Ibn Khaldûn Journal of Innovation and Development Vol.(3) No.
(2) (0202)
Integration between rational approach and intuitive approach in strategic
decision making: an theoretical approach
[email protected]
2021 10 15 2021 09 28 2021 09 20
Simon Mintzberg
Abstract:
The aim of this research is to gather, present, and discuss the opinions, ideas and results of
some researchers who aim to contribute to the proposal of an integrative model between
rational approach and intuitive approach in strategic decision making, focusing on the
research work of Mintzberg and Simon. Determining how a manager can make a strategic
decision is a process that is still not fully understood. There is still a relatively large gap
between the rational approach that sees strategic decision making as a logical-analytical
procedure based on a series of introductions that leads to results and is viewed as a process
based on personal judgment based on intuitive approach
Keywords: Rational approach, Intuitive approach, Strategic decision, manager.
Mintzberg
(Mintzberg, H., al., 1976)
Vasconcelos
orthodoxe
hétérodoxe
(VASCONCELOS,
2009):
2
hétérodoxe orthodoxe
Barnard, 1938 Barnard, 1938
Epstein, 1994 Simon, 1987
Shapiro Spence 1997
Carlson Kaiser, 1999 Russo Shoemaker 1993
non-linear Miller Burke 1999
intelligence
Shakun, 2001
(VASCONCELOS, 2009):
.
Preston Hayward .
05 Nutt
Mintzberg Langley Zbaracki Eisenhardt
(Sinclair, Ashkanasy,
2005)
Delaney
(Delaney, al., 2014).
Mikels
.(Kaylene, 2012)
Tichá
Kleinmuntz Quinn (Ticha, al., 2010)
(Khatri., Ng, 2000)
Pratt Dane
(Liebowitz, 2015)
Vasconcelos
(VASCONCELOS, A., F., 2009)
Miller Burke Isenberg
Ng Khatri
(Khatri., Ng, 2000)
Tichá
(Ticha, al., 2010)
41 4891 Isenberg
(Isenber, 1984)
Kaylene
.(Kaylene, 2012)
Alas
)(Alas, al., 2010
Valenzi Taggart 0
(ػام) ) هتخصص(
كيف يتم حل المشكلت؟
تحليل
استكشاف تظىس تحليل
نوورج تنظين
تلخيص هرالبة
( ) كيف يتم تحضيش المستقبل ؟ ) تطوير التراحات(
تخطيظ
تخيل سؤيت التراح
تولغ تنبؤ
إبذاع تصوين
) التركيز ػلى اإلجراءات(
)التركيز ػلى الفرد( ما المنهج الزي يتم إتباعه؟
مشاقبت
هشاركة توافك
تقسيم
تؼاوى اهتالن
لسن هنغ
المظذسTaggart, William., Valenzi, Enzo. (1990). :
Valenzi Taggart
Horstmann
)(Horstmann, al., 2009
Meyer De Wit
)(Henden, 2004, p. 97
2
تذابير
الخظائ
ص
الشخظي
السياق ة
المرار
Sinclair, Marta., Ashkanasy, Neal M. (2005).
Ashkanasy Sinclair
0
النتائج إهكانية الوؼالجة الؼمالنية خظائض النشاط
العقالنيت
المحذودة
فائذة
فعاليت
المعشفت
اتخار القشاس
طذق
الحذس
ALLARD, C.R., et al. (2003):
Simon Mintzberg 0
Simon
Mintzberg
Mintzberg .2 0
Mintzberg
Mintzberg
Simon
Mintzberg, Henry.(2013) Simply Managing. California : Berrett-Koehler Publishers, Inc..
Mintzberg, Henry. (2009) Managing. California Barrett Koehler Publishers. Inc.
Mintzberg, Henry. (2005) Des managers des vrais Pas des MBA. Paris : Edition d’organisation.
Mintzberg Simon
Roger Sperry
Mintzberg (Mintzberg, 2004, p. 313)
(Mintzberg, 2007, p.
Mintzberg 107.)
Mintzberg
(Ashley, 2001)
Mintzberg
Mintzberg
Chester (Campbell, 1991)
4899 Bernard
9 (Dammak, 2004)
Mintzberg
3
Mintzberg
وظائف
Hémisphère droit
وظائف
Hémisphère
gauche
المدخل التحليلي الخبرة
تنفيز القشاس
Simon
Eisenhardt Zbaracki
(Eisenhardt., Zbaracki, 1992)
Simon 00
Simon
.
(Simon,
1987)
Patton
Simon
(Patton, 2003)
Mintzberg Simon
Simon
1
9
Simon
Mintzberg
Simon
4
Simon
المدخل التحليلي
الخبرة
تنفيز القشاس
Mintzberg
Miller Burke
8410 4888
1550 Gladwell
(Rory., Philomena, 2007)
Miller Burke
.(Burke., Miller,1999)
1550 Ogilvie Hough
(Hough., Ogilvie, 2005)
1544 La Pira
(La Pira, 2011)
De Vries
(De Vries, M., et al. 2012)
(De Vries, M., et al. 2012)
Hogarth
(Hogarth, 2002)
(Lebraty, 2007)
Glass
(Glass, 2008)
Simon
Mintzberg
Simon
Mintzberg
1. ALLARD, C.R., et al.(2003) Effectiveness and Scope of Decision Making Styles.
In: VAN, Riel., ALLARD, C.R, Effective Decision Making in the High Tech Service
Innovation Process, Doctoral Dissertation, Maastricht University, Maastricht
University Press, 20031
2. Ashley, Floyd Fields.(2001). A study of intuition in decision-making using
organization engineeering methodology. A dissertation of doctor of business
administration, Nova Southeastern University.
3. Burke, L.A., Miller, M.K. (1999). Taking the mystery out of intuitive decision
making. Academy of Management Executive, (Vol.13), No.4, pp. 91-99.
4. Campbell, A.(1991). Brief Case: Strategy and Intuition - A Conversation with
Henry Mintzberg. Long Range Plan-ning, (Vol.24), No.2, pp.108-110.
5. Dammak, Ahmed. (2004).Le recours à l’intuition lors de la prise de décision et
l’influence de l’environnement socio-culturel. Le management face à
l’environnement socio-culturel. In : Colloque CIDEGEF-CEMADIMO, Université St
Joseph ; Beyrouth, pp.1-20.
6. De Vries, M., et al. (2012). Combining deliberation and intuition in patient
decision support. Patient Educ Couns, pp. 1-7. Format PDF. Disponible sur :
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.pec.2012.11.016 (consulté le 12 Juin 2015)
7. Delaney, Deborah., Guiding, Chris., Mcmanus, Lisa.(2014). The use of intuition in
the sponsorship decision-making process. Contemporary Management Research,
(Vol. 10), No. 1, pp. 33-60.
8. EISENHARDT, Kathleen., ZBARACKI, Mark.(1992). Strategic Decision Making.
Strategic Management Journal, (Vol. 13), pp. 17-37.
9. Glass, R. L. (2008).Intuition’s role in decision making. IEEE Computer Society,
(Vol. 25), Iss.96, s.p.
10. Hogarth, Robin M. (2002). Deciding analytically or trusting your intuition? The
advantages and disadvantages of analytic and intuitive thought. UPF Economics
and Business Working Paper, No. 654 . Available at SSRN:
http://ssrn.com/abstract=394920
11. Hough, Jill R ., Ogilvie, Dt. (2005). An empirical test of cognitive style and
strategic decision outcomes. Journal of Management Studies, (Vol. 42), Issue 2, pp.
417–448.
12. Isenber, Daniel J. (1984)1 How Senior Managers Think. Harvard business review,
(Vol.62), No.6, pp. 81-90.
13. Kaylene C., Williams. (2012). Business Intuition: The Mortar among the Bricks of
Analysis. Journal of Management Policy and Practice, (Vol. 13), No.5, pp. 48-65.
14. Khatri, N., Ng, H.A.(2000). The role of intuition in strategic decision making,
Human Relations, (Vol.1), No.53, pp.57-86.
15. La Pira, Frank.(2011). Entrepreneurial intuition, an empirical approach. Journal of
Management and Marketing Research, (Vol.6), pp. 1-22.
16. Lebraty, Jean-Fabrice. (2007). Décision et Intuition : un état des lieux,Format PDF.
Disponible sur : https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00264342/document (consulté
le 12 Juin 2015)
17. Liebowitz, Jay. (2015).Intuition-based decision-making: The other side of
analytics, pp. 1-8.
18. Mintzberg, H., Rasinghani. D., Thearet, A. (1976)1 The structure of unstructured
decision processes. Administration Science Quarterly, 1976, Vol. 21, No.2, p.246-275
19. Mintzberg, Henry. (2005) Des managers des vrais Pas des MBA. Paris : Edition
d’organisation.
20. Mintzberg, Henry. (2007). Le mangement, voyage au centre des organisations.
(2ème Ed). Paris : Edition d’organisation.
21. Mintzberg, Henry. (2009) 1Managing. California Barrett Koehler Publishers. Inc.
22. Mintzberg, Henry.(2013)1 Simply Managing. California : Berrett-Koehler Publishers,
Inc.
23. Patton, J R.(2003). Intuition in decisions. Management Decision, (Vol. 41), Iss. 10,
pp. 989-996.
24. Rory, Martin., Philomena, Hanlon. (2007). An examination of the role of intuition
in individual decision making in organizations. In: 10th Annual Conference of the
Irish Academy of Management, Queens University, Belfast 3rd – 5th September, pp.1-
34.
25. Simon, H.A.(1987). Making management decisions: The role of intuition and
emotion. Academy of Management Executive,(Vol.1), Issue.1, pp.57-64.
26. Sinclair, Marta., Ashkanasy, Neal M. (2005). Intuition: Myth or a Decision-Making
Tool? Management Learning , (Vol.36), No.3, pp. 353–370.
27. Taggart, William., Valenzi, Enzo. (1990). Assessing rational and intuitive styles: a
human information processing metaphor, Journal of Management Studies,
(Vol.27), No.2, pp. 151-172.
28. Ticha, Ivana., Hron, Jan., Fiedler, Jiří.(2010) Managerial decision making –
importance of intuition in the rational process. Agric. Econ. – Czech, (Vol.56),
No.12, pp. 553–557.
29. Vasconcelos, Anselmo Ferreira.(2009)1 Intuition, prayer, and managerial decision-
making processes: a religion-based framework. Management Decision, (Vol. 47),
No. 6, pp. 930-949.
