°C (7°F) TO LOUT
                                  THE RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE APPLICATION OF THESE DATA REMAINS WITH THE USER
      Outside Air                                                       Approximate Holdover Times Under Various Weather Conditions
     Temperature1            Type II/IV Fluid                                                 (hours: minutes)
                             Concentration
 Degrees      Degrees                             Freezing Fog    Snow, Snow Grains or Snow Pellets2
                            Neat Fluid/Water                                                                 Freezing        Light      Rain on Cold
                                                        or                                                                                                Other6
 Celsius     Fahrenheit     (Volume %/Volume %)                                                              Drizzle4      Freezing     Soaked Wing5
                                                   Ice Crystals
                                                                  Very Light3      Light3      Moderate                      Rain
                                  100/0
   -3 and       27 and
                                  75/25                             Refer to holdover times provided in the appropriate
   above        above
                                                               fluid-specific or generic holdover time table published in the
                                  50/50                   Transport Canada Holdover Time (HOT) Guidelines Winter 2016-2017
                                                                                                                                               CAUTION:
  below -3    below 27            100/0                                        Original Issue: August 5, 2016
   to -14       to 7                                                                                                                          No holdover
                                  75/25
NOTES
1 Ensure that the lowest operational use temperature (LOUT) is respected. Consider use of Type I fluid when Type II/IV fluid cannot be used.
2 To determine snowfall intensity, the Snowfall Intensities as a Function of Prevailing Visibility table (Table 7) is required.
3 Use light freezing rain holdover times in conditions of very light or light snow mixed with light rain.
4 Use light freezing rain holdover times if positive identification of freezing drizzle is not possible.
5 No holdover time guidelines exist for this condition for 0°C (32°F) and below.
6 Heavy snow, ice pellets, moderate and heavy freezing rain, small hail and hail (Table 6 provides allowance times for ice pellets and small hail).
7 No holdover time guidelines exist for this condition below -10°C (14°F).
8 Refer to the fluid-specific HOT table in the document Transport Canada HOT Guidelines Winter 2016-2017, Original Issue: August 5, 2016 for the LOUT of each
   fluid. This information is also provided in Table 8 of the same document. If the LOUT is unknown, no holdover time guidelines exist below -22.5°C (-8.5°F).
9 Table 8 table in the document Transport Canada HOT Guidelines Winter 2016-2017, Original Issue: August 5, 2016 provides the glycol base information for each
   fluid. If the fluid base is unknown, assume it is propylene glycol for the purpose of determining holdover times.
CAUTIONS
• The only acceptable decision-making criterion, for takeoff without a pre-takeoff contamination inspection, is the shorter time within the applicable
   holdover time table cell.
• The time of protection will be shortened in heavy weather conditions, heavy precipitation rates, or high moisture content. High wind velocity or jet
   blast may reduce holdover time below the lowest time stated in the range. Holdover time may be reduced when aircraft skin temperature is lower than
   outside air temperature.
• Fluids used during ground de/anti-icing do not provide in-flight icing protection.
TABLE EG-90%
NOTES
1  Ensure that the lowest operational use temperature (LOUT) is respected. Consider use of Type I fluid when Type IV fluid cannot be used.
2  To determine snowfall intensity, the Snowfall Intensities as a Function of Prevailing Visibility table (Table 7) is required.
3  Use light freezing rain holdover times in conditions of very light or light snow mixed with light rain.
4  Use light freezing rain holdover times if positive identification of freezing drizzle is not possible.
5  No holdover time guidelines exist for this condition for 0°C (32°F) and below.
6  Heavy snow, ice pellets, moderate and heavy freezing rain, small hail and hail (Table 6 provides allowance times for ice pellets and small hail).
7  No holdover time guidelines exist for this condition below -10°C (14°F).
8  Refer to the fluid-specific HOT table in the document Transport Canada HOT Guidelines Winter 2016-2017, Original Issue: August 5, 2016 for the LOUT of each fluid. This information is also
   provided in Table 8 of the same document. If the LOUT is unknown, no holdover time guidelines exist below -22.5°C (-8.5°F).
9  Table 8 table in the document Transport Canada HOT Guidelines Winter 2016-2017, Original Issue: August 5, 2016 provides the glycol base information for each fluid. If the fluid base is
   unknown, assume it is propylene glycol for the purpose of determining holdover times.
CAUTIONS
• The only acceptable decision-making criterion, for takeoff without a pre-takeoff contamination inspection, is the shorter time within the applicable holdover time table cell.
• The time of protection will be shortened in heavy weather conditions, heavy precipitation rates, or high moisture content. High wind velocity or jet blast may reduce holdover time
   below the lowest time stated in the range. Holdover time may be reduced when aircraft skin temperature is lower than outside air temperature.
• Fluids used during ground de/anti-icing do not provide in-flight icing protection.
TABLE PG-90%
NOTES
1  Ensure that the lowest operational use temperature (LOUT) is respected. Consider use of Type I fluid when Type II/IV fluid cannot be used.
2  To determine snowfall intensity, the Snowfall Intensities as a Function of Prevailing Visibility table (Table 7) is required.
3  Use light freezing rain holdover times in conditions of very light or light snow mixed with light rain.
4  Use light freezing rain holdover times if positive identification of freezing drizzle is not possible.
5  No holdover time guidelines exist for this condition for 0°C (32°F) and below.
6  Heavy snow, ice pellets, moderate and heavy freezing rain, small hail and hail (Table 6 provides allowance times for ice pellets and small hail).
7  No holdover time guidelines exist for this condition below -10°C (14°F).
8  Refer to the fluid-specific HOT table in the document Transport Canada HOT Guidelines Winter 2016-2017, Original Issue: August 5, 2016 for the LOUT of each fluid. This information is also
   provided in Table 8 of the same document. If the LOUT is unknown, no holdover time guidelines exist below -22.5°C (-8.5°F).
9  Table 8 table in the document Transport Canada HOT Guidelines Winter 2016-2017, Original Issue: August 5, 2016 provides the glycol base information for each fluid. If the fluid base is
   unknown, assume it is propylene glycol for the purpose of determining holdover times.
CAUTIONS
• The only acceptable decision-making criterion, for takeoff without a pre-takeoff contamination inspection, is the shorter time within the applicable holdover time table cell.
• The time of protection will be shortened in heavy weather conditions, heavy precipitation rates, or high moisture content. High wind velocity or jet blast may reduce holdover time
   below the lowest time stated in the range. Holdover time may be reduced when aircraft skin temperature is lower than outside air temperature.
• Fluids used during ground de/anti-icing do not provide in-flight icing protection.
TABLE RC EG
100/0
  -3 and         27 and
                                   75/25
  above          above
                                                     Refer to the regression coefficients provided in the appropriate
                                                 fluid-specific regression coefficients table published in the document
                                   50/50             Transport Canada HOT Guidelines Regression Information
                                                         Winter 2016-2017, Original Issue: August 5, 2016
                                   100/0
                                                                                                                                                    CAUTION:
 below -3        below 27                                                                                                                          No holdover
  to -14           to 7                                                                                                                          time guidelines
                                                                                                                                                      exist
                                   75/25
                                   5         2          25           10            3           13            5          25           13          75               5
                 100/0
 +1 / -3 **      75/25                              Refer to the verification times provided in the appropriate
                                             fluid-specific regression coefficients table published in the document
                 50/50
                                                  Transport Canada HOT Guidelines Regression Information
                 100/0                                Winter 2016-2017, Original Issue: August 5, 2016
-10 / -14 ***
                 75/25
    -25          100/0                                  15.0        30.0         50.0
* Refer to Table 5 in the document Transport Canada HOT Guidelines Regression Information Winter 2016-2017, Original Issue: August 5, 2016 for the lowest
  usable precipitation rates in snow
** Rain on cold soaked wing calculated at +1°C; all other conditions calculated at -3°C
*** Freezing fog and snow calculated at -14°C; freezing drizzle and light freezing rain calculated at -10°C
100/0
  -3 and         27 and
                                 75/25
  above          above
                                                    Refer to the regression coefficients provided in the appropriate
                                                fluid-specific regression coefficients table published in the document
                                 50/50               Transport Canada HOT Guidelines Regression Information
                                                         Winter 2016-2017, Original Issue: August 5, 2016
                                 100/0
 below -3        below 27
  to -14           to 7                                                                                                                             CAUTION:
                                                                                                                                                   No holdover
                                 75/25
                                                                                                                                                 time guidelines
                                                                                                                                                      exist
                                                         I = 2.0691        I = 1.7911        I = 2.2336
 below -14       below 7
                                 100/0                   A = -0.7757       A = -0.3140       A = -0.7565
   to -18          to 0
                                                         B = 0.0000        B = 0.0000        B = 0.0000
                                 5          2           25           10            3           13            5          25           13          75               5
                 100/0
 +1 / -3 **      75/25                             Refer to the verification times provided in the appropriate
                                            fluid-specific regression coefficients table published in the document
                 50/50
                                                 Transport Canada HOT Guidelines Regression Information
                 100/0                               Winter 2016-2017, Original Issue: August 5, 2016
-10 / -14 ***
                 75/25
    -18          100/0                                 15.0         30.0         50.0
    -25          100/0                                  8.0         10.0         25.0
* Refer to Table 5 in the document Transport Canada HOT Guidelines Regression Information Winter 2016-2017, Original Issue: August 5, 2016 for the lowest
  usable precipitation rates in snow
** Rain on cold soaked wing calculated at +1°C; all other conditions calculated at -3°C
*** Freezing fog and snow calculated at -14°C; freezing drizzle and light freezing rain calculated at -10°C