The Path Ahead For Business Schools: Looking Beyond Capitalism For Sustainability
The Path Ahead For Business Schools: Looking Beyond Capitalism For Sustainability
Abstract: The purpose of this paper is to examine the current position of the Business Schools at a time when criticism and
protests against capitalism are rising across the world, which is also the main ideology served and propagated by Business
Schools. Capitalism has been blamed for increasing gap between rich and poor, stagnation in wages, increasing corporate
influence on Governments, climate change and environmental impacts, increasing consumerism and many other negative
effects on the society and the planet. In this context the relevance and legitimacy of management education provided at B-
schools is questioned. The paper builds on existing literature on criticism of B-schools and Capitalism to assess the
relevance of Business Schools in current scenario. The paper proposes different alternatives that could be taught and
incorporated in Business Schools’ curriculums to create more sustainable economies and societies. What could be the
purpose and role of Business schools in such disruptive times is pondered upon.
Keywords: Business Schools, Capitalism, Management Education, Management Research, Economic Inequality, Sustainability.
How to Cite: Dr. Jagdish Sambada (2025). The Path Ahead for Business Schools: Looking Beyond Capitalism for Sustainability.
International Journal of Innovative Science and Research Technology, 10(2), 201-206.
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.14899143
Merriam-Webster dictionary defines capitalism as “An Capitalism has done more harm than just class divide
economic system characterized by private or corporate and workers’ exploitation. Economic inequality is also one
ownership of capital goods, by investments that are of the grave consequences of capitalism. Some statistics at
determined by private decision, and by prices, production, the inequality in the world paints a grim picture of the world
and the distribution of goods that are determined mainly by we live in. Although there could be many factors
competition in a free market.” (Smith, 1776) in his work responsible behind this, capitalism is one of the dominant
“An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of one in creating this economic inequality. According to an
Nations” stressed upon leaving the markets self-regulated Oxfam analysis, the wealth of billionaires worldwide rose
and introduced the concept of invisible hand which is a by $3.9 trillion between March 18 and the end of 2020. In
metaphor for unseen forces driving the free market contrast, the International Labour Organization reports that
economy. millions of people worldwide lost their employment,
resulting in a $3.7 trillion drop in their total incomes.
So, the assumption is that if markets are left
uninterrupted then the forces of supply and demand in the The wealth gap between the world's billionaires and
market will lead to equilibrium as well as competition in the the poorest half of humanity is widening rapidly, according
market will benefit everybody participating in the market to an Oxfam analysis. The number of billionaires needed to
and to the society as well. Prices will adjust according to the match the wealth of the world's poorest 50% of people
supply and demand and competition will lead firms to decreased from 380 to 26 between 2009 and 2018.
innovate and finally everyone in the society will be well off. According to data from the World Inequality Report, the
Profit maximization seems to be the noble goal which wealthiest 1 percent's share of national income has grown
capitalism or free market economy pursues. significantly in North America (here defined as the US and
Canada), China, India, and Russia since 1980, while it has
It was the great depression of 1930 which led many expanded more slowly in Europe.
people to question the free market economic system. But
since then, free markets and capitalism have been the Above statistics show that there is something wrong in
dominant systems in the world. During the period of 1970s the way different elements in capitalist system are
rapid increases in economic inequality also led many people organised. If that was not the case then the world would not
to doubt the long-term viability of the capitalist system. be facing such extreme inequalities in wealth. In his book
Capitalism has been blamed for many problems the world is "Capital in the Twenty-First Century," Piketty (2013)
facing today. These problems range from economic examined global inequality data and found that in capitalist
inequality to more extreme destruction of natural resources society, capital and the money it generates expand more
at unprecedented pace. quickly than economic growth. He demonstrated how
financial inequality is increasing in the twenty-first century
Karl Marx (1844) was of the view that Capitalism is and doing so at a very risky rate.
not good for the workers. In the Economic and Philosophic
Manuscripts, he wrote about alienation of labour which was As stated by Sara Stevano (2021) in "COVID-19 and
based on Economics and human nature. According to Marx crises of capitalism: intensifying inequalities and global
in a capitalist economy the means of production are owned responses," "The COVID-19 crisis is a stark reminder that
privately and hence there are two classes in a capitalist the core of human activity is intrinsically material and
economy, those (bourgeoisie) who own the means of embedded in the socio-economic and biophysical basis of
production and those (the proletariat) workers who do not. production and reproduction, despite the significant
In a capitalist economy as works compete with each other transformations of globalized contemporary capitalism
for wages and raises it actually brings down their wages and through financialization and technological progress."
the class benefiting from this competition is not the workers
but the capitalists. In this situation workers are alienated The loss of biodiversity and climate change have also
from other workers. As workers do not own the means of been attributed to capitalism. "In just 200 years of existence,
production and whatever they produce is sold by the capitalism has brought us to the brink of such a calamitous
capitalists in the market. Here workers are alienated from breakdown in the world's natural systems that our entire
the products of their labor. As capitalist own the firms where civilization is now under threat," according to James Plested
Workers are employed it is the capitalist who decide what to (2020) in "Capitalist roots of the environment crisis." He
make, how to make and how much to make. In this situation goes on to say: "The breakup between the primary forces
workers are alienated from the act of labor. behind economic activity and the environment that supports
us is what makes capitalism particularly destructive when
Marx also noted that the capitalist class takes compared to earlier systems." Additionally, he contends that
advantage of workers by stealing their excess value, which the capitalist elite transfers environmental degradation to
serves as the capitalists' source of profit. Workers must sell society as "externality."
The WWF's Living Planet research reveals that (Mitroff, 2004) made numerous attacks on business
between 1970 and 2016, wild animal numbers declined by schools in "An Open Letter to the Deans and the Faculties of
68%. "Global trade, consumption, and population growth American Business Schools." "The business theories that we
have all exploded in the last 50 years, and there has been a have developed and thus teach are based upon the narrowest
massive shift towards urbanization," the research states. and the basest of human motives," he wrote. He went on to
Humankind's ecological footprint was less than the pace of criticize faculty, saying: "A lot of business school faculty
regrowth of the planet until 1970. At least 56% of the members make a lot of erroneous assumptions and claims
Earth's biocapacity is being overused by humans to feed and about the topic of ethics. They first claim that ethics is
fuel our 21st-century lifestyles. The paper also identified a merely a question of personal values. Put otherwise, ethics is
number of indirect drivers of biodiversity loss, including about values and nothing else. Additionally, they believe
overuse of natural resources, production, consumption, that by the time a person reaches business school, their
finance and governance, migration, and urbanization values are set in stone. And is the role of one’s parents and
demography. religious instructors to teach values, not business school
faculty. Thus, to state it somewhat differently, business
"Nature is declining globally at rates unprecedented in faculty has little, if any, role in teaching values.”
millions of years," warns Marco Lambertini, Director
General of WWF International in their report, The Living Business schools have aggressively released their
Planet. Our existing economic model's egregious disrespect students from any feeling of moral obligation by spreading
for the environment, coupled with the way we produce and ideologically driven amoral ideas, according to Ghoshal's
use food and energy, has pushed the natural world to its 2005 paper, "Bad Management Theories Are Destroying
limits. Good Management Practices."
Agriculture and farming are also not spared by Bennis (2005) critiques the direction that many
capitalism. While the current capital and technology- business schools have taken, arguing that they have adopted
intensive farming systems have been incredibly productive an inappropriate model of academic excellence over the past
and able to provide low-cost food, Miguel Altieri (1998) few decades. He asserts that rather than focusing on the
discussed the devastating effects of capitalist agriculture in competence of their graduates or understanding the key
"Ecological Impacts of Industrial Agriculture and the drivers of business performance, these schools prioritize the
Possibilities for Truly Sustainable Farming" and wrote: "The rigor of scientific research. According to Bennis, this shift
very nature of the agricultural structure and prevailing has led to a focus on abstract financial and economic
policies in a capitalist setting have led to [the present] analysis, statistical multiple regressions, and laboratory
environmental crisis by favoring large farm size, specialized psychology, which ultimately undermines the practical
production, crop monocultures, and mechanization." Due to applicability of the education provided in these institutions.
the widespread use of chemical fertilizers and pesticides, the
biological imperative of diversity is being undermined by Grey (2005) of Warwick Business School argues that
the increasing integration of farmers into global markets. many business schools have transformed into “finishing
Specialized farms are being rewarded by economies of schools” for elites, primarily preparing students for careers
scale. in finance and consulting. He critiques the lack of emphasis
on ethical and moral challenges of leadership, asserting that
There have been many critics of the capitalism and as these institutions do not encourage students to reflect on
can be seen here from above critics that capitalism as a their broader roles in society.
system is arranged in such a way that in pursuit of unlimited
growth and profits so many vital things are compromised. In Confronting Managerialism: How the Business Elite
These vital things are ecological balance, preservation of and Their Schools Threw Our Lives Out of Balance, Locke
biodiversity, economic equality, workers’ rights and the (2011) discusses how methodologies commonly introduced
planet itself. So, it is indeed the need of the hour that in business schools—such as numerical analysis,
humans explore and try alternatives to this system where mathematical modeling, and financial economics—can lead
growth and profits are realized but within the ecological to rational decisions that overlook critical issues of culture,
limits of the planet. Only time will tell whether humans will managerial behavior, and ethics. Locke critiques the
emphasis on these methods, arguing that they often neglect
The Food Commons Fresno project exemplifies how Business Schools will have to see that they do not have
individuals can be organized for the collective benefit of all. a narrow view of business only but also how the business
It operates as a network of community-owned trusts that impacts society, people and environment. Academic
collaborate with landowners, farmers, food processors, research in Business Schools will also have to explore
distributors, retailers, and workers to achieve a common alternatives to capitalism as well as other forms of
goal: providing high-quality, safe, locally grown food that is organization like platform cooperativism or internet
accessible to everyone. Rather than diverting profits to ownership. Business Schools can really transform the
investors, the Food Commons redistributes financial society and be catalysts in creating sustainable future only if
surpluses across the system, alleviating market pressures they dare to look beyond capitalism.
that typically lead to soil depletion, the exploitation of farm
workers, the degradation of food quality, and rising prices. REFERENCES
Relocalization, platform cooperativism, Eco socialism, [1]. The History Of The MBA. Retrieved from
degrowth and circular economy are some of the alternatives https://www.mbacentral.org/history-of-the- mba/
to the current economic system which present great [2]. Harvard to XLRI: Four oldest B-schools in the
possibility for sustainable society but these ideas challenge world.Retrievedfrom
the assumptions of current capitalist system and ask for https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/harvard-to-
radical overhaul of different factors like finance, production, xlri-four-oldest-b-schools-
consumption, regulation in the economic system. intheworld/articlesshow/47025829.cms
[3]. AISHE Final Report 2018-19.pdf. Retrieved from
These alternative ideas or systems place great https://www.education.gov.in › files › statistics-new
emphasis on ecology or nature and don’t see economic [4]. Capitalism. Retrieved from
growth and profit as the ultimate goal but rather these https://www.britannica.com/topic/capitalism
systems try to achieve balance between economic growth [5]. Smith, A. (1776). "An Inquiry into the Nature and
and nature by adopting a holistic approach. These are some Causes of the Wealth of Nations". London: Methuen
of the alternatives that Business Schools will have to and Co.
incorporate as main part of their curriculum and also offer as [6]. Marx, K., (1844). Economic and Philosophical
core specialization in MBA program. Only then it will be Manuscripts of 1844.
able to make some effect on the businesses and society. [7]. Marx, K., (1847). Wage Labour and Capital
[8]. Retrieved from
Till now Business Schools have postulated that there https://oxfamilibrary.openrepository.com/bitstream/h
do not exist alternative forms of organization as mentioned andle/10546/621149/bp-the-inequality-virus-summ-
above and capitalism is the only model which has surpassed 250121-en.pdf
all other models. But now it is time for introspection for [9]. Retrieved from https://wir2018.wid.world/