Ag2021-30 20220204
Ag2021-30 20220204
INTRODUCTION
This application guide describes how to test the single-phase and three-phase directional power
element (32) in the SEL-351S-7 Protection System and three-phase directional power elements in
the SEL-421-4, -5 Protection, Automation, and Control System and the SEL-700G Generator Pro-
tection Relay (the SEL-700GW Wind Generator Relay does not have power elements). This appli-
cation guide includes a Microsoft Excel spreadsheet with the calculations to simplify your testing
process and uses ACSELERATOR QuickSet® SEL-5030 Software for the terminal sessions. For ref-
erence, the application guide also includes SEL-5601-2 SYNCHROWAVE® Software custom calcu-
lations for these relays in Appendix A and the equations used in the power calculations for an open-
delta-connected PT are included in Appendix B.
THEORY
Electrical apparent power (S) is a product of voltage and the complex conjugate of current. Appar-
ent power is conventionally expressed in VI. Equation 1 shows the apparent power calculation:
S = VI
Equation 1
where the asterisk denotes the complex conjugate of the current, I, meaning that the sign (positive
or negative) of its imaginary component is reversed.
The phase angle difference between voltage and current is denoted by . The real part of the appar-
ent power in Equation 2 gives real power (P measured in W), and the imaginary part of the appar-
ent power equation gives reactive power (Q measured in VARs). Equation 1 then can be written as
Equation 2.
Figure 1 illustrates this in terms of a power triangle: the projection of the apparent power vector
onto the real axis has length P and corresponds to the real power, and the projection of the apparent
power onto the imaginary axis has length Q and corresponds to reactive power.
Apparent Power, S
Reactive Power, Q
Real Power, P
APPLICATIONS
You can use power elements in many applications including generators, distributed generation
(DG), and the point of common coupling (PCC) between the utility and customer facilities.
In the present power grid, DG penetration has led to some significant issues regarding protection,
reliability, stability, and power quality. If DG supplies more power than the load demands, excess
power is fed back into the substation and transmission grid. This can create instability in the whole
system and result in overvoltage on the feeder, protection miscoordination, increasing fault cur-
rents, and incorrect operation of protective equipment.
Generator motoring can occur when the prime mover input power to the generator is cut off while
the generator is connected to the system. When this happens, the generator acts as a synchronous
motor to drive the prime mover shaft. In steam turbine prime mover applications, generator motor-
ing can quickly damage the turbine because of overheating. In other prime mover applications,
motoring can cause mechanical damage and/or unsafe operating conditions. You can use a reverse
or low-forward power element in the relay to provide antimotoring protection for a generator.
You can also use a power element to detect reverse power flow or low-forward power flow condi-
tions in all prime mover applications. This element measures the power flow and asserts a Relay
Word bit when the measured value exceeds the set threshold.
Direction of Reverse
Real Power
Feeder 1
Distributed
SEL-421 Generation
Direction of Positive
Real Power
Direction of Positive
Real Power
Feeder 2
SEL-700G Load
SEL-351S
SEL relays use the IEEE convention for power measurement. Figure 3 summarizes the conven-
tional power flow direction. When the SEL-700G measures the real and reactive power being
delivered to the grid, it has a lagging power factor and operates in Quadrant 1 of Figure 3. When a
feeder or line relay like the SEL-351S-7 or SEL-421, respectively, operates in Quadrant 1, this
indicates that the feeder or line is receiving real and reactive power and has a lagging power factor
(indicating inductive load).
Reactive Power
(VAR) Delivered (+)
Quadrant 2 Quadrant 1
Reactive Power
Received Reactive Power
(Capacitive Load) Apparent Power Delivered
Quadrant 3 Apparent Power (Inductive Load)
Quadrant 4
Reactive Power
(VAR) Received (–)
Current Output
Z01 Z01
1 IAX 1 IAX
Z02 Z02
Z03 Z03
2 IBX 2 IBX
Z04 Z04
Z05 Z05
3 ICX 3 ICX
Z06 Z06
Z07 Z07
N INX N INX
Z08 Z08
AVI AVI
Voltage Output
Voltage Output
1 1
Z09 VAX VAX Z09 VAX VAX
VBX VBX
2 Z10 VBX
(COM)
2 Z10 VBX
(COM)
Z11 VCX VCX Z11 VCX VCX
3 3
Z12 NX COM Z12 NX COM
(a) (b)
Figure 4 SEL-700G Test Set Connection With (a) WYE-Connected PT and (b) DELTA-Connected PT
This guide tests the power Element 1 on the X-side. The following steps describe how to perform
the pickup and timing test of the 3PWRX1P and 3PWRX1T Relay Word bits. Use similar steps for
the other power elements.
Step 1. Connect the current sources and voltage sources to the terminals of the relay as shown
in Figure 4(a) or Figure 4(b) based on the DELTAY_X setting in the relay.
Step 2. In the calculation spreadsheet, enter all required settings. Once entered, the spread-
sheet automatically populates the current and voltage magnitudes and phase angles.
Step 3. Program the Sequential Events Recorder (SER) to include the 3PWRX1P and
3PWRX1T Relay Word bits.
Step 4. Inject the current and voltage magnitudes and phase angles. Verify that the 3PWRX1P
Relay Word bit is set to logical 0 by issuing the TAR 3PWRX1P command to the
relay.
When injecting current, adhere to the current input ratings of the relay (see Specifica-
tions in [2]) to avoid causing damage to the relay.
Step 5. Issue the TAR 3PWRX1P 10000 command from the terminal window or use an HMI
window to monitor the target status. This causes the relay to repeat the TAR
3PWRX1P command 10,000 times so that the Relay Word bits can be monitored in
real-time.
Step 6. Start with a current magnitude that is 10 percent lower than the value shown in the
spreadsheet and slowly increase the magnitude (all three phases by the same amount)
until the 3PWRX1P Relay Word bit becomes logical 1.
Step 7. Turn off the current source. Press Ctrl+X while in the terminal window to abort the
target command entered in Step 5 (the Send Ctrl Characters check box in the upper left
corner of the terminal window must be selected for this to work).
Step 8. Issue an SER command to the relay. Note the times that the 3PWRX1P and
3PWRX1T Relay Word bits assert. The difference in assertion times of both these
Relay Word bits should be approximately the same as the power element time delay
(PWRX1D).
1 2 3 N 1 2 3 N
This application guide tests the overpower and underpower Element 1. The following steps
describe how to perform the pickup and timing test of the overpower elements 32OP01 and
32OPT01 and the underpower elements 32UP01 and 32UPT01. Use similar steps for other power
elements.
Step 6. Issue the TAR 32UP01 10000 command from the terminal window. This causes the
relay to repeat the TAR 32UP01 command 10,000 times so that the Relay Word bits
can be monitored in real-time.
Step 7. Start with a current magnitude that is 10 percent higher than the value shown in the
spreadsheet and slowly increase the magnitude (all three phases by the same amount)
until the 32UP01 Relay Word bit becomes logical 1.
Step 8. Turn off the current source. Press Ctrl+X while in the terminal window to abort the
target command entered in Step 6 (the Send Ctrl Characters check box in the upper left
corner of the terminal window must be selected for this to work).
Step 9. Issue the SER command to the relay. Note the assertion times of the 32UP01 and
32UPT01 Relay Word bits. The difference in assertion times of both these Relay Word
bits should be approximately the same as the power element time delay (32UPD01).
(a) (b)
Figure 6 SEL-351S Test Set Connection With (a) WYE-Connected PT and (b) DELTA-Connected PT
This application guide tests the power Element 1. The following steps describe how to perform the
pickup of the 3PWR1 Relay Word bit. Use similar steps for the other power elements.
Step 1. Connect the current sources and voltage sources to the terminals of the relay as shown
in Figure 6(a) or Figure 6(b) based on the Global PTCONN setting in the relay.
Step 2. In the calculation spreadsheet, enter all required settings. Once entered, the spread-
sheet automatically populates the current and voltage magnitudes and phase angles.
Step 3. Inject the current and voltage magnitudes and phase angles. Verify that the 3PWR1
Relay Word bit is set to logical 0 by issuing the TAR 3PWR1 command to the relay.
When injecting current, adhere to the current input ratings of the relay (see Specifica-
tions in [4]) to avoid causing damage to the relay.
Step 4. Issue the TAR 3PWR1 10000 command from the terminal window or use an HMI
window to monitor the target status. This causes the relay to repeat the TAR 3PWR1
command 10,000 times so that the Relay Word bits can be monitored in real-time.
Step 5. Start with a current magnitude that is 10 percent lower than the value shown in the
spreadsheet and slowly increase the magnitude (all three phases by the same amount)
until the 3PWR1 Relay Word bit becomes logical 1.
Note that there is a built-in time delay, PWR1D, in the power element logic of the
SEL-351S-7. The 3PWR1 Relay Word bit asserts when the three-phase power is
higher than the 3PWR1P setting pickup threshold for the PWR1D delay.
Step 6. Turn off the current source. Press Ctrl+X while in the terminal window to abort the
target command entered in Step 3 (the Send Ctrl Characters check box in the upper left
corner of the terminal window must be selected for this to work).
(a) (b)
Figure 7 SEL-351S Test Set Connection With (a) WYE-Connected PT and (b) A-Phase-Connected PT and
PTCONN := SINGLE and PHANTV := VA
CONCLUSION
This application guide provides step-by-step instructions for testing three-phase elements with
WYE- and DELTA-connected PTs in the SEL-700G and the SEL-351S, testing three-phase power
elements with WYE-connected PTs in the SEL-421, and testing single-phase power elements with
SINGLE- or WYE-connected PTs in the SEL-351S-7. The calculation spreadsheet included with
this application guide helps with computing the test quantities required for testing the power ele-
ments, and the SYNCHROWAVE Event custom calculations provided in Appendix A help with event
analysis.
REFERENCES
[1] IEEE 1459-2010, IEEE Standard Definitions for the Measurement of Power Quantities
Under Sinusoidal, Nonsinusoidal, Balanced, or Unbalanced Conditions.
[2] SEL-700G Generator and Intertie Protection Relays Instruction Manual. Available:
selinc.com.
[3] SEL-421-4, -5 Protection, Automation, and Control System Instruction Manual. Available:
selinc.com.
[4] SEL-351S Protection System Instruction Manual. Available: selinc.com.
SEL-421
###converting to secondary value:
VA_Sec=VA_kV.Phasor*1000/PTRY.Set
VB_Sec=VB_kV.Phasor*1000/PTRY.Set
VC_Sec=VC_kV.Phasor*1000/PTRY.Set
IA_sec=IA_A.Phasor/CTRW.Set
IB_sec=IB_A.Phasor/CTRW.Set
IC_sec=IC_A.Phasor/CTRW.Set
#3-PHASE POWER CALCULATION
S=VA_SEC*CONJ(IA_SEC)+VB_SEC*CONJ(IB_SEC)+VC_SEC*CONJ(IC_SEC)
Q=IMAG(S) #3-phase reactive power
P=REAL(S) #3-phase real power
SEL-351S-7
PTCONN = WYE/SINGLE PTCONN = DELTA
###converting to secondary value: ###converting to secondary value:
VA_SEC=VA_kV.Phasor*1000/PTR.Set VAB_Sec=VAB_kV.Phasor*1000/PTR.Set
VB_SEC=VB_kV.Phasor*1000/PTR.Set VBC_Sec=VBC_kV.Phasor*1000/PTR.Set
VC_SEC=VC_kV.Phasor*1000/PTR.Set VN_Sec=VS_kV.Phasor*1000/PTRS.Set
IA_SEC=IA.Phasor/CTR.Set IA_sec=IA.Phasor/CTR.Set
IB_SEC=IB.Phasor/CTR.Set IC_sec=IC.Phasor/CTR.Set
IC_SEC=IC.Phasor/CTR.Set I0_sec=IG.Phasor/CTR.Set/3
##Single-phase power #3-PHASE POWER CALCULATION
#A-phase aparent, real, and reactive power VSCONN=1 #set to "0" if VSCONN=VS and "1" if
SA=VA_SEC*CONJ(IA_SEC) VSCONN=3V0
PA=REAL(SA) S=IF(VSCONN=1, VAB_SEC*CONJ(IA_SEC-I0_SEC)-
VBC_SEC*CONJ(IC_SEC-I0_SEC)-
QA=IMAG(SA) VN_SEC*CONJ(I0_SEC),VAB_SEC*CONJ(IA_SEC-
#B-Phase aparent, real, and reactive power I0_SEC)-VBC_SEC*CONJ(IC_SEC-I0_SEC))
SB=VB_SEC*CONJ(IB_SEC) Q=IMAG(S) #3-phase reactive power
PB=REAL(SB) P=REAL(S) #3-phase real power
QB=IMAG(SB)
#C-Phase aparent, real, and reactive power
SC=VC_SEC*CONJ(IC_SEC)
PC=REAL(SC)
QC=IMAG(SC)
##Three-phase power
S3=SA+SB+SC
P3=REAL(S3)
Q3=IMAG(S3)
S 3 = V AB I A – I 0 – V BC I C – I 0 + 3 • V 0 • I 0
Equation 3
For a delta-connected PT (Global setting PTCONN = DELTA) with no broken delta 3V0 connec-
tion (Global setting VSCONN = VS), the three-phase power is the same as the sum of the theoret-
ical single-phase powers only in balanced conditions. For unbalanced conditions, the three-phase
power element value includes an error term that is proportional to the amount of unbalance.
S 3 = V AB I A – I 0 – V BC I C – I 0
Equation 4
SEL-700G
For the X-side and Y-side power calculation with a delta-connected PT (configuration setting
DELTAY_X = DELTA), the three-phase power is theoretically the same as the sum of the single-
phase powers in balanced conditions. For unbalanced conditions, the three-phase power element
value includes an error term that is proportional to the amount of unbalance.
S 3 = V AB I A – I 0 – V BC I C – I 0
Equation 5
TECHNICAL SUPPORT
We appreciate your interest in SEL products and services. If you have questions or comments,
please contact us at:
Schweitzer Engineering Laboratories, Inc.
2350 NE Hopkins Court
Pullman, WA 99163-5603 U.S.A.
Tel: +1.509.338.3838
Fax: +1.509.332.7990
Internet: selinc.com/support
Email: [email protected]