Comparative Summary of the Four Ethical Theories
Virtue Ethics Natural Law Deontology CONSEQUENTIALISM
(Aristotle) (St. Thomas Aquinas) (Immanuel Kant) Utilitarianism
Virtue- the excellence of a reconciled reason & faith rule-based / duty-based / Hedonism of the Ancient
thing to perform its agreed on Aristotle’s goodwill Greeks– seeks for what is
function/purpose (telos) proposition about man’s actions are good or bad pleasurable
Man is a rational being (can nature according to a clear set of Jeremy Bentham –
reason) Man has innate ability to rules. maximization of pleasure
The focus is on character determine right from wrong, Categorical Imperative – the and minimization of pain.
development moral from immoral. core of Kantian Ethics. It Felicific calculus- calculation
Man’s nature is TO Man’s ability to reason commands everyone to of happiness
REASON. Man’s function is comes from God. God follow regardless of the Greatest pleasure to the
TO REASON. It is natural for expects us to be good, so He circumstance. greatest number of people
man to use his reason; equipped us to know how to TWO PRINCIPLES: Basis of morality is in the
unnatural for man not to be good. 1. UNIVERSALIZABILITY – act consequence or result of the
reason. There are four kinds of law: only in a way you would want action, if the result has
Golden Mean- the key to ETERNAL, natural, divine, everyone else in the world. Kant higher pleasure than pain.
moral behavior and human laws. said act is permissible if you are John Stuart Mill – did not
God gave us natural human willing for that action to be agree on felicific calculus
inclinations: self- universalized. If not, then it Greatest pleasure to the
preservation, just dealing cannot be a moral law greatest number of people is
with others and propagation 2. Formula of HUMANITY – “Treat not applicable in all
Right acts are those in humanity in every case or in situations.
accordance with the that of anyone else, as an end, Rule Utilitarianism- rules
NATURAL LAW. never only as a means.” should be the basis of
morality if rules are moral
and are pleasurable to the
majority.
Use your reason on how to
achieve the mean (balance)
to be moral in your behavior.