Dorothy20 - KAP of Rabies and Free Roaming Dogs in Penang
Dorothy20 - KAP of Rabies and Free Roaming Dogs in Penang
ABSTRACT. Free roaming dogs (FRDs) are defined as unconfined dogs and are not prevented from roaming. In
Malaysia, the status quo of our FRDs and its management is inconclusive. This study was initiated after the 2015
rabies outbreak in Penang and many parties have been involved in their management. Henceforth, this survey
was conducted to determine the status quo of FRDs and its management, concomitantly with the other details
than comes along with it. Many aspects of these FRDs welfare knowledge were included in the questionnaire
and analysed accordingly. Basic analysis for 157 public respondents that consist of locals of Penang had been
accomplished, which brought to a success rate of 78.5%. Statistical analysis has been conducted to identify the
knowledge, awareness and prevention of Rabies and FRDs. Our survey also reported that 40% agreed that rabies
is a problem in Malaysia and 70% of respondents believed that children are at high risk of contracting it. Sixty-
nine percent were not knowledgeable about rabies and its zoonotic implications. In conclusion, it was noted that
the overall awareness and understanding level of Rabies knowledge is unsatisfactory. The results showed public
concern towards FRDs and encouraged the authorities to seek out improved methods of population and FRDs
control which is humane and acceptable in society.
Keywords: Free roaming dogs (FRDs), Penang, rabies, knowledge, awareness, prevention
1
MALAYSIAN JOURNAL OF VETERINARY RESEARCH V olume 11 N o . 2 J uly 2020
cause and reduce the size or turnover of the the feeding and management of these free
population (Massei and Miller, 2013; Taylor roaming dogs in Penang. However, the actual
et al. , 2017). The DPM is a common practice status quo of our FRDs, its management
in many countries worldwide now to further and the involvement of these organisations
combat and permanently solve this matter in the welfare of these animals in terms of
as this FRD problem has become a global controlling population, disease prevention
problem (Sternheim, 2012). of rabies and treatment is unknown. Hence,
The Word Health Organisation (WHO), this was the pioneer study conducted in the
the World Organisation for Animal Health country, in Penang namely.
(OIE), the Food and Agriculture Organisation The culling of FRDs had generated
of the United Nations (FAO) and the Global controversy and mass protests by animal
Alliance for Rabies Control (GARC) have lovers and welfare activists around the
established a global “United Against Rabies” country, especially in Penang state. The main
collaboration to provide a common strategy concerns of the activists were what they
to achieve “zero human rabies deaths by perceived as the indiscriminate culling of free
2030” (Abela-Ridder, 2018). Examples of roaming dogs instead of mass vaccination
successful rabies elimination programmes of all dogs against rabies (Bamaiyi, 2015).
can be witnessed at Latin America and the Simultaneously, the Malaysian statistics have
Caribbean, Bangladesh, Mexico, Philippines, also indicated that the latest Sarawak Rabies
South Africa, Sri Lanka and United Republic episode 2018 has 16 human cases, claimed
of Tanzania (Abela-Ridder, 2018). WHO has 15 lives and left one survivor (child) with
also estimated that there are more than 200 severe neurological complications (MOH,
million stray dogs worldwide, and the total 2018; Navanithakumar et al. , 2019).
population of free roaming dogs makes up
about 75-85% of the global dog population MATERIALS AND METHOD
(WAP, 2013). Every year 69,000 people die
from rabies, while another 15 million receive This research project was a survey that
post-exposure treatment to avert the deadly involved questionnaires. The main categories
disease. Ninety-five percent of these cases included the public. Every respondent of this
occur in Asia and Africa, and 99% of the project was required to fill in a consent form
fatalities are caused by dogs (WAP, 2013; to give acknowledgement of involvement.
Bamaiyi, 2015; Menghistu et al., 2018). Respondents can either choose to be
In Malaysia, the status quo of our FRDs interviewed or fill in the questionnaires at
and its management is inconclusive. This their convenience (Dorothy et al., 2019).
study was initiated after the 2015 rabies The questionnaires prepared for public
outbreak in Penang and concerned many respondents were divided into seven main
parties that are either involved directly or sections that include the following: (A) Basic
indirectly in the management of these FRDs. Information of Participant, (B) Ownership
Animal lovers and welfare organisations of Dogs, (C) Free Roaming Dogs, (D) Waste
have been reported to have been involved in Management, (E) General Thought of
2
V olume 11 N o . 2 J uly 2020 MALAYSIAN JOURNAL OF VETERINARY RESEARCH
3
MALAYSIAN JOURNAL OF VETERINARY RESEARCH V olume 11 N o . 2 J uly 2020
4
V olume 11 N o . 2 J uly 2020 MALAYSIAN JOURNAL OF VETERINARY RESEARCH
5
MALAYSIAN JOURNAL OF VETERINARY RESEARCH V olume 11 N o . 2 J uly 2020
6
V olume 11 N o . 2 J uly 2020 MALAYSIAN JOURNAL OF VETERINARY RESEARCH
Strongly agree
6% (10) Moderately agree
Knowledgeable
13% (23)
31% (49)
Neutral
Not knowledgeable Strongly disagree 7% (12)
69% (110) 48% (81)
Moderately
disagree
26% (26)
Knowledgeable
No previous animal Had previous animal 28% (40)
bite incidents bite incidents
52% (82) 48% (75) Not knowledgeable
72% (103)
Knowledgeable
Not knowledgeable
44% (93)
56% (119)
7
MALAYSIAN JOURNAL OF VETERINARY RESEARCH V olume 11 N o . 2 J uly 2020
unfamiliar with the treatment options par with the ideology and stand of WHO,
available in which 56% do not know the and the OIE which states that vaccinating
next step after a dog bite for post-exposure dogs is the most cost-effective strategy for
prophylaxis (PEP) and first-aid of the wounds preventing rabies in people and elimination
regardless it is a rabid or non-rabid dog. in dogs. Dog vaccination reduces deaths
Respondents were unaware of the attributable to rabies and the need for PEP
PEP as recommended by WHO, and the as a part of dog bite patient care (WAP, 2013;
OIE that includes extensive washing and WHO, 2015).
local treatment of the wound as soon as Only 24% respondents disagreed with
possible after exposure, a course of potent this statement and 11% were neutral about
and effective rabies vaccine that meets WHO it.
standards and the administration of rabies
immunoglobulin (RIG), if indicated, that Education on dog behaviour and bite
should be followed if bitten by rabid dogs. prevention
Fur th e r inte r v iew in g ha d als o
indicated that respondents were unaware of WHO and OIE have also stated that
the extensive wound washing method that education on dog behaviour and bite
includes immediate and thorough flushing prevention for both children and adults is an
and washing of the wound for a minimum of essential extension of a rabies vaccination
15 minutes with soap and water, detergent, programme and can decrease both the
povidone iodine or other substances that kill incidence of human rabies and the financial
the rabies virus. burden of treating dog bites. Increasing
awareness of rabies prevention and control
Prevention of Rabies in communities includes education and
information on responsible pet ownership,
Rabies is a preventable viral disease how to prevent dog bites, and immediate
which occurs in more than 150 countries care measures after a bite. Engagement
and territories. (WAP, 2013) Increasing and ownership of the programme at the
awareness of rabies prevention and control community level increases reach and uptake
in communities includes vaccination, of key messages (WAP, 2013; WHO, 2015).
education and information on responsible This statement is also agreed by 84%
pet ownership, how to prevent dog bites, respondents in this study (Table 3). From this
and immediate care measures after a bite. table, 38% respondents strongly agree and
46% moderately agree. Thirteen percent
Eliminating rabies in dogs by vaccination of respondents have neutral opinions of
prevention of rabies by education. Education
Table 3 indicates that 66% respondents on dog behaviour and its movement is
agreed that rabies can be effectively important for bite prevention purposes.
prevented by vaccinating dogs, as rabies Learning and understanding dogs’ instinct
is a vaccine-preventable disease. This is in on its surrounding is important as it will
8
V olume 11 N o . 2 J uly 2020 MALAYSIAN JOURNAL OF VETERINARY RESEARCH
react to it accordingly as perceived by its how to react if they had encountered a dog
brains (WAP, 2013; WHO, 2015). A set of in the streets generally (Table 4). Our analysis
questions were included in the questionnaire had also revealed that respondents also did
survey to determine how respondents will not know how to react if dogs run up to
react to different situations involving dogs them (72%), were chasing (60%), jumping
per say (Table 4). Questions included were (65%) or barking (66%) at them in various
respondents’ response if dogs were chasing, types of scenarios as shown in Table 4.
jumping or barking at them during different This clearly shows that education is
activities. crucial in terms of awareness of rabies and
Our analysis revealed that 64% of preventing dog bites. Dogs are the main
respondents were not knowledgeable of source of human rabies deaths, contributing
9
MALAYSIAN JOURNAL OF VETERINARY RESEARCH V olume 11 N o . 2 J uly 2020
up to 99% of all rabies transmissions to dog behaviour, dos and don’ts when
humans. The one and only way to do it is to interacting with dogs in children’s education
learn, understand and practice what we have of all ages as well as in adults will definitely
learnt on how to recognise and react when help (WAP, 2013; WHO, 2015).
playing with a dog or in situations of threat Educ ation and information on
(WAP, 2013; WHO, 2015). Responsible Pet Ownership (RDO) will also
Dogs will normally exhibit their definitely help in the prevention of rabies
emotions or reactions by body movements and dog bite. Our study has also indicated
and recognising that is very important to that FRDs with owners are more compared
prevent dog bites. A dog will only exhibit to FRDs without owners. Hence, all pet
signs of fear and bite if it feels that it is in owners should know and practice the five
danger and being threatened. Incorporating freedoms that are in the Responsible Pet
animal welfare, learning and understanding
10
V olume 11 N o . 2 J uly 2020 MALAYSIAN JOURNAL OF VETERINARY RESEARCH
11
MALAYSIAN JOURNAL OF VETERINARY RESEARCH V olume 11 N o . 2 J uly 2020
13. Jones, K.E., Patel, N.G., Levy, M.A., Storeygard, A., Balk, 21. Raymond T.N., Roland M.E., Francoise K.M., Francis Z.,
B. and Gittleman, J.L. (2008). Global trends in emerging Livo E.F. and Clovis S.T. (2015). Do open garbage dumps
infectious diseases. Nature, 451, 990-993. play a role in canine rabies transmission in Biyem-Assi
14. Krishna C.S. (2010). The success of the ABC-AR health district in Cameroon? Infect. EcolEpidemiol, 5,
Programme in India. Accessed online at http://www. 26055. https:doi:10.3402/iee.v5.26055
fao.org/fileadmin/user_upload/animalwelfare/S.%20 22. Sternheim I. (2012). How Holland became free of
Chinny%20%20Krishna_ABC_August_2010.doc stray dogs. Isis 2-9. Accessed from http://info@
15. Macpherson C.N.L., Meslin F.X. and Wandeler A.I. animalfoundationplatform.nl
(2012). Dogs, zoonoses and public health (2nd Ed.). CABI: 23. Taylor, L.H., Wallace, R.M., Balaram, D., Lindenmayer,
Wallingford, UK. J.M., Eckery, D.C., Mutonono-Watkiss, B., Parravani,
16. Massei, G. and Miller, L. (2013). A review of the E. & Nel, L.H. (2017). The Role of Dog Population
interactions between free-roaming domestic dogs and Management in Rabies Elimination. A Review of Current
wildlife. Theriogenology, 80, 829-838. Approaches and Future Opportunities. Frontiers in Vet.
17. Menghistu H.T., Thaiya A.G.,Bajitie M., Bundi J., Gugssa Sci., 4, 1-16 https:/doi:10.3389/fvets2017.00109.
G., Bsrat A., Kirui G., Kitaa J.M.A., Tsegaye Y. and Teferi 24. WAP (2013). World Animal Protection. Controlling rabies
T.(2018). Free roaming dogs and the communities’ one humane solution, three reasons why. http://www.
knowledge, attitude and practices of rabies incidence/ worldanimalprotection.org/sites/default/files/int_files/
human exposures: Cases of selected settings in controlling_rabies-one_humane_solution.pdf
Ethiopia and Kenya. Ethiop. J. Health Dev., 32(1), 27-35. 25. WHO (2015). Global School Health Initiatives: Achieving
18. MOH (2018). Situasi Terkini Rabies di Sarawak. Media Health and Education Outcomes. Report of a meeting,
statement 11 Dec 2018, Director-General of Health Bangkok, Thailand, 23–25 November 2015. Report
Malaysia. Accesse d f rom ht tps: // k pkesihatan. No WHO/NMH/PND/17.7. Geneva, Swit zerland.
c o m / 2 0 18 / 12 / 11/ k e n y a t a a n - a k h b a r - k p k -11 - Accessed from https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/
disember2018-situasi-terkini-rabies-di-sarawak /, handle/10665/259813/WHO-NMHPND-17.7-eng.pdf
Ministry of Health Malaysia. 26. Young, J.K., Olson, K.A., Reading, R.P., Amgalanbaatar
19. Muthunuwan J.T., Ganhewa A.G.K.H, Perera H.D.S.G, S. and Berger, J. (2011). Is wildlife going to the dogs?
Hishaam M., Bandara W.M.M.S and Gunasekera H.A.K.M Impacts of feral and free-roaming dogs on wildlife
(2017). Preliminary survey on knowledge, attitudes and populations. BioScience, 61(2), 125-132. ht tps:/
practices regarding rabies. Sri Lankan J. Infect. Dis., 7(1), doi:10.1525/bio.2011.61.2.7.
38-46. http://doi.org/10.4038/sljid.v7i1.8133
20. Navanithakumar, B., Sohayati, A.R., Rohaiza, Y., Sarah ACKNOWLEDGEMENT. The authors wish to acknowledge
Dadang, A.,Mariani, H., Leonora, T.M. and Dorothy, K.S. the Director-General of Veterinary Services Malaysia for his
(2019). An Overview of Rabies Outbreak in Malaysia. support and cooperation.
Malay. J. Vet. Res., 11(2), 148-158.
12