Road Pavement
Road Pavement
MODULO 2:
Urban road mobility design and maintenance
Road pavement
1. ROAD SECTIONs
2. SUBGRADE: materials, design parameters and tests
3. FOUNDATION or SUB-BASE: materials and tests
4. BASE LAYER: traditional materials and tests
5. BINDER LAYER: traditional materials and tests
6. SURFACE LAYER: traditional materials and tests
2
Road pavements: an overview
A road section is formed by overlapping layers, needed to spread the traffic
loads into the subgrade.
3
Road pavements: an overview
TELFORD ROAD STRUCTURE (1700s)
4
Functions of a road section
• BEARING CAPACITY
• SKID RESISTANCE
• ROUGHNESS OF THE PAVEMENT SURFACE
• DRAINABILITY
• VISIBILITY FOR THE DRIVER
EDGE CARRIAGEWAY EDGE
DITCH DITCH
From the 50s, new materials and design criteria have been developed to ensure
suitable travel and security standards to drivers. Today it is possible to project
the road section according to the weather, subgrade, traffic and surrounding
landscape conditions.
5
Road section classification
Basically, all hard surfaced pavement types can be categorized into two main
groups: flexible and rigid. The main differences between the two groups are
related to:
• Number of layers;
• Materials;
• Thickness;
• Distribution of loads over the subgrade.
6
Road section classification
• FLEXIBLE;
• SEMI-FLEXIBLE;
• RIGID;
• SEMI-RIGID;
• MODULAR PAVEMENTS.
7
FLEXIBLE ROAD SECTION
Flexible pavements are surfaced with bituminous materials. These can be
either in the form of pavement surface treatments or asphalt mixtures. These
pavements are called “flexible” since the total pavement structure “bends” or
“deflects” due to traffic loads.
8
FLEXIBLE ROAD SECTION
PROs:
• Stress reduction in the lower layers;
• Lack of joints;
• Rapid completion and re-opening of areas to
traffic;
• Roughness and high skid resistance.
CONs:
• Limited resistance to permanent deformations;
• Visual impact;
• Costs (?).
9
RIGID ROAD SECTION
10
RIGID ROAD SECTION
PROs:
• High mechanical performances;
• High resistance to permanent
deformations;
• Low visual impact.
CONs:
• Time for constructions;
• Presence of joints (roughness and
comfort for the driver);
• Costs and time for maintenance.
11
SEMI-RIGID ROAD SECTION
The semi-rigid road section is a mix between a flexible pavement (upper
layers) and a rigid section (bottom layers). It is generally designed for high-
traffic areas.
12
SEMI-RIGID ROAD SECTION
PROs:
• High resistance to loads;
• Increased fatigue resistance;
• Smoothness and high skid resistance.
CONs:
• Excessive stiffness of the base layer
(development of cracking);
• Visual impact;
• Costs (?).
13
SEMI-FLEXIBLE ROAD SECTION
14
SEMI-FLEXIBLE ROAD SECTION
PROs:
• High resistance to heavy loads and
shear stresses;
• Increased fatigue resistance;
• Possibility of surface treatments;
• Rapid re-opening to traffic (compared to
rigid pavement).
CONs:
• Time for construction (compared to semi-
rigid pavements);
• Costs (?).
15
MODULAR ROAD SECTION
Modular pavements are used in urban areas for special lanes, walking
paths or parking or pedestrian areas.
16
MODULAR ROAD SECTION
PROs:
• Visual impact;
• Easy maintenance;
• Possibility of create porous surfaces.
CONs:
• Smoothness;
• Structure not suitable for heavy traffic
or loads.
17
SUBGRADE (Existing soil)
The subgrade must be able to support the loads transmitted from the pavement structure. The
bearing capacity is often affected by the level of compaction, moisture content, and soil
type. The soil can be tested and classified according to the UNI EN ISO 14688 (particle size
distribution and Atterberg limits).
The Italian standard UNI EN 11532 indicates the type of construction or layer in which the existing
soil can be used, according to its classification.
18
SUBGRADE (Existing soil)
GRANULOMETRIC CURVE (UNI EN 933-1,2)
CLAY
Argilla LIME
Limo SAND
Sabbia GRAVEL
Ghiaia
100
90
80
in peso, p (%)
70
PASSING
60
50
GRAVEL d > 2mm
passante
0.002mm
20
CLAY d < 0.002mm
10
0
0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1 10 100
DIAMETER OFdiametro,
SIEVEd (mm)
19
SUBGRADE (Existing soil)
PROCTOR TEST (UNI EN 13286 – 2)
secco
Ɣ max
wopt w%
20
SUBGRADE (Existing soil)
Laboratory tests are available to characterize the mechanical parameters of the
subgrade soils including the Resistance value (R-value), California Bearing Ratio
(CBR), and repeated load triaxial tests.
21
SUBGRADE (Existing soil)
22
SUBGRADE – Best Practice
PLATE LOAD TEST
p
Md D
w
Con:
DINAMIC TEST
D = plate diameter;
p = load increase= 0.1 MPa;
w = corresponding settlement increment
Md = Deformation moduli.
23
SUBGRADE – Best Practice
If the soil does not have suitable properties, it can be replaced, mixed with
aggregates and/or binders (cement, lime…), injected whit different mixtures
(cementitious, resinous or chemical).
24
SUBGRADE – Best Practice
25
SUBGRADE – Soil stabilization
The soil stabilization is the alteration of soil to enhance its physical and
mechanical properties (increase the shear strength, control the shrink-
swell properties), improving its bearing capacity.
The stabilization is generally accomplished using lime and/or and
Portland cement, depending on the properties of the soil (plasticity, pH…).
The mix design and lab tests are fundamental in any stabilization project.
The stabilization can be performed in situ or in traditional cement concrete plants.
26
SUBGRADE – Soil stabilization
IN SITU SOIL STABILIZATION
1st MIXING
2nd MIXING
3rd MIXING
1 2 3 3
1. Soil preparation;
2. Lime or cement laying;
3. Mixing with cold recycling machine
(pulvimixer);
4. Soil compaction (sheepfoot drum + 5 4
smooth wheeled/rubber tired roller);
5. Soil protection (foundation or upper layer).
The evaluation of the moisture content is important during the whole process!
27
FOUNDATION or SUB-BASE layer
28
FOUNDATION or SUB-BASE layer
The layer is generally constituted by aggregates (natural and/or
recycled) that must be assorted according to a proper particles size
distribution (max size 63 mm). The mixture is carried to the yard, laid
with a grader and compacted by rollers.
Foundation layer gradation band
100
90
80
Passing material [%]
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
0,01 0,1 1 10 100
Sieve dimension [mm]
29
FOUNDATION or SUB-BASE layer
CEMENT or HIDRAULICALLY BOUND MIXTURE (CBM)
The mix design and lab tests are fundamental for the achievement of specific
performances.
The CBMs can be produced in situ or in traditional cement concrete plants where the
aggregates are mixed with cement (2 – 4 % by aggregates weight) and the obtained
mixture is laid down with the asphalt paver machine.
If compared to an unbound crushed aggregates layer for foundation, the CBM layer can be
reduced in thickness and the maximum aggregate size is 31 mm.
CBM gradation band
100
90
80
Passing material [%]
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
0,01 0,1 1 10 100
Sieve dimension [mm]
30
FOUNDATION or SUB-BASE layer
CEMENT or HIDRAULICALLY BOUND MIXTURE (CBM)
1. Laboratory characterization and mix design:
• Grading distribution;
• Optimum water content (Proctor method);
• Amount of cement (2-4 % by aggregates weight);
• Mechanical tests on samples (Rc > 2.5 MPa, Rt> 0.30 MPa);
1
2. In plant production;
3. Laying with asphalt paver or grader;
2 3 4. Compaction with roller (smooth
wheeled roller and/or rubber tyred
roller);
5. Protection with specific bitumen
emulsion.
4 5
31
BASE layer
The base course is immediately beneath the surface course. It provides for additional load
distribution and contributes to waterproof the foundation layer.
According to the design requirement, different materials can be suitable for the layer:
• Asphalt Concrete;
• Cold Mix Asphalt (recycled in situ or in plant);
• Cement Bound Mixture;
AC and CBM can be coupled for a double base layer in case of a semi-rigid road section.
32
BASE layer
Asphalt Concrete
An AC is a mixture produced with:
• Selected aggregates;
• Filler;
• Bitumen;
• Additives (if needed).
Depending on the desired final performance of the mixture and the design
requirements, the following variables can be affected:
• Type of aggregates, particles size distribution and amount of filler;
• Type of bitumen (neat or modified) and dosage;
• Additives (chemical additives, fibers, rejuvenators, waxes…).
33
BASE layer
Asphalt Concrete for Base layer: traditional Mix Design and Requirements
• Aggregate max size: 31.5 mm;
• Amount of filler: 2-4 %;
• Type of bitumen: neat bitumen 50-70 pen;
• Amount of bitumen: > 4 % on the weight of aggregates;
• Additives: rejuvenator if RAP is added, adhesion promoter.
AC BASE LAYER gradation band
100
90
80
Passing material [%]
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
0,01 0,1 1 10
Sieve dimension [mm]
34
BASE layer
Asphalt Concrete for Base layer: Traditional Mechanical properties:
•Air voids content @ Ndes: 4-8 %
•ITS @ 25 °C: 0.80 - 1.40 MPa
•ITSM @ 20 °C: > 3000 MPa
35
BASE layer
INDIRECT TENSIL TEST ITS (UNI EN 12697- 23)
36
BASE layer
INDIRECT TENSILE STIFFNESS MODULUS ITSM (UNI EN 12697- 26)
e e Orizontal
deformation (mm)
Thickness (mm)
Carico, F
v
h
D= diametro
g th
len
l=
37
BASE layer
Cold Mix Asphalt
The Cold Mix Asphalt (CMA) is traditionally classified as a sustainable technology considering the
possibility of recycling the old AC from the existing pavement (Reclaimed Asphalt Pavement, RAP).
The mixture is formed by:
• RAP up to 100 % on the weight of aggregates;
• Modified bitumen emulsion (3 - 5 % by the weight of aggregate);
• Cement (2 - 3 % by the weight of aggregate).
38
BASE layer
Cold Mix Asphalt in situ
When cold recycling in-situ, a cold recycler granulates the existing pavement material while
homogeneously mixing in binding agents and water at the same time. This method produces
a new construction material mix in just one single machine pass. Cold recyclers are
equipped with powerful milling and mixing rotors and with highly efficient injection systems.
Some machine models are additionally fitted with paving screeds for placing and pre-
compacting the new material mix. This method produces base layers of high bearing capacity.
39
BASE layer
Cold Mix Asphalt in situ
40
BASE layer
Cold Mix Asphalt in situ
3.
The grader can be equipped with GPS in The rollers can be vibratory (in order to speed
order to obtain the desired slopes and height up the bitumen emulsion “breaking”) and
pneumatic tired to improve the compaction.
41
BASE layer
ADVANTAGES:
• Recycling;
• Save virgin material;
• Reduction in energy consumption;
• No fumes and emissions.
42
BASE layer
Cold Mix Asphalt
• The amount of modified bitumen emulsion and cement must be defined on the basis lab tests:
• Optimum water content (Proctor test);
• Compaction of samples with different amount of bitumen emulsion and cement;
• Physical (Density) and mechanical tests (Compressive Strength, Indirect Tensile
Strength and Indirect Tensile Stiffness Modulus).
43
BASE layer
Cold recycling with foamed bitumen
The recycling technology with foamed bitumen is considered cold because the aggregates
don’t need to be heated.
Foamed bitumen is produced by injecting small quantities of water and air into hot
bitumen under high pressure. The water evaporates and makes the bitumen foam up
rapidly to between 15 and 20 times its original volume. The foam is then injected into a
mixer through injection nozzles and mixed with cold aggregates.
Hot Bitumen
(160-180 °C)
Water (5 bar)
Expansion chamber
44
BASE layer
Cold recycling with foamed bitumen
Water tank
Hot bitumen
Vibrating steel
Cold Recycler wheel roller
45
BASE layer
Cold recycling with foamed bitumen
ADVANTAGES:
• High mechanical properties of the final material;
• Lower moisture contents are required in comparison to bitumen emulsion stabilization and hence wet
spots are minimized;
• after construction, the pavement can tolerate heavy rainfall and hence is less susceptible to the effects
of weather than other methods of stabilization;
LIMITS:
• The mix design need to be carefully studied;
• Specific machines are needed to reproduce the technology in lab.
• The bitumen is hot, so the technology is less eco-friendly if compared to cold recycling with bitumen
emulsion.
46
BINDER layer
The binder course is the layer directly below the surface course and it generally
consists of AC. This layer provides the bulk of the AC structure. Its chief
purpose is to distribute load.
According to the type of AC mixture, its thickness can range between 6 and 11
cm.
47
BINDER layer
48
BINDER layer
Asphalt Concrete for Binder layer: traditional Mix Design and Requirements
• Aggregate max size: 20 mm;
• Amount of filler: 4-5 %;
• Type of bitumen: neat bitumen 50-70 pen or Hard PmB 45-80 pen;
• Amount of bitumen: > 4.8 % on the weight of aggregates;
• Additives: rejuvenator if RAP is added, adhesion promoter.
AC BINDER LAYER gradation band
100
90
80
Passing material [%]
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
0,01 0,1 1 10
Sieve dimension [mm]
49
BINDER layer
Asphalt Concrete for Binder layer: Traditional Mechanical properties:
•Air voids content @ Ndes: 3-6 %
•ITS @ 25 °C: 0.95 - 1.50 MPa
•ITSM @ 20 °C: > 3500 MPa
50
SPECIAL BINDER layer
High Modulus Binder layer
51
SPECIAL BINDER layer
HM AC Mix Design and Requirements
• Aggregate max size: 20 mm;
• Amount of filler: 5 %;
• Type of bitumen: Hard PmB 45-80 pen (Polymer Modified Bitumen);
• Amount of bitumen: > 4.5 % on the weight of aggregates;
• Additives: waxes, adhesion promoter.
HM AC BINDER LAYER gradation band
100
90
80
Passing material [%]
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
0,01 0,1 1 10
Sieve dimension [mm]
52
SPECIAL BINDER layer
53
MODIFIED BITUMEN
Why to modify the neat binder?
Thermal cracking Fatigue Rutting Workability
Neat bitumen
Shear Modulus, G*
Ideal
bitumen
54
MODIFIED BITUMEN
Polymer Modified Bitumen (PmB)
ADVANTAGES:
• Improve the rheological properties of the original neat bitumen;
• Improve the final performances of the AC.
LIMITI:
• Cost of the final product (according to the type of modification);
• Limitation for small plant productions;
• Environmental and energetic costs for the production.
Production temperature
between 180 and 200°C
55
MODIFIED Asphalt Concrete
Modified AC
The modification of ACs with polymer is today the most suitable alternative to the
use of modified bitumen. The polymer compound and/or additives are added
directly in the mixer, using a traditional neat bitumen.
Polymer
Neat bitumen
56
MODIFIED Asphalt Concrete
Polymer modified Asphalt (PmA)
ADVANTAGES:
• Improve the final performance of the AC;
• Relatively cheap;
• Possibility of tailoring the AC properties according to the design needs;
• Suitable for small productions;
• Possibility of use waste materials as additives (crumb rubber, etc.);
• Low environmental and energetic consumptions if compared to PmB production.
DOWNSIDES:
• Relatively new technology;
• Lack of reference in the Technical specifications (…on going);
• A4 Motorway;
• A7 Motorway;
• Roma municipality;
• Bologna municipality;
• ….
57
SURFACE layer
The surface course is the layer in contact with traffic loads and normally
contains the highest quality materials. It provides:
• Friction and skid resistance;
• Roughness;
• Noise control;
• Rutting and raveling resistance;
• Drainage and waterproof the bottom layers.
58
SURFACE layer
59
SURFACE layer
Asphalt Concrete for Surface layer: traditional Mix Design and Requirements
• Aggregate max size: 12.5 mm;
• Amount of filler: 5-6 %;
• Type of bitumen: Hard PmB 45-80 pen (Polymer Modified Bitumen);
• Amount of bitumen: > 5.0 % on the weight of aggregates;
• Additives: rejuvenator (RAP), waxes, adhesion promoter.
AC SURFACE LAYER gradation band
100
90
80
Passing material [%]
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
0,01 0,1 1 10
Sieve dimension [mm]
60
SURFACE layer
61
SPECIAL SURFACE layers
62
SPECIAL SURFACE layers
The particles size distribution, the type and amount of bitumen and
additives dramatically affect the final performance of the AC.
63
SPECIAL SURFACE layers
Splittmastix Asphalt (SMA)
SMA features:
• High skid resistance and drainability;
• Gap graded particles distribution;
• Selected high quality aggregates
(Basalt or Porphyry);
• High fatigue and rutting resistance;
• Bituminous mastic rich in bitumen.
64
SPECIAL SURFACE layers
SMA traditional Mix Design and Requirements
• Aggregate max size: 12.5 mm;
• Amount of filler: 6-7 %;
• Type of bitumen: Hard PmB 45-80 pen (Polymer Modified Bitumen);
• Amount of bitumen: > 6.0 % on the weight of aggregates;
• Additives: waxes, adhesion promoter, fibers.
SMA gradation band
100
90
80
Passing material [%]
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
0,01 0,1 1 10
Sieve dimension [mm]
65
SPECIAL SURFACE layers
SMA Traditional Mechanical properties:
•Air voids content @ Ndes: 4-8 %
•ITS @ 25 °C: 0.90 - 1.30 MPa
•ITSM @ 20 °C: > 4000 MPa
66
SPECIAL SURFACE layers
SMA properties, advantages and issue:
67
SPECIAL SURFACE layers
SMA properties, advantages and issue:
The high dosage of modified bitumen, filler and the quality of aggregates
make the mixture expensive if compared to traditional ACs. However, the higher
initial cost must be balanced with the lower maintenance needed.
68
SPECIAL SURFACE layers
Porous Asphalt (PA) concrete
69
SPECIAL SURFACE layers
Porous Asphalt (PA) concrete
PA
PA layer layer
The drainage system allow the water flowing through the thickness of the
layer. In traditional ACs for surface layers the water moves to the edge of the
road by the pavement slope.
70
SPECIAL SURFACE layers
PA properties, advantage and issues:
• High drainability;
• Open graded particles distribution;
• Good acoustic properties;
• Fibers to avoid bitumen draindown;
• Relatively low mechanical properties.
71
SPECIAL SURFACE layers
PA properties, advantage and issues:
The mixture is not suitable for urban and low traffic roads considering the
possibility of voids clogging.
72
SPECIAL SURFACE layers
PA traditional Mix Design and Requirements
• Aggregate max size: 14 mm;
• Amount of filler: 5 %;
• Type of bitumen: Hard PmB 45-80 pen (Polymer Modified Bitumen);
• Amount of bitumen: > 5.0 % on the weight of aggregates;
• Additives: waxes, adhesion promoter, fibers.
PA gradation band
100
90
Passing material [%]
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
0,01 0,1 1 10
Sieve dimension [mm]
73
SPECIAL SURFACE layers
PA Traditional Mechanical properties:
•Air voids content @ Ndes: ≥ 20 %
•ITS @ 25 °C: 0.35 – 0.90 MPa
•Vertical drainability: > 1 ·10-3m/s
74
SPECIAL SURFACE layers
Grouted Macadam
The Grouted Macadam (GM) is an hybrid surface asphalt mixture for semi-
flexible pavement. The final material is a open-graded asphalt mixture which is
grouted with a specific cementitious slurry.
75
SPECIAL SURFACE layers
GM Mix Design and Requirements
• Aggregate max size: 14 mm;
• Amount of filler: 4 %;
• Type of bitumen: PmB;
• Amount of bitumen: > 4.5 % on the weight of aggregates;
• Additives: waxes, adhesion promoter, fibers, GROUTING MORTAR.
GM gradation band
100
90
80
Passing material [%]
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
0,01 0,1 1 10
Sieve dimension [mm]
76
SPECIAL SURFACE layers
GM Traditional Mechanical properties:
•Air voids content before grouting @ Ndes: ≥ 20 %
•ITS @ 25 °C > 0.9 MPa
•ITSM @ 20°C: 10.000 MPa
77
SURFACE layer for Rigid Pavements
CEMENT CONCRETE PAVEMENT
1
In order to maximize the bearing properties of a road section,
the wearing course can be produced with Cement Concrete.
78
SURFACE layer for Rigid Pavements
CEMENT CONCRETE PAVEMENT
79
SURFACE layer for Rigid Pavements
There are two methods for paving with concrete: slipform and fixed form.
SLIPFORM PAVER
The fresh concrete is deposited in front of the paver, which
spreads, shapes, consolidates, screeds, and float finishes
the cement concrete in a continuous operation.
The pavement construction is rapid and the quality of the
final product is high. As downside, the construction costs
are higher if compared to traditional paving operations.
80
SURFACE layer for Rigid Pavements
CEMENT CONCRETE PAVEMENT construction:
81
SURFACE layer for Rigid Pavements
4. The surface is textured to obtain the desired skid resistance.
6. After concrete hardening, the joints are cleaned and sealed with polymeric
sealants.
4 5 6
82
Grazie per l’attenzione
Università di Bologna
DICAM – Settore Strade
Viale del Risorgimento 2, Bologna
e-mail:
[email protected]
83