Lucia Di Lammemoor
Lucia Di Lammemoor
GAETANO DONIZETTI
lammermoor
conductor Opera in three acts
Riccardo Frizza
Libretto by Salvadore Cammarano,
production
Simon Stone based on the novel The Bride of
Lammermoor by Sir Walter Scott
set designer
Lizzie Clachan Saturday, May 21, 2022
costume designers 1:00–4:35 pm
Alice Babidge
Blanca Añón Last time this season
lighting designer
James Farncombe
projection designer
Luke Halls The production of Lucia di Lammermoor
choreographer was made possible by a generous gift from
Sara Erde the Estate of Michael L. Tapper, M.D., and
the Rosalie J. Coe Weir Endowment Fund
general manager
Peter Gelb With this performance and its entire spring
jeanette lerman - neubauer season, the Met honors Ukraine, its citizens,
music director
Yannick Nézet-Séguin and the many lives lost.
2021–22 season
lucia di
GAETANO DONIZETTI’S
lammermoor
This performance
is being broadcast
live over The
Toll Brothers–
Metropolitan Opera
International Radio co n duc to r
Network, sponsored Riccardo Frizza
by Toll Brothers,
America’s luxury in order of vocal appearance
®
homebuilder ,
with generous normanno
long-term support Alok Kumar
from the Annenberg
Foundation en r i co
Nadine Sierra’s h a r p s o lo
This performance is also Please remember that face masks are required at all times
being broadcast live inside the Met.
on Metropolitan Opera
Radio on SiriusXM Met Titles
channel 355. To activate, press the red button to the right of the screen in front of
your seat and follow the instructions provided. To turn off the display,
press the red button once again. If you have questions, please ask an
Visit metopera.org. usher at intermission.
2021–22 season
Act I
An intruder has been spotted near the Ashton family home, and Normanno
sends Enrico’s men off in search of the stranger. Enrico arrives, troubled. His
family’s fortunes are in danger, and only the arranged marriage of his sister, Lucia,
with Arturo Bucklaw can save them. The chaplain Raimondo reminds Enrico that
the girl is still mourning the death of her mother. But Normanno reveals that
Lucia is concealing a great love for Edgardo, leader of the Ashtons’ enemies.
Enrico is furious and swears vengeance. The men return and explain that they
have seen and identified the intruder as Edgardo. Enrico’s fury increases.
Just before dawn, Lucia and her companion Alisa are waiting for Edgardo. Lucia
relates that, in this very spot, she has seen the ghost of a girl who was stabbed
by a jealous lover. Alisa urges her to forget Edgardo, but Lucia insists that her
love for Edgardo brings her great joy and may overcome all. Edgardo arrives
and explains that he must leave on a political mission. Before he leaves, he
wants to make peace with Enrico. Lucia, however, asks Edgardo to keep their
love a secret. Edgardo agrees, and they exchange rings and vows of devotion.
Act II
It is some months later, on the day that Lucia is to marry Arturo. Normanno
assures Enrico that he has successfully intercepted all correspondence between
the lovers and has in addition procured a forged letter, supposedly from
Edgardo, that indicates that he is involved with another woman. As the captain
goes off to welcome the groom, Lucia enters, continuing to defy her brother.
Enrico shows her the forged letter. Lucia is heartbroken, but Enrico insists that
she marry Arturo to save the family. He leaves, and Raimondo, convinced no
hope remains for Lucia’s love, reminds her of her late mother and urges her to
do a sister’s duty. She finally agrees.
As the wedding guests arrive, Enrico explains to Arturo that Lucia is still in a state
of melancholy because of her mother’s death. The girl enters and reluctantly
signs the marriage contract. Suddenly, Edgardo bursts in, claiming his bride.
The entire company is overcome by shock. Arturo and Enrico order Edgardo to
leave, but he insists that he and Lucia are engaged. When Raimondo shows him
Visit metopera.org. 39
Synopsis CONTINUED
the contract with Lucia’s signature, Edgardo curses her and tears his ring from
her finger before finally leaving in despair and rage.
Act III
Enrico visits Edgardo at his dilapidated home and taunts him with the news that
Lucia and Arturo have just been married. The two men agree to meet at dawn
for a duel.
Back at Lucia’s house, Raimondo interrupts the wedding festivities with the
news that Lucia has gone mad and killed Arturo. Lucia enters, covered in
blood. Moving between tenderness, joy, and terror, she recalls her meetings
with Edgardo and imagines that she is with him on their wedding night. She
vows that she will never be happy in Heaven without her lover and that she will
see him there. When Enrico returns, he is enraged at Lucia’s behavior but soon
realizes that she has lost her senses. After a confused and violent exchange with
her brother, Lucia collapses.
Edgardo laments that he has to live without Lucia and awaits his duel with
Enrico, which he hopes will end his own life. Guests coming from the wedding
tell him that the dying Lucia has called his name. As he is about to rush to her,
Raimondo announces that she has died. Determined to join Lucia in Heaven,
Edgardo takes his own life.
40
In Focus
Gaetano Donizetti
Lucia di Lammermoor
Premiere: Teatro di San Carlo, Naples, 1835
The title role of Lucia di Lammermoor has become an icon in opera and
beyond, an archetype of the constrained woman asserting herself in society.
She reappears as a touchstone for such diverse later characters as Flaubert’s
adulterous Madame Bovary and the repressed Englishmen in the novels of E. M.
Forster. The insanity that overtakes and destroys Lucia, depicted in opera’s
most celebrated mad scene, has especially captured the public imagination.
Donizetti’s handling of this fragile woman’s state of mind remains seductively
beautiful, thoroughly compelling, and deeply disturbing. Madness, as explored
in this opera, is not merely something that happens as a plot function: It is at
once a personal tragedy, a political statement, and a healing ritual.
The Creators
Gaetano Donizetti (1797–1848) composed about 75 operas, in addition to
orchestral and chamber music, in a career abbreviated by mental illness and
an early death. Most of his works, with the exceptions of the ever-popular
Lucia and the comic gems L’Elisir d’Amore and Don Pasquale, disappeared
from the public eye after he died, but critical and popular opinion of his huge
oeuvre has grown considerably over the past 50 years. The Neapolitan librettist
Salvadore Cammarano (1801–52) also provided libretti for Verdi (Luisa Miller and
Il Trovatore). The source for this opera was The Bride of Lammermoor, a novel by
Sir Walter Scott (1771–1832), set in the years immediately preceding the union
of Scotland and England in 1707. Scott’s novels of adventure and intrigue in a
largely mythical old Scotland were wildly popular with European audiences.
The Setting
Lucia di Lammermoor is originally set in Scotland, which, to artists of the Romantic
era, signified a wild landscape on the fringe of Europe, with a culture burdened
by a French-derived code of chivalry and an ancient tribal system. Civil war and
tribal strife are recurring features of Scottish history, creating a background of
fragmentation reflected in both Lucia’s family situation and her psychological
breakdown. This season’s new production, by Simon Stone, relocates the action
to a declining present-day town in America’s Rust Belt, finding contemporary
resonance in the opera’s themes of abuse, misogyny, and economic decline.
The staging makes extensive use of video to provide close-up views and more
than one perspective.
Visit metopera.org. 41
In Focus CONTINUED
The Music
Donizetti’s operas and those of his Italian contemporaries came to be classified
under the heading of bel canto (from the Italian for “beautiful singing”), a
genre that focused on vocal agility and lyrical beauty to express drama. Today,
the great challenge in performing this music lies in finding the right balance
between elegant but athletic vocalism and dramatic insight. Individual moments
from the score that can be charming on their own (for example, Lucia’s Act I aria,
“Regnava nel silenzio ... Quando rapito in estasi” and the celebrated sextet in
Act II) take on increased dramatic force when heard within the context of the
piece. This is perhaps most apparent in the soprano’s extended mad scene in
Act III. The beauty of the melodic line throughout this long scene, as well as the
graceful agility needed simply to hit the notes, could fool someone who heard
it in concert into believing that this is just an exercise in vocal pyrotechnics. In
its place in the opera, however, with its musical allusions to past events and
with the dramatic interpretation of the soprano, the mad scene is transformed.
Within the context of the drama, it is a shattering depiction of desperation, while
the beauty of the music becomes an ironic commentary on the ugliness of “real”
life. The tomb scene, built around two tremendously difficult arias for the tenor,
is another example of dramatic context augmenting great melody and provides
a cathartic contrast to the disciplined tension of the preceding mad scene.
Met History
Lucia di Lammermoor had its company premiere on October 24, 1883, two days
after the first performance by the brand new Metropolitan Opera Company. The
versatile Marcella Sembrich, who would become a New York favorite during the
Met’s first two and a half decades, tackled the challenging title role. For a long
time, Lucia was the domain of lyric sopranos who dazzled audiences with their
coloratura techniques: French soprano Lily Pons debuted in the role in 1931 and
sang it a record 92 more times until 1958; the colorful Australian Nellie Melba
sang it 31 times between 1893 and 1901 (often dispensing with the final tomb
scene so that the diva’s great mad scene would conclude the opera). Many
different kinds of sopranos have since taken the role, including Maria Callas (seven
performances in 1956 and 1958), Roberta Peters (29 performances between 1956
and 1971), Joan Sutherland (37 performances from her impressive Met debut
in 1961 until 1982), Renata Scotto (20 performances from 1965 to 1973), Beverly
Sills (seven performances in the 1976–77 season), and Ruth Ann Swenson (20
performances from 1989 to 2002). Mary Zimmerman directed a new production
in 2007 with Natalie Dessay as Lucia. In subsequent revivals, both Diana Damrau
and Anna Netrebko took on the title role. This season, Simon Stone makes his
Met debut with a new staging that stars Nadine Sierra, Javier Camarena, Artur
Ruciński, and Matthew Rose, conducted by Riccardo Frizza.
42
Program Note
S
urprising as it may seem, Gaetano Donizetti’s Lucia di Lammermoor is actually
based on a true story that took place in 17th-century Scotland, involving Janet
Dalrymple, the eldest daughter of James Dalrymple, First Viscount of Stair,
and his wife, Margaret. Janet was described as beautiful and gentle, very much
under the control of her mother. Though both parents were socially ambitious, it
was Margaret, “a clever, hard, worldly woman with a witty, unsparing tongue,” who
was ruthless in her determination to advance the family. Janet met and fell in love
with Archibald, Third Lord Rutherford, a suitor who did not please her parents. His
fortune, though adequate, was not large, and his politics, as an ardent supporter of
Charles II, were opposed to those of Viscount Stair, a staunch Whig. Nonetheless,
Janet and Lord Rutherford pledged their love to one another, and Rutherford
broke a gold coin, each wearing half to solemnly call on God to witness their vows.
Janet’s mother, however, decided that her daughter would marry David Dunbar,
the young laird of Baldoon, regardless of the vow that Janet had made to Lord
Rutherford. When Rutherford heard the news, he wrote to Janet, reminding her of
their vows. It was Lady Stair who replied, stating that her daughter realized that she
had made a mistake in agreeing to wed without her parents’ consent and that she
retracted her promise. Lord Rutherford refused to believe that Janet had changed
her mind unless he heard it from her own lips. A meeting between the lovers was
arranged, at which Janet’s mother was present. She answered all of Rutherford’s
arguments while Janet herself remained silent—pale, terror ridden, never raising
her eyes from the ground. Lady Stair ordered her daughter to return her half of the
gold coin to Lord Rutherford, who erupted in a fury, flinging the coin to the ground
and cursing the young woman that he had loved.
The wedding between Janet Dalrymple and David Dunbar took place on
August 24, 1669. The bride showed no opposition to what was happening but
remained unresponsive and deathly pale throughout. After the newlyweds retired,
the celebrations continued until loud, persistent screams were heard coming from
the bridal chamber. When the door was opened, David Dunbar was found stabbed
and heavily bleeding. Janet, covered in gore, was cowering in a corner, repeating
the words, “Take up your bonny bridegroom.” She died on September 12, insane,
without explaining her actions. Dunbar recovered from his wounds, remarried in
1674, and died in 1682, but always refused to talk about what happened between
himself and Janet Dalrymple. It was widely believed that Janet stabbed her groom,
but there were those who believed Lord Rutherford hid in the chamber during
the wedding, then attacked his rival and fled through a window. (Rutherford went
abroad and died in 1685.)
Around this story, Sir Walter Scott created a rich, colorful, engrossing novel,
The Bride of Lammermoor, first published in 1819. The young lovers are renamed
Lucy Ashton and Edgar, Master of Ravenswood, and a bitter feud between the
families is somewhat mitigated when Edgar saves not only Lucy, but her father as
well, from a rampaging bull. Lord Ashton eventually begins to favor a marriage
Visit metopera.org. 47
Program Note CONTINUED
between the two, but his wife is bitterly opposed to it. While Edgar is in France on
business, Lady Ashton intercepts all the letters between the couple and spreads
lies about Edgar’s relationship with a French woman. She eventually bullies Lucy
into marrying Francis, Laird of Bucklaw, but Lucy stabs him in the bridal chamber,
wounding him severely. He survives, but she goes mad and dies. Edgar, who
has returned from France, is blamed for Lucy’s death by her older brother, who
challenges him to a duel. Edgard agrees, but on the way to the duel, he falls into
quicksand and dies.
Given the story’s wildly exotic yet romantic setting in Scotland, the tragedy of a
young woman forced to sacrifice herself and obey her family’s wishes at the expense
of her own true love, and the horrendous events that follow, it was inevitable that
The Bride of Lammermoor would be turned into an opera. Fortunately, it was
the perfect combination of composer Gaetano Donizetti and librettist Salvadore
Cammarano who did so, and in the process created one of the cornerstones of the
Italian Romantic repertoire. Lucia was the first collaboration between the two men,
but they went on to write seven operas together. (Later, Cammarano provided
Verdi with several libretti, including for Luisa Miller and Il Trovatore.) In Lucia, the
librettist did a masterful job of whittling down Scott’s sprawling, episodic novel
to the essential conflict. He heightened the drama by having Lucia actually kill
her husband (renamed Arturo) and having Edgar commit suicide on stage. In the
opera, it is Lucia’s brother, Enrico, who forces her to marry Arturo, an alliance that
will save Enrico from ruin. Throughout the opera, the motivation of the characters
is always clear, and the drama moves quickly, but the libretto still provides space
for expanded musical numbers at crucial moments.
Anna Bolena (1830) had spread Donizetti’s fame beyond Italy, and operas like
L’Elisir d’Amore (1832), Lucrezia Borgia (1833), and Maria Stuarda (1835) had only
confirmed his standing with the public. By the time Donizetti composed Lucia, in
six weeks between May and July of 1835, he was at the height of his powers. The
wealth of melody that he lavished on Lucia is prodigious, but the melodies of
Lucia are never just pretty tunes. Throughout, the music always serves the drama.
The orchestration is powerfully evocative, brilliantly setting the emotional tone of
each scene. The fact that Donizetti wanted Lucia’s mad scene accompanied by
the eerie—and uncommon—glass harmonica shows the importance he gave to
matching the emotional timbre of a scene with the precise colors of individual
instruments. For instance, when Lucia enters for her confrontation with her brother,
the solo oboe immediately conveys her deep sadness as well as her emotional
fragility. And the tempestuous and sinister orchestral introduction that precedes
Enrico’s visit to Edgardo’s home perfectly captures the drama that will ensue. At the
end of the opera, after Edgardo stabs himself, it was a master stroke on Donizetti’s
part to give the melody of Edgardo’s aria to the cello, with the tenor only singing
isolated phrases for the first 15 measures of the second verse, vividly conveying
Edgardo’s weakening condition.
48
Though Lucia’s mad scene is celebrated as a technical tour de force of glittering
cadenzas and dazzling high notes, there is also much more to it, and the reason that
it is so effective in the theater is because it truly conveys the entire kaleidoscope
of Lucia’s constantly shifting emotions. One of its most poignant moments is when
Lucia thinks she is marrying Edgardo. “Oh, day of rapture,” she sings. “At last I
am yours, at last you are mine! A god gave you to me.” The beginning phrase
is sung a cappella, as the simple vocal line falls. The words “At last I am yours”
are set toward the bottom of the soprano range, giving them a soft intimacy that
Donizetti heightens by having them accompanied only by the orchestra’s string
section, plucking out a rhythm. No instruments double her vocal line, which leaves
her utterly exposed vocally, perfectly mirroring Lucia’s emotional state. It is an
extraordinarily poignant moment that can reduce listeners to tears as they, too,
experience the depth of Lucia’s loss.
Three days after the premiere of Lucia, Donizetti wrote to his publisher,
Giovanni Ricordi, “Lucia di Lammermoor has been performed, and kindly permit
me to shame myself and tell you the truth. It has pleased, and pleased very much, if
I can believe in the applause and the compliments I have received. I was called out
many times, and a great many times the singers, too. The king’s brother Leopold,
who was present and applauded, paid me the most flattering compliments.” It
seems that the second performance was even better received than the first: “Every
number was listened to in religious silence and spontaneously hailed with shouts
of ‘Evviva!’”
Indeed, that has been the judgment of the opera audience ever since. Unlike
most other bel canto operas, Lucia never faded from the stage as tastes changed
and new types of operas caught the public’s enthusiasm. In fact, Lucia has found its
way from the opera house into popular culture in rather extraordinary ways. It plays
a part in such literary classics as Flaubert’s Madame Bovary and Tolstoy’s Anna
Karenina. In Howard Hawks’s 1932 film Scarface, Paul Muni whistles the melody of
Lucia’s sextet before and after he murders people. Onscreen references to Lucia
also crop up everywhere from Law & Order to The Three Stooges, Laurel and Hardy
films to Bugs Bunny cartoons. How many other operas have generated such an
extraordinarily wide appeal, across so many cultures, for such a long time?
—Paul Thomason
Paul Thomason, who writes for numerous opera companies and symphony orchestras in
the U.S. and abroad, has contributed to the Met’s program books since 1999.
Visit metopera.org. 49
The Cast and Creative Team
Riccardo Frizza
conductor (brescia , italy)
Simon Stone
director (basel , switzerland)
Lizzie Clachan
set designer (london, england)
Alice Babidge
costume designer (sydney, australia )
Blanca Añón
costume designer (valencia , spain)
Visit metopera.org. 51
The Cast and Creative Team CONTINUED
James Farncombe
lighting designer (london, england)
Luke Halls
projection designer (london, england)
Sara Erde
choreographer (new york , new york )
52
returns next season to choreograph Ivo van Hove’s new production of Don Giovanni.
career productions She trained at New York’s Ballet Hispánico with Tina Ramirez. Recent
credits include choreographer for Manon Lescaut in Baden-Baden, Madama Butterfly and
Ariadne auf Naxos at Berkshire Opera Festival, Carmen at Washington National Opera and
the Seiji Ozawa Music Academy, and Ercole su’l Termodonte at Italy’s Festival dei Due Mondi;
associate director and choreographer for Roméo et Juliette and Madama Butterfly at Atlanta
Opera; associate director for La Forza del Destino and Don Giovanni at Washington National
Opera; and assistant director for Le Nozze di Figaro at the Santa Fe Opera.
Nadine Sierra
soprano (fort lauderdale, florida )
Javier Camarena
tenor (veracruz , mexico)
Visit metopera.org. 53
The Cast and Creative Team CONTINUED
Artur Ruciński
baritone (warsaw, poland)
54