Final Dissertation Ha
Final Dissertation Ha
A Dissertation
Submitted in
Partial fulfillment of the requirement
For the award of the Degree of
MASTER OF ARTS
(In Psychology)
Department Of Psychology
BANASTHALI VIDYAPITH
RAJASTHAN-304022
2019-2020
Dedicated
Sandhya Gupta for always picking me up over everything, again and again and
for never leaving me alone. I, honestly, can never thank her enough for helping
me grow and teaching me how to build a shelter for myself, when I had none.
Thank you for accepting me with all my imperfections and for always showering
I also dedicate this research to my loving parents, Mrs. Shobhana and Dr.
Alok Awasthi, for making me understand the value of hard work and for
teaching me to be persistent and never ever give up. Both of them have
provided me with their immense support throughout the process. Thank you so
much for being the light and the hope that I carry with myself each day.
CERTIFICATE
Women”. It is the genuine work of the candidate herself and it has not been
submitted previously.
worked under Dr. Sandhya Gupta for the research project entitled “Marital
Women”. It is the genuine work of the candidate herself and it has not been
submitted previously.
Women” is my own work and that it has not been submitted previously.
Prima facea, I am grateful to the God for the good health and wellbeing
that were necessary to complete this Research Dissertation.
Last but not the least; I would also like to thank all my friends who have
been a constant support in my sojourn of life.
I also place on record, my sense of gratitude to one and all, who directly
or indirectly, have lent their hand in this venture.
CONTENTS
Page
No.
1. INTRODUCTION
2. REVIEW OF LITERATURE
3. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
4. RESULTS
5. DISCUSSION
6. REFERENCES
INTRODUCTION
Contemporary life is very rapid and full of competition. The whole world is looking
for recognition, money, victory and glory. This combat of attainment is made extra
challenging by the variations that are repetitively happening round the world like mechanical,
technical, economical and industrial changes. These variations have promoted quality and
manner of existence through development but on the dimmer side it places a great demand on
our portion to go further than our lines and attain everything imaginable. To deal with these
rising benchmarks of life it becomes necessary for both the companions to earn so as to afford
a proper living. Currently, there appears to be a rise in the quantity of working women.
Educated females nowadays strive for career in the areas which were dominated by males.
Despite this modern change in the gender and professional roles of women, there still subsists
a huge part of society which is of the opinion that even though a woman is greatly educated,
her key and single aim in life is to watch over her family, husband and children. This throws
light on “housewives”, a class of women who don‟t work outside their homes. Housewives
work unremittingly; doing all the housework like chopping, cooking, cleaning, nursing and
what not; managing it all to perfection. Nonetheless, regrettably, in most of the circumstances,
women are maltreated gravely and the significance of women in our society is undervalued.
that being without a job unfavorably disturbs an individual‟s wellbeing. Multiple researches
have also shown that non-working people, as compared to working people, are at a higher risk
complications; and behavioral problems (Goldsmith et al., 1997; Layard, 2005; Theodossiou,
1997; Flatau et al., 2000; Morrell et al., 1998; Creed et al., 1999; Shamir, 1986; Murphy and
Athanasou, 1999).
In the current scenario of India, a sole earning is not ample any longer to run the
family and in-turn wives incomes have turned out to be of vital importance. In these freshly
picked up roles, the hurdles encountered by working women are dissimilar than those of non-
working women, for, mostly, the working women‟s manifold role involvement disrupts
anticipations of others and their boundless array of demands. Regardless of the working status
of a woman, the society in which we live still envisions her as the chief caretaker of the
household, family and children and hence a working woman is bound to perform a twofold
role of a homemaker and an employee. While accomplishing these dual duties, working
women face complications in managing their time accordingly in order to complete their
domestic chores adequately, take proper care of their family, husband and children, and also
cope with the obstacles and deadlines in their work as an employee, all of which leads to role
conflict. Various researches have also put forward that this role burden leads to depression,
stress, anxiety and conflict amid partners. Conflict between fulfilling role demands is often
encountered by working women (Begum & Tasneem, 1984). When a career oriented woman
is not able to meet the roles and expectations effectively, she undergoes guilt, depression,
stress, anxiety and difficulties in marital adjustment. According to Bloustein (1968), a modern
and career oriented woman is often told that she can pool her family and marital life with a
job, but then again on each step she has to cope with hurdles of unfairness, bigotry and
institutional support. The story of housewives is not much different either; generally they are
full of activity in their domestic deeds, such as taking care of her in- laws and husband, being
a procreator of children, arranging meals, cleaning and so on. As a consequence she is not
capable of finding out time for herself and her marital life which leads to problems in marital
adjustment.
Marriage has certain purposes to live up to and it is one of the most crucial
relationships between a man and a woman as it comprises of legal and emotional vow that is
pretty essential in adult life. Thus, various descriptions of marriage are there which state its
multiple aims. The goals of marriage as pointed out by Dr. Hannah M. Stone and Abraham
Stone are, “Men and women may marry for any number of individual reasons. Basically,
however, they seek in marriage three main objectives - a stable, permanent association based
on mutual affection, on love and companionship; sexual intimacy and procreation are then, at
least the main motives of the marriage.” Focus on subjective happiness is laid by Judson T.
Landies and Mary G. Landies in the subsequent words – “Most people, when they marry are
concerned primarily with their own happiness as a pair. More realistically, we should say that
at marriage, each individual is hoping to be happy and to receive certain benefits from
marriage.” Iwao Hoshii in The World of Sex – Vol. I Sexual Equality, define marriage as
“Marriage is a process of exploration conflict and compromise in which two partners live,
grow and mature or wither and decay together.” Marriage, according to Lehner and Cube, is,
“When people marry, they enter into new relationship, yet they bring to it the same behavior
patterns, needs and attitudes that characterized their former relationship.” Fred McKinney, in
Psychology of Personal Adjustment 3rd edition, describe marriage as, “Marriage in its best
form usually is the culmination of romantic love and courtship, with some sublimation of the
attraction.”
The purposes of marriage can be summed up from the different definitions given
Therefore, a pleasant bond between significant others is referred to as marriage and marriage
conveys love, warmth, friendship, affection and maximum fulfillment of essential needs of
life. This gratification can be attained through the mutual efforts of partners.
witnessed in this process. The process of interaction between an individual and his
surroundings is known as his personal adjustment. In it, an individual can either acclimate to
his settings or alter them. Moreover, one can not only alter and modify his or her environment
(directly or indirectly) but he can also modify his own conduct. Pleasing relationships and
individual primarily comprises of his family members and one can unconsciously attain some
ways of adjustment by intermingling with his family. The constant interaction with oneself,
with other individuals and with the world can be referred to as adjustment.
MARITAL ADJUSTMENT
which is achieved in different areas where conflict may exist in marriage.” Marital
adjustment, as per Locke and Williamson, is defined as “An adoption between husband and
wife to the point where there is companionship, agreement on basic values, affection,
adjustment is an extremely intricate phenomenon and no one specific factor is there which
entirely influences the success of matrimony. There are numerous factors which promote
marital success and contentment. Based on several researches, the following determinants of
Fiscal attitudes.
Thus, it can be said that spousal adjustment rests on the shared interaction and mindful and
conscious effort of husband and wife to accomplish marital happiness, contentment and
adjustment. Both intrapersonal and interpersonal relationships are likely to affect marital
adjustment. Pleasant relations must be sustained between the partners and the family members
in order to attain marital adjustment. People enter into matrimony due to numerous aims, like;
love, pleasure, companionship, and the longing to have children, physical desirability, or wish
spouses, with each other and with their marriage can be termed as the state of marital
adjustment (Sinha and Mukherjee). In one manner or the other, the objective of all the
matrimonies is happiness. A relationship amid couples is not instant but a gradual process.
Discontentment in married life is similar to the unnoticed cancer that destroys mutely and
softly.
Traditionally, in India, marriage was regarded as a ritual, binding together two entities
into a sanctified and eternal relationship. Due to this notion, marital adjustment was not
considered as an obstacle by married individuals. Rather than splitting with each other in the
Marriage was more of a social responsibility towards the relatives, family or community
rather than being meant for personal satisfaction, wellbeing, desires and aspirations.
maladjustment in marriage was hardly ever emphasized and given any attention and
consequently, barely any of the marriages were seen as unhappy and inappropriate.
(1961), this system of joint family provided the husband and wife with equals in age and sex
with whom they could acquire „companionship‟ gratification. Since they were not completely
reliant on each other for intense affection, warmth, friendliness and companionship, they had
comparatively good adjustment. The specified roles, regulations, status and obligations for
both the sexes were largely followed by the society as a whole and one was expected and
supposed to perform their specified duties and roles. As Dubey (1955) wrote, in accordance
with the traditional customs of Indian culture, a husband was supposed to be an authoritative
figure who dictated and whose choices and wills were given all the preferences. On the other
hand, the wife was supposed to treat her husband as her 'master' and was expected to serve
him staunchly. Moreover, males and husbands were deemed as „superior‟ and females and
traditional Hindu wife include taking care of household matters and being particularly
devoted to the demands and desires of her husband. Moreover, she was also supposed to keep
her own comforts and needs after those of her husband‟s. Kapadia (1958) wrote that a wife
was believed to fuse her distinctiveness and uniqueness with that of her husband in the same
way as a river unifies its identity and individuality with that of an ocean. The sole purpose of
a wife was the fulfillment of the needs and desires of her husband and she was considered to
be at his service all the times. Hence, in orthodox Indian households, the exact allocation of
work between husbands and wives, definite roles to be performed by them, and the docile
perception of women played a vital role in resolving some of the discords and disputes in
marital life.
Profound transformations and modifications have been witnessed by India, in the last
eight decades or so, in almost all the facets and Indian marriages are not an exception. A
major role has been played by the liberation of women from their tradition constrained
character in changing the concept of Indian marriages. Psychosocial changes in the outlooks
and values of Indian people have been brought about by the processes like co-education,
social reforms, etc. Overtime, there has been a considerable change in the perceptions and
outlooks of educated women and also of educated men (to some extent) towards marriage and
status of women in our society. Traditional conception of marriage is greatly being replaced
by subjective conception of marriage, systems of joint family and sacramental marriages are
fading and vital changes are also evident in the economic status of women. Kapur (1960),
educated and working women with their husbands. Personal fulfillment of emotional,
communal, financial and bodily needs is demanded by educated working women out of their
marriage and they give more importance to their privileges rather than their obligations.
Nowadays, marital happiness or unhappiness, in the urban nuclear families, largely depends
on the husband-wife relationship and the spouses primarily rely on one another for emotional
security. Frictions and frustrations are likely to arise when the needs and expectations from
marriage are not met. This in turn gives rise to the problem of marital adjustment.
The relationship between marital adjustment and women employment has remained
contradictory. Some investigations have pointed out a positive relationship between these two
while other investigations have put across a negative relationship between these variables.
Clashes in relationship and spousal distress and maladjustment often result in melancholy,
substantiate that anxiety and depression are experienced more by women than men. Some of
nuptial quarrels,
mistreatment by in-laws,
ANXIETY
Anxiety is part and parcel of human existence. Restlessness, dread and pressure that
arise from expectation of danger, which may be imaginary or actual is referred to as anxiety.
uneasy behavior, like striding to and fro, somatic illnesses, and negative cyclic thinking.
Anxiety differs from fear in the sense that fear is a reaction to an actual or perceived instant
danger, while anxiety is the anticipation of some future danger from a largely unreal source.
Anxiety often coexists with edginess, exhaustion, muscular rigidity and difficulties in
focusing. Being anxious can be apt, but when one undergoes anxiety on a regular basis, one
Although anxiety is related to fear, it is not the same thing. Fear is a direct, focused
response to a specific event or object, and the person is consciously aware of it. Most people
will feel fear if someone points a loaded gun at them or if they see a tornado forming on the
horizon. They also will recognize that they are afraid. Anxiety, on the other hand, is often
unfocused, vague, and hard to pin down to a specific cause. In this form it is called free-
floating anxiety. Sometimes anxiety being experienced in the present may stem from an event
or person that produced pain and fear in the past, but the anxious individual is not consciously
aware of the original source of the feeling. It is anxiety's aspect of remoteness that makes it
hard for people to compare their experiences of it. Whereas most people will be fearful in
physically dangerous situations, and can agree that fear is an appropriate response in the
presence of danger, anxiety is often triggered by objects or events that are unique and specific
being stimulated by present circumstances, not because of some immediate danger. Another
individual looking at the anxious person from the outside may be truly puzzled as to the
Anxiety plays a valuable role in self-preservation - the fear of the consequences often
prevents us from taking unnecessary risks. This kind of unnecessary risks usually comes in
female life and it all depends on her to tackle thumped situation. Anxiety as a disorder results
from the fear response becoming out of proportion to the actual risk. The body responds to
anxiety stimulus both physically and mentally. Anxiety can lead to over-stimulation of the
insomnia and difficulty in concentrating. Anxiety is often seen as a triggering of the fight-or-
flight reaction, causing excess adrenaline to be produced by the adrenal glands, which in turn
produce other hormones that affect various parts of the body, such as heartbeat and
respiration. Anxiety can also be a symptom of a wide range of medical and mental health
develop into a mental health condition, called an anxiety disorder. Treatment of anxiety varies
depending on the underlying cause, the severity, and a person's medical history, age, and
general health.
State-Trait Anxiety –
feelings of tension and apprehension, and heightened autonomic nervous system activity."
'State' anxiety is the anxiety state we experience when something causes us to feel
appropriately and temporarily anxious and this anxiety then retreats until we feel 'normal'
again. So, state anxiety is what one experiences when a dog runs out in front of the car; an
intense anxiety reaction that produces a number of strong anxiety symptoms associated with
the respiratory, digestive and circulatory systems. After the 'threat' has subsided, the anxiety
state retreats and one feels 'normal' again. This is how most people feel most of the time.
differences in anxiety proneness and refers to a general tendency to respond with anxiety to
perceived threats in the environment.‟ Trait anxiety is the 'preset' level of anxiety experienced
by an individual who has a tendency to be more anxious; to react less appropriately to anxiety
provoking stimuli.
REVIEW OF
LITERATURE
Literature review linked to the topic which is to be studied offers significant
information, which aids in conducting the study directly or indirectly. Reviewing the relevant
literature related to the topic helps the researcher in understanding the aspects of the topic
which have already been delved into considerably and also the topics that need more
concentration. Reviewing literature also provides the researcher with the tools and techniques
that are valuable in assessing the variables closely related to the topic. Hence, an important
The variables of the present study have been studied extensively but separately and
therefore it is slightly difficult to take into account all the research work that has already been
carried out in this field. Yet, an effort has been made and a few new and old studies associated
Ozcan et al. (2019) conducted a research on “The Relationships between Prenatal Attachment,
Basic Personality Traits, Styles of Coping with Stress, Depression, and Anxiety, and Marital
Adjustment among Women in the Third Trimester of Pregnancy”. The aim of the present
study was to explore the possible socio-demographic and clinical factors (personality features,
styles used in coping with stress, depression, and situational anxiety levels, and marital
support, and turning to religion as a coping mechanism with stress were found to be positively
correlated with prenatal attachment scores. The duration of marriage and number of births
given and the avoidance/disengagement subscale of Coping with Stress Scale and BDI scores
were negatively correlated with prenatal attachment scores. A BDI score of ≥17 (this score
suggests moderate and/or severe symptoms of depression) was found to be an independent
Pedro et al. (2017) studied “Marital adjustment in the context of female breast cancer: A
systematic review”. The objective was to systematically review studies assessing marital
adjustment in the context of female breast cancer to understand which factors are associated
with marital adjustment in both patients and partners and characterize the measures used to
assess marital adjustment within these studies. Fourteen studies were included. Results
Specifically, open and constructive communication, more social support, and supportive
dyadic coping were found to be associated with higher levels of marital adjustment. Other
variables such as self-efficacy, sexual functioning, and psychological adjustment were also
Nadam and Sylaja (2015) conducted a study on “Marriage Adjustment among Working and
Non-Working Women”. The result of this study revealed that the marriage adjustment of
Khalid et al. (2015) conducted a research on “Social support, marital adjustment, and
psychological distress among women with primary infertility in Pakistan”. The aim of this
study was to identify the prevalence rates of psychological distress among Pakistani women
seeking help for primary infertility. The associations of social support, marital adjustment,
and socio-demographic factors with psychological distress were also examined. The
prevalence of psychological distress was 37.3%. The results of this study suggested that
marital adjustment and social support were significantly negatively associated with
psychological distress in this sample. These associations were not confounded by any of the
demographic variables controlled in the multivariable regression models. The results of this
small-scale effort highlight the need for social and familial awareness to help tackle the
Qadir et al. (2013) studied “The association of marital relationship and perceived social
support with mental health of women in Pakistan”. The results of the study revealed that
perceived higher social support reduces the likelihood of depression and anxiety by enhancing
positive relationship as reflected by a low score on the relationship dynamics scale which
decreases CMD symptoms. Moreover, perceived higher social support is positively associated
with marital adjustment directly and indirectly through relationship dynamics which is
associated with the reduced risk of depression through the increased level of reported marital
satisfaction. Nuclear family structure, low level of education and higher socio-economic
Whisman et al. (2012) conducted a research on “Marital functioning and binge eating disorder
in married women”. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the association between marital
functioning and binge eating disorder (BED). The results of this study revealed that women
with BED reported lower levels of marital satisfaction and higher levels of negative
interaction than women with other disorders, who in turn reported poorer functioning
than women with no disorder. Women with other disorders reported lower levels of positive
interaction than women with BED, who in turn reported lower levels than women with no
disorder.
Lopez et al. (2011) conducted a study on “Religious commitment, adult attachment, and
marital adjustment in newly married couples”. This study examined the effects of religious
commitment and insecure attachment on marital adjustment. Newly married couples who did
commitment, adult attachment, and marital functioning. There was a small positive
buffered the negative association between attachment avoidance and marital adjustment, but
exacerbated the negative association between attachment anxiety and marital adjustment.
Kazmi et al. (2010) studied the association between marital adjustment and economic
resources. Results indicated that economic resources play significant role in marital
adjustment. Significant difference exists between economic resources of working and non-
working women. Non-working married women have to face more economic problems in their
married life as compared to working married women and consequently they faced more stress
and less adjusted. Working women are more martially adjusted as compare to non-working
women.
387 married couples. Regression analyses demonstrated that communication and sexual
Alternatively, if couples have difficulty communicating but are sexually satisfied, they will
experience greater marital satisfaction than if they have a less satisfying sexual relationship.
Thus, sexual satisfaction may partially compensate for the negative effects of poor
Nathawat and Mathur (1993) studied “Marital adjustment and subjective well-being in Indian-
educated housewives and working women”. Results indicated significantly better marital
adjustment and subjective well-being for the working women than for the housewives.
Specifically, working women reported higher scores on general health, life satisfaction, and
self-esteem measures and lower scores on hopelessness, insecurity, and anxiety, compared
with the housewives, although the housewives had lower scores on negative affect than
the working women. Findings were insignificant on positive affect and depression.
STUDIES ON ANXIETY –
and Anxiety among Adult Women in an Urban Population in Kerala”. The objective of this
study is to estimate the prevalence and determinants of somatization and anxiety among
adult women in an urban population of Kochi. This study concluded that mental health
services for urban women deserve immediate attention as the prevalence of somatization
Abbas et al. (2019) conducted a research on “The moderating role of social support for
marital adjustment, depression, anxiety, and stress: Evidence from Pakistani working and
nonworking women”. This study examined how social support moderates the prolongation of
mental distress related to depression, anxiety, stress, and marital adjustment in working and
nonworking women. The study aimed to reveal the relationship between social support and
mental health issues associated with depression, anxiety, stress, and marital adjustment among
females. The results of the study revealed that social support was positively and significantly
associated with marital adjustment, although it showed a negative association with anxiety,
depression, and stress in working and nonworking women; this finding reflects the better
mental health of the study population. The findings proved that marital adjustment has a
negative relation with depression and anxiety in married working and nonworking females.
Social support acts as a moderator for marital cohesion, affection, stress, and depression, and
the results reflected that nonworking women with higher marital cohesion and affection
Diago et al. (2018) studied “Anxiety and depressive symptoms, and stress biomarkers in
pregnant women after in vitro fertilization: a prospective cohort study”. The purpose of the
study was to find out whether in vitro fertilization (IVF) affects the course of anxiety and
The results of this study revealed that IVF mothers have more anxiety symptoms and higher
stress biomarker levels but fewer depression symptoms than natural conception mothers at the
third trimester of pregnancy, but these differences are negligible during postpartum period.
Villar et al. (2017) conducted a research on “Quality of life and anxiety in women with breast
cancer before and after treatment.” The objectives of the study were to determine the quality
of life and anxiety in patients with breast cancer and the changes they experience after
treatments. The results showed that the baseline quality of life dimensions with the lowest
score were future prospects (46.0/100) and sexual enjoyment (55.7/100). The dimensions with
the highest score were body image (94.2/100) and role (93.3/100). The most disturbing
symptoms were insomnia, fatigue and concern about hair loss. After treatment, the
dimensions of physical function, role, body image, financial concerns and symptomatology
worsened, whereas emotional function and future prospects improved. Severe anxiety
presented as a state (48.6%) and as a trait (18.2%). The highest baseline state anxiety was
associated with married-widowed status and anxiolytic medication. The greatest trait anxiety
was associated with an inactive work situation, anxiolytic medication, breast swelling and
Chhansiya and Jogsan (2015) conducted a study on “Ego Strength and Anxiety among
Working and Non-working Women”. The aim of the research was to find out the mean
difference between working and non-working women. The study revealed that there was
significant difference between working and non-working women in Ego strength. There was
significant difference between working and non-working women in anxiety. While the
correlation between Ego strength and anxiety reveals 0.54 positive correlation.
Bansal et al. (2015) studied “Depression and anxiety among middle-aged women: A
community-based study”. The objective of the study was to assess the level of depression and
anxiety among middle age women and the possible factors behind it. The results showed that
the level of syndromal depression and anxiety was found to be 86.7% and 88.9%,
respectively. Most of the subjects had the moderate type of depression (49.5%) followed by
mild (29.4%) and severe depression (7.8%). While in case of anxiety, most of the subjects
(69.4%) had a mild form of anxiety and 17.8% had moderate anxiety level. A significant
difference was observed in the level of depression with respect to marital status (P = 0.009)
and in the level of anxiety with respect to age (P = 0.021) in the study subjects. On applying
logistic regression, none of the factors studied were found to be significant variables for
Irfan and others (2012) studied “A Comparative Study of Working and Non-working Married
Women: Effect of Anxiety Level on Life Satisfaction”. The results of the study show that
females those who are working and married, are low on anxiety with higher life satisfaction in
comparison to the non-working married females. They perceived their life as challenging and
secure. They feel comfortable with their life situations. Whereas, the non-working married
females are less satisfied with their lives and their anxiety level is also higher than the anxiety
Bahrami and Yousefi (2011) conducted a research on “Females Are More Anxious than
Males: a Metacognitive Perspective”. The purpose of this study was to determine the factors
that cause anxiety disorders and more prevalent among women than men. The results have
shown a higher rate of health anxiety and metaworry in girls than boys. Besides, it can be
inferred that girls more than boys believe that worry is uncontrollable and must be avoided
due to metacognition.
Iqbal and others (2004) studied “Anxiety in Non-working women with Reference to their
Education, Family system and number of Children”. Anxiety was observed in 74% of non-
working women and 36% of working women had anxiety. A statistically significant
association between anxiety in women and education and number of their children was found.
Mukhopadhyay et al. (1993) studied “Working status and anxiety levels of urban
educated women in Calcutta.” The primary objective of the present study was to assess the
similar group of non-working mothers with respect to their anxiety level. The possible
relationships between anxiety score and age of these mothers as well as their children were
studied. Non-working mothers showed higher anxiety levels than their working counterparts
with respect to the total anxiety score as well as its components, although the differences were
values with increasing age of children. This trend was absent among the working mothers.
The age of these mothers was not related to their anxiety level.
class women of Calcutta”. The present study compares a group of working mothers with
their non-working counterparts with respect to: (a) stress level, measured in terms of
their anxiety score; and (b) certain general indicators of health including a broad measure of
stress. The results show that anxiety and health scores of the two groups of women are
similar. Further, the health score and anxiety score seem to be correlated, more clearly among
and unemployed women with normal vaginal delivery”. This study investigated the
differences in health-related quality of life of employed and unemployed women with normal
lower health-related quality-of-life than the unemployed at the three time-points, the lowest
mean score being at 18 weeks postpartum (Mean = 73.9). Women with higher education and
Employed women have more problems with physical health components and are more
negatively affected by increasing age except those with higher education and personal
income.
Raza and others (2017) studied “Dietary practices and severity of depression: Comparative
study among housewives and working women in Karachi”. The aim of the study was to
depression severity in housewives and working women. Study outcomes revealed that dietary
study groups were those who were taking 3 meals [18(14.5%) housewives and
and76(44.7%) working women]. A high number of women with minimal depression were
witnessed among participants who rarely consumed vegetables [16(13.1%) housewives and
housewives (p<0.001). the study concluded that although housewives were more depressed
than working women, the highest number of participants with none or minimal depression in
both study groups were those who had better dietary practices.
Mardhekar and others (2012) conducted a study on “Coping strategies and learned
helplessness of employed and nonemployed educated married women from India”. In the
present study, three types of coping strategies (cognitive, physical, and social coping) and
learned helplessness between married women who are either employed or nonemployed in
Pune, India were compared. A total of 100 employed women and 100
nonemployed women were surveyed. Employed women were found to have significantly
higher cognitive, physical, and social coping, as well as lower learned helplessness than
nonemployed women.
employed women and housewives: a cross sectional study from southeast Iran”. The purpose
of the study was to compare the quality of life of employed women with housewives in
Zahedan, Iran. The results indicated that employed women scored higher than housewives in
all measures except for physical functioning. The differences were found to be remarkable for
vitality, mental health and role emotional. However, after controlling for age, education and
Gao and others (2009) studied “Comparison of factors correlating life satisfaction between
full-time working women and housewives in an urban city using covariance structural
analysis”. The purpose of this study was to clarify and compare components of life
satisfaction between full-time working women and housewives in an urban city using
covariance structural analysis. This analysis revealed that low gender role consciousness and
high self-efficacy directly led to high life satisfaction in full-time working women, and low
life satisfaction in housewives with significance. On the other hand, it was shown that high
support from family or friends indirectly led to high life satisfaction in full-
symptoms and social support among women with coronary artery disease”. The study
investigated whether work and marital status are associated with depressive symptoms, social
support, and daily stress behavior in women with coronary artery disease (CAD). Results
revealed that women who were working at the time of measurement had lower levels of
depressive symptoms and higher levels of social support than the nonworking women,
whereas marital status was not related to any of the outcome variables. Results were similar
after adjusting for potential confounders, that is, age, education, self-reported health, and risk
factors for CAD. There was no significant interaction between marital status
and working status on depressive symptoms, social support, or daily stress behavior.
Meleis and Stevens (1992) conducted a study on “Women in clerical jobs: spousal role
satisfaction, stress, and coping”. The research was designed to respond to the need for
understanding the daily experiences of women in clerical jobs. The data about spousal role
satisfactions, stress and coping strategies, as perceived and articulated by them, indicated that
there are almost an equal number of satisfying and stressful aspects of the spousal
domination. Women in this study coped by using strategies that are more solitary in nature.
They identified very little power to negotiate support and tangible assistance.
RATIONALE
Marital conditions are highly responsible for depression and anxiety among women. It
is often advocated that in order to bring women to equal status with men, economic
independence is necessary. As a result women are being provided with various jobs in the
society. Working women have additional problems of marital adjustment, mental, health,
emotional and social problems, etc. in the process of adjustment with their job demands and
family demands. The story of housewives is not much different either; generally they are full
of activity in their domestic deeds, such as taking care of her in- laws and husband, being a
procreator of children, arranging meals, cleaning and so on. As a consequence she is not
capable of finding out time for herself and her marital life which leads to problems in marital
adjustment and mental health. It is therefore relevant to study the marital adjustment and
anxiety among working and non-working women and the present research aims to study the
difference between working and non-working married women with respect to marital
Married women between 35 to 45 years of age are taken for this study as physical
changes come in this period which in turn has significant impacts on psychological level as
well and different changes in circumstances also lead to behavioral changes in women.
Working women of the same profession (university teachers) are selected for the present
study as they go through a lot of pressures on the professional front as well as in their
personal lives. If they are working they are supposed to perform all duties at office as well as
at home. Non-working women, on the other hand, are always expected to be perfect and are
under a lot of pressure to be the „ideal‟ housewife. Marital conditions are highly responsible
for depression and anxiety among women. Because our society is man-oriented society,
women have to face all problems. Hence, this research aims at exploring the difference
between anxiety and marital adjustment among working and non-working married women.
OPERATIONAL DEFINITIONS
Marital Adjustment – It is the state in which there is an overall feeling in husband and
wife of happiness and satisfaction with their marriage and with each other.
of the person.
Working Women – Women who work out of the house for paying jobs are classified
as working women.
described as women not involved in any kind of paid jobs or employment and not
collection, design of the study, sample selected for the study, statistical method used for the
PROBLEM –
To assess whether there would be any difference between working and non-working married
OBJECTIVES –
marital adjustment.
anxiety.
HYPOTHESES –
women.
women.
SAMPLE –
The total sample for this study constituted 150 married women, i.e. 75 working and 75 non-
working women. The sample was selected from Kanpur district with the help of purposive
TOOLS –
Marital Adjustment Questionnaire was developed by Kumar and Rohatgi (1999). The
reliability and the test-retest reliability of the questionnaire were found to be 0.70 and
0.84 respectively, making the test highly reliable. The face validity and the content
validity of the questionnaire were also fairly high and adequately assured.
Sinha‟s Comprehensive Anxiety Test was developed by Sinha and Sinha (1971). It
consists of 90 items, to be answered in Yes or No. The internal consistency reliability
coefficient of the test was found to be 0.92 which ensures a high reliability of the test.
RESEARCH DESIGN –
A survey research design was used for the study to assess the marital adjustment and anxiety
of working and non-working women between 35 to 45 years of age from Kanpur district,
Uttar Pradesh.
STATISTICAL TECHNIQUE –
PROCEDURE –
The questionnaires were distributed individually to all the participants. It was made clear to
the respondents that the questionnaires were to be filled out anonymously and their responses
according to the instructions given. Completed questionnaire forms were collected from each
respondent. The obtained data was analyzed as per objectives of the present study.
RESULTS
The main objectives in the analysis of the data were to assess the difference in
working and non-working married women in terms of marital adjustment and anxiety. For this
Comprehensive Anxiety Test by Sinha and Sinha were administered on a sample of 150
married women (75 working and 75 non-working) in the age range of 35-45 years. The
TABLE – 1: Mean ranks, U value and p-value of working and non-working married women
on Marital Adjustment.
WOMEN
Women
Non-working 75 78.78
Women
Both the groups of married women (working and non-working) were assessed on marital
adjustment and the p-value was found to be non-significant (p > 0.05). The findings do not
support the first hypothesis (there would be a significant difference in the marital adjustment
on Anxiety.
WOMEN
Women
Non-working 75 77.37
Women
Both the groups of married women (working and non-working) were assessed on the level of
anxiety and the p-value was found to be non-significant (p > 0.05). The findings do not
support the second hypothesis (there would be a significant difference in the anxiety of
working and non-working married women) as there is no significant difference in the anxiety
women.
The first hypothesis of the present research prognosticated that there would be a
significant difference in the marital adjustment of working and non-working married women
and the results discard the stated hypothesis. The findings of the current study suggest that
there is no significant difference between both the groups indicating that working and non-
The outcomes implicate the reality that women whether working or non-working have
always been considered responsible for their families and homes and employment of women
has never substantially reduced their duties and responsibilities towards their families and
homes. Working women are always held accountable for the vast majority of household tasks
regardless of their jobs. Although, this modern and patriarchal society in which we live wants
women to be well educated, take up jobs and have an independent career and personality, this
society, nonetheless, expects working women to be submissive, obedient, meek, docile and
efficient wives. While undertaking these dual duties, working women encounter obstacles in
handling and managing their time appropriately in order to meet with the boundless array of
demands and expectations effectively such as completing their domestic chores amply, taking
proper care of their family, husband and children and also coping with the hurdles and
deadlines in their work as an employee. This twofold role of a homemaker and an employee
instigates a lot of stress in their life and adversely influences their relationship with their
husband and other family members. All this makes their life miserable and eventually results
Conversely, it can be seen that non-working married women are predominantly full of
household activities such as sweeping, dusting, doing laundry, preparing meals and taking
care of her in-laws, looking after her husband and children and so on. Due to such state of
affairs, she is barely able to take out time for her marital and personal life and consequently
The results of the present study suggest that the problems in marital adjustment are
faced by both working and non-working married women although the reasons might differ
and the results are also consistent with the study conducted by Moore et al. (1984). Their
women and their marital adjustment. Hashmi et al. (2007) in their study regarding marital
adjustment of working and non-working women also concluded that both the groups exhibit
no clear difference in their marital adjustment. Jamabo and Ordu (2012) also failed to find
women.
However, the findings are inconsistent with the study conducted by Nathawat and
Mathur (1993); Rogers and May (2003); Rita et al. (2017) which indicates that working
women are more satisfied and better adjusted in their marital life as compared to their non-
working counterparts.
The second hypothesis proposed that there would be a significant difference in the
anxiety of working and non-working married women and the findings of the present study
reject the stated hypothesis. The result suggests that there is no significant difference between
both the groups indicating that working and non-working married women have somewhat
Nowadays, a single earning is not enough anymore to run the family and hence there
has been an escalation in the employment rate of women. Women, nevertheless, continue to
endure the responsibility of nurturing and domestic chores and doing it all has turned out to be
a common norm for women. Married women are left ragged and dilapidated under the
Numerous researches have pointed out that working women are often bound to play
multiple roles at the same time and all the workload of carrying out dual duties, more often
than not, results in anxiety, stress, depression and clashes among the partners and other family
members. Pertaining to this, the effort-recovery model (Meijman & Mulder, 1998) states that
effort is indispensable for fulfilling job commitments and obligations and recovery is there
when the person does not put in his/her mental or bodily effort. This model assumes that the
effort in jobs is strongly linked with severe reactions like heart problems, high blood pressure,
exhaustion, muscular rigidity and fatigue. The chances of recovery become very thin if the
stress persists thereby increasing the possibility of depression, anxiety and complications in
sleeping pattern and diminishing the probability of positive emotions and psychological well-
being. After the working hours, working women have to complete their home related
responsibilities and do all the domestic chores. They are trapped in this vicious cycle due to
which their recovery is hampered and this lack of recovery intensifies the likelihood of poor
According to the scarcity hypothesis (Edwards & Rothbard, 2000), in this regard,
individuals have limited and fixed resources which are hardly sufficient to be apportioned to
their manifold roles and results in having feelings of anxiety, guilt and also hampers their
mental well-being. Working women are still envisioned as the prime caretaker of the
household, family, husband and children and consequently a working woman is destined to
perform a twofold role of a housewife and an employee. When a career oriented woman is not
able to meet the roles and expectations effectively, she undergoes guilt, depression, stress and
anxiety.
Non-working women, on the other hand, work incessantly; doing all the housework
like chopping, cooking, cleaning, nursing and what not; managing it all to perfection.
Nevertheless, deplorably, in most of the circumstances, non-working women are grimly ill-
treated and their significance in our society is belittled. Multiple studies have concluded that a
major stressor for non-working women was lack of social life. Non-working women lack
social connections, power, respect, financial independence, individual identity and as a result
have low self-efficacy, self-confidence and self-esteem. All these factors lead to feelings of
The results of the current research state that both the working and non-working
women have roughly equal level of anxiety despite having distinct set of problems. The
results of the research are in line with the study conducted by Mukhopadhyay (1989). The
findings showed that anxiety and health scores of the two groups of women are similar.
However, the findings are not consistent with the study conducted by Patel et al.
(2017). Their results revealed that homemakers (non-working women) had 1.2 times higher
anxiety and 1.3 times higher stress than working women. Bhadoria (2013) reported significant
differences in the level of anxiety and depression between working and non-working women.
The results of the study by Kaur et al. (2012) also show that women who are married and
working are low on anxiety with higher life satisfaction as compared to females who are
CONCLUSION
Thus, it can be concluded from the above discussion that there is no significant
difference in marital adjustment and anxiety of working and non-working married women and
the results reject both the hypotheses of the study. Women have continually made a
substantial contribution to their communities, but their contribution is not appreciated and
acknowledged frequently due to a patriarchal conspiracy. It is clear from the above findings
that the reasons behind problems in marital adjustment and anxiety might be different for both
the groups but both working and non-working married women have approximately equal
The sample of the present study was taken from a particular city.
Married women of only 35 to 45 years of age were taken for the study.
SUGGESTIONS –
The study can be widened by taking into account different cities and states for better
IMPLICATIONS –
The findings of the present research are extremely beneficial for mental health
professionals, relationship counselors, community supporters, life coaches, teachers, and for
enrich their formal educational level in order to enhance their chances of learning and
improving self-efficacy and self-assistance. They should also be encouraged to take active
part in social works and develop social connections in order to avoid their chances of
developing anxiety.
The study is of vital importance as it throws light on the essential aspects that must be
considered for the enhancement of marital adjustment and satisfaction and mental health of
married women. Social cooperation and support may be used as a resource to improve marital
relationship and potentially decrease marital troubles as a threat to women‟s mental health.
Equal amount of support, attention, care and protection must be rendered to both working and
non-working women. Furthermore, the facility of mental health services is also an essential
requirement and techniques like meditation, guided imagery, yoga, muscle relaxation, self-
hypnosis, mindfulness breathing, etc. should be utilized by both the groups of women for
moderating role of social support for marital adjustment, depression, anxiety, and
Ahrens, C.J.C., & Ryff, C.D. (2006). Multiple roles and well-being: Sociodemographic and
Alex, R.A. (2015). Stress tolerance and adjustment among working and non-working
6(1), 7-12.
Association.
Babu, A.R., Sreedevi, A., John, A., & Krishnapillai, V. (2019). Prevalence and
10.4103/ijcm.IJCM_55_19.
Bahrami, F., & Yousefi, N. (2011). Females Are More Anxious than Males: a
5(2), 83-90.
Bansal, P., Chaudhary, A., Soni, R. K., Sharma, S., Gupta, V. K., & Kaushal, P. (2015).
doi:10.4103/2249-4863.174297
Barnett, R. C., & Hyde, J. S. (2001). Women, men, work, and family: An expansionist
Begum, H.A., & Tasneem, S. (1984). Development of scale measuring perceived role of
Bhadoria, S. (2013). Level of Anxiety and Depression Among Working Women and Non-
4(42), 111-113.
Blom, M., Georgiades, A., László, K.D., Alinaghizadeh, H., Janszky, I., & Ahnve, S. (2007).
Work and marital status in relation to depressive symptoms and social support
among women with coronary artery disease. Journal of Women’s Health, 16(9), 1305-
Chhansiya, B.M., & Jogsan, Y.A. (2015). Ego Strength and Anxiety among Working and
Chinweuba, A.U., Okoronkwo, I.L., Anarado, A.N., Agbapuonwu, N.E., Ogbonnaya, N.P., &
unemployed women with normal vaginal delivery. BMC Women’s Health, 18(1), 13.
doi: 10.1186/s12905-017-0481-0
Diago, V., Gracia, A., Hervas, D., Ghosn, F., Vento, M., & Chafer, C. (2018). Anxiety and
10.1093/humrep/dey109.
Edwards, J. R., & Rothbard, N. P. (2000). Mechanisms linking work and family: Clarifying
Gao, Y., Hoshi, T., Nakayama, N., & Nakamura, T. (2009). Comparison of factors correlating
life satisfaction between full-time working women and housewives in an urban city
using covariance structural analysis. Japanese Journal of Public Health, 56(3), 155-
62.
Gupta, G., & Nafis, N. (2014). Does Marital Adjustment and Psychological Well-Being
Hashami, H.A., Khurshid, M., & Hassan, I. (2007). Marital Adjustment, Stress and
Science, 2, 19-26.
Irfan, M., Kaur, N., Panwar, N., & Thind, H. S. (2012). A comparative study of working and
Iqbal, A., Nadeem, R., & Fatima, N. (2004). Anxiety in non-working women with reference
Janzen, B.L., & Muhajarine, N. (2003). Social role occupancy, gender, income inadequacy,
life stage and health: A longitudinal study of employed Canadian men and women.
Joshi, K., Singh, R., & Jaswal, S. (2013). Intergenerational Differences in Perceived Conflict
Kapadia, K.M. (1958). Marriage and Family in India. Bombay: Oxford University Press.
Kapur, P. (1970). Marriage and the working women in India. Delhi: Vikas Publishing House
Kazmi, S.F., Pervez, T., & Ijaz, S. (2010). The Role of Economic Resources in Marital
Khalid, A., Qadir, F., & Medhin, G. (2015). Social support, marital adjustment, and
Landis, J.T. (1946). Length of time required to achieve adjustment in marriage. American
Landis, J.T., & Landis, M.G. (1963). Building a successful marriage. Englewood Cliffs,
sexual satisfaction, and marital satisfaction. Journal of Sex and Marital Therapy,
Locke, H.J., & Williamson, R.J. (1958). Marital Adjustment: A factor analysis study.
Lopez, J.L., Riggs, S.A., Pollard, S.E. & Hook, J.N. (2011). Religious commitment, adult
Mardhekar, V., Li, M., & Wadkar, A. (2012). Coping strategies and learned helplessness of
employed and nonemployed educated married women from India. Health Care for
Meleis, A.I., & Stevens, P.E. (1992). Women in clerical jobs: spousal role satisfaction, stress,
Moore, K., Spain, D. & Bianchi, S. (1984). Working wives and mothers. Marriage and
Mukhopadhyay, S. (1989). Working status and stress of middle class women of Calcutta.
and anxiety levels of urban educated women in Calcutta. The International Journal
Nadam, P.S., & Sylaja, H. (2015). Marriage adjustment among working and non-working
Nathawat, S.S., & Mathur, A. (1993). Marital adjustment and subjective well-being in
Nevin, S., & Fatima, A. (2007). A study into the effects of stress on women‟s health.
Ozcan, H., Ustundag, M.F., Yilmaz, M., Aydinoglu, U., Ersoy, A.O., & Eyi, E.G.Y. (2019).
Parasuraman, S., & Simmers, C. (2001). Type of Employment, Work-Family Conflict and
Patel, P.A., Patel, P.P., Khadilkar, A.V., Chiplonkar, S.A., & Patel, A.D. (2017). Impact of
Occupation on Stress and Anxiety among Indian women. Women Health, 57(3), 392-
Plaisier, I., De Bruijn, J. G. M., Smit, J. H., De Graaf, R., Ten Have, M., Beekman, A.T.F., &
Penninx, B.W.J.H. (2008). Work and family roles and the association with depressive
and anxiety disorders: Differences between men and women. Journal of Affective
Qadir, F., Khalid, A., Haqqani, S., & Medhin, G. (2013). The association of marital
relationship and perceived social support with mental health of women in Pakistan.
Rani, M.R. (2013). Marital adjustment problems of working and non-working women in
Raza, L., Ali, T.M., & Hasnain, A. (2017). Dietary practices and severity of depression:
Comparative study among housewives and working women in Karachi. The Journal
Rita, Suri, K., & Singh, S. (2017). A comparative study on mental health and marital
Rogers, S.J., & May, D.C. (2003). Spillover between marital quality and job Satisfaction:
Long-term patterns and gender differences. Journal of Marriage and Family, 65(2),
482-496.
Ross, A.D. (1961). The Hindu Family in its Urban Setting. Bombay: Oxford University Press.
Sahu, K., & Singh, D. (2014). Mental health and marital adjustment of working and non-
Saravi, F.K., Navidian, A., Rigi, S.N., & Montazeri, A. (2012). Comparing health-related
quality of life of employed women and housewives: a cross sectional study from
Schoon, I., Hansson, L., & Salmela-Aro, K. (2005). Combining workand family life. Life
satisfaction among married and divorcedmen and women in Estonia, Finland, and the
Singh, S.K. (2014). Life Satisfaction and Stress Level among Working and Non-Working
Sinha, A.K.P., & Sinha L.N.K. (1973). Sinha’s Comprehensive Anxiety Test. National
Sinha, S.P., & Mukherjee, N. (1989). Marital adjustment and personal space orientation. The
Stone, H.M., & Stone, A. (1953). A marriage manual: A practical guide-book to sex and
Sumra, M.K., & Schillaci, M.A. (2015). Stress and the Multiple-Role Woman: Taking a
Villar, R.R., Fernández, S.P., Garea, C.C., Pillado, M., Barreiro, V.B., & Martín, C.G. (2017).
Quality of life and anxiety in women with breast cancer before and after
8345.2258.2958.
Whisman, M.A., Dementveva, A., Baucom, D.H., & Bulik, C.M. (2012). Marital functioning
and binge eating disorder in married women. The International Journal of Eating