pysch
pysch
Passamonti et al (2012)
A - To investigate the relationship between neurotransmission (serotonin levels) and violent
behavior
S - Healthy volunteers, 19 participants, 9 women and 10 men, average age of 25
M - Healthy participants' serotonin levels were manipulated by altering their diet using
tryptophan (an amino acid that builds serotonin levels). Placebo with normal levels of tryptophan
and drink that lacked tryptophan. Took place in two weeks, 1 session each week. fMRI scans
are used to measure brain activity when serotonin is manipulated and they are exposed to
emotional faces as well (happy, sad, etc.) and participants then self-reported mood.
- Reduced activity in the frontal lobe during low serotonin conditions when participants viewed
an angry face. Reduced activation of the prefrontal cortex may affect violence and react
impulsively.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 1/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
Under it:
- Strict localization is the idea that very particular parts of the brain perform particular functions.
- Relative localization is the idea that different functions are handled by larger areas, like
hemispheres.
- One of the earliest discoveries in this was the discovery of a speech center by Paul Broca in
1861 while studying “Tan”. Tan lost the ability to speak when he was 30 and could only say the
word “tan”. An autopsy of his brain once he died showed a lesion in the frontal area of the left
hemisphere in an area now known as “Broca’s area”.
Maguire et al (2000)
A - Investigate neuroplasticity for spatial memory in taxi drivers
S - 16 right handed male licensed taxi drivers, Average experience was around 14 years (range
of 1.5 to 42 years). All healthy.
MRI scans of control subjects taken from a database where brain scans were performed with
taxi drivers. Control subjects were between 32 and 62 years, right handed, and healthy. 50 in
total.
M - MRI scans of taxi drivers and control subjects
R - increased brain matter volume in the brains of taxi drivers in the posterior hippocampus.
Control subjects had more grey matter in the anterior hippocampus. General volume of the
hippocampus was the same, but redistribution from anterior to posterior (i.e. front to back).
(however another explanation is the people with more grey matter in the front CHOOSE to be
taxi drivers).
So to test this.
M - correlation between hippocampal volume and time as a taxi driver
R - grey matter volume in posterior hippocampus correlation with experience being a taxi driver.
Reverse relationship with grey matter in anterior hippocampus.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 2/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
Draganski et al (2004)
A - to investigate whether the human brain can really change structure in response to
environmental demands
S - random sampling design, self-selected sample, volunteers split up into group: jugglers and
non-jugglers
M - both groups had no experience in juggling and brain scan performed. Juggler group had 3
months of classes and then second brain scan performed. Another three months where jugglers
were not supposed to practice juggling. 3rd brain scan.
R - 1st brain scan, no difference between groups. 2nd brain scan, juggler group had more grey
matter in some areas of the cortex, especially the mid-temporal area (known for coordination
and movement) in both the left and right hemispheres. 3rd brain scan, difference decreased but
still remained. Jugglers with better performances had more grey matter than others.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 3/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
- So, neurotransmission of impulses can have an effect on behavior in different ways depending
on changing the levels of different neurotransmitters.
- Serotonin is a neurotransmitter that helps to form neural networks. It is inhibitory and has been
linked to aggressive behaviors.
Passamonti et al (2012)
A - To investigate the relationship between neurotransmission (serotonin levels) and violent
behavior
S - Healthy volunteers, 19 participants, 9 women and 10 men, average age of 25
M - Healthy participants' serotonin levels were manipulated by altering their diet using
tryptophan (an amino acid that builds serotonin levels). Placebo with normal levels and drink
that lacked tryptophan. Took place in two weeks, 1 session each week. fMRI scans are used to
measure brain activity when serotonin is manipulated and they are exposed to emotional faces
as well (happy, sad, etc.) and participants then self-reported mood.
- Reduced activity in the frontal lobe during low serotonin conditions when participants viewed
an angry face. Reduced activation of the prefrontal cortex may affect violence and react
impulsively.
CE - Because serotonin helps form neural networks, reduced serotonin could cause a disruption
to these networks and could lead to less connectivity between areas of the brain. An example of
this is the amygdala-PFC neural network. Our amygdala generates emotions (especially
negative ones like fear and anger). Our prefrontal cortex (PFC) can help control our
emotions.Low serotonin levels is linked to more aggressive behaviors.
Draganski et al (2004)
A - to investigate whether the human brain can really change structure in response to
environmental demands
S - random sampling design, self-selected sample, volunteers split up into group: jugglers and
non-jugglers
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 4/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
M - both groups had no experience in juggling and brain scan performed. Juggler group had 3
months of classes and then second brain scan performed. Another three months where jugglers
were not supposed to practice juggling. 3rd brain scan.
R - 1st brain scan, no difference between groups. 2nd brain scan, juggler group had more grey
matter in some areas of the cortex, especially the mid-temporal area (known for coordination
and movement) in both the left and right hemispheres. 3rd brain scan, difference decreased but
still remained. Jugglers with better performances had more grey matter than others.
Passamonti et al (2012)
A - To investigate the relationship between neurotransmission (serotonin levels) and violent
behavior
S - Healthy volunteers, 19 participants, 9 women and 10 men, average age of 25
M - Healthy participants' serotonin levels were manipulated by altering their diet using
tryptophan (an amino acid that builds serotonin levels). Placebo with normal levels and drink
that lacked tryptophan. Took place in two weeks, 1 session each week. fMRI scans are used to
measure brain activity when serotonin is manipulated and they are exposed to emotional faces
as well (happy, sad, etc.) and participants then self-reported mood.
- Reduced activity in the frontal lobe during low serotonin conditions when participants viewed
an angry face. Reduced activation of the prefrontal cortex may affect violence and react
impulsively.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 5/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
Feder et al (2014)
A - investigate the effectiveness of ketamine on reducing the symptoms of PTSD/depression
M - participants diagnosed with PTSD were given ketamine or another antidepressant (2 weeks
apart (repeated measures)). Their symptoms of PTSD and depression were measured before
and after the treatment using a questionnaire. Randomized order (preventing order effect) and
double blind procedure (to prevent researcher bias).
R - ketamine reduced symptoms drastically compared to the other drug (was more effective in
reducing PTSD symptoms)
ketamine is an effective anti-PTSD drug; blocking glutamate receptors may be an effective
treatment for depression and PTSD (because ketamine is the antagonist for glutamate)
Luby et al (2013)
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 6/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
A - To see how children’s brain development and therefore their cognitive development is
affected by behavior
S - 145 children already enrolled in a 10 year study of pre-school depression who had already
undergone testing before
M - longitudinal study. Once a year (for 3-6 years), children had taken cognitive, emotional, and
social aptitude tests, along with parental involvement and stressful or negative events.
Collecting this info, two MRI scans, one of the entire brain and one of the hippocampus and
amygdala.
R - Hippocampus and amygdala showed less grey matter in the MRI scans of the poorer
children, with a positive correlation between income/needs being met and brain volume.
Children grown under positive care had less negative effect in hippocampus. Stressful events
affected only left hippocampus.
CE - Stress may accelerate neural pruning during adolescence. This could explain links
between people who have high levels of stress and reduced brain development
Feder et al (2014)
A - investigate the effectiveness of ketamine on reducing the symptoms of PTSD/depression
M - participants diagnosed with PTSD were given ketamine or another antidepressant (2 weeks
apart (repeated measures)). Their symptoms of PTSD and depression were measured before
and after the treatment using a questionnaire. Randomized order (preventing order effect) and
double blind procedure (to prevent researcher bias).
R - ketamine reduced symptoms drastically compared to the other drug (was more effective in
reducing PTSD symptoms)
ketamine is an effective anti-PTSD drug; blocking glutamate receptors may be an effective
treatment for depression and PTSD (because ketamine is the antagonist for glutamate)
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 7/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
Passamonti et al (2012)
A - To investigate the relationship between neurotransmission (serotonin levels) and violent
behavior
S - Healthy volunteers, 19 participants, 9 women and 10 men, average age of 25
M - Healthy participants' serotonin levels were manipulated by altering their diet using
tryptophan (an amino acid that builds serotonin levels). Placebo with normal levels and drink
that lacked tryptophan. Took place in two weeks, 1 session each week. fMRI scans are used to
measure brain activity when serotonin is manipulated and they are exposed to emotional faces
as well (happy, sad, etc.) and participants then self-reported mood.
- Reduced activity in the frontal lobe during low serotonin conditions when participants viewed
an angry face. Reduced activation of the prefrontal cortex may affect violence and react
impulsively.
CE - Because serotonin helps form neural networks, reduced serotonin could cause a disruption
to these networks and could lead to less connectivity between areas of the brain. An example of
this is the amygdala-PFC neural network. Our amygdala generates emotions (especially
negative ones like fear and anger). Our prefrontal cortex (PFC) can help control our emotions.
Communication between the amygdala and the frontal lobe was weaker in this low serotonin
condition. Adequate amounts of serotonin are necessary for a stable mood and to balance any
excessive excitatory neurotransmitter firing in the brain. The reduced activity in their PFC as a
result of the low serotonin may also affect their ability to inhibit impulsive reactions and think
through their actions.
Explain the role of one hormone in human behavior, making use of one
study.
- Hormones are chemical messengers that are released into the bloodstream and travel with
blood to their destination
[ Difference from neurotransmitters:
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 8/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
- Hormones regulate long term processes (growth, digestion, metabolism, etc.) while the
nervous system focuses on more rapid processes. Hormones allow less voluntary control
compared to neural regulation ]
- Oxytocin is a hormone produced in the hypothalamus and released into blood by the pituitary
gland
- It has a role in sexual reproduction, childbirth, and social bonding. Also known as "the love
hormone", "the bonding hormone", and the "the cuddle chemical"
Kosfeld et al (2005)
A - To investigate the role of oxytocin in interpersonal trust
S - 128 healthy male students, mean age of 22 years
M - Oxytocin and placebo group administered intranasally. Subjects assigned the role of
investor and trustee and partook in a trust game with monetary stakes. Starts with all getting 12
monetary units. The investor then decides how much to send to the trustee (0,4,8, or 12 units)
which is then tripled and sent to the trustee. The trustee then decides how much to send back.
This happens 4 times.
R - The level of trust in the oxytocin group is higher, median transfer of 10 while 8 in placebo
group. 45% of the oxytocin group showed maximum trust while only 21% in the placebo group
did.
CE - Oxytocin reduces risk aversion or oxytocin increases people’s trust in other humans.
Follow up study with computers done,
M - independent group of subjects played a similar trust game but against a random
mechanism. The algorithm is modeled on the previous game’s players.
R - No difference between oxytocin and placebo group, median transfer of 8 for both.
CE - Oxytocin affects trust in interpersonal interactions.
Refuting study:
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 9/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
Hare et al (2017)
A - Investigate whether AND and EST signal gender and affect male perception
M - hetero participants completed two computer based tasks twice on 2 days consecutively. On
either one of the days, they were exposed to the pheromone (AND or EST) and on the other, a
control scent (clove oil) which were taped under the nose. This was a double-blind experiment.
The first task showed 5 gender neutral facial morphs and participants were made to choose
whether they thought it was male or female. The second task, they were shown the opposite
sex’s photographs and made to rate them from 1 to 10. Two experimenters, one male and one
female alternated each day.
R - First task, no difference in gender assigned in both groups. Second task, no difference in
average ratings. Gender of experimenter had no effect either.
Kaminsky et al (2008)
A - Investigating epigenetics (the study of how the environment affects gene expression)
S - 49 year old female MZ twins, one a war journalist and one an office manager in a law firm
M - Twins were close and lived together until 17. War twin traveled and experienced war. Law
twin settled down early. War twin sometimes drank alcohol in excess which the law twin never
did. Epigenetic testing performed on DNA extracted from blood cells.
R - In personality questionnaires, the law twin had a tendency to overreact to minor problems
with tension and anxiety. Law twin was also more risk-averse. DLX1 gene was differently
methylated in both twins.
IE - DNA extracted from blood cells and gene expression in blood and brain cells may be
different.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 10/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
Fessler et al (2005)
A - Investigate whether disgust sensitivity is adjusted as a function of the immune system.
H - Disgust sensitivity varies across pregnancy in a manner that compensates for the changes
in the vulnerability of disease
S - 496 middle-aged pregnant women, 155 participants were in the first trimester, 341 in the
second and third.
M - web based survey, 2nd and 3rd trimester women’s responses compared with 1st trimester
women’s answers
R - participants in the 1st trimester had greater overall disgust sensitivity than the other 2 and
experienced more nausea. Overall disgust sensitivity was positively related to the current level
of nausea.
Explain the use of twin studies and/or kinship studies using one study.
(for twin studies - Kaminsky et al (2008) and for kinship studies - Weissman et al)
- Used mainly in studies in genetics (the study of genes)
- Twin studies estimate the similarity between identical/monozygotic twins and compare it to the
similarity between fraternal/dizygotic twins. Identical twins share 100% of genotype (the set of
traits coded in an individual’s DNA) while fraternal twins share 50%.
- Estimation of genetic heritability (quantitative measurement of the relative contribution of
genetic factors into a trait or behavior) in twin studies is based on the Falconer model. This
model assumes that phenotype (the set of traits that actually manifest in an individual’s body) is
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 11/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
Kaminsky et al (2008)
Weissman et al (2005)
A - To study the potential genetic nature of Major depressive disorder over 3 generations.
S - 161 grandchildren and their parents and grandparents
M - Original sample of depressed patients taken from an outpatient clinic with a specialization in
treating mood disorders. Non-depressed participants taken from the same local community.
These patients/participants and their children interviewed 4 times 20 years later. The children,
now adults with their own children. Data collected from physicians blind to past diagnoses.
Children were evaluated by two experienced clinicians,one a child psychiatrist and the other a
psychologist.
R - Inter-rater reliability of their diagnoses was 0.82 for MDD, 0.65 for anxiety disorders, and
0.94 for alcohol dependency. High rates of psychiatric disorders with grandchildren when both
generations suffered from MDD. By 12 years old, 54.2% showed signs of a psychiatric disorder.
No increased risk of MDD if only one generation had it.
(for kinship studies, just use your brain and make stuff up)
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 12/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
Cognitive processes :
Alter et al (2007)
A - To investigate the effect of cognitive disfluency on fonts on the use of system 1 or system 2
to answer questions
S - 40 princeton students
M - Participants were given cognitive reflection tests, which had 3 questions used to measure
whether participants were fast thinking or slow thinking in answering questions. Half were given
easy to read fonts, half were given the opposite
R - 90% of students with easy to read fonts answered at least 1 question wrong (used system 1
thinking). 35% of students given hard to read fonts answered at least 1 question wrong. (used
system 2 thinking)
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 13/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
- Cognitive schemas are the mental representations that organize our knowledge, beliefs, and
expectations. Schemas are derived from prior experiences and knowledge, they simplify reality
by creating unrealistic expectations about what is probable in social and textual contexts.
- Schemas are culturally specific: they vary socio-culturally even within a single country
- Help us to make sense of our current experiences
- Schema theory was proposed by J. Piaget in 1920
- Types of schemas : (don’t have to mention all, just a few)
Role Schemas - Expectations about people in particular roles and social categories
Person Schemas - Expectations based on personality traits
Event Schemas (or Scripts) - Expectations about sequences of events in social situations
Cultural schema/
- First Investigated in 1932 by Bartlett. Bartlett used British subjects and gave them a short
Native American legend called "The War of the Ghosts". They were told to read the story two
times, and then after a short interval they were told to recall the story that they had just read.
They were then to visit the laboratory several times over the course of weeks, months and
years. As a result, Bartlett found that the subjects were all prone to similar errors in their recall
abilities. These are: Assimilation (the subjects contorted the story so that it would fit their cultural
standards.) Leveling: when the subjects recalled the story, it was much shorter than the original.
This is because the subjects unconsciously discarded information from the legend that did not fit
their cultural schemata or standards. Sharpening: the subjects tended to change the order of the
story in order to make it more coherent to themselves.
The subjects still recalled the general theme of the story but changed small details in order to
make the stories more coherent to their expectations. The subjects distorted the story in this
way because it is easier to remember things that follow a certain cognitive rule - in this case, it is
cultural schemata.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 14/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
Explain one model of memory with reference to one study. / Explain the
Multi-Store Model with reference to one study.
- Memory is the cognitive process of encoding, storing, and retrieving information
- One model of memory to explain its process is the multi-store memory model which was
proposed by Atkinson and Shiffrin in 1968
Model of 3 components all containing a specific duration, capacity, and certain conditions to
move to the next memory store:
Sensory memory store - Does not process information. Detects information and holds it until it is
transferred to STM or lost. Many sub-components, including iconic memory (visual inputs) and
echoic memory (auditory inputs).
- Its duration is short, iconic memory decays after 1 second while echoic memory decays
after 2-5 seconds.
- Its capacity is limited by perception (anything we see or hear presently for iconic and
echoic memory for example).
- The condition of attention must be met for information to transfer to STM.
Short-term memory store - Information entering this system can change between modalities (for
example, pronouncing a word one sees visually allows the info to enter STM acoustically)
- Its duration depends on modality, but it is usually no more than 30 seconds
- Its capacity is 7±2 chunks of information
Its condition is rehearsal of information
Long-term memory store - Storage of large amounts of information for indefinite periods of time
- Duration, capacity unlimited. However retrieval can be difficult
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 15/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
R - 1st condition, participants were better at remembering words at the start of the list (primacy
effect) and at the end (recency effect). 2nd condition, participants were still better at recalling the
start of list but not the end anymore.
CE - When people hear a list of words, they repeat that to themselves and that becomes
rehearsed. The first words get repeated more often and enter the LTM, being unaffected by the
filler-task. Opposite for the words at the end.
Supports the idea of STM and LTM being separated.
Evaluation :
- Model is oversimplified, acts as if STM and LTM act as unitary stores
- Rehearsal is not the only factor that allows STM to go to LTM (not everything rehearsed is
remembered)
- There is a bidirectional flow of information between the memory stores (one performs chunking
based on prior knowledge, i.e. LTM needed for STM)
If one store is utilized for both tasks, then task performance is poorer than when they are
completed separately, due to the store’s limited capacity. If the tasks require different stores,
performance would be unaffected when performing them simultaneously
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 16/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
A - Investigates effects of articulatory suppression (blocking inner voice) (in the experiment,
repeating the-the-the or 1,2,3,1,2,3) on the phonological similarity effect.
M - 4 conditions were set, rhyming words with a spoken or written mode of presentation and
non-rhyming words with a spoken or written mode of presentation.
R - Rhyming words were harder to recall than non-rhyming words due to the phonological
similarity effect. No phonological similarity effect under written mode of presentation. Under
articulatory suppression, spoken information can still enter the phonological store. Written info
also gets encoded and enters the visuospatial sketchpad, seen visually so rhyming words are
not hard to recall.
- The WMM provides an explanation for parallel processing (i.e. where processes involved in a
cognitive task occur at once), unlike Atkinson and Shiffrin’s MSM.
Weaknesses:
- Despite providing more detail of STM than the multi-store model, the WMM has been criticized
for being too simplistic and vague, e.g. it is unclear what the central executive is, or its exact
role in attention.
- Results from laboratory experiments researching the WMM will often have low ecological
validity (i.e. may not relate to real life), as tasks such as repeating ‘the the the’ are arguably not
representative of our everyday activities.
Explain one model of thinking and decision making with reference to one
study.
- This essay will discuss a topic under the cognitive approach to understanding behavior. This
studies how mental processes carried out by the brain, such as memory, thinking, perception,
attention, etc. guide our behavior.
- Thinking is the process of modifying the information retrieved from the process of memory, its
function being to analyze, synthesize, and categorize this information
- Decision making is a cognitive process that involves selecting one of the possible beliefs or
actions, as in, making a choice between some alternatives. Thinking is therefore integral to
decision making.
- In Order to understand a model of thinking and decision making, first one should know that
there are two types of models: normative models and descriptive models. Normative models
which describe the way thinking should be (assume unlimited time and resources are available
to make a decision), and descriptive models which describe what people actually do when they
think and make decisions (accurate descriptions of real life thinking patterns).
- A descriptive model : The theory of reasoned action is the idea that an individual’s choice of a
behavior is based on its expected outcomes.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 17/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
- If we believe that a desired outcome will occur, a predisposition called behavioral intention is
created and the stronger it is, the more effort we put into making that outcome happen
- 2 factors that determine behavioral intention, attitude (individual perception) and subjective
norms (perceived social pressure). Depending on the situation, attitudes and subjective norms
may have varying degrees of importance in determining the intention
- This theory was proposed by Martin Fishbein in 1967 and was later extended in 1985 into the
theory of planned behavior in order to introduce a third factor, perceived behavioral control
(whether you think you can do that action)
Albarracin et al (2001)
A - To identify the important attitudinal or behavioral predictors of the frequency of condom use
S - 42 articles and a total of 96 data sets
M - Meta-analysis
R - TRA and TPB are successful predictors of condom use, correlation between intention and
behavior is 0.51. If behavior is assessed retrospectively, assessment of intentions and behaviors
are carrious at the same time (correlation in 0.57). If behavior is assessed prospectively,
assessment of the two is carried out at different periods (correlation is 0.45).
People more likely to use condoms if they have previously formed the corresponding intentions,
the intentions derive form attitudes, subjective norms, and perceived behavioral control (TPB)
IE - Study relies on assumption that self-reported condom use is accurate and reflects their
everyday behavior
Evaluation of TRA/TPB :
- Model is useful for making predictions, by considering the variables as inputs for the model \
- Can be applied to how people’s behavior can change and what the barriers are to it (business
and other real life things)
- Model can fail in some situations (positive behavioral intention does not necessarily lead to the
behavior occurring), thus implementation intentions could be added
- Does not include other behavioral factors like emotions
- Does not address how to determine actions that result in changing behavior (cannot find
relationship between attitudes and behavioral intentions)
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 18/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
- One theory of memory is the the theory of reconstructive memory, which is the idea that
memory is an active process that involves the reconstruction of information, i.e. the idea that
memory can be distorted
- Some factors that affect reconstructive memory:
Schemas (mental representations that organize our knowledge, belief, and expectations) which
can influence the encoding and retrieval of memory. (shown in Bransford and Johnson (1972)
and Anderson and Pichert (1978)
Time (over time one’s memory gets weaker, one tries to fill in gaps)
Preconceived notions (change perceptions and fills in gaps with wrong information)
Leading questions and Misleading information can influence one’s belief about an event
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 19/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
CE - Refutes the theory of reconstructive memory as memory was not distorted at all. However
this study could display something else called flashbulb memory formed due to high emotional
arousal (a crime counts) and are very vivid. Other studies are mostly valid, so how can this
study disprove them all?
Festinger (1956)
A - The aim of the observation was to see how the members of the religious cult behave and
what their beliefs are.
S - A small UFO cult in Chicago called the Seekers who believed in an imminent apocalypse
M - belief disconfirmation paradigm (people with strong beliefs come across new contradictory
evidence). Leon Festinger and his colleagues wanted to observe the cult members, however
their beliefs stated that they needed to stay isolated from non-believers. They joined the cult in
order to be able to observe them. On December 21, when the world was supposed to end, they
observed how the people reacted when it didn't. They monitored the group members doubt,
debate, and rationalization of what had taken place
R - The members still remained in their cult's beliefs even when the world did not end, making
up a theory that God saved them through their prayers so that they could maintain their
self-esteem (Cognitive dissonance). The members blindly followed what they heard
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 20/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
Explain one theory of how emotion may affect one cognitive process.
- This essay will discuss a topic under the cognitive approach to understanding behavior. This
studies how mental processes carried out by the brain, such as memory, thinking, perception,
attention, etc. guide our behavior.
- Cognitive processes are the processes that underlie one’s mental representations of the world
- Emotion comes from latin “ex” meaning “out”, and “movere” meaning “to move”
- One theory of how emotion affects one cognitive process is known as Flashbulb memory (how
emotion affects memory)
- Flashbulb memory was proposed by Roger Brown and James Kulik in 1977
- Flashbulb memories are vivid memories of the circumstances in which one first learned of a
surprising and emotionally arousing event.
- The mechanism of formation is a photographic representation of events that are surprising,
personally consequential, and therefore emotionally arousing.
- The mechanism of maintenance includes overt rehearsal (rehearsing the event with others)
and covert rehearsal (rehearsing the event in one’s memory) which both in turn consolidate
memory traces keeping the memory of the event vivid.
- There are three unique and distinguishable properties of flashbulb memory: its unique neural
mechanism, vividness, and accuracy.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 21/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
- Most studies in this field tend to focus on public events that caused negative emotional
experiences. But personal events mostly overlooked due to lack of ability to standardize
research conditions
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 22/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
- This essay will attempt to discuss Social Identity Theory with the help of the studies Tajfel et
and Cialdini et al.
Tajfel et al (1971)
A - To demonstrate that when individuals are allocated to groups based on minimal
characteristics, it is possible to create discrimination without existing prejudice
S - 64 boys, ages 14 to 15 years old from a school in the UK
M1 - 2 studies both where they were assigned groups based on minimal characteristics. In the
first study, boys were assigned into groups labeled “overestimator” and “underestimator” based
on their estimates of number of dots on a screen in a visual judgment task (this being arbitrary).
Boys were told that they would be part of a task in which they would give rewards and penalties
to others in the form of real money. Identities of the receivers of these rewards or penalties were
unknown to the boys, and at the end the boys would receive the amount they had been
rewarded. The boys were placed into cubicles and given booklets with columns. Each column
was told to equate to rewarding or penalizing another participant. The booklet contained
columns enabling ingroup choices, outgroup choices, and intergroup choices.
R2 - Results showed that boys displayed ingroup favoritism when making intergroup choices
and allocated more rewards to members of their own group and when two members of the
same group were chosen, the boys usually went with the option with maximum fairness.
M2 - In the second study, a different group of boys were categorized into groups based on
artistic preference after being shown paintings of Paul Klee and Wassily Kandinsky. The
columns were slightly different however, where the study encouraged the boys to make one of
three decisions : maximum joint profit, where boys could allocate the largest amount to both
boys in the column, maximum ingroup profit, where boys could allocate the largest amount to
members of their ingroup, and maximum difference, where boys could maximize the amount
given to members of their ingroup and minimize the amount given to members of the outgroup.
R2 - Results showed that boys would rather maximize the difference in scores even when given
a chance of obtaining a higher score with more money. Maximum fairness was seen when
concerning two members of the ingroup.
CE - Results of first study support the idea that discrimination can be created by merely being
allocated to a group. And it highlights that discrimination can take place even without previous
prejudice or competition.
Cialdini et al (1976)
A - To investigate the role of social identity in self-esteem
M - Study conducted in the campuses of 7 large American universities which had popular
American football teams. The clothing students wore the monday after a big football match
against a rival university was recorded. The students’ opinions of the team’s performance was
also recorded.
R - Students were more likely to wear clothing associated with the university if their football
team won the match. If the team won, the first person plural pronoun (we) was more likely to be
used, while if the team lost, the third person plural pronoun (they) was more likely to be used.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 23/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
CE - Social identity plays a role in self-esteem, i.e. to maintain a high level of self-esteem
people like to associate themselves with a successful group and distance themselves from a
group that failed/fails.
Evaluation of SIT :
- Demonstrates the role of social categorization in intergroup behaviors.
- Explores the basic need to belong and its effects on social interaction.
- Application of SIT restricted by the generally low ecological validity of the studies on it (not
shown a lot here though so mention the other ones more), studies with low generalizability, and
the adoption of reductionist principles
- SIT generally favors situational factors rather than dispositional factors (inherent
characteristics) which are not supported by evidence. For example, competitive participants
show higher ingroup favoritism than more cooperative participants.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 24/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
- Bandura broke down the Social Cognitive theory into four factors: attention, retention,
reproduction (affected by self-efficacy - the belief that you are able to do a task), and
motivation.
- This essay will attempt to explain Social Cognitive Theory with the help of the study
Bandura, Ross and Ross.
Sheridan et al (2011)
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 25/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
Evaluation of SCT :
- A comprehensive theory that takes human behavior, cognition, and environment into
account
- Addresses how reinforcement and self-efficacy affect reproduction and motivation and
how an individual works
- Focuses on the importance of self-regulation in learning, i.e. the self is integral to
learning
- Does not address the full complexities of humans in regards to their biological
differences, traits, etc. when explaining their behaviors
- Somewhat of a loosely organized theory
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 26/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
correlation and ignore evidence that contradicts it. For example, you sit next to a brilliant
Asian math student so you think all Asians are good at mathematics.
- This essay will attempt to discuss these theories of formation with the help of one
study.
Schaller (1991)
A - To investigate illusory correlation
S - 141 US university students
M - Participants again read sentences about members of two distinct groups : A and B,
group B containing fewer members. Participants were then randomly assigned group
membership to either group A or group B.There was also a control condition with no
group membership assigned. They were presented with a series of statements about
both groups with both desirable and undesirable behaviors. Given a questionnaire to
assess how much they thought there was a relationship between group membership
and behavior.
R - Results showed ingroup bias when asked about their ingroup and negative
stereotyping about the outgroup.
CE - Another example of illusory correlation.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 27/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
M - Female college students were told that they would either meet an introvert or an
extrovert and were asked to prepare a set of questions for that specific introvert or
extrovert.
R - Results showed that the women came up with questions that generally conformed to
the stereotypes around extroverts and introverts. For example, the women asked, “What
do you dislike about parties?” for introverts, while for extroverts, they asked, 'What do
you do to liven up parties?’
CE - People naturally try to confirm their pre-existing expectations about group
members.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 28/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 29/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
groups. Culture also guides and influences the group in how they act, live, behave, and
in what they believe in.
- In an effort to study this concept, Geert Hofstede researched 40 of the largest
countries of which IBM Europe has subsidiaries, distributing questionnaires to
employees about their values, beliefs, and behaviors. Hofstede found trends in the data
leading to his identification of four cultural dimensions.
- Basically, under the term culture, there exist cultural dimensions which are
components or subsets of culture that are directly affected and changed by it. Some
cultural dimensions include the Individualism vs. Collectivism, Power Distance Index
(PDI), and Masculinity vs. Femininity.
- Individualism versus Collectivism measures the degree to which people's identities are
defined by social groups
- In individualistic cultures, identity is defined by personal characteristics, their success,
and unique features, and the strongest values are autonomy, competitiveness, and
self-reliance. People are expected to look after themselves.
- In collectivist cultures, identity is linked to the social group, and values associated with
belonging to a group take priority over personal values such as social harmony,
modesty, and interdependence.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 30/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
R - Individualistic cultures were active in voluntary prosocial behavior for causes they
deemed to be in line with individualistic values (self-determination, self-promotion, or
self-actualization). Individualism positively related to charitable giving and volunteerism,
both are more likely in individualist states.
Finkelstein (2010)
A - To examine the effect of culture on volunteer behaviour.
S - 194 undergraduates at a US university who participated in exchange for extra
course credit.
M - Online self-report questionnaires that measured a variety of possible reasons for
volunteering including:
• altruistic motivation to help
• the desire to strengthen social ties
• role identity (volunteering for the sake of consistency with one’s self-image)
• career-related reasons.
R - Collectivism was more strongly related than individualism to altruistic motivation and
the desire to strengthen social ties. Collectivism, but not individualism, correlated with
helping in order to sustain role identity. On the other hand, individualism was most
closely associated with engaging in volunteering for career related reasons.
Conclusion - The researchers concluded that individualists and collectivists differ in why
they choose to volunteer, but not in the willingness to volunteer itself.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 31/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
Cohen et al (1996)
A - To investigate if southern white males in the USA responded differently to threats
and insults than northern white males
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 32/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
S - male University of Michigan students who either grew up in the south or the north of
the USA
M - Where a confederate bumped into the participants and insulted them with
derogatory names.
R - Northerns were relatively unaffected by the insult but southerners were found to
think that their masculine reputation was threatened, be more upset. be more physically
and cognitively primed for aggression, and be more likely to engage in
aggressive/dominant behavior. Northerns were only half as likely to be angry by the
insult, 35%, while southerners had an 85% chance of being angry.
IE - less generalizeability as it was only done in the USA
CE - Results of the study highlight the southern culture of honor where insults diminish
a man's reputation, resulting in an attempt to restore the lost repuation through
dominance and aggression. The men who grew up in the south learned these behaviors
and responses growing up there and hence repeat them in this study. While the
northerners did not grow up to worry about their reputation as men to the extent the
southerners had to.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 33/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
How does acculturation affect the health behavior of migrants? Research in this area
has identified two interesting effects.
The healthy migrant effect—people who recently migrated have a tendency to be
healthier than their counterparts who stayed in the country of origin. One potential
explanation is that host countries are selective and they prefer to select healthy
immigrants.
The negative acculturation effect—the healthy migrant effect diminishes over time:
migrants are becoming less healthy and more similar to their counterparts who stayed in
the country of origin. One potential explanation is that the food environments in the
migrant origin cultures tend to be healthier than food environments in the more
“developed” host societies.
- This essay will attempt to explain the study, Shah et al, a study of acculturation
Shah et al (2015)
A - To investigate acculturation in migrant workers
S - 1375 male migrant workers in the UAE mainly from South India (India, Pakistan, and
Bangladesh). Haf of them had been living in the UAE for 6 years.
M - Participants completed a questionnaire between January and June 2012
R - Migrant workers had a significantly higher body mass (BMI) than men of the same
age in their cultures of origin. The longer the migrant workers spent in the UAE, the
greater the difference between their BMI and the BMI of the men of their culture of
origin. The mean BMIs for men aged 20-59 for indians and indian migrant workers had
difference of 8.4 (indian migrant workers being higher), for bangladeshis and their
migrant workers, a difference of 6.5, and for Pakistanis it was almost double. Also,
positive association between obesity and acculturation.
IE - Generalizability less as only male migrant workers were studied and only the
direction of people from South India migrating to the UAE was studied
CE - The migrant workers moving to the UAE adopted the strategy of
integration/assimilation and were open to the culture of the country they moved to. This
influenced them psychologically, as they enjoyed UAE's culture, their food, and
everything under it. As they were previously much poorer, they now had the ability to eat
more and as they were not averse to the culture they ate a lot more. Thus affecting
them physically. Because acculturation occured in them, their BMIs increased.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 34/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
Evaluation:
As pointed out by Schwartz et al (2013), most studies of acculturation and health outcomes rely
on a unidimensional understanding of acculturation—accultured versus non-accultured to the
receiving culture, ignoring the second dimension proposed by Berry (1997), the ties with the
original culture.
• As a result of this, it is not clear whether the observed effects of immigration on health are due
to immigrants’ adaptation to the receiving culture, loss of connection with the heritage culture, or
both.
• Another criticism is that it is not the process of acculturation that seems to matter, but the
culture to which one is acculturating. There were other studies that did not show a signicant
correlation between the risk of being overweight and the duration of residence.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 35/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
Assimilation : individuals are open to change and unconcerned about the loss of their
own culture, results in a melting pot.
AND Individuals openly seek interaction with cultures other than their own and are
willing to adjust their behavior, attitudes, and beliefs.
Integration : individuals want to hold onto traditional values and beliefs and also desire
interaction with other cultures, results in multiculturalism
Separation : individuals value their original culture and are averse to losing it so they
avoid contact with other cultures, results in segregation
Marginalization : individuals have little interest in maintaining their own culture and have
little interest in opening relations with other cultures, results in exclusion
Acculturation, and therefore Assimilation, can be stressful and can happen to people
who are coping with conflicting cultural norms. Acculturative stress can be defined as
biopsychosocial difficulties when adapting to a new cultural context. Assimilation lead to
intermediate levels of stress.
- This essay will focus on one study of assimilation, Shah et al.
Shah et al (2015)
A - To investigate acculturation in migrant workers
S - 1375 male migrant workers in the UAE mainly from South India (India, Pakistan, and
Bangladesh). Haf of them had been living in the UAE for 6 years.
M - Participants completed a questionnaire between January and June 2012
R - Migrant workers had a significantly higher body mass (BMI) than men of the same
age in their cultures of origin. The longer the migrant workers spent in the UAE, the
greater the difference between their BMI and the BMI of the men of their culture of
origin. The mean BMIs for men aged 20-59 for indians and indian migrant workers had
difference of 8.4 (indian migrant workers being higher), for bangladeshis and their
migrant workers, a difference of 6.5, and for Pakistanis it was almost double. Also,
positive association between obesity and acculturation.
IE - Generalizability less as only male migrant workers were studied and only the
direction of people from South India migrating to the UAE was studied
CE - The migrant workers moving to the UAE adopted the strategy of
integration/assimilation and were open to the culture of the country they moved to. This
influenced them psychologically, as they enjoyed UAE's culture, their food, and
everything under it. As they were previously much poorer, they now had the ability to eat
more and as they were not averse to the culture they ate a lot more. Thus affecting
them physically. Because assimilation occurred in them, their BMIs increased. And
explain even more.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 36/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
Globalization :
Buchan et al (2009)
Aim To investigate the effects of globalization on cooperation strategies. In this, two alternative
hypotheses were investigated.
(a) Globalization prompts reactionary movements, and large-scale cooperation takes the form of
defending the interests of one’s ethnic, racial or language group.
(b) Globalization strengthens people’s cosmopolitan attitudes by weakening their identication
with their group of origin.
Method and procedure
• To measure cooperation strategies the researchers used multilevel sequential cooperation
experiments. In a typical trial subjects would be given 10 tokens and required to distribute the
tokens among three accounts—personal, local and world.
• Each token placed in the personal account was saved.
• Each token placed in the local account was added to local contributions of three other
individuals from the same country, the sum was multiplied by two and each of the four
participants received 1/4 of that amount. For example, if Mike placed one token in the local
account, and so did three other people from his country, the total would become 4 × 2 = 8, and
each of the four participants would get two tokens.
• Each token placed in the world account was added to the contributions from the same three
local people plus two other groups of four people from different countries. The sum was tripled
by the experimenter, and the participant received 1/12 of the resulting amount. Placing tokens in
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 37/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
the world account is potentially the most profitable decision, but only if it is shared by other
players— so it is the riskiest.
• In these experiments the amount of an individual’s contributions to the world account was
taken as an operationalization of cosmopolitan interests (cosmopolitan cooperation strategy).
Contributions to the local account were taken as an operationalization of parochial interests
(parochial cooperation strategy).
• Globalization was measured by a standardized questionnaire (Globalization Index) which asks
a variety of questions tapping into the degree to which an individual takes part in the network of
global economic, social and cultural relations. An example of a question is “How often do you
watch a television programme or a movie from a different country?”
Participants - Samples from six countries were used: the USA, Italy, Russia, Argentina, South
Africa and Iran. There were approximately 190 participants per country.
Results • The study lent support to the hypothesis that globalization strengthens people’s
cosmopolitan attitudes. People who had higher scores on the Globalization Index were also
more likely to cooperate on the global level—that is, contribute more to the world account in the
cooperation experiment. • In order of increasingly cosmopolitan (and decreasingly parochial)
cooperation the countries ranked as follows: Iran, South Africa, Argentina, Russia, Italy, the
USA. Conclusion Higher levels of globalization are associated with stronger cosmopolitan
cooperation strategies—a preference of global interests to the local interests. Globalization
probably inuences an individual to reduce perceived social distance with geographically remote
others
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 38/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
But the spread of ideas is often one directional, often coming from the West. Western cultures
(e.g. European countries, North America, Australia, NZ etc.) are highly individualistic, so as
globalization (i.e. Westernization) has occurred over the recent decades, other cultures have
becoming increasingly individualistic as well. This Westernization primarily occurs through the
influence of media (TV, films, the internet) and the effect of this change in values is an important
topic to study. Not everyone is pleased with this idea of a global cultural ingroup, as pointed out
by Rosenmann, Reese and Cameron (2015).
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 39/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
Berry (2008) argues that it is essential to distinguish globalization as a process and outcomes of
this process. The outcomes of globalization, according to him, depend on the predominant
acculturation strategy (integration, assimilation, separation or marginalization). In its turn, the
acculturation strategy is formed by an interaction of local and global influences.
Globalization is closely connected to acculturation. In its turn, choosing one of the four
acculturation strategies (integration, assimilation, separation or marginalization) is the result of
the interaction between the influences of the local culture and the global culture. The choice of
acculturation strategies is fateful for the outcomes of globalization.
Berry (2008) describes how the concepts of acculturation and globalization are related to each
other. Both acculturation and globalization are initiated by intercultural contact and lead to
change both on the individual and on the cultural level.
Two assumptions used to be predominant in research and popular thinking.
- Acculturation and globalization induce more change in non-dominant peoples.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 40/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
• The ultimate result of these processes is the loss of uniqueness of non-dominant group
members and establishing a homogeneous society.
Both of these assumptions have been challenged. Berry’s two-dimensional model of
acculturation strategies (1) desire to preserve their ethnic culture and (2) wish to interact
with the members of the majority group), for example, incorporates the opportunity for
multicultural societies to be established on the basis of integration as the acculturation strategy
that embraces both the original culture and the new culture. Globalization as a process refers to
societies engaging in international contact, establishing an interconnected network of relations.
Globalization is the contact that provides the starting point for acculturation. This process,
according to Berry, can have four possible outcomes, each outcome being the ultimate result of
the adopted acculturation strategy.
• Globalization will lead to a homogeneous world culture, most likely based on the values and
norms of the dominant cultures, with non-dominant societies adopting (assimilating) these
norms
Mutual change will occur where societies share some common qualities but at the same time
retain unique distinctive features (integration).
• Non-dominant groups will end up rejecting the growing inuence of the dominant societies
(separation).
• Globalization can lead to the destruction of nondominant cultures, leaving these groups
essentially with no culture (marginalization)
Berry (1997) proposed the term ‘acculturative stress’ to describe the conflict between one’s
original culture and a new culture, and the effect they have on a person’s identity. The stress is
greatest when the values of the indigenous culture are incompatible with those of the global
culture. This acculturative stress contributes to identity confusion, so the greater the
acculturative stress the greater the identity confusion.
Chen et al (2008)
A - to investigate Bicultural Identity Integration (BII)
S - researchers sampled participants from 3 different bicultural populations all found in
Hong Kong
1. Mainland Chinese immigrants to Hong Kong
2. Filipino temporary residents employed as domestic workers in Hong Kong
3.Bilingual college students in both Hong Kong and mainland China
Although the cultural context is constant, each of these groups faces different
acculturation pressures, and the groups have different statuses and sociocultural
backgrounds.
M - The researchers administered questionnaires to each group of participants,
assessing cultural identity and psychological well-being along several dimensions
included:
- cultural identification
- a bicultural identity integration scale
- an acculturation stress inventory
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 41/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 42/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
Use the studies above (Becker, Uchigaha (something lol) and Chen) all work. Talk about the use
of constructs like Hofstede;s cultural dimensions to perform cross cultural studies and see
influences of globalization.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 43/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
Interpersonal Relationships :
Fisher et al (2016)
A - To investigate the idea that intensely passionate love is a neurobiological process similar to
drug addiction
S - 10 women and 7 men
M - Questionnaire about feelings for each other toward their loved one, placed in an MRI.
Participants were shown a photograph of their loved one, performed a distraction task, then a
photo of an acquaintance. Repeated 6 times.
R - Results of study show the same brain mechanism active in substance abuse, the
mesolimbic dopamine reward pathway, is also active when individuals think about a romantic
partner. (especially the early stage of love with shares many symptoms with substance abuse,
but soon gives way for longer-term calm attachment)
Schneiderman et al (2012)
A - Investigates oxytocin’s role in bonding
S - 60 couples in new relationships and control group of 43 individuals
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 44/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
M - interviewed individually and then as a couple, blood samples taken to measure blood
plasma oxytocin levels in both cases.
R - High levels of plasma oxytocin levels correlated with affectionate touching, preoccupation
with partner, etc.
Wedekind et al (1995)
A - Whether or not our body odor has an effect on attraction
M- A clean t-shirt was given to 44 male participants to wear for 2 nights.
-49 female participants were then asked to sniff three different types of shirts: MHC similar,
MHC different, and a shirt that wasn't worn. Then they were asked to rate them dependent on
the pleasantness of odor
-All of the women participants were midway through their menstrual cycle, which is when smell
is strongest
R - The shirts from men with dissimilar immune systems were preferred by the women, so long
as they weren't using any oral contraception. This shows that women prefer the smells of men
that are more likely to boost the immune systems of any potential offspring
Byrne (1961)
Attraction similarity model
Aim - To investigate the relationship between interpersonal attraction and attitude similarity.
Method - Researchers asked participants to rank a number of issues on their importance (from
most important to least important). Examples included a range of issues from God and
premarital sex to Western movies. Two weeks later they were shown an anonymous
questionnaire from another student. In fact, the questionnaire was faked so that responses were
one of the following: – identical to that of the participant on all issues – opposite to that of the
participant on all issues – similar on important issues and dissimilar on unimportant ones –
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 45/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
similar on unimportant issues and dissimilar on important ones. Participants were asked to
indicate their feelings towards the stranger and rate this person on such characteristics as
intelligence and morality.
Results – Participants provided more positive ratings towards the stranger when their attitudes
were similar. – Similarity in important attitudes was more closely associated with positive ratings
than similarity in less important attitudes.
Conclusion: Perceived similarity of attitudes indeed increases interpersonal attraction.
Berscheid et al (1971)
A - to investigate the matching hypothesis
M- Participants were randomly split into two groups: high probability of rejection (POR) and low
POR. The high POR participants were told that there would be a preliminary meeting with their
tentative date prior to the dance where their date would be given a chance to either accept or
reject them as a partner. The low POR participants were told that their dates had agreed to
attend the dance with whoever was chosen by the computer algorithm. After this, participants
were requested to specify characteristics that they desired in a date—how intelligent, outgoing,
attractive and popular they wished their date to be.
Results – Attractive participants chose more physically attractive and popular dates than
unattractive participants did. This supports the matching hypothesis. – It was not different in high
and low POR groups. In other words, increasing fear of rejection had no effect on the choosing
strategy.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 46/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
A - The aim of this study was to investigate the influence of individualistic culture or collectivistic
culture on love and intimacy in marriage.
M - Meta-analysis. The researchers performed a meta analysis of research done in 2
individualistic countries (US and Canada) and 3 collectivistic cultures (China, India, Japan)
R - The findings of the meta analysis suggest that romantic love is more likely the basis for
marriages in individualistic cultures than in collectivistic ones. Intimacy in marriage is more
about satisfaction with marriage and personal wellness in individualistic cultures → could seem
contradictory to individualism values (romantic love and intimacy) but a psychologically
individual mindset tends to value their wellbeing and independence than connection to others.
(familiarity/proximity)
Moreland and Beach (1992) conducted a similar study in a more natural setting. Four female
confederates of similar appearance attended a large lecture class in college. One of them
attended 5 sessions, another 10 sessions, another 15 sessions, and the fourth one actually did
not attend any classes. At the end of the term students were shown photographs of these four
women and asked to rate them on a number of dimensions (such as interesting, attractive,
intelligent, honest). As predicted, the more frequently the confederate appeared in class, the
higher the ratings.
Jones et al (2007)
A- to investigate social proof
Procedure - Female participants in the study were shown pairs of male faces and asked to rate
their attractiveness. Later they were shown the same pairs of faces again, but this time one
picture in each pair had a female face at the side. The female face was shown staring at the
man’s face with either a smile or a neutral expression. Participants were then asked to rate the
attractiveness of the faces again.
Results – The second round of ratings did not change for the faces that were not accompanied
by a female face staring at it. – Ratings in the second round were higher for the pictures that
had a smiling woman staring at the male face. – Ratings were lower for pictures where the
woman was staring at the man’s face with a neutral expression.
Conclusion - Researchers conclude that when forming attraction women may use social clues
and mimic the attitude of other women to men
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 47/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
Wedekind et al (1995)
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 48/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
Rusbult et al (1982)
402 undergraduate students studied and found that prior satisfaction and an individual’s
investment in the relationship predicted constructive strategies. Perception of more attractive
relationship options promoted exit and limited loyalty.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 49/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
Differentiating - Individuals begin to grow apart and increasingly identify as individuals instead of
as a couple. (can be due to external pressures)
Circumscribing - Communication becomes problematic (Gottman’s Four Horsemen comes into
play)
Stagnating - Communication becomes limited and relationships in danger of dissolution. At this
point, only external pressures keep the couple together.
Avoiding - Avoiding contact and intimacy physically, emotionally, and communicatively in order
to avoid conflict.
Terminating - End of relationship formally, mutually, or one-sidedly.
- Rollie and Duck (2006) proposed a more specific model dealing with relationship breakdown.
Intrapsychic - Internal unhappiness with the relationship. Dissatisfaction not communicated but
the partner may start withdrawal, resentment, and try to find alternatives to the relationship.
Nothing is shared.
Dyadic - Dissatisfaction is expressed and discussed. They either actively or passively construct
or deconstruct the relationship
Social - Public phase and problems shared with others for support. Normative social influence
plays a role here (trying to fit in)
Grave dressing - Recovering from the relationship ending. Defending the decision and saying it
was justified to cope.
Resurrection - Complete recovery of the relationship and a “new person” emerges by redefining
themselves.
LeFebvre et al (2014)
A - To apply Rollie and Duck (2006) relationship dissolution model to investigate how Facebook
users behave online both during and after a break-up
S - 226 college students, purposive sample
M - Semi-structure interview with an online survey. Complete online survey asking open-ended
questions about romantic relationship that had ended within the past two years. participants
rated the seriousness of the relationship, the frequency of face-to-face and online
communication with the partner and behaviors that occured during and after the break-up.
R - During relationship dissolution, deleting facebook relationship status, removing posts,
removing any evidence of the relationship
after relationship dissolution, continuing removing evidence. making posts that paint the person
in a positive light, with the goal to evoke jealousy or regret. Lefebvre supports Rollie and Duck's
relationship dissolution model.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 50/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
answered a set of open-ended questions in a story-like fashion while their partner was present
in the same room. A coding scheme was used later to assess the interview transcripts against a
set of scales such as fondness, affection and negativity toward the spouse, among others. In
addition, relationship development was assessed through relationship development breadth—a
questionnaire completed by the participants alone. Relationship development breadth is the
extent to which partners have experienced specific behaviours (such as becoming sexually
intimate), cognitions (such as thinking that the partner was the right person for them) and affect
(such as feeling a deep emotional connection) in the course of the relationship. The more
behaviours, cognitions and emotional reactions you experienced in the course of a relationship,
the “broader” your relationship development has been.
R - Break-up and lower satisfaction at time 2 (six months after the start of the study) were
related to little relational development breadth and negative oral history appraisals.
Abnormal Psychology
diagnosing mental disorders is extremely challenging and the line between normality and
abnormality is unclear.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 51/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 52/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
Evaluation:
Strengths
• It is more humanistic—it focuses on health rather than disorders.
• It provides a balanced description of what it means to be healthy.
Limitations
• It seems impossible for a person to achieve all six criteria, so most people would be classified
as “not entirely healthy” in this framework.
• Some parameters are difficult to measure. For example, it may require a subjective opinion of
the clinician to establish that the client’s perception of the world is “accurate”.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 53/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
altogether. Instead it focuses on mental disorders one by one, defining them descriptively by a
system of symptoms. All these descriptions are then brought together in a classification system.
Such classification systems assume that each disorder is characterized by a defined set of
symptoms that can be differentiated from other sets of symptoms (disorders).
Evaluation:
Strengths
• It makes diagnosis independent of clinicians’ beliefs regarding what causes the disorder.
Psychiatrists may disagree on the origin of a disorder, but they should be able to use the
common language of observable symptoms to agree on the presence of a disorder.
• It is flexible and testable. Like any model, it can be tested against empirical observations and
refined if the fit is not perfect (this takes the form of new editions of classification systems being
published).
Limitations
• Many symptoms of mental illness are not as easily observed as symptoms of physical disease.
• One symptom may be an indicator of multiple disorders, and any single disorder manifests
itself in a variety of symptoms. This is a difficulty that classification systems must tackle.
• The problem of threshold is relevant for this approach as well. For example, if some symptoms
are present and others are not, do we still diagnose a disorder?
(Luhrmann et al (2014)
- Hearing voices and having conversations with those voices
- Cultural differences: schizophrenia in Western cultures, believed in Ghana culture that
the dead and spirits are able to converse with us)
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 54/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
symptoms and trying to create classification categories that would not overlap. In this way, the
role of theory in diagnosis was gradually reduced. This might have made diagnosis more
superficial, but it also allowed clinicians with diverse theoretical backgrounds to use a common
language and arrive at similar diagnoses.
Someone designing a classification system faces a variety of challenges, some of which are:
• explanation versus description
• validity versus reliability—when explanation is eliminated from the process of diagnosis, it
makes diagnosis more consistent across clinicians (more reliable), but leaves less room for
consideration of unique individual circumstances (which may reduce validity)
• discrete diagnostic categories hard with the idea of degrees of abnormality (i.e. some more
severe than others)
• delineation between categories (deciding if a particular pattern of behavior belongs to one
category or another is not an easy task sometimes)
• cross-cultural applicability (needs to be equally applicable to people of different cultural
backgrounds)
• medicalization of the population (percentage of the population that can be categorized as
mentally ill. Don't want a situation where too many people can potentially be diagnosed with a
mental disorder).
• changing social norms (i.e. homosexuality)
Empirical research of classification systems takes the form of establishing their validity and
reliability. A good classification system should:
• allow different clinicians using it to arrive at the same diagnoses, even if their theoretical
orientations are not the same
• allow a diagnosis that corresponds to the real problem experienced by the patient
• take into account cultural differences regarding reporting, demonstrating and interpreting
symptoms of abnormal behaviour
• minimize potential biases in the diagnostic process.
DSM-I: 1952
This edition was heavily based on psychoanalytic traditions (an approach to diagnosing mental
illness, based on the works of Sigmund Freud and his followers, focused on identifying
unconscious drives and theorizing about childhood experiences): clinicians looked for origins of
abnormal behavior in childhood traumas. The focus was on establishing causes, which involved
a lot of interpretation on the part of the psychiatrist.
DSM-II: 1968
The publication itself was triggered by attacks from scientists (for example, behaviourists
criticized using unobservable constructs such as “trauma” or “unconscious drives”) and social
activists (for example, the antipsychiatry movement viewed psychiatry as a form of social
manipulation). However, DSM-II still retained a lot of psychoanalytic features; it was focused
more on explaining and interpreting disorders than describing them.
DSM-III: 1980
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 55/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
The publication was the result of doubts raised in the scientific community regarding the ability
of psychiatrists to reliably differentiate between normality and abnormality. Studies such as
Rosenhan (1973) questioned the validity of diagnosis. Diagnostic categories had to be made
more “scientific”, and this was done by a change of focus from explaining and interpreting
disorders to describing them. With a focus on describing sets of observable symptoms, DSM-III
included 265 disorders organized in 5 groups (the multi-axial system).
DSM-IV: 1994
DSM-III was criticized for overdiagnosis (too many people could be diagnosed with a mental
disorder). In response, the diagnostic categories were revised and DSM-IV included the clinical
significance criterion: symptoms were considered clinically significant if they created major
distress or interfered with daily functioning.
Described each diagnosis in terms of five dimensions or axes highlighting different aspects…
- Clinical disorders (patterns of behavior that impair functioning, eg. depression)
- Personality disorders (rigid patterns of maladaptive (not adjusting to situation) behavior that
have become a part of a person’s personality, eg. narcissistic disorders)
- General medical conditions
- Psychosocial and environmental problems contributing to the disorder (eg. divorce, death)
- Global assessment of functioning of GAF on a scale of 1 to 100 to evaluate current need for
treatment.
DSM-5: 2013
The multi-axial system was criticized for being artificial and not reflecting the reality of things.
Ultimately, it was eliminated. Cultural variability of symptoms was emphasized and tools such as
the “Cultural formulation interview” were included to help clinicians avoid cultural bias in
diagnosis
Beck et al (1962) found that for DSM-I agreement on a specific diagnosis between two
psychiatrists was only 54% on average. Reliability of DSM-II was shown to be similarly low
Williams et al (1992) showed that test-retest reliability for different diagnostic categories in
DSM-III varied from “almost perfect” to “moderate” and “weak”. This seemed to depend mostly
on whether or not a disorder has clear behavioral manifestations. For example, substance
abuse has more obvious behavioral manifestations than a social phobia. Research studies
confirmed that there was a visible improvement to reliability of diagnosis using DSM-III. This
was also enhanced by the addition of the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM (SCID)—a
standardized interview that allowed all clinicians to follow the same protocol.
Regier et al (2013) summarized data from old trials for the DSM-5 and reported mixed results.
On the one hand, out of 23 diagnostic categories that were studied, more than half
demonstrated moderate to strong reliability. On the other hand, six categories were in the weak
range and three categories were in the unacceptable range. Major depressive disorder (MDD)
was among the categories that had “weak” reliability of diagnosis, which is surprising because
this category did not change much from the earlier editions of the DSM
Could be explained by observing that modern studies of reliability of diagnosis use more
rigorous methods and research procedures, as compared to earlier studies. Most importantly,
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 56/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
eld trials for DSM-5 almost exclusively used the test-retest method of establishing reliability,
while earlier studies often used audio-/videorecordings. As we know, estimates of reliability in
the test-retest method are more conservative, but probably closer to the reality of clinical
diagnosis.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 57/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
Validity cannot be directly quantified. There are two approaches commonly used to assess
validity of diagnosis.
• Assessment of systematic biases in the diagnostic process. (ex: we can compare two sets of
diagnoses that should not differ if diagnosis is valid)
. • Assessment of psychiatrists’ ability to detect the mental disorder when the disorder is
objectively known. A classic study by Rosenhan (1973) brought into question the ability of
psychiatrists to tell mentally healthy people from the mentally ill (at the time when DSM-II was in
use).
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 58/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
this alarming situation could be explained by the effect of labelling: once someone is labelled
with a disorder, everything he or she does is interpreted through the lens of that disorder
And for validity add one study from clinical biases as well
Reliability:
Beck et al (1962) found that for DSM-I agreement on a specific diagnosis between two
psychiatrists was only 54% on average. Reliability of DSM-II was shown to be similarly low
Regier et al (2013) summarized data from old trials for the DSM-5 and reported mixed results.
On the one hand, out of 23 diagnostic categories that were studied, more than half
demonstrated moderate to strong reliability. On the other hand, six categories were in the weak
range and three categories were in the unacceptable range. Major depressive disorder (MDD)
was among the categories that had “weak” reliability of diagnosis, which is surprising because
this category did not change much from the earlier editions of the DSM. Modern studies of
reliability of diagnosis use more rigorous methods and research procedures, as compared to
earlier studies. Most importantly, trials for DSM-5 almost exclusively used the test-retest method
of establishing reliability, while earlier studies often used audio-/videorecordings. As we know,
estimates of reliability in the test-retest method are more conservative, but probably closer to
the reality of clinical diagnosis.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 59/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
- Cultural factors in diagnosis (which result from the clinician and the patient having different
cultural backgrounds)
Expression of symptoms
Diagnosed rates of mental illness differ across cultural groups. These differences could be due
to many factors: genuine differences, biased judgement of clinician, altered behavior of patient
in clinical context. Altered behavior could be related to the idea of stereotype threat (in how
certain situations activate certain stereotypical expectations causing one to unintentionally
modify one’s own behavior).
The clinician bias hypothesis - Two groups exhibit similar depression symptoms but clinicians
mistakenly judge these symptoms based on personal predjudices.
Cultural variance hypothesis - Two groups express their symptoms differently, but clinicians are
insensitive to such cultural differences.
— Cultural dimensions started making their way into the DSM in its fourth edition. It included a
“cultural formulation interview” in an appendix and a glossary of “cultural syndromes”. More
attention was given to cultural variables in DSM-5. “Cultural syndromes” are sets of symptoms
that are only recognized as illness in a particular culture. In fact, these symptoms may only exist
in a given culture and nowhere else. Some examples of cultural syndromes follow.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 60/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
• Ataque de nervios (“attack of the nerves”) is a syndrome found mostly among Hispanic people.
Symptoms include uncontrollable screaming, trembling and partial loss of consciousness. It may
be a culturally acceptable form of reaction to extreme stress.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 61/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
R - Perception of depression differed among Asian and British participants. For example, Asian
participants (but not British participants) believed depression is temporary and can be fixed by
having a job outside the home. These differences were less pronounced in the group of younger
women. Asian middle-aged women reported being depressed significantly less than the younger
group.
Conclusion - Cultural differences exist in the way depression is perceived. These differences
may be attributed to underlying cultural dimensions (such as individualism versus collectivism).
These cultural differences influence the rates at which disorders are reported: people from
traditional collectivistic societies tend to report depression more to relatives and less to
professionals. Globalization gradually erases these cultural differences, with younger
generations having less reporting bias.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 62/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 63/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 64/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 65/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
• The cognitive triad: negative beliefs about the self, the world and the future—these negative
beliefs are deeply rooted and they influence automatic thoughts to be irrationally pessimistic.
• Negative self-schemata: when negative beliefs about the self become generalized, individuals
start seeing their own fault in everything that happens to them, even if they cannot control it.
• Faulty thinking patterns: these are logical fallacies and irrational conclusions that people make
because the way they process information is biased.
Ex: Dichotomous thinking (either i am a success or i am a failure), arbitrary inference (far
fetched conclusions), selective abstraction (only noticing one aspect of experience),
overgeneralization (making conclusions based on one event), personalization (blaming oneself
for everything).
Cognitive theory of depression forms the basis of cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT). The core
idea of this approach to treatment is that confronting the client’s faulty thinking patterns with the
objective reality of the situation will replace the irrational elements with more logical thinking,
which will in turn affect behaviour.
Alloy et al (1999)
A - To investigate whether a particular cognitive style (positive or negative) in freshmen is
associated with subsequent development of depressive symptoms.
S - Non-depressed college freshmen
M - Quasi-experiment; longitudinal study. At the start of the study, participants were given a
questionnaire that determined their cognitive style and split into two groups based on results:
low risk versus high risk for depression. Participants with a negative cognitive style (allocated to
the high-risk group) typically believed that negative life events were catastrophic and that the
occurrence of such events meant that they (the participants) were flawed or worthless.
Participants were then followed longitudinally for 5.5 years. Assessments included self-report
measures and structured interviews.
R-
• During the first 2.5 years of follow-up, high-risk freshmen were more likely to develop major
depressive disorder than low-risk freshmen (17% versus 1%).
• High-risk freshmen were also more likely than low-risk freshmen to develop suicidal thoughts
and behaviour (28% versus 13%).
Conclusion - Negative cognitive styles may influence the development of major depression.
Caseras et al (2007)
A - To investigate whether attention to positive versus negative stimuli is different in depressed
versus non-depressed participants.
S - 43 participants recruited through a university website.
M - Quasi-experiment; eye-tracking technology was used to measure the variables. Depressive
symptoms were assessed using a questionnaire. On the basis of the scores, participants were
split into two groups—those with depressive symptoms and nondepressed.
• Participants were shown a series of 32 picture pairs with negative, positive and neutral stimuli.
Each pair of pictures was presented for three seconds. The negative pictures presented images
of sadness and loss, whereas the positive pictures showed people engaging in enjoyable
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 66/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 67/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
traditional societies is stigmatized, which may cause people to misinterpret their symptoms and
either fail to report them (reporting bias) or report them as symptoms of physical illness
(somatization)
Kivela et al (1996)
A - To investigate (in a longitudinal study) the extent to which various social factors predict
occurrence of depression in an elderly Finnish population.
S - 1,529 participants aged 61 or older all from Finland
M - Longitudinal study; quasi-experimental comparison of two groups. A clinical study of
depression in old age was completed in 1984–85. Those participants who were not depressed
in 1984–85 were clinically interviewed and examined again in a follow-up study in 1989–90.
Social variables and the occurrence of certain life events in the period 1984–89 were measured
through questionnaires. Two groups were compared: depressed versus nondepressed in
1989–90.
R - In 1989–90, 8.2% of the men and 9.3% of the women in the sample were diagnosed with
depression. Comparison with non-depressed men revealed the most powerful predictors of
depression in men: poor relationship with the spouse; a negative change in the relationship with
the spouse and with the neighbours; the loss of mother while under 20 years of age; a
grandchild’s divorce; moving into institutional care; an alcohol problem of a close person.
The most powerful predictors of depression in women were: the loss of father while under 20
years of age; low activity in religious events; worsening of relationships with neighbours; a
decline in the social participation rate; an alcohol problem of a close person; living with one’s
husband but without other people.
Conclusion - Social factors and changes in social ties may predict the onset of depression at
old age. There are certain sex differences in the social factors of depression in old age, probably
associated with differences in experiencing marital stress.
Rosenquist et al (2011)
A - To investigate if depressive symptoms can spread from person to person
S - 12,067 participants
M - Statistical analysis of social networks, longitudinal data. Data was taken from an earlier
Framingham Heart Study, a longitudinal study of risk factors for heart disease initiated in 1948.
To keep track of participants, the researchers collected information that would help them locate
participants later: names of their friends, neighbours, co-workers and relatives. Since
Framingham was a small town, many of these nominated contacts also participated in the study.
A questionnaire for measuring depression was administered three times between 1983 and
2001 to one of the cohorts in this longitudinal study. Rosenquist, Fowler and Christakis (2011)
computerized all data, with a focus on levels of depression in each individual as well as friends,
relatives, neighbours and co-workers. Data was analysed using statistical methods of social
network analysis.
R - There was a significant correlation in depressive symptoms between people up to three
degrees of separation away. Participants were:
• 93% more likely to be depressed if a person they were directly connected to (such as a friend)
was depressed
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 68/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
• 43% more likely to be depressed if a person within two degrees of separation (such as a
friend’s friend) was depressed
• 37% more likely to be depressed if a person within three degrees of separation (such as a
friend’s friend’s friend) was depressed. Changes in social ties (for example, acquiring new
friends) predicted changes in depressive symptoms, but not vice versa.
Conclusion - Depression in one person may cause depression in people the individual is socially
connected to (friends, relatives, coworkers). In this sense, symptoms of depression may spread
along the network of social connections somewhat like an infectious disease.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 69/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
R - MDD is a commonly occurring disorder in all countries where epidemiological surveys were
carried out. Lifetime prevalence estimates for MDD ranged widely from 1% (Czech Republic) to
16.9% (USA). The 12-month prevalence estimates ranged from 0.3% (Czech Republic) to 10%
(USA). The age of onset, on the other hand, does not vary substantially. For example, the
median age of onset is similar in high income and low-middle income countries (25.7 versus 24
years, respectively). Sociodemographic correlates of depression are also fairly consistent
across cultures. For example, women’s risk for developing MDD is typically twice that of men.
Conclusion - Prevalence rates of MDD vary considerably across cultures. This may be due to a
variety of factors including the classification system in use, the survey used to establish the
symptoms, representativeness of samples used in research, as well as true prevalence. The
highest prevalence estimates are found in some of the wealthiest countries in the world. The
authors suggest that this may be due to income inequality, but this requires further exploration.
Cooper (1972)
Asked American and British psychiatrists to diagnose patients by watching a number of
videotaped clinical interviews. Found that schizophrenia was diagnosed twice as often in the
USA than in Britain, and the reverse was true for depression. Used DSM-II diagnostic criteria.
When study was replicated later using DSM-III, differences disappeared. In DSM-II
schizophrenia was diagnosed both for acute and chronic manifestations of the disorder,
whereas in DSM-III this was narrowed down to chronic symptoms only, more like British
approach.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 70/71
22/02/2025, 22:48 Copy of IB Psychology Notes - Google Docs
Results of study have nothing to do with cross-cultural differences. Study of diagnostic criteria
and how changeable they are.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XTB3SnpQ_kj8b8YPhDF1P59UZjF4AJ8CSkt8MtcxNFw/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.ed5ptalb7afh 71/71