Fq 175-176

The image you've uploaded is from a section titled "Teaching Pronunciation." Here's a detailed
summary based on the text:

*Introduction:*

The introduction of this section discusses the importance and challenges of teaching
pronunciation in language learning. Pronunciation includes individual sounds, sound segments,
and suprasegmental features like stress, rhythm, and intonation. Achieving native-like
pronunciation is challenging, and many learners may be comfortable with their accent as part of
their cultural identity. The text highlights the evolution of pronunciation teaching approaches,
moving from focusing on individual speech sounds to broader communicative aspects of
connected speech.

*Key Questions:*

It raises questions about the value of pronunciation teaching and the effectiveness of various
approaches:

- Is pronunciation worth teaching?

- How effective are different teaching methods found in course books and materials?

- Should a direct or indirect approach be used?

- What should be done about persistent pronunciation errors?

- Can subtle dimensions like rhythm and intonation be taught, or are they picked up through
exposure?
*Debate within Language Teaching:*

There is a debate about the influence of teaching on L2 phonological development. Some believe
teachers can do little to change natural development, while others believe teaching can help
improve pronunciation and shape learners' attitudes toward its importance.

*Jones' Paper:*

Jones reviews recent research on second language phonology and its implications for teaching
materials. He suggests incorporating activities that address communicative, psychological, and
sociological dimensions of pronunciation.

*Hebert's Paper:*

Hebert argues that teachers often neglect pronunciation or focus too much on individual sounds.
He advocates for teaching global features like stress, rhythm, intonation, pitch variation, and
volume. Hebert also emphasizes the importance of creating diagnostic profiles for learners'
pronunciation difficulties and provides examples of how to teach these global features.

Overall, the section aims to provide a comprehensive view of the current state of pronunciation
teaching and its significance in language learning. It encourages educators to consider both the
individual and broader communicative aspects of pronunciation, and to use research-based
methods to enhance their teaching practices.

--

Sure, here are some insights to address the questions from the text:

1. *Is pronunciation worth teaching?*

 Pronunciation is indeed worth teaching as it significantly impacts communication effectiveness.
Clear pronunciation helps in understanding and being understood, which is essential for
successful interactions in a second language. While achieving native-like pronunciation may be
challenging, improving intelligibility and reducing communication barriers is valuable for
learners.

2. *How effective are different teaching methods found in course books and materials?*

The effectiveness of teaching methods varies. Traditional methods focusing on individual

sounds are less effective than those emphasizing communicative aspects of pronunciation.
Activities that integrate pronunciation into real-life communication scenarios tend to be more
effective. Incorporating exercises that address stress, rhythm, intonation, and connected speech
can enhance learners' overall pronunciation skills.

3. *Should a direct or indirect approach be used?*

Both approaches have their merits. A direct approach involves explicit instruction and practice
of pronunciation features, which can be beneficial for learners who need targeted help. An
indirect approach, where pronunciation is embedded in broader language activities, helps learners
develop natural pronunciation patterns through exposure and use. A balanced combination of
both approaches may yield the best results.

4. *What should be done about persistent pronunciation errors?*

Persistent pronunciation errors should be addressed with targeted practice and feedback.
Teachers can create diagnostic profiles to identify specific areas of difficulty for each learner.
Using focused exercises, repetition, and corrective feedback can help learners overcome these
errors. Encouraging self-monitoring and providing opportunities for practice in various contexts
can also aid improvement.
5. *Can subtle dimensions like rhythm and intonation be taught, or are they picked up through
exposure?*

While exposure plays a crucial role in acquiring rhythm and intonation, these features can also
be taught explicitly. Activities that raise awareness of these subtle dimensions, such as listening
and imitation exercises, can help learners develop a better sense of rhythm and intonation.
Incorporating these features into communicative practice allows learners to apply them in
meaningful contexts.

These answers provide a comprehensive view of the key considerations in teaching pronunciation
effectively. If you have any specific questions or need further elaboration, feel free to ask!

Fq 176-177

Sure, here are the detailed answers to the questions from the document:

### Before Reading Questions

1. *Why do you think it is difficult for adults to acquire a native-like pronunciation in a second or
foreign language even if other aspects of their speech are native-like?*

Acquiring a native-like pronunciation is challenging for adults due to the critical period
hypothesis, which suggests that there is a window of time in early childhood when the brain is
particularly receptive to learning new sounds. After this period, it becomes harder for the brain to
adapt to new phonetic systems. Additionally, adults have more entrenched language habits from
their first language, which can interfere with the sounds of a second language.
2. *What do you think is a suitable target in the learning of pronunciation – a native-like accent
or a fluent but accented style of speaking?*

A suitable target is often a fluent but accented style of speaking. The primary goal should be
intelligibility—being easily understood by others. While a native-like accent can be desirable, it’s
not always necessary for effective communication and can be an unrealistic goal for many
learners.

3. *What factors do learners need to attend to or become conscious of in learning new sounds or
correcting fossilized pronunciation habits?*

Learners need to be aware of articulatory features (such as tongue position, lip shape, and
voicing), the phonetic context of sounds (how sounds change in different word positions), and
suprasegmental features (like stress, rhythm, and intonation). Consistent practice and focused
listening are also crucial for correcting fossilized errors.

4. *What is the role of imitation-based activities in teaching pronunciation?*

Imitation-based activities are fundamental in pronunciation teaching. They help learners

develop accurate sound production and prosody by mimicking native speakers. These activities
can improve auditory discrimination and muscle memory, which are essential for producing new
sounds correctly.

5. *Do you think young learners have less difficulty with pronunciation than older learners? If so,
why might this be the case?*

Yes, young learners generally have less difficulty with pronunciation. They benefit from greater
neuroplasticity, making it easier for their brains to adapt to new sounds. Additionally, they often
have more exposure to the language in natural settings and are less inhibited about making
mistakes, which fosters learning.
6. *Have you learned to speak a foreign language? What difficulties did you have with
pronunciation? How did you address these difficulties?*

I haven't personally learned a foreign language, but common difficulties in pronunciation

include unfamiliar sounds, stress patterns, and intonation. Addressing these involves targeted
practice, listening to native speakers, and using language learning tools that provide feedback on
pronunciation.

7. *Do you think some people have a better “ear” for accents and pronunciation in a new
language than others?*

Yes, some individuals have a better ear for accents and pronunciation. This can be due to
factors like musical training, heightened phonetic sensitivity, and more exposure to diverse
languages and accents, which can improve their ability to perceive and reproduce new sounds.

8. *Do you think explaining to learners how to produce difficult sounds has a role in the teaching
of pronunciation?*

Absolutely. Explaining the mechanics of sound production can demystify difficult sounds and
provide learners with concrete techniques to improve their pronunciation. Understanding how
sounds are formed can help learners correct errors and practice more effectively.

9. *Why do you think much pronunciation teaching appears to be ineffective?*

Pronunciation teaching can be ineffective if it focuses too narrowly on individual sounds

without integrating them into meaningful communication. Lack of practical application,
insufficient feedback, and a focus on perfection rather than intelligibility can also hinder
progress.

10. *What personality factors do you think might play a role in learning pronunciation?*
 Personality traits like openness to experience, extroversion, and a willingness to take risks can
positively impact pronunciation learning. These traits encourage learners to practice more
frequently, seek out interaction with native speakers, and persist despite mistakes.

11. *To what extent do you think intelligibility is a sufficient goal in the learning of
pronunciation?*

Intelligibility is a crucial and sufficient goal for most learners. The primary aim should be to
communicate clearly and be understood. While a native-like accent can be beneficial, it’s not
necessary for effective communication.

### After Reading Questions

1. *Examine a textbook for teaching pronunciation. What aspects of pronunciation does it teach?
What exercise types does it employ? To what extent do the exercises link pronunciation to
communicative interaction?*

A comprehensive pronunciation textbook should cover individual sounds (phonemes), stress,

rhythm, intonation, and connected speech. It should include exercises like minimal pair drills,
listening and repetition, and communicative activities that integrate pronunciation practice with
real-life interactions, ensuring that learners apply pronunciation skills in meaningful contexts.

2. *Jones suggests that older learners “might benefit from a more descriptive or analytic
approach” to the teaching of pronunciation than younger learners. What might the implications of
this be for program design and teaching strategies?*

For older learners, teaching strategies should include explicit explanations of phonetic rules and
sound production. Programs might incorporate detailed phonetic transcriptions, contrastive
analysis with learners’ L1, and analytical activities that cater to their cognitive strengths and
learning preferences.
3. *Design an activity that teaches pronunciation within a communicative task.*

A role-play activity where learners practice a dialogue at a restaurant can teach pronunciation.
Learners focus on intonation and stress while ordering food, ensuring that they practice
pronunciation in a realistic and engaging context.

4. *Do you agree that teachers and classrooms seem to have very little to do with how well
students pronounce English?*

While natural exposure and practice play significant roles, teachers and classrooms are still
crucial. Effective instruction, personalized feedback, and structured practice can significantly
improve learners' pronunciation.

5. *What is the role of the teacher in a pronunciation class? What is the role of the learners?*

The teacher provides clear models, corrects errors, and creates a supportive environment for
practice. Learners should actively participate, practice regularly, and apply feedback to improve
their pronunciation.

6. *What are the arguments for and against the use of pronunciation drills?*

Pronunciation drills help reinforce correct pronunciation through repetition, building muscle
memory. However, they can be monotonous and may not promote communicative competence if
used in isolation.

7. *What is the role of focused listening in the teaching of pronunciation? Give examples of
activities of this kind.*
 Focused listening helps learners identify and replicate correct sounds and intonation patterns.
Activities might include listening to and repeating sentences with varied intonation, identifying
stressed words in speech, and shadowing native speakers.

8. *What is the role of monitoring in the learning of pronunciation? Suggest activities that can
develop this capacity.*

Monitoring allows learners to self-assess and adjust their pronunciation. Activities include
recording and analyzing their speech, peer feedback sessions, and using language learning apps
with pronunciation feedback features.

9. *How can learners be included “in the decision-making process concerning the areas in which
they would like to improve their speaking,” according to Hebert?*

Teachers can involve learners by discussing their pronunciation goals, encouraging self-
assessment, and allowing them to choose practice activities that align with their interests and
needs.

10. *Listen to some samples of low-level second language learners speaking, and use the
diagnostic profile proposed by Hebert to identify their pronunciation problems.*

This activity involves analyzing learner speech for common pronunciation issues, such as
incorrect stress, rhythm, or vowel/consonant sounds, and using a diagnostic profile to identify
and address these areas.

11. *Choose a topic for a speaking lesson and plan a lesson that builds in a pronunciation focus,
following the approach illustrated by Hebert.*

For a lesson on travel, learners could practice a dialogue at an airport, focusing on

pronunciation features like stress and intonation in questions and responses. The lesson would
include listening, repetition, and role-play activities to reinforce correct pronunciation.
I hope these detailed answers help! If you have any more questions or need further elaboration,
feel free to ask.