Here’s a structured outline for an 8-9 page paper discussing the direct fulfillment of
the prophecy in Hosea 11:1 as seen in Matthew 2:15, incorporating insights from G.K. Beale's
work on the use of the Old Testament in the New Testament.
I. Introduction
● Brief introduction to the significance of Old Testament prophecies in the New Testament.
● Overview of Matthew’s purpose in relating Jesus’ life to Old Testament scripture.
● Thesis statement: Matthew’s use of Hosea 11:1 to depict Jesus as the fulfillment of
Israel’s story illustrates a deeper theological significance.
V. Theological Implications
VIII. Conclusion
IX. References
● Include a bibliography of scholarly works, particularly focusing on G.K. Beale and other
relevant literature on the topic.
Expanded Sections
I. Introduction
In this section, briefly introduce how the New Testament frequently cites the Old Testament,
presenting these references as fulfilled prophecies that establish Jesus’ identity and mission. Set
the stage for discussing the specific prophecy from Hosea and its application in Matthew.
Delve deeper into Hosea's background, explaining how the prophet addresses Israel's
unfaithfulness yet underscores God's enduring love. Explore the significance of calling Israel
"My son," emphasizing the relationship between God and His people.
III. Matthew’s Context and Audience
Discuss the Gospel of Matthew’s unique perspective as a text aimed primarily at a Jewish
audience. Highlight how this context shapes Matthew’s interpretative approach and his focus on
demonstrating Jesus as the long-awaited Messiah.
Analyze the narrative structure of Matthew 2:15, emphasizing the immediate circumstances
leading to the flight to Egypt. Explore the implications of Matthew's claim that this event fulfills
Hosea's prophecy, linking Jesus' experiences to the collective experience of Israel.
V. Theological Implications
Discuss how Beale’s work connects the dots between Jesus and Israel, arguing that Jesus fulfills
Israel’s role and purpose. Explore how the Exodus theme resonates throughout Jesus’ life,
signifying liberation and God’s salvific plan.
Examine how Matthew’s portrayal of Jesus aligns with other Old Testament references, forming
a cohesive narrative that portrays Jesus as the culmination of Israel’s history. Highlight how this
strategy solidifies Jesus’ authority.
Summarize Beale’s arguments, focusing on typology and how Matthew’s interpretation of Hosea
11:1 fits into a broader understanding of scriptural fulfillment. Compare this with other scholarly
opinions to provide a well-rounded view.
VIII. Conclusion
Conclude by reaffirming the significance of Hosea 11:1 in understanding Jesus’ identity as the
fulfillment of Israel’s narrative, emphasizing the continuity between the Old and New
Testaments and its implications for Christian theology.
This outline provides a framework for developing a comprehensive paper on the topic. You can
expand each section with detailed analysis, scholarly quotes, and theological reflections to meet
the desired length. If you need further elaboration on any specific section or topic, let me know!