Similarity Report
PAPER NAME AUTHOR
IOS ASSIGNMENT.docx Durva Thakare
WORD COUNT CHARACTER COUNT
3315 Words 17500 Characters
PAGE COUNT FILE SIZE
12 Pages 71.1KB
SUBMISSION DATE REPORT DATE
Sep 23, 2024 12:16 AM GMT+5:30 Sep 23, 2024 12:17 AM GMT+5:30
11% Overall Similarity
The combined total of all matches, including overlapping sources, for each database.
11% Internet database 0% Publications database
Crossref database Crossref Posted Content database
4% Submitted Works database
Excluded from Similarity Report
Cited material Manually excluded text blocks
Summary
KES’ Shri. Jayantilal H. Patel Law College, Mumbai
7
INTERNAL AIDS TO INTERPRETATION OF STATUES
INTERPRETATION OF STATUTES
A project submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the Ninth
Semester of BA. LL.B. Course
DURVA THAKARE
DIV: B ; ROLL NO : 48
Fifth Year BA. LL.B.
Under the Supervision of
Asst. Prof. Namrata Shetty
22nd September, 2024
Page | 1
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I would like to extend my profound gratitude to Ms. Namrata Shetty Ma’am, an esteemed
mentor in the realm of law, for her invaluable guidance and unwavering support throughout the
course of my Interpretation of Statutes project. Her profound expertise in the field of law and
unwavering dedication to cultivating the skills of her students have significantly contributed to
the refinement of my aptitude for case analysis.
In addition, I wish to convey my deep appreciation to KES’ Shri Jayantilal H. Patel Law
College for providing me the privilege to partake in this enriching endeavour. The institution's
unwavering commitment to fostering experiential learning and relentless pursuit of academic
excellence have been pivotal in shaping my journey as a discerning law scholar.
I am sincerely beholden to both Ms. Namrata Shetty Ma’am and KES’ Shri Jayantilal H. Patel
Law College for their momentous contributions to my legal education, which have undeniably
augmented my knowledge and proficiency in the intricate field of law.
Durva Thakare
22nd September, 2024
Page | 2
INDEX
SR. NO. PARTICULARS PAGE NO.
1. ABSTRACT 4
2. INTRODUCTION 5
3. WHAT ARE INTERNAL AIDS? 5
4. KINDS OF INTERNAL AIDS TO INTERPRETATION 6
OF STATUES
5. OVERCOMING CHALLENGES IN THE USE OF 10
INTERNAL AIDS TO INTERPRETATION
6. CONCLUSION 11
7. BIBLIOGRAPHY 12
Page | 3
3
INTERNAL AIDS TO INTERPRETATION OF STATUTES
ABSTRACT
Interpretation is the process of clarifying complex concepts in a manner that makes them more
5
accessible to individuals. This is particularly relevant in the context of legal texts, where the
language can be intricate and challenging for those without a legal background. In India, for
instance, statutes outlined in the Constitution are crafted by legal experts and can be
significantly difficult for laypersons to comprehend. This disparity in understanding highlights
the necessity for effective interpretation, especially for individuals lacking familiarity with
legal terminology and legislative frameworks.
4
Judicial interpretation plays a crucial role in deciphering the meaning of legal provisions. The
judiciary steps in to analyze statutes and clarify their intent, ensuring that the law is applied
consistently and fairly. However, this interpretative process is guided by established principles
and rules that the courts must adhere to. These frameworks are designed to maintain a level of
consistency and predictability in legal outcomes, which is essential for upholding the rule of
law.
This is a detailed analysis of internal aids to interpretation, which are vital tools used by legal
1
scholars and practitioners. Interpreting legal texts can be likened to navigating a labyrinth,
filled with complexities that require careful thought and consideration. Internal aids serve as
1
intrinsic components of legal documents, acting as guideposts that illuminate the intended
meaning and scope of legal provisions. They encompass definitions, interpretive provisions,
and explanatory notes that assist interpreters in understanding the legislative intent behind the
language used.
By delving into the intricacies of these internal aids, we can appreciate their significance in the
broader context of legal interpretation. They not only facilitate a clearer understanding of
2
statutes but also ensure that legal practitioners and judges are equipped to apply the law in a
Page | 4
manner that aligns with the intentions of the lawmakers. In doing so, internal aids help bridge
the gap between complex legal language and the need for equitable access to justice, ultimately
fostering a more transparent and fair legal system.
INTRODUCTION
Interpretation is the mechanism used by the courts to assess or determine the purpose of the
legislation or rule of law. It is essentially a process by which the courts attempt to determine
the true meaning and true intention of the term, word, or phrase in question in any statute before
the court. A judicial interpretation process can be done through various tools or principles of
statutory interpretation, including the request of assistance from internal or external
interpretative aids, and the application, by the court over a period, of primary or secondary rule
of interpretation. What is interpretation? In day-to-day life, if someone says something that you
do not understand, you ask him to explain himself more fully. This is impossible with the
interpretation of statutes, because when parliament has passed an Act the words of Act are
authoritative as words. The function of the court is to interpret the document according to the
intent of them that made it. From that function the court may not resile , however ambiguous
or difficult of application he words of Act of Parliament may be, the court is bound endeavour
to place some meaning upon them. Internal aids to interpretation are those devices that are
present within the statute. No external references are required to interpret the meaning. Various
in-texts (within the statute) are sufficient to interpret it. On the contrary, sometimes external
references are also used to understand the true meaning of a particular disputed provision.
These are references as termed as ‘external aids. The Supreme Court enjoys advisory
jurisdiction as per Article 143 of the Indian constitution. Similarly, High Courts are often
referred to when a substantial question of law is involved in a case. Judiciary uses these aids to
solve the ambiguity related to the interpretation of statutes.
WHAT ARE INTERNAL AIDS?
According to Salmond, “Interpretation is the process by which the court seek to ascertain the
meaning of the legislature through the medium of authoritative forms in which it is expressed.”
In simple meaning it is referred to as those aids which are available in the statutes, The courts
or judges may take help of these aids without referring to the external sources. Legal
interpretation plays a pivotal role in the judicial process, bridging the gap between legislative
intent and practical application. Within this intricate framework, exploring internal aids is
Page | 5
crucial for gaining valuable insights into the complexities of understanding statutory law. Each
internal aid, from the broad scope of the Long Title to the finer details of Punctuation and
Explanations, is carefully examined to reveal its distinct contribution to the interpretive
process. By drawing from a diverse range of legal principles and court decisions, this study
navigates through the intricate terrain of legal language, illuminating the interplay between
statutory provisions and interpretive aids. Through a detailed qualitative analysis and thorough
review of court interpretations, this research goes beyond theoretical concepts, providing
practical insights into how internal aids shape legal discussions and court decisions.
Particularly in the dynamic socio-legal context of India, with its diverse legal traditions and
cultural nuances, understanding internal aids becomes even more crucial, highlighting the
importance of nuanced comprehension in promoting fair access to justice.
6
KINDS OF INTERNAL AIDS TO INTERPRETATION OF STATUES
1) LONG TITLE – Every Statute is headed by a long title at the head of the statutes, and it
gives the description about the object of an Act. For e.g. the long title of the “Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908”, is – “An Act to consolidate and amend the laws relating to the procedure of
the Courts of Civil Judicature”. In recent times, long title has been used by the courts to
interpret certain provision of the statutes. However, it is useful only to the extent of removing
the ambiguity and confusions and is not a conclusive aid to interpret the provision of the statute.
In olden days the long title was not considered a part of the statutes and was , therefore , not
considered an aid while interpreting it . therefore, has been a change in the thinking of the
courts in recent times and there are numerous occasions when help has been taken from the
long titles to interpret certain provision. In Re Kerala Education bill, the Supreme Court held
that the policy and purpose may be deduced from the long title and the preamble. In Manohar
Lal v. State of Punjab, Long title of the Act is “relied as a guide to decide the scope of the Act”.
The Supreme Court, in M.P.V. Sundararamier & Co. v. State of A.P., considered whether the
impugned enactment was in the true sense a Validation Act. This Court held that while the short
title as well as the marginal note described the Act as a Validation Act, that description was not
answered by the substance of the legislation.
2) SHORT TITLE: The short title of an Act is for the purpose of reference & for its
identification. It ends with the year of passing of the Act. For e.g. Section 1 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908, says –“This Act may be cited as the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. It shall
come into force on the first day of January 1909.” Even though short title is the part of the
Page | 6
statute, it does not have any role in the interpretation of the provisions of an Act. Neither can it
extend, nor can it delimit the clear meaning of particular provisions.
3) PREAMBLE: “A Preamble is an introductory statement of an document which shows the
aims, objective, purpose and history behind the creation of such act. Many old statues have
preambles in which the main objects of the Act are set out, and there are legitimate aids in
construing the enacting parts”. The main objective and purpose of the Act are found in the
Preamble of the Statute. Through the preamble of the statute, the importance or the purpose
and objective of the act is determined or simply the preamble of the statute is something which
contains the aims or objectives of the concerning Act which are sought to be achieved or the
importance of the Act. The difference between the long title provided and the preamble is that
it (Preamble) delivers the causes and basis as to the creation of a particular law within the Act,
the preamble cannot be used to delete any clauses within the statute which are operative or by
declaring the clause unintended or unnecessary, but can be used to refer any uncertainty or
helps in correcting the meaning of the terms which might have more than one meaning. The
preamble is mentioned in the first page of any concerning act, though those are or where
applicable to all the Acts which are old but the modern or the Acts which are passed doesn’t
consist of the preamble in the first page for reference declining its importance.
In Global Energy Ltd. v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission, it was put forth by the
apex court that the preamble is to be used to analyse the object of a legislation. In Rashtriya
Mill Mazdoor Sangh v. NTC (South Maharashtra), while interpreting certain provisions under
the Textile Undertakings (Take over of Management) Act of 1983, the Supreme Court held that
“the preamble cannot be appealed to restrict or to curtail the scope of the concerning enactment
when the language of the mentioned Act is clear.”
4) HEADINGS
Headings are generally prefixed to sections or group of sections. Headings give the key to the
interpretation and may be treated as preambles to the provisions following them. According to
one view, “Heading” is to be interpreted as giving the key to the interpretation of the clauses
under it, unless the language is inconsistent with such interpretation and the headings may be
viewed “as preambles to the provisions which follow.” The Supreme Court recently stated as
follows:
Page | 7
‘It is well known that headings prefixed to sections or entries (of a tariff schedule) cannot
govern the plain words of the provisions they cannot also be referred to for the purpose of
making provision where the words used in the provision are explicit and unambiguous; nor can
they be used to diminish the plain meaning of the provision. Similarly, the title serves as a
succinct descriptor, offering clues regarding the subject matter and focus of the legislation. In
Krishnaiah v. State of A.P. and OR’s, it was held that headings prefixed to sections cannot
control the plain words of the provisions. Only in the case of ambiguity or doubt, heading or
sub-heading may be referred to as an aid in construing provision.
In Durga Thathera v. Narain Thathera and Anr7, the court held that “the headings are like a
preamble which helps as a key to the mind of the legislature but do not control the substantive
section of the enactment.”
5) DEFINITION OR INTERPRETATION CLAUSE
The definition or the interpretation clauses are included within a statute with the purpose of
extending the already existing meaning of certain words, whose meaning is not clear by
providing them with meaning in a general sense. The court during the interpretation of the
provision feels that if the definition clause if in a case is applied the result would be
unreasonable or simply absurd. The definition clause, however, is not used in explaining the
same word which is being used in the other statute, if the word is defined or explained in one
statute under the definition clause it must be limited to its use under the same. if in case both
acts or statutes are pari materia (on the same subject) then the word which is defined under the
interpretation or definition clause could be assigned to the other Act. Under the rule of
interpretation if the words mean and means and include are being used within the scope of the
provided definition then the definition is considered to be exhaustive i.e., “simply complete
which will not allow the words to be interpreted widely but if the word ‘include’ is only used
within the definition then it shall provide the interpretation in the widest way possible or simply
it expands the already existing meaning of the clause with the use of the word include.”
Considering the case of Mahalaxmi Oils Mills v. State of A.P., where in the case the word
tobacco which was interpreted was in question which provided that the word tobacco implies
any form of tobacco whether manufactured or not or whether cured or uncured and this also
includes the stems of the tobacco plant and the leaf stalks. The Apex Court held that the
definition provided for the word is exhaustive and the Supreme Court refused to consider the
tobacco seeds within the scope of the provided definition.
Page | 8
6) EXPLANATION
The purpose of adding explanations to sections within Acts is to provide clarity and aid in
understanding the meaning of specific provisions. These explanations serve to remove doubts
and facilitate clear comprehension, rather than expanding the scope of the section. In Indian
legislation, many Acts include explanations attached to sections to assist in interpretation. For
example, Section 108 of the Indian Penal Code defines the term "abettor" and includes five
explanations clarifying its application. These explanations are typically added after the
enactment of the statute, not during its initial drafting. For instance, in “Section 405” of the
Penal Code, 1860, which defines "Criminal breach of trust," two explanations were inserted
into the provision in 1973 and 1975 respectively, to provide further clarification. Explanations
are keys to the sections to which they appended. They explain the heart of the matter with a
purpose. An explanation does not enlarge the scope of the original section that it is supposed
to explain.10 In the case of Bihta Co-operative Development Cane Marketing Union v. State
of Bihar. in case of conflict between the explanation provided for the main provision, the
Supreme Court held that “as of the duty of the courts to harmonise or settle the issue or the
two.”
7) PUNCTUATIONS AND SCHEDULE
Punctuation plays a crucial role in both written communication and the interpretation of
1
statutes. Proper punctuation, such as semicolons, colons, commas, and dashes, helps clarify
meaning and structure in legal texts. Historically, courts did not place much emphasis on
punctuation in statutes, but modern courts now recognize its importance for ensuring clarity
and precision. When interpreting statutory provisions, courts closely examine punctuation, as
it can significantly alter the intended meaning of a law. On the other hand, schedules, typically
found at the end of statutes, are also integral to the interpretation and implementation of legal
provisions. Although they contain essential details necessary for enforcing the main provisions
1 1
of the Act, schedules cannot override the explicit terms of the main body of the statute. In the
event of a conflict between the two, the main body takes precedence, as affirmed by the
1
Supreme Court in cases like M/s. Aphali Pharmaceuticals Limited v. State of Maharashtra.
Schedules serve to further the objectives of the main provisions, but they do not have the
authority to contradict or override them.
1
10) PROVISO
Page | 9
A proviso serves the specific purpose of addressing cases that would otherwise be covered by
the general language of the main statute. Its effect is limited to that particular case. Essentially,
it's a clause added to a law that commonly expresses a condition or exception. Typically, a
proviso is used to qualify or establish an exception to the main provisions of the law, rather
than stating a general rule. It usually does not go beyond what it is intended to address. In legal
texts, a proviso is part of the sections that begin with phrases like "provided that ___." It's added
after the main provision to restrict or modify its application. Its primary function is to exclude
or qualify certain aspects within the scope of the law. Courts have the authority to interpret and
potentially expand the scope of a proviso by adding words to it. In cases of conflict between
the proviso and the main provision, the interpretation of the proviso is given precedence, as it
is presumed to reflect the intention of the legislature or drafters of the law. Under the case of
“Union of India v. Sanjay Kumar Jain, the court held that the proviso’s function is to carve out
or to qualify the exception to the concerning main provision.”
1
OVERCOMING CHALLENGES IN THE USE OF INTERNAL AIDS TO
INTERPRETATION
Internal aids to interpretation are essential tools in legal texts, but they come with significant
challenges. Ambiguities in language, evolving judicial trends, and divergent interpretative
approaches can lead to inconsistent and uncertain legal outcomes. Additionally, as language
and societal norms evolve, legal terminology may shift, complicating interpretation. Internal
1
aids must also navigate the complexities of legal frameworks, balancing clarity with the
intricacies of legal doctrine and precedent, and harmonizing with external aids such as
legislative history and judicial precedents. Moreover, cultural, technological, and judicial
factors further complicate the consistent application of these aids.
To address these challenges, clarity and consistency in drafting internal aids are paramount.
Precise language, consistent usage, and a clear hierarchy of aids within legal documents can
enhance coherence. Effective cross-referencing, regular updates, and ensuring accessibility of
these aids are also critical for accurate interpretation. Training legal professionals on the proper
1
use of internal aids further promotes consistency. By tackling these issues, legal drafters and
interpreters can improve the effectiveness of internal aids, fostering clearer, more predictable
legal outcomes.
Page | 10
CONCLUSION
In conclusion, internal aids are crucial for interpreting statutes, as each clause and section
crafted by lawmakers carries specific meaning and importance. Understanding these provisions
is essential for both legal professionals and individuals, as any misinterpretation can lead to
challenges before authorities. Internal aids facilitate a systematic approach to interpreting
statutory provisions, allowing for clarity in complex legal texts.
1
This research underscores the significance of internal aids in navigating linguistic, contextual,
and structural elements to discern legislative intent and clarify ambiguities. By guiding legal
1
practitioners and policymakers, these aids ensure adherence to legislative intent and contribute
to a just and transparent legal system.
Page | 11
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. INDIAN PENAL CODE, 1860
2. CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE,1973
3. CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE,1908
4. LEXIS NEXIS ON INTERPRETATION OF STATUTES
5. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2334
Page | 12
Similarity Report
11% Overall Similarity
Top sources found in the following databases:
11% Internet database 0% Publications database
Crossref database Crossref Posted Content database
4% Submitted Works database
TOP SOURCES
The sources with the highest number of matches within the submission. Overlapping sources will not be
displayed.
ijrpr.com
1 10%
Internet
NALSAR University of Law Hyderabad on 2023-05-06
2 <1%
Submitted works
Institute of Technology, Nirma University on 2014-05-13
3 <1%
Submitted works
The WB National University of Juridical Sciences on 2021-02-23
4 <1%
Submitted works
See, Kok Fie. "Are the Taxpayers' Rights Adequately Protected in Malay...
5 <1%
Publication
Wawasan Open University on 2011-03-06
6 <1%
Submitted works
blog.ipleaders.in
7 <1%
Internet
Sources overview
Similarity Report
Excluded from Similarity Report
Cited material Manually excluded text blocks
EXCLUDED TEXT BLOCKS
KES’ Shri. Jayantilal H. Patel Law College, Mumbai
Global Banking Training on 2024-05-12
A project submitted in partial
www.coursehero.com
Page | 1
mostwiedzy.pl
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTI would like to
www.coursehero.com
INDEXSR. NO.PARTICULARSPAGE NO.1.ABSTRACT42.INTRODUCTION5
www.coursehero.com
is a detailed analysis of internal aids to interpretation
ijrpr.com
into the intricacies of
ijrpr.com
INTRODUCTIONInterpretation is the mechanism used by the courts to assess or d...
ijrpr.com
1) LONG TITLE – Every Statute is headed by a long title at the head of the statutes,...
ijrpr.com
Eachinternal aid, from the broad scope of the Long Title to the finer details of Punc...
ijrpr.com
Excluded from Similarity Report
Similarity Report
In Global Energy Ltd. v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission, it was put forth ...
ijrpr.com
6) EXPLANATIONThe purpose of adding explanations to sections within Acts is to ...
ijrpr.com
1. INDIAN PENAL CODE, 18602. CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE,19733
pdfcoffee.com
5. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id
www.coursehero.com
Excluded from Similarity Report