Dharma-Saṅgrahaḥ

The Dharma Collection

text by
Kenjiu Kasawara
edited by
F Max Müller and H Wenzel
1885

translated by
Ānandajoti Bhikkhu
(Ver. 1.1, Feb, 2017)
 2

Table of Contents

Translator’s Preface

Editor’s Preface

Dharmas 1-20

1. Three Treasures

2. Three Vehicles

3. Five Buddhas

4. Four Goddesses

5. Five Protectors

6. Seven Realised Ones

7. Four World Protectors

8. Eight World Protectors

9. Ten World Protectors

10. Fourteen World Protectors

11. Ten Wrathful Ones

12. Eight Bodhisattvas

13. Six Yoginis

14. Seven Supreme Offerings

15. Three Roots of Wholesomeness

16. Four Spiritual States

17. Six Perfections

18. Ten Perfections

19. Four Bases of Sympathy

20. Five Deep Knowledges

 3

Dharmas 21-40

21. Four Noble Truths

22. Five Components

23. Five Super-Mundane Components

24. Twelve Sense Spheres

25. Eighteen Elements

26. Eleven Form Components

27. Three Kinds of Feeling

28. {Two} Perception Components

29. Two Kinds of Conditions

30. Forty Conditions that are associated with Mind

31. Thirteen Conditions that are unassociated with Mind

32. Three Unconditioned Things

33. Six Spheres

34. {Twenty} Form Objects

35. Twenty-Eight Kinds of Sounds

36. Six Kinds of Tastes

37. Four Smells

38. Eleven Tangibles

39. Five Great Elements

40. Five Qualities

 4

Dharmas 41-60

41. Twenty Emptinesses

42. Twelve Factors of Conditional Origination

43. The Thirty-Seven Things on the Side of Awakening

44. Four Ways of Attending to Mindfulness

45. Four Right Strivings

46. Four Bases of Spiritual Power

47. Five Faculties

48. Five Strengths

49. Seven Factors of Awakening

50. Noble Eightfold Path

51. Four Analytical Knowledges

52. Four Retentions

53. Four Reliances

54. Six Recollections

55. Four Dharma Sentences

56. Ten Unwholesome (Things)

57. Six Destinations

58. Six Elements

59. Eight Liberations

60. Five (Things) having Immediate Consequence

 5

Dharmas 61-80

61. Eight Worldly Conditions

62. Nine (Types of) Teachings

63. Twelve Ascetic Virtues

64. Ten Stages of the Bodhisattva

65. Thirteen Stages of the Bodhisattva

66. Five Eyes

67. Six Defilements

68. Five Views

69. Twenty-Four Minor Defilements

70. Five Nutriments

71. Five Fears

72. Four Absorptions

73. Three Liberations

74. Ten Masteries of the Bodhisattvas

75. Ten Strengths of the Bodhisattvas

76. Ten Strengths of a Realised One

77. Four Confidences

78. Five Selfishnesses

79. Eighteen Special Qualities of the Buddha

80. Four Destroyers

 6

Dharmas 81-100

81. Four Factors of Faith

82. Nine Succeeding Attainments of Concentration

83. Thirty-Two Marks of a Great Man

84. Eighty Secondary Characteristics

85. Seven Jewels of Universal Monarchs

86. Three Times

87. Four Aeons

88. Four Ages

89. A Pair of Worlds

90. Four Wombs

91. Five Stains

92. Three Comprehensions

93. Ten Knowledges

94. Five Knowledges

95. Two Truths

96. Sixteen Marks of being receptive to Knowledge

97. Four Aspects in the Truth of Suffering

98. Four States in the Truth of Arising

99. Four States in the Truth of Cessation

100. Four States in the Truth of the Path

 7

Dharmas 101-120

101. Four Concentrations

102. Eight Persons

103. Eighteen Individuals

104. Twelve Ways that the Dharma Wheel is Turned

105. Three Kinds of Gifts

106. Three Kinds of Virtue

107. Manifold Receptivities

108. Three Kinds of Energy

109. Three Kinds of Meditation

110. Three Kinds of Wisdom

111. Manifold Means

112. Three Kinds of Aspirations

113. Three Kinds of Strengths

114. Three Kinds of Knowledge

115. Two Obstructions

116. Two Kinds of Selflessnesses

117. Two Kinds of Requisites

118. Six Obstacles to Concentration

119. Eight Practices for the Abandoning of Conditions

120. Four Continents

 8

Dharmas 121-140

121. Eight Hot Hells

122. Eight Cold Hells

123. Seven Lower Regions

124. Two Mountain Ranges

125. Eight Mountains

126. Seven Oceans

127. Six Gods of the Sensual-Realms

128. Eighteen Gods of the Form-Realms

129. Four Gods of the Formless-Realms

130. Three Kinds of Transgressions

131. Three Kinds of Great Friendliness

132. Three Kinds of Deeds

133. Three Kinds of Miracles

134. Eight Inopportune Births

135. Three Kinds of Discrimination

136. Four Concentrations

137. Fourteen Unanswered Things

138. Three Roots of Wholesomeness

139. Three Roots of Unwholesomeness

140. Three Trainings

 9

Translator’s Preface

The text here is essentially a transliteration of the edition published posthumously

according to Kasawara’s notes by Müller and Wenzel in 1885.

I originally worked with Vaidya’s text published in his Mahāyāna-Sūtra-Saṅgraha of

1961. When I compared that text with Kasawara’s, however, it quickly became evident
that, while claiming to base his text on Kasawara’s edition, Vaidya had Sanskritised the
text, and in virtually every reading Kasawara’s edition is to be preferred as it represents a
more authentic form of the text.

I have not bothered to add variants from Vaidya’s edition as they represent changes made
only on the authority of the editor, and there was no manuscript evidence for the readings
given. I have rarely made changes to the text myself, but where changes seemed necessary
I have recorded these in the notes.

In making the transliteration I have interpreted anusvara (ṁ) with the gaṇa nasal it
represents in the case of ṅ, ñ, ṇ, n and m. I have not changed it though when it occurs
before the sibilants; or at the end of word. So §42:

etc.

becomes:

Dvādaśāṅga-pratītya-samutpādāḥ, avidyā, saṁskārā, vijñānaṁ, nāma-rūpaṁ, etc.

Occasionally Kasawara’s text would print an ellipsis marker, for instance §101:

in this edition the ellipsis has been filled in and placed in curly braces:

Āloka- -{samādhiḥ}, ekādaśa-pratiṣṭha-{samādhiḥ}, ānantarya-

samādhiś-ceti.

Kasawara’s text gave a number followed by the title, and, on the following line, the listed
items, as so:

II. .
.

I believe the number was probably added by the editor and was not part of the original
text. So I have preferred to present the text and translation in the following form:1

1
The numbers in curly braces are my additions for clarification.
 10

2. Three Vehicles

Trīṇi yānāni,
{1} Śrāvaka-yānaṁ,
{2} Pratyeka-Buddha-yānaṁ,
{3} Mahā-yānaṁ ceti.

The text has never been translated before, and, unlike the Arthaviniścaya,2 which I
recently translated, there is no explanation of the factors listed. The items in the lists
given are not always paralleled in other texts, which makes it difficult to check either the
form or the translation. Edgerton’s dictionary,3 though useful at times, sometimes makes
no effort at translation, and just reproduces the list found here.

Because of these factors some of the translations are really quite tentative. I have tried to
indicate this either in the notes, or by adding question marks where the translation is
unsure.

The seven things on the side of Awakening (43-50) are grouped together, and just after
the opening (3-13) there are lists of beings of one sort or another, but apart from that it is
hard to see any organising principle at work anywhere. Because of the lack of any sort of
organisation it must have been easy to both insert new factors, and remove – or lose –
others.

To divide the text up and make it more manageable I have divided it into 7 sections,
having twenty items in each. This division is not part of the original, but is my addition. A
complete rearrangement of the text would in many ways be desirable, but would also
obscure the disarrangement of the original.

The text as it stands was collected or at least finalised sometime after the rise of the
Mahāyāna texts, as, for instance, the three vehicles, including the Mahāyāna,
Bodhisattvas from that tradition, and the five dhyāni Buddhas are listed, and important
Mahāyāna categories like śūnyatā are emphasised. Many of the lists, however, are
common to the early tradition.

The text is attributed to Nāgārjuna at the conclusion, and although this attribution seems
unlikely, the text does seem to have been influenced by Nāgārjuna’s thought, and the
attribution may be taken as indicating the school to which it belongs.

I am very grateful to Mike Cross, who went over the whole translation a number of times
and helped greatly with corrections and suggestions, many of which I have managed to
incorporate here. Any mistakes remaining, of course, are entirely my own fault.

Ānandajoti Bhikkhu
January, 2017

2
See: http://bit.ly/2dRKVeF.
3
Buddhist Hybrid Sanskrit Grammar and Dictionary, Volume II: Dictionary, New Haven, 1953.
 11

Editor’s Preface
(unsigned but written by F Max Müller)

[i] This edition of the text of the Dharma-Saṅgraha,4 with notes and indices,5 will, I hope,
serve as a lasting monument of a most conscientious, laborious, and amiable Buddhist
priest, Kenjiu Kasawara, who arrived in England in 1876, became my pupil in Sanskrit
from 1879-82, and died shortly after his return to his native country, in 1883.

I have given an account of him and his fellow-student, Bunyiu Nanjio, in my

‘Biographical Essays’ (Longmans, 1884), and I shall here quote a few lines only, in order
to enable Sanskrit scholars, who may not have read these Essays, to form some idea of
what this promising young student was.

Kasawara’s life at Oxford was very monotonous. He allowed himself no pleasures of any
kind, and took little exercise. He did not smoke, or drink, or read novels or newspapers. He
worked on day after day, often for weeks seeing no one and talking to no one but to me and
his fellow-worker, Bunyiu Nanjio. He spoke and wrote English correctly, he learnt some
Latin, also a little French, and studied some of the classical English books on history and
philosophy. He might have become a most useful man after his return to Japan, for he was
not only able to appreciate all that was good in European civilisation, but retained a certain
national pride, and would never have become a mere imitator of the West. His manners
were perfect – they were the natural manners of an unselfish man. As to his character, all I
can say is that, though I watched him for a long time, I never found any guile in him, and I
doubt whether, during the last four years, Oxford possessed a purer and nobler soul among
her students than this poor Buddhist priest. Buddhism may indeed be proud of such a man.

During the last year of his stay at Oxford I observed signs of depression in him, though he
never complained. I persuaded him to see a doctor, and the doctor at once declared that my
young friend was in an advanced stage of consumption, and advised him to go home. He
never flinched, and I still hear the quiet tone in which [ii] he said, “Yes, many of my
countrymen die of consumption.” However, he was well enough to travel and to spend some
time in Ceylon, seeing some of the learned Buddhist priests there, and discussing with them
the differences which so widely separate Southern from Northern Buddhism. But after his
return to Japan his illness made rapid strides. He sent me several dear letters, complaining
of nothing but his inability to work. His control over his feelings was remarkable. When he
took leave of me, his sallow face remained as calm as ever, and I could hardly read what
passed within. But I know that after he had left, he paced for a long time up and down the
road, looking again and again at my house, where, as he told me, he had passed the happiest
hours of his life. Yet we had done so little for him. Once only, in his last letter, he
complained of his loneliness in his own country. “To a sick man,” he wrote, “very few
remain as friends.” Soon after writing this he died, and the funeral ceremonies were
performed at Tokio on the 18th of July, 1883.

He has left some manuscripts behind, which I hope I shall be able to prepare for publication,
particularly the “Dharma-Saṅgraha,” a glossary of Buddhist technical terms, ascribed to
Nāgārguna, But it is hard to think of the years of work which are to bear no fruit; still
harder to feel how much good that one good and enlightened Buddhist priest might have
done among the thirty-two millions of Buddhists in Japan. Have, pia anima! I well
remember how last year we watched together a glorious sunset from the Malvern Hills, and

4
In this transcription I have converted the old and now unused transliteration schema to unicode.
5
I have omitted the variant readings, the notes and the indices in this edition.
 12

how, when the Western sky was, like a golden curtain, covering we knew not what, he said
to me, “That is what we call the Eastern gate of our Sukhāvatī, the Land of Bliss.” He
looked forward to it, and he trusted he should meet there all who had loved him, and whom
he had loved, and that he should gaze on the Buddha Amitābha, i. e. Infinite Light.

It has taken more time than I expected to prepare the text and notes of the Dharma-
Saṅgraha, as left by Kasawara, for Press, and I have gratefully to acknowledge the
assistance which I received from Dr. H. Wenzel in this sometimes very troublesome work.
While preparing my lectures for my Japanese pupils, I had myself to study that peculiar
kind of Sanskrit which their sacred books are written, and in collecting new materials,
chiefly from MSS., I came across the MS. of the Dharma-Saṅgraha at the India Office. As
it contained long lists of technical [iii] terms, which form one of the greatest difficulties
to the students of Buddhism, I copied nearly the whole of it, and made frequent use of it
in my lectures.

After a time Kenjiu Kasawara expressed a wish to copy the text for himself, and I then
encouraged him to prepare a critical edition of it. Though a critical edition was, perhaps,
hardly called for in the case of a text like the Dharma-Saṅgraha, Kasawara copied the
MS. of the India Office very carefully, and afterwards collated it with a MS. and with a
fragment of another MS. at Cambridge. The MS. of the India Office, No. 2932, one of
those presented by Mr. B. H. Hodgson, is most carelessly written, and in some parts quite
illegible. The MSS. at Cambridge are better, but of little assistance in really difficult
passages. If I say that a critical edition was, perhaps, hardly called for, I do not mean to
undervalue the collation which we owe to Mr. Kasawara; all I mean is that in most cases
we found that the correctness or incorrectness of the technical terms had to be settled by
independent evidence rather than by the various readings of our MSS.

The collation having once been made, it was thought best to print it. Though neither I nor
Dr. Wenzel can be responsible for its accuracy, I may say that whenever I was led to test
it by reference to the India Office MS., which was lent to me through the kindness of Dr.
Rost, the learned librarian of the India Office, I found Kasawara quite as dependable as
most European editors. The collation becomes important whenever a question arises as to
certain words or classes of words being included or excluded from our text. Thus our text
knows of nine Aṅgas only, like the Hīnayāna, not of twelve, like the Mahāyāna. The four
Devīs, the five Rakshās, the ten Krodhas, and the six Yoginis are unsupported by the
Cambridge MS. and by the Chinese Version. Here the comparative list of the chapters
contained in the Sanskrit MSS., and in the Chinese Version, will prove very instructive.

Mere blunders, which could be of no interest, have mostly been corrected without special
remarks. Thus, though all the MSS. in sect. VII read catur-loka-pālāḥ, we have printed
catvāro loka-pālāḥ, not because catur-loka-pālāḥ is impossible (it might be, the guardians
of the four worlds), but because it is against the character of the Dharma-Saṅgraha, where
the principal object throughout is to give the number of terms [iv] in each paragraph.
Where a passage was completely unintelligible to us, we have said so in the Notes.

While reading this and other Sanskrit texts with me, Kasawara had prepared a large
number of notes, consisting chiefly of references to books which he had been studying at
Oxford. Dr. Wenzel has had the kindness to revise and arrange these notes, and he has
himself added new references to the works of Köppen, Kern, Cunningham, Oldenberg,
Wassiljew, and to Tibetan authorities. He wishes, however, to have it clearly understood
 13

that he is not responsible for the accuracy of quotations from the Mahāvyutpatti, the
Abhidharmakośa, and other works, chiefly Chinese, which Kasawara had made from
MSS., not accessible to Dr. Wenzel.

The order of the quotations is generally the following. The Pāli words are given
immediately after the Sanskrit words. Then follow: 1) The Buddhist Sanskrit works and
their Tibetan translations; (2) the Pāli sources, i. e. Childers and whatever has appeared
after him; and, finally, (3) the European authors who have discussed the subject. Of these
last the principal works only have been cited, and only their more important passages.
Sometimes, at the end, some other Sanskrit works have been added which may happen to
mention the same subject. The translations have mostly been given after Childers, but
with constant regard to later authorities.

As to the arrangement of the Dharma-Saṅgraha itself, no certain plan is discernible in the

disposition of its matter. Sometimes kindred subjects follow each other, but they are also
scattered here and there through the whole work. So, for instance, we find the
cosmological terms enumerated in sections 3-13, 86-91, 120-129; other groups are the
Bodhipakṣika-dharmas (sects. 43-50), the four divisions of each of the four Noble Truths
(sects. 97-100), the three classes of each of the ten Pāramitās (sects. 105-114); the divisions
of Śabda, Rasa, Gandha, Sparṣa (sects. 35-38), etc.

Most of the Dharmāloka-mukhas of the fourth chapter of the Lalitavistara are found in
our collection, viz.: Sect. 15, cp. Dharmāloka-mukhas 83 and 84; 16, cp. 14-17; 17, cp. 87-
92; 19, cp. 94; 21, cp. 48-51; 44-50, cp. 52-82; 54, cp. 8-13; 55, cp. 18-21; 64, cp. 108 and
109; 107, cp. 51, 105, and 106; 117, cp. 97-100.
 14

Dharma-Saṅgrahaḥ
The Dharma Collection
[1]
Namo Ratna-Trayāya
Homage to the Three Treasures

Ratna-Trayaṁ namas-
Having paid homage to the Three Treasures,

sarva-sattva-hitodayaṁ,
which increase the welfare of all beings,

kathyate mohanāśāya
for the end of delusion I relate

Dharma-sāra-samuccayaḥ.
a collection of the main Dharma points.

Dharmas 1-20
1. Three Treasures

Tatra prathamaṁ tāvat-Trīṇi Ratnāni, tad-yathā:

Herein, at the beginning, there are Three Treasures, they are:

{1} Buddho,
{1} The Buddha,

{2} Dharmaḥ,
{2} the Dharma,

{3} Saṅghaś-ceti.
{3} and the Saṅgha.

2. Three Vehicles

Trīṇi yānāni,
There are three vehicles,

{1} Śrāvaka-yānaṁ,
{1} the Disciples’ vehicle,

{2} Pratyeka-Buddha-yānaṁ,
{2} the Independent Buddhas’ vehicle,

{3} Mahā-yānaṁ ceti.

{3} and the Great vehicle.
 The Dharma Collection – 15

3. Five Buddhas

Pañca Buddhāḥ, tad-yathā:

There are five (dhyāni) Buddhas, they are:

{1} Vairocano
{1} Vairocana (Shining Buddha),

{2} ’kṣobhyaḥ,
{2} Akṣobhya (Immovable Buddha),

{3} Ratna-sambhavo,
{3} Ratna-sambhava (Jewel-Born Buddha),

{4} ’mitābho,
{4} Amitābha (Endless-Light Buddha),

{5} ’mogha-siddhiś-ceti. [2]

{5} Amogha-siddhi (Unfailing Buddha).

4. Four Goddesses

Catasro devyaḥ,6 tad-yathā:

There are four goddesses, they are:

{1} Rocanī,
{1} Rocanī (Yellow goddess),

{2} Māmakī,
{2} Māmakī (Devoted goddess),

{3} Pāṇḍurā,
{3} Pāṇḍurā (White goddess),

{4} Tārā ceti.

{4} and Tārā (Shining goddess).

5. Five Protectors

Pañca rakṣāḥ,7 tad-yathā:

There are five protectors, they are:

{1} Pratisarā,
{1} Assailer,

6
Omitted in the Cambridge manuscript.
7
Omitted in the Cambridge manuscript.
 The Dharma Collection – 16

{2} Sāhasra-pramardanī,
{2} Thousands-crusher,

{3} Mārīcī,
{3} Moonlight,

{4} Mantrānusāriṇī,
{4} Mantra-follower,

{5} Śītavanī ceti.

{5} and Cool Wood.

6. Seven Realised Ones

Sapta Tathāgatāḥ, tad-yathā:

There are seven Realised Ones, they are:

{1} Vipaśyī,
{1} Vipaśyī (Buddha),

{2} Śikhī,
{2} Śikhī (Buddha),

{3} Viśvabhūḥ,
{3} Viśvabhū (Buddha),

{4} Krakucchandaḥ,
{4} Krakucchanda (Buddha),

{5} Kanaka-muniḥ,
{5} Kanaka-muni (Buddha),

{6} Kāśyapaḥ,
{6} Kāśyapa (Buddha),

{7} Śākya-muniś-ceti.
{7} and Śākya-muni (Buddha).

7. Four World Protectors

Catvāro loka-pālāḥ, tad-yathā:

There are four world protectors, they are:

{1}
{1}

{2} Virūpākṣo,
{2} Virūpākṣa,
 The Dharma Collection – 17

{3} Virūḍhakaḥ,
{3} Virūḍhaka,

{4} Kuberaś-ceti.
{4} and Kubera.

8. Eight World Protectors

Aṣṭau loka-pālāḥ, tad-yathā:

There are eight world protectors, they are:

{1} Indro,
{1} Indra,

{2} Yamo,
{2} Yama,

{3} Varuṇaḥ,
{3} Varuṇa,

{4} Kubera,
{4} Kubera,

{5} Īśāno,
{5} Īśāna,

{6} ’gnir-
{6} Agni,

{7}
{7}

{8} Vāyur-iti.
{8} Vāyu.

9. Ten World Protectors

Daśa loka-pālāḥ,
There are ten world protectors, they are:

{1-8} Aṣṭa-loka-pālādhikam-ūrdhvaṁ
{1-8} Beginning with the eight world protectors and then

{9} Brahmādhaḥ
{9} Brahmā and

{10}
{10}
 The Dharma Collection – 18

10. Fourteen World Protectors

Catur-daśa loka-pālāḥ, tad-yathā:

There are fourteen world protectors, they are:

{1-10} Daśa-loka-pāla-sakalaṁ,
{1-10} Consisting of the ten world protectors,

{11} Candraḥ,
{11} Candra,

{12} Sūryaḥ,
{12} Sūrya,

{13} -
{13}

{14} Asuraḥ. [3]

{14} Asura.

11. Ten Wrathful Ones

Daśa krodhāḥ,8 tad-yathā:

There are ten wrathful ones, they are:

{1} Yamāntakaḥ,
{1} Yamāntaka,

{2} Prajñāntakaḥ,
{2} Prajñāntaka,

{3} Padmāntako,
{3} Padmāntaka,

{4} Vighnāntako-
{4} Vighnāntaka,

{5} ’caraṭarki-rājo,
{5} Acaraṭarki-rāja,

{6} Nīla-daṇḍo,
{6} Nīla-daṇḍa,

{7} Mahā-bala,
{7} Mahā-bala,

8
Omitted in the Cambridge manuscript.
 The Dharma Collection – 19

{8} Uṣṇīṣaś-
{8} Uṣṇīṣa,

{9} Cakra-vartī,
{9} Cakra-vartī,

{10} Sambha-rājaś-ceti.
{10} and Sambha-rāja.

12. Eight Bodhisattvas

Aṣṭau Bodhisattvāḥ, tad-yathā:

There are eight Bodhisattvas, they are:

{1} Maitreyo,
{1} Maitreya,

{2} Gagana-gañjaḥ,
{2} Gagana-gañja,

{3} Samanta-bhadro,
{3} Samanta-bhadra,

{4} Vajra-pāṇir-
{4} Vajra- pāṇī,

{5} Mañjuśrīḥ,
{5} Mañjuśrī,

{6} Sarva-nivaraṇa-viṣkambhī,
{6} Sarva-nivaraṇa-viṣkambhī,

{7} Kṣiti-garbhaḥ,
{7} Kṣiti-garbha,

{8} Khagarbhaś-ceti.
{8} and Khagarbha.

13. Six Yoginis

Ṣaḍ-yoginyaḥ,9 tad-yathā:
There are six yoginis, they are:

{1} Vajrā-10
{1} Vajrā,

9
Omitted in the Cambridge manuscript.
10
Text prints: Vajra.
 The Dharma Collection – 20

{2} Vārāhī,
{2} Vārāhī,

{3} Yāminī,
{3} Yāminī,

{4} Sañcāraṇī,
{4} Sañcāraṇī,

{5} Santrāsanī,
{5} Santrāsanī,

{6} Cāṇḍikā ceti.

{6} and Cāṇḍikā.

14. Seven Supreme Offerings

Sapta-vidhānuttara-pūjā, tad-yathā:
There are seven supreme offerings, they are:

{1} Vandanā,
{1} Worshipping,

{2} pūjanā,
{2} honouring,

{3} pāpa-deśanā-
{3} confessing faults,

{4} ’numodanā-
{4} rejoicing,

{5} ’dhyeṣaṇā,
{5} requesting instruction,

{6} Bodhicittotpādaḥ,
{6} the generating of a mind set on Awakening,

{7} pariṇāmanā ceti. [4]

{7} developing (that mind).

15. Three Roots of Wholesomeness

Trīṇi kuśala-mūlāni,
There are three roots of wholesomeness, they are:

{1} Bodhicittotpāda,
{1} The generating of a mind set on Awakening,
 The Dharma Collection – 21

{2} āśaya-viśuddhir-
{2} purification of the heart,

{3} ahaṁ-kāra-mama-kāra-parityāgaś-ceti.
{3} and the abandoning of the I-maker, the me-maker.

16. Four Spiritual States

Catvāro brahma-vihārāḥ,
There are four spiritual states, they are:

{1} Maitrī,
{1} Friendliness,

{2} karuṇā,
{2} kindness,

{3-4} muditopekṣā ceti.

{3-4} gladness, and equanimity.

17. Six Perfections

Ṣaṭ pāramitāḥ,
There are six perfections, they are:

{1} dāna-pāramitā,
{1} the perfection of generosity,

{2} śīla-pāramitā,
{2} the perfection of virtue,

{3} kṣānti-pāramitā,
{3} the perfection of patience,

{4} vīrya-pāramitā,
{4} the perfection of energy,

{5} dhyāna-pāramitā,
{5} the perfection of meditation,

{6} prajñā-pāramitā ceti.

{6} the perfection of wisdom.
 The Dharma Collection – 22

18. Ten Perfections

Daśa pāramitāḥ,
There are ten perfections, they are:

{1-6} Ṣaṭpāramitā-sakalam-
{1-6} Consisting of the six perfections, and

{7} upāyaṁ,
{7} skilful means,

{8} praṇidhir-
{8} aspiration,

{9} balaṁ,
{9} strength,

{10} jñānaṁ ceti.

{10} and knowledge.

19. Four Bases of Sympathy

Catvāri saṅgraha-vastūnī,
There are four bases of sympathy, they are:

{1} dānaṁ,
{1} generosity,

{2} priya-vacanam-
{2} kindly speech,

{3} artha-caryā,
{3} usefulness,

{4} samānārthatā ceti.

{4} and similarity of purpose.

20. Five Deep Knowledges

Pañcābhijñāḥ,
There are five deep knowledges,

{1} divya-cakṣur-
{1} the divine eye,

{2} divya-śrotraṁ,
{2} the divine ear,
 The Dharma Collection – 23

{3} para-citta-jñānaṁ,
{3} knowledge of others’ minds,

{4} pūrva- -
{4} recollection of previous lives,

{5} -ceti. [5]

{5} and spiritual power.
 The Dharma Collection – 24

Dharmas 21-40
21. Four Noble Truths

Catvāry-ārya-satyāni, tad-yathā:
There are four noble truths, they are:

{1} Duḥkhaṁ,
{1} Suffering,

{2} samudayo,
{2} arising,

{3} nirodho,
{3} cessation,

{4} mārgaś-ceti.
{4} and path.

22. Five Components

Pañca skandhāḥ,
There are five components,

{1} rūpaṁ,
{1} bodily-form,

{2} vedanā,
{2} feelings,

{3} saṁjñā,
{3} perceptions,

{4} saṁskārā,
{4} volitions,

{5} vijñānaṁ ceti.

{5} and consciousness.

23. Five Super-Mundane Components

Lokottara-pañca-skandhāḥ,
There are five super-mundane components,

{1} śīla-
{1} virtue,
 The Dharma Collection – 25

{2} samādhi-
{2} concentration,

{3} prajñā-
{3} wisdom,

{4} vimukti-
{4} freedom,

{5} vimukti-jñāna-darśana-skandhā iti.

{5} the components of knowledge and insight into freedom.

24. Twelve Sense Spheres

Dvādaśāyatanāni,
There are twelve sense spheres,

{1} cakṣuḥ-
{1} eye,

{2} śrotra-
{2} ear,

{3} ghrāṇa-
{3} nose,

{4} jihvā-
{4} tongue,

{5} kāya-
{5} body,

{6} mana-āyatanāni;
{6} mind sense spheres;

{7} rūpa-
{7} form,

{8} gandha-
{8} smell,11

{9} śabda-
{9} sound,

{10} rasa-
{10} taste,

11
The order is unexpected here, normally we would expect sounds to precede smells.
 The Dharma Collection – 26

{11} sparśa-
{11} tangible,

{12} dharmāyatanāni ceti.

{12} and thought sense spheres.

25. Eighteen Elements

Aṣṭādaśa dhātavaḥ,
There are eighteen elements,

{1} cakṣuḥ-
{1} eye,

{2} śrotra-
{2} ear,

{3} ghrāṇa-
{3} nose,

{4} jihvā-
{4} tongue,

{5} kāya-
{5} body,

{6} mano-
{6} mind,

{7} rūpa-
{7} form,

{8} gandha-
{8} smell,

{9} śabda-
{9} sound,

{10} rasa-
{10} taste,

{11} sparśa-
{11} tangible,

{12} dharma-dhātavaś-;
{12} and thought elements;
 The Dharma Collection – 27

{13} cakṣur-vijñāna-
{13} eye-consciousness,

{14} śrotra-vijñāna-
{14} ear-consciousness,

{15} ghrāṇa-vijñāna-
{15} nose-consciousness,

{16} jihvā-vijñāna-
{16} tongue-consciousness,

{17} kāya-vijñāna-
{17} body-consciousness,

{18} mano-vijñānadhātavaś-ceti. [6]

{18} and mind-consciousness elements.

26. Eleven Form Components

Tatraikādaśa rūpa-skandhāḥ,
Herein, there are eleven form components,

{1} cakṣuḥ,
{1} eye,

{2} śrotraṁ,
{2} ear,

{3} ghrāṇaṁ,
{3} nose,

{4} jihvā,
{4} tongue,

{5} kāyo,
{5} body,

{6} rūpaṁ,
{6} form,

{7} śabdo,
{7} sound,

{8} gandho,
{8} smell,
 The Dharma Collection – 28

{9} rasaḥ,
{9} taste,

{10} sparśo,
{10} tangible,

{11} vijñaptiś-ceti.
{11} and intimation.

27. Three Kinds of Feeling

Vedanā tri-vidhā,
There are three kinds of feeling,

{1} sukhā,
{1} pleasant,

{2} duḥkhā-
{2} unpleasant,

{3} ’duḥkhāsukhā ceti.

{3} and neither unpleasant-nor-pleasant.

28. {Two} Perception Components

{Dve} saṁjñā-skandhaḥ,
There are {two} perception components,

{1-2} nimittodgrahaṇātmakā.
{1-2} having the nature of signs and descriptions. ??

29. Two Kinds of Conditions

Saṁskārā dvi-vidhāḥ, tatra,

There are two kinds of conditions, herein,

{1} citta-samprayukta-saṁskārāḥ,
{1} conditions that are associated with mind,

{2} citta-viprayukta-saṁskārāś-ceti.
{2} and conditions that are unassociated with mind.

30. Forty Conditions that are associated with Mind

Citta-samprayukta-saṁskārāś-catvāriṁśat, tad-yathā:
There are forty conditions that are associated with mind, they are:

{1} Vedanā,
{1} Feelings,
 The Dharma Collection – 29

{2} saṁjñā,
{2} perceptions,

{3} cetanā,
{3} intentions,

{4} chandaḥ,
{4} desire,

{5} sparśo,
{5} contact,

{6} matiḥ,
{6} design,

{7} -
{7} mindfulness,

{8} manaskāro
{8} application of mind,

{9} ’dhimokṣaḥ,
{9} determination,

{10} samādhiḥ,
{10} concentration,

{11} śraddhā-
{11} faith,

{12} ’pramādaḥ,
{12} heedfulness,

{13} prasrabdhir-
{13} tranquillity,

{14} upekṣā,
{14} equanimity,

{15} hrīr-
{15} shame,

{16} apatrapā-
{16} conscience,

{17} ’lobho
{17} non-greed,
 The Dharma Collection – 30

{18} ’dveṣo,
{18} non-hatred,

{19} ahiṁsā,
{19} non-violence,

{20} vīryaṁ,
{20} energy,

{21} mohaḥ,
{21} delusion,

{22} pramādaḥ,
{22} heedlessness,

{23} kausīdyam-
{23} indolence,

{24} aśrāddhyaṁ,
{24} faithlessness,

{25} styānam-
{25} sloth,

{26} auddhatyam-
{26} agitation,

{27} ahrīkatā-
{27} shamelessness,

{28} ’napatrapā,
{28} lack of conscience,

{29} krodha,
{29} anger,

{30} upanāhaḥ,
{30} enmity,

{31} śāṭhyam-
{31} deceit,

{32} īrṣyā,
{32} jealousy,

{33} pradāno,
{33} goading,
 The Dharma Collection – 31

{34} mrakṣo,
{34} ill-will,

{35} mātsaryaṁ,
{35} selfishness,

{36} māyā,
{36} deception,

{37} mado,
{37} intoxication,

{38} vihiṁsā,
{38} violence,

{39} vitarko,
{39} thinking,

{40} vicāraś-ceti. [7]

{40} and reflection.

31. Thirteen Conditions that are unassociated with Mind

Tatra citta-viprayukta-saṁskārās-trayodaśa,
Herein, there are thirteen conditions that are unassociated with mind,

{1} prāptir-
{1} occurrence, ??

{2} aprāptiḥ,
{2} non-occurrence, ??

{3} sabhāgatā-
{3} participation, ??

{4} ’saṁjñikaṁ,
{4} unconsciousness,

{5} samāptir-
{5} attainment,

{6} jīvitaṁ,
{6} life,

{7} jātir-
{7} birth,
 The Dharma Collection – 32

{8} jarā,
{8} old age,

{9} sthitir-
{9} stability,

{10} anityatā,
{10} impermanence,

{11} nāmakāyo,
{11} a group of words,

{12} padakāyaḥ,
{12} a group of sentences,

{13} vyañjanakāyaś-ceti.
{13} and a group of syllables.

32. Three Unconditioned Things

Trīṇy- i, tad-yathā:
There are three unconditioned things, they are:

{1} Ākāśaḥ,
{1} Space,

{2} pratisaṅkhyā-nirodho
{2} observed cessation,

{3} ’pratisaṅkhyā-nirodhaś-ceti.
{3} and unobserved cessation.

33. Six Spheres

Ṣaḍ viṣayāḥ, tad-yathā:

There are six spheres, they are:

{1} Rūpaṁ,
{1} Form,

{2} śabdo,
{2} sound,

{3} gandho,
{3} smell,

{4} rasaḥ,
{4} taste,
 The Dharma Collection – 33

{5} sparśo,
{5} tangible,

{6} dharmaś-ceti.
{6} and thought.

34. {Twenty} Form Objects

Tatra, {viṁśati} rūpaṁ viṣaya-svabhāvaṁ,

Herein, there are {twenty} form objects,

{1} nīlaṁ,
{1} black,

{2} pītaṁ,
{2} yellow,

{3} lohitam-
{3} red,

{4} avadātaṁ,
{4} white,

{5} haritaṁ,
{5} green,

{6} dīrghaṁ,
{6} long,

{7} hrasvaṁ,
{7} short,

{8} parimaṇḍalam-
{8} circular,

{9} unnatam-
{9} bent up,

{10} avanataṁ,
{10} bent down,

{11} sātaṁ,
{11} pleasant,

{12} visātam-
{12} unpleasant,
 The Dharma Collection – 34

{13} acchaṁ,
{13} clear,

{14} dhūmo,
{14} clouded,

{15} rajo,
{15} dusty,

{16} mahikā,
{16} frosty,

{17} chāyā-
{17} shadowy,

{18} ’tapa,
{18} sunny,

{19} āloko
{19} light,

{20} ’ndhakāraś-ceti.
{20} and dark.

35. Twenty-Eight Kinds of Sounds

Aṣṭāviṁśati-vidhaḥ śabdaḥ,
There are twenty-eight kinds of sounds,

{1-7} sapta puruṣa-vāk-śabdāḥ,

{1-7} there are seven human sounds made with the voice,

{8-14} sapta puruṣa-hastādi-śabdāḥ,

{8-14} seven human sounds made with the hands and so on,

{15-28} eta evaṁ manojña-bhedenāṣṭāviṁśatiḥ. [8]

{15-28} these are divided into agreeable and disagreeable, making twenty-eight.

36. Six Kinds of Tastes

Rasaḥ ṣaḍ-vidhaḥ, tad-yathā:

There are six kinds of tastes, they are:

{1} Madhuro
{1} Sweet,

{2} ’mlo,
{2} sour,
 The Dharma Collection – 35

{3} lavaṇaḥ,
{3} salty,

{4} kaṭus-
{4} acidic,

{5} tiktaḥ,
{5} bitter,

{6} kaṣāyaś-ceti.
{6} and astringent.

37. Four Smells

Catvāro gandhāḥ, tad-yathā:

There are four smells, they are:

{1} Sugandho,
{1} Pleasant smell,

{2} durgandhaḥ,
{2} unpleasant smell,

{3} sama-gandho,
{3} neutral smell,

{4} viṣama-gandhaś-ceti.
{4} and mixed smell.

38. Eleven Tangibles

Ekādaśa spraṣṭavyāni,
There are eleven tangibles,

{1} -
{1} solid,

{2} āpas-
{2} fluid,

{3} tejo,
{3} fiery,

{4} vāyuḥ,
{4} windy,

{5} ślakṣṇatvaṁ,
{5} smooth,
 The Dharma Collection – 36

{6} karkaśatvaṁ,
{6} rough,

{7} laghutvaṁ,
{7} light,

{8} gurutvaṁ,
{8} heavy,

{9} śītaṁ,
{9} cool,

{10} jighatsā,
{10} hunger,

{11} pipāsā ceti.

{11} and thirst.

39. Five Great Elements

Pañca mahā-bhūtāni,
There are five great elements,

{1} -
{1} earth,

{2} āpas-
{2} water,

{3} tejo
{3} fire,

{4} vāyur-
{4} wind,

{5} ākāśa-ceti.
{5} and space.

40. Five Qualities

Pañca bhautikāni,
There are five qualities,

{1} rūpaṁ,
{1} form,

{2} śabdo,
{2} sound,
 The Dharma Collection – 37

{3} gandho,
{3} smell,

{4} rasaḥ,
{4} taste,

{5} sparśaś-ceti.
{5} and tangible.

Dharmas 41-60
41. Twenty Emptinesses

Viṁśatiḥ śūnyatāḥ, tad-yathā:

There are twenty emptinesses, they are:

{1} Adhyātma-śūnyatā,
{1} Internal emptiness,

{2} bahirdhā-śūnyatā-
{2} external emptiness,

{3} ’dhyātma-bahirdhā-śūnyatā,
{3} internal and external emptiness,

{4} śūnyatā-śūnyatā,
{4} emptiness of emptiness,

{5} mahā-śūnyatā,
{5} great emptiness,

{6} paramārtha-śūnyatā,
{6} ultimate emptiness,

{7} -śūnyatā-
{7} emptiness of the conditioned,

{8} -śūnyatā- [9]

{8} emptiness of the unconditioned,

{9} ’tyanta-śūnyatā-
{9} endless emptiness,

{10} ’navarāgra-śūnyatā-
{10} emptiness of the extremes,

{11} ’navakāra-śūnyatā,
{11} emptiness without beginning or end,
 The Dharma Collection – 38

{12} -śūnyatā,
{12} natural emptiness,

{13} sarva-dharma-śūnyatā,
{13} emptiness of all things,

{14} lakṣaṇa-śūnyatā-
{14} marked emptiness,

{15} ’lakṣaṇa-śūnyatā,
{15} unmarked emptiness,

{16} bhāva-śūnyatā-
{16} emptiness of existence,

{17} ’bhāva-śūnyatā,
{17} emptiness of non-existence,

{18} svabhāva-śūnyatā-
{18} emptiness of self-existence,

{19} bhāva-svabhāva-śūnyatā,
{19} emptiness of the self-existence of existence,

{20} parabhāva-śūnyatā ceti.

{20} and emptiness of other-existence.

42. Twelve Factors of Conditional Origination

Dvādaśāṅga-pratītya-samutpādāḥ,
There are twelve factors of conditional origination,

{1} avidyā,
{1} ignorance,

{2} saṁskārā,
{2} volitions,

{3} vijñānaṁ,
{3} consciousness,

{4} nāma-rūpaṁ,
{4} name and bodily-form,

{5} ṣaḍ-āyatanaṁ,
{5} the six sense spheres,
 The Dharma Collection – 39

{6} sparśo,
{6} contact,

{7} vedanā,
{7} feeling,

{8-9}
{8-9} craving, attachment,

{10} bhavo,
{10} continuity,

{11} jātir-
{11} birth,

{12} jarā-maraṇaṁ, śoka-parideva-duḥkha-daurmanasyopāyāsāś-ceti.

{12} and old age and death, grief, lamentation, pain, sorrows, and despairs.

43. The Thirty-Seven Things on the Side of Awakening

Sapta-triṁśad-bodhi-pākṣikā dharmāḥ,
There are thirty-seven things on the side of awakening,

{1-4} -upasthānāni,
{1-4} four ways of attending to mindfulness,

{5-8} catvāri samyak-prahāṇāni,

{5-8} four right strivings,

{9-12} -pādāḥ,
{9-12} four bases of spiritual power,

{13-17} pañcendriyāṇi,
{13-17} five faculties,

{18-22} pañca balāni,

{18-22} five strengths,

{23-29} sapta bodhyaṅgāni,

{23-29} seven factors of awakening,

{30-37} āryāṣṭāṅgika-mārgaś-ceti.
{30-37} and the noble eightfold path.
 The Dharma Collection – 40

44. Four Ways of Attending to Mindfulness

-upasthānāni? Tad-yathā:
Herein, what are the {four} ways of attending to mindfulness?12 They are:

{1} Kāye kāyānudarśa- -upasthānaṁ,

{1} Attending to (the nature of) the body in the body,

{2} vedanāyāṁ vedanānudarśa- -upasthānaṁ,

{2} attending to (the nature of) the feelings in the feelings,

{3} citte cittānudarśa- -upasthānaṁ,

{3} attending to (the nature of) the mind in the mind,

{4} dharme dharmānudarśa- -upasthānaṁ. [10]

{4} attending to (the nature of) things in (various) things.

45. Four Right Strivings

Katamāni catvāri samyak-prahāṇāni? Tad-yathā:

What are the four right strivings? They are:

{1} Utpannānāṁ kuśala-mūlānāṁ saṁrakṣaṇaṁ,

{1} The protection of the wholesome roots that have arisen,

{2} anutpannānāṁ samutpādaḥ,

{2} and the arising (of wholesome roots) that have not (yet) arisen,

{3} utpannānām-akuśalānāṁ dharmāṇāṁ prahāṇam,

{3} the abandoning of unwholesome things that have arisen,

{4} anutpannānāṁ punar-anutpādaś-ceti.

{4} and the non-arising (of unwholesome things) that have not arisen yet.

46. Four Bases of Spiritual Power

-pādāḥ, tad-yathā:
There are four bases of spiritual power, they are:

{1} Chanda-samādhi-prahāṇāya saṁskāra- -pādaḥ,

{1} The basis of spiritual power that is concentration of desire accompanied by the
volition of striving,

{2} evaṁ, citta- -pādaḥ,

{2} similarly, the basis of spiritual power regarding thought,

12
Asking a question here and in the next analysis breaks the pattern of simply stating the factors
in the list.
 The Dharma Collection – 41

{3} vīrya- -pādaḥ,

{3} the basis of spiritual power regarding energy,

{4} mīmāṁsā-samādhi-prahāṇāya saṁskāra-samanvāgata- -pādaś-ceti.

{4} and the basis of spiritual power that is concentration of investigation accompanied
by the volition of striving.

47. Five Faculties

Pañcendriyāṇi, tad-yathā:
There are five faculties, they are:

{1} Śraddhā-
{1} Faith,

{2} samādhi-
{2} concentration,13

{3} vīrya-
{3} energy,

{4} -
{4} mindfulness,

{5} prajñendriyaṁ ceti.

{5} and the faculty of wisdom.

48. Five Strengths

Pañca balāni,
There are five strengths, they are:

{1} Śraddhā-
{1} Faith,

{2} vīrya-
{2} energy,

{3} -
{3} mindfulness,

{4} samādhi-
{4} concentration,

{5} prajñābalaṁ ceti.

{5} and the strength of wisdom.

13
The order is unexpected here, see the strengths below, which follows the normal order.
 The Dharma Collection – 42

49. Seven Factors of Awakening

Sapta bodhyaṅgāni, tad-yathā:

There are seven factors of awakening, they are:

{1} Sm -sambodhyaṅgaṁ,
{1} The factor of awakening that is mindfulness,

{2} dharma-pravicaya-sambodhyaṅgaṁ,
{2} the factor of awakening that is investigation of the (nature of) things,

{3} vīrya-sambodhyaṅgaṁ,
{3} the factor of awakening that is energy,

{4} prīti-sambodhyaṅgaṁ,
{4} the factor of awakening that is joy,

{5} praśrabdhi-sambodhyaṅgaṁ,
{5} the factor of awakening that is tranquillity,

{6} samādhi-sambodhyaṅgam-
{6} the factor of awakening that is concentration,

{7} upekṣā-sambodhyaṅgam-iti. [11]

{7} the factor of awakening that is equanimity.

50. Noble Eightfold Path

Āryāṣṭāṅgika-mārgaḥ,
There is the noble eightfold path,

{1} Samyag-
{1} Right view,

{2} samyak-saṅkalpaḥ,
{2} right thought,

{3} samyag-vāk,
{3} right speech,

{4} samyak-karmāntaḥ,
{4} right action,

{5} samyag-ājīvaḥ,
{5} right livelihood,

{6} samyag-vyāyāmaḥ,
{6} right endeavour,
 The Dharma Collection – 43

{7} samyak-
{7} right mindfulness,

{8} samyak-samādhiś-ceti.
{8} and right concentration.

Ete sapta-triṁśad-bodhi-pākṣikā dharmāḥ.

These are the thirty-seven things on the side of awakening.

51. Four Analytical Knowledges

Catasraḥ pratisaṁvidaḥ, tad-yathā:

There are four analytical knowledges, they are:

{1} Dharma-pratisaṁvid-
{1} The analytical knowledge of the way things are,

{2} artha-pratisaṁvin-
{2} the analytical knowledge of meaning,14

{3} nirukti-pratisaṁvit-
{3} the analytical knowledge of language,

{4} pratibhāna-pratisaṁvic-ceti.
{4} the analytical knowledge of inspired speech.

52. Four Retentions

Catasro dhāraṇyaḥ, tad-yathā:

There are four retentions, they are:

{1} Ātma-dhāraṇī,
{1} The rentention of oneself,

{2} grantha-dhāraṇī,
{2} the rentention of a book,

{3} dharma-dhāraṇī,
{3} the rentention of the dharma,

{4} mantra-dhāraṇī ceti.

{4} and the rentention of a spell.

14
The first two are normally seen in reverse order to that seen here.
 The Dharma Collection – 44

53. Four Reliances

Catvāri pratiśaraṇāni, tad-yathā:

There are four reliances, they are:

{1} Artha-pratiśaraṇatā na vyañjana-pratiśaraṇatā,

{1} Reliance on the meaning, not reliance on the word,

{2} jñāna-pratiśaraṇatā na vijñāna-pratiśaraṇatā,

{2} reliance on knowledge, not reliance on awareness,

{3} nītārtha-pratiśaraṇatā na neyārtha-pratiśaraṇatā,

{3} reliance on the plain sense, not reliance on the inferred sense,

{4} dharma-pratiśaraṇatā na pudgala-pratiśaraṇatā ceti.

{4} and reliance on the dharma, not reliance on a person.

54. Six Recollections

Ṣaḍ-
There are six recollections,

{1} -
{1} Recollection of the Buddha,

{2}
{2} recollection of the Dharma,

{3} -
{3} recollection of the Saṅgha,

{4}
{4} recollection of generosity,

{5} -
{5} recollection of virtue,

{6} -ceti. [12]

{6} recollection of the gods.

55. Four Dharma Sentences

Catvāri dharma-padāni, tad-yathā:

There are four dharma sentences, they are:

{1} Anityāḥ sarva-saṁskārāḥ,

{1} All conditions are impermanent,
 The Dharma Collection – 45

{2} duḥkhāḥ sarva-saṁskārāḥ,

{2} all conditions are suffering,

{3} nirātmānaḥ sarva-dharmāḥ,15

{3} all things are without self,

{4} śāntaṁ nirvāṇaṁ ceti.

{4} and nirvāṇa is peaceful.

56. Ten Unwholesome (Things)

Daśākuśalāni, tad-yathā:
There are ten unwholesome (things), they are:

{1} Prāṇātipāto
{1} Killing living creatures,

{2} ’dattādānaṁ,
{2} taking what has not been given,

{3} kāma-mithyācāro,
{3} sexual misconduct,

{4} -vādaḥ,
{4} false speech,

{5} paiśunyaṁ,
{5} malicious speech,

{6} pāruṣyaṁ,
{6} rough speech,

{7} sambhinna-pralāpo
{7} frivolous talk,

{8} ’bhidhyā,
{8} avarice,

{9} vyāpādo,
{9} ill-will,

{10} mithyā- -ceti.

{10} and wrong view.

15
Text: niratmānaḥ sarva-saṁskārāḥ.
 The Dharma Collection – 46

57. Six Destinations

Gatayaḥ ṣaṭ, tad-yathā:

There are six destinations, they are:

{1} Narakas-
{1} Hell (world),

{2} tiryak,
{2} animal (world),

{3} preto
{3} ghost (world),

{4} ’suro,
{4} demon (world),

{5} manuṣyo,
{5} human (world),

{6} devaś-ceti.
{6} and god (world).

58. Six Elements

Ṣaḍ dhātavaḥ,
16
There are six elements,

{1} -
{1} earth,

{2} āpas-
{2} water,

{3} tejo,
{3} fire,

{4} vāyur-
{4} wind,

{5} ākāśo,
{5} space,

{6} vijñānaṁ ceti.

{6} and consciousness.

16
Cf. the pañca mahābhūtāni, 39 above.
 The Dharma Collection – 47

59. Eight Liberations

Aṣṭau vimokṣāḥ, tad-yathā:

There are eight liberations, they are:

{1} Rūpī rūpāṇī paśyati śūnyaṁ,

{1} One having form perceives forms as empty,

{2} ādhyātmā-rūpa-sañjñī bahirdhā-rūpāṇi paśyati śūnyaṁ,

{2} not perceiving forms internally, one perceives forms externally as empty,

{3} {śubham-eva adhimukto paśyati śūnyaṁ,}17

{3} {one perceives being resolved on beauty as empty,}

{4} ākāśānanty-āyatanaṁ paśyati śūnyaṁ,

{4} one perceives the sphere of endless space as empty,

{5} vijñānānanty-āyatanaṁ paśyati śūnyaṁ,

{5} one perceives the sphere of endless consciousness as empty,

{6} ākiñcany-āyatanaṁ paśyati śūnyaṁ, [13]

{6} one perceives the sphere of nothingness as empty,

{7} naiva-saṁjñā-nāsaṁjñāyatanaṁ paśyati śūnyaṁ,

{7} one perceives the sphere of neither-perception-nor-non-perception as empty,

{8} saṁjñā-vedayita-nirodhaṁ paśyati śūnyaṁ ceti.

{8} one perceives the sphere of the cessation of perception and feeling as empty.

60. Five (Things) having Immediate Consequence

Pañcānantaryāṇi, tad-yathā:
There are five (things) having immediate consequence, they are:

{1} -vadhaḥ,
{1} Matricide,

{2} -vadho
{2} patricide,

{3} ’rhad-vadhas-
{3} killing an arhat,

{4} Tathāgata-duṣṭa-citta-rudhirotpādaḥ,
{4} with corrupt mind causing a Realised One’s blood to flow,

17
Missing from the edition, so it may be a manuscript issue; added here based on the Pāḷi.
 The Dharma Collection – 48

{5} Saṅgha-bhedaś-ceti.
{5} and causing schism in the Saṅgha.

Dharmas 61-80
61. Eight Worldly Conditions

Aṣṭau loka-dharmāḥ,
There are eight worldly conditions,

{1} lābho
{1} greed,

{2} ’lābho,
{2} non-greed,

{3} sukham,
{3} happiness,

{4} duḥkham,
{4} suffering,

{5} yaśo,
{5} fame,

{6} ’yaśo,
{6} infamy,

{7} nindā,
{7} blame,

{8} praśaṁsā ceti.

{8} and praise.

62. Nine (Types of) Teachings

Navāṅga-pravacanāni, tad-yathā:
There are nine (types of) teachings, they are:

{1} Sūtram,
{1} Discourses,

{2} geyam,
{2} prosimetrum,

{3} vyākaraṇam,
{3} explanation,
 The Dharma Collection – 49

{4-5} gāthodānam,
{4-5} verse, exalted utterance,

{6} jātakam,
{6} birth-story,

{7} vaipulyam-
{7} elaboration,

{8} adbhuta-dharma,
{8} wonderful thing,

{9} upadeśaś-ceti.
{9} and instruction.

63. Twelve Ascetic Virtues

Dvā-daśa dhūta-guṇāḥ,
There are twelve ascetic virtues,

{1} paiṇḍapātikas-
{1} (eating only) almsfood,

{2} trai-cīvarikaḥ,
{2} (wearing only) three robes,

{3} khalupaścād-bhaktiko,
{3} not (accepting more) after starting eating,

{4} naiṣadyiko,
{4} not lying down,

{5} yathā-saṁstariko,
{5} bed in accordance (with whatever is offered),

{6} -mūlika,
{6} (living at) the root of a tree,

{7} ekāsanika,
{7} (eating during) one sitting,

{8} ābhyavakāśika,
{8} (living in an) empty place,

{9} āraṇyakaḥ,
{9} (living in a) wilderness,
 The Dharma Collection – 50

{10} śmāśānikaḥ,
{10} (living in a) charnel ground,

{11} pāṁśūkūliko,
{11} (wearing only) robes made from discarded materials,

{12} nāmatikaś-ceti. [14]

{12} and (wearing only) felt garments.

64. Ten Stages of the Bodhisattva

Daśa bhūmayaḥ,
There are ten stages (of the Bodhisattva),

{1} pramuditā,
{1} the rejoicing,

{2} vimalā,
{2} the unstained,

{3} prabhākary-
{3} the light-making,

{4} arciṣmatī,
{4} the radiant,

{5} sudurjayā-
{5} the very difficult of success,

{6} ’bhimukhī,
{6} the manifest,

{7} dūraṅgamā-
{7} the far-gone,

{8} ’calā,
{8} the immovable,

{9} sādhumatī,
{9} the really intelligent,

{10} dharma-meghā ceti.

{10} and the cloud of dharma.
 The Dharma Collection – 51

65. Thirteen Stages of the Bodhisattva

{11} Samanta-prabhā,
{11} The all-round light,

{12} nirupamā,
{12} the incomparable,

{13} jñānavatī,
{13} the knowledgeable,

etāḥ sahitās-trayodaśa bhūmayaḥ.

when put together with the (previous, this makes) the thirteen stages (of the Bodhisattva).

66. Five Eyes

Pañca cakṣūṁṣī,
There are five eyes,

{1} māṁsa-cakṣur-
{1} the fleshly eye,

{2} dharma-cakṣuḥ,
{2} the dharma eye,

{3} prajñā-cakṣur-
{3} the wisdom eye,

{4} divya-cakṣur-
{4} the divine eye,

{5} Buddha-cakṣuś-ceti.
{5} and the Buddha eye.

67. Six Defilements

Ṣaṭ kleśāḥ,
There are six defilements,

{1} rāgaḥ,
{1} passion,

{2} pratigho,
{2} repulsion,

{3} māno,
{3} conceit,
 The Dharma Collection – 52

{4} ’vidyā,
{4} ignorance,

{5} -
{5} bad view,

{6} vicikitsā ceti.

{6} and doubt.

68. Five Views

There are five views,

{1} sat-kāya- -
{1} embodiment view,

{2} antagrāha- -
{2} holding extreme views,

{3} mithyā- -
{3} wrong view,

{4} -parāmarśaḥ,
{4} grasping at view,

{5} śīla-vrata-parāmarśaḥ.
{5} grasping at virtue and practice.

69. Twenty-Four Minor Defilements

Catur-viṁśatir-upakleśāḥ, tad-yathā:
There are twenty-four18 minor defilements, they are:19

{1} Krodha,
{1} Anger,

{2} upanāho,
{2} enmity,

{3} mrakṣaḥ,
{3} ill-will,

18
In fact only 23 are listed in both texts, hard to see what is missing, as this was not a standard
number anyway.
19
Many of these occur in section 30 above.
 The Dharma Collection – 53

{4} pradāśa,
{4} contention,

{5} īrṣyā,
{5} jealousy,

{6} mātsaryaṁ,
{6} selfishness,

{7} śāṭhyaṁ,
{7} treachery,

{8} māyā,
{8} deception,

{9} mado,
{9} intoxication,

{10} vihiṁsā,
{10} violence,

{11} hrīr-
{11} shame,

{12} anapatrapā,
{12} lack of conscience,

{13} styānam-
{13} sloth,

{14} aśrāddhyaṁ,
{14} faithlessness,

{15} kausīdyaṁ,
{15} indolence,

{16} pramādo, [15]

{16} heedlessness,

{17} muṣita- -
{17} lack of mindfulness,

{18} vikṣepo
{18} scatteredness,

{19} ’samprajanyaṁ,
{19} lack of knowledge,
 The Dharma Collection – 54

{20}
{20} worry,

{21} middhaṁ,
{21} torpor,

{22} vitarko,
{22} thinking,

{23} vicāraś-ceti.
{23} and reflection.

70. Five Nutriments

Pañcāhārāḥ,
There are five nutriments,

{1} dhyānāhārāḥ,
{1} nutriment of absorption,

{2} kavalīkār-āhārāḥ,
{2} nutriment of food,

{3} pratyāhārāḥ,
{3} nutriment from withdrawal,

{4} sparśāhārāḥ,
{4} nutriment of contact,

{5} sañcetanikāhārāś-ceti.
{5} and nutriment of intention.

71. Five Fears

Pañca bhayāni,
There are five fears,

{1} ājīvikā-bhayam-
{1} fear for (one’s) livelihood,

{2} śoka-bhayaṁ,
{2} fear of grief,

{3} maraṇa-bhayaṁ,
{3} fear of death,

{4} durgati-bhayaṁ,
{4} fear of a bad destination,
 The Dharma Collection – 55

{5} parṣadaś{ar}ādya-bhayaṁ20 ceti.

{5} and fear through timidity.

72. Four Absorptions

Catvāri dhyānāni, tad-yathā:

There are four absorptions, they are:

{1} Savitarkaṁ savicāraṁ vivekajaṁ prīti-sukham-iti prathama-dhyānaṁ,

{1} The first absorption has thinking, reflection, and the happiness and joy born of
seclusion,

{2} adhyātma-pramodanāt-prīti-sukham-iti dvitīyaṁ,

{2} the second has internal clarity, and happiness and joy,

{3} upekṣā- -samprajanyaṁ sukham-

{3} the third is equanimous, mindful, and has full knowledge,

{4} upekṣā- -pariśuddhir-aduḥkhāsukhā vedaneti caturthaṁ dhyānam-iti.

{4} the fourth absorption has complete purity of mindfulness and equanimity, with
feeling that is neither-unpleasant-nor-pleasant.

73. Three Liberations

Trayo vimokṣāḥ,
The are three liberations,

{1} śūnyato
{1} empty,

{2} ’nimitto
{2} signless,

{3} ’praṇihitaś-ceti. [16]

{3} and desireless.

74. Ten Masteries of the Bodhisattvas

Bodhisattvānāṁ daśa vaśitāḥ,

There are ten masteries of the Bodhisattvas,

{1} āyur-vaśitā,
{1} mastery of life,

{2} citta-vaśitā,
{2} mastery of mind,

20
Text: parṣadaśādya-bhayaṁ; amended at Edgerton’s suggestion, s.v. śarādya.
 The Dharma Collection – 56

{3} pariṣkāra-vaśitā,
{3} mastery of discipline,

{4} dharma-vaśitar-
{4} mastery of dharma,

{5} ’ddhi-vaśitā,
{5} mastery of spiritual power,

{6} janma-vaśitā-
{6} mastery of birth,

{7} ’dhimukti-vaśitā,
{7} mastery of resolution,

{8} praṇidhāna-vaśitā,
{8} mastery of aspiration,

{9} karma-vaśitā,
{9} mastery of deeds,

{10} jñāna-vaśitā ceti.

{10} and mastery of knowledge.

75. Ten Strengths of the Bodhisattvas

Bodhisattvānāṁ daśa balāni, tad-yathā:

There are ten strengths of the Bodhisattvas, they are:

{1} Adhimukti-balaṁ,
{1} The strength of resolution,

{2} pratisaṅkhyāna-balaṁ,
{2} the strength of observation,

{3} bhāva-balaṁ,
{3} the strength of behaviour,

{4} kṣānti-balaṁ,
{4} the strength of patience,

{5} jñāna-balaṁ,
{5} the strength of knowledge,
 The Dharma Collection – 57

{6} prahāṇa-balaṁ,
{6} the strength of abandoning,

{7} samādhi-balaṁ,
{7} the strength of concentration,

{8} pratibhāna-balaṁ,
{8} the strength of inspired speech,

{9} puṇya-balaṁ,
{9} the strength of merit,

{10} pratipatti-balaṁ ceti.

{10} and the strength of practice.

76. Ten Strengths of a Realised One

Tathāgatasya daśa balāni, tad-yathā:

There are ten strengths of a Realised One, they are:

{1} Sthānāsthāna-jñāna-balaṁ,
{1} The strength of knowing the possible and impossible,

{2} karma-vipāka-jñāna-balaṁ,
{2} the strength of knowing deeds and results,

{3} nānā-dhātu-jñāna-balaṁ,
{3} the strength of knowing the various elements,

{4} nānādhimukti-jñāna-balaṁ,
{4} the strength of knowing the various inclinations,

{5} sattvendriya-parāpara-jñāna-balaṁ,
{5} the strength of knowing the faculties of beings, near and far,

{6} sarvatra-gāminī-pratipatti-jñāna-balaṁ,
{6} the strength of knowing the practice that leads to all destinations,

{7} dhyāna-vimokṣa-samādhi-samāpatti-
{7} * the strength of knowing the absorptions, liberations, concentrations, attainments

saṅkleśa-vyavadāna-vyutthāna-jñāna-balaṁ,
and purification and arising from defilements,

{8} pūrvaniv -jñāna-balaṁ,

{8} the strength of knowing the recollection of his manifold past existences,
 The Dharma Collection – 58

{9} cyutyutpatti-jñāna-balam-
{9} the strength of knowing the passing away and arising (of beings),

{10} āsravakṣaya-jñāna-balaṁ ceti.

{10} and the strength of knowing the destruction of the pollutants.

77. Four Confidences

Catvāri vaiśāradyāni, tad-yathā:

There are four confidences, they are:

{1} Abhisambodhi-vaiśāradyam-
{1} Confidence in the Awakening,

{2} āsrava-kṣaya-jñāna-vaiśāradyaṁ,
{2} confidence in the destruction of the pollutants,

{3} nairvāṇika-mārgāvataraṇa-vaiśāradyam-
{3} confidence in the path that leads to entering emancipation,

{4} {antarāyika-dharmānanya-thātva-niścita-vyākaraṇa-vaiśāradyaṁ}21 ceti. [17]

{4} {and confidence that those things declared in the dharma to be obstacles are not
other than stated.}

78. Five Selfishnesses

Pañca mātsaryāṇi,
There are five selfishnesses,

{1} dharma-mātsaryaṁ,
{1} selfishnessregarding dharma,

{2} lābha-mātsaryam-
{2} selfishnessregarding wealth,

{3} āvāsa-mātsaryaṁ,
{3} selfishnessregarding dwellings,

{4} kuśala-mātsaryaṁ,
{4} selfishnessregarding wholesomeness,

{5} varṇa-mātsaryaṁ ceti.

{5} and selfishnessregarding class.

21
Added from the list in Mahāvyutpatti.
 The Dharma Collection – 59

79. Eighteen Special Qualities of the Buddha

Aṣṭādaśāveṇikā Buddha-dharmāḥ, tad-yathā:

There are eighteen special qualities of the Buddha, they are:

{1} Nāsti Tathāgatasya skhalitaṁ,

{1} The Realised One does not stumble,

{2} nāsti ravitaṁ,

{2} he does not cry out,

{3} nāsti muṣita-

{3} he does not lose mindfulness,

{4} nāsty-asamāhita-cittaṁ,
{4} he does not have uncollectedness of mind,

{5} nāsti nānātva-saṁjñā,

{5} he does not have perceptions of variety (of feelings),

{6} nāsty-apratisaṅkhyāyopekṣā,
{6} he does not have equanimity due to lack of observation,

{7} nāsti chanda-parihāṇiḥ,

{7} he does not have a loss of desire,

{8} nāsti vīrya-parihāṇiḥ,

{8} he does not have a loss of energy,

{9} -parihāṇiḥ,
{9} he does not have a loss of mindfulness,

{10} nāsti samādhi-parihāṇiḥ,

{10} he does not have a loss of concentration,

{11} nāsti prajñā-parihāṇiḥ,

{11} he does not have a loss of wisdom,

{12} nāsti vimukti-parihāṇiḥ,

{12} he does not have a loss of liberation,

{13} nāsti vimukti-jñāna-darśana-parihāṇiḥ,

{13} he does not have a loss of knowledge and insight into liberation,22

22
At this point the list is different from the standard one, adding this item, changing the order of
the following items, and omitting knowledge and insight into the future.
 The Dharma Collection – 60

{14} sarva-kāya-karma-jñāna-pūrvaṅgama-
{14} all his bodily deeds are preceded by knowledge, in accordance with knowledge,

{15} sarva-vāk-karma-jñāna-pūrvaṅgama-
{15} all his verbal deeds are preceded by knowledge, in accordance with knowledge,

{16} sarva-manas-karma-jñāna-pūrvaṅgama-
{16} all his mental deeds are preceded by knowledge, in accordance with knowledge,

{17} atīte ’dhvany-asaṅgama-pratihata-jñānaṁ,

{17} he has independent, unobstructed knowledge and insight into the past time,

{18} pratyutpanne, ’dhvanya-saṅgama-pratihata-jñāna-darśanaṁ ceti.

{18} he has independent, unobstructed knowledge and insight into the present time.

80. Four Destroyers

Catvāro mārāḥ, tad-yathā:

There are four destroyers, they are:

{1} Skandha-māraḥ,
{1} The components destroyer,

{2} kleśa-māro,
{2} the defilements destroyer,

{3} deva-putra-Māro,
{3} the destroyer-god Māra,

{4} -māraś-ceti. [18]

{4} and death as destroyer.

Dharmas 81-100
81. Four Factors of Faith

Catvāri śraddhāṅgāni, tad-yathā:

There are four factors of faith, they are:

{1} Ārya-satyam,
{1} Noble truth(s),

{2} tri-ratnam,
{2} three jewel(s),

{3} karma,
{3} deeds,
 The Dharma Collection – 61

{4} karma-phalaṁ ceti.

{4} and deeds and fruit.

82. Nine Succeeding Attainments of Concentration

Navānupūrva-samādhi-samāpattayaḥ, tad-yathā:
There are nine succeeding attainments of concentration, they are:

{1-4} Catvāri dhyānāni,

{1-4} The four absorptions,

{5-8} catasra ārūpya-samāpattayo,

{5-8} the four formless attainments,

{9} nirodha-samāpattiś-ceti.
{9} and the attainment of cessation.

83. Thirty-Two Marks of a Great Man

Dvātriṁśal-lakṣaṇāni, tad-yathā:
There are thirty-two marks of a great man, they are:

{1} Cakrāṅkita-pāṇipāda-talatā,
{1} Wheels on his palms and soles,

{2} supratiṣṭhita-pāṇi-pāda-talatā,
{2} palms and soles well-placed,

{3} jālā-baddhāṅguli-pāṇi-pāda-talatā,23
{3} fingers, palms and soles bound with nets,

{4} -taruṇa-hasta-pāda-talatā,
{4} hands and soles that are soft and tender,

{5} saptotsadatā,
{5} seven prominent marks,

{6} dīrghāṅgulitā,
{6} long fingers,

{7} āyata-pārṣṇitā,
{7} heels that are long and deep,

{8} -gātratā,
{8} upright limbs,

23
Text: jālā-bala-baddhāṅguli-pāṇi-pāda-talatā.
 The Dharma Collection – 62

{9} utsaṅga-pādatā,
{9} high ankles,

{10} urdhvāgra-romatā,
{10} bristling hair,

{11} aiṇeyajaṅghatā,
{11} antelope-like calves,

{12} pralamba-bāhutā,
{12} arms that hang low,

{13} koṣa-gata-vasti-guhyatā,
{13} what is covered by a cloth is ensheathed,

{14} suvarṇa-varṇatā,
{14} golden in colour,

{15} śuklac-chavitā,
{15} fine skin,

{16} pradakṣiṇāvartaika-romatā,
{16} each hair arises singly and turns to the right,

{17} -mukhatā,
{17} a circle of hair decorates his forehead,

{18} siṁha-pūrvānta-kāyatā,
{18} a torso like a lion’s,

{19} -skandhatā,
{19} upper back that is even all round,

{20} citāntarāṁsatā,
{20} between the shoulders it is firm,

{21} rasa-rasāgratā,
{21} his taste buds are supremely sensitive,

{22} nyagrodha-parimaṇḍalatā, [19]

{22} his (body) is well-proportioned like a banyan tree,

{23} uṣṇīṣa-śiras-katā,
{23} he has a protuberance on the head,

{24} prabhūta-jivhatā,
{24} his tongue is large,
 The Dharma Collection – 63

{25} siṁha-hanutā,
{25} his jaw is like a lion’s,

{26} śukla-hanutā,
{26} his jaw is fine,

{27} sama-dantatā,
{27} his forty teeth are even,

{28} haṁsa-vikrānta-gāmitā,
{28} a gait like that of a goose,

{29} avirala-dantatā,
{29} the teeth are without gaps,

{30} sama-catvāriṁśad-dantatā,
{30} the forty teeth are even,

{31} abhinīla-netratā,
{31} the eyes are very dark,

{32} gopakṣa-netratā ceti.

{32} and the eyes have eyelashes like a cow’s.

84. Eighty Secondary Characteristics

Aśīty-anuvyañjanāni, tad-yathā:
There are eighty secondary characteristics, they are:

{1} Tāmra-nakhatā,
{1} Copper-coloured nails,

{2} srigdha-nakhatā,
{2} glossy nails,

{3} tuṅga-nakhatā,
{3} prominent nails,

{4} chatrāṅgulitā,
{4} round fingers,

{5} citrāṅgulitā,
{5} firm fingers,

{6} anupūrvāṅgulitā,
{6} regular fingers,
 The Dharma Collection – 64

{7} gūḍha-śiratā,
{7} hidden veins,

{8} nigranthi-śiratā,
{8} unhindered veins,

{9} gūḍha-gulphatā,
{9} hidden ankles,

{10} aviṣama-pādatā,
{10} even feet,

{11} siṁha-vikrānta-gāmitā,
{11} a gait like that of a lion,

{12} nāga-vikrānta-gāmitā,
{12} a gait like that of a elephant,

{13} haṁsa-vikrānta-gāmitā,
{13} a gait like that of a goose,

{14} -vikrānta-gāmitā,
{14} a gait like that of a bull,

{15} pradakṣiṇa-gāmitā,
{15} a respectful stride,

{16} cāru-gāmitā,
{16} a beautiful stride,

{17} avakra-gāmitā,
{17} straight limbs,

{18} -gātratā,
{18} rounded limbs,

{19} -gātratā,
{19} pleasant limbs,

{20} anupūrva-gātratā,
{20} regular limbs,

{21} śuci-gātratā,
{21} pure limbs,

{22} -gātratā,
{22} soft limbs,
 The Dharma Collection – 65

{23} viśuddha-gātratā,
{23} purified limbs,

{24} paripūrṇa-vyañjanatā,
{24} fulsome genitals,

{25} -cāru-maṇḍala-gātratā,
{25} broad, beautiful knees,

{26} samakramatā,
{26} an even step,

{27} viśuddha-netratā,
{27} purified limbs,

{28} sukumāra-gātratā,
{28} delicate limbs,

{29} adīna-gātratā,
{29} noble limbs,

{30} utsāha-gātratā,
{30} upright limbs,

{31} gambhīra-kukṣitā,
{31} a deep belly,

{32} prasanna-gātratā,
{32} clear limbs,

{33} suvibhaktāṅga-pratyaṅgatā,
{33} well-proportioned minor limbs,

{34} vitimira-śuddhālokatā,
{34} a pure luminescence that dispels the darkness,

{35} -kukṣitā,
{35} a rounded belly,

{36} -kukṣitā,
{36} a pleasant belly,

{37} abhugna-kukṣitā,
{37} a straight belly,

{38} kṣāma-kukṣitā, [20]

{38} a slim belly,
 The Dharma Collection – 66

{39} gambhīra-nābhitā,
{39} a deep navel,

{40} pradakṣiṇāvartanābhitā,
{40} a navel that turns to the right,

{41} samanta-prāsādikatā,
{41} (an appearance) that is pleasant on all sides,

{42} śuci-samudācāratā,
{42} pure behaviour,

{43} vyapagata-tilaka-gātratā,
{43} limbs that are free of moles,

{44} tūlasa- -sukumāra-pāṇitā,

{44} hands that are soft as cotton,

{45} snigdha-pāṇi-lekhatā,
{45} glossy palms of the hands,

{46} gambhīra-pāṇi-lekhatā,
{46} deep palms of the hands,

{47} āyata-pāṇi-lekhatā,
{47} long palms of the hands,

{48} nātyāyata-vacanatā,
{48} a not overly-long face,

{49} bimba-pratibimboṣṭhatā,
{49} a lovely appearance and lips,

{50} -jivhatā,
{50} a soft tongue,

{51} tanu-jivhatā,
{51} a slim tongue,

{52} rakta-jihvatā,
{52} a red-coloured tongue,

{53} megha-garji-ghoṣatā,
{53} a voice that sounds like thunder,

{54} madhura-cāru-mañjusvaratā,
{54} a voice that is sweet, charming and lovely,
 The Dharma Collection – 67

{55} -daṁṣṭratā,
{55} rounded eye-teeth,

{56} tīkṣṇaṁ-daṁṣṭratā,
{56} sharp eye-teeth,

{57} śūkla-daṁṣṭratā,
{57} fine eye-teeth,

{58} sama-daṁṣṭratā,
{58} even eye-teeth,

{59} anupūrva-daṁṣṭratā,
{59} regular eye-teeth,

{60} tuṅganāsatā,
{60} a long nose,

{61} śucināsatā,
{61} a clean nose,

{62} viśālanayanatā,
{62} wide eyes,

{63} citrapakṣmatā,
{63} thick eyelashes,

{64} sitāsita-kamala-dala-nayanatā,
{64} having eyes like the black and white lotus,

{65} āyata-bhrūkatā,
{65} long brows,

{66} śukla-bhrūkatā,
{66} fine brows,

{67} susnigdha-bhrūkatā,
{67} very glossy brows,

{68} pīnāyata-bhujalatā,
{68} having full and long arms,

{69} sama-karṇatā,
{69} even ears,

{70} anupahata-karṇendriyatā,
{70} unimpaired ear faculty,
 The Dharma Collection – 68

{71} avimlāna-lalāṭatā,
{71} unfaded forehead,

{72} -lalāṭatā,
{72} spacious forehead,

{73} suparipūrṇottamāṅgatā,
{73} a very complete head,

{74} bhramara- -keśatā,

{74} hair of the head that is like a black bee (in colour),

{75} citra-keśatā,
{75} beautiful hair,

{76} guḍā-keśatā,
{76} thick hair,

{77} asaṁlulita-keśatā,24
{77} unconfused hair of the head,

{78} aparuṣa-keśatā,
{78} smooth hair of the head,

{79} surabhi-keśatā,
{79} fragrant hair of the head,

{80} śrīvatsa-mukti-kanandy-āvarta-lakṣita-pāṇi-pāda-talatā ceti.

{80} and the curl of hair, pearl, and diagram marks on palms and soles.

85. Seven Jewels of Universal Monarchs

Cakravartināṁ sapta ratnāni, tad-yathā:

There are seven jewels of Universal Monarchs, they are:

{1} Cakra-ratnam-
{1} The wheel jewel,

{2} aśva-ratnaṁ,
{2} the horse jewel,

{3} hasti-ratnaṁ,
{3} the elephant jewel,

{4} maṇi-ratnaṁ,
{4} the gem jewel,

24
Text: asammuṇita?
 The Dharma Collection – 69

{5} strī-ratnaṁ,
{5} the woman jewel,

{6} khaṅga-ratnaṁ,
25
{6} the rhinoceros jewel,

{7} pariṇāyaka-ratnaṁ ceti. [21]

{7} and the advisor jewel.

86. Three Times

Tatra trayo ’dhvānaḥ, tad-yathā:

Herein, there are three times, they are:

{1} Atīto ’dhvā-

{1} Past time,

{2} ’nāgato ’dhvā,

{2} future time,

{3} pratyutpanno ’dhvā ceti.

{3} and present time.

87. Four Aeons

Catvāraḥ kalpāḥ, tad-yathā:

There are four aeons, they are:

{1} Antara-kalpā,
{1} An intervalic aeon,

{2} mahā-kalpāḥ,
{2} a great aeon,

{3} śūnya-kalpāḥ,
{3} an empty aeon,

{4} sāra-kalpāś-ceti.
{4} and an essential aeon.

88. Four Ages

Catvāri yugāni, tad-yathā:

There are four ages, they are:

{1} -yugaṁ,
{1} The accomplished age,

25
This is normally given as , the householder jewel.
 The Dharma Collection – 70

{2} tretā-{yugaṁ},
{2} the threefold-life {age},

{3} dvāparaṁ,
{3} the twofold {life age},

{4} kali-yugaṁ ceti.

{4} and the dark age.26

89. A Pair of Worlds

Loka-dvayaṁ, tad-yathā:
There are a pair of worlds, they are:

{1} Sattva-loko,
{1} The world of beings,

{2} bhājana-lokaś-ceti.
{2} and the inanimate world.

90. Four Wombs

Catvāro yonayaḥ, tad-yathā:

There are four wombs, they are:

{1} Aṇḍajaḥ,
{1} Egg-born,

{2} saṁsvedajo,
{2} moisture-born,

{3} jarāyuja,
{3} viviparous,

{4} upapādukaś-ceti.
{4} and spontaneously-born.

91. Five Stains

Pañca kaṣāyāḥ, tad-yathā:

There are five stains, they are:

{1} Kleśa-kaṣāyo,
{1} The stain of defilements,

26
SED: The duration of each (yuga) is said to be respectively 1,728,000, 1,296,000, 864,000, and
432,000 years of men, the descending numbers representing a similar physical and moral
deterioration of men in each age.
 The Dharma Collection – 71

{2} -kaṣāyaḥ,
{2} the stain of views,

{3} sattva-kaṣāya,
{3} the stain on beings,

{4} āyuḥ-kaṣāyaḥ,
{4} the stain of age,

{5} kalpa-kaṣāyaś-ceti. [22]

{5} and the stain of practice.

92. Three Comprehensions

Trayaḥ parijñāyāḥ,27 tad-yathā:

There are three comprehensions, they are:

{1} Pūrvānta-koṭi-parijñāyā,
{1} Comprehension of the beginning time,

{2} aparānta-koṭi-parijñāyāś-
{2} comprehension of the end time,

{3} catur-māra-koṭi-parijñāyāś-ceti.
{3} comprehension of the time having four destroyers.

93. Ten Knowledges

Daśa jñānāni, tad-yathā:

There are ten knowledges, they are:

{1} Duḥkha-jñānaṁ,
{1} Knowledge of suffering,

{2} samudaya-jñānaṁ,
{2} knowledge of arising,

{3} nirodha-jñānaṁ,
{3} knowledge of cessation,

{4} mārga-jñānaṁ,
{4} knowledge of path,

{5} dharma-jñānam-
{5} knowledge of dharma,

27
Text: sattvādhyāḥ?
 The Dharma Collection – 72

{6} anvaya-jñānaṁ,
{6} knowledge of conformity,

{7} -jñānaṁ,
{7} knowledge of the concealed,

{8} paracitta-jñānaṁ,
{8} knowledge of others’ minds,

{9} kṣaya-jñānam-
{9} knowledge of destruction,

{10} anutpāda-jñānaṁ ceti.

{10} and knowledge of non-production.

94. Five Knowledges

Pañca jñānāni, tad-yathā:

There are five knowledges, they are:

{1} Ādarśana{jñānaṁ},
{1} Mirror-like (knowledge),

{2} samatā{jñānaṁ},
{2} (knowledge) of equality,

{3} pratyavekṣaṇā{jñānaṁ},
{3} (knowledge) of reflection,

{4}
{4} (knowledge) of performance,

{5} suviśuddha-dharma-dhātu-jñānaṁ ceti.

{5} and knowledge of the very pure dharma element.

95. Two Truths

Dve satye, tad-yathā:

There are two truths, they are:

{1} -satyaṁ,
{1} Conventional truth,

{2} paramārtha-satyaṁ ceti.

{2} and ultimate truth.
 The Dharma Collection – 73

96. Sixteen Marks of being receptive to Knowledge

Catur-ārya-satyeṣu ṣoḍaśa kṣānti-jñāna-lakṣaṇāḥ, tad-yathā:

There are sixteen marks of being receptive to knowledge regarding the four noble truths,
they are:

{1} Duḥkhe dharma-jñāna-kṣāntir-

{1} being receptive to the dharma knowledge of suffering,

{2} duḥkhe dharma-jñānaṁ,

{2} the dharma knowledge of suffering,

{3} duḥkhe ’nvaya-jñāna-kṣāntir-

{3} being receptive to the conformity knowledge of suffering,

{4} duḥkhe ’nvaya-jñānaṁ;

{4} the conformity knowledge of suffering;

{5} samudaye dharma-jñāna-kṣāntiḥ,

{5} being receptive to the dharma knowledge of arising,

{6} samudaye dharma-jñānaṁ, [23]

{6} the dharma knowledge of arising,

{7} samudaye ’nvaya-jñāna-kṣāntiḥ,

{7} being receptive to the conformity knowledge of arising,

{8} samudaye ’nvaya-jñānaṁ;

{8} the conformity knowledge of arising;

{9} nirodhe dharma-jñāna-kṣāntir-

{9} being receptive to the dharma knowledge of cessation,

{10} nirodhe dharma-jñānaṁ,

{10} the knowledge of cessation,

{11} nirodhe ’nvaya-jñāna-kṣāntir-

{11} being receptive to the conformity knowledge of cessation,

{12} nirodhe ’nvaya-jñānaṁ;

{12} the conformity knowledge of cessation;

{13} mārge dharma-jñāna-kṣāntir-

{13} being receptive to the dharma knowledge of the path,

{14} mārge dharma-jñānaṁ,

{14} the dharma knowledge of the path,
 The Dharma Collection – 74

{15} mārge ’nvaya-jñāna-kṣāntir-

{15} being receptive to the conformity knowledge of the path,

{16} mārge ’nvaya-jñānaṁ ceti.

{16} and the conformity knowledge of the path.

97. Four Aspects in the Truth of Suffering

Tatra duḥkha-satye catvāra ākārāḥ, tad-yathā:

Herein, there are four aspects in the truth of suffering, they are:

{1} Anityato,
{1} Relating to impermanence,

{2} duḥkhataḥ,
{2} relating to suffering,

{3} śūnyato
{3} relating to emptiness,

{4} ’nātmataś-ceti.
{4} and relating to no-self.

98. Four States in the Truth of Arising

Samudaya-satye catvāra ākārāḥ, tad-yathā:

There are four aspects in the truth of arising, they are:

{1} Hetutaḥ,
{1} Relating to cause,

{2} samudayataḥ,
{2} relating to arising,

{3} prabhavataḥ,
{3} relating to birth,

{4} pratyayataś-ceti.
{4} and relating to conditions.

99. Four States in the Truth of Cessation

Nirodha-satye catvāra ākārāḥ, tad-yathā:

There are four aspects in the truth of cessation, they are:

{1} Nirodhataḥ,
{1} Relating to cessation,
 The Dharma Collection – 75

{2} śāntataḥ,
{2} relating to peace,

{3} praṇītato,
{3} relating to performance,

{4} niḥsaraṇataś-ceti.
{4} and relating to escape.

100. Four States in the Truth of the Path

Mārga-satye catvāra ākārāḥ, tad-yathā:

There are four aspects in the truth of the path, they are:

{1} Mārgato,
{1} Relating to the path,

{2} nyāyataḥ,
{2} relating to method,

{3} pratipattito,
{3} relating to practice,

{4} nairyāṇikaś-ceti.
{4} and relating to leading out.

Dharmas 101-120
101. Four Concentrations

Catvāraḥ samādhayaḥ, tad-yathā:

There are four concentrations, they are:

{1} Āloka-{samādhiḥ},
{1} (Concentration on) light,

{2} -{samādhiḥ},
{2} (concentration on) enclosed light,

{3} ekādaśa-pratiṣṭha-{samādhiḥ},
{3} the eleven establishments (of concentration),

{4} ānantarya-samādhiś-ceti. [24]

{4} and the concentration giving immediate result.
 The Dharma Collection – 76

102. Eight Persons

Tatrāṣṭau ... pugdalāḥ, tad-yathā:

Herein, there are eight persons, they are:

{1} Srota-āpanna-phala-pratipannakaḥ,
{1} The one on the path to the fruit of stream-entry,

{2} srota-āpannaḥ,
{2} the stream-enterer,

{3} -phala-pratipannakaḥ,
{3} the one on the path to the fruit of once-returning,

{4} -
{4} the once-returner,

{5} anāgāmi-phala-pratipannako
{5} the one on the path to the fruit of non-returning,

{6} ’nāgāmy-
{6} the non-returner,

{7} arhat-phala-pratipannako
{7} the one on the path to the fruit of worthiness,

{8} ’rhaṁś-ceti.
{8} and the worthy one.

103. Eighteen Individuals

Tathāṣṭadaśa28 pratipugdalāḥ, tad-yathā:

Herein, there are eighteen individuals, they are:

{1} Śraddhānusārī,
{1} The faith follower,

{2} dharmānusārī,
{2} the dharma follower,

{3} srota-āpanno,
{3} the stream-enterer,

28
Text: aṣṭau (eight). There appears to be eighteen individuals listed. It is not always clear where
the text should be divided, though, or what the meaning of some of these are. Cf.
Puggalapaññatti’s list of fifty-four persons (http://bit.ly/2iiVRZw), which partially coincide.
 The Dharma Collection – 77

{4} deva-kulaṅkulo,
{4} the one of the lineage of the gods,

{5} manuṣya-kulaṅkulaḥ,
{5} the one of the lineage of humans,

{6} -phalaḥ,
{6} the one with the fruit of once-returning,

{7} śraddha-vimuktir- -prāpta,

{7} the one who attains vision of liberation through faith,

{8} eka-vīciko,
{8} the one-intervaller, ??

{9} ’nāgāmy-
{9} the non-returner,

{10} antarā-parinirvāyy-
{10} the one who attains nirvāṇa before the middle (of the aeon),

{11} upahatya-parinirvāyy-
{11} the one who attains nirvāṇa at the end (of the aeon),

{12} abhisaṁskāra-parinirvāyī,
{12} the one who enters nirvāṇa after preparation,

{13} pluto,
{13} the one who floats,

{14} ’rddha-plutaḥ,
{14} the one who half-floats,

{15} sarvāstāna-pluto,
{15} the one who fully floats, ??

{16} -dharma-samaḥ,
{16} peaceful ?? in this very life,

{17} kāyasākṣī,
{17} body-witness,

{18} khaṅgaś-ceti. [25]

{18} and the solitary. ??
 The Dharma Collection – 78

104. Twelve Ways that the Dharma Wheel is Turned

Tad-atra29 dvādaśākāra-dharma-cakra-pravartakaṁ.
There are twelve ways that the dharma wheel is turned here.

Katamat?
Which (twelve)?

{1} Idaṁ duḥkham-ārya-satyam-iti,

{1} This is the noble truth of suffering,

{me}, bhikṣavaḥ, pūrvam-ananuśruteṣu dharmeṣu,

to me monastics, regarding these previously unheard-of things,

yoniśo manasi-kurvataḥ,
applying the mind,

cakṣur-udapādi, jñānam-udapādi, vidyodapādi,

vision arose, knowledge arose, understanding arose,

bhūrir-udapādityekaṁ parivartakam.
wisdom arose, this is the first turning.

{2} Idaṁ duḥkham-ārya-satyaṁ tatra

{2} Herein, that to which this is the noble truth of suffering refers

khalv-abhijñāya parijñeyam-iti,30
ought to be deeply and fully known,

{me}, bhikṣavaḥ pūrvam-ananuśruteṣu dharmeṣu,

to me, monastics, regarding these previously unheard-of things,

yoniśo manasi-kurvata iti... dvitīyaṁ.

applying the mind... is the second.

{3} Idaṁ duḥkham-ārya-satyaṁ tatra

{3} Herein that to which this is the noble truth of suffering refers

khalv-abhijñāya parijñātam-iti,
has been deeply and fully known,

{me}, bhikṣava ityādi... pūrvavad- [26]

{to me}, monastics... as before is the third.

29
The manuscripts are confused and conflicting, with a number of impossible readings. There is a
restored text, but the asymmetry there is unlikely. Therefore I have restored it even further.
30
Text: parijñātam-iti hi, which belongs to the next line.
 The Dharma Collection – 79

{4} [Tathedaṁ duḥkha-samudayam-ārya-satyam-iti... prathamaṁ.31

{4} [Herein, this is the noble truth of the arising of suffering... is the first.

{5} Idaṁ duḥkha-samudayam-ārya-satyaṁ, tatra

{5} Herein, that to which this is the noble truth of the arising of suffering refers,

khalv-abhijñāya prahātavyam-iti... dvitīyaṁ.]32

ought to be deeply known and given up... is the second.]

{6} Idaṁ duḥkha-samudayam-ārya-satyaṁ tatra

{6} Herein, that to which this is the noble truth of the arising of suffering refers,

khalv-abhijñāya prahīṇam-iti hīty-

has been deeply known and given up and so on... is the third.

{7} Tathedaṁ duḥkha-nirodham-ārya-satyam-iti hi... prathamaṁ.

{7} Herein, this is the noble truth of the cessation of suffering... is the first.

{8} Idaṁ duḥkha-nirodham-ārya-satyaṁ tatra

{8} Herein, that to which this is the noble truth of the cessation of suffering refers

khalv-abhijñāya sākṣāt-kartavyam-iti hīty-ādi... dvitīyaṁ.

ought to be deeply known and seen for oneself and so on... is the second.

{9} Idaṁ duḥkha-nirodham-ārya-satyaṁ tatra

{9} Herein, that to which this is the noble truth of the cessation of suffering refers,

khalv-abhijñāya sākṣāt- -
has been deeply known and seen for oneself... is the third.

{10} Tathedaṁ duḥkha-nirodha-gāminī pratipadity-ārya-satyam-iti...33 prathamaṁ.

{10} Herein, this is the noble truth of the path leading to the cessation of suffering... is
the first.
34
{11} Idaṁ duḥkha-nirodha-gāminī pratipadity-ārya-satyaṁ tatra [27]
{11} Herein, that to which this is the noble truth of the path leading to the cessation of
suffering refers
35
khalv-abhivijñāya bhāvayitavyam-iti hi ity-ādi... dvitīyaṁ.
ought to be deeply known and developed and so on... is the second.

31
Texts reads: pratyekaṁ, for which I can find no good meaning; also at similar places below.
32
Section in brackets is part of Kasawara’s restoration.
33
Text prints -mārga- in place of -nirodha-.
34
Text: duḥkha-mokṣa-gāminī; also in the next line.
35
Text adds: bhikṣava.
 The Dharma Collection – 80

{12} [Idaṁ duḥkha-nirodha-gāminī pratipadity-ārya-satyaṁ tatra

{12} [Herein, that to which this is the noble truth of the path leading to the cessation
of suffering refers

khalv-abhijñāya bhāvitam-
has been deeply known and developed is the third.]

105. Three Kinds of Gifts

Tatra dānaṁ tri-vidhaṁ, tad-yathā:

Herein, there are three kinds of gifts, they are:

{1} Dharma-dānam-
{1} The gift of the dharma,

{2} āmiṣa-dānaṁ,
{2} the gift of material things,

{3} maitrī-dānaṁ ceti.

{3} and the gift of friendliness.

106. Three Kinds of Virtue

Śīlaṁ tri-vidhaṁ, tad-yathā:

There are three kinds of virtue, they are:

{1} Sambhāra-śīlaṁ,
{1} Meritorious virtue,

{2} kuśala-saṅgrāha-śīlaṁ,
{2} the virtue of holding to wholesome deeds,

{3} sattvārtha-kriyā-śīlaṁ ceti.

{3} and the virtue of seeking the welfare of beings.

107. Manifold Receptivities

Kṣāntis-vividhā, tad-yathā:
There are manifold receptivities, they are:

{1} Dharma-nidhyāna-kṣāntir-
{1} Receptivity from seeing the dharma,

{2} duḥkhādhivāsanā-kṣāntiḥ,
{2} receptivity from forbearance with suffering,
 The Dharma Collection – 81

{3} paropakāra-dharma-kṣāntiś-ceti.36
{3} and receptivity from the state of helping others.

108. Three Kinds of Energy

Vīryaṁ tri-vidhaṁ, tad-yathā:

There are three kinds of energy, they are:

{1} Saṁnāha-vīryaṁ,
{1} Energy as armour,

{2} prayoga-vīryaṁ,
{2} energy as practice,

{3} pariniṣṭhā-vīryaṁ ceti. [28]

{3} and energy as accomplishment.

109. Three Kinds of Meditation

Dhyānaṁ tri-vidhaṁ, tad-yathā:

There are three kinds of meditation, they are:

{1} Sadoṣāpakarṣa-dhyānaṁ,
{1} Meditation with fault that leads to decay,

{2} sukha-vaihārika-dhyānam-
{2} meditation that is a happy abiding,

{3} aśeṣa-vaibhūṣita-dhyānaṁ ceti.

{3} and meditation that is entirely magnificent.

110. Three Kinds of Wisdom

Prajñā tri-vidhā, tad-yathā:

There are three kinds of wisdom, they are:

{1} Śruta-mayī,
{1} By way of learning,

{2} cintā-mayī,
{2} by way of thinking,

{3} bhāvanā-mayī ceti.

{3} and by way of meditation.

36
Text prints dhama in place of dharma.
 The Dharma Collection – 82

111. Manifold Means

Upāyas-vividhaḥ, tad-yathā:
There are manifold means, they are:

{1} Sarva-sattvāvabodhakaḥ,
{1} That which understands all beings,

{2} sattvārthābhāvakaḥ,
{2} that which develops the welfare of beings,

{3} kṣipra-sukhābhisambodhiś-ceti.
{3} and that which awakens quickly and pleasantly.

112. Three Kinds of Aspirations

Praṇidhānaṁ tri-vidhaṁ, tad-yathā:

There are three kinds of aspirations, they are:

{1} Susthāna-prābandhikaṁ,
{1} Bound to the beautiful,

{2} sattvārtha-prābandhikaṁ,
{2} bound to the welfare of beings,

{3} Buddha-kṣetra-pariśodhakaṁ ceti.

{3} and purifying the Buddha-field.

113. Three Kinds of Strengths

Balaṁ tri-vidhaṁ, tad-yathā:

37
There are three kinds of strengths, they are:

{1} Karma-vyāvartakaṁ,
{1} Revolution through deeds, ??

{2} kleśopakarṣakaṁ,
{2} the torment of the defilements, ??

{3} māna-pramādādi-vyāvartakaṁ ceti.

{3} and revolution through heedlessness of mind and so on. ??

37
It is not clear how what follows should be translated, or how they can be counted as strengths.
 The Dharma Collection – 83

114. Three Kinds of Knowledge

Jñānaṁ tri-vidhaṁ, tad-yathā:

There are three kinds of knowledge, they are:

{1} Avikalpakaṁ,
{1} Undoubting,

{2} vikalpa-samabhāva-bodhakaṁ,
{2} awakening from the nature of doubt,

{3} satyārthopāya-parokṣaṁ ceti.

{3} and a secret means to truth and welfare.

115. Two Obstructions

Tatrāvaraṇe dve, tad-yathā:

Herein, there are two obstructions, they are:

{1} Kleśāvaraṇaṁ,
{1} The obstruction of defilements,

{2} jñeyāvaraṇaṁ ceti. [29]

{2} and the obstruction of what remains to be known.

116. Two Kinds of Selflessnesses

Nairātmyaṁ dvi-vidham, tad-yathā:

There are two kinds of selflessnesses, they are:

{1} Dharma-nairātmyam,
{1} The selflessness of (all) things,

{2} pudgala-nairātmyaṁ ceti.

{2} and the selflessness of people.

117. Two Kinds of Requisites

Sambhāro dvi-vidhaḥ, tad-yathā:

There are two kinds of requisites, they are:

{1} Puṇya-sambhāro,
{1} The requisite of merit,

{2} jñāna-sambhāraś-ceti.
{2} and the requisite of knowledge.
 The Dharma Collection – 84

118. Six Obstacles to Concentration

Tatra ṣaṭ samādhy-āvaraṇāni, tad-yathā:

Herein, there are six obstacles to concentration, they are:

{1} Kausīdyaṁ,
{1} Indolence,

{2} mānaṁ,
{2} conceit,

{3} śāṭhyam-
{3} deceit,

{4} auddhatyam-
{4} agitation,

{5} anābhogaḥ,
{5} lack of effort,

{6} satyābhogaś-ceti.
{6} and lack of truth.

119. Eight Practices for the Abandoning of Conditions

Tatra pratipatty-āṣṭau prahāṇa-saṁskārāḥ, tad-yathā:

Herein, there are eight practices for the abandoning of conditions, they are:

{1} Śraddhā,
{1} Faith,

{2} buddho,
{2} intelligence,

{3} vyāyāmaḥ,
{3} endeavour,

{4} prasrabdhiḥ,
{4} calm,

{5}
{5} mindfulness,

{6} samprajanyaṁ,
{6} full knowledge,

{7-8} cetanopekṣā,
{7-8} intention and equanimity.
 The Dharma Collection – 85

120. Four Continents

Tatra catvāro dvīpāḥ, tad-yathā:

There are four continents, they are:

{1} Pūrva-videho,
{1} Pūrva-videha (in the east),

{2} Jambu-dvīpo
{2} Jambu-dvīpa (in the centre),

{3} ’paragodānir-
{3} Aparagodānī (in the west),

{4} Uttarakuru-dvīpaś-ceti.
{4} and Uttarakurudvīpa (in the north).

Dharmas 121-140
121. Eight Hot Hells

Aṣṭāv-uṣṇa-narakāḥ, tad-yathā:
There are eight hot hells, they are:

{1} Sañjīvaḥ,
{1} The reviving (hell),

{2} kāla-sūtraḥ,
{2} the black-thread (hell),

{3} saṅghāto,
{3} the crushing (hell),

{4} rauravo,
{4} the hot (hell),

{5} mahā-rauravas-
{5} the great hot (hell),

{6} tapanaḥ,
{6} the remorseful (hell),

{7} pratāpano
{7} the scolding (hell),

{8} ’vīciś-ceti. [30]

{8} and the never-ceasing (hell).
 The Dharma Collection – 86

122. Eight Cold Hells

Aṣṭau śīta-narakāḥ, tad-yathā:

There are eight cold hells, they are:

{1} Arbudo,
{1} The tumourous (hell),

{2} nirarbudo
{2} the very tumourous (hell),

{3} ’ṭaṭo
{3} the squealing (hell),

{4} ’papo,
{4} the running (hell),

{5} hāhādhara,
{5} the grieving (hell),

{6} utpalaḥ,
{6} the blue-lotus (hell),

{7} padmo,
{7} the red-lotus (hell),

{8} mahā-padmaś-ceti.
{8} the great red-lotus (hell).

123. Seven Lower Regions

Sapta pātālāni, tad-yathā:

There are seven lower regions, they are:

{1} Dharaṇi-talo
{1} The plains of the earth,

{2} ’calo
{2} the mountain,

{3} mahācala,
{3} the great mountain,

{4} āpaḥ,
{4} the water (realm),

{5} kāñcanaḥ,
{5} the golden (realm),
 The Dharma Collection – 87

{6} sañjīvo,
{6} the reviving (hell),

{7} narakaś-ceti.
{7} and hell.

124. Two Mountain Ranges

Dvau cakravāḍau, tad-yathā:

There are two mountain ranges, they are:

{1} Cakravāḍa-
{1} The mountain range,

{2} mahā-cakravāḍau ceti.

{2} and the great mountain range.

125. Eight Mountains

Aṣṭāṅga-parvatāḥ, tad-yathā:
There are eight mountains, they are:

{1} Yugaṁdhara,
{1} The Yoke-bearer (mountain),

{2} Īśādharaḥ,
{2} the Bearing of the Supreme (mountain),

{3} Khadirakaḥ,
{3} the Acacia (mountain),

{4} Sudarśano,
{4} the Beautiful (mountain),

{5} Vinatako
{5} the Bending (mountain),

{6} ’śva-karṇo,
{6} the Horse’s Ear (mountain),

{7} Nemiṁdharagiriḥ,
{7} the Wheel-Bearing mountain,

{8} Sumeruś-ceti.
{8} and the Excellent (mountain).
 The Dharma Collection – 88

126. Seven Oceans

Sapta sāgarāḥ, tad-yathā:

There are seven oceans, they are:

{1} Kṣāraḥ,
{1} Salty,

{2} kṣīro,
{2} milky,

{3} dadhy-
{3} coagulated,

{4} udadhir-
{4} watery,

{5}
{5} buttery,

{6} madhuḥ,
{6} sweet,

{7} surā ceti. [31]

{7} and spirituous.

127. Six Gods of the Sensual-Realms

Tatra ṣaṭ kāmāvacarā devāḥ, tad-yathā:

Herein, there are six gods of the sensual-realms, they are:

{1} Cātur-Mahā-rāja-kāyikās-
{1} The group of Four Great Kings,

{2} Trāyas-triṁśās-
{2} the Thirty-Three,

{3} Tuṣitā,
{3} the Contented,

{4} Yāmā,
{4} the Watchful,

{5} Nirmāṇa-ratayaḥ,
{5} those Delighting in Creation,

{6} Paranirmita-vaśavartinaś-ceti.
{6} and those Wielding Power over the Creation of Others.
 The Dharma Collection – 89

128. Eighteen Gods of the Form-Realms

Aṣṭādaśa rūpāvacarā devāḥ, tad-yathā:

There are eighteen gods of the form-realms, they are:

{1} Brahma-kāyikā,
{1} The Brahma group,

{2} Brahma-purohitā,
{2} the Ministers of Brahmā,

{3} Brahma-pārṣadyā,
{3} Brahmā’s Retinue,

{4} Mahā-brahmāṇaḥ,
{4} Great Brahmās,

{5} Parīttābhā,
{5} Limited Radiance,

{6} Apramāṇābhā,
{6} Unbounded Radiance,

{7} Ābhāsvarāḥ,
{7} Streaming Radiance,

{8} Parītta-śubhāḥ,
{8} Limited Beauty,

{9} Śubha-
{9} Refulgent Beauty,

{10} Anabhrakāḥ,
{10} Cloudless,

{11} Puṇya-prasavā,
{11} the Fruit of Merit,

{12} -phalā,
{12} Great Fruit,

{13} Asañjñi-sattvā,
{13} Unconscious Beings.

{14}
{14} Steadfast,
 The Dharma Collection – 90

{15} Atapāḥ,
{15} Untroubled,

{16}
{16} Beautiful,

{17} Sudarśanā,
{17} Clear-sighted,

{18} Akaniṣṭhāś-ceti.
{18} and the Highest.

129. Four Gods of the Formless-Realms

Catvāro ’rūpāvacarā devāḥ,

There are four gods of the formless-realms, they are:

{1} Ākāśānanty-āyatanopagā,
{1} Belonging to the sphere of infinite space,

{2} Vijñānānanty-āyatanopagā,
{2} belonging to the sphere of infinite consciousness,

{3} Ākiñcany-āyatanopagā,
{3} belonging to the sphere of nothingness,

{4} Naiva-saṁjñā-nāsaṁjñāyatanopagāś-ceti.
{4} and belonging to the sphere of neither-perception-nor-non-perception.

130. Three Kinds of Transgressions

Tri-vidhā ālaṅghanāḥ, tad-yathā:

There are three kinds of transgressions, they are:

{1} Satyālaṅghanā,
{1} Transgressing the truth,

{2} dharmālaṅghanā-
{2} transgressing the dharma,

{3} ’nālaṅghanā ceti.

{3} and non-transgression.
 The Dharma Collection – 91

131. Three Kinds of Great Friendliness

Tri-vidhā mahāmaitrī, tad-yathā:

There are three kinds of great friendliness, they are:

{1} Satyālambanā,
{1} Grounded in truth,

{2} dharmālambanā,
{2} grounded in dharma,

{3} anālambanā ceti.38 [32]

{3} and without ground.

132. Three Kinds of Deeds

Tri-vidhaṁ karma, tad-yathā:

There are three kinds of deeds, they are:

{1} -dharma-vedanīyam-
{1} To be experienced in this very life,

{2} utpadya-vedanīyam-
{2} to be experienced in (the next) rebirth,

{3} apara-vedanīyaṁ ceti.

{3} and to be experienced later.

133. Three Kinds of Miracles

Tri-vidhaṁ prātihāryaṁ, tad-yathā:

There are three kinds of miracles, they are:

{1} -prātihāryam-
{1} The miracle of spiritual power,

{2} ādeśanā-prātihāryam-
{2} the miracle of mind-reading,

{3} anuśāsanī-prātihāryaṁ ceti.

{3} and the miracle of instruction.

38
Text: Satyālaṅghanā, dharmālaṅghanānālaṅghanā ceti, which makes no sense. Amended
following Vaidya. Edgerton surprisingly doesn’t comment.
 The Dharma Collection – 92

134. Eight Inopportune Births

Aṣṭāv-akṣaṇāḥ, tad-yathā:
There are eight inopportune births, they are:

{1} Narakopapattis-
{1} Rebirth in hell,

{2} tiryag-upapattir-
{2} rebirth in the animal kingdom,

{3} Yama-lokopapattiḥ,
{3} rebirth in Yama’s world,

{4} pratyanta-janapadopapattir-
{4} rebirth in the border regions,

{5} dīrghāyuṣa-devopapattir-
{5} rebirth amongst the gods of long life,

{6} indriya-vikalatā,
{6} (rebirth) with impaired faculties,

{7} mithyā- -
{7} (rebirth) with wrong view,

{8} cittotpādarāgitatā ceti.

{8} and (rebirth) with a mind intent on passion.

135. Three Kinds of Discrimination

Tri-vidhā vikalpāḥ, tad-yathā:

There are three kinds of discrimination, they are:

{1} Anusmaraṇa-vikalpaḥ,
{1} Discrimination through recollection,

{2} saṁtīrana-vikalpaḥ,
{2} discrimination through investigation,

{3} sahaja-vikalpaś-ceti.
{3} and innate discrimination.
 The Dharma Collection – 93

136. Four Concentrations

Catvāraḥ samādhayaḥ, tad-yathā:

There are four concentrations, they are:

{1} Śūraṅgamo,
{1} Heroic march,

{2} gagaṇa-gañjo,
{2} sky-jewel,

{3} vimala-prabhaḥ,
{3} pure light,

{4} siṁha-vikrīḍitaś-ceti.
{4} and lion’s sport.

137. Fourteen Unanswered Things

Catur- -vastūni, tad-yathā:

There are fourteen unanswered things, they are:

{1} Śāśvato loko

{1} The world is eternal,

{2} ’śāśvato lokaḥ,

{2} the world is not eternal,

{3} śāśvataś-cāśāśvataś-ca, [33]

{3} it is eternal and not eternal,

{4} naiva śāśvato nāśāśvataś-ca,

{4} it is neither eternal nor not eternal,

{5} antavāṁlloko
{5} the world has an end,

{6} ’nantavāṁlloko
{6} the world has no end,

{7} ’ntavāṁś-cānantavāṁllokaś-ca,
{7} the world has an end and no end,

{8} naivāntavānnānantavāṁś-ca,
{8} the world neither has an end nor no end,

{9} bhavati Tathāgataḥ paraṁ maraṇāc-ca,

{9} the Realised One exists after death,
 The Dharma Collection – 94

{10} na bhavati Tathāgataḥ paraṁ maraṇāc-ca,

{10} the Realised One does not exist after death,

{11} bhavati na ca bhavati ca Tathāgataḥ paraṁ maraṇāt-

{11} the Realised One both exists and does not exist after death,

{12} naiva bhavati na na bhavati Tathāgataḥ paraṁ maraṇāt,

{12} the Realised One neither exists nor does not exist after death,

{13} sa jīvastac-charīram-
{13} that which is soul, that is (also) the body,

{14} anyo jīvo ’nyac-charīraṁ ceti.

{14} and the soul is one thing, the body is another thing.

138. Three Roots of Wholesomeness

Trīṇi kuśala-mūlāni, tad-yathā:

There are three roots of wholesomeness, they are:

{1} Adveṣo
{1} Lack of hatred,

{2} ’lobho
{2} lack of greed,

{3} ’mohaś-ceti.
{3} and lack of delusion.

139. Three Roots of Unwholesomeness

Etad-viparyayān-trīṇy-akuśala-mūlāni, tad-yathā:
Contrary to this, there are three roots of unwholesomeness, they are:

{1} Lobho,
{1} Greed,

{2} moho,
{2} delusion,

{3} dveṣaś-ceti.
{3} and hatred.39

39
Note how the order is different from the immediately preceding list.
 The Dharma Collection – 95

140. Three Trainings

Tisraḥ śikṣāḥ, tad-yathā:

There are three trainings, they are:

{1} Adhicitta-śikṣā-
{1} Training in the higher mind,

{2} ’dhiśīla-śikṣā-
{2} training in the higher virtue,

{3} ’dhiprajñā-śikṣā ceti.

{3} and training in the higher wisdom.

Iti Nāgārjuna-pāda-viracito ’yaṁ Dharma-Saṅgrahaḥ Samāptaḥ

Thus this Dharma Collection written by Nāgārjuna is Complete

Śubham-astu Sarvadā!
May you always be Happy!