MARTIN J. Sodium Based Heat Pipe Modules For Space Reactor Concepts
MARTIN J. Sodium Based Heat Pipe Modules For Space Reactor Concepts
-
Abstract A heat pipe cooled reactor is one of several candidate reactor cores being considered
for advanced space power and propulsion systems to support firture space exploration
applications. Long life heat pipe modules, with designs verified through a combination of
theoretical analysis and experimental lifetime evaluations, would be necessary to establish the
viability of any of these candidates, including the heat pipe reactor option. A hardware-based
program was initiated to estabiish the infrastructure necessary to build heat pipe modules. This
effort, initiated by Los Alams National Laboratory and referred to as the Safe Affordable Fission
Engine (SAFE) project, set out to fabricate and pegonn non-nuclear testing on a modular heat
pipe reactor prototype that can provide 1 OO-kWtfrom the core to an energy conversion system at
700°C.Prototypic heat pipe hardware was designed,fabricated, filled, closed-out and acceptance
tested.
I. INTRODUCTION AND APPROACH Alkali metal heat pipes have demonstrated reliability
over multi-year operation and tolerance to many times the
Near-term ambitious space exploration would benefit fast neutron fluence of expected core designs6. AUrali metal
from systems that have high specific power with associated heat pipes have been successfully tested aboard the Space
high specific impulse. Nuclear electric propulsion systems Shuttle Endeavor. Results correlated well with existing
have the potential to meet this requirement, offering a long models, indicating that the first flight heat pipe core will
life power rich environment in which to conduct scientific operate as intended'. A large body of data documents the
investigations'. A potential reactor concept for near term excellent compatibility of stainless steels with the
space exploration application of nuclear energy, to both in- vaporizing K and Na at temperatures up to 925°C *.
space and surface power needs, is a compact fast spectrum Since their invention 40 years ago, heat pipes using
heat pipe reactor system, a configuration that couples well fluids such as ammonia and water have found wide use on
to a number of power conversion systems including earth and in space. The original heat pipe embodiment was
Brayton, Stirling, and thermoelectric. The benefits of the intended expressly for space nuclear reactor energy
heat pipe reactor choice are its simple modular design that conversion9. A heat pipe cooled reactor was the initial SP-
eases assembly, built in redundancy that minimizes single 100 baseline design". Alkali metal heat pipes still occupy a
point failures, and a layout that is highly testable in a non- niche associated mostly with space nuclear power systems.
nuclear e n ~ i r o n m e n t ~Non-nuclear
~'~. evaluation allows for Despite the stunted US space reactor effort, R&D projects
fast paced, cost effective development, identifying thermal during the 1970s and 1980s sponsored by the DOE,NASA,
hydraulic issues early on when changes can be easily and the US Air Force brought alkali metal heat pipes to a
implemented. This approach increases the probability of level of understanding and technical maturity unusual for
success should a costly full power ground nuclear space reactor components". If heat pipe container and
demonstration be required'. Success of an early hardware worlung fluid impurities can be kept low, care is taken in
test program will foster the continued development of fabrication, and isolation is achieved from external
infrastructure necessary to field larger, more capable contamination sources, long operating life is possible.
systems in the future.
. P r o c e e d i of ICAPP '04
Pittsburgh, PAUSA, June 13-17,2004
Paper4275
These conditions can be met with idusrty standard Solubility of the wall in the working fluid increases in
practice (ASTM C997-83, C105 1-85, and G68-80)'2'3*14. the presence of impurities when ternary compounds form
-4ssa i~itia!step the ?.kii!iafl S p c e Flight Center with hie working fluid and containmenr. 'hpurity corrosion
Early Flight Fission - Test Facility (EFF-TF) team has rate in sodium heat pipes is related to the accumulation of
taken the approach of establishing a hardware-based test elements such as 0, N, and C in the heat pipe evaporator.
program to evaluate potential reactor concepts; the heat Such impurity accumulation makes the corrosion rate
pipe reactor system is one of those under eval~ation'~. somewhat dependent on mass fluence. The radial heat flux
Designed by Los Alamos National Laboratory and referred applied to the evaporator is Qmd = Q l(ndL,),the mass
to as the Safe Affordable Fission Engine (SAFE), this
flux through the evaporator is a function of the radial heat
concept has been implemented at multiple power levels.
Work discussed in this paper relates to the lOO-kW, design flux, G = (id l h , , and the mass fluence through the
that is referred to as the SAFE-100. The SAFE-100 makes evaporator is M" = Gz.
use of 61-stainless steel sodium heat pipe modules and has Mass diffusion transfers impurities from the heat pipe
a nominal operating temperature of 973 K 1617. To lower structure to the working fluid. The Arrhenius equation
project costs, a reduced version of the SAFE-100, core relates impurity diffusion rates to heat pipe temperature. As
referred to as the SAFE-100a, has been fabricated. This an initial approximation, data can be Arrhenius normalized
configuration is identical to the SAFE-100 with the for heat pipe tests conducted away from the o p a t i n g
exception that only the central 19 heat pipe modules are temperature by:
used. For all tests, fission heating is simulated with
specially designed electrical resistance heaters and
electrical power control systems. Infrastructure has been
established to fabricate, fill, process, and evaluate the heat
pipe modules at a component level. These stainless steel
heat pipes serve as an excellent forerunner to the where k is Boltzmann's constant, To is the operating
fabrication and testing of higher temperature refractory temperature, T is the heat pipe test temperahm and AH is
metal heat pipe modules. the activation energy. Testing on the order of 100°C over
the design temperature greatly accelerates the Arrhenius-
11. OVERVIEW OF HEAT PIPE MODULE governed diffusion rate in the heat pipe evaporator. Mass
LIFETIME ISSUES fluence can be accelerated by applying power along a
shortened heat pipe evaporator length. Corrosion rates in
This section discusses some lifetime issues associated stainless steel sodium material systems has been correlated
with alkali metal material systems. A striking advantage of with the expression *I:
the heat pipe core approach is the numerous temperature
and power configurations offered. For instance, a single
stainless steel heat pipe module can work with K or Na,
allowing high power density compact reactor operating
options from 800 K to 1173 K.
Lifetime issues are well established for alkali metal 2.59.106
systems and are summarized in several textbooks1 w . m.
When a heat pipe working fluid condenses, it is essentially 111. THE SAFE-100 MODULE DESIGN
free of impurities when compared with the adjacent wall.
'.
Nonmetallic impurities such as oxygen and carbon can The SAFE-100 is an intermediate stop along the path
diffuse from the condenser wall into the working fluid. to a lar er refractory metal system such as the SAFE400
These impurities may be carried toward the evaporator design This initial system requires 61 heat pipe modules
where they can concentrate. Impurities can precipitate and fabricated from stainless steel with sodium as the working
clog the wick, form low melting point eutectics with the fluid. This system has been designed with the intention of
container, or form ternary compounds with the container coupling it to a heat exchanger capable of transporting
and working fluid. thermal power to a Brayton power conversion system. For
If any of the elements in the wick or wall is soluble in simplicity, each of the 61 SAFE-100modules is identical in
the working fluid, they can dissolve and move to the geometry and performance. The full power design was set
evaporator end of the pipe. The heat pipe structure must be at 100 kW,, requiring that each module operate at a nominal
insoluble to avoid this condition. Proper material selection power throughput of 1.6 kW,. Based on previous
avoids this problem entirely. In the absence of non-metallic experience with the SAFE-30 projecpH*z, a 30 kW,
impurities, the solubility of stainless steel in K or Na is device, the new design makes use of symmetric evaporates
<<lo ppm (by weight).
2
Pmceedii
. of ICAPP ‘04
Pittsburgh. PA USA, June 13-17,2004
Paper 4275
assembly, reducing stresses on the evaporator section that Figure 2. SAFE-100 sodium heat pipe design
can result in module warping. The new layout, illustrated in margins: axial heat transfer rate versus
Figiirc 1 has a iri-lobe arrangement with the fuei tubes set at temperature at the evaporator exit.
120’ intervals about the evaporator perimeter. Analyses
were performed to assess operating limits, setting the final The internal capillary channel is formed by a crescent
module geometry. annular wick composed of 7 layers of 400-mesh 304L
stainless steel screen with a wire diameter 0.03 mm. Bubble
point tests of the assembled wick structure (using ethyl
alcohol and helium pressurant) measured a maximum wick
pore diameter of 16 pm. The final geometry leaves a 0.6-
mm annular-liquid flow gap between the module inner wall
and outer edge of the wickz6.
3
Proceedhg~of ICAPP ‘04
Pittsburgh, PA USA, June 13-17,2004
Paper 4275
two-stage process (Figure 5). First, the known volume is transfer (sufficiently above the sodium melting point to
5
filled from the bulk sodium storage, followed by a transfer minimize the chance of premature freezing).
from the known voiume to a heat plpe module. W-eights are
taken at both stages to verify sufficient material has been Sodium Vent
transferred. Inlet lsdiition
Known
Sodium
Fitter Vdwne
Isolation
Transfer
Known Irobtlw,
Vdume
Module
Fill RU Stem
Vacuum
Isolation Modok
4
Pnx;eedings of ICAPP '04
Pittsburgh, PA USA, June 13-17,2004
Paper 4275
40 \
50
04
d
0 low
Module Heating h t e r v ~ l
2000 WW 40.0
11mo
5Wn
5
Prooeedigs of ICAPP ‘04
Pittsburgh, PAUSA, June 13-17,2004
Paper 4275
Figure 10. Module instrumentation layout. power QCod was found to be 1.25 kW (1.58 kW input
power Qmap- 0.33 kW QbJ. This assessment can be
Three thermocouples are located on the heater tubes, verified by inspecting the heat transfer of the condenser
three on the evaporator section and nine on the condenser. section to the environment, that includes heat transfer by
The modules are operated in air with an approximate 1- both radiation and convectionz9.This can be written as:
hour startup leading into the 6-hour steady state hold at
temperature. To limit the module’s evaporator heat loss, the
evaporator section is wrapped in an insulation blanket with
a thickness of approximately 10 cm. The condenser is
exposed to allow natural convection to remove the input
power (Figure 11). Qconv = 1 .42dLc3I4(T, - T, ),I4. (7)
6
P r o c e e d i of ICAPP Q4
Pittsburgh, PA USA, June 1317,2004
Paper4275
For the module conditions being evaluated. the power configuration. Throughout all heat pipe-proctssing
dissipated from the condenser section Q d was found to be operations, close attention was paid to the numbcr of steps
1.24 kR7, which compares weii to the evaporator that were taken and a detailed set of procedures was
assessment of 1.25 kW. The completed heat pipe units that developed to document the process. This informarion
pass acceptance testing are incorporated into the SAFE- serves as a working guide should a full complement of
lOOa hardware setup. This configuration is a full-up system modules be required.
evaluation in which all modules shall be operated together
with an integrated heat exchanger to actively remove heat ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
from the condenser section.
The authors wish to acknowledge the substantial
i TClfC)
contributions to the design, fabrication, assembly of
’‘-
- TC2(C)
TCYC)
TCqC)
hardware, and development of process/procedures for this
project by Applied Materials and Methods, Los A l m s
, TCYCJ National Laboratory, and the NASA Marshall Space night
TCWI Center. NASA’s Project Prometheus, the Nuclear System
- TC7[C)
I - TCWC) Program, supported the work described within this paper as
- TCgC) part of the program’s technology development and
1- TC1qq
- TCll(C) evaluation activities. Any opinions expressed are those of
’ TClaC) the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of
TClYC)
- TClqC) Project Prometheus.
TCl5(C)
- P a a
NOMENCLATURE
Figure 12. Sodium heat pipe module startup: = insulation surface area (mz)
Am
temperature profile versus time. d = condenser diameter (m)
ls00 G = mass flux (kg/m2-s)
hh = latent heat of vaporization (Jkg)
kaw = insulation thermal conductivity (W/m-K)
1-, = insulation thickness (m)
LC = condenser length (m)
Le = evaporator length (m)
M I = mass fluence (kg/m2)
TC111C)
Qcmv = convective loss (W)
TClZiC) Qcod = condenser power (W)
- TClYC) QNW = evaporator power (W)
Qbss = parasihc losses from evaporator (W)
0 Qrd = radiation loss (W)
aooo lswo
0 4000 1 m
nmo (seconda)
20000 24000
&ad, 4 = radial heat flux (W/mz)
Figure 13. Sodium heat pipe module temperature Ti? = ambient temperature (K)
profile during steady state operation. TC = condenser temperature (K)
TWr = Insulation inner temperature (K)
VII. SUMMARY Tower = Insulation outer temperature (K)
0 = Stefan-Boltzmann constant (W/mz-K‘)
To begin the verification process, a hardware program E = total hemispherical emittance (-)
was initiated to investigate fabrication and operation of a
= time(s)
number of sodium-filled stainless steel heat pipes with
geometry prototypic of a heat pipe reactor system. Thirty-
five modules have been constructed; 19 modules have been
REFERENCES
filled and acceptance tested. Each completed module was
filled with 3 5 i 2 grams of sodium, closed out, and then
1. M. G HOUTS, et al., “Utilizing Fission
successfully operated in excess of 650°C for over 6 hours.
All 19 filled modules passed the acceptance test. The 19 Technology to Enable Rapid and Affordable
Access to any Point in the Solar System,”
completed modules will be integrated into the SAFE-100a
7
Proceedhgs of ICAPP '04
Pittoburgh, PA USA, June 13-17,2004
paper4275
8
PmxAhgsdlCAPPW
Pi#sburgh. PA USA. J ~ n e13-17. #)04
paper-
19. W. E. BERRY, Corrosion in Nuclear Applications. Space Technology and Applications International
John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1971. Forum (STAIF-2003). edited by M.S. El-Genk,
Ai? Conf proceedings 654, AIP. New York, 2003,
20. H. U. BORGSTEDT, and C. K. W H E W S , pp 101-105.
Applied Chemistry of the Alkali Metals, Plenum
Press, New York, 1987. 29. J. P. HOLMAN, (1981) Heat Transfer, McGraw
Hill, New York, NY
21. R. W. LOCKHART, R. S. YOUNG "General
Electric Sodium Mass Transfer Program," AEC
Sodium Components Development Program
Information Meeting, Chicago, JL,June 16, 1965.