Journal of Namibian Studies, 39 S1 (2023): 238-258 ISSN: 2197-5523 (online)

Constitutional Provisions In India And The

Need For Gender Neutral Laws

Vartika Pandey1 , Dr. Shashank Shekhar2

1
PhD research scholar Institute of Legal studies Shri
Ramswaroop memorial University SRMU Lucknow U.P.
[email protected]
2
Associate professor Institute of Legal studies Shri
Ramswaroop memorial University SRMU Lucknow U.P.

ABSTRACT
Gender neutrality within legal frameworks is a cornerstone
of promoting fairness, equity, and justice for individuals of
all genders. This paper critically examines the challenges,
opportunities, and policy recommendations surrounding the
implementation of gender-neutral laws in India, with a focus
on addressing the misuse of laws by both men and women.
Key areas of analysis include existing laws favoring women,
such as those pertaining to domestic violence and sexual
offenses, which often neglect the rights and protections of
men. Conversely, laws neglecting men, such as those
governing parental rights and child custody, perpetuate
stereotypes and inequalities within society. Instances of law
misuse further underscore the need for more balanced and
equitable legal provisions, with recommendations including
legislative reforms, institutional initiatives, and public
awareness campaigns. Suggested policy recommendations
emphasize the importance of enacting gender-neutral
legislation, strengthening safeguards against law misuse,
providing institutional training programs, launching public
awareness campaigns, and investing in research and data
collection efforts. By implementing these recommendations,
policymakers can work towards creating a more just,
equitable, and inclusive legal system that upholds the rights
and dignity of all individuals, irrespective of their gender
identity or expression.

Keywords: gender neutrality, legal framework, gender

equality, law misuse, legislative reforms, institutional
initiatives, public awareness, India.

1. INTRODUCTION

238
 Journal of Namibian Studies, 39 S1 (2023): 238-258 ISSN: 2197-5523 (online)

Gender equality and justice have long been central tenets of

modern democracies, including India, where constitutional
provisions strive to ensure fairness and equity for all citizens.
The Indian Constitution, a beacon of democracy and social
justice, enshrines fundamental rights and directive principles
aimed at fostering an egalitarian society. However, despite the
progressive legal framework, the issue of gender neutrality in
laws remains a subject of contention and debate.1

In recent years, there has been a growing discourse

surrounding the need for gender-neutral laws, particularly
concerning the perception that existing legislation
disproportionately favors women while neglecting the rights
and protections of men. This asymmetry in legal provisions has
led to concerns over fairness and justice, prompting calls for a
reevaluation of India's legal landscape.2

One of the primary concerns driving the demand for gender-

neutral laws is the perceived misuse of existing legal provisions
by individuals, particularly women. While legislative measures
intended to safeguard women's rights and address historical
gender disparities are crucial, instances of misuse or
exploitation of these laws have raised serious questions about
their efficacy and fairness.3

The phenomenon of law misuse encompasses various

scenarios, including false accusations, extortion, and
manipulation of legal mechanisms for personal gain or
vendetta. Such misuse not only undermines the credibility of
the legal system but also perpetuates injustice by subjecting
innocent individuals, often men, to unwarranted legal scrutiny
and hardship.4

One prominent example is the misuse of laws pertaining to

dowry harassment (Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code) and
domestic violence (Protection of Women from Domestic
Violence Act, 2005). While these laws were enacted with the

1
Manupatra, “Articles – Manupatra” available at:
https://articles.manupatra.com/article-details/Access-to-Justice-for-
Women-in-India.
2
Sandra Fredman FBA Kc, “Equality: Concepts and Controversies”
OUP Academic, 2022 available at:
https://academic.oup.com/book/45338/chapter/389236591.
3
Ibid.
4
Arti Aasha, “Social Tranformation Law Current Issues &
Challenges” ABS Books India New Delhi, 2022 available at:
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/362156459_Social_Tranfor
mation_Law_Current_Issues_Challenges.

239
 Journal of Namibian Studies, 39 S1 (2023): 238-258 ISSN: 2197-5523 (online)

noble intention of protecting women from abuse and

exploitation within the household, they have been reported to
be misused by some individuals to settle personal scores or
gain leverage in marital disputes. The indiscriminate arrest of
husbands and their family members based on false allegations
has drawn criticism from various quarters, highlighting the
need for greater safeguards against legal abuse.

Similarly, laws addressing sexual offenses, such as rape and

sexual harassment, have been subject to misuse, with
instances of false accusations and extortion tarnishing the
credibility of genuine cases and compromising the principles of
justice. The absence of stringent penalties for filing false
complaints or providing misleading evidence further
exacerbates the problem, creating a climate where the
presumption of innocence is often overshadowed by the fear
of false accusations.

Moreover, the societal stigma attached to reporting incidents

of male victimization further compounds the issue,
discouraging men from seeking legal recourse and
perpetuating a culture of silence and impunity. Cases of male
victims being overlooked or dismissed by law enforcement
agencies and support services underscore the systemic biases
that undermine gender equality and justice.5

In light of these challenges, there is a pressing need to

reevaluate existing legal frameworks and enact gender-neutral
laws that uphold the principles of equality, fairness, and due
process for all individuals, irrespective of gender. By addressing
the shortcomings of current legislation and incorporating
safeguards against misuse and exploitation, policymakers can
ensure that the legal system remains a bulwark of justice and
integrity.6

This paper seeks to explore the nuances of gender neutrality in

Indian laws, with a focus on the imperative for legislative
reforms to address the issue of law misuse and promote
gender equality. Through an analysis of relevant case studies,
legislative provisions, and scholarly literature, it aims to
elucidate the complexities of the legal landscape and propose

5
Eugene Emeka Dim and Alexandra Lysova, “Male Victims’
Experiences With and Perceptions of the Criminal Justice Response
to Intimate Partner Abuse,” 37 Journal of interpersonal violence
NP13067–91 (2022).
6
Ibid.

240
 Journal of Namibian Studies, 39 S1 (2023): 238-258 ISSN: 2197-5523 (online)

actionable recommendations for fostering a more equitable

and inclusive society.

1.1. OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY

The study aims to achieve the following objectives:

1. To critically examine the existing legal provisions in

India related to gender-specific laws and assess their
impact on gender equality and justice.

2. To analyze the prevalence and implications of law

misuse, particularly in cases where individuals exploit
gender-specific legislation for personal gain or
vendetta.

3. To identify the socio-cultural, legal, and institutional

factors contributing to the misuse of gender-specific
laws and assess the challenges in addressing this
phenomenon.

4. To propose policy recommendations and legislative

reforms aimed at promoting gender neutrality in
Indian laws, with a focus on ensuring fairness, equity,
and due process for all individuals, regardless of
gender.

2. CONSTITUTIONAL PROVISIONS IN INDIA

The Indian Constitution, adopted on January 26, 1950, is the

supreme law of the land, providing the framework for
governance and ensuring fundamental rights and freedoms for
all citizens. Its preamble declares India to be a sovereign,
socialist, secular, and democratic republic, committed to
securing justice, liberty, equality, and fraternity for its people.
Embedded within its provisions are safeguards and directives
aimed at fostering gender equality and social justice.7

Fundamental Rights, enshrined in Part III of the Constitution,

form the cornerstone of individual liberties and protections
against state encroachment. Article 148 guarantees the right to
equality before the law and equal protection of laws,
prohibiting discrimination on grounds of sex, among others.
However, while this provision theoretically applies to both men

7
“Constitution of India,” available at:
https://indiankanoon.org/doc/237570/ (last visited March 25, 2024).
8
“Article 14 in Constitution of India,” available at:
https://indiankanoon.org/doc/367586/ (last visited March 25, 2024).

241
 Journal of Namibian Studies, 39 S1 (2023): 238-258 ISSN: 2197-5523 (online)

and women, the practical application has often been criticized

for its failure to address gender-specific injustices adequately.

Article 15 9 prohibits discrimination on grounds of religion,

race, caste, sex, or place of birth, reinforcing the principle of
equality before the law. Yet, the persistence of gender-based
discrimination and disparities in various spheres of life
highlights the need for more robust legal mechanisms to
address systemic inequalities.

Directive Principles of State Policy, outlined in Part IV10 of the

Constitution, provide guidelines for state policy-making,
emphasizing social and economic justice. Article 39(a) directs
the state to ensure that men and women have the right to an
adequate means of livelihood and equal pay for equal work.
However, despite such directives, disparities in wages and
employment opportunities persist, necessitating
comprehensive legislative measures to ensure gender parity in
the workforce.

Gender-specific provisions within the Constitution aim to

address historical injustices and disparities faced by women.
Article 15(3) allows the state to make special provisions for
women and children, acknowledging the need for affirmative
action to uplift marginalized groups. While such provisions are
crucial for promoting gender equality, there is a growing
recognition of the need for a balanced approach that considers
the rights and vulnerabilities of all genders.

The legal framework for gender justice in India comprises

various statutes and judicial interpretations aimed at
safeguarding the rights and dignity of individuals, irrespective
of gender. The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence
Act, 2005, for instance, provides legal recourse to women
facing domestic abuse, acknowledging the disproportionate
impact of such violence on women. However, the absence of
similar legal protections for men facing domestic violence
underscores the need for gender-neutral legislation to address
the needs of all victims.

Similarly, laws addressing sexual offenses, such as rape and

sexual harassment, primarily focus on protecting women from
violence and exploitation. While these laws play a crucial role

9
“Article 15 in Constitution of India,” available at:
https://indiankanoon.org/doc/609295/ (last visited March 25, 2024).
10
Part IV of the Constitution

242
 Journal of Namibian Studies, 39 S1 (2023): 238-258 ISSN: 2197-5523 (online)

in ensuring women's safety and security, the lack of adequate

provisions for male victims reflects a systemic bias that
undermines the principles of equality and justice. Instances of
false accusations and misuse of these laws further highlight the
need for stringent safeguards against legal abuse.11

3. GENDER NEUTRAL LAWS: CONCEPT AND NEED

Gender neutrality in law refers to the principle of ensuring that

legal provisions are applied without discrimination based on
gender, thereby treating individuals of all genders equally
under the law. It aims to dismantle traditional gender roles and
stereotypes embedded within legal frameworks, promoting
fairness, equity, and inclusivity. While the concept of gender
neutrality is integral to achieving true gender equality, its
implementation in legislative practice remains a complex and
evolving process.12

Significance of Gender Neutral Laws:

Gender-neutral laws play a crucial role in addressing the

systemic biases and inequalities that disproportionately affect
individuals based on their gender. By eliminating
discriminatory practices and ensuring equal rights and
protections for all genders, these laws contribute to fostering
a more just and inclusive society. Moreover, gender-neutral
legislation helps challenge traditional stereotypes and norms
that perpetuate gender-based discrimination and reinforce
power imbalances.

In the context of addressing the misuse of laws by both men

and women, gender-neutral legislation serves as a vital tool for
promoting accountability and fairness. By establishing clear
guidelines and safeguards against legal abuse, such laws
mitigate the risk of false accusations and wrongful convictions,
thereby upholding the principles of justice and due process.
Additionally, gender-neutral laws empower individuals of all

11
katharina.kiener-manu, “Crime Prevention & Criminal Justice
Module 9 Key Issues: Topic 1 - Gender-based discrimination and
women in conflict with the law” available at:
https://www.unodc.org/e4j/en/crime-prevention-criminal-
justice/module-9/key-issues/1--gender-based-discrimination-and-
women-in-conflict-with-the-law.html.
12
Rigmor Argren et al., “The Evolving Recognition of Gender in
International and European Law” Springer International Publishing,
2023 available at: https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-
031-14360-1_8.

243
 Journal of Namibian Studies, 39 S1 (2023): 238-258 ISSN: 2197-5523 (online)

genders to seek legal recourse and protection against injustice,

regardless of societal expectations or stereotypes.

Current Status of Gender Neutral Laws in India:

Despite significant progress in advancing gender equality and

justice, the legal landscape in India continues to grapple with
challenges related to gender neutrality. While certain laws,
such as those pertaining to property rights and inheritance, are
inherently gender-neutral, many statutes still exhibit gender
biases or fail to adequately address the needs and
vulnerabilities of all genders.13

One area where gender-neutral laws are particularly lacking is

in addressing domestic violence. While legislation such as the
Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 14 ,
provides crucial protections for women facing abuse, there is a
noticeable absence of similar provisions for male victims. This
asymmetry not only undermines the rights of male victims but
also perpetuates the misconception that domestic violence is
exclusively a women's issue, thereby hindering efforts to
address the problem comprehensively.

Similarly, laws governing sexual offenses often focus primarily

on protecting women from violence and exploitation,
overlooking the experiences of male victims. The Criminal Law
(Amendment) Act, 2013, introduced significant reforms to
address sexual violence against women, including the
recognition of new offenses such as acid attacks and stalking.
However, the absence of adequate legal provisions for male
victims of sexual violence reflects a systemic bias that
undermines the principles of gender equality and justice.

In addition to the lack of gender-neutral legislation, the misuse

of existing laws by both men and women further underscores
the need for comprehensive legal reforms. Instances of false
accusations and manipulation of legal mechanisms for
personal gain highlight the shortcomings of gender-specific
laws in safeguarding against abuse and exploitation. Without
adequate safeguards and penalties for misuse, the credibility

13
Ojaswini Singh & Atulit Raj, “Live Law” Live Law, 15 April
2023.
14
“Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005,” 2005
available at: https://www.indiacode.nic.in/handle/123456789/2021
(last visited March 25, 2024).

244
 Journal of Namibian Studies, 39 S1 (2023): 238-258 ISSN: 2197-5523 (online)

of the legal system is compromised, leading to injustice and

erosion of trust.

In response to these challenges, there have been calls for

reforms aimed at promoting gender neutrality in Indian laws.
Initiatives such as the drafting of the Gender Equality Bill seek
to address gaps in existing legislation and ensure equal rights
and protections for individuals of all genders. By adopting a
holistic approach to legal reform and incorporating principles
of gender neutrality, policymakers can work towards creating
a more inclusive and equitable legal framework that upholds
the rights and dignity of all individuals, irrespective of gender.

4. CRITIQUE OF EXISTING LAWS AND THEIR IMPACT ON

GENDER JUSTICE

Laws favoring women have been a subject of both praise and

critique in India's legal landscape. While these laws were
introduced with the intention of addressing historical injustices
and disparities faced by women, their implementation and
impact have been met with mixed reactions.

One of the most notable laws favoring women is the Protection

of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005. This legislation
provides comprehensive protection to women against various
forms of domestic abuse, including physical, emotional, verbal,
economic, and sexual abuse. While the enactment of this law
was a significant step towards addressing the pervasive issue
of domestic violence against women, critics argue that its
gender-specific focus overlooks the experiences of male
victims of domestic abuse. As a result, male victims often find
themselves marginalized and without adequate legal recourse,
highlighting the need for more inclusive and gender-neutral
legislation in this regard.15

Similarly, laws governing matrimonial disputes, such as Section

498A of the Indian Penal Code, have faced criticism for their
biased application and potential for misuse. This provision,
which deals with dowry harassment, has been accused of being
weaponized by some women to falsely implicate their
husbands and in-laws in cases of marital discord. The
widespread misuse of this law has led to numerous instances
of innocent individuals being subjected to harassment, arrest,

15
Ravneet Kaur and Suneela Garg, “Addressing domestic violence
against women: an unfinished agenda,” 33 Indian journal of
community medicine : official publication of Indian Association of
Preventive & Social Medicine 73–6 (2008).

245
 Journal of Namibian Studies, 39 S1 (2023): 238-258 ISSN: 2197-5523 (online)

and legal proceedings, casting doubts on its effectiveness as a

tool for addressing genuine cases of dowry-related abuse.
Critics argue that the lack of stringent safeguards against false
accusations and the presumption of guilt tilts the scales of
justice in favor of women, undermining the principles of
fairness and due process.16

Furthermore, laws governing alimony and maintenance in

divorce cases have been criticized for perpetuating gender
stereotypes and inequalities. While these laws are intended to
ensure financial support for spouses, irrespective of gender,
their implementation often results in disproportionately high
awards in favor of women. The presumption that women are
inherently more vulnerable and in need of financial assistance
reinforces traditional gender roles and fails to account for
changing social dynamics. As a result, men may find themselves
burdened with exorbitant financial obligations, regardless of
their actual financial capacity or circumstances, leading to
feelings of injustice and resentment.

On the other hand, laws neglecting men have also been a cause
for concern in India's legal system. Despite significant strides in
advancing women's rights and protections, men continue to
face challenges and injustices in various spheres of life, often
due to the absence of gender-neutral laws. For example, while
the definition of rape under Section 375 of the Indian Penal
Code is gender-neutral, the legal framework surrounding
sexual offenses predominantly focuses on protecting women
from sexual violence. Male victims of rape or sexual assault
may find it difficult to access support services or seek justice
due to societal stigmas and the lack of adequate legal
provisions tailored to their needs.17

Additionally, laws governing parental rights and child custody

often favor mothers over fathers, perpetuating the stereotype
that women are inherently better caregivers. Despite changing
social norms and evolving family structures, courts may still
exhibit bias towards awarding custody to mothers, even in
cases where fathers are equally capable and willing to provide

16
Shalu Nigam, “Is Domestic Violence a Lesser Crime? Countering
the Backlash against Section 498A, IPC” Elsevier BV, 2016
available at:
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/314461180_Is_Domestic_
Violence_a_Lesser_Crime_Countering_the_Backlash_against_Secti
on_498A_IPC.
17
Tannvi Tannvi and Sharmila Narayana, “The challenge of gender
stereotyping in Indian courts,” 8 Cogent Social Sciences (2022).

246
 Journal of Namibian Studies, 39 S1 (2023): 238-258 ISSN: 2197-5523 (online)

care. This gender-based presumption not only undermines

fathers' rights but also deprives children of meaningful
relationships with their fathers, reinforcing harmful
stereotypes and perpetuating inequalities within families.

Instances of laws misused by women further underscore the

need for more balanced and equitable legal provisions. False
accusations of dowry harassment, domestic violence, and
sexual offenses not only harm innocent individuals but also
erode trust in the legal system and perpetuate a culture of
suspicion and hostility. By addressing the root causes of law
misuse and strengthening safeguards against abuse,
policymakers can uphold the principles of justice, fairness, and
gender equality, ensuring that the legal system serves the
interests of all individuals, regardless of gender.

5. ARGUMENTS FOR GENDER NEUTRAL LAWS

Arguments in favor of gender-neutral laws emphasize the

importance of ensuring fairness, equity, and inclusivity within
the legal system. Advocates contend that gender-neutral
legislation is essential for addressing systemic biases,
promoting gender equality, and safeguarding the rights and
dignity of all individuals, irrespective of gender.

One compelling argument for gender-neutral laws is rooted in

the principle of equality before the law, enshrined in Article
14 18 of the Indian Constitution. This fundamental right
guarantees equal protection of laws to all citizens, regardless
of their gender. However, the existence of gender-specific
laws, which predominantly favor women and neglect the rights
of men, undermines the principle of equality and perpetuates
gender-based discrimination. By adopting a gender-neutral
approach to legislation, policymakers can ensure that legal
provisions are applied without bias or favoritism, thereby
upholding the principles of justice and fairness.

Moreover, gender-neutral laws play a crucial role in

challenging traditional gender roles and stereotypes that
perpetuate inequality and restrict individual freedoms. By
dismantling outdated notions of masculinity and femininity,
gender-neutral legislation empowers individuals to defy
societal expectations and pursue their aspirations without fear
of judgment or discrimination. For example, laws governing

18
Article 14 in Constitution of India,” available at:
https://indiankanoon.org/doc/367586/ (last visited March 25, 2024).

247
 Journal of Namibian Studies, 39 S1 (2023): 238-258 ISSN: 2197-5523 (online)

parental leave and childcare should be gender-neutral to

encourage shared parenting responsibilities and combat the
stereotype that caregiving is solely a woman's responsibility.

Furthermore, gender-neutral laws are essential for addressing

the diverse needs and vulnerabilities of individuals across the
gender spectrum. While traditional legal frameworks may fail
to recognize the experiences of transgender and non-binary
individuals, gender-neutral legislation acknowledges and
affirms their identities, ensuring equal rights and protections
under the law. For instance, laws governing access to public
facilities, healthcare services, and employment opportunities
should be inclusive and accommodating of diverse gender
identities to prevent discrimination and exclusion.19

Another argument in favor of gender-neutral laws is their

potential to mitigate the misuse and abuse of legal provisions
by both men and women. By eliminating gender-specific biases
and loopholes within the legal system, gender-neutral
legislation reduces the likelihood of false accusations, wrongful
convictions, and legal harassment. For example, laws
governing domestic violence and sexual offenses should be
crafted in a manner that protects all victims, regardless of their
gender, while also ensuring due process and accountability for
perpetrators. Strengthening safeguards against law misuse not
only enhances the credibility of the legal system but also
fosters a climate of trust and transparency.20

Furthermore, gender-neutral laws contribute to fostering

healthier and more equitable relationships between
individuals, families, and communities. By promoting mutual
respect, cooperation, and shared responsibilities, gender-
neutral legislation cultivates a culture of equality and mutual
support, thereby reducing conflict and violence within
households and society at large. For example, laws governing
marriage and divorce should prioritize the equitable
distribution of assets and liabilities, regardless of the genders

19
Aoife M O’Connor et al., “Transcending the Gender Binary under
International Law: Advancing Health-Related Human Rights for
Trans* Populations,” 50 The Journal of law, medicine & ethics : a
journal of the American Society of Law, Medicine & Ethics 409–24
(2022).
20
“Part 2: The Argument for a Gender-Neutral PoSH Legislation,”
Rainmaker Blog available at: https://rainmaker.co.in/blog/view/part-
2-the-argument-for-a-gender-neutral-posh-legislation.

248
 Journal of Namibian Studies, 39 S1 (2023): 238-258 ISSN: 2197-5523 (online)

of the spouses, to prevent financial exploitation and ensure a

dignified transition out of marriage.

6. CHALLENGES AND ROADBLOCKS IN IMPLEMENTING

GENDER NEUTRAL LAWS

Implementing gender-neutral laws poses several challenges

and roadblocks, ranging from societal attitudes and cultural
norms to legal complexities and institutional barriers. These
obstacles hinder efforts to promote gender equality and justice
within the legal system, requiring comprehensive strategies to
address systemic biases and ensure the effective
implementation of gender-neutral legislation.21

One significant challenge in implementing gender-neutral laws

is the resistance from entrenched patriarchal attitudes and
societal norms that perpetuate gender-based discrimination
and inequality. Deep-rooted beliefs regarding gender roles and
responsibilities often hinder progress towards gender equality,
leading to resistance and backlash against efforts to reform
existing legal frameworks. For example, laws governing
property rights and inheritance may be influenced by cultural
traditions and customs that prioritize male heirs over female
heirs, perpetuating economic disparities and limiting women's
access to resources and opportunities.22

Moreover, legal complexities and ambiguities surrounding

gender identity and expression pose challenges in crafting and
enforcing gender-neutral laws. While efforts have been made
to recognize and accommodate diverse gender identities
within legislative frameworks, the lack of standardized
definitions and terminology complicates implementation and
enforcement. For instance, laws governing access to public
facilities, healthcare services, and employment opportunities
may inadvertently exclude or marginalize transgender and
non-binary individuals due to inadequate legal recognition and
protection.

21
katharina.kiener-manu, “Crime Prevention & Criminal Justice
Module 9 Key Issues: Topic 1 - Gender-based discrimination and
women in conflict with the law” available at:
https://www.unodc.org/e4j/en/crime-prevention-criminal-
justice/module-9/key-issues/1--gender-based-discrimination-and-
women-in-conflict-with-the-law.html.
22
Mayank Gupta, Jayakrishna S Madabushi and Nihit Gupta,
“Critical Overview of Patriarchy, Its Interferences With
Psychological Development, and Risks for Mental Health,” 15
Cureus e40216 (2023).

249
 Journal of Namibian Studies, 39 S1 (2023): 238-258 ISSN: 2197-5523 (online)

Additionally, institutional barriers within the legal system,

including bias and discrimination among law enforcement
officials, judiciary, and legal practitioners, impede the effective
implementation of gender-neutral laws. Prejudices based on
gender stereotypes and biases may influence decision-making
processes, leading to unequal treatment and outcomes for
individuals of different genders. For example, male victims of
domestic violence or sexual assault may encounter skepticism
and disbelief from law enforcement agencies and courts,
perpetuating the misconception that such crimes primarily
affect women.

Furthermore, the lack of awareness and understanding among

policymakers, lawmakers, and the general public about the
importance and implications of gender-neutral laws poses a
significant obstacle to their implementation. Misconceptions
and myths about gender equality and justice may lead to
resistance or apathy towards legislative reforms aimed at
promoting gender neutrality. Education and awareness-raising
initiatives are essential to foster a more inclusive and
supportive environment for gender-neutral legislation,
ensuring broad-based support and engagement from
stakeholders.

Another challenge in implementing gender-neutral laws is the

absence of comprehensive data and research on gender-based
disparities and inequalities within the legal system. Limited
availability of disaggregated data based on gender identity and
expression hinders efforts to identify and address systemic
biases and gaps in legal protections. Without robust evidence
and analysis, policymakers may struggle to formulate effective
strategies and interventions to promote gender equality and
justice.23

Moreover, the politicization of gender issues and legislative

reforms can impede progress towards gender-neutral laws, as
competing interests and ideological differences may hinder
consensus-building and compromise. Political opposition to
gender-neutral legislation may stem from concerns about
perceived threats to traditional gender roles and power
structures, leading to legislative gridlock and stagnation.
Overcoming political resistance requires sustained advocacy

23
Eva Bermúdez Figueroa et al., “Gender and Structural Inequalities
from a Socio-Legal Perspective” Springer International Publishing,
2023 available at: https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-
031-14360-1_4.

250
 Journal of Namibian Studies, 39 S1 (2023): 238-258 ISSN: 2197-5523 (online)

and coalition-building efforts to mobilize support for gender

equality and justice initiatives.

CASE LAWS

As held by the Delhi High Court in the case of Rakesh v. State

of NCT of Delhi 24 (2023), the POCSO Act is applicable to
children of all genders, and claiming that it is being misused
due to its gender-inclusive terminology is misleading.

the Supreme Court of India in the case of “Binu Tamta & Anr.
Versus High Court Of Delhi & Ors. 25 ” on November 07,2023
refused the request made to direct that “sexual harassment”
be defined in gender-neutral terms to bring within its purview
acts of sexual harassment committed by respondents of the
same sex as the “aggrieved person”. The Court also refused to
direct that references to “aggrieved woman” be supplanted
with “aggrieved persons” to reflect the gender-neutral
protection of the (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal)
Regulations, 2013.

7. POLICY RECOMMENDATIONS

Policy recommendations aimed at addressing the challenges

surrounding gender-neutral laws and mitigating the misuse of
laws by both men and women are essential to promoting
fairness, equity, and justice within the legal system. These
recommendations encompass legislative reforms, institutional
initiatives, and awareness-raising efforts to foster a more
inclusive and supportive environment for gender equality and
justice.26

One key policy recommendation is the enactment of gender-

neutral legislation that ensures equal rights, protections, and
opportunities for individuals of all genders. Legislative reforms
should prioritize the elimination of gender-based biases and
stereotypes within existing laws, particularly those governing
family law, domestic violence, sexual offenses, and
employment rights. For example, laws governing parental
rights and child custody should be revised to promote shared

24
Rakesh v. State of NCT of Delhi CA No.75/2022
25
Binu Tamta & Anr. Versus High Court Of Delhi & Ors. (2014) 13
SCC 257
26
“National Policy for Women Empowerment Ministry of Women &
Child Development,” hudqm available at:
https://wcd.nic.in/womendevelopment/national-policy-women-
empowerment.

251
 Journal of Namibian Studies, 39 S1 (2023): 238-258 ISSN: 2197-5523 (online)

parenting responsibilities and ensure the best interests of the

child, regardless of the genders of the parents.27

Moreover, legislative reforms should incorporate stringent

safeguards against the misuse of laws by both men and
women, including penalties for false accusations, perjury, and
abuse of legal processes. For instance, provisions within the
Indian Penal Code and other relevant statutes should be
amended to deter individuals from making false complaints or
providing misleading evidence for personal gain or vendetta.
By strengthening accountability and transparency within the
legal system, policymakers can restore public trust and
confidence in the administration of justice.

In addition to legislative reforms, institutional initiatives are

essential to promote gender neutrality and prevent law misuse
within law enforcement agencies, judiciary, and legal
institutions. Training programs and capacity-building initiatives
should be implemented to raise awareness among law
enforcement officials, judges, and legal practitioners about
gender-based biases and stereotypes and their impact on
decision-making processes. Sensitization workshops and
educational modules on gender equality, diversity, and human
rights should be integrated into the curriculum of law schools
and professional training programs to instill a culture of gender
sensitivity and inclusivity within the legal profession.

Furthermore, institutional mechanisms for monitoring and

evaluating the implementation of gender-neutral laws and
addressing instances of law misuse should be strengthened.
Dedicated oversight bodies, such as gender equality
commissions or ombudsman offices, should be established to
investigate complaints of discrimination, bias, and misconduct
within the legal system and recommend corrective actions.
Transparent and accountable grievance redressal mechanisms
should be accessible to individuals who have experienced
injustice or discrimination based on their gender identity or
expression.

Public awareness and advocacy campaigns are crucial for

generating support and mobilizing action towards gender
equality and justice. Civil society organizations, grassroots
movements, and advocacy groups should collaborate with

27
Rebecca Stewart et al., “Gendered stereotypes and norms: A
systematic review of interventions designed to shift attitudes and
behaviour,” 7 Heliyon e06660 (2021).

252
 Journal of Namibian Studies, 39 S1 (2023): 238-258 ISSN: 2197-5523 (online)

government agencies, media outlets, and community leaders

to raise awareness about the importance of gender-neutral
laws and the consequences of law misuse. Public education
initiatives should focus on dispelling myths and misconceptions
about gender roles, stereotypes, and biases and promoting
values of equality, respect, and dignity for all individuals,
irrespective of their gender identity or expression.28

Moreover, collaborative efforts between government

agencies, civil society organizations, and academic institutions
are essential for conducting research and collecting data on
gender-based disparities and inequalities within the legal
system. Evidence-based policy-making requires reliable and
comprehensive data to identify gaps in legal protections,
assess the impact of legislative reforms, and inform targeted
interventions to promote gender equality and justice. By
investing in research and data collection efforts, policymakers
can develop evidence-based strategies to address systemic
biases and barriers to gender-neutral laws effectively.29

8. CONCLUSION

In conclusion, the quest for gender equality and justice within

India's legal system necessitates a nuanced understanding of
the challenges, opportunities, and complexities surrounding
the implementation of gender-neutral laws. While significant
strides have been made in advancing women's rights and
protections, persistent biases, societal norms, and institutional
barriers continue to hinder progress towards gender equality
for individuals of all genders.

The critique of existing laws reveals a dichotomy wherein

certain laws favor women, while others neglect the rights and
protections of men. Laws addressing issues such as domestic
violence and sexual offenses predominantly focus on
protecting women, often at the expense of male victims who
may encounter skepticism and disbelief within the legal
system. Conversely, laws governing areas such as parental
rights and child custody may exhibit biases that favor women

28
Ada Hasanagic, “25 Organizations Fighting for Gender Equality”
Human Rights Careers, 2019 available at:
https://www.humanrightscareers.com/magazine/organizations-
gender-equality/.
29
“Gender-Based Data Crucial for Developing Intersectional Digital
Spheres Reflecting Women’s, Girls’ Identities, Lives, Speakers Tell
Commission,” Meetings Coverage and Press Releases available at:
https://press.un.org/en/2023/wom2227.doc.htm.

253
 Journal of Namibian Studies, 39 S1 (2023): 238-258 ISSN: 2197-5523 (online)

over men, perpetuating stereotypes and inequalities within

families and society.

Moreover, instances of law misuse by both men and women

underscore the need for more balanced and equitable legal
provisions. False accusations, manipulation of legal processes,
and exploitation of gender-specific laws for personal gain or
vendetta erode trust in the legal system and perpetuate
injustice. Strengthening safeguards against law misuse and
enhancing accountability within the legal system are essential
to upholding the principles of fairness, equity, and due process
for all individuals.

Policy recommendations aimed at promoting gender-neutral

laws and preventing law misuse emphasize the importance of
legislative reforms, institutional initiatives, and public
awareness campaigns. Enacting gender-neutral legislation that
ensures equal rights and protections for individuals of all
genders is crucial for addressing systemic biases and
stereotypes within the legal system. Strengthening
accountability mechanisms and implementing penalties for law
misuse are essential to restoring public trust and confidence in
the administration of justice.

Institutional initiatives, including training programs and

capacity-building efforts, are necessary to raise awareness
among law enforcement officials, judges, and legal
practitioners about gender-based biases and stereotypes.
Public awareness and advocacy campaigns play a vital role in
mobilizing support for gender equality and justice initiatives
and dispelling myths and misconceptions about gender roles
and biases within society.

Collaborative efforts between government agencies, civil

society organizations, and academic institutions are essential
for conducting research and collecting data on gender-based
disparities and inequalities within the legal system. Evidence-
based policy-making requires reliable and comprehensive data
to inform targeted interventions and strategies to promote
gender equality and justice effectively.

Ultimately, achieving gender equality and justice within India's

legal system requires a collective commitment to challenging
entrenched biases, dismantling discriminatory practices, and
fostering a culture of inclusivity, respect, and dignity for all
individuals, irrespective of their gender identity or expression.
By adopting a holistic and multi-faceted approach that

254
 Journal of Namibian Studies, 39 S1 (2023): 238-258 ISSN: 2197-5523 (online)

addresses the root causes of gender-based discrimination and

inequality, policymakers can lay the groundwork for a more
just, equitable, and inclusive society.

9. SUGGESTIONS

Certainly, here are some suggestions to further the cause of

gender equality and justice within India's legal system:

1. Legislative Reforms: Advocate for the enactment of

gender-neutral laws across various domains, including
family law, domestic violence, sexual offenses, and
employment rights, to ensure equal rights and
protections for individuals of all genders.

2. Safeguards Against Law Misuse: Strengthen

accountability mechanisms and implement penalties
for law misuse, including false accusations and
manipulation of legal processes, to uphold the
principles of fairness, equity, and due process for all
individuals.

3. Institutional Training Programs: Provide training

programs and capacity-building initiatives for law
enforcement officials, judges, and legal practitioners
to raise awareness about gender-based biases and
stereotypes and promote gender sensitivity within the
legal system.

4. Public Awareness Campaigns: Launch public

awareness and advocacy campaigns to mobilize
support for gender equality and justice initiatives and
dispel myths and misconceptions about gender roles
and biases within society.

5. Research and Data Collection: Invest in research and

data collection efforts to gather comprehensive data
on gender-based disparities and inequalities within the
legal system, enabling evidence-based policy-making
and targeted interventions to promote gender equality
and justice effectively.

6. Collaborative Efforts: Foster collaboration between

government agencies, civil society organizations, and
academic institutions to develop holistic strategies and
interventions for advancing gender equality and justice
within the legal system.

255
 Journal of Namibian Studies, 39 S1 (2023): 238-258 ISSN: 2197-5523 (online)

By implementing these suggestions, policymakers can work

towards creating a more just, equitable, and inclusive legal
system that upholds the rights and dignity of all individuals,
irrespective of their gender identity or expression.

REFERENCES

1. Dixit, P. (2020). Navtej Singh Johar v Union of India:

decriminalising India’s sodomy law. The International
Journal of Human Rights, 24(8), 1011-1030.
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/13642987.
2019.1690465
2. Roy, A. (2021). Gender and citizenship in India. In Routledge
handbook of gender in South Asia (pp. 87-102). Routledge.
https://www.taylorfrancis.com/chapters/edit/10.4324/978
1003043102-9/gender-citizenship-india-anupama-roy
3. Jain, D., & DasGupta, D. (2021). Law, gender identity, and
the uses of human rights: The paradox of recognition in
South Asia. Journal of Human Rights, 20(1), 110-126.
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/14754835.
2020.1845129
4. Vijeyarasa, R. (2020). What is gender-responsive legislation?
Using international law to establish benchmarks for labour,
reproductive health and tax laws that work for women.
Griffith Law Review, 29(3), 334-350.
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/10383441.
2020.1853900
5. Chemerinsky, E. (2023). Constitutional law. Aspen
Publishing.
https://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=aM3lEAAA
QBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PR31&dq=CONSTITUTIONAL+PROVISION
S+IN+INDIA+AND+THE+NEED+FOR+GENDER+NEUTRAL+LA
WS&ots=SG6MoZzSX-&sig=J9-2owzcI-Q1NuIL_G2W2EarFig

6. Nigam, S. (2021). Domestic violence law in India: myth and

misogyny. Routledge India.
https://www.taylorfrancis.com/books/mono/10.4324/978
0429326974/domestic-violence-law-india-shalu-nigam
7. Modi, T. (2021). A Critique of Gender Neutrality in India.
Issue 2 Int'l JL Mgmt. & Human., 4, 1121.
https://heinonline.org/hol-cgi-
bin/get_pdf.cgi?handle=hein.journals/ijlmhs10&section=10
3
8. Nikharika. (2021). Gender Neutrality of Criminal Law in
India-A Comparative Myth or Reality with Special
Reference to Criminal Law (Amendment) Bill, 2019. Issue 1
Int'l JL Mgmt. & Human., 4, 916.
https://heinonline.org/hol-cgi-
bin/get_pdf.cgi?handle=hein.journals/ijlmhs9&section=77

256
Journal of Namibian Studies, 39 S1 (2023): 238-258 ISSN: 2197-5523 (online)

9. Malik, D. K. (2021). Women empowerment and gender

equality: A study of Indian constitution. Quest Journals
Journal of Research in Humanities and Social Science, 9(4),
27-33.
https://www.academia.edu/download/66264614/E090427
33.pdf
10. Khan, B. N., & Mishra, V. (2021). Acknowledging sexual
equality vis-a-vis article 21 of the Indian constitution: Issues
and challenges.
http://dr.ddn.upes.ac.in:8080/jspui/bitstream/123456789/
3602/1/Acknowledging%20sexual%20equality%20vis-
a%20Bharti%20Nair%20Chapter-10.pdf
11. Anushka; Chauhan, Mayank. (2021). Gender Neutrality for
LGBTQ in Rape Laws: The Need of the Hour. Indian JL & Legal
Rsch., 2, 1. https://heinonline.org/hol-cgi-
bin/get_pdf.cgi?handle=hein.journals/injlolw2&section=10
3
12. Subasini, N., Sasikumar, N., Kalaiyarasan, G., Ramnath, R.,
& MAHENDRAPRABHU, M. (2021). INDIAN CONSTITUTION
AND WOMEN LEGAL RIGHTS: A CONGLOMERATE ANALYSIS.
Ilkogretim Online, 20(5).
https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Subasini-
Nagarajan/publication/349768675_INDIAN_CONSTITUTION
_AND_WOMEN_LEGAL_RIGHTS_A_CONGLOMERATE_ANAL
YSIS/links/604102604585154e8c77cf75/INDIAN-
CONSTITUTION-AND-WOMEN-LEGAL-RIGHTS-A-
CONGLOMERATE-ANALYSIS.pdf
13. Thakur, Y. (2021). Men's Right in India. Supremo Amicus,
26, 602. https://heinonline.org/hol-cgi-
bin/get_pdf.cgi?handle=hein.journals/supami26&section=6
7
14. Aditi; Mordhwaj. (2021). Gender Inequality in Criminal Laws:
Denial of Rights to Men and Transgender. Supremo Amicus,
24, 787. https://heinonline.org/hol-cgi-
bin/get_pdf.cgi?handle=hein.journals/supami24&section=8
8
15. Akanksha, B. (2021). Gender Neutrality of Sexual Offences.
Issue 4 Int'l JL Mgmt. & Human., 4, 3015.
https://heinonline.org/hol-cgi-
bin/get_pdf.cgi?handle=hein.journals/ijlmhs12&section=28
2
16. Panchori, D. (2021). Gender Justice and Judicial System. Jus
Corpus LJ, 2, 106. https://heinonline.org/hol-cgi-
bin/get_pdf.cgi?handle=hein.journals/juscrp2&section=161
17. Ukrani, A. (2021). An Anti-Discrimination Law for India: An
Analysis of the Equality Bill, 2021. DME Journal of Law,
2(01), 85-93.
https://www.dmejournals.com/index.php/DMEJL/article/vi
ew/111

257
Journal of Namibian Studies, 39 S1 (2023): 238-258 ISSN: 2197-5523 (online)

18. Desikan, G. V. (2022). Sex Laws and Constitutional Rights in

India: A Quintessential Paradox concerning Gender
Neutrality. Issue 4 Int'l JL Mgmt. & Human., 5, 1169.
https://heinonline.org/hol-cgi-
bin/get_pdf.cgi?handle=hein.journals/ijlmhs18&section=10
8
19. Pandita, S. (2022). Gender Neutrality of Indian Laws-Myth
or Reality?. FIMT Law Journal, 5(1).
https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=412
3805
20. Dhingra, A. (2022). Gender discourses and the making of
the Indian Constitution. Indian Journal of Gender Studies,
29(1), 33-54.
https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/097152152
11056794

21. Baloni, A., & Ahmad, K. (2023). A 21st century quest for
gender neutral maintenance in the Indian legal system.
International Journal of Human Rights and Constitutional
Studies, 10(4), 323-335.
https://www.inderscienceonline.com/doi/abs/10.1504/IJH
RCS.2023.133754
22. Bindal, M., & Shrivastava, P. (2023). Gender-Neutral Rape
Laws: Addressing the Long-Standing Conundrum in Indian
Laws. Asian Law & Public Policy Review, 8, 119-136.
https://thelawbrigade.com/wp-
content/uploads/2023/08/Megha-Prakshay-ALPPR.pdf
23. Yadav, J., Rani, M., Choudhury, P., Mishra, P., & Singh, K.
(2023). Gender-Discriminatory Criminal Laws in India: A
Critical Analysis. Boletin de Literatura Oral-The Literary
Journal, 10(1), 3226-3232.
http://www.boletindeliteraturaoral.com/index.php/bdlo/a
rticle/view/644
24. Lathika, K. D. The Need for a Gender-Neutral Domestic
Violence Act. In Forensic Justice (pp. 204-218). Routledge.
https://www.taylorfrancis.com/chapters/edit/10.4324/978
1032629346-14/need-gender-neutral-domestic-violence-
act-kumari-lathika

258