Negligence Course Outline
Negligence Course Outline
SCHOOL OF LAW
SECOND YEAR SECOND SEMESTER
NEGLIGENCE AND STRICT LIABILITY
COURSE DESCRIPTION/OUTLINE
Negligent invasions of interests in person and property; strict liability; invasions of privacy, nuisance.
Occupier’s liability; procedural issues in the law of torts.
1. Enable students to grasp the meaning of negligence as a cause of action as well as its socio-economic
basis.
2. Enable student to understand nuisance occupiers’ liability, private and public nuisance and strict
liability.
3. Enable students to understand death as a cause of action and other provisions of the Law Reform
(Miscellaneous Provision Act).
LEARNING OUTCOMES
1. Identify and explain the ingredients of the remedies and defenses to an action of negligence
2. Identify and explain as well as distinguish between the torts strict liability, public and private
nuisance and occupiers’ liability.
3. Identity and appreciate the nature of death as a cause of action and certain procedural elements in
relation to actions against the government.
REQUIREMENTS
Students MUST:
1. COME TO CLASS ON TIME
2. Hand in assignments and course work on time
1
3. Participate actively in class, discussions, regularly assessments and study group activities. A student
shall only qualify to sit and write an examination for this course if he or she has 75% attendance
METHOD OF GRADING
NOTE:
The course emphases a student-centred learning experience this means that the lectures will mainly be
active learning rather than passive. Students are encouraged to actively participate in the learning experience
and the Lecturer will only facilitate, provide resources to the students and guide the students as
opposed to presenting information to the students.
REFERENCE BOOKS
1. W.V.H.ROGERS, 14/ Winfred & Jolowicz on Tort, 16th Edition, London,Sweet & Maxwell,
2002/17`h Edition, London, Maxwell, 2006.
2. JOHN MURPHY, Street on Torts, 12`1 Edition, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2006.
3. GRAHAM STEPHENSON, Sourcebook on Torts, 2nd Edition, Cavendish Publishing
Ltd, 2000.
4. MARKESINIS B.S. & DEAKINS S.F, Tort Law, 4th Edition, Claredon Press, Oxford 1999.
5. JOHN G. Fleming, The law of Torts, 9th Edition, 1998.
6. CLERK & LINDSELL, On Torts, The Common Law Library No.3, 17th Edition, London, Sweet &
Maxwell, 1995.
7. E.VEITCH, East African cases on the law of Torts, London, Sweet & Maxwell, 1972
8. HEYDON J. D, Economic Torts, London, Sweet & Maxwell, 1973.
9. PAGE KEETON & ROBERT KEETON, Tort Cases and Materials, American casebook series, West
Publishing Co.
10. MUNKMAN JOHN, Employer's Liability at Common Law, 7th Edition,
Butterworth, 1971.
11. SALMOND on the law of Torts, 9th Edition, London, Sweet & Maxwell, 1977. I2. HARRY STREET,
The Law of Torts, 5th Edition, Butterworths, 1972, 6th Edition, London Butterworths, 1976.
13. TONY WEIR, 4 Casebook on Tort, 6th Edition, London. Sweet & Maxwell, 1988, 8th Edition, Sweet
& Maxwell, 1996, 9th Edition.
14. WINFIELD on Tort, 6th Edition, Sweet & Maxwell, London, 1954.
2
15. R.A. PERCY, Charlesworth on Negligence, The Common Law Library No.6, 4th Edition, London,
Sweet & Maxwell 1962, 5th Edition in 1971 and 9th Edition in 1997.
16. KEMP & KEMP, The Quantum of Damages, vol.1, 2nd Edition, London, Sweet & Maxwell 1964.
17. P.M. NORTH, Occupiers; Liability, London, Butterworth, 1971
18. P.S.ATIYAH, Vicarious Liability in the Law of Torts, London, Butterworths. 1967.
19. JOHN LOGAN. Briefcase: Tort Lou'. 2" Edition, Cavendish Publishing Ltd 1996.
20. DAVID HOWARH, Text Book. on Tort, Butterworth, London. 1995.
21. VIVIENNE HARPWOOD, Principles of Tort Law, 3rd Edition. Cavendish Publishing
Ltd, 1997, 4`'' Edition2000.
22. HALSBURY'S Laws of England Tort of Negligence, 4th Edition, Vol. 34.
23. P.S. ATIYAH, Accidents Compensation the law, Willmer Brothers Ltd. Birkenhead. 1970.
24. CARTER. Ruck on Libel &,Slander, Butterworth, 5th Edition, 1997.
25. RICHARD BINGHAM. /111 the Modern Cases 017 Negligence, 2" Edition, Sweet & Maxwell.
1964.
26. A.S. BURROWS. Remedies for Torts & Breach of Contract, London, Butterworth,
1987.
27. C.H.S FIFOOT, History & Sources of the Common Lou.' and Contract, London, Stevens & Sons Ltd,
1949.
28. HEPPLE & MATHEWS, Tort: Cases & Materials, London, Butterworth. 1974, 4th Edition, 1991.
29. WILLIAM PROSSER. Law of Toils, Hornbook Series, Berkley6. California. 1955.
30. GLANVILLE WILLIWMA & B.A. HEPPLE, Foundations Foundations of the Law of Torl. London,
Butterworth, 1976, 2" Edition, 1984.
31. RALPH THERAN, Tort in a Nutshell, 2" Edition, London, Sweet & Maxwell. 1990.
32. W.L. MORISON, ROBIN L. SHARWOOD &C.0 PHEGAN, Cases on Torts Edition,
1973.
33. CECIL A. 'WIGHT, Cases on the Law of Torts, 4th Edition, London.
Butterworths, 1967.
34. R.A. BUCKLEY, The Modern Law of Negligence, 2nd Edition Butterworths. London, Dublin,
Edinburg, 1993.
35. CHARLES KRAMER, The rules of Evidence In Negligence Cases, Revised Edition 1966 by
Practicing Law Institute.
36:HAROLD & MARVIN V. ANSUBEL, Preparation of a Negligence Case, Revised
Edition 1970, Practicing Laws Institute.
37. Sir BRIAN NEILL & RICHARD RAMPTON, Duncan & Neill 017 defamation..2nd Edition.
London. Butterworths, 1983.
38. WADLOW C.. The Law of Passing of oil. London. Sweet &Maxwell, 1990.
39. DAVID GREEN, Q & A Series Torts Law, 4th Edition, Cavendish Publishing 2001.
40. RICHARD QUEN, Essential Tort Law, 3rd Edition. Cavendish Publishing. 2000.
41. CAROL HARLOW, Understanding Tort Law 2nd Edition. Fontana Press. 1995.
42. VERA BERMINGHAM„Nutcases Tort, Ist Edition, 1996, 4th Edition in 1996. 5th Edition in 1999.
Sweet & Maxwell.
43. The Digest, Annotated British, Common Wealth & European Cases, Butterworrhs, Volumes, 17 (2)
Damages, 32 (1) Libel & Slander, 36 (1)
3
Negligence, 36 (2) Nuisance.
44. Halsbury's Lows of England, 4th Edition, Butterworths, Volumes: 28 (Libel to Local Government),
34 (Negligence to Parliament)
45. D.G. Cracknell, Cracknell's Law students companion Torts, 4th Edition in 1978, and 60 Edition in
19.83.
46. Salmond and Henston on The Law of Torts, 9° Edition, Sweet and Maxwell 1987.
47. Edward J. Kionka, Torts: Injuries to persons and property West publishing Company, 1981.
NEGLIGENCE
DUTY OF CARE
4
16. Brooks v Metropolitan Police Comr [2005] UKHL 24 at [17], [2005] 2 All ER 489 at [17], [2005]
1 WLR 1495 at [17]
17. Customs and Excise Comrs v Barclays Bank plc [2006] UKHL 28 at [32], [2007] 1 AC 181 at [32],
[2006] 4 All ER 256 at [32] .
18. Grant v Australian Knitting Mills Ltd [1936] AC 85 at 103, PC.
STANDARD OF CARE
6
51. Marc Rich & Co AG and others. v Bishop Rock Marine Co Ltd and others. The Nicholas H [1994]
*ALL ER 686. (C'. A).
52. Marc Rich & Co AG and others v Bishop Rock Marine Co Ltd and others The Nicholas 11995) 3
ALL El? 307 (11.L)
53. Welsh v Chief Constable of Merseyside Police and another 119931 I ALL El? 692.
54. RMC.' Roadstone Products Ltd v Jester 119941 4 ALL ER 1037.
55. Walker v Northumberland County Council [1995] 1 ALL El? 73 7.
56. Theresa Okoth Ofirmbi and another v A limed Karim (1993) 2 KALI? 112.
57. Andrews v Schooling and Others 11991] 3 ALL El? 723.
58. McAuley v Bristol City Council [1992] 1 ALL ER 74449.
8
CAUSATION & REMOTENESS
RESCUE SITUATIONS
10
4. Harrison v. British Rlys Board (1981)3 ALL ER 679
5. Crossley v. Rawlison (1981)3 ALL ER 674
6. Ogwo v. Taylor (1987)3 ALL ER 961
7. Salomon v. Seafare Restaurants Ltd. (1983) ALL ER 7
11
FAILURE TO ACT AS NEGLIGENCE or OMISSIONS
12
PROOF - RES I PSA LOQUITUR
DEFENCE TO NEGLIGENCE
Contributory negligence.
1. Chrisofull V E.Atobacco Co. Ltd. (1960) E.A 800 V/- 2.
Wilson & Anor V. Jack Bryant (1960) E.A
3. Queen's Hotel V. Cummings (1953) EA 4.
Alio V. 1Vlbarak (1956) EA
5. Ag V. Vinod & Another (1971) EA 147
6. Nasanairi Nkata V.Ali Kisoke & Anor. (1973) HCB 46
7. Filipo Munyampirwa V. Associated Match Co. (1973) HCB 63
8. Patel V. Yafeesi & Ors (1972) EA 28
9. Nsubuga V. P.N. Kavuma (1978) HCB 307
13
10. Fitzgerald V. Lane & Anor (1987)2 All EAR 454
14
11. Capps V. Miller (1989)2 All ER 333
12. Kasimu Mukasa V. K.C.C. (1979) HCB 93
13. Nanyanzi Agnes V. Uganda Metal Products (1989) KALR
14. Kimera V. Nurali Jiwani (1971)1 ULR 194
15. Fernandes V. Peoples' Newspaper Ltd. (1971)1 ULR 119
16. Ag V. Joseph Barwogeza (1975) HCB 1
17. Peter Ndura V. Ag 1975 NCB 78
18. Yoko Mukasa V. A G 1993 4 KALR 8
19. Kibimba Rice Co. Ltd V Umar Salim 1992 5 KALR 17
20. Lydia Oketcho V Nimrod Okuna & 2 Ors 1994-95 H•CB 78
21. Alliance & Leicester Building Soc. V Edgestop & Ors 1994 2 All ER
15
8. Burgess V Florence Nightingale 1955 1 QB 349
16
9. Hayden V Hayden 1992 4 All E R 681
10. Barret V Min Of Defence 1995 3 AIIER 87
11. I I. 7 . 7 . i 1 1 Z i 1 1 C 2 , L 1 Zzizinga V U C B 1993 1 KALR 72
12. Margaret Kirumira & Ors VStirling 1990-91 KALR 25 13.Jolabeu Nathala Joshi & 5 Ors
V Popat & Sons 1970 FIC13.
13. Agnes iviasena V Utc 1975 Ltd 1992-93 HCB 207
14. Edward Nyanzi & Anna Ma's ejje V Securicor 197$ FIC.I3 92
15. Frank Makumbi V Kigczi Africa Bus 1986 FICB 69
16. U.E.B V G. Ni1 Musoke 1994 1 KALR 163
18
S. R V Bernina & V Codling, R V Elvin 1994 3 All ER. 964
8. R. V. Crown Court At Knightsbridge, R V DPP 1993 4 All ER 49.1
9. Filburn V The People's Palace & Aquarium Ltd. 1890 25 QBD 258
10. Lowery V Walker 1911111 AC 10
11. Baker V Smell 1908 2 KB 825
12. Brock V Richards 1951 1 KB 529.
D. NUISANCE
PUBLIC NUISANCE
1. Arima Nantongo & Anor V HOral Mohammed 1974 HCB 181V
2. AR V Kafeero Mambulc 1959 EA 665
3. Kitamirike V Mutagubya 1965 EA 443
4. Singh & Ors V Lochaba & Anor 1966 EA 401
5. Lyon V Gulliver 1914 Ch 631
6. Tindarweisire V Kabala Town Council 1980 HCB33
7. Mombasa Auto Services V Esso Petroleum 1968 Ch 605
8. Bower V Peate 1873 1 OB 321
9. Nlatania V Nat. Provincial Bank 1936 2 All ER 633
10. Dcp Or Transport N \V Water Auth 1983 3 All ER 273
11. Holiday V National Telephone Co 1899 2 QB 182
12. Ridgetown Rly Ltd V Lockshire Electricity Board 1965 Ch 436 :13. Halsey V Esso
Petroleum Co Ltd 1961 1 \VLR 683
19
13. AB ,S: Ors V SW Water Services Ltd 1992 4 All ER 574
20
14. Jones V Llanrost Urban Dist. Council 1911 1 Ch 393
15. R. V 'Metropolitan Stupendiary Magistrate 1993 3 All ER 113
16. City 01 Londan Corp V Bovis Coust: Ltd 1992 3 All ER 697
17. Gillingham Borough Council V Medway Dock Co 1992 3 All ER 923
18. AB & Ors V Awe Water Services Ltd 1992 4 All ER 574
19. AB & Ors V SW Water Services Ltd 1992 4 Al! ER 574
20. Stovin V Wise Norfolk C.0 1994 3 All ER 467
21. Nurundin Abdutla V British 1958 17 EACA 72
PRIVATE NUISANCE
1. Sedleigh-Dentield V O'callaghan 1940 AC 880
2. C:ollingwood V Home Colonial Store 1940 3 All
ER 200
3. Warren V Brown 1900 2 QB 197
4. Christie V Davie 1893 1 Ch 316
5. liollvwood Silver Fox Farm V Emmet 1936 2 KB
468
6. Malone V Laskey 1907 KB 144
7. British Celanese Ltd V Hunt (Capacitators) 1970
2 All ER 1252
8. Chrohurst V Burial Board 01 Parish Amarsham
1878 4 Ex D 5
9. Ag V Cooke 1932 1 CO 89
10. Hoare & Co. V. McAlpine 1923 1 Ch 167
11. Laws & Ors V Florinplace Ltd & Anor 1981 1 All
ER 659
12. Khoras and Jian V Bush 1993 3 ALLER 669.
13. Tetley & Ors V.Chitty & Ors (1986) 1 ALL ER
663
14. Kennaway V. Thompson & Anor (1981) 1 QB 89
15. Allen V.Gulf Oil Refining Ltd (1981AC1001
16. Aitken V. South Hams Dist Council (1994)3 ALL
ER400
17. Laskey & Ors V.Nat Trust For Places Of Interest
(1980)1 QB 485
18. Miller & Anor V. Jackson & ORS (1977)1 QB
966
19. Lemmon V. Webb (1894)3 Ch.1
20. Tate&Lyle Ind. V.London Council & Anor
(1983)2 AC 509
21
21. Butler V. Standard Telephones, Mccarthy (1940)1
ALL ER 121
22. Nat Rivers Auth V. Yokshire, Water Services
(1994)4 ALL ER 274
23. Nat Water Auth. Wright Eng Co Ltd (1994)4 ALL
ER 281
24. Nat Rivers Auth V. Alfred McAlpine Homes Ltd
(1994)4 ALL ER 286
25. Wheeler & Anor V. J.J. Saunders Ltd (1995)2
ALL ER697
26. Wychavon D.0 V. Nat Rivers Auth (1993)2 ALL
ER 440
27. Leeman V. Montagu (1936)2 UBD 1677
E. OCCUPIER'S LIABILITY
1. Bakabonieki V. Bunyoro District Administration (1970) EA 310
22
2. Sole V. W.J Halt Ltd (1973)2 WLR 171
23
3. Comm For Railways V. Quinlan (1964) 2 WLR 817
4. Videan V. British Transport Comm. (1963) 2 Qb650
5. Glasgow Corp V. Muir (1943) Ac 448: (1943)2 ALL ER 44
6. Phipps V. Rochester Corp (1955) 1 ALL ER 129
7. British Rlys Board V. Herrington (1971) 1 ALL ER 897
8. Haseldine V. C.A. Dan & Son Ltd (1941)3 ALL ER 156
9. Kibedi V. Uganda Sugar Factory Ltd (1978) HCB 195
10. Plannet V. McGuinnes (1972) 2 QB 599
11. Ferguson V. Welsh & Ors (1987)3 ALL ER77
12. Vincesio Kyoibera V. W.Mmengo Dist. Admin (19871)1 ULR 273
13. Solomon V. Seafarer Restaurants (1983)3 All ER 727
14. Mcgeown V. N.I Reland Housing Executive (1994)3 AIIER 53
15. Allan William Goldman V. Rapers William (1967) AC 645
16. Lowery V. Walker (1911) AC 10
17. Andrews V. Schooling & Ors (1991)3 All ER 723 1
18. Harris V.Brickenhead Corp & Anor (1976)1 WLR 279 White
ECONOMIC TORTS
1. Lonrho Plc V. Fayed & Ors (19890)2 All ER 68
2. Daily Nirrow Newpapers V.Garncr & Ors (1968)2 All ER163
3. Rookes V. Barnard (1964)1 All ER367
4. J.Bollinger & Ors V. Costa Brava Wine Co.(1960)1 Ch 262
5. Universal Thermo Sensors Lyd V.Hibben & Ors (1992)3 All ER 257
6. Constantine V. imperial London Hotels (1944)2 All ER 171
7. Frank Redawav Tors V. George Benham Anor (1 S96) AC 199
24
8. Glamorgan Coal Co Ltd .V. S.Walcs Miner' Fed.(1903)2 KB 545
9. Havana Ciger & Tobacco Factories Ltd V.Oddenino (1924)1 CH. 179
10. Cutler V.Wandsworth Stadium Ltd (1949) AC 398
11. Royscoit Trust Ltd Rogerson (1991)2 QB 297
12. London Armoury Co.Ltd .V.Everready Co.(Gr.B) Ltd (1941)1 KB 74,2
13. Sharneyford Supplies Ltd V.Edge Barrington (1986)1 Ch 128
14. Leigh & Sillavan V.Alliakmon Shipping Co. (1986)1 AC 785
15. Darbishire V.Warran (1963)1 WLR 1067
16. The Singer Manufacturing Co.V.Hermann Logg (1882)8 App cas i 5
17. Bents Brewery Co.Ltd & Anotv.Luke Hogan (1945)2 All ER 570
18. Erven Warwick & Ors V. Townend & Sons Ltd (1979)2 ALL ER 927
19. Reckitt & Coleman Products V. Borden Inc & Ors (1990)1 ALL ER 873
20. Akticbolaget Jonkoping V.La Match Co. (1964) EA 62
21. Timothy White V. Guster Mellin (1895) AC 154
22. RateHIT V. Evans (1895)2 QI3 525
23. Spring V.Guardian Ass.Plc & Ors (1994)3 ALL. ER 129
24. Inland Revenve Comm. V.11 Ambrook (1956)3 ALL ER 338
25. British Motor Trade Ass. V Salvadori & Ors 1949 1 ALL ER 208
26. Mallet & Anor V. Dunn 1949 1 ALL ER 972
27. Torquay Hotel Co V Cousins & Ors 1968 3 ALL ER 43
28. D.C. Thormsom Co Ltd V Deakin & Ors 1952 2 ALL ER 361
29. British Industrial Plastics & Ors V. Ferguson & Ors 1940 1 ALL ER 479
30. Naughton & Anor V. O'callaghan 1990 3 ALL ER 19l
31. East & Anon V Maurer & Anor 1991 2 ALL ER 733
32. Emerald Const. Co V Lowthian & Ors 1966 1 ALL ER 1013
33. Murphy V Brentwood District Council 1991 1 AC 398
34. Crofter Handwoven Harris Tweed V Veitch 1942 1 ALL ER. 142
35. Junior Brooks V Veitch Co Ltd 1982 3 ALL ER 201
36. Al-Nakib Investments V Longroft & Ors 1966 1 ALL ER 1013 37. Morgan Crucible Co.
V. Hill Samuel Bank Ltd 1991 1 ALL ER 148
38. Spartan steel & Alloys v. Martin Co. Ltd. [1973] QB 27.
39. Simaan Gen. Cont. v. Pilkington Glass (No.2). [1988] QB 758.
40. Mutual Lilo & citiaen Ass v. Evatt [19 71] AC 793.
41. Esso Petroleum v. Mardou [1976] I QB 801.
42. Chandry v. Probhakas [1989] 1 WLR 29.
43. Smith v. Bussh [1990] 1 AC 831.
44. Harris v. Wyre Forest D.C. [1990] 1 AC 831.
45. Carpro Industries Plc v. Dickman [1990] 2 AC 605.
46. Ross v. Counters [1980] Ch 297.
47. Allen v. Flood [1898] Ac 1.-
25
48. Ware v. De Frenile v. Motor Trade Ass [1921] 3 KB 40.
26
49. Jones Bross v. Stevens [1955] 1 QB 715.
50. Temperton v. Russell [1893] 1 QB 715.
51. The Arpad [1934] P 189.
52. Electrochrome v. Welsh Plastics [1968] 2 ALL ER 20
27